Why not? It's not my favourite movie nor is it even my favourite by Orson Welles but I understand how it's an obvious choice for a lot of film buffs especially directors.
It does bother me a little that all the animated movies on the list are by the same guy. Like, Miyazaki isn't the only person to ever make a good animated movie, guys.
The only argument I can see for it not being on there is that so much of its merit comes from its script, and since it was a teleplay and theatrical play before it was on screen, it might not be advancing the genre much, even if it’s really good.
@@gemmamoon5998 but what's the argument for this films? Technical achievement? Writing achievement? Directing? Acting? Or Impact? Because if we're talking impact, I could take 30 out and bring 200 to the table so we can discuss where they go
I was absolutely shocked at there only being a single Bergman film on the list. No Fanny and Alexander, no Seventh Seal, no Wild Strawberries... Also really surprised at there only being Close-Up from Kiarostami on the list, but overall unsurprised at how little representation there was from outside of Europe and America.
@@patrickjames1798 right. Like I said, a single Bergman film was included. I'm shocked at those ones that weren't, including the three I listed that fell off the last since 2012.
Wow I’m so surprised to see Daisies so highly ranked on this list! One of my all time favourite films, I didn’t think it would rank at all, let alone so high
You should look for Haneke's Hidden. It presents itself as an extremely effective psychological/political suspense thriller, then pulls the rug out from under the audience at the end. I'm tempted to say more, but it's better if you don't know what you're in for the first time. Absolutely brilliant film.
I heard the statistic that 50 of 100 of the critics’ list have Criterion disc releases. Also that Sight and Sound is British and maybe some of the success of Jeanne Dielman is due to a Joanna Hogg programmed full Ackerman retrospective in London. Ackerman is actually still pretty inaccessible on Region 2/B physical media. The same is true of some of Kiarostami’s Koker trilogy. I know the Bfi player now shows Jeanne Dielman, but prior to this I wonder how UK and Irish people saw it.
Pretty much instantly invalidates the list. He's probably one of the greatest directors of the last 70 years and not 1 film in the top 100? Out of respect that's insanity
I participated in the Sight & Sound "Greatest of All Time" polls in 2002 and 2012, so this prompted me to go back and look at my past lists. In 2012, mine (in alphabetical order) was: Barry Lyndon (Kubrick, 1975) Chinatown (Polanski, 1974) Citizen Kane (Welles, 1941) Late Spring (Ozu, 1949) Nashville (Altman, 1975) Only Angels Have Wings (Hawks, 1939) Our Hospitality (Keaton, 1923) Sansho Dayu (Mizoguchi, 1954) Trouble in Paradise (Lubitsch, 1932) Vertigo (Hitchcock,1958) Notes: These are movies that made me who I am and shaped my love of cinema. I would also defend each and every one of them as an awe-inspiring work of art. I looked at my 2002 list and some of the titles are different, but the overall contours are much the same: Our Hospitality instead of Sherlock Jr. for Buster Keaton, film’s greatest (and funniest) visual philosopher; the inevitable Citizen Kane, because no great movie has ever been more dynamic, ingenious and sheer fun - we shouldn’t take it for granted (last time I also had The Magnificent Ambersons on my list, a film I love as much as Kane, but I wanted to make room for other auteurs); Kubrick’s Barry Lyndon instead of 2001: A Space Odyssey because it is equally visionary and gorgeous, and perhaps slightly more poignant. [...] Others will have to champion films such as Sunrise (F.W. Murnau, 1927), Kings of the Road (Wim Wenders, 1976), The Night of the Hunter (Charles Laughton, 1955), Playtime (Jacques Tati, 1967), The Scarlet Empress (Josef von Sternberg, 1934), Holiday (George Cukor, 1938), Miller’s Crossing & No Country for Old Men (Joel & Ethan Coen, 1990 & 2007), Letter From an Unknown Woman & The Earrings of Madame de… (Max Ophüls, 1948 & 1953), Deep End (Jerzy Skolimowski, 1970) and Fast, Cheap & Out of Control (Errol Morris, 1997).
Re: Haneke: Haneke and Claire Denis are quite different filmmakers, but they are contemporary with each other (Denis first feature 1988, Haneke 1990) and equally masterful, and share at least Binoche and Huppert in common as actresses that they cast. I think it would be rewarding to watch a few of their well known film in alteration if both directors are still largely unseen by you. These are some of the very best recent-ish films there are. Haneke’s style is a benchmark for authoritativeness.
It’s a top hundred list derived from asking critics and directors around the world to name their top ten. Not enough people put it in their top ten. The format means that if the hundreds of people who made the list had Twelve Angry Men as their 11th best movie of all time then although it should be 11th on the list it would actually not appear in the top hundred at all.
Yeah I agree. Not only do I think it is a better standalone film-experience than any of the Godfathers, but since Godfather 3 exists, the entire and full picture of the Godfather has been diminished in my mind lol
@@ahnmensch3115 I agree, my feeling is that although the godfather part 1 and 2 are masterpieces in film-making, they are sadly held down by part 3. But with apocalypse Now it's completely untainted Its a weird way to explain it but I hope u get what I mean lol
Taste of Cherry is really amazing! Some other Movies I absolutely love are Corbucci's The great Silence, The Human Condition, Dekalog, Network, Nibelungen, Autumn Sonata, Harakiri, Market Lazarova, Come and See, I am Cuba, The Bridge, The Hill, Night and Fog, Cria Cuervos, Last Picture Show, The Land, Berlin Alexanderplatz, Repulsion, Le Trou, Seventh Continent, Dead Man's Letters, The Conformist, Bela Tarr, Lav Diaz, Brazil, Festen, Fires on the Plane... There are so many great Movies....
i havent seen most of those movies but you have some of my personal favorites on there (nibelungen, repulsion etc.) which really makes me wanna see the rest
@@rikurodriguesneto6043 The only Problem is, that some of the Movies are not easy to get. May be on Rarefilms or TH-cam, Dailymotion etc. The Land (1969) i watched on Mubi, Dead Man's Letter in Dailymotion for example. 😜
a lot of people seem to be making a big deal about the number spit but i can’t be the only one who strongly disagreed with the previous number one vertigo. like idk to me that seemed like such an odd choice it’s not even hitchcocks best film much less the best film of all time
I like it, every time I watch it the last few minutes always get my heart racing and it's visually beautiful with the colors and so on - which I think is not a common appreciation of a Hitchcock film. Morbid erotic obsession is Hitchcock's big theme running thru his oeuvre and Vertigo is kind of culminatinon of that (tho if it's a culmination that makes Psycho a..apotheosis?). Kim Novak's performance within a performance is very admirable. It always felt very flawed to me mainly b/c of well, the big reveal moment towards the end - wouldn't even call it a twist as you're led to suspect it's coming, anyway, the scene where a character just starts randomly 'writing a letter' but really just talking straight to the camera, I never liked how they did that, felt inelegant and contrived, like they really couldn't think of any other way to do it. And it wasn't seen as a major film at all in its own day, despite Hitchcock being long established as one of the biggest directors in the world. While I got sick of seeing Citizen Kane at the top of every list, I find it a far more understandeable choice, being a total game-changer made by a wunderkind newcomer to the industry.
@@leorrocher in terms f Hitchcock getting meta and coming to terms with his own themes and his own obsessions that fuel his film-making, Rear Window, vertigo, and Psycho are the most interesting on that front and are usually the critics' choices (North by Northwest also, which is self-referential in a more light-hearted way). But they're all also fairly flawed imo. The perfect Hitchcock movie, meaning the most flawless execution of his style that I would show to someone who wanted to know what a Hitchcock movie is like or why Hitchcock is considered great - I'd show them Notorious every time
The BFI is obviously going to be biased, but I’m especially shocked at the lack of cinema from the “global South,” especially South America and India, both huge, populous regions with robust film industries. And most of the African films were collaborations with their colonizer countries :/ but I digress
The west has also been producing movies for like 50-60 years longer and on a much larger scale. Not longer or more than India though, they just have a bad film tradition. Melodrama, musicals, and nationalism doesn't make good art
Yeah, I’m especially surprised Tree of Life didn’t show up somewhere in the back half since I think it said Tree of Life was only 1 vote off from making it onto 2012’s.
tbh it probably has a lot to do with polanski’s reputation being in the dirt right now. which he absolutely deserves, of course. not many people want to be “the guy that backed polanski”, you know?
@randywhite3947 the obvious answer is There Will Be Blood, which is wholly deserving. But my personal pick would be Phantom Thread. Either way, you just gotta have PTA here somewhere.
What's the question though Technical achievement? Money gross? Artistic method? Script, Cinematography, acting, editing, impact, can they outlive their time, soundtrack, depth in story, directing? Just acting? Just script? Idk mates, to me Bela Tarr has probably 1 if no 2 of the best films I've ever seen, Lav Diaz Just impact, is such a strong line between good and great and in my opinion some do get there and some dont......a few of th movies on the list, are great, but not the best Directing?
@@ssjAnnaPaquin I would argue Lav Diaz, films should be on here, even if they are 9 hours long, but at least 1 should be here, technically beautiful and it just destroys the whole concept of the artform and it truly makes it a world to live
If we're going with recent films, Get Out doesn't belong. Moonlight for sure, Portrait and Parasite maybe. First Reformed and An Elephant Sitting Still should be on there
Edawrd Yang's films should be higher 🙃. Very western-centric list, the asian films that were there are the popular ones (Great films obviously). I would like to see the countries votes percentage since there are no latin film (maybe I missed some) from middle eastern only saw Kiarostami, China? Africa? Guess there are no Great films from there 😐. Surprised with Kieslowski's lack of films as I considered him one of if not the reates film director. Also, great top 10 list love those films!
Yi Yi and A Brighter Summer Day always struggle to get into the top half because the critics/directors are split on which of them to fully back, so it ends up being 50-50'd. Basically, they can't decide between 2 masterpieces.
Bruh 50% of movies come from the USA of course there’s going to be a lot of western movie. Ur movie doesn’t become better just because ur in a lesser represented country
No Fincher, Nolan, Tarantino, or PTA!!! Wild. I guess the post 1990s films will get there love on the next list. Such as Fight Club, The Dark Knight, Pulp Fiction and There Will Be Blood/Phantom Thread for each of the directors I named.
Seventh Seal definitely should have made it. I watched it for the first time about a month ago, and it really stuck with me. One of the only films with that level of critical regard that made sense to me from the first viewing. I immediately understood why that movie is held to that high standard. I can't say the same for Persona. I love experimental touches in film, but Persona was just opaque and inscrutable in a way that wasn't even fun; hot take, I know.
What is the argument for get out to be a top 100 film of all time, I agree with it being a good movie but I would never consider it as being that important other than for it's cultural impact I guess
Fair point, but I honestly think that impact on the culture/art form is sort of the main criteria for a lot of the people who submitted ballots for this. The value of a list like this and it’s specific reputation is that it’s basically a pretty comprehensive genealogical record of cinema and it’s history/evolution. Get Out is a really good movie on its own, but it’s also something with a real legacy. It’s going to open a lot of doors down the line in terms of genre filmmaking and that I think makes it deserve its spot.
@@tatehildyard5332 i guess I would agree more with it's inclusion if it was other genre because if you are going to put it as the only horror movie on the list you are kinda dismissing that whole lineage of filmmaking
@@helvete_ingres4717 I get that sentiment, i do find myself questioning if everyone loved it so much more than I because it's that good or because it's socially relevant but i do geneuly believe that it's a very good movie that really stands out in the cinema landscape of the decade so I guess when making a new list you have to add a few newer ones and get out stands out temathically and stylistically I'm just salty that it is there and not the witch :(
@@a.s.f.g.8345 one's a cheap exploitation of stories dominating media at the time culminating in a tacky manipulative shot of a black man in the headlights of a police car; the other is nothing but an ill-conceived mood piece. I thought it was good when I first saw it too just b/c it was unusual to see a modern horror film with a confident command of atmosphere - but that's all it is
Immediately going in to mentioning which movies you believe do or do not deserve to be on the list is very telling of how limiting and reductive a list like this inherently is.
It’s a list comprised of critics being asked to name the ten best of all time and from that compiling a top hundred. Most critics would regard UP as a lovely movie but not necessarily one of the top ten best of all time
I think Parasite is an excellent movie, but a great movie, well not in my opinion. I would put Shoplifters in place of it. If i was putting a film by the same director as Parasite, it would be Memories of Murder. For me also the greatest movie, I have seen is Underground, and as far I could make out it is not even on the list. Surprised that Raging Bull is not on the List.Personally I think it is way overrated, but still surprised it is not on it. Yes, I would put A Man Escaped than Au Hazard Balthazar. I need to see Pickpocket.
Its not wise to make lists like this, usually there will be a handful of films that just wont come close to a lot of other ones which wont even get on the list.
The fact that S.S. Rajamouli (the director of RRR) voted for Kung Fu Panda makes me so happy.
Also, facts ngl.
Where can I see all his votes??
Legend.
He speaks the truth
Based
Holy shit, based ngl, kung fu panda 2 is one of my fav. movies of all time
Surprised not a mention of Harakiri, City of God or Cinema Paradiso
I like lists that do not have Citizen Kane on number one
I get that it’s become a very boring and cliche pick for #1 but it really is that freaking amazing. Idk I just can’t hate that pick.
@@CaptianFishyPants i wish rko wouldnt massacre the magnificent ambersons, even though i think it's a masterpiece as it is
@@CaptianFishyPantsno
Why not? It's not my favourite movie nor is it even my favourite by Orson Welles but I understand how it's an obvious choice for a lot of film buffs especially directors.
L take
I wish perfect blue was on this list. I just want satoshi kon to get the recognition he deserves !
paprika is also amzaing, satoshi kon needs to be more mainstream.
It does bother me a little that all the animated movies on the list are by the same guy. Like, Miyazaki isn't the only person to ever make a good animated movie, guys.
@@Irisversethe sight and sound voters have a very limited exposure to anime, it's kinda sad tbh
12 angry men definitely should be on there
The only argument I can see for it not being on there is that so much of its merit comes from its script, and since it was a teleplay and theatrical play before it was on screen, it might not be advancing the genre much, even if it’s really good.
@@gemmamoon5998 but what's the argument for this films?
Technical achievement?
Writing achievement?
Directing?
Acting?
Or
Impact?
Because if we're talking impact, I could take 30 out and bring 200 to the table so we can discuss where they go
@@gemmamoon5998cry
Damn it’s not on there?
That should be on there more than get out!
No Park Chan-wook films in this list? I think Oldboy deserves a spot here (or even The Handmaiden if you ask me)
Oldboy 100%. One of my all time favourites
The Handmaiden for me.
Oldboy is a bit ridiculous and ultimately fails to say much of anything at all
@@funkmeisterclownshiz9959 cmon don’t try to sound smart :D
Handmaiden is PCW's magnum opus
I’m belgian and it’s so funny to see that nobody in Belgium has ever heard about Jeanne Dielman
few movies i think should be on here: chinatown, harakiri, city of god, high & low, cuckoos nest, mishima
Nest ....nah......if you want a real crazy filmz watch possession 1981 the soundtrack alone is better than any film you mention
insane that sidney lumet was completely skipped tbh
Agreed on Mishima, Cuckoo’s Nest, Chinatown, and Harakiri. Can’t speak to the others but I’ll get to High & Low soon probably
City of God and Cuckoos Nest are must picks.
I was absolutely shocked at there only being a single Bergman film on the list. No Fanny and Alexander, no Seventh Seal, no Wild Strawberries... Also really surprised at there only being Close-Up from Kiarostami on the list, but overall unsurprised at how little representation there was from outside of Europe and America.
Persona was 18th
@@patrickjames1798 right. Like I said, a single Bergman film was included. I'm shocked at those ones that weren't, including the three I listed that fell off the last since 2012.
@@kjak94 sorry, misread that.
@@patrickjames1798 and seventh seal was on the directors list
Ikr I was hyped
So happy to see Killer Of Sheep so high that's truly one of the single greatest pieces of art ever made
The Thing is also in my top 10 as well, cool to see that this movie is one of your favorites too Kursten
I'm so glad to see Do the Right Thing so high on both lists, one of my all-time-favorites and it fully deserves the recognition.
Wow I’m so surprised to see Daisies so highly ranked on this list! One of my all time favourite films, I didn’t think it would rank at all, let alone so high
I just finished it, what a blast
@@samrainnie2104 right, such a unique piece of cinema ☺️
Me yelling “but the directors list!!” the entire goddamn video
Alex Hunter is shook that Spider-Man 2 is not here.
can't believe they snubbed Tenet
lmao
Agree on Mulholland Drive. It’s my favorite movie all time. So happy to se it get the respect it deserves.
Same here
Samesies
You should look for Haneke's Hidden. It presents itself as an extremely effective psychological/political suspense thriller, then pulls the rug out from under the audience at the end. I'm tempted to say more, but it's better if you don't know what you're in for the first time. Absolutely brilliant film.
its mostly known as Caché, so maybe some people get confused. amazing movie!
literally insane that i've seen the top movie without knowing it's a top movie
Why?
@@JoaoAlves-yx3rb probably cause most people check out a top movie already knowing its a top movie.
I heard the statistic that 50 of 100 of the critics’ list have Criterion disc releases. Also that Sight and Sound is British and maybe some of the success of Jeanne Dielman is due to a Joanna Hogg programmed full Ackerman retrospective in London.
Ackerman is actually still pretty inaccessible on Region 2/B physical media. The same is true of some of Kiarostami’s Koker trilogy. I know the Bfi player now shows Jeanne Dielman, but prior to this I wonder how UK and Irish people saw it.
Damn, I randomly found this old comment, but that's actually kind of wild.
I can’t believe there’s no Spielberg at all
Pretty much instantly invalidates the list. He's probably one of the greatest directors of the last 70 years and not 1 film in the top 100? Out of respect that's insanity
my fave of his is The Color Purple .
same, cant believe so many people are actually based
I participated in the Sight & Sound "Greatest of All Time" polls in 2002 and 2012, so this prompted me to go back and look at my past lists. In 2012, mine (in alphabetical order) was:
Barry Lyndon (Kubrick, 1975)
Chinatown (Polanski, 1974)
Citizen Kane (Welles, 1941)
Late Spring (Ozu, 1949)
Nashville (Altman, 1975)
Only Angels Have Wings (Hawks, 1939)
Our Hospitality (Keaton, 1923)
Sansho Dayu (Mizoguchi, 1954)
Trouble in Paradise (Lubitsch, 1932)
Vertigo (Hitchcock,1958)
Notes: These are movies that made me who I am and shaped my love of cinema. I would also defend each and every one of them as an awe-inspiring work of art. I looked at my 2002 list and some of the titles are different, but the overall contours are much the same: Our Hospitality instead of Sherlock Jr. for Buster Keaton, film’s greatest (and funniest) visual philosopher; the inevitable Citizen Kane, because no great movie has ever been more dynamic, ingenious and sheer fun - we shouldn’t take it for granted (last time I also had The Magnificent Ambersons on my list, a film I love as much as Kane, but I wanted to make room for other auteurs); Kubrick’s Barry Lyndon instead of 2001: A Space Odyssey because it is equally visionary and gorgeous, and perhaps slightly more poignant. [...] Others will have to champion films such as Sunrise (F.W. Murnau, 1927), Kings of the Road (Wim Wenders, 1976), The Night of the Hunter (Charles Laughton, 1955), Playtime (Jacques Tati, 1967), The Scarlet Empress (Josef von Sternberg, 1934), Holiday (George Cukor, 1938), Miller’s Crossing & No Country for Old Men (Joel & Ethan Coen, 1990 & 2007), Letter From an Unknown Woman & The Earrings of Madame de… (Max Ophüls, 1948 & 1953), Deep End (Jerzy Skolimowski, 1970) and Fast, Cheap & Out of Control (Errol Morris, 1997).
Re: Haneke: Haneke and Claire Denis are quite different filmmakers, but they are contemporary with each other (Denis first feature 1988, Haneke 1990) and equally masterful, and share at least Binoche and Huppert in common as actresses that they cast.
I think it would be rewarding to watch a few of their well known film in alteration if both directors are still largely unseen by you. These are some of the very best recent-ish films there are. Haneke’s style is a benchmark for authoritativeness.
Biggest surprise for me is that 12 angry men isn’t on the list
Is he just gonna ignore the fact that the true greatest film of all time, Gummo did not make the list?
insert clip of CHR83 shouting "Gummo!"
well
haha.. just watched it. good movie
thank you for uploading these here
Where is there will be blood?????
it's crazy La Strada doesn't even appear in the top 250 critic's list and it appears in top 38 director's list.
Come and See not being in this list just blows my mind. I hope everyone in the planet actually watches that movie.
12 Angry Men not on it is a fucking crime.
It’s a top hundred list derived from asking critics and directors around the world to name their top ten. Not enough people put it in their top ten. The format means that if the hundreds of people who made the list had Twelve Angry Men as their 11th best movie of all time then although it should be 11th on the list it would actually not appear in the top hundred at all.
12 Angry Men?
I have so many movies to see and am so excited to watch and connect with these films at some point in my life
Seeing the godfather, citizen Kane, and 2001 all in the top three is so mind numbing.
Gonna be honest I was very surprised to see Kung Fu Panda absent from all the lists
Unpopular opinion but I think apocalypse now is better then the godfather tbh
I think the same, leaves you with so much more thoughts imo
agreed, there's not enough surfing in the Godfather
Yeah I agree. Not only do I think it is a better standalone film-experience than any of the Godfathers, but since Godfather 3 exists, the entire and full picture of the Godfather has been diminished in my mind lol
@@Ant12468 surfing is a needed component to make a great film lol
@@ahnmensch3115 I agree, my feeling is that although the godfather part 1 and 2 are masterpieces in film-making, they are sadly held down by part 3. But with apocalypse Now it's completely untainted
Its a weird way to explain it but I hope u get what I mean lol
As I Was Moving Ahead Occasionally I Saw Brief Glimpses of Beauty
Portrait of a Lady on Fire being in top 50 is so awesome, i adore that movie
Taste of Cherry is really amazing!
Some other Movies I absolutely love are Corbucci's The great Silence, The Human Condition, Dekalog, Network, Nibelungen, Autumn Sonata, Harakiri, Market Lazarova, Come and See, I am Cuba, The Bridge, The Hill, Night and Fog, Cria Cuervos, Last Picture Show, The Land, Berlin Alexanderplatz, Repulsion, Le Trou, Seventh Continent, Dead Man's Letters, The Conformist, Bela Tarr, Lav Diaz, Brazil, Festen, Fires on the Plane... There are so many great Movies....
I thought come and see was on there! Definitely agree with The Conformist and Network
What about POTC 3
i havent seen most of those movies but you have some of my personal favorites on there (nibelungen, repulsion etc.) which really makes me wanna see the rest
@@rikurodriguesneto6043 The only Problem is, that some of the Movies are not easy to get. May be on Rarefilms or TH-cam, Dailymotion etc. The Land (1969) i watched on Mubi, Dead Man's Letter in Dailymotion for example. 😜
It’s crazy that the good the bad and the ugly is not on the list lol
Fair point but also westerns r lame
Imo the good the bad the ugly >>>>> once upon a time in the west
yeah thats insane 😂
Man just really wanted to play geogeusser and went "ugh fiiinne ill do this first"
a lot of people seem to be making a big deal about the number spit but i can’t be the only one who strongly disagreed with the previous number one vertigo. like idk to me that seemed like such an odd choice it’s not even hitchcocks best film much less the best film of all time
I agree. I watched it recently in a film class and liked it but didn't really understand the hype
I like it, every time I watch it the last few minutes always get my heart racing and it's visually beautiful with the colors and so on - which I think is not a common appreciation of a Hitchcock film. Morbid erotic obsession is Hitchcock's big theme running thru his oeuvre and Vertigo is kind of culminatinon of that (tho if it's a culmination that makes Psycho a..apotheosis?). Kim Novak's performance within a performance is very admirable. It always felt very flawed to me mainly b/c of well, the big reveal moment towards the end - wouldn't even call it a twist as you're led to suspect it's coming, anyway, the scene where a character just starts randomly 'writing a letter' but really just talking straight to the camera, I never liked how they did that, felt inelegant and contrived, like they really couldn't think of any other way to do it. And it wasn't seen as a major film at all in its own day, despite Hitchcock being long established as one of the biggest directors in the world. While I got sick of seeing Citizen Kane at the top of every list, I find it a far more understandeable choice, being a total game-changer made by a wunderkind newcomer to the industry.
I like it but it would have been cooler with an ending that doesnt explain everything.
It’s by far the best Hitchcock with Psycho
@@leorrocher in terms f Hitchcock getting meta and coming to terms with his own themes and his own obsessions that fuel his film-making, Rear Window, vertigo, and Psycho are the most interesting on that front and are usually the critics' choices (North by Northwest also, which is self-referential in a more light-hearted way). But they're all also fairly flawed imo. The perfect Hitchcock movie, meaning the most flawless execution of his style that I would show to someone who wanted to know what a Hitchcock movie is like or why Hitchcock is considered great - I'd show them Notorious every time
Would have loved to see some Koreeda :)
did i wake up this morning in a different universe !?
* farhadi ?
* ceylan ?
* kieslowski ?
The BFI is obviously going to be biased, but I’m especially shocked at the lack of cinema from the “global South,” especially South America and India, both huge, populous regions with robust film industries. And most of the African films were collaborations with their colonizer countries :/ but I digress
The west has also been producing movies for like 50-60 years longer and on a much larger scale. Not longer or more than India though, they just have a bad film tradition. Melodrama, musicals, and nationalism doesn't make good art
@@BalimSwogat Pather Panchali was in the list, ellitist dipshit
lol
Those films are awful.
12 Angry Men is only at no. 533 on the TSPDT consensus list, so not surprised it's not here.
Having no Polanski or Malick in the top 100 is nuts. Rosemary's Baby is better than Get Out.
Yeah, I’m especially surprised Tree of Life didn’t show up somewhere in the back half since I think it said Tree of Life was only 1 vote off from making it onto 2012’s.
tbh it probably has a lot to do with polanski’s reputation being in the dirt right now. which he absolutely deserves, of course. not many people want to be “the guy that backed polanski”, you know?
L
@@based5834 common L
@@gemmamoon5998 No i dont know but I think cancel culture is crazy right now. The man made great films. You don't need to have sex with him.
No PTA is criminal
@randywhite3947 the obvious answer is There Will Be Blood, which is wholly deserving. But my personal pick would be Phantom Thread. Either way, you just gotta have PTA here somewhere.
@randywhite3947there will be blood or boogey nights
@randywhite3947 thanks... you knew what I meant... autocorrect exists
Yeah no boogie nights or there will be blood is i crazy
Robots got snubbed
I expected there to be at least one Clouzot film (namely The Wages Of Fear and/or Diabolique).
Clouzout, Friedkin and Chabrol would have been nice.
man.. i loved wages of fear
Also holy shit The Thing is in your top ten?! I have gained so much respect for you just now❤️
All About Eve not being on there is CRAZY!!
Get Out on this list is ridiculous
Yeah, because it's clearly better than Schindler's List 🙄
Get out, Get Out.
What's the question though
Technical achievement?
Money gross?
Artistic method?
Script, Cinematography, acting, editing, impact, can they outlive their time, soundtrack, depth in story, directing?
Just acting?
Just script?
Idk mates, to me Bela Tarr has probably 1 if no 2 of the best films I've ever seen,
Lav Diaz
Just impact, is such a strong line between good and great and in my opinion some do get there and some dont......a few of th movies on the list, are great, but not the best
Directing?
Where is he getting this list? Could someone link it for me please?
Did I miss a PTA or did none of his make it???
Mans' really thinks Godfather 2 doesn't deserve to be on this list... common Karsten L
Aint no way Portrait of a Lady on Fire is better than Lawrence of Arabia, Raging Bull, and Once upon a time in the West.
I enjoyed it way more than raging bull or OUATITW. Technically though, idk. Lawrence getting snubbed from the critics list is extremely suprising.
@@ssjAnnaPaquin I would argue Lav Diaz, films should be on here, even if they are 9 hours long, but at least 1 should be here, technically beautiful and it just destroys the whole concept of the artform and it truly makes it a world to live
...or Blue is the Warmest Color
I haven't seen Portrait, but you just named 2 films I think are way overrated, and one I think should be on the list.
@@ssjAnnaPaquinit’s not about “snubbing” Critics were asked to name their top ten and from that a top hundred was compiled.
Punch-Drunk Love should be top 10
Drunk
I feel like the coen bros., pta, and Tarantino should have a film on here
If we're going with recent films, Get Out doesn't belong. Moonlight for sure, Portrait and Parasite maybe. First Reformed and An Elephant Sitting Still should be on there
Edawrd Yang's films should be higher 🙃. Very western-centric list, the asian films that were there are the popular ones (Great films obviously). I would like to see the countries votes percentage since there are no latin film (maybe I missed some) from middle eastern only saw Kiarostami, China? Africa? Guess there are no Great films from there 😐. Surprised with Kieslowski's lack of films as I considered him one of if not the reates film director. Also, great top 10 list love those films!
Yi Yi and A Brighter Summer Day always struggle to get into the top half because the critics/directors are split on which of them to fully back, so it ends up being 50-50'd. Basically, they can't decide between 2 masterpieces.
Bruh 50% of movies come from the USA of course there’s going to be a lot of western movie. Ur movie doesn’t become better just because ur in a lesser represented country
The list you are looking at is the Critics’ list not the directors list which is why mad max is not on it
No Fincher, Nolan, Tarantino, or PTA!!! Wild. I guess the post 1990s films will get there love on the next list. Such as Fight Club, The Dark Knight, Pulp Fiction and There Will Be Blood/Phantom Thread for each of the directors I named.
Kursten out here lookin like Barton fink
Where is spong bob movie
at least one park chan wook films deserves to be there
Seventh Seal definitely should have made it. I watched it for the first time about a month ago, and it really stuck with me. One of the only films with that level of critical regard that made sense to me from the first viewing. I immediately understood why that movie is held to that high standard.
I can't say the same for Persona. I love experimental touches in film, but Persona was just opaque and inscrutable in a way that wasn't even fun; hot take, I know.
Hungarian film makers like Jancso, Istvan Zabo, Peter Basco are literally omitted.
goodbye dragon inn is truly one of the best. hope you can watch that one soon! 😌
No nod to Synecdoche, New York on this list or even Kursten is criminal
Directors list cooked
Where's Come and See 😩😩😩
I'd love to see Se7en on that list tbh
Se7en is definitely filmbro core, but I dont even think its a top 2 fincher
@@ssjAnnaPaquin what the hell is the "film bro core"? And yes it is, it's definitely the best fincher
@@ssjAnnaPaquin chronically online
@@theyorkerguyot even in the Fincher top 5, man, and certainly not in top 100 of all time
What is the argument for get out to be a top 100 film of all time, I agree with it being a good movie but I would never consider it as being that important other than for it's cultural impact I guess
Fair point, but I honestly think that impact on the culture/art form is sort of the main criteria for a lot of the people who submitted ballots for this. The value of a list like this and it’s specific reputation is that it’s basically a pretty comprehensive genealogical record of cinema and it’s history/evolution. Get Out is a really good movie on its own, but it’s also something with a real legacy. It’s going to open a lot of doors down the line in terms of genre filmmaking and that I think makes it deserve its spot.
@@tatehildyard5332 i guess I would agree more with it's inclusion if it was other genre because if you are going to put it as the only horror movie on the list you are kinda dismissing that whole lineage of filmmaking
the argument is they felt a need to put a lot of stuff by/about black people on there
@@helvete_ingres4717 I get that sentiment, i do find myself questioning if everyone loved it so much more than I because it's that good or because it's socially relevant but i do geneuly believe that it's a very good movie that really stands out in the cinema landscape of the decade so I guess when making a new list you have to add a few newer ones and get out stands out temathically and stylistically I'm just salty that it is there and not the witch :(
@@a.s.f.g.8345 one's a cheap exploitation of stories dominating media at the time culminating in a tacky manipulative shot of a black man in the headlights of a police car; the other is nothing but an ill-conceived mood piece. I thought it was good when I first saw it too just b/c it was unusual to see a modern horror film with a confident command of atmosphere - but that's all it is
How is Spielberg not on this list
Because he mostly makes blockbuster garbage
No clue honestly
Great video and all, but i found it kind of odd when you said shawshank redemption would be better if Morgan Freeman was white
men
The Fantano commenters have entered the chat
did he fr say this?
I truly think when all said and done 2001 Space Odyssey is the best film of all time
Not top 6 Kubrick
@@dwaynekeenum1916 What a bonkers take bud
@@dwaynekeenum19162001 is easily a top 2 Kubrick film at least
@@diedlisteningtorush*easily top 1 at least
that is my favorite movie still.. although Svankmajers Alice came very close recently
Me when Fist Fight (2017) isn’t on the list:
🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯😤🤯🤯🤯🪟🤯🪟🤯🤯🤯
Godfather 2 deserves a placement on that list
Social Network and for me The Lighthouse should be on here
thats crazy
When I realised which 4 recent films are on here I laughed out loud a bit, but yeah it makes sense, they're obviously great films
The Irishman is better than Get out ......fuck The lobster is better than Get out
What year did The Hole release?
fallen angels should have been in chungking express’ spot tbh
karsten jack antonoff era
No Claude Chabrol, no belle de jour...i mean. what is going on.
Immediately going in to mentioning which movies you believe do or do not deserve to be on the list is very telling of how limiting and reductive a list like this inherently is.
I feel like Up should be in the top 100...
Same
It’s a list comprised of critics being asked to name the ten best of all time and from that compiling a top hundred. Most critics would regard UP as a lovely movie but not necessarily one of the top ten best of all time
No way
La Haine ?
Yeah true that should be thrre
What's your opinion on 8/12 and Fellini?
are you asking me?
Jeane Dilemann winning getting best picture of all time is like calling Chopsticks the best musical composition of all time.
lmao
a lot more like calling 4'33 the best musical composition of all time.
You are a man, we get it..
Regarding modern horror movies.I would put The Witch on there.
HARD TO BE A GOD BY ALEKSEI GERMAN IS THE MOST UNDERRATED FILM EVER MADE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
FUCK YES!!!!!! I FUCKING LOVE THAT MOVIE AND NOT HAVING IT HERE JUST SHOW HOW CLOSE MINDED SOME PEOPLE TRULY ARE
can anybody explain the moonlight obsession to me? genuine question
The movie was very dull for me too... I've seen many other movies about coming to grips with being gay that stood out more to me. 🤷♂️
Where the hell is Paddington 2
I think Parasite is an excellent movie, but a great movie, well not in my opinion. I would put Shoplifters in place of it. If i was putting a film by the same director as Parasite, it would be Memories of Murder. For me also the greatest movie, I have seen is Underground, and as far I could make out it is not even on the list. Surprised that Raging Bull is not on the List.Personally I think it is way overrated, but still surprised it is not on it. Yes, I would put A Man Escaped than Au Hazard Balthazar. I need to see Pickpocket.
Not one Disney classic. eg Snow White and The Seven Dwarves, which in my opinion is a masterpiece.
Love this!
Le magnifiique big maq
Why is Pulp Fiction not number one? Its my number one movie what the fuck, whyyyyyyeeheehregh im gonna cry they made me sad, evil evil peopel.
13:30 the shining made it
Its not wise to make lists like this, usually there will be a handful of films that just wont come close to a lot of other ones which wont even get on the list.