The last one was definitely better than something I'd see on those Minecraft clone websites that claim to be Minecraft. Also applies to 70% of the remakes on Google Play.
I really really like the first game. The animations look incredibly smooth and the fact that the water is "smart" as well as the sand makes it even more cool! Shoutout to the developer!
The last one isn't really from the developer on fiver, though. He just took an existing game from Alec Shedelbower, who should be credited for this game.
@@erlbertjune4229 They Are Not Getting Paid as They Should Be. In His Other Video titled "I Paid Game Developers on Fiverr to Make the Same Game " He Paid Only 10 Dollars for an Awesome Game but Did not Give him Credit For His Work
Just came from a previous episode of this... I really appreciate how you seem to have taken feedback from the comments into consideration. It's such a little thing, but so few TH-camrs actually integrate the little bits of feedback into their content (in your case, giving credit to the developers)
The world generation was great, and the world generation was fantastic, not to mention how good the world generation was. Very impressed by the world generation, as well as the world generation.
Yeah, the world generation was really good. I think that the world generation was really good, especially considering the really good world generation. My favorite part was probably the world generation, which was easily better than everything but the world generation.
You're not wrong but frankly I'm more impressed by the world generation. While the world generation was as impressive as you claim, the work behind the world generation is just crazy.
Fact: ¾ of the people underestimate the work behind the third game. Also, I don't understand why people complain about how much the second dev was paid: he agreed the price and did what he thought was "fair", what's the problem?
1st game reminded me of a game called Blockheads that I used to play back then when I didn’t have Minecraft. It was a really fun game and well planned out game. Definitely recommend it
I remember that game! My friend showed me it when I asked for free alternatives to Minecraft! I freaking loved it, but when I actually got Minecraft, I deleted it.
@@stusigrest typical AI bro you use excuses to smoke screen a larger problems that will have severe consequences besides never be a company shill cause they dont give social credit score
9:28 no you didn’t fucking assume that, there is no way in hell you saw an enderman head and went “oh yeah of course i can right click and teleport with this”
Do more videos on 5r just give them rough directions to make the same game pick the best one then keep hiring each of them to improve the game I feel like that’d get alot of views
@@blueboi5808 he commissioned 3 games at very insulting prices, and then did not even credit the game makers not including their names. So they worked for next to nothing and got no publicity
@@Enderia2 You can make a minecraft clone without using any of mojang's code or assets. They also specifically mention in their EULA to not distribute anything they've made.
@@uBiuui id hope that the 3rd game isnt a issue. It is not nearly as fleshed out as minecraft and is not a negative to minecraft in anyway. There would be no reason for them to pursue for it.
That last one looks like it has enough time into it that he maybe just sold you one that he did on his own time as an experiment / learning experience.
Heya! I was the one to develop the first game, and yeah, it's pretty much it! The entire world generation was made around the wave created because I wanted to mess around with a feature in GameMaker called "animation curves", and it looked like the perfect opportunity (I admit it's not the best method tho)
The first game could literally end up being a hit if you keep working on it. Like adding mini ppl who are artificially smart that can build, explore and make things. They’re purpose is to basically evolve and as they build they learn with mini ppl having different traits and creating new occupations and the world slowly evolves and becomes more and more mordern. The mini ppl have thoughts of their one and basically free will so they’ll do things like steal, murder or help, and do good deeds. Just my take on it, I really think it has the potential to turn into a great game. I have many ideas so hit me up if you ever plan on expanding in the game🙄
I wasn't as interested about first two games (especially the second one), but the third game just blow my mind. It literally had EVERYTHING to be a successful Minecraft clone. Really good job
@@faseplay. I don't know. i feel like he just loaded up minecraft and checked for every single detail within the program and copied it.. just my opinion. even the assets look exactly the same. making something a game "like" minecraft doesn't mean to make a duplicate of it, but nevermind me that's just what i thought..
This one is actually dumb idea, there are tons of minecraft clone tutorials out there. Every aspiring game dev out there tried or have built his clone of minecraft. I bet the 3rd one was straight up cloned from some github repo.
@@hackandcode3474 It's not that hard when you know how to do it... and he sayed that it took 2 weeks to get all the game. The third one is litteraly doable in 3 or 4 days or even less. Minecraft have soooo much more feature than that tird game.
Clearly none of them actually remade minecraft. How much did you pay them? Was it just like “do you best in this timeline?” They were all interesting starts but i wouldn’t call any of them complete.
He even stated that they weren't complete, but could be good starters for an actual project. He didn't say they had to be fully complete games.
2 ปีที่แล้ว +5
Hello! I was the one developer to make Totally Not Minecraft It was a "do your best in this timeline". We had around a week or so to make the games, and he specified that the concept of remaking Minecraft was subjective and we could just use our imagination to do something close to it, with a twist if we wanted to
He didn’t get scammed he got what he paid for lol no one’s gonna spend a shit ton of their time making a fully fledged tons of features game for like 100 bucks, they’re adults and pay bills.
Don't know how I stopmed onto this. All in all Damn good video 🙌🙌. I also have been watching those rather similar from mStarTutorials and kinda wonder how you guys make these stuff. MStar Tutorials also had amazing information about similiar things on his channel.
Except you don't do that much progress so fast and for this cheap, not without downloading the project and changing some textures, one of the reasons I'm never going to make an open source game, people will steal it and sell it as their own.
I have two ideas to turn Minecraft into an 8-bit game and a clicker game where you have to click objects to get your little guys to do stuff and click stuff to make money to get more guys to get more materials
Pay game developers on Fiverr to remaster old games. Since it's my idea I guess you could go with one of the games I would like to see remastered Evil Dead: A Fistful of Boomstick.
the third one was really just like Minecraft, they should've have added trees to break, a simple crafting system and inventory. But every game was good and they tried their best.
Video idea: make a game on scratch
This would hurt like a bitch
no
Yes pls
I have tried scratch and it aint that bad imo
Yes
The last one was definitely better than something I'd see on those Minecraft clone websites that claim to be Minecraft. Also applies to 70% of the remakes on Google Play.
Jesus Christ died for your sins please repent for the kingdom of heaven is at hand 2356777775554433223455634663
It's a unity asset and literally is the demo that comes with it
@@dawsonpate7385disrespecting developers, unacceptable
I really really like the first game. The animations look incredibly smooth and the fact that the water is "smart" as well as the sand makes it even more cool! Shoutout to the developer!
Water and sand falling gave me Tetris feels
I thought the same. The first looks so smooth and honestly, fun to play.
I don't like it because it's 2d and Minecraft is 3d. It doesnt at all simulate Minecraft. Only the last one actually gets the job done
those are all games that could build upon themselves quite nicely, hell the last one might as well be a Minecraft alpha 2.0. good stuff!
@Horshu fa sho
The last one isn't really from the developer on fiver, though. He just took an existing game from Alec Shedelbower, who should be credited for this game.
Its kinda like terarria stardew valley and minecraft clones
@Horshu your mother
th-cam.com/video/BzeUNhWKtIE/w-d-xo.html
I was blown away by the impressive work all the devs went through to make their game!
yeah,iam too
same
th-cam.com/video/BzeUNhWKtIE/w-d-xo.html
I am Happy That You are Giving Credit to Game Developer
Me not 🤬🤬😡😡
@@h.z72 why
unlike the last video
why u guys talking about giving credits to game developer :/
they get paid tho:/
@@erlbertjune4229 They Are Not Getting Paid as They Should Be.
In His Other Video titled "I Paid Game Developers on Fiverr to Make the Same Game
" He Paid Only 10 Dollars for an Awesome Game but Did not Give him Credit For His Work
Little did we know that he is all of the game developers in this video and he paid himself so he doesn't lose any money
@LythNotHere he was..
@LythNotHere 4 reply
How dare you it's now 6
7
11 HA I BEAT YOU
I like how they all used different game engines
edit: wow
180 likes and 0 comments just wow
@@techkiller24 1 comments
3 comments
5 comments
6 comments
Just came from a previous episode of this... I really appreciate how you seem to have taken feedback from the comments into consideration. It's such a little thing, but so few TH-camrs actually integrate the little bits of feedback into their content (in your case, giving credit to the developers)
Minecraft clone looks like classic minecraft if you could use shaders on it
th-cam.com/video/BzeUNhWKtIE/w-d-xo.html
In my opinion the 1st game could be a real game called "Building Sandbox"
It is a real mobile game and it's called The Blockheads.
th-cam.com/video/BzeUNhWKtIE/w-d-xo.html
@@johnnyp.5816 Blockheads was taken off market when a hack was exploited. Wish I could find it.
Minecraft 2D actually looks like a really mellow game
Terraria
th-cam.com/video/BzeUNhWKtIE/w-d-xo.html
Jesus Christ died for your sins please repent for the kingdom of heaven is at hand 2356777775554433223455634663
Try Minicraft! It was made by Notch!
The world generation was great, and the world generation was fantastic, not to mention how good the world generation was. Very impressed by the world generation, as well as the world generation.
Yeah, the world generation was really good. I think that the world generation was really good, especially considering the really good world generation. My favorite part was probably the world generation, which was easily better than everything but the world generation.
Ok but why is no one talking about how good the world generation was
You're not wrong but frankly I'm more impressed by the world generation. While the world generation was as impressive as you claim, the work behind the world generation is just crazy.
The constant spew of him saying "I assume [random feature] does [exactly what it does]". He's so good at assuming!
Fact: ¾ of the people underestimate the work behind the third game.
Also, I don't understand why people complain about how much the second dev was paid: he agreed the price and did what he thought was "fair", what's the problem?
doesn't mean it really is fair
@@saiyanfang1047
what is fair in this case?
@@diadetediotedio6918 assuming it took a day to make $320 at least
@@saiyanfang1047
why $320?
@@diadetediotedio6918 $40 for fair pay per hour for game developers for 8 hours
8:48 he did not do it entirely by himself. I think he got the old version of minecraft, remade it, and said "I cODeD iT bY MySElF!!!11!1!!1!"
1st game reminded me of a game called Blockheads that I used to play back then when I didn’t have Minecraft. It was a really fun game and well planned out game. Definitely recommend it
I remember that game! My friend showed me it when I asked for free alternatives to Minecraft! I freaking loved it, but when I actually got Minecraft, I deleted it.
oh man,that was way back 2015,i wonder how my friends theres doing now.
th-cam.com/video/BzeUNhWKtIE/w-d-xo.html
I remember that too. Good times
I thought the same thing!
instructions unclear accidentally made terraria
7:31 isn't this one of the Minetest demos? The open source minecraft clone-like voxel engine?
I would love to see the second one fleshed out
Yeah I see a lot of potential, maybe add animals and stuff and this could be the biggest game in the world
You guys are not going to believe what I just found
@@rickytickybobbywobbin055 what, a way to scam us?
It's more or less Stardew Valley,
Play don't starve then
BadGameDev "Make Minecraft"
Fiverr "Makes Terraria"
1. Terraria Clone
2. Don't Starve Clone
3. Minecraft Clone
Good work! It would be nice if you put how much it costs for each Fiveer Project!
th-cam.com/video/BzeUNhWKtIE/w-d-xo.html
Last time it was $10, and ppl got mad. It makes sense why he didn't show them this time around, lol.
@@rosslewerenz9360 why were they mad
Fiverr is a sad platform where desperate creators will slave for rock bottom prices
true af
@@stusigrest typical AI bro
you use excuses to smoke screen a larger problems that will have severe consequences
besides never be a company shill cause they dont give social credit score
Love the fiverr vids man. Keep em coming xD
Same
th-cam.com/video/BzeUNhWKtIE/w-d-xo.html
Make more of this I'm a big fan
9:28 no you didn’t fucking assume that, there is no way in hell you saw an enderman head and went “oh yeah of course i can right click and teleport with this”
Bro why are you so mad
@@eventrxgaming6486 im not
Do more videos on 5r just give them rough directions to make the same game pick the best one then keep hiring each of them to improve the game I feel like that’d get alot of views
th-cam.com/video/BzeUNhWKtIE/w-d-xo.html
The second game used the Godot game engine just looking at the button was enough to tell for a regular Godot user like me
th-cam.com/video/BzeUNhWKtIE/w-d-xo.html
Realy you are mad
Sorry
Jesus Christ died for your sins please repent for the kingdom of heaven is at hand 2356777775554433223455634663
The quick brown fox jumped over the lazy dogs
the last one literally just looks like modded mine-craft lol
Seems like the last developer forgot to add trees
it's cool how you added credits not like the other gun runner video.
Third person definitely knew what Minecraft was
Its look like old minecraft🪑
It looks like old Minecraft*
@@VaMaHD74 No one asked*
th-cam.com/video/BzeUNhWKtIE/w-d-xo.html
@@amburger1984 noone cared about who asked*
no one will admire the shadows in "minecraft clone"...
Game 1: terraria
Game 2 : terraria
Game 3 : Minecraft in 2010 with shaders
😂😂
th-cam.com/video/BzeUNhWKtIE/w-d-xo.html
That third one seems like casual copyright violation
1st game is really sick, could be rlly cool and creative with all minecraft blocks
th-cam.com/video/BzeUNhWKtIE/w-d-xo.html
Damn you got scared about the backlash of what you did previously. Good, hope you learnt your lesson.
What did he do?
@@blueboi5808 he commissioned 3 games at very insulting prices, and then did not even credit the game makers not including their names. So they worked for next to nothing and got no publicity
Next up do a more obscure game.
The last one probably got banned from Fiverr since their link is a 404 home page.
i like the second one, but i think it would be better if the pixel resolution would be more consistent
th-cam.com/video/BzeUNhWKtIE/w-d-xo.html
Ah yes I payed a game developer for 30 dollars to make a minecraft game Andy he just sent me original minecraft
I wouldn't distribute the third game if I were you. Mojang might send you a DMCA since it contains actual minecraft assets.
Ye.
Mojang literally gives you a guide on how to make minecraft. THEY WERE ASKING FOR IT.
@@Enderia2 You can make a minecraft clone without using any of mojang's code or assets. They also specifically mention in their EULA to not distribute anything they've made.
@@uBiuui id hope that the 3rd game isnt a issue. It is not nearly as fleshed out as minecraft and is not a negative to minecraft in anyway. There would be no reason for them to pursue for it.
th-cam.com/video/BzeUNhWKtIE/w-d-xo.html
That last one looks like it has enough time into it that he maybe just sold you one that he did on his own time as an experiment / learning experience.
The last one was a free template, he got scammed -_-
Am I the only one here that really wants to play the first 2 games?
Yeah
The second didnt had anything of minecraft
glad badgamedev is uploading more
Minecraft 2D Really Reminded me of this old Xbox 360 game with SM64 Graphics that i think it was called world of kelfing and kingdom of kelfings
Watch someone give him Muck, or a crappy recreation of it lmao
th-cam.com/video/BzeUNhWKtIE/w-d-xo.html
Amazing dude best video watched in the last month
i like how the last one is quite clearly just straight up copy and pasted from some early alpha minecraft
this video will go super viral o betcha
The first game's world generation was pretty cool but i figured they just input a lot of instructions after creating a sine wave
th-cam.com/video/BzeUNhWKtIE/w-d-xo.html
Heya! I was the one to develop the first game, and yeah, it's pretty much it!
The entire world generation was made around the wave created because I wanted to mess around with a feature in GameMaker called "animation curves", and it looked like the perfect opportunity (I admit it's not the best method tho)
@ Great game bro!👌👌
@@twintrouble8421 Thanks!
Third person did pretty good. Like that legit look's like Minecraft. Exactly like it.
The first game could literally end up being a hit if you keep working on it. Like adding mini ppl who are artificially smart that can build, explore and make things. They’re purpose is to basically evolve and as they build they learn with mini ppl having different traits and creating new occupations and the world slowly evolves and becomes more and more mordern. The mini ppl have thoughts of their one and basically free will so they’ll do things like steal, murder or help, and do good deeds. Just my take on it, I really think it has the potential to turn into a great game. I have many ideas so hit me up if you ever plan on expanding in the game🙄
That last guy properly already had his Minecraft clone made, so he just shipped it and took the money :D
th-cam.com/video/BzeUNhWKtIE/w-d-xo.html
I wasn't as interested about first two games (especially the second one), but the third game just blow my mind. It literally had EVERYTHING to be a successful Minecraft clone. Really good job
well it was just a big copy paste after all, nothing original compared to the other two
@@cedricantunes4600 but it was the idea, wasn't it?
@@faseplay. I don't know.
i feel like he just loaded up minecraft and checked for every single detail within the program and copied it.. just my opinion. even the assets look exactly the same.
making something a game "like" minecraft doesn't mean to make a duplicate of it, but nevermind me that's just what i thought..
Copyright be like: *"Oh HELL NAHHH"*
This one is actually dumb idea, there are tons of minecraft clone tutorials out there. Every aspiring game dev out there tried or have built his clone of minecraft. I bet the 3rd one was straight up cloned from some github repo.
probs is, the guy made the entire minecraft all by him self and it took an entire team to make the game
@@hackandcode3474 It's not that hard when you know how to do it... and he sayed that it took 2 weeks to get all the game. The third one is litteraly doable in 3 or 4 days or even less. Minecraft have soooo much more feature than that tird game.
@@Akinata405 Oh iv never really played minecraft I might look into game development!
@@hackandcode3474 Also, Mojang and Notch (previously) used Java with OpenGL instead of a game engine like Unity which would make things much easier.
th-cam.com/video/BzeUNhWKtIE/w-d-xo.html
Loved the improvement..
I feel like I've seen this video 20x before
imagine someone casually telly bridging on the mc clone
so you got
- terraria
- minicraft
- stolen unity mc clone
No
No
the second one was made in godot, i recognise the default button node theme anywhere haha
Video starts at 1:50
Ty bro!
Hi I love your videos keep up the good work
Clearly none of them actually remade minecraft. How much did you pay them? Was it just like “do you best in this timeline?” They were all interesting starts but i wouldn’t call any of them complete.
He even stated that they weren't complete, but could be good starters for an actual project. He didn't say they had to be fully complete games.
Hello! I was the one developer to make Totally Not Minecraft
It was a "do your best in this timeline". We had around a week or so to make the games, and he specified that the concept of remaking Minecraft was subjective and we could just use our imagination to do something close to it, with a twist if we wanted to
Glad I found this channel!
U literally got scammed
Third ones dope though
And he is not paying himself anyway...it is sponsored
🤲😊
You realize that games production take a whole lot of money
He didn’t get scammed he got what he paid for lol no one’s gonna spend a shit ton of their time making a fully fledged tons of features game for like 100 bucks, they’re adults and pay bills.
Minecraft Clone literally has better built-in graphics that the original XD
5:18i letarally figured out how the Gen system works just by looking this should be the basic of how to do a world gen
ay, shut
@@darkmattercouch6754 nah, u
Well, I had 1 day to make the world generation, so...
Tbh it was really fun making the world generation, it's really interesting how much you can do with such a simple concept like a curve
@ great work👍 and yeah its really interesting
My maths is too bad for me to be a game developer
5:00 amei o nome do cara kkkk, o grão do pão
Valeu kkkkkkkkk
Bro keep bringing up his own game
Don't know how I stopmed onto this. All in all Damn good video 🙌🙌. I also have been watching those rather similar from mStarTutorials and kinda wonder how you guys make these stuff. MStar Tutorials also had amazing information about similiar things on his channel.
th-cam.com/video/BzeUNhWKtIE/w-d-xo.html
Totally not Minecraft was my favorite. Gives me adobe flash game vibes
Dude should have credit them😐
Finally He did it next time dont forgot it👍
Except you don't do that much progress so fast and for this cheap, not without downloading the project and changing some textures, one of the reasons I'm never going to make an open source game, people will steal it and sell it as their own.
pretty sure last one copied from the original source of minecraft and enchanted it
You should do a Fortnite one haha
💀
Plot twist: this is just a sponsorship
The second game, Minecraft 2D, is pretty a game called Minicraft which was also made by Notch in 48 hours.
I have two ideas to turn Minecraft into an 8-bit game and a clicker game where you have to click objects to get your little guys to do stuff and click stuff to make money to get more guys to get more materials
I was so happy when I heard madmaker7s voice, i always wondered where you went
the last one probably is the version of open-source minecraft
im on fiverr too, but I make music, if you ever need some gaming music, DM!
left side of thumbnail has an iron pickaxe from Roblox Bedwars 💀
The last is literally better than real minecraft dev 1.0 or whatever
Good channel playa keep at it...
Nice vid!
this entire video is a fiverr ad. great.
Don't forget, he plugged his patreon too!
Plot twist you paid Notch to make Minecraft clone
Bro the first one reminded me of sitting in the tech lab at school playing paper minecraft😔i miss those days
Pay game developers on Fiverr to remaster old games. Since it's my idea I guess you could go with one of the games I would like to see remastered Evil Dead: A Fistful of Boomstick.
They can't remaster games without the original source code, it would be exactly the same as this video, they'd have to make it from scratch
The second game could really be built upon as a fun top down pixel survival game in multiplayer
Go play minicraft, basically minecraft 2d is a minicraft clone, which is another game made by notch
@@cocobruh what is it called?
@@gfuelsoccermom5307 minicraft, it has ports on varipus consoles, and is playable online
this just shows that people that are dedicated can literally make minecraft
They are acually interasting
to be fair, i really want to play the third minecraft as a replacement to the real minecraft
the third one was really just like Minecraft, they should've have added trees to break, a simple crafting system and inventory. But every game was good and they tried their best.