Ask Shaykh YQ #84: The Punishment of the Crime of Rape in the Shari’ah
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ก.ย. 2020
- Today's Question: The Punishment of the Crime of Rape in the Shari’ah
Please LIKE, COMMENT, & SHARE!
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Credits:
Outro Nasheed:
Link: tiny.cc/outro2
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official Social Media Pages
Facebook: yasirqadhi
Instagram: yasir.qadhi
Twitter: yasirQadhi
Snapchat: snapchat.com/add/yasir.qadhi
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
© Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official TH-cam Channel
![[Full Episode] MasterChef Junior Thailand มาสเตอร์เชฟ จูเนียร์ ประเทศไทย Season 3 Episode 4](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/e7Oqqo90x_w/mqdefault.jpg)
Absolutely and totally agree with you. That incident has shaken us to the core, thank you for addressing every aspect of it.
What incident now?
@@bloodtalon1 muhamed raping his slaves and his child bride
in islam, there are rules and exceptions, no rules for leaders, islam is corruption
Happened in Pakistan.
Thank you so so much for addressing this issue! Especially about the sexual abuse statistics,victim blaming and shaming. This was totally the need of the hour.
Also please please address the men on LOWERING THEIR GAZES! Scholars and speakers rarely stress on this!
finally an unapologetic answer. Be proud of shari'a law :) it's the only solution to humanity.
@@themistersmith your getting confused between zina and rape
@@bullseye9723 I know the difference between zina and rape, so I don't know why you made that comment.
@@themistersmith I don't think he realised you were refuting that position.
@ShitGotRealPost the hadeeth please.
@ShitGotReal I am not interested in a back and forth with you. Bye.
Rape is similar to a death event. The person either goes on fight mode and that is very rare, or goes on fright mode and dissosiates from her/his own body, and is just pralysed. Of course, because of that dissociation, the traumatic memory is sometimes '' missplaced'' in the hippocampus. May Allah save us from this kind of injustice.
@ShitGotReal The punishment is death. In case you didn't watch the video. This is what the sunna shows, but there's a lot of countries who don't follow th suna.
@ShitGotReal ok, my bad
Sheikh, may God bless you & your family & loved ones 🤲👨👩👧👦
Words always fail me to express how deeply grateful i am for your existence & presence among us, your e-brothers-&-sisters from all around the world!
May God reward you & grant you sincerity in everything that you do, & may He allow us to continue to benefit from your knowledge & wisdom.
Omg, thank you so much for this video! I was searching for this video, suphanallah! One year past I've got touched by a random man, a photographer in a photostudio. He basically trappes me and I first didn't know what he was doing but then I realized it was sexual assault/rape. I kind of still feel guilty sometimes that I went there. He basically promised me a job offer an trapped me, told me that on the shooting day there woul be a whole team and we wouldn't be alone. When I saw that there wasn't anyone besides the photographer I started to become suspuccious about the situation. Then the second time a guy from my workplace just invited me to a date/meeting etc. he seemed like a nice guy but yeah. I was really blaming my self a lot for this and I still do but at least this video gave me a lot of hope. Thank you so much I'm also trying to get closer to deen. 🤲🏻😖❤
There was also a very recent incident in Morocco happening to a young sweet innocent boy who after having to endure such a vicious disgusting act was then murdered. It literally shook the entire country and everyone is in uproar demanding the death penalty of this despicable person who admitted his guilt. It makes me so angry and it breaks my heart to know this happens on regular basis. True justice will be served with Allah.
Precaution measures also include following the guidelines of Quran and Sunnah . For instance not travelling alone , travelling early morning etc
Saying duas of leaving home, of starting journey , by following these we have strong feeling of security , we can read the translation of these duas and learn what we are asking for from our Rabb Al Hafeez , As Salaam , and Al Walee and
Allah knows best .
I think pornography is a big part of why this kind of thing is becoming so rampant. The men are becoming less human and more animalistic. We have a very sick ummah. Im so glad it is being addressed. I think the severity of the punishment is necessary. The shariah law has to be upheld in order to protect people from harm and violation of their rights. Allah's law is above everything.
alcohol is also one of the reasons
Thank you Sheikh for speaking so firmly and honestly about this.
Great speech
jazakallah khair shaikh
Very nicely explained each n every aspect
Jazak’Allah kherun kaseerun🌹
Jazakallahu khairan shaykh! Such a beautiful lecture!❤️
Jazak Allah khairun Shiekh for tackling this issue. Very thorough answer indeed to a very sensitive topic. May Allah swt shower his mercy on you. Ameen
Comprehensive and well documented lecture on the topic delivered very effectively. Thank you for the advice for parents and elders.
What Brother Yasser
saying is afact
And that have to be talked about it's so important 🙏❤
Jazakum Allahu khairan to both of you, the sister who´s asking and sheikh for the clear answer.
ماشاء اللّه
Salaam from Nottingham Uk
و عليكم اسلام اختي
Assalaamu Alycum Sheikh. Can you please give advice on missed Salaah over years. In Shaa Allah
Rip
Here is Sheikh yasir qadi's advice:th-cam.com/video/DH4M0n30bqs/w-d-xo.html
Shaykh's laptop and panjabi are matching in color. Ma-sha-allah, you are looking handsome
Ameen🤲🏻
Finally someone talking sense. Someone add Urdu and Arabic captions please.
Punishment is at 25:50
👍👌✌️
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم
(33) - إِنَّمَا جَزَاءُ الَّذِينَ يُحَارِبُونَ اللَّهَ وَرَسُولَهُ وَيَسْعَوْنَ فِي الْأَرْضِ فَسَادًا أَنْ يُقَتَّلُوا أَوْ يُصَلَّبُوا أَوْ تُقَطَّعَ أَيْدِيهِمْ وَأَرْجُلُهُمْ مِنْ خِلَافٍ أَوْ يُنْفَوْا مِنَ الْأَرْضِ ۚ ذَٰلِكَ لَهُمْ خِزْيٌ فِي الدُّنْيَا ۖ وَلَهُمْ فِي الْآخِرَةِ عَذَابٌ عَظِيمٌ
Indeed, the penalty for those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger and strive upon earth [to cause] corruption is none but that they be killed or crucified or that their hands and feet be cut off from opposite sides or that they be exiled from the land. That is for them a disgrace in this world; and for them in the Hereafter is a great punishment,
Verse of hiraba حرابة
How do we send in questions? Please add to description box.
Unfortunately politics is usually taking place and I wont be sure if this was done purposefully to take away attention from the main issues going on in the country...may Allah give us hidaya and protect usn
How can I ask Yasir Qadhi in this series?
Also SH. The USA are DEFINITELY to light on punishment but here in CANADA it's even worse. Recently someone got slaughtered in the Mosque I go to and the police have the audacity to say it wasn't a hate crime. Everytime something like this happens they just say they have mental illness or put them on probation for just 8 months which our probation here still allows you to go Anywhere IN the province. It is such a warzone here in Toronto that every single crime you can think of happens on a daily to the point I don't know what to do.
Most sexual assault is said to be American and statistics indicate the same for preadolescent molestation.
Not true , listen to what was said at 11:05, 21:10 and at about 18:01. In Many under developed countries these things often aren't reported due to cultural stigmas. The west reports , investigates and records so we hear about it more. Just adding to the conversation.
molestation is very very likely to happen, regardless of in which country, because many parents is not aware that their own children, especially girls, were much friendlier toward other adults, such as their uncles. So every interaction in regards to your children and your own family members, like niece or sibling, should be supervised.
it doesn't matter. When it happens, the victim isn't thinking "this is an American phenomenon or I'm an adult, not an adolescent."
@@hylianlegends Adolescents are accountable for their choices and beliefs. Victim means it is not their fault and it needs dealt with regardless of age, gender, or other factors.
@ShitGotReal That was the pre quranic punishment according to Muslim and no Hadith can be used to justify violating Quran. Ahmad bin Hanbal will live in infamy for relating weak narratives against the Prophet and Islam.
We all know that country is"Pakistan"😔
We can't know others never send your kids to anyone's home NEVER! I was a teacher in a school and there was this boy who goes to the neighbour and the dad ...always did what he did ...I was surprised I always heard that such people didn't have babies so how come.To me the mom was to blame why allow your child to go people's homes we can't be sure who they are especially in these times of corruption and contradiction.
As salaamu 'alaykum sheikh, you're probably not going to read this. However, I hope your admins confer the message to you if they find it important. I never comment on videos, and now I'm only writing because I have no doubt that your intentions are as good as they can be and I know that you revise your opinions if need be.
I propose we leave the issue of women's clothing and the reason of being at any place at any time out of any discussion about rape or molestation. Like you've said, the fault is 100% on the perpetrator and that has nothing to do with what the other person is doing. It doesn't matter whether the woman was properly dressed, had any business to be in a certain place etc. These things may lead to invitations for flirtatious behaviour etc., but one who wants to flirt or have sex with the consent of the other party, does not go on to rape and molest. A person wanting to commit consenting zina, doesn't become a rapist or molester just because they want to have sex. A rapist or molester does not respect the other person's autonomy of their own body at all, loves the feeling of power, is very entitling, is a manipulator and aggressive etc.
Of course, there is a place and time to teach women and men to dress modestly, even take precautions to keep away criminals, but that place is not when we're talking about Islam's stance on rape and the causes of rape etc. Even bringing that up leads to ignorant people using this to always direct the attention to the victim and what she's done wrong in stead of justice for her. We should give the victims at least this dignity, that their actions have nothing to do with why they were victimized.
😞😞
O ALLAH, PLEASE PROTECT ME FROM THE EVIL OF WHAT I THINK, FROM THE EVIL OF WHAT I HEAR, FROM THE EVIL OF WHAT I SEE, AND FROM THE EVIL OF MY SEMEN(I.E SEXUAL PASSION)
Shaikh not mentioning the name of the country...but when everyone already know which country....
I wrote an article in bahasa indonesia about my bad experience about a minor incident that i think related to sexual abuse and you know what?
Thats happen inside the masjid when i pray in jamaah.
Dear Shaykh,
Technically, is that raper considered as sahaba as well?
no, technically he need to confess that he witness Muhammad as prophet of Allah, and he believe in Allah. There's no indication in the story that he did.
xponen_ ultimatly he confessed out of guilt, which must be taqwa. Can I think it took place in mosque
@@xponen Please don't answer things you don't know. He was a Muslim. He did confess his sin when he saw the other man being convicted for a crime he didn't commit. And in Islam, when you pay the punishment in this world, you are forgiven. Allah knows best.
@@hylianlegends but are we sure he was a Muslim, is this an information contained in hadith?
@@xponen It's heavily implied. If he was a Christian or Jew why would he be at Masjid al Nabawi? If he were a Munafiq why would he confess?
That country was Pakistan sadly a Muslim country. Allahu Musta'an
The punishment of Rape is the punishment of فساد في ارض killing, hanging by post, or cutting opposite hand and foot or banishment .
And evidence is questions and examination of accused as no1
Doctor female preferably no 2
Investigative Officer for circumstantial evidence no3
And forensic expert no 4
As in our era as in حشر hands and feet and earth with no eyes can give evidence. And even 1 or 2 or 3 or 4 evidence will do if judge is satisfied by the level of evidence.
زنا
Of error is توبة and pain
زانى
A habitual and addicted to زنا
Is 100 lashes in front of group of people. And to marry each other or a مشرك i.e equal to شرك
If 2 men or women restricted to confinement and given pain till repent not to do again .
If a husband or wife is only witness give 4 oaths and 5 th curse for punishment if spouse agree and if not then طلاق.
If a family accuse own woman or man confine in house till die or evidence come or accuser proven false.
If a محصن man or woman is accused 4 credible evidence and if unable then lashes and never to be taken as evidence, i.e all police stations and courts made known and take their testimony on that level unless 100 percent proven true
However stoning are not mentioned in The Al Quran, so its not mandated by Al Quran, wawallahu a’lam 🙏🙏
Stoning is from Islam umar said a time will come where people will say stoning is not from Islam's he said something similar to this
@m m, in term of Islam is the religion since Adam, Daud, Moses, etc yes, stoning is from Islam, it's (the stoning) the syaria mention in Torah, The Prophet Muhammad SAW, have done the syaria even though He try to avoid it, however, if we talk about Al Quran, the stoning is not mentioned in the Al Quran, wawallahu a'lam, Allah know best 🙏🙏
@@darmawan88 akhi stoning is found in the sunnah of the prophet sallahualayhiwassalam but the prophet stones a few people
@@darmawan88 True but according to a Saheeh Hadeeth, stoning is mentioned. However the way it says it has to be implemented is very tough. You need to have 4 pious witness who have witnessed it. So virtually its impossible. Allah knows best. 👍
Just letting everyone know the country Shaik is talking about is Pakistan.
What does a daughter do when her father sexually abuses her ?
@@maisalem2243 generally if the trauma breaks out it is too late. And sometimes your whole life is an evidence, even for doctors, but you have no proof.
That assumes that there are pure witnesses. And these days DNA evidence. The wrongly accused have the right for protection. Death is often only for the satisfaction of the angered in many cases. (Accusations that come from hatred or revenge or for a cover up of one’s own weakness, or for some worldly gain like inheritance.) Not for the protection of a society. Many times rape occurs because of consensual meeting in secrecy +/-foreplay. Many a time not in a way of assault but from ignorance. Something that is less seen in Islamic lands but growing. This is a big difference between the US and other lands.
US law places “innocent until proven guilty” for a reason that people of these days are not of those whom were of consciousness of their Creator back when. They would not have the integrity to ask the important questions, but only assume.
Now surround the cultural issues of “don’t let anyone know, you will shame our family!” How are we to wed our daughter who is not a virgin!” Etc.
I believe in death for a death. But I can’t absorb the accusation of rape being automatically tied to a death penalty. And I believe the victim has the right to forgive if they wish, despite opposition. And the criminal would have to live in shame yet have a chance to repent and give compensation of some preset range.
The whole purpose is to keep each life from being tossed into the Fire. How are we as an Ummah doing that if all are not correcting our own families, institutions, and societies? How are we to neglect asking why someone would do such sin upon others and try to place solutions? Choosing to work at the bottom end to a quick disposal neglects the top end of the issue.
Prison time allows for one to reflect and learn from their actions. If not, then death is a clear choice for it is not upon just one individual, it is upon the society. Just thoughts from my own personal life’s experience and I had to voice my heart’s sense to choose a less aggressive view. It’s easy to become disconnected when not experiencing being a victim. Some victims don’t want to be reminded and be forced to relive such horror, in the public, in court, in front of their attacker, and move on in life in peace and patience of Judgement Day.
Unless you have an idea of the trauma a sexually assaulted person goes through please dont go around dispensing your 2 cents on mercy and forgiveness. Even if you do,and are speaking for forgiveness of an accused please limit it to speaking for yourself. Jail time is introspection time for accused? God knows on what basis you arrived on that probability for ALL. Some crimes can never be forgiven even in this world and rape is 1 amongst those- and rightfully so without doubt our lord has laid down repercussions for it subhanallah.
Rape is only allowed in Islam if the one being raped is not a Muslim. Speaking of which, whenever I bring up the FIRST part of Quran 4:24, Muslims will always bring up the REST of Quran 4:24 that allows for prostitution by paying the lady, and, has nothing to do with the FIRST part of Quran 4:24.
Elaborate
@@edsmijr.5893 Well, the FIRST part of Quran 4:24 says, "Forbidden to you are married women (you can't have 'forbidden sex" with MARRIED women) EXCEPT (that's the key word so you can) EXCEPT what your 'right hand possess' (slave/captured). And, since there is no mention of consent to make it adultery, that's rape of someone's wife.
@Joe Bide Didn't read those scriptures, I see.
@Joe Bide To this in german we say "ungebildet" (underaducated), she or he idk basically missinformed her/hisself. And is interpretting somethis in our beautiful deen.