Which Sim Racing Wheel Is Right For You: GT Edition
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 มี.ค. 2021
- With me in the studio I have 7 GT wheels, and I've owned a few more for good measure. So, I'm going to do my best to talk through the important points, and the pros and cons of each of these types of wheel, similar wheels, and hopefully we'll all come out the other side having learned something in addition to having aged by around 8 minutes. Now, this isn't a "what am bestest wheel" video, more an overview of what you should probably look for.
Thanks again to www.raceanywhere.co.uk/ who let me play with the Sim Line wheels in order to get my feedback on them. I won't be making dedicated review videos, because I'm trying to limit the number of those I do, but for what it's worth, I think the Lambo/Audi wheel and the Porsche are great products, especially at the price point. That's it, that's the review!
Image attribution:
Water wheel - Heretiq, CC BY-SA 3.0 creativecommons.org/licenses/b..., via Wikimedia Commons
Broth - Hannes Grobe, CC BY 3.0 creativecommons.org/licenses/..., via Wikimedia Commons - เกม
Presentation is flawless, and the accompanying 'B roll' is straight out the top drawer. No-one matches Chris for film footage
Thanks for the kind words. Just need to work out how to do it all a bit quicker now!
Ok well now i need a big Fat wooden rim... great stuff
I managed to pick up that OMP rim for about £90 on sale... I don't think it's a lot more normally tbh.
You’ll need to for those excellent vintage racing videos you do.
It's an honor to be able to make something you enjoy 🙏
Quality content - perfect mix of helpful information and subtle humor, honestly haven't not been recommended this channel I'd probably be procrastinating on building a sim setup for the 14th time...
Are you planning on posting racing sim content in the future on top of the usual Tarkov/tarkov style content?
just found this video as an avid simracer and a person who likes to play tarkov never thought id see veritas in this comment section
I race in VR so have one beautifully wallet-friendly round wheel.
I have a thrustmaster 458 spyder Ferrari wheel with no force feedback it does the job for every car that I drive
G29 user here. I genuinely like the FFB from my wheel and honestly, the only reason I would be upgrading is for the aesthetics. However, I'd love a decent set of pedals, but I don't have the money for that kind of stuff.
@@hileutewie I've gotten really serious in sim racing recently and just now upgraded from my Logitech to DD I would highly suggest looking into a load cell pedal as it makes the biggest difference in performance mostly by consistency and ability to modulate braking easier I upgraded pedals and kept my Logitech for a while and gained a full 2 seconds in time on most track with the pedal upgrade
I feel personally attacked by that last part...
jokes aside, insanely high quality video as always Chris! :)
Honestly, I may have to play that on loop on my second monitor to remind myself :D
Can't wait for the open wheel edition
That one may take a little while ;)
All the videos are extremely informative, high quality with great audio and a relaxed vibe. Thank you.
my god the production value is stunning, I could watch these videos purely for the satisfaction of watching them rather than the actual content, which is stellar as well.
I was looking forward for a video like this! i'm actualy in the process of buying one so thank you Chris! Amazing work as usual!
Really impressive work all-around! Keep the great stuff coming🔥
Map probz for the effort you are putting into making your videos dude!
The Sim-Racing community can be truly glad to have people like you among them!
Simply terrific, Chris! Love your stuff. Thanks.
Yet another brilliant and funny video ... exactly the pick me up I needed today Chris - thankyou!
As the saying goes : A Chris Haye video a day keeps the blues at bay. Lovely video, mate. I bet you have as much fun making them as we do watching them. Loving this new style and presentation. Truly reflects that you’re just happy making videos that you enjoy making.
Back to the topic at hand, I’d probably love to have one of those semi open wheels, or D-wheels for GT racing since that’s all I sim race these days. But unfortunately, my wallet begs to differ that I should first prioritise getting a gaming pc that can actually play ACC optimally. For now, the t300 ferrari alcantara wheel will have to do. Not to say that I’m not enjoying it, it’s a great wheel and wheel base when you stop comparing gears all the time. Besides, what more could I ask for since I’ve already added thrustmaster’s T-LCM load cell brake pedal set.
This was really good, Chris. Thank you!
Love that bit at the end...that's how every discussion about gear on the internet should end.
I watched a load of your stuff back in November before I bought my first wheel, even saw the video where you warn people this is like crack and we'll get addicted, yet here I am, four months in and I've already bought a rig, upgraded my pedals and bought a handbrake and now you tempt me with shiny new wheels arghhh! that wooden wheel does look like a beauty though....
Haha. Yeah, I do try to warn people! It's funny that the wooden wheel seems to be getting more comments than any of the GT wheels ;)
When discussing on-wheel displays "I personally don't like to look at my wheels much", but produces a 10 minute video showing off fancy sim racing wheels no one can afford! 🤣🤣🤣. Seriously though, great video as usual. The production value is off the charts. Having recently tried a little video editing (of my own appalling driving), I can now appreciate the time and effort. Thanks. 👍
To dim down the "clicky" part of the shifter I used 2 layers from a rubber glove to cover the magnets and it works perfect for me by just slightly muffling the click.
I love the ending! That was hilarious!
God damn that PSA video insert was amazing lol. Great stuff, my TMX will have to carry me for a good while still, but I'll get to this kind of stuff eventually. (Just don't tell the wife!)
And here I was, falling in love with the idea of getting the Turn Racing r20, and Chris comes baring in with an unexpected GT rim video and some new wheel maker I hadn't heard of! Take responsibility, Mr Haye, and tell me how that Lambo wheel compares to the r20 with Turn's button plate! It's fifty US dollars more and comes with two more buttons and an extra encoder, but I've heard only great things about Turn.
Don't make me have to buy both...
Thanks for the thorough explanation.
As usual your trademark laconic British style makes something as unimaginative as GT wheels compulsive viewing; add in a smirky innuendo or two & I'm grinning like a Cheshire cat....'Carry On' producing this kind of brilliant content :)
Good work. Thanks.
Your Videos Are awesome!!!
For what it's worth, the Ginetta G55 has rather satisfying clicky paddles. I didn't get a chance to drive one mind you, but I did mess with a rim like an amused toddler when I helped scan one for work.
As per usual great content thank you. Although i may slightly disagree on a certain few issues one point i would like to highlight is the following, Wheel feel in conjunction with button placement. The wheels in the review: people may have noticed in some cases buttons were further placed behind the wheel rim itself. this can in some cases make it more challenging to press those buttons in the heat of racing. This can reduce the overall experience by the user and in cases de-rate the wheels ability to perform with that particular user. Cost is always a concern but imo opinion if your having fun on a $100 setup that's all that counts. ive seen 50k setups they look amazing and have there place too as it shows the dedication enthusiasts are willing to go.
Great job Chris.
Love that end video 🤣. So true .
What a wheelie good video. 💪
Awesome outro!
i'm having a weird issue with sim racing.. i reeaaallyyy love all gear aspects about it, but actually driving mostly frustrates me. often i just start a sim because i have the gear, have a little bit of fun but end up frustrated after about 40 minutes.
Everytime i see cool gear i wanna buy it, but end up restraining myself because i will probably not make good use of it.
im trying my best to learn this hobby properly, but its really difficult and everytime i make my car spin, frustration hits me again x.x
OK, Enough for my self help, great video as always, we need more people like you chris
I think that's a good opportunity to sit back and reflect on what's actually fun and enjoyable for you and what's only there because "that's what people do" or "that's what I must do"
You need to look up some TH-cam tutorials mate. I struggled for the first month. Personally believe GT Sport is the best game to pick up the fundamentals before moving onto more difficult sims.
Was that a Mitch Hedberg reference? Wonderful!
The one thing that you didn't mention is the dual clutch paddle option. As far as I can tell, the only GT style wheels that offer this as an option (upgrade) is Fanatec and either the Ascher F64 (possibly their button boxes can add them, but not sure how difficult that is).
I realize that the dual clutch isn't always an option on most GT cars, and are less useful with rolling start races, but some titles and race series put you into standing starts, where the dual clutch can be handy. Any feedback on how hard it is to modify say an SRC, GSI, Cube Control, etc, wheel to include dual clutch?
I have Simracingbay GT3 wheel for GT and open wheel racing, and a Sparco round wheel with simline button box for Ovals and Rallying, so I am pretty much covered, and since I race in VR two different button placements to memorize is enough :)
Hmm a review of the wheel conversion kits like for the T300 wheel or the TM Open wheel addon.
Swapped my used modified G27 (GTEye springs+replaced potentiometers with the 3drap kit) for a used T500RS set and so the topic of the Video was really interesting.
Especially as modding the brake pedal to my taste and requirements (sadly I can't hardmount them) was a bit tricky, given that I want a progressive feel and a pedal roughly as firm or slightly firmer than the GTEYE s but not enough to send the Pedals sliding.
Great video Chris. Best production values out there. What is the button setup you are using on that Turn racing wheel. I have never seen it before. Is it sold by Fanatec?
That same Turn rim is my primary rim for ACC, it's been great.
I'm always surprised by how many people use the 270MM Fanatec Formula V2 for ACC. The only reason I can think of is it is the nicest mid-range all in one wheel they have. The McLaren wheel is relatively plastic and cheap, while the M4 rim is as much 4 to 5 times as much.
Fanatec would be smart to release a GT all in one on the same level as their Formula wheel IMO
I started out with the Fanatec WRC wheel. I mainly ride ACC so I decided I wanted more of a formula style wheel. The Fanatec clubsport has been my main wheel for the last couple of months and it's a great step up from the WRC wheel, however, I'm starting to realize it's actually a little to small. I'm now in the process of replacing my CSL DD for a VRS DFP and therefore choosing a new wheel. For now, the choice is between a Turner and a Polsimer setup. However, I might treat myself and buy a Eau Rouge P1 :-D
Great video !!
I am an avid racer - just not in a sim. I’m looking at the fanatec club sport alcantera fully round wheel as my only wheel to start out with. I love rally so think a round wheel will be best for everything - plus that’s what I’m used to in my own race car.
9:12 this! Everytime I look at getting a second rim for my T300 I think this, shrug and go "better save the money instead for when something breaks".
7:16 Real MVP shit. Thank you Chris
Hi Chris, thanks for another video, great idea for the content. I have DD1 F1 wheel PS4/5 but I always had T300 F599x alcantara edition. I play ASsetto Corsa Competizione but I want to try all different street cars in Assetto Corsa and also try a rally game. Obviously I can’t enjoy it with F1 wheel. My plan was to disassemble DD1 F1 wheel (the blue one) and add F599x wheel using podium hub to DD1. You meanthat will not work? What happens when you add F599X wheel to podium hub and DD1. Is there reduced FFB or there’s none, do shifters work? (I haven’t got a gear shifter). Many thanks!
Chris we love youu !!! :D
Should do one on Oval and options with MPI and dirt wheel options
thank you very much brother.
Off to a good start with a Mitch Hedberg reference 😂
Chris I’m wondering if you are aware of a video comparing a number of direct drive wheel bases? I am now ready to purchase my first dd base and I am aware of Fanatec’s new $350 base but for my next purchase I am hoping for a base that gives me the best force feedback experience or rather the most realistic representation of what a game might provide. I found one vid from sim racing garage but they compared 3 and I was only familiar with the one that took 3rd place. I am guessing that it would be difficult and expensive to bring a current selection of dd bases together for this comparison. Is there a generally excepted brand that is currently considered the best racing experience?
9:11 WRONG! I simply cannot support this blatant misinformation masquerading as analysis. You ALWAYS need more gear! ;-)
Great video Chris. I've been waiting for this with great anticipation. My Turn Racing R20 should be arriving this week.
Haha. I like to flirt with controversy ;) Hope you like the wheel, they've always been a favourite of mine.
How do I give a like for video and a second one for the public information broadcast? It was brilliant and funny.
Yet another question 4 U, Does the Magnetic Shifter Mod for the G29 &920 work with the G923... ?
Lovely video! Are you actually full or parttime?
I've had a fanatec formula wheel for 2 years but recently changed to a round wheel and it made slides much easier to catch and reduced the overall grip strentgth I had to use on the wheel, on the flipside, car dashes are harder to see but moving the seating position a bit and using a third party dash kinda nullify this
I been looking at the Simline wheels. They seem to be pretty high quality, what are your thoughts on the HURACAN GT3 you have from them?
these are so expensive but now i have a good enough reason to save up🤣
can u please do a video on which wheel would be best for F1?
2:23 me 360 drifting it to the inside of the corner while flipping off the newbs behind me as I face them
Chris you forgot to cover the most important aspect: how cool it looks and how cool you feel while using it.
I'm at point where I can't drive a car if I don't have a replica wheel
Mario karts it is
Well, you are making them, so thats a bit different story :)
@@Pucis666 they are still not made out of air😁
@@tracklizard4018 *F1 Race Stars here I come!*
I would love to see a rally version of this
I've always been that guy that appriciate things that replicate the real counter part, for an example, I prefer the Simline Porsche wheel over the Fanatec one, just because it has the raw finish to it, it's just like it should be, no more, no less.
That's the reason to why I never got myself to buy any of the licensed Fanatec wheels either, they simply don't look right, they might have the shape, they might have the right diameter and so on, but there's always a compromise to fit that LCD screen for an example.
They add unnecessary things like a extra frame, to fit things like the rev lights, TC/ABS lights, which has never been a part of the real life counter part.
I understand that people enjoy this kind of stuff, and I understand that people take advantage of the info they can get out of it, and I got nothing against it, whatever floats your goat I guess.
But for me, it got to look right. And the irony here, is that I'm using VR, I'm not even looking at the wheel when using it, like at all. 😂
As lovely as this all looks... my G25 was given to me for free by a mate, and has given me more than enough pleasure the past few years! 😂
Holy shit the TV broadcast at 9 minutes was hilarious.
I own too many gt wheels (fanatec mclaren and porsche, a turnracing mclaren and an aston) but i keep coming back to the cheapest, but grip-superiour mclaren gt3 wheel by fanatec. Bang for the buck
That ending really made me laugh out loud
I'm waiting for the new thrustmaster f1 wheel
Hi mate, what do you use to keep your wheels standing upright? I Need it :D
I know this is an old video but I have to know more about that Corvette wheel. I neeeeeed it plzzzzzz
Might be a weird question but what is the overall difference between gt wheels and formula style wheels?
does the sim line Lamborghini wheel work with Xbox and the fanatec csl base
You should put the public information video as a standalone video for use as a meme whenever anyone says they want some new gear.
hi! is there meant to be a mini fanatec direct drive base?
So many innuendos!
More wheels than a wheel convention - was that a mcclusky reference? (To hell with good intentions!)
What shape/size is apt for 50s to 90s open wheelers...?
.... and for everybody who wants to Keep their kidneys and their G29/920/27, Iran only recommend the MVH Studios GT Wheel 😉
Really good video Chris, thanks for making me research wether I need two kidneys.
Mclusky rocked, the only difference between you me is that I don't have a fanatec wheel, or do mclusky does wheels😂
Hi Chris, are you planning to record a review of the latest F1 car from RSS?
Yeah, hopefully later this week. Though, I do't make promises about such things anymore, since I'm terrible at keeping them!
@@ChrisHaye Thanks for the reply. I will look forward. I'll be looking forward to it. Have a great day.
Oh yes so good living in Brazil (where I would have to sell my apartment to buy any of these) and watching this video, I'll go back crying to my g29 T_T
Chris, what's your impression on the Ricmotech Sim ?
I've not had a chance to try any of the Richmotech stuff - it seems to be a lot more common State-side.
@@ChrisHaye Thanks for the feed back. I haven't physically seen one, but they do look solid..
I have my eyes on the Fanatec Porsche wheel 👀
Anybody know if the turn racer style wheel can be used with an h pattern or does it not really work
Is there any gt style wheel and pedals that have a price of about $400-$500
Thrustmaster rim is super easy to mod to magnetic shifting :)
Chris says T300 is not compatible with Fanatec, I have DD1. So what is the issue? He hasn’t got back to me. Would you know? I upgraded from T300 (F599XX) to DD1 ps4 and need round wheel, so I thought I could use T300 rim.
I think a lot of people spend far too much money on fancy wheels. Completely unnecessary but you like what you like I guess. For me it's just a wheel and I'm happy with the one one that came with my wheelbase. I drive all cars with the same wheel, if I need faster initial turn in I do it thru the sim software. I think size becomes an issue with more powerful setups, even 6Nm gets pretty tiring via a 280mm wheel. You can add magnetic shifter mods to just about everything that doesn't have it it out of the box and in some cases the mod can also be used to shorten the travel on the paddle should you wish. The stuff that is crammed into it the more likely it will go wrong especially when the manufacturer overtightens the screws. Yes, you know who you are. Fix up.
Wow, I feel personally attacked by that ending
Huracan Gt3 ❤️
Yeah, it's a looker alright!
Lastima. Acá en Argentina no llegan
And here’s me with my g920 :)
What would you say is the best gt game?
I think there's a problem when the racing wheel (the whole setup) costs more than a decent Mountain bike.
Do you now of a wheel that you can change for xbox?
Grandpa tell them about your G27!
6:44
Yeeeaaahhhhhh
Can you do the same with F1 wheels?
5:43 what game is that?
Load cell pedals were faster when tested against g920 pedals by driver61
Have you tried the Rosso Sim Racing replica wheels?
I have! There's a video about it on my channel I made back in 2019 based on the prototype of the Audi wheel.
@@ChrisHaye Ooooh let me have a look at it :)
@@ChrisHaye What are the differences between the Rosso Sim Racing wheel and the simline GT3 Huracan Replica ? Did you feel any difference ?
@@ChrisHaye I actually watched this video lol, I forgot I actually discovered Rosso Sim Racing thanks to you in the first place loool