MGI Zip Navigator vs Motocaddy M7 // Best Electric Remote Golf Trolley Under $2000
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ส.ค. 2024
- Motocaddy M7 Remote or the MGI Zip Navigator? What’s the BEST electric golf trolley under $2000? We put 2 of the best and most popular eletric remote golf trolleys head to head on the golf course in a series of tests to find the winner.
For our full review of each click link below:
MGI Zip Navigator Review - • MGI Zip Navigator Elec...
Motocaddy M7 Remote Review - • Motocaddy M7 Remote El...
All that, and more.........
► Hit Subscribe & HitTheBell so you don't miss out on any new videos!
Get your swag at www.newninegolf.com WORLD WIDE SHIPPING AVAILABLE
Thanks so much to everyone that has supported the channel!
Like and Leave a Comment Below!
Instagram ► / newninegolf
Facebook ► / newninegolf
Web ► www.newninegolf.com/
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hi I’m Brandon Cubitt or @NEWNINEGOLF on Instagram, welcome to my channel New Nine Golf. I'm a scratch golfer and I'm obsessed with all things golf! I'll give you unbiased reviews from a consumer perspective and ill bring on golf pro's for lesson series to help make you a better golfer. My golf course vlogs will give you an inside look at the courses I'm playing and you can see where my game is at. New Nine Golf is a culture of not giving up, learning from mistakes and moving forward to be a better version of yourself everyday.
Timestamps:
00:00 - Intro
00:43 - Common Features
02:18 - Motcaddy Advantages
03:14 - MGI Advantages
04:00 - Head to Head Test 1 - Fold and Unfold
06:18 - Test 2 - Remote Controls
08:55 - Test 3 - Manual Controls
11:23 - Test 4 - Hill Test
12:55 - Test 5 - Overall Build Quality
14:30 - Final Thoughts and Winner
Please email brandon@newninemediaco.com for all business inquiries.
#golf #golfing #golfreview
Thanks for watching the video Motocaddy M7 vs MGI Zip Navigator // Best Electric Remote Golf Trolley - กีฬา
![[Live] : ONE FIGHT NIGHT 24 “จาร์เร็ด vs กุสตาโว”](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ENNA-fsT67c/mqdefault.jpg)
I've owned my ZIp Navigator for over 3 years and I have over 2000 miles on my odometer. It paid for itself during the second year. It DOES have a USB port under the handle. The AT does have wider front wheels for added stability but it doesn't have a USB port or the front wheel gyro. The gyro keeps the cart on track even after hitting any bump or hidden sprinkler hear. After folding the cart, it occupies less space than my folded Sun Mountain Speed Cart. The best part is all I do now is walk, no pushing, no pulling. I don't think the STOP button being at the bottom of the remote is an issue. Since I don't have multiple remotes it doesn't matter where it is. And finally, what I've learned with a battery cart, keep your eyes on it. If you get distracted it's going to keep going where it's pointed. Just stop it before you start looking for a ball, start a conversation, etc.
I think you made a mistake with the uphill test. The M7 went straight up the hill while the MGI was aimed up at an slight angle and as the MGI has the gyroscope it tried to stay on that path, that’s why it had to steer sometime. You should have tried the M7 at the same angle and it probably would have steered to the left considerably.
Thank you for the review. I have had a Motocaddy M7 for a little over a year and am thinking about switching to an MGI. The main issues I've had with the Motocaddy are: 1) The arm lock mechanism on the side is very stiff and it's taken over a year for it to loosen up slightly. 2) The cart veers hard left and right without the gyroscope technology. I'm constantly having to adjust direction. 3) I've had a really difficult time adjusting to the sensitivity of the remote. If I press a turn button lightly, it only turns a little bit, if I add a little more pressure, it turns 90 degrees. This may just be me. I haven't tried remotes on other trolleys to compare. Otherwise, the Motocaddy is a well built, very sturdy piece of equipment. The battery is very easy to install and remove and it takes a couple hours to recharge after 18 holes on a moderately hilly course. MGI's are much more popular where I play, in part due to their availability at Costco.
Pro Tip: You don't want the MGI Zip Navigator if you play on courses with lots of hills, mounds and elevation changes. You want the MGI Zip Navigator AT (All Terrain) model. Why, you may ask? The AT fixed the problem that both the regular Zip and other competitors (such as Motocaddy) have. The AT spreads out the front wheel base out wider, which makes it much less susceptible to tip over and makes it a much better balanced unit than any models with the wheel bases like the two you see in this video. If you play relatively flat courses, then the M7 and regular Zip are fine.
Agreed. Even though the motocaddy does better on hills. The AT model is still better like you said with the wide front wheel base. Keep in mind though with the wider wheel base, it makes the cart less nimble. The turning radius is bigger. So depends on what people want I guess.
I own the A/T and can confirm on hilly wet courses it still tips over when one wheel slips and buggy spins , motocaddy should be better balanced due to battery been in the center not hung of the back like MGI
I have the MGI Zip Navigator AT version with front wheels farther apart for stability. I play on hilly courses and it works great. It may need a little hands on to stabilize it better on really steep hills. I 100% recommend this product. Best investment I've ever made for my golf game. And this things is a tank! It's been through a lot in well over two years and it's still going strong...cart and batteries. The only negative is the accessories. They are pricey for being poorly made plastic junk. Every single accessory has broken and I'm about to go on my third drink holder under normal use. I am careful with stuff so it's a bit frustrating.
Been looking at the M7 option bc I’ve had an M3 Pro for 5 seasons and am really impressed with the build quality. Only thing I don’t like is the accessories are junk, on the M3 I’ve taken the clips off my old clicgear to use their accessories. BUT I can’t say enough about the easy lock pins, it works amazing with the standbag. Thanks for a great review.
Both great buggies in my opinion, I ended up getting the MGI Zip Navigator AT, only problem is the MGI accessories are terrible. I ended up finding an All In 1 accessory made by Stadium Golf, that really is a massive help when playing, it carries absolutely everything you need and has a small footprint. I'm pretty sure they make them for the Motocaddy buggies too.
I have the accessory too, it’s very good
Can you install seat on both model?
It's nice to do the comparisons,I have the new mgi with wider from swivel wheels plus recharge function under handle...it's brilliant and very easy to navigate It makes a big difference with energy levels after a round...thanks for the review.... cheers...
That’s awesome to hear. Thanks for the support!
Great review, Thanks!
Thank you! This helps me decide which one to purchase for my hubby!
What an awesome gift!
I have had a Motocaddy S7 remote for several years, and whilst it supposedly has a corrective feature to maintain a straight line on a side hill, it doesn't work well, and the gyroscope feature sounds really fantastic. I have had 2 S7's and always said I would get another if it was stolen! But this gyroscope trick could be a game changer.
I put a 5 lbs dumbell weight in the front pocket of my bag and it eliminated the wheels coming up off the ground while going uphill. I have the MGI Zip Navigator AT.
Great review! Love my Motocaddy.
BTW, the Zip Navigator has a USB charging port underneath the handle also. The weakness with the Zip is the battery placement being behind the reader axle. That makes it tippier and you have to be careful not to dump it. This is why the new MGI moved the battery forward. The gyro that keeps it going straight is a big plus. If you ever drive on in a pond or creek, then it’s done no matter what make or model.
Great review, now I want one.
Thanks! An electric cart is probably one of my best golf investments. 👍
up hill test should have run them on the same track
Thanks for the video!!!!!
Thanks for watching Ryan! 🍻
I know guys who have both these units as wells as the Stewart. I like how upright the bag sits on the MGI.
Can't really go wrong with any of them.
I've had the Caddytrek for 6 yrs now and it's been outstanding. I've seen a couple of my friends go through 2-3 different types or remotes and still not be as satisfied as me with the Caddytrek.
Glad you found something that works well for you. Happy golfing. ⛳🍻
Even on a phone scree I can see you sent the moto caddy up a smooth incline and the zip up one win a bump in it. 😂
Yes, that's what he did. The MGI's gyro was self-evident as you notice the correction done during the uphill.
Is there a way to make the speed control dial more flexible? For me, 4 is too slow, and 5 is too fast. Especially noticeable when in manual mode and you have your hands on the handle and trying to use the umbrella.
He is 100 percent right about the mgi remote. I had the zip and the stop button away from the arrows made using the cart annoying. The 2023 zip has a redesigned remote.
due to the battery placement moto would benefit from tipping over but I'm still pleased with MGI zip nav. Gyro was my main reason why I went with Nav. really helps out a lot. although reluctant to install the seat.. might be the laughing stock at my club lol
You’ll be laughing when you’re lounging and they are walking up a hill with clubs on their back.
Have you considered reviewing the Alphard Golf V2 e wheels? This is a great option for players who already have a push cart. I have this and absolutely love it. The main reason I would never switch is because I love the top lock technology on the bag boy carts that hold the bag in perfectly. Since I can just add the electric motor wheels to my BagBoy cart, this is the perfect electric cart.
I have a couple buddies that own one and they love it. Same reason as you as their bags fit better on their push cart. For me personally, I have storage for my bag and my cart. They won't store ewheels so I would have to take it with me every time. But I would definitely consider doing a review on them.
Just an update. My club doesn’t store e wheels either so ended up getting the MGI Zip Navigator
If you use them day in and day out, the gyro is the biggest difference. You don't have to constantly adjust your direction. I like where the battery is because I can take it off and on without removing the bag.
BTW the Zip Navigator has a USB port like the Motocaddy M7.
Pretty sure I’m going to lose some money this weekend. Awesome video man.
Thanks!
Was waiting for this
Thoughts?
Overall good review. Would like to know about services, replacement parts, maintenance, etc. Wish they had a bag to put all my junk. Appreciate the review...guess I'm going to take your word for it...M7 it is.
I totally agree about the bag accessory. You can’t go wrong with an M7! Let me know how you like it.
@@NewNineGolf will do. 👍
I wish you would have reviewed all accessories that can be purchased with each. I would definitely want a seat.
How would you compare these with the Aiphgard v2
Please do a review of the new Bagboy Volt electric push cart.
You did a review of the stewart q follow. Compared to one of these two would you say the follow is quite significantly better taking into account the increased cost ? Am considering the q follow for my next cart.
The follow feature is quite amazing! It also folds considerably smaller than both of these. I would consider it a superior cart but close to twice the cost.
@@NewNineGolf Thanks. I would also like a seat which I don't think is an option for stewart. I golf in Az in the winter and our course doesn't have a benches. It's nice if you have to wait to sit down fora bit. Older knees appreciate it.
@New Nine Golf I have a Ghost stand bag. I see you have a Vessel. Does one of these carts fit better, or do they both work?
They both should work. Its sit a little better on the motocaddy. The leg mechanism on stand bags are pretty annoying for carts but as long as you strap the legs to the bag so it doesnt open on its on the cart. Hope this helps.
No.6: What is the cost to replace the battery for each unit?
I’m looking at getting an electric cart but I want to know which one is best for a bloke who is 6’4? Do you know the ground to handle heights?
You’ll be fine. I’m 6’3 and never felt any cart was short. Plus you’ll be using a remote 90% of the time.
How would compare the Motocaddy M7 remote to the Axglo golf E5 Electric Caddy?
I’d go Axglo just for the follow feature
what is the weight difference?
Can add a seat on both?
? up hills, side hills, how easly tipped over, battery life?
Would you take these over a Q follow? (regardless of price)
Fair question. I’m obsessed with that follow feature. On the course, the only thing that beats it is someone else carrying your clubs. So I would still rank the q follow higher.
@@NewNineGolf Thanks, very helpful
@@nathanbutterworth7700 but's double the cost.
Question for you. If price was not a issue. Which Electric Golf Trolley would you recommend (MGI Zip Navigator , Motocaddy M7, or Stewart Q follow).?
Q follow. You don’t have to worry about the gyroscope when it follows you. It also has the best materials of the 3. It’s also the most compact for putting it in a car or storage.
@@NewNineGolf Thanks for the quick response and thanks for all the reviews.
Anytime. Thanks for the support 👊🏻
Have you seen their new mgi zip navigator ai? It has gps, remote, and follow function! It looks pretty epic
I just looked it up. Looks awesome!
Do you need a different bag or can you use your existing bag
You can use your existing bag but I went over the pros and cons of certain bags in the video…..
I like the motocaddy better but I am worried I am going to regret not having the gyroscope? Can you talk about how much pain is it not having gyroscope with M7?
It’s not a huge pain at all.
Without the gyroscope feature, on an even slightly hilly course, you are forever correcting the trolley, and it is a pain.
I wonder if you swapped bags on the uphill challenge if the Zip might not have tipped back? It's possible your bag had more stuff in in it at the bottom of the bag to add a bit of weight.
I also suspect that whichever brand one chooses, and gets used to, that is which one works best for that customer. You'll get used to the remote and its functions. Along with the utilization of the trolley.
I'm considering my first battery operated trolley. So, your video helped. I think I would prefer one with the gyroscope to keep it straight. Also, you did not review how easy it is to go to manual mode in case the battery runs out or fails. Or if you hitch a ride back to the clubhouse because of rain or whatever. From reading other articles, you do not want to ruin the electronics and need to put the cart into manual mode.
As I live in Oregon, where it can rain..lol, i'd like more information on how to maintain a trolley if it gets wet and what is the failure rate of the battery or electronics. I suspect it's very low, and one may never get the truth from the manufacturer, but it's my money and I don't want warranty hassles. 😊
Hi there. Ive used both on the course with different bags and the Zip does tend to tip back more than the motocaddy. I dont think its a deal breaker though as you want to hold the handlebars on both if you're going up or down very steep hills. The gyroscope technology is really good on the zip. In the case you do need manual mode to push, there's that button on the wheel you push and you put the wheel out of geared mode so it's easier to push. (It allows the wheels to spin freely) I do think it's probably extremely rare that rain will damage the electronics. I think you'll be happy with either. Thanks for watching and hope this helps.
I have the zip navigator and I’m very happy with it. My course is very hilly. I think the reason it tipped in your video might have been the gyroscope feature which is actually a positive point because on uneven terrains the trolly might just go anywhere. With the gyroscope it stays where it is supposed to go. That’s my experience at least. I think an advantage for the motocaddy would be if you also had a motocaddy bag with the quick locking mechanism.
I fully agree
It’s tipping due to MGI having battery on the back vs M7 battery in the center so better balance
@@marlboroguy1975 Well, I ended up buying a M3. So far no tipping issues.
What is the REAL advantage of these electric carts over a manual push/pull carts?
Effort
both have USB port ;) and if the uphill was don i same track it would give same result :)
Yes on usb port. No on uphill. I own both of these and played numerous round with both after this review. M7 is better uphill.
@New Nine Golf i dont agree, and I had both, but now only MGI because it has gyro.
You're entitled to your own opinion. Enjoy your MGI. 🍻
Dear new nine golf.
You guys lucky: in North America, europe, etc. I mean i am in malaysia, just next door to the manufacturer in australia, and mgi remotes are not available here.
Ah sorry to hear.
The MGI Zip Navigator does have a USB charging port and I believe the main battery can be charged while mounted to the frame
Ya i found out after it has a usb port. Can't charge the battery while it's mounted though. The connectors are built into the battery and not a cable that comes out like some other units.
Great video, loved the intro also! Will you be trying the Powakaddy RX1 Remote/GPS in the near future? I am really wanting a electrical push cart because my back is bad, is having a remote essential in your opinion, or would you do well without one and just get a S1/FX3 etc? The remote versions are almost twice the price here in Norway
Thanks 🙂
Thanks! Appreciate it. I can definitely try to get my hands on one. That must be a new model? When I looked last year, they didn't have remote options available. I personally think the remote options are worth the investment. I have buddies that own non remote versions and they're alway have to hang on to the cart and I feel there's so much more freedom with the remote versions. You can park it to one side by a green or teebox and control the cart to the other side as your walking off. Rather than having to walk back to where you parked it. Hope this helps and hope your back get better. 🍻
When you did the up hill climb was the speed the same. Looked like the motto caddy was faster then the mgi.
It looked like the MGI gyro was self-correcting that's why the line wasn't straight.
I'd go for the MGI.
Are you shooting it at the Country Hills Golf Club in Calgary NW?
Yes
@@NewNineGolf Nice! That was my home course for nearly a decade. One of those houses in the background up the hill is my in-laws. I still sit and sip my coffee and watch golfers finish #8 Ridge and tee on #9. My only hole in one is at #16 at the talons. Good ol’ days.
That’s awesome. I’ve been there close to 18 years.
@@NewNineGolf nice. I would still be there had I not moved to Houston
Didn’t go uphill at same speed not a fair comparison in my opinion of the hill test. Should be same speed during test
Just bought the Navigator AT at Costco on their Christmas sale. Comes with full accessories including a seat. $300 off the regular price.
I think also the resistance to turning in manual mode is probably the gyroscope working to maintain it straight, still, good observation.
Nice review.
Awesome. Thats a sweet deal. Youll love it. Thanks for watching and the comment.
How much at costco?
$1,249
What about battery warranty’s
Both 2 year.
B
Do they both have a "follow me" function?
Neither do
@@NewNineGolf thanks !!! ... Damn, Ive never used one of these , but I think "follow" is a deal-breaker, must-have feature for me. I don't want to be distracted by fiddling with a remote control constantly during my round ?? Right? Follow would be magic 🤔🤔🤔
@huddwah I received a couple follow ones in the Stewart golf Q follow and Axglo. Check those out.
@@NewNineGolf will do. Love your reviews btw. Great quality, thorough and very watchable. Great work ! 👏🙂
Thank you. 🙏
Q-Follow beats both these
For this price it needs to have a seat and the ability for me to ride it all the way round.
What an absolute rip off
SIgh, why can't these testers use the same test conditions? Use the same damn bag on the same damn course. It takes a bit more effort, but c'mon.
Lol what? The bags aren’t even within a 1Lb difference and they are on the same course. Did we watch the same video?
Made the mistake of getting the callaway traverse. Wouldn’t wish it on my worst enemy worst designed product maybe ever