From the moment that the Shi'a DISMISSED to recognize the (Rashidun) 3 other rightly-guided caliph of Islam, I doubted the sincerity of their faith that is clearly tainted with hatred and jealous to the other companions (Sahaba) . I do not know whether during the reign of Caliph Ali (RA) criticized any of his companions the (asara mobaseren). But the Shi;a did criticize them including the wife of prophet Aisha (ra).
The first three caliphs were not chosen by Allah through Rasulallah but Imam Ali was, so why on earth should the Shia, the followers of Rasulallah through Imam Ali, accept the integrity of the first three?
@@Faz110786in Quran its written that Prophet Muhammad (saw) is the last Prophet (Quran 33:40) Now bring 1 ayat claiming what you're saying here (which you would never find) To save your time, whatever happens, is because of Allah's will, eventually it was Allah's will that Abu Bakr Siddique (RA) becomes the first Caliph and be did become the first Caliph... It was Allah's will that Ali RA works under him and he did so did for the other two By not accepting this, you're only proving that you're not accepting that Allah is the supreme authority and this will only prove that you're doing shirk which is the biggest sin So kindly don't involve in shirk and accept what Allah willed ❤️ And no doubt Allah is the best planner ❤️
@@zawwaryawarso by this logic it was Allah's will that Hitler massacred all the Jews and that IDF massacre Palestinians. This is very bad logic. Allah ta'ala has given human beings choice and volition to do right and wrong, and it is the human being's fault if they choose wrong like what Abu Bakr and Umar did for example. Also, no Shia denies that the Nabi (peace be upon him and his progeny) is the final Messenger and Prophet. So I'm not sure why you brought that up.
@@zawwaryawar Ignorance is a disease. Your logic fails; if it is Allahs will that Abu Bakr becomes the first Khalifah, and this you’re saying is good, then it was also Allah’s will that Firawn ruled over Prophet Musa, that the tyrant of Prophet Yahya murdered him and that Yazid the son of Muawiya slaughters Hussain Ibn Ali in Karbala. Now, was that all good and the way things should’ve been? You couldn’t answer this without retracting your statements.
I have read the history of the prophet Muhammad pubf multiple time and read he’s name mention in the Quran but nowhere have I ever seen or heard ever the prophet insulting he’s enemy and also the prophet never retaliated against he’s enemy until he was attacks. And none of the imam of the Ahlul bayt ever insulted and demeaned anyone as you are doing. I’m a shia Muslim but I don’t imam ali ever comparing himself with anyone else or even if someone says they are better than Ali I don’t see him making that as an issue like you are doing. You are a fitna brother causing sectiism among the children of adam
Wtffff go read what our prophet saw when people compare imam Ali as to these RAN AWAY, harami, and that gay forget about saying these harami gays shit are better than imam Ali as shame on you for not standing up for your religion shameless
He is providing sources. Was it wrong of Amir Ul Momineen to call out fabricators on their false attributions? Imam may not make a big deal if attacks were personal. But when a hadith is attributed to him, he would. Because his followers will believe that fake hadith and be misguided. Imagine someone in prophet's time attributing false saying to him? Would prophet have stayed quiet?
@awakenedsight; So tell me for the past 1,400 they killed prophet Muhammad saw disrespect prophet killed each one of the Ahlul bayt since that time these 🫏 start killing of the shia Muslim to this day 2024. What he did was reading and proving from their own books do not comment here since such a shitty bs word again. Imam Ali doesn’t need fake people like you.
![Imam Ibn Taymiyyah [RA]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eH8dW-LSoYA/mqdefault.jpg)
Спасибо!
Thank you Sheikh, for giving us helpful knowledge through these shows that empower Shia to educate others in English.
My pleasure
Allah bless you
Hassan Allahyari Sahab is a precious gem of this era ⚠️💎
Super Umar got bullied so badly poor guy deleted his channel.
English farsi arabic, incredible
May Allah SWT give you more courage and strength to face these no good Umaris
If he said that, i would not be surprised,
From the moment that the Shi'a DISMISSED to recognize the (Rashidun) 3 other rightly-guided caliph of Islam, I doubted the sincerity of their faith that is clearly tainted with hatred and jealous to the other companions (Sahaba) . I do not know whether during the reign of Caliph Ali (RA) criticized any of his companions the (asara mobaseren). But the Shi;a did criticize them including the wife of prophet Aisha (ra).
The first three caliphs were not chosen by Allah through Rasulallah but Imam Ali was, so why on earth should the Shia, the followers of Rasulallah through Imam Ali, accept the integrity of the first three?
@@Faz110786in Quran its written that Prophet Muhammad (saw) is the last Prophet (Quran 33:40)
Now bring 1 ayat claiming what you're saying here (which you would never find)
To save your time, whatever happens, is because of Allah's will, eventually it was Allah's will that Abu Bakr Siddique (RA) becomes the first Caliph and be did become the first Caliph... It was Allah's will that Ali RA works under him and he did so did for the other two
By not accepting this, you're only proving that you're not accepting that Allah is the supreme authority and this will only prove that you're doing shirk which is the biggest sin
So kindly don't involve in shirk and accept what Allah willed ❤️
And no doubt Allah is the best planner ❤️
@@zawwaryawarso by this logic it was Allah's will that Hitler massacred all the Jews and that IDF massacre Palestinians. This is very bad logic. Allah ta'ala has given human beings choice and volition to do right and wrong, and it is the human being's fault if they choose wrong like what Abu Bakr and Umar did for example.
Also, no Shia denies that the Nabi (peace be upon him and his progeny) is the final Messenger and Prophet. So I'm not sure why you brought that up.
@@zawwaryawar Ignorance is a disease. Your logic fails; if it is Allahs will that Abu Bakr becomes the first Khalifah, and this you’re saying is good, then it was also Allah’s will that Firawn ruled over Prophet Musa, that the tyrant of Prophet Yahya murdered him and that Yazid the son of Muawiya slaughters Hussain Ibn Ali in Karbala. Now, was that all good and the way things should’ve been? You couldn’t answer this without retracting your statements.
🎉🎉
I have read the history of the prophet Muhammad pubf multiple time and read he’s name mention in the Quran but nowhere have I ever seen or heard ever the prophet insulting he’s enemy and also the prophet never retaliated against he’s enemy until he was attacks.
And none of the imam of the Ahlul bayt ever insulted and demeaned anyone as you are doing.
I’m a shia Muslim but I don’t imam ali ever comparing himself with anyone else or even if someone says they are better than Ali I don’t see him making that as an issue like you are doing.
You are a fitna brother causing sectiism among the children of adam
Wtffff go read what our prophet saw when people compare imam Ali as to these RAN AWAY, harami, and that gay forget about saying these harami gays shit are better than imam Ali as shame on you for not standing up for your religion shameless
He is providing sources. Was it wrong of Amir Ul Momineen to call out fabricators on their false attributions? Imam may not make a big deal if attacks were personal. But when a hadith is attributed to him, he would. Because his followers will believe that fake hadith and be misguided. Imagine someone in prophet's time attributing false saying to him? Would prophet have stayed quiet?
@awakenedsight; So tell me for the past 1,400 they killed prophet Muhammad saw disrespect prophet killed each one of the Ahlul bayt since that time these 🫏 start killing of the shia Muslim to this day 2024. What he did was reading and proving from their own books do not comment here since such a shitty bs word again. Imam Ali doesn’t need fake people like you.
@@MehmoodAli-uj9fgwhat sources brother ? ... The only not fabricated source is Quran... Either bring it from Quran or accept reality