All these games seem pretty good, but the first is definitely my favourite. The second game looks nice enough, however the gameplay looks rather bland.
Based on their Fiverr pages the first game appears to have cost $25, the second $35, third $5, and last one is listed at $30. I would have to say #1 was easily the best investment.
Crazy that a skilled developer sells his craft for such a small prize. Even a hour worth of his time should cost more and the game wasn't made anywhere close to an hour(if he did, cudos).
The first game could end up being successful with proper funding and development. I love the idea of the recoil that launches you. Imagine that they added bosses, multiplayer, etc.
So what you are saying is, it could be successful if there was more money behind it, a proper team to develop it and if overall it would be a different game with bosses, multiplayer etc.
The first one definitely felt more varied and had more to it, compared to the others. Which, they DID do what they were requested, but the other 3 just looked...generic in a way? While the first had enemies with AI that would attack you, interesting level design, and the movement and gunplay had more personality to them(being able to move the gun in any direction, using recoil to jump/lift off the ground), as well as different types of guns to play with. I guess it just had more polish to it, compared to the others too.
@@Epochs33 ya,, I'd like to know how much the content creator spent for each on Fiverr. I've used the service and It can easily be from $5 to $100. Value is important to judge the results for me.
Yeah, this being the case of it being produced so quickly with great quality I’d love to have one of these video games made . I was just talking about having a video game made not too long ago .
you should pay 4 different artists to make original assets for the first game, and could even continue, 4 different musicians for music and theme, another four artist for promo art, it will make this a video series
I feel like the gun mechanics from the first game, with the gameplay and visuals from the third and the gun effects from the fourth one, combined, would make a great game.
Great video! The only thing I don't like is how the thumbnail are 3D games but no 3D game was featured in the video. Maybe something to keep in mind for the next one.
Last game was cleary made using Corgi Engine from the Unity Asset Store, that's ok, I mean I guess the first one used Corgi Engine too, the problem with the last one is that the developer used the demo assets provided by Corgi Engine not even worriyng to change at least the UI, basically he just put together some demo asset and sold the game not writing a single line of code
Same with the other games, they just used base assets and code included in the engines, you can tell that they just want to make a quick buck without much work
it would make no sense to go above and beyond when you get about 20 $ to create a game from this guy who chooses some of the cheaper devs so he does not have to spend much which the person paying for the service makes back and then some from the youtube videos while also using clickbait to get more money ,sponsored either way is a lose lose situation most the time so why go above and beyond for less then 2 hours of wages ? its a mutual financial agreement no 1s going to send him the next great thing for 20 dollars but he knows he is earning money from these videos even if the games are not good quality
You know the way these things are supposed to work is that you tell us how much they wore, and then rank them by price and your rating... Oh well, OK video.
This video failed to say if these games cost different prices. Like that first one is it 4x as expensive to have made? because it was clearly the most innovative.
Hey BadGameDev! How about hosting game jam where you ask participants to make "platformer shooter" or something similar and then making "I asked n Game Developers to make platformer shooter" video? I think that would be very interesting!!
I love how limonado created him game for 10$ in his previous video where he didn’t even credited him and now created him a masterpeice again for only 30$ lmao. Limonado if you are reading this just grab his links and put it on your fiverr to show your work for youtuber and earn what you deserve big bucks
First video that I have seen of you (sorry), but I must leave a comment of how maximum positive the community is ! Nobody trolls or is hating some of the games. All respect the art of the developers. I love that! Thanks for restoring some faith in humanity :D
Id like to see the difference in code quality and how feasible it is to build on top of the created project, or is it a spaghetti coded pile of garbage that can never be edited again without breaking half the game
Limonado is genius ... my words cant explain how perfect, creative and intertaining his games are !!! if I was a millionaire, I would give this guy a million dollar as an investement
Honestly i love this concept of videos but i think you could do more with it. This video felt a little too similar to the last one. I think its mainly because of the game concept. they honestly felt the exact same. moving and shooting. i think next time do a more different style game like melee, tower deffense, survival etc.
You really expand on the first game with level designers, musicians, graphic designers and a little bit of story/lore and a general theme to it and bam its a winner
So basically what you are saying is that if he hired a whole gamedev studio and made a different game with story and lore it would be definitely be a winner? I'd think they would need at least one programmer on the team to make it really pop out you know.
When someone says "Platform Shooter" I think of something like MegaMan. But if someone says "Platformer but with guns," I definitely get the vibes of *Cute animal with murder weapons* So Number 1 and 3 were definitely my favorite from that 😂
This video's concept is actually really interesting. But maybe spend more time giving feedback/criticism on the quality of the game you've requested? This types of video can help showcasing how useful fiverr can be. Giving "Yeah u can jump, ah yes it's decent. Can you kill enemies by jumping on them?" comments don't really help the viewers and the video itself
In the 4th game, it's surprising to me that you didn't try to use some more game mechanics which might be possible, such as pressing "down" while standing on a pipe or hitting the bricks from the bottom with your head to see if they break or even reveal something. You know, that thing looks a lot like Super Mario Bros., so why not try all the things that are possible in that game?
The fourth game is literally the Corgi Engine asset from the unity asset store with some free assets pasted in. You can tell because of the coin, the bullets and the health bar
I think first one is the best game, could be more challenging if it have limited ammo like the 3rd game, so you don't spam it like no tomorrow. And when the ammo runs out, you'll be forced to use knife
all these games just seems so easy. like something i would have bought for my ps2 back in the day that would have been super hard when i was 8 but now i just breeze through it
All the games look cool and I definitely see them being played by everyone. The first game looked really cool and cute :3 The second game looked like it had some high-res textures. The third one looked really cinematic with those effects. The last one looks like a typical flash game. Good job!
This was pretty clearly a fully sponsor-driven analysis. Mentioned nothing about actual flaws of the games, price-points, anything. Just a heavy "paid 5-star review" kinda vibe. Didn't even mention the last game's environment was half of a complete mario ripoff.
Regarding Game #1, that part where you can move up by shooting down - this gameplay element - it originally appeared in the MS-DOS game "Duke Nukem II".
Entered the video to see the difference between paying 10$ and 1,000$. Turns out it was clickbait (basically that you're a liar.) Will never enter your channel again.
Wouldn't it be extremely nice to upgrade the specs for a multiple player scroller. It would be interesting to see if they can do the game too with a theme. You know like Halloween or Christmas or even another type of holiday (let the developer decide)
The first game is easily the best. It's creative, has a nice aiming mechanic and offers multiple challenges. The others are boring and can go in the bin.
The first one was the best I mean it's fairly difficulty by the looks but it looks fun! Getting either health or weapon upgrades with different damage and fire rate or extra HP It's awesome id pop that game in
I would charge you 2000$ to make that game as good as they were. I can do it. For 25 $ I would rather just return my empty beer cans to the beer store. Lol. I Like the content!!
@@thomasdale6217 I am not but I think that would be awesome to do a great fighting game. I could do it in html5 and js even. Or you need a apple game? That is Harder to do.
The first one was a very polished game and had really unique shooter mechanics. The second game was a bit bland but seemed like it had some decent mechanics. The third one was a bit more unique, but the platforming seemed pretty bad. The character would just instantly stop when you let go of the key. The fourth one had some neat art, and looked like a great starting point for a shooter.
The first game is Wonder and so well polished. Imagine if it was released in 90s it would've wiped the market
Maybe, as it would of had to compete with either Metroid or Super Metroid... maybe some Contra too...
It would prob need a limited ammo source and regain half or all when you save a friend.
90’s???!! It looks like a simple 2008-2013 armor games game..
@@laurentspatola5374 it does in the 90s all we played was snake
reminds me of newgrounds. lots of games there
All these games seem pretty good, but the first is definitely my favourite. The second game looks nice enough, however the gameplay looks rather bland.
@@lolsofishthesecond4698 the vid has been out for about 20 mins
@@TX20 Sorry just realised my dumbness while watcching the vid. 🎂Heres a cake as sorry
@@lolsofishthesecond4698 thanks for the cake
I agree
The first game has a much more interesting mechanic than the rest.
Based on their Fiverr pages the first game appears to have cost $25, the second $35, third $5, and last one is listed at $30. I would have to say #1 was easily the best investment.
Thats a lot of work for no pay
5 dollars is for the bug helping package
Crazy that a skilled developer sells his craft for such a small prize. Even a hour worth of his time should cost more and the game wasn't made anywhere close to an hour(if he did, cudos).
$25 per hour or the total game? If it's the total amount, wow.
what 25$ for this dev is like stealing money
The first game could end up being successful with proper funding and development. I love the idea of the recoil that launches you. Imagine that they added bosses, multiplayer, etc.
multiplayer will make it like doodle army 2: mini militia
Isnt that game just Broforce but with dinos
Cave Story vibes.
So what you are saying is, it could be successful if there was more money behind it, a proper team to develop it and if overall it would be a different game with bosses, multiplayer etc.
They should add this game to cp77 you play as rebecca XD
The first one definitely felt more varied and had more to it, compared to the others. Which, they DID do what they were requested, but the other 3 just looked...generic in a way? While the first had enemies with AI that would attack you, interesting level design, and the movement and gunplay had more personality to them(being able to move the gun in any direction, using recoil to jump/lift off the ground), as well as different types of guns to play with. I guess it just had more polish to it, compared to the others too.
and 2nd and 3rd only had copied graphics
The second game was a ripoff those graphics were terrible
The third game looks like it will change into an creepypasta type of game
Shooter bunny creepypasta
Yea it's got potential
Why, did I miss something lol
The first game was a really clever reference to no time to explain, with very similar mechanics, and pretty much the same genre
No time to explain mechanics for sure
Oh yea wow you're right lol
Video idea: pay 4 develpor to work together and make a single game
this has a lot of potential. either a great game will emerge, or chaos and a hilarious video
Second this!! Would be a great vid
The developer of the first game is sick 🤯... Great game!
yeah! Awesome job
Worst to best games in that order (my opinion)
Game 4, game 2, game 3, and game 1
Game 2, game 4, game 3, game 1
What were the costs for each one? That's very important. The first one stands out a lot. The others feel very dull.
I think 3 is cool
I agree, the first one looked the most fun by far.
Costs ?
@@Epochs33 ya,, I'd like to know how much the content creator spent for each on Fiverr. I've used the service and It can easily be from $5 to $100. Value is important to judge the results for me.
Yeah, this being the case of it being produced so quickly with great quality I’d love to have one of these video games made . I was just talking about having a video game made not too long ago .
you should pay 4 different artists to make original assets for the first game, and could even continue, 4 different musicians for music and theme, another four artist for promo art, it will make this a video series
make it yourself
@@vishwarao6064 Im making my own game, I dont have the time or the money to be hiring people on fiverr and editing videos
@@dicarlostrujillo Woahh thats even better
@@dicarlostrujillo How old are you
@@vishwarao6064 29 yo
I feel like the gun mechanics from the first game, with the gameplay and visuals from the third and the gun effects from the fourth one, combined, would make a great game.
Yeah Third Underrated
Great video! The only thing I don't like is how the thumbnail are 3D games but no 3D game was featured in the video. Maybe something to keep in mind for the next one.
Total click bait
@@JoshuaCamacho09 yeah but I understand because it looks cooler
Last game was cleary made using Corgi Engine from the Unity Asset Store, that's ok, I mean I guess the first one used Corgi Engine too, the problem with the last one is that the developer used the demo assets provided by Corgi Engine not even worriyng to change at least the UI, basically he just put together some demo asset and sold the game not writing a single line of code
Same with the other games, they just used base assets and code included in the engines, you can tell that they just want to make a quick buck without much work
I mean thats what every under paid developer is going to do
Especially one that is also under skilled, and usually under paid means under skilled.
unity's particle system
The first one was made in GameMaker, not Unity.
it would make no sense to go above and beyond when you get about 20 $ to create a game from this guy who chooses some of the cheaper devs so he does not have to spend much which the person paying for the service makes back and then some from the youtube videos while also using clickbait to get more money ,sponsored either way is a lose lose situation most the time so why go above and beyond for less then 2 hours of wages ? its a mutual financial agreement no 1s going to send him the next great thing for 20 dollars but he knows he is earning money from these videos even if the games are not good quality
Okay, you missed some info there didn't you?
How much did you pay?
What does the code look like?
Same questions I'm scrolling through the comments to find out
You know the way these things are supposed to work is that you tell us how much they wore, and then rank them by price and your rating...
Oh well, OK video.
They were too embarassed about how cheap the wages were and felt like it they would come off as exploitative.
This video failed to say if these games cost different prices. Like that first one is it 4x as expensive to have made? because it was clearly the most innovative.
Limo ado is clearly very skilled in his craft. That first game looked so polished and well thought out.
Hey BadGameDev! How about hosting game jam where you ask participants to make "platformer shooter" or something similar and then making "I asked n Game Developers to make platformer shooter" video? I think that would be very interesting!!
No sane gamedev would want to participate in a game jam with the mindnumbingly generic theme of "platformer shooter".
I love how limonado created him game for 10$ in his previous video where he didn’t even credited him and now created him a masterpeice again for only 30$ lmao. Limonado if you are reading this just grab his links and put it on your fiverr to show your work for youtuber and earn what you deserve big bucks
First game really thought about the concept of combining platformers and guns. Great work.
THIS IS THE BEST VIDEO ON TH-cam YOU DESERVE WAY MORE SUBS
I love the concept of the fourth game! You're in a Mario game...but you're an alien invader killing little Marios. I'd play a polished version of it.
First video that I have seen of you (sorry), but I must leave a comment of how maximum positive the community is ! Nobody trolls or is hating some of the games. All respect the art of the developers. I love that! Thanks for restoring some faith in humanity :D
Flying with bullets was a great idea and it was fun.
Had fun being apart of this thanks
Id like to see the difference in code quality and how feasible it is to build on top of the created project, or is it a spaghetti coded pile of garbage that can never be edited again without breaking half the game
Limonado is genius ... my words cant explain how perfect, creative and intertaining his games are !!!
if I was a millionaire, I would give this guy a million dollar as an investement
Nice click bait thumbnail. At least you didn’t say you were gonna rip of a game you had someone make for next to nothing.
Longest/most interesting commercial I’ve ever watched…
Thanks?
Hey @BadGameDev I'm curious how much did you pay each of these developers?
1 was the best, so thorough. 3 looked interesting.
Honestly i love this concept of videos but i think you could do more with it. This video felt a little too similar to the last one. I think its mainly because of the game concept. they honestly felt the exact same. moving and shooting. i think next time do a more different style game like melee, tower deffense, survival etc.
You really expand on the first game with level designers, musicians, graphic designers and a little bit of story/lore and a general theme to it and bam its a winner
So basically what you are saying is that if he hired a whole gamedev studio and made a different game with story and lore it would be definitely be a winner? I'd think they would need at least one programmer on the team to make it really pop out you know.
The 1st one has great potential to be a full game.
4th game looks like it was made in gamemaker XD
literally
Bad game dev uses game maker lol
You should’ve asked Five(err) game developers😩
Lol yeh
LMAO
When someone says "Platform Shooter" I think of something like MegaMan. But if someone says "Platformer but with guns," I definitely get the vibes of *Cute animal with murder weapons*
So Number 1 and 3 were definitely my favorite from that 😂
You should do it again but with a more detailed description. It would be interesting to see how the games would implement each feature differently
Thumbnail is spot on
The first one was the best and felt more complete, the others had alot of things missing
The Dino game was the only one that truly put some love into making the game, lol. The rest was like fast food versus home cooking, right? :)
I like how the fourth game is just mario with a gun and out of place characters
The first game was the only one that looked marketable.
Limonado has his own Itchio account.
There are other shooter games made by him.
If you want, you can contribute.
tldr: the first one's the only actual game, pretty much
This video's concept is actually really interesting. But maybe spend more time giving feedback/criticism on the quality of the game you've requested? This types of video can help showcasing how useful fiverr can be. Giving "Yeah u can jump, ah yes it's decent. Can you kill enemies by jumping on them?" comments don't really help the viewers and the video itself
The first game is reminiscent of something you’d see in Scratch, but it obviously runs much smoother
1st game was the best generally.
2nd one has good animations.
3rd one has a unique vibe.
4th one has good shooting animations.
That first game deff needs a full release with lore and everything
In the 4th game, it's surprising to me that you didn't try to use some more game mechanics which might be possible, such as pressing "down" while standing on a pipe or hitting the bricks from the bottom with your head to see if they break or even reveal something. You know, that thing looks a lot like Super Mario Bros., so why not try all the things that are possible in that game?
What a cool idea for a video. That first one with a bit more polish and a unique art style could be a 20 dollar game
The first game uses the mechanic from "No Time to Explain."
Awesome! Id love a mix of the 4 ! But the first was the best
İ am proud of the 2. And 3. Developers bcs they are both Turkish like me and did pretty good work.
The fourth game is literally the Corgi Engine asset from the unity asset store with some free assets pasted in. You can tell because of the coin, the bullets and the health bar
The gun mechanics and sort of a storyline in 1st game makes all the other games look faded
I think first one is the best game, could be more challenging if it have limited ammo like the 3rd game, so you don't spam it like no tomorrow. And when the ammo runs out, you'll be forced to use knife
I'd pay money to buy the first one, great job
I doubt it.
In my opinion the firt one was the best, the creator had more creativity than the others
Yo, the first game is SICC.
Yes I’ve been waiting for this.
Yess, he tagged and referenced the Fiverr sellers this time
the third game got nice visuals. some horror story and better mechanics it would make a nice game
Nice man you are really helping fiverr gameDev community
That first one can be released right now for $3 and people would buy it if it had more levels.
all these games just seems so easy. like something i would have bought for my ps2 back in the day that would have been super hard when i was 8 but now i just breeze through it
the second one is just most basic phaser game ever made ("engine" for making games), looks like scam tho
Graphics of the 3rd game were my favourite, but the mechanics of the 1st game take it for sure. Wish you showed price of each person.
i love the particles in the fourth game
First game was made by someone who understood developing games.
The others basically just did what you asked with absolutely no thought.
All the games look cool and I definitely see them being played by everyone. The first game looked really cool and cute :3 The second game looked like it had some high-res textures. The third one looked really cinematic with those effects. The last one looks like a typical flash game. Good job!
love these fiverr videos ngl
First one seems like a flash game I would've played about 10 years ago
The second game is kinda like Mario but with a gun. The fourth game is more of just a Mario theme than a Mario style game.
This was pretty clearly a fully sponsor-driven analysis. Mentioned nothing about actual flaws of the games, price-points, anything. Just a heavy "paid 5-star review" kinda vibe. Didn't even mention the last game's environment was half of a complete mario ripoff.
Did you notice the clickbait thumbnail?
Watching this kind of games made me miss the old J2ME games
Regarding Game #1, that part where you can move up by shooting down - this gameplay element - it originally appeared in the MS-DOS game "Duke Nukem II".
You need the flame weapon to do it, though.
Anyone want to talk about the thumbnail?
I know right, it's another one of those fucking clickbait videos.
Instant dislike
To me the first game seemed like it would be the most fun.
Thumbnail was misleading by showing 3D games. Then I realize this is a ad for a freelance game dev website. First game looked pretty cool though.
that third game looks sick
Take a shot everytime he's says "game". You'll be smashed by the end of it 😂
First game looked really good fun, I love the idea of recoil as propulsion
yeah, that was an interesting game mechanic if you ask me.
Wait so these people on fivverr just designed the games from scratch with your idea??? Holy crap I got to try this
Entered the video to see the difference between paying 10$ and 1,000$. Turns out it was clickbait (basically that you're a liar.) Will never enter your channel again.
the first one was perfect, it needs a phone version, and it can be a big game
Sadly the dev of the first game now has his service on hold apparently.
Another interesting video in this series
Wouldn't it be extremely nice to upgrade the specs for a multiple player scroller. It would be interesting to see if they can do the game too with a theme. You know like Halloween or Christmas or even another type of holiday (let the developer decide)
The first one was made by a Brazilian, what a pride.
Other comments:talking about stuff
Me:yo is the 4th game have pollished smb1 sprites
Some of the sprites for the 3rd game were from a game on math playground named ninja frog
The first game is easily the best. It's creative, has a nice aiming mechanic and offers multiple challenges. The others are boring and can go in the bin.
The first one was the best I mean it's fairly difficulty by the looks but it looks fun! Getting either health or weapon upgrades with different damage and fire rate or extra HP
It's awesome id pop that game in
I didn't know game dev in fiverr is this much easy. I will start working on fiverr soon
I would charge you 2000$ to make that game as good as they were. I can do it.
For 25 $ I would rather just return my empty beer cans to the beer store. Lol. I Like the content!!
Are you on fiverr? I would pay twice that but for a v good two person, platform fight Tekken style.
@@thomasdale6217 I am not but I think that would be awesome to do a great fighting game. I could do it in html5 and js even. Or you need a apple game? That is Harder to do.
@@firewoodlake
I really needed it making on Unity. Owing to their powerful graphics and superior gaming experience.
Dev be like: you only had 2 requirements
The first one was a very polished game and had really unique shooter mechanics.
The second game was a bit bland but seemed like it had some decent mechanics.
The third one was a bit more unique, but the platforming seemed pretty bad. The character would just instantly stop when you let go of the key.
The fourth one had some neat art, and looked like a great starting point for a shooter.