You can have 10 difference of opinion with Ghamidi sb(i too have) but the way he explains difficult & contemporary topics is beautiful & very enlightening. It gives a perspective & clarity. Wonderfully explained. Jazakallah khair.
Bahut khoob....hamare dil ka to qila aapne quma bahut pahle kar liya tha... Aaj Turkey ka bhi .....ho gaya... Musalmano ko khabe ghaflat se jagane ka bahut shukriya
Ghamidi sahab acknowledged the presence of proper ambience/ situations or 'Halaat' ( and not one's aptitude or potential only) for realization of one's potential...( Whether at individual level or Collective level) Same has once been stated by Dr.Israr Ahmed Sahab. One of the best views ever by Ghamidi sahab
محققانہ انداز گفتگو کی گئی ہے اسکو سنجیدگی سے لینا چاہیے عقل سے سوچنا چاہیے اور بہت غور کرنے کے بعد اپنی اخلاقی اقدار کو بلند کرنے کی کوشش کرنے کے ساتھ ساتھ علم کے میدان بھی آگے بڑھنا ہوگا
بہت عمدہ تجزیہ ہے ۔ قوموں کے باری باری سٹیج پر نمودار ہونے کے قرآنی قانون کا جو تذکرہ غامدی صاحب نے کیا ہے اس کی کیا تفصیل ہے اور قرآن میں وہ کہاں مذکور ہے ؟
Alhamdulillahi wa salawati alal mursalin wa salamun alaik ya akhi fil islami! Khilafat is a Qur'anic necessity (3.103, 8.46, 61.4, 42.13) for a smooth Dawah process and for the security of basic human rights of muslims in case of their persecution only on the basis of their being Muslims. Khilafat (organization of muslims on different scales and not a form of government) is a Qur'anic social duty regardless of the present world's pragmatic conditions. Every muslim needs to fulfill this social duty in proportion to their respected "wusa'at". An organized ummah (Jamiu'un muntasir) is a bliss for Dawah and Allah's message. Wassalam!
Achay uhsol insaniyat insaf Qaim krnay walon ki Qiadat ko khalifa lader rahnoma Qaid rahbar ka Alqab Apni zaban ma yous istemal hote han Hazrat yousef a.s ki traf roshani .... good speech hai
قرآن کے مطابق خلافت کا وعدہ ایمان و عمل صالح کی بنیاد پر کیا گیا یے۔ خلافت کے لیے علم و اخلاق ظن و قیاس آرائیاں ہیں یا ان کی کوئی دلیل بھی یے؟ یہ تو سب مفروضے پر مبنی باتیں ہیں کہ اگر ایسا ہو جاۓ یا ویسا ہو جاۓ تو بہت اچھی بات یے۔ قرآن تو کچھ کرنے والوں سے وعدہ کر رہا ہے۔
السلام و علیکم ورحمتہ اللہ وبرکاتہ شخصی تفوق و برتری کی جبلت پر برائے کرم لیکچر کی طرف اشارہ فرما دیجئے ۔ علاوہ ازیں اس پر ایک مکمل نشست کا انعقاد فرما دیجیے ۔ میں یہ چند جملے شاید سو بار سن بیٹھا ھوں ۔ اوری۔ اس جبلت کا مریض شاید ازل سے رہا ھوں ۔ مہربانی فرما کر دوا تجویز فرما دیجئے ۔ کہ بقیہ زندگی اس کے مہلک اثرات سے خود کو بچا لوں اور خیر کے پہلو اپنے اندر پیدا کر لوں ۔ بفضلہ تعالیٰ
Aoa.sawaal ye ha ap dono bhaion sy ghanmdi shb kea Allah k Rasool ne tmam umt e muslema ko jaty hoy ye hukm nhi dea tha k ab deen ghalib krna hm sb muslmano pe phla frz ha to ap q zubaan sy hi jhaad krty ja rhien hen ,hath sy bhi krien
It is very painful to accept these hard facts and truth has to prevail. If we racial Muslims who are born in Muslim nations want to prevail again over the globe, we would have to take the usual way now ie the way of economic and military progress and infact some of us already have done that. Muslim nations have armies, even nukes and missiles.
With immense respect.... Here ghamdi sb wants to say that i m the only person who has perceived the explicit narration of prophet regarding revival of islamic governance in the later times n others have misinterpreted it...... The problem why ghamdi sb can't affirm this undisputable reality is becoz he thinks dajjal , imam mehdi , jesus are not gonna come n those who affirm these affairs, they will never deny the later dominance of islam
What you conveniently attributed to marhoom Wahiduddin Khan is actually what Sir Syed preached and worked for. Marhoom himself acknowledged that, a grace that others lack.
Islam main qoumiat ka aur muktalif aqwam ka tassawur nahin hey balka aik aik aqeeda jo tamam baqi aqaiad se mukhtalif hay aur is ke ijtamaiat k baghair is k infradi zindagi k masail b Sahih tariqay se anjam pazir nahin ho saktay comments choon k lamba ho jaye ga is k liye sirf aik misal is waqt Allah swt ka irshad khuz min amwale em Yaney muslamono k mall se ley kar (zakat) taqseem kia jaye un logon me jin ko Allah swt ney categorically bata diya Swal yeh hey kia main individuality yeh amar anjam dey sakta hoon? aur is tarah k aur Kai ahkamat Islam ka nizam apni fitrat main individual nahin hey Islam ba haissiat deen belief k sath is ka amli nafaz ka b mutalba karta hey you like it or not
bhai arbi to ghamdi sahab ne 12 saal me hasal karli thi 😮 baqi drs e nizami karne wale is ka muqam wazeh karte rehty hen😂😂😂😂😂 . bhai pehle bat samaj to lo😅
السلام و علیکم ورحمتہ اللہ وبرکاتہ محترم استاذ جناب غامدی صاحب ، سوال ھے کہ اس بات کی سمجھ نہیں آئی کہ افغانستان میں بندوق جیت گئی ھے ؟ جبکہ امریکہ اور اس کے حواریوں نے سوائے ایٹم و ہائیڈروجن بم کے ہر جدید سے جدید اور مہلک ترین ہتھیار افغانستان میں استعمال کیا ھے ، باقاعدہ نسل کشی کی حد تک خونریزی کی ھے ، اور آخ میں انہیں ظالمانہ فاسقانہ اور کفریہ طاقتوں کو شکست ھوئی ھے ۔ یعنی بندوق ہار گئی ھے اور قبائلی طرز کے افغانستان کی نمائندہ جماعت طالبان کو فتح حاصل ھو گئی ھے ۔ یہ تو کائنات جانتی ھے نہ کہ افغانستان میں طالبان ھی کو اکثریت کی حمایت حاصل ھے ۔ پھر کیسے مظلوموں کے سر یہ الزام باندھا جا سکتا ھے کہ ان کی طرف سے بندوق جیت گئی ھے ؟
To be fair they weren’t really defeated were they, it was simply no longer in their interests to remain as they had other fish to fry, which is evident by the timing of their withdrawal from Afghanistan which was very very conveniently just prior to their new proxy war against Russia in Ukraine, not to forget their sabre rattling in the South China Sea around Taiwan in order to antagonise China and provoke war there like they have done with Russia in Ukraine, hardly seems like a defeat. Look at it this way, they the US and the West lost a few thousand troops, Afghanistan lost millions of people, Afghanistan was destroyed physically, the US was untouched, even the trillion dollars that many Muslims keep boasting about that the US was forced to waste in Afghanistan was in reality 95% recycled to US companies etc and therefore back to the US, so in reality they lost nothing there, in fact for the US it was and always is a game proven by the fact that they have moved on to Ukraine and Taiwan, so I just wish that Muslims were not so naive and saw the fact that Afghanistan ended up destroyed with millions of dead and many millions of internal and external refugees, the only winner was the US. And if the Afghans really won, don’t get me wrong here, I’m happy they got their country back, then how come they only “swept” the country when US forces disappeared in the middle of the night, how come there was no sweeping the country in the previous twenty years, all I’m saying is be real.
Aap kahrai European union muttahid hai.afsos Allah kahra tumhe dikhraha hai. Haqiqat me wo muttahid nahi hai. Hazar saal ki baat karahe ho jahelo wali. Allah kahraha hai chand saal me chaligaee tumhari hukumat.jitni kitabe aap dikharahe hai sab jaladijiye. Aur Quran ki do soorte gour se padhiye. Sura bani Israel aur sura Room.
Thandi guftagoo. ye kaha say pata chala ha kay musalman (collectively) ilmo ikhlaq kay akhri darjay ma hain. aap bus molana tariq jameel sahib kay muqabala ma thori si zayada garam guftagoo kartay hain.
Top 50 universities m s aik bhi musalman majority mulk m nai hai, last 100 years m aik bhi ejaad aeroplane aur medicine s ly kar aik pamper tak musalmano ki nai hai.Quaid-e-Azam aur Allama Iqbal ko bhi higher education k liyay europe jana para tha.ye to hogaya collective ilmi zawaal.
Does the very honourable Ghamdi Sahib ignore the fact that there is something like Capitalism/Empire/Modernism? Or has he aligned Islam with all three of them? How could Islam be an argument before the world if it could not be practically implemented? Education and ethics are controlled by a discourse. Getting rid of that discourse is a political move against Capitalism/Empire/Modernism. But Ghamdi Sahib sounds so apolitical, especially at a time of such challenges faced by Muslim civilisation. I appreciate your interpretations very much and have followed you over the course of many years. You are suggesting social evolution by making us accept the lie of Europe that they are leading the world. Have you not read western psychoanalysts who have diagnosed their western society that you want us to accept as a fate? Like Hegel's dialectics, you suggest, slave will be transformed into master at a certain evolutionary trajectory. Have your limits reached? I wish I am wrong.
GET THE APP To Ask Questions and Join Community Discussions! www.ghamidi.org/app
This logical reasoning is contradictory to the fictional stories we have been listening since childhood. Great effort by respected Ghamidi sahib
You can have 10 difference of opinion with Ghamidi sb(i too have) but the way he explains difficult & contemporary topics is beautiful & very enlightening. It gives a perspective & clarity. Wonderfully explained. Jazakallah khair.
May Allah Bless Ustaaz Ghamidi with Health. (Ameen)
aameen
آمین۔
May Ghamidi Sb's ilm prevail in recognized in his life time - Ameen.
Bahut khoob....hamare dil ka to qila aapne quma bahut pahle kar liya tha...
Aaj Turkey ka bhi .....ho gaya...
Musalmano ko khabe ghaflat se jagane ka bahut shukriya
غلبہ سے مراد اللہ کا غلبہ کسی نسل قوم کی حکمرانی نہیں ھم حکمران نہیں منتظمين ھیں
What a beautiful message 🌹❤️🌹 by ustaad e mohtaram.... jazaq Allah
Ghamidi sahab acknowledged the presence of proper ambience/ situations or 'Halaat' ( and not one's aptitude or potential only) for realization of one's potential...( Whether at individual level or Collective level)
Same has once been stated by Dr.Israr Ahmed Sahab.
One of the best views ever by Ghamidi sahab
Yes situation plays a crucial role.
pure true positive logic, for religion as well, no one, if human and Muslim can deny.
دانشورانہ گفتگو اور سیر حاصل بحث.
ما شا اللہ.
Useful view بہت عمدہ لا جواب جزاک اللّٰه
Alhamdulillah
Very Very clear
Jazak ALLAH khairan
Mashallah sir ❤️
Brilliant explaination
mere liye dua ki darkhuast, kuch pareshaniyan hain, dur hon
May the blessings of Allah be upon you so that you may come out of f your predicament at the earliest. Ameen
اللہ تعالیٰ بھائی کے لیے آسانیاں پیدا فرمائے.
آمین ثم آمین
allah karam kre ap pe.
aameen
اللہ پاک مشکلات میں آسانیاں پیدا کرے آمیں
Allah aap ko nijat dai
Jaza kallah u khair.
Watching this and enjoying Khilafat Cola 😀
بہترین بہترین بہترین۔
Assalam o Alaikum, jazak Allah khair, May Allah Kareem bless you with health, safety and prosperity. AMEEN summa AMEEN.
Brilliant analytical discourse
Love you ustaz ❤️
Mind blowing analysis!!! Ustaz ❤️
MashaAllah,... What a clear and logical explanation
Misplaced Idealism,,, Brilliant summation of dreaming ummah
Ghamidi sahib.
You have converted me from considering myself AALIM to JAHIL.
May ALLAH help us follow Islaam as it is.
why he is so underrated when he talks sense😢
Since he isn't a so called mystic or mulla
He will become popular only when people actually want to listen to truth and actually become a progressive society
Extraordinary..
محققانہ انداز گفتگو کی گئی ہے اسکو سنجیدگی سے لینا چاہیے عقل سے سوچنا چاہیے اور بہت غور کرنے کے بعد اپنی اخلاقی اقدار کو بلند کرنے کی کوشش کرنے کے ساتھ ساتھ علم کے میدان بھی آگے بڑھنا ہوگا
Musalmanoon ke akhlaqeyat sirf ketaboon main bund hain. Amle tor per nazar nahe aateen aur na aeen ge.
Masallah salmaat rahein.
❤❤❤
Very impressive the way he explains things
Convincing speech
KHILAFAT ka zamana guzr gaya AB sirf MUKHALFAT ka zamana hai.
Well said !
Very good.
بہت عمدہ تجزیہ ہے ۔ قوموں کے باری باری سٹیج پر نمودار ہونے کے قرآنی قانون کا جو تذکرہ غامدی صاحب نے کیا ہے اس کی کیا تفصیل ہے اور قرآن میں وہ کہاں مذکور ہے ؟
Long Live Ghamdi sahb.May our uloma understand it sothat our our generation not be cut as prevailing these days.Aamin.
Alhamdulillahi wa salawati alal mursalin wa salamun alaik ya akhi fil islami!
Khilafat is a Qur'anic necessity (3.103, 8.46, 61.4, 42.13) for a smooth Dawah process and for the security of basic human rights of muslims in case of their persecution only on the basis of their being Muslims. Khilafat (organization of muslims on different scales and not a form of government) is a Qur'anic social duty regardless of the present world's pragmatic conditions. Every muslim needs to fulfill this social duty in proportion to their respected "wusa'at". An organized ummah (Jamiu'un muntasir) is a bliss for Dawah and Allah's message. Wassalam!
Achay uhsol insaniyat insaf Qaim krnay walon ki Qiadat ko khalifa lader rahnoma Qaid rahbar ka Alqab Apni zaban ma yous istemal hote han Hazrat yousef a.s ki traf roshani .... good speech hai
Mashallah
perfect
قرآن کے مطابق خلافت کا وعدہ ایمان و عمل صالح کی بنیاد پر کیا گیا یے۔ خلافت کے لیے علم و اخلاق ظن و قیاس آرائیاں ہیں یا ان کی کوئی دلیل بھی یے؟ یہ تو سب مفروضے پر مبنی باتیں ہیں کہ اگر ایسا ہو جاۓ یا ویسا ہو جاۓ تو بہت اچھی بات یے۔ قرآن تو کچھ کرنے والوں سے وعدہ کر رہا ہے۔
Sir lekin agar tarki yafta mulk zulm kare toh kya karna chaiye ??
Molana Waheed du dun Khan kamal
Elaborate by all means
Assalam o Alikum Need link for albayan pdf
قوموں کو ایک خاص " ترتیب " سے اقتدار دیتا ہے۔ یہ ترتیب قرآن میں کہاں ہے؟ " تلک الایام نداولھا بین الناس " ترتیب کا معنی کہاں ہے۔
السلام و علیکم ورحمتہ اللہ وبرکاتہ
شخصی تفوق و برتری کی جبلت پر برائے کرم لیکچر کی طرف اشارہ فرما دیجئے ۔ علاوہ ازیں اس پر ایک مکمل نشست کا انعقاد فرما دیجیے ۔
میں یہ چند جملے شاید سو بار سن بیٹھا ھوں ۔ اوری۔ اس جبلت کا مریض شاید ازل سے رہا ھوں ۔ مہربانی فرما کر دوا تجویز فرما دیجئے ۔ کہ بقیہ زندگی اس کے مہلک اثرات سے خود کو بچا لوں اور خیر کے پہلو اپنے اندر پیدا کر لوں ۔ بفضلہ تعالیٰ
momino zyada socha mat Karo. Aqal se Kaam Lena mana hai.
Surah bani israel aayat 23 se 36 padh lo bha
Aoa.sawaal ye ha ap dono bhaion sy ghanmdi shb kea Allah k Rasool ne tmam umt e muslema ko jaty hoy ye hukm nhi dea tha k ab deen ghalib krna hm sb muslmano pe phla frz ha to ap q zubaan sy hi jhaad krty ja rhien hen ,hath sy bhi krien
It is very painful to accept these hard facts and truth has to prevail. If we racial Muslims who are born in Muslim nations want to prevail again over the globe, we would have to take the usual way now ie the way of economic and military progress and infact some of us already have done that. Muslim nations have armies, even nukes and missiles.
With immense respect....
Here ghamdi sb wants to say that i m the only person who has perceived the explicit narration of prophet regarding revival of islamic governance in the later times n others have misinterpreted it......
The problem why ghamdi sb can't affirm this undisputable reality is becoz he thinks dajjal , imam mehdi , jesus are not gonna come n those who affirm these affairs, they will never deny the later dominance of islam
What you conveniently attributed to marhoom Wahiduddin Khan is actually what Sir Syed preached and worked for. Marhoom himself acknowledged that, a grace that others lack.
ایمان کیا ہے ؟؟ اس پر گفتگو کریں
Islam main qoumiat ka aur muktalif aqwam ka tassawur nahin hey balka aik aik aqeeda jo tamam baqi aqaiad se mukhtalif hay aur is ke ijtamaiat k baghair is k infradi zindagi k masail b
Sahih tariqay se anjam pazir nahin ho saktay
comments choon k lamba ho jaye ga is k liye sirf aik misal is waqt
Allah swt ka irshad khuz min amwale em
Yaney muslamono k mall se ley kar (zakat) taqseem kia jaye un logon me jin ko Allah swt ney categorically bata diya
Swal yeh hey kia main individuality yeh amar anjam dey sakta hoon?
aur is tarah k aur Kai ahkamat
Islam ka nizam apni fitrat main individual nahin hey Islam ba haissiat deen belief k sath is ka amli nafaz ka b mutalba karta hey you like it or not
کوٸ بھی انتظام بنالیں شرط نظام کی ھے
Saudi turkey ar irani in teenon Ka ikhata hona bht mushkal ha
Ghamdi Sahab ..here doing very big mistake...in your point of view islam.just a mazhab ....there are some custome and tradition
غامدی صاحب پر کوئی وحی ہا القا ہوتا،ہے ؟؟
کیا غامدی صاحب امت کو represent کر رہے ہیں ؟
bhai arbi to ghamdi sahab ne 12 saal me hasal karli thi 😮 baqi drs e nizami karne wale is ka muqam wazeh karte rehty hen😂😂😂😂😂 . bhai pehle bat samaj to lo😅
Aap bate kerte rehte he
V
السلام و علیکم ورحمتہ اللہ وبرکاتہ
محترم استاذ جناب غامدی صاحب ، سوال ھے کہ اس بات کی سمجھ نہیں آئی کہ افغانستان میں بندوق جیت گئی ھے ؟ جبکہ امریکہ اور اس کے حواریوں نے سوائے ایٹم و ہائیڈروجن بم کے ہر جدید سے جدید اور مہلک ترین ہتھیار افغانستان میں استعمال کیا ھے ، باقاعدہ نسل کشی کی حد تک خونریزی کی ھے ، اور آخ میں انہیں ظالمانہ فاسقانہ اور کفریہ طاقتوں کو شکست ھوئی ھے ۔ یعنی بندوق ہار گئی ھے اور قبائلی طرز کے افغانستان کی نمائندہ جماعت طالبان کو فتح حاصل ھو گئی ھے ۔
یہ تو کائنات جانتی ھے نہ کہ افغانستان میں طالبان ھی کو اکثریت کی حمایت حاصل ھے ۔
پھر کیسے مظلوموں کے سر یہ الزام باندھا جا سکتا ھے کہ ان کی طرف سے بندوق جیت گئی ھے ؟
To be fair they weren’t really defeated were they, it was simply no longer in their interests to remain as they had other fish to fry, which is evident by the timing of their withdrawal from Afghanistan which was very very conveniently just prior to their new proxy war against Russia in Ukraine, not to forget their sabre rattling in the South China Sea around Taiwan in order to antagonise China and provoke war there like they have done with Russia in Ukraine, hardly seems like a defeat. Look at it this way, they the US and the West lost a few thousand troops, Afghanistan lost millions of people, Afghanistan was destroyed physically, the US was untouched, even the trillion dollars that many Muslims keep boasting about that the US was forced to waste in Afghanistan was in reality 95% recycled to US companies etc and therefore back to the US, so in reality they lost nothing there, in fact for the US it was and always is a game proven by the fact that they have moved on to Ukraine and Taiwan, so I just wish that Muslims were not so naive and saw the fact that Afghanistan ended up destroyed with millions of dead and many millions of internal and external refugees, the only winner was the US. And if the Afghans really won, don’t get me wrong here, I’m happy they got their country back, then how come they only “swept” the country when US forces disappeared in the middle of the night, how come there was no sweeping the country in the previous twenty years, all I’m saying is be real.
Aap kahrai European union muttahid hai.afsos Allah kahra tumhe dikhraha hai. Haqiqat me wo muttahid nahi hai. Hazar saal ki baat karahe ho jahelo wali. Allah kahraha hai chand saal me chaligaee tumhari hukumat.jitni kitabe aap dikharahe hai sab jaladijiye. Aur Quran ki do soorte gour se padhiye. Sura bani Israel aur sura Room.
.
Thandi guftagoo.
ye kaha say pata chala ha kay musalman (collectively) ilmo ikhlaq kay akhri darjay ma hain.
aap bus molana tariq jameel sahib kay muqabala ma thori si zayada garam guftagoo kartay hain.
Top 50 universities m s aik bhi musalman majority mulk m nai hai, last 100 years m aik bhi ejaad aeroplane aur medicine s ly kar aik pamper tak musalmano ki nai hai.Quaid-e-Azam aur Allama Iqbal ko bhi higher education k liyay europe jana para tha.ye to hogaya collective ilmi zawaal.
Janab ghamidi sahib ,all these books in the back ground needs to be removed .Umer the great said we have qurqn and it is enough for guidance.
Quran pe jo books likke hen unko phenk den phir?
Did you listen what he said? or just looking the book shelf?
Focus on topic plz
Does the very honourable Ghamdi Sahib ignore the fact that there is something like Capitalism/Empire/Modernism? Or has he aligned Islam with all three of them? How could Islam be an argument before the world if it could not be practically implemented? Education and ethics are controlled by a discourse. Getting rid of that discourse is a political move against Capitalism/Empire/Modernism. But Ghamdi Sahib sounds so apolitical, especially at a time of such challenges faced by Muslim civilisation. I appreciate your interpretations very much and have followed you over the course of many years. You are suggesting social evolution by making us accept the lie of Europe that they are leading the world. Have you not read western psychoanalysts who have diagnosed their western society that you want us to accept as a fate? Like Hegel's dialectics, you suggest, slave will be transformed into master at a certain evolutionary trajectory. Have your limits reached? I wish I am wrong.
He is well read I guess
Bahot gadhi urdu Hai