Herman Miller Aeron vs Steelcase Leap V2 : Which Is The Best Office Chair? Review
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ก.ย. 2021
- Both chairs are extremely comfortable.
Either of these will do you very well but which is best for someone wanting a comfortable seat for years to come?
Thanks for the upload! A comparison from a regular person is wonderfully valuable. As most reviews are done by used chair resellers, or reviewers who have affiliates with such resellers.
No affiliates here just honest opinions :)
Thanks, man. This video was very informational. I went with the leap v2
Awesome, I'm glad I could help. It is a really solid chair, I'm sure you will like it. Let me know how you find it
I have had an aeron and mirra. Steelcase still wins because it has a lot more options to adjust. I was blown away the amount of additional options that the Herman was lacking.
Great video. Unbiased
Nice review. just to leave a note here. I got the Classic in my office and the remastered at home and the difference is huge. The classic is a version from 1994 and the remastered in 2017 and there are a lot of improvements. it is much better!
I'm glad you are enjoying it! I've sat in the remastered once and it felt very comfortable. After 2005 they made a couple of changes to the classic so that may be a better model. But overall for people I would recommend a used aeron since it is often much cheaper.
@@modernexploration5282 please review the remastered version it will be ur next daily driver for sure.
Good news everyone, Steelcase is releasing their version of the Aeron called Karman. All Steelcase goodness in a Herman Miller mesh design and looking stylish to boot.
Interesting looking chair. They definitely seem to be targeting as competition something like the Aeron or Cosm since it has a very simple design with seemingly only one knob for adjustability. If I get a chance to try one I certainly will :)
totally agree on the Aeron sizing. I’m not a big guy, 5’7 and found the size B was too short in the backrest, a size C is just about perfect. almost feels like a high back.
But arent your legs too short for size c? Im 6' and find the seat too large
@@adameva8719 u have stumpy legs which kinda sucks tbh.
The armrest for Aeron, you can tighten it. You need to unscrew 4 screw from the back to access it.
You can search at youtube.
Appreciate the reply! I will have a look :)
ayy yoo, aerons with the waves
This is by far the best comparison video of these 2 chairs side by side on TH-cam because it is very practical as opposed to things I can research of the website of the companies. You mentioned in the video you were gonna start using the V2 as your daily driver instead of aeron, have you switched over? If so how do like the experience of sitting in one for a few hours a day (WFH) compared to an aeron…also, in my job I have to both read/write on papers as well as use a computer so I wonder if the forward seat tilt on the aeron should be the deciding factor or it’s something you don’t notice you miss as much on the V2 since as you mentioned the seat design puts you more upright to begin with. Lastly, I know the tilt mechanism of the remastered has been upgraded, but in general would you say both chairs offer comfortable tilt to slightly change the posture in the chair throughout the day to prevent you from slouching over time? Thanks in advance:)
I appreciate the feedback :) Actually I have since sold the V2 and stuck with the aeron. For me I find the Aeron over long hours to be more comfortable. Standarly, yes, the seat on the V2 is more upright but it just doesn't beat the forward tilt functionality. I think for now I would always recommend chairs that come with forward tilt. I reviewed some other chairs on this channe actually that have that functionality and they really are nice : Okamura Contessa and Haworth Zody. Both chairs are comfortable ad very nice however over time I have come to dislike the tilting mechanism on the V2 more. The way the seat shifts also in it is not to my liking and generally I like it upright since I work at my computer most of the time.
I will be putting up a separate video just on the Aeron soon so consider subscribing if you don't want to miss it :)
@@modernexploration5282 thanks for the prompt reply and I will definitely subscribe:) I was not aware the contessa had forward seat tilt. I live in Canada and I think they are sold under the name teknion contessa. There is a local distributor in my city. I unfortunately don't have a herman miller dealer nearby to try out the aeron. I'm close to your height and weight actually do if I was to blindly order one I'd order the size C, whereas the contessa is nice bec of the shifting seat. I'm not sure how the mesh compares to aeron when sitting for long hours. Maybe another video idea is to do a comparison of those 2 chairs (contessa vs aeron) side by side ☺
@@SamerMatti Sure I can do a comparison video side by side. The contessa mesh feels more firm, it isn't quite as comfortable for longer periods. However the armrests are much better, recline stop is superior since it can lock at basically any angle and stay there + it has a seat depth adjustment which is really handy. I think Aeron size C would be a good bet for you but I probably wouldn't buy one new unless I had tried it before, although I think Herman Miller still have a return policy
Ordered an Aeron remaster yesterday.
Currently have an embody which is really abrogating my SI issue in my lower back.
The seat in the body isn’t nice on a boney arse like mine after 30 mins.
Hoping the mesh will be far more comfortable on the Aeron
@@Captain-Chats that’s the one I got in the largest size and it’s amazing…Gluck!
Ive considered Steelcase but the leap looks like an 80 dollar chair. The arm rests have a lot of play the chair wobbles in the base because the gas cylinder is so skinny theres high force on the mounting components. Does not make the impression like it could last 20 years like some Aerons and be basically good as new.
The aerons are super sturdy chairs. I agree on that. Unsure how long the steelcase last for but they aren't as well built overall I would say but still extremely high quality office chairs
Hey, loved your video, great comparison. I'm looking to buy a Mirra 2 or a Leap V2 in the UK. I know this video is from 2 years ago, but the prices you mentioned seemed very good. Where would you advise to look to buy a Leap V2 and/or a Mirra?
Thanks!
Best place to find is facebook marketplace if you are ok with driving a little
i bought a second hand Mirra 1, returned it and bought a Mirra 2 (new) but wasn't happy with the finishing (too many blemishes), returned it and now bought the Aeron from the London Showroom. i thought i fitted well on the size C but ended up buying the size B as the back of my knee was too close to the seat pan on the C.
Honestly, i much preferred the C as it is wider and taller on the back. Not sure if Herman Miller would swap the B for a C. After trying these chairs, i wish i kept the Mirra 1 which was way more comfortable and better build quality and i would have saved £600. Oh well.
We live and learn :)
Generally for anyone over 5"11 I would recommend a size C Aeron. The mirra is really extremely comfortable too, I did a review of that chair also. About the same comfort as the Aeron honestly
Why did you return the Mirra 1? Was thinking of a used one. Or a new Aeron as there are quite a few on sale. But can’t decide between C and B. I don’t want it to cradle me too much,
@@pressrepeat2000 I am selling my Aeron as it doesn't suit me.
@@unklerolly Right, but why did you not like the Mirra 1?
@@pressrepeat2000 I wanted a new chair with 12 year warranty
You nailed so many things in this review. I totally agree the b size is too small in the back for me at 5'10" 160 lb. It hits me right in the shoulder blades and is really irritating. Also the armrest design is really poor and if I were to size up to C, the warm rests are far too wide for my shoulders. Also the comparison to Apple was spot on. Overpriced for elitist maybe? Needless to say I went with the leap which I found to be perfect so far.
funny he went back to the aeron as his daily driver. its been around for 25 years for a reason. nothing beats the aeron especially not the remastered version. no contest.
@@dwight2310 idk I'm not going back to the aeron from the steelcase leap
@@Nickporter17 dude u are missing out and u know it. get urself an aeron r asap.
@@dwight2310 I have one. I don't use it because the fit is bizarre. The back is too short and causes pain. I tried the size up and it's too big everywhere else. Bizarre design on this chair.
does the seat bottom out after a short time on the leap? thats my biggest concern
Hi Alex. I Don't believe so. I didn't use mine for very long but the foam was still quite springy. I am about 190lb. I have a very old leap V1 and the bottom of the chair is still in very good condition
I've had my Leap for 10 years and the bottom seat cushioning does bottom out, but it is an easy fix with buying a standalone ergonomic seat cushion like a Purple.
The leap is fantastic btw, highly recommend.
@@M0M0M0M0M honestly though, with a chair like this it shouldn't bottom out. i had a $172 chair that i had to use a purple cushion on, and I took apart the seat and put the purple cushion inside of the fabric with the other cushion so it was seamless. but if im paying for a high end chair, it needs to not bottom out and be comfortable for the life of the chair
@@spectre3492 Exactly. Having to use a seat cushion on 1.5k chair is beyond absurd.
every cushion foam bottoms out eventually. another reason the aeron reigns suprime.
An office chair which don't let you nap doesn't worth even 100, whether ergonomic or not.
I can't fucking stand my V2 - try your chair before buying
Why
everybody has different body mechanics and anatomy, you do need to try it out, like a glove or getting tailored
the leap caresses my spine perfectly
its great on my back, but the seat cushion is hard....
the leap is a scam but most people only ever notice it when its too late. get the aeron and actually feel good about ur purchase.