- The vocal ranking is hugely based on Vocal Support and then Technique, Consistency, pitch, etc were taken into consideration. - From Heejin and Up are the idols who have support even if it's shallow or inconsistent it's better than having none. Except for Minnie who is ranked higher than idols like Sihyeon, Mia, Yuqi (These two have support and are the strongest in their groups) I didn't want to deal with Forevers and Neverlands, I already put on my big-boy pants and placed Sieun lower (WAY lower) - If I made an error in the Vocal Ranking you are free to correct me RESPECTFULLY. - Other than that,,,,, The Dance and rap ranking is Totally based on my Opinion. P.s. Wendy will be in the B+ tier, I did some research most people said there is no vocalist in the A tier, Which I kinda agree with now. Forgot this --> 🙉
@@pyaytsone9717 not really, there's only so much autotune can do, for studio vocals to sound great the raw material the producers are working with need's to be good as well. I don't get the misconception that autotune is this magical gift from Jesus that can make anyone sound great.
Notice how Ningning is one of the youngest ( 19) on this list and she’s literally ranked 2nd out of 60 peopel. Girly just debuted a year ago. And she’s already getting this high? Yeah Ningning truly is 4th gens best vocalist. I would definitely giver her an b+/A- she’s been showing improvements and her live singing when on variety shows is so beautiful. She’s so stable and versatile. I dread no one is beating her.
Ning Ning is a good vocalist (+ I love her voice) but you should listen to Yechan (Pink Fantasy) and Nayul (12dal) sing. They have the best technique in 4th gen. Ning Ning is the best mainstream 4th gen vocalist tho. (Monday is very good too but usually more inconsistent.)
She should be, she's from SM. Taeyeon and wendy are both already the best in their generation even at their debut (taeyeon was above average at her debut (higher level than current ningning) and she was only 18 back then, was the best until hyorin came out; while wendy was already a proficient vocalist at her debut (20 at that time), definitely destined to be the best female vocalist of 3rd gen). Ningning is the weakest among all SM main vocalist at their debut (being average to above average at debut and still is up till now), she's doing good but she needs to exercise more to catch up to her senior's level.
Wow, this proof aespa have a great vocalist! Even karina and giselle who is a rapper and sub vocalist, have a high rank. Also this proof karina is an ACE
Some people didnt know that karina has a good vocals even though she is a main dancer.. SM please let Karina show her amazing vocal more often 😭 (sorry i cant speak english well)
@@eubiasedforeverglow i mean, i said karina has good vocal not based on karina is my bias. I have bad english. So sorry if u misunderstanding what i mean
The problem is that we've yet to hear live vocals from aespa, I'm sure they're all amazing singers but everyone is saying they're better vocalists that all other groups but why don't they ever perform live?
A lot of people in the comments are doubting Karina's vocals when she IS one of the best vocalists in the 4th generation of Kpop. Simple, go listen to Savage and Dreams Come True, she have a really healthy and beautiful vibrato, her A4 notes are developed. "But she above main vocalists and lead vocalists" yes she is because her vocals are good. By the way I desagree Tzuyu's vocal ranking, actually she deserve way better, I think she's better than Yeri, Tzuyu is actually the 6th best vocalist in Twice. Mina and Chaeyoung are so low in vocals, they can support, shallow but they have some sense of support. Also I don't think that Jeongyeon is the worst dancer like I've no idea about dancing but some professional dancers said that she's not bad as people makes her be. Other than that the rest of the ranking is debatable because the sub vocals are all underdeveloped and don't have materials to be analysed, so I agree with you, only Tzuyu, Mina and Chaeyoung positions that I desagree. Yes, Stayc members are not that good in singing, people need to understand that. Everyone can do high notes but we need to analyse if the high notes are healthy or have proper technique, this is more important. Also, sorry for my English, I'm still learning ok? Good video, you're so hardworking
I think Chaeyoung should go a lot higher in rap since she is actually the 2nd fastest female kpop rapper right now. If you watch her Sixteen performances she is AMAZING.
@@indescribableconfusion7017 yes true and that’s why I’m not necessarily saying she should be 2nd on the list, but I do think she should be higher anyway because her flow is amazing too
*Jeongyeon* got 6th place out of 70 Members, also she treated like a sub Vocalist 😩😩 She deserves every good thing in this World!!! #GetwellsoonJEONGYEON 💚✨ #LastChorusQueen 💚✨ And being a Jeongyeon Stan it's painful!!!
Sadly we can’t hear E:U full potential despite she ranked #4 because their company won’t give her more rap lines and ending up eaten by Mia (no hate to mia btw, just their company)
I just realized that if hypothetically, Karina was in StayC or Ive, and there were positions, Karina would be a main dancer, main vocalist and main rapper in both groups since she is the best in all 3 categories in both groups, what an ace
@@tbxk06 because she is, Stayc vocal line is the weakest in 4th gen, Sieun isnt good vocalist, Yoon isnt bad but not good tho, Isa is the best vocal in stayc and Karina is better than her
The fact that E:U is in the top 4 of best rappers speaks volumes given the fact that compared to all of the rappers there have a lot of rap lines in their songs while E:U still delivers versatility and flow with the little lines they give her. She's very good
Only fools would doubt SM vocalist superiority. While I love Jihyo (my Twice bias) i would put Seulgi over her and for dance Momo 1 and (unpopular opinion) Seulgi 2nd. I just love how sharp Seulgi's dancing is. Also not just saying this cause Wendy is my ult but if she were in the rap line she'd be right up there.
E:U being literally right behind Lisa and Jennie when it comes to rapping but having one of the least lines and mistreated by their company is unbelievable
The vocal ranking is on point ❤❤ , tho I think most ppl will say jennie is higher than jisoo since jisoo kinda regressed and her mix has so much issues now esp after the show while jennie ( even tho she start shouting above A4 ) some ppl say she is kinda getting closer to support ? Also as far as I know yuqi can support a little( shallow but it is there I think around G#3-F4 ? Not sure tho ) while minnie cant so yuqi>minnie ? Did minnie start supporting or something ? I Just genuinely asking no hate ❤❤ The rest is perfect ofcours .
@@fleija482 I'm actually a multifandom and in my opinion, like the majority who saw this video, it's true, completely true. I think you were the person who does not want to accept reality and believes that everyone should think like you hahaha
I was really hoping Momo would get her Pink Lamborghini line for the rap section 😭 great video though! In a more objective sense, you did really good, and I definitely had a lot of “surprised yet agreeing” moments lol
The lowest aespa member for vocals being at 12 we love to see it 🤩 (and there’s even debate that she’s better than Lia because her support is more consistent)
@@K4TSEYE most definitely but not rly in their songs edit: and also, being a good vocalist is not necessarily about hitting high notes, it's about execution and technique. im no professional tho 🤠
They're among the best in overall female idols, the other who I know and are on the same level or slightly better are Chaeyeon from Izone, queen Boa, Hyo from Girl's Generation, Minzy from 2NE1 , Chungha and Alexa.
I think Lisa Is Better than her because Many dancers Have Confirmed That Lisa Is Very Good at Dancing and Has 10 at every thing and she is the first one while Momo is In the 6th
I think Winter is above Seulgi in vocal consider the fact that Winter have less issues on her mid belt than Seulgi. With more material in the future, NingNing can arguably be place on the B- tier. I don’t think Jihyo is in C+ tier, she suitable to be place in tier C since she’s is inconsistent with her C5. I thought Wendy was still in B+ tier?
@@rocioramilo4833 well if NingNing show her more ability of her supporting her head voice and show more of her agility and low she can. Take Wendy for example she doesn’t really resonance but her head voice, agility and low boost her rank to the B+/A- tier
@@Dimyixx Yeah that's true, dunno if A but def B (I mean A idols as Ailee can't be compared with Wendy for a reason, even tho the diff is not that big)
Even Aespa main rapper and main dancer is a better vocalists than someone main vocalist, is a proof that Aespa has the strongest vocal line for 4th gen female group
Karina in the top 10 for all 3 categories. All of the 72 people wow. She is real ACE. She really good at dancing. She raps very very well. She good at singing i really love her voice. She is very beautiful. And her body shame is amazing!
I think many people would also put Winter very slightly above Seulgi and Jihyo in vocals because her mix is stronger but ig those 3 are interchangeable based on what you value.
I agree with these because 3 of them has its strong and weak side yet they are close on each other. Like selugi her strength is her lower register the best among the 3 and she have a very good sense of pitch however in the mixed she is really struggling in her nasality and tongue tension. In Jihyo, her strength is also her lower register and dynamics and she isn't struggling in nasality like selugi. However she regressed and the quality in Bb4 and B4 is not as good compared to her other mixed register and also she is starting to suffer in tightness and not as open as before. In Winter, her weakness is her lower register which the worst among the 3 yet is still good in general however her strength is in her mixed register she is more open, doesn't struggle in her nasality and tongue tension, she isn't tight and she has a better placement among the 3. But in the end they are a really great vocalist with their strengths and weaknesses
@@rafaelm6181 jihyo is somewhat become more nasal tho since alcohol free era, her jaws start shapping as a stylistic choice but it's almost become a habit.
Hikaru in dance- agree she's definitely the best in kepler Ningning and giselle in vocals- so accurate (for those who says that giselle's vocal is overated, it's acctually not. Although she didn't hit crazy high notes her vocal technique was pretty develop)
Anyway, it's so funny to see some people down here keep yelling that Karina and Giselle is not a good vocalist with a NONSENSE reason like "they don't sing live", blah blah blah. When the fact is, them both literally CAN produce support, a significant sign that prove someone is a developed vocalist, and something people that those say a better vocalist than Karina and Giselle CAN'T do, especially Karina who has potential to move up from Weak to Average to Average level, since she has not shown her full material yet.
You know what? They're just can't accept the truth, that is. Lip-syncing, yes, and? Does not change the fact that they are all developed vocalist. Their performance at encore stage and several TV shows shows that, because at there, they're absolutely singing live.
3RD GEN IS A ICONIC !!! *Wendy* - The Vocal Queen 👑 *Momo* - The Dance Queen 👑 *Jennie* - The Rap Queen 👑 3 GEN QUEENS 👑 RED VELVET! TWICE!! BLACKPINK!!!
@@kokoiii_00 Professionals don‘t say so, I‘m sorry. And that‘s my opinion, what‘s my problem? It‘s obvious that Wendy is the best vocalist, but not obvious that Lisa is the best dancer? Hypocrites….
Nice job! Vocal top 10 is really accurate. For the dance ranking there are somethings to correct. Top 10 should be, based on idol dancing: Hikaru (she is a better idol dancer) - Momo - Heejin - Seulgi - Lisa - Chaeryeong - Yeji - Mia - Jihyo - Yuna/Dayeon I think the scores are a bit high, but these 10 are the best. Also i think E:U, Mina and Yves are too high, but i know you are trying to avoid hate. I recommend you to watch Kpop Dance Deep Dives videos, If you haven't watched it yet, her rankings are really accurate.
@@Devikapk3 idol dancing is a different style of dance, requires a different kind of movement, that's why some people say "X is a better idol dancer, while Y is a better overall dancer", although the term overall dancer shouldn't be used, the right term is open style
correction: 1. jennie better than jisoo cause she shows her shallow support sometimes, but really rare 2. mina and chaeyoung on the same level, F+ or E
EU needs more rap lines. Sometimes I think their company is doubting the group when it comes to vocals and raps. Though Mia is a great vocalist, she's eating up all the lines (No hate to Mia, I'm blaming the company). And its great to see someone who notices Momo's dancing skills. Queen deserved 1st spot
Celebrating Kep1er on this ranking 🥳🎉 when most people say they don't have main vocal material,, y'all chaeyeon @top 6,, just ranked below sm girls.. itzy and kep1er members are indeed great dancers.. Aespa and RV are vocal queens.. yeri should be higher than some who are ranked above her ...nonetheless this ranking is really good and seems accurate..
If you want to talk about an incredible level of talent in a group, you left out one obvious contender......Mamamoo!.....three of the four members are a match for the very top female vocalists in all of K-Pop, all are amazing dancers, great stage presence, all can rap, are mega-talented, and underrated group!
I actually agree with this. I think Yeri's flow is much better than Joy's. The funny thing about Red Velvet though...the person who enjoys rapping and would probably rank higher than Irene? Wendy. Easily better rapper than all the other RV members, she even does the sub rapping but goes uncredited for it in a lot of songs (you literally see her do the sub harmonies to the rap on Queendom recording). Also when she covers Irene's rap in ICC is is FIRE.
I Already knew who will be #1 in Rapping and in Vocal and In Dance I thought it would be Tie but Yeah still agree... For me: Vocals 1. Wendy 2. Ningning 3. Winter 4. Jihyo 5. Seulgi 6. Jeongyeon 7. Nayeon 8. Karina 9. Rosé 10. Lia Rap 1. Soyeon 2. Jennie 3. Lisa 4. E:U 5. Giselle & Chaeyoung 6. Karina 7. Hikaru 8. Dayeon 9. Ryujin 10. Yuna Dance: 1. Momo & Lisa 2. Chaeryeong & Seulgi 3. Hikaru 4. Heejin 5. Yeongeun & Yeji 6. Yves & Mia 7. Dayeon 8. Karina & Ryujin 9. Soojin 10. Irene
@@kimjennie322 you have to look in other side, not because she is from blackpink, we shouldn't always judge her by the group, but by her abilities, because she is a very good dancer I will show you with respect 🙂: technique: Momo (9.7/10), Lisa (9.2/10) energy: Momo (9.2/10), Lisa (9.6/10) moves: Momo (9.5/10), Lisa (9.4/10) controls: Momo (10/10), Lisa (9/10) MOMO: 38.4/40 LISA: 37.2/40 conclusion: both are very good, only momo is a hair better, but I'm blink and lisa is better in energy, so we shouldn't get discouraged.
Wendy’s technique isn’t advanced enough for Proficient to Good. Her placement is still noticeably lacking compared to other Proficient vocalists like Taeyeon or Eunji. Even if she got consistency on Eb5 it would still be questionable to place her above if she still retains the same approach. What is Jihyo doing in Average to Above Average? Even the High Averages are doing a much better job she doesn’t stand out much really compared to Mid Average girls. I’m assuming this is another of those Jihyo having B4/C5 misinformation haha but nah it’s not uncommon for Mid Averages to carry some support on C5’s really people just pay attention to her more that’s why they talk all about it but other Averages like Yuri, Jiwon, and especially Seulgi have shown more developed C5’s NGL. I’d place Jihyo below both Winter and Seulgi. Winter’s approach is cleaner in general and she regularly produces forward belts in the A4/Bb4 area better than what Jihyo is usually putting out nowadays. Seulgi has more issues with tongue tension but her mid-range and lower range is still quite more developed. Nayeon’s not bad but I don’t think she’s comparable to Karina her approach can get messy due to the tongue tension and nasality + she’s not as developed above G#4 well her overall grasp of support doesn’t seem to be developed as Karina’s in general. Jeongyeon should be in Weak to Average or whatever people call that tier nowadays she’s not that consistent with proper support. Both Miyeon and Giselle has shown a better grasp of support than Lia it’s noticeable as well when you compare the clips you put out for those three but that’s as far as I go talking about the underdeveloped girls lol.
@@mydearonthetop6139 she is. rose is only main vocal because blackpink is not vocally focused. if you placed her in twice, aespa, or even stayc she wouldn't be main vocal.
I disagree with the Giselle, Miyeon and Lia one. Most of the time Giselle is not supported or has little support. Miyeon has a better grasp than Giselle but Lia has a better support than those two, most times. It also doesn't help that Aespa's and g-idle songs fit their vocal ranges better so they don't have to strain as much as Lia does.
I think most of us know who will top those vocal, rap and dance ranking, no other group member can take the throne of Wendy, Soyeon and Momo right now 💖
i was so proud for Hikaru ranking 7th in rap and 4th in dance!! And i think hikaru's vocals could be better to. In next cb i hope she have more line in rap or vocal
Than you for searching, I know, sometimes singer that are underdeveloped can sound good, but doesn't mean they are THAT good, and for that reason que be confusing. Momo for example, she is not as bad as people make seen, people act like she were the only bad singer in the entire kpop when there a lot of singers that are like her or even weaker. And Lia from Itzy too, she is not bad singer in general, I think because she is from the big3 , in the main vocal position, in a group with great dancers = that she is an easy target to people to hate on her
I know Wendy will be first in vocal ranking For rapping jeon soyeon is always in first For dance i was confusing between momo and lisa I was also hoping for visual 😂
Mina ranking are so weird like she is way to low in vocal, she have shallow support if I’m not wrong (same with Chaeyoung by the way) but she is way too high in dancing, especially compared to her member, Jihyo, Sana and Nayeon are all better than her… This is not based on technique and support, especially considering than at least half of them don’t have proper technique or even shallow support…
i totally agree with your opinion on the vocal but in dance? no. compared to all the other twice members only her and momo has full body control that doesn't look stiff, overpowered and lacking at the same time. sana is a bit lacking on some parts, nayeon is strong yet stiff dancer and jihyo she overpower her dance moves that may somehow look stiff on their choreos maybe that's why she is ranked higher than the other 3.
i agree with the vocal one. the vocal ranking isnt accurate at all. ryujin and shuhua are better than momo? michaeng that low when they obviously have better sense of support than several idols ranked above them.
Staycs vocal ranking took me by suprise I love isa, Giselle out ranking half of the main vocalists is funny since sm vocalists are just built different I'm not sure why Lisa is 3rd on rap above chaeyoung but okay 👌
I think my favorite top 10 vocals based on their technique (my version) are : 1. Wendy 2. Ningning 3. Winter 4. Miyeon 5. Seulgi 6. Rosé 7. Jihyo 8. Nayeon 9. Lia 10. Chaehyun
Based on technique and my version doesn't go together. It's either your opinion or based on technique because criteria of technique are same for everyone, you cannot change them.
@@Natureisbeauty-b8uthe best dancer in black pink and one of the best dancer in all among all the gg not the best dancer in kpop whole industry she is not a above or she not a tier 1 dancer 😅and she not above most professional dancers so she even not the best dancer in the planet 😅
For me i just think kep1er and aespa winter can go above twice i think still underdeveloped they are very new groups however twice ha trained for a lot of years. 😅
I don't think that lisa deserve the rank, she should have the first ranking I am not letting other down but lisa and momo should have same ranking in the dance bcz they are the dancing machine of kpop Don't hate ( it's my opinions) And in vocals all have got correct rank and also in rap expect that lisa should be in second rank and soyeon and jennie in first place bcz jennie hasnot got much chance to show her rapping and how much can she rap fast. ( my opinion)
I honestly think it’s because yg is stupid and don’t give jisoo parts that fit her voice, like why does she always have the same parts of rosé It don’t make any sense
-
The vocal ranking is hugely based on Vocal Support and then Technique, Consistency, pitch, etc were taken into consideration.
-
From Heejin and Up are the idols who have support even if it's shallow or inconsistent it's better than having none.
Except for Minnie who is ranked higher than idols like Sihyeon, Mia, Yuqi (These two have support and are the strongest in their groups)
I didn't want to deal with Forevers and Neverlands, I already put on my big-boy pants and placed Sieun lower (WAY lower)
-
If I made an error in the Vocal Ranking you are free to correct me RESPECTFULLY.
-
Other than that,,,,, The Dance and rap ranking is Totally based on my Opinion.
P.s. Wendy will be in the B+ tier, I did some research most people said there is no vocalist in the A tier, Which I kinda agree with now.
Forgot this --> 🙉
🙉
@@cherryglam7919 I think sihyeon is stronger
@@cherryglam7919 sihyeon has support while Mia doesn’t
@@cherryglam7919 sure a toxic fan created a bs ranking video that has no value whatsoever. That is all.
@@incheonguy lol, your funny Ron Wesley
not to mention, but we are all already know that wendy is gonna be first in vocal. but im still waitung the whole rank hahahaah, our best vocalist!!!
Yeeeesss 😂😂
Ikr!!!
She'd probably still be on top 3 ..she could still possibly beat taeyeon and IU TO BE NUMBER 1
Honestly thought it was gonna be NingNing 🤣🤣🤣
@@human-bing2033
Maybe tayeon but iu no ✌️😘
I love how Joy, Giselle and Karina are in the same level of a lot Main Vocals
this PART
Karinas vocals give me chills
I don’t get how you can tell them good but never heard them sing live, you can fixed bad vocal in studio
@@pyaytsone9717 not really, there's only so much autotune can do, for studio vocals to sound great the raw material the producers are working with need's to be good as well.
I don't get the misconception that autotune is this magical gift from Jesus that can make anyone sound great.
@@pyaytsone9717 pitch and tension can be fixed and reduced in the studio, but you cannot fake support.
Notice how Ningning is one of the youngest ( 19) on this list and she’s literally ranked 2nd out of 60 peopel. Girly just debuted a year ago. And she’s already getting this high? Yeah Ningning truly is 4th gens best vocalist. I would definitely giver her an b+/A- she’s been showing improvements and her live singing when on variety shows is so beautiful. She’s so stable and versatile. I dread no one is beating her.
Ning Ning is a good vocalist (+ I love her voice) but you should listen to Yechan (Pink Fantasy) and Nayul (12dal) sing. They have the best technique in 4th gen. Ning Ning is the best mainstream 4th gen vocalist tho. (Monday is very good too but usually more inconsistent.)
She should be, she's from SM. Taeyeon and wendy are both already the best in their generation even at their debut (taeyeon was above average at her debut (higher level than current ningning) and she was only 18 back then, was the best until hyorin came out; while wendy was already a proficient vocalist at her debut (20 at that time), definitely destined to be the best female vocalist of 3rd gen). Ningning is the weakest among all SM main vocalist at their debut (being average to above average at debut and still is up till now), she's doing good but she needs to exercise more to catch up to her senior's level.
@@brendan6555 I still think Ningning is 4th best vocalist.
@@rosie5816 you mean 4th gen?
@@brendan6555 yeah lol
Wow, this proof aespa have a great vocalist! Even karina and giselle who is a rapper and sub vocalist, have a high rank. Also this proof karina is an ACE
They sing well but why always lip syn ??
But in terms of vocals, that‘s not true and they can‘t sing live
@@Komdej100 sm won't let them sing live
@@sullyoonwaffles7182 Vocal skills has no anything to do with Live Singing, please adjust your understanding.
@@sullyoonwaffles7182 Studio vocals and live vocals Is almost same bug studio ver is has bigger volume and More cleaner.
Some people didnt know that karina has a good vocals even though she is a main dancer.. SM please let Karina show her amazing vocal more often 😭 (sorry i cant speak english well)
Ur icon shows it all that ur not biased
well i mean karina is auditioning as a vocalist
@@eubiasedforeverglow even if she being biased she still saying the truth
@@slaypa ik but that dosent mean she/he/they has to lie saying im not biased...
@@eubiasedforeverglow i mean, i said karina has good vocal not based on karina is my bias. I have bad english. So sorry if u misunderstanding what i mean
Karina in the top 10 for all 3 categories with 70 people competing 😧 Truly an ace all arounder!
Can rap
Can dance
Can sing
And very pretty
72*
But I think she can’t be in the top 10 for vocal and rap,author not professional expert
@@nurtilekkylshabaev6247 i want karina in dance,rap on top 10 but in vocals i think she will be in above 20?
@@nurtilekkylshabaev6247 she could be 15 in vocal n 10 in rap n 10 in dance n 5 in visual Still no one got to do this she’s an ace
the fact that the sub vocals of aespa are on the same tier with other groups' main vocalists (even higher than some)
Exactly 😍
The problem is that we've yet to hear live vocals from aespa, I'm sure they're all amazing singers but everyone is saying they're better vocalists that all other groups but why don't they ever perform live?
@@Taylor-jj5ob burn sm. sm let my girlies sing live
@@Taylor-jj5ob They never perform their song live but they sing live several times. And it's enough to say that they are talented vocalist.
@@Taylor-jj5ob mad at sm not aespa
proud of ningning for vocals, she’s right where she’s supposed to be. she’s truely a queen 😌💕
A lot of people in the comments are doubting Karina's vocals when she IS one of the best vocalists in the 4th generation of Kpop. Simple, go listen to Savage and Dreams Come True, she have a really healthy and beautiful vibrato, her A4 notes are developed. "But she above main vocalists and lead vocalists" yes she is because her vocals are good.
By the way I desagree Tzuyu's vocal ranking, actually she deserve way better, I think she's better than Yeri, Tzuyu is actually the 6th best vocalist in Twice. Mina and Chaeyoung are so low in vocals, they can support, shallow but they have some sense of support.
Also I don't think that Jeongyeon is the worst dancer like I've no idea about dancing but some professional dancers said that she's not bad as people makes her be. Other than that the rest of the ranking is debatable because the sub vocals are all underdeveloped and don't have materials to be analysed, so I agree with you, only Tzuyu, Mina and Chaeyoung positions that I desagree.
Yes, Stayc members are not that good in singing, people need to understand that. Everyone can do high notes but we need to analyse if the high notes are healthy or have proper technique, this is more important.
Also, sorry for my English, I'm still learning ok?
Good video, you're so hardworking
Nu uhhhhh, yeri is nasal but at least she is not flat. Tzuyu vocal is so flat 😭😭
I kinda disagree with stayc seiun ranking in singing. She can be on the same level as Lia itzy.
@@nishtha2788 she doesn't support tho
@@nishtha2788 Definitely no
@@justlia6863 :o
I think Chaeyoung should go a lot higher in rap since she is actually the 2nd fastest female kpop rapper right now. If you watch her Sixteen performances she is AMAZING.
Rapping isn't only about being fast
@@indescribableconfusion7017 yes true and that’s why I’m not necessarily saying she should be 2nd on the list, but I do think she should be higher anyway because her flow is amazing too
@@mommysaranghae1281 ah i know i was just saying ^-^
Talking fast is not a rap. Chae is actually great in 16 teen but if u hear her raps in twice she just go that flow.
She doesnt get as good rap lines, wish she could rap again like she did on sixteen
The top 6 vocals for me based on their techniques is
1. Wendy
2. Ningning
3. Winter
4. Jihyo
5. Seulgi
6. Jongyeon
7
*Jeongyeon* got 6th place out of 70 Members, also she treated like a sub Vocalist 😩😩
She deserves every good thing in this World!!!
#GetwellsoonJEONGYEON 💚✨
#LastChorusQueen 💚✨
And being a Jeongyeon Stan it's painful!!!
7. Rose
8. Nayeon
9. Karina
7 Nayeon
@@musicformylife6550 7. Nayeon
8. Karina
9. Rosé
@@slaypa Not agree, because rose main vocal for reason, but i respect
Let's be honest we all already knew soyeon was going to be first in rap
Tbh we all knew who the top 3 for rappers was gonna be
@Hyungskook True
Yesse
@@K4TSEYE true
Sadly we can’t hear E:U full potential despite she ranked #4 because their company won’t give her more rap lines and ending up eaten by Mia (no hate to mia btw, just their company)
I just realized that if hypothetically, Karina was in StayC or Ive, and there were positions, Karina would be a main dancer, main vocalist and main rapper in both groups since she is the best in all 3 categories in both groups, what an ace
Yes and she is good performer and sh'e a visual according to kbs !
Imagine thinking she is better at singing than yoon and sieun omg
@@tbxk06 better than Yoon sure, Sieun not
@@Gabz98_ no def not she barely sang live ever so we can‘t really tell if she‘s better but Yoon is main vocal material
@@tbxk06 because she is, Stayc vocal line is the weakest in 4th gen, Sieun isnt good vocalist, Yoon isnt bad but not good tho, Isa is the best vocal in stayc and Karina is better than her
Wendy is 100% the best female vocalist of Gen 3.
The fact that E:U is in the top 4 of best rappers speaks volumes given the fact that compared to all of the rappers there have a lot of rap lines in their songs while E:U still delivers versatility and flow with the little lines they give her. She's very good
I was spoil😭 HAHAHAHA
CORRECT E:U IS THE BEST
Only fools would doubt SM vocalist superiority. While I love Jihyo (my Twice bias) i would put Seulgi over her and for dance Momo 1 and (unpopular opinion) Seulgi 2nd. I just love how sharp Seulgi's dancing is.
Also not just saying this cause Wendy is my ult but if she were in the rap line she'd be right up there.
@@Sun-kissed_lips Winter is better than Jihyo but people are so biased with twice
Not when Seulgi still has tongue tension and more nasality on mixed notes compare to Jihyo
@@spheksophobiaurinal lol no, winter is definitely not better than jihyo
@@shannon3658 she has better support and overall better technique, Jihyo just has a nicer and deeper tone, but it doesn't matter
@@Sun-kissed_lips yes, although Jihyo sounds more relaxed while belting compared to Seulgi, i still think Seulgi is a better singer
Kep1er and ITZY are dance group!
And WENDY is always the best main vocal
Soyeon is just a friking rap goddess, I LOOOOVE HER
Jihyo deserves a higher place in the dance rank. shes really good at dancing. LIKE REALLY GOOD. atleast top 10.
For me jihyo deserves higher rank for her dance
Agree
And jeongyeon too
@@asxtro7145 yeah I agree
Agree
what? HAHAHAHAH
karina being at the same level of nayeon (who is a strong lead vocalist) prove that she is a lead vocal material
E:U being literally right behind Lisa and Jennie when it comes to rapping but having one of the least lines and mistreated by their company is unbelievable
The vocal ranking is on point ❤❤ , tho I think most ppl will say jennie is higher than jisoo since jisoo kinda regressed and her mix has so much issues now esp after the show while jennie ( even tho she start shouting above A4 ) some ppl say she is kinda getting closer to support ?
Also as far as I know yuqi can support a little( shallow but it is there I think around G#3-F4 ? Not sure tho ) while minnie cant so yuqi>minnie ?
Did minnie start supporting or something ? I
Just genuinely asking no hate ❤❤
The rest is perfect ofcours .
Read the pinned the comment,
Minnie doesn’t support, yeah Yuqi does
@@Minty_Sana got it .. sorry if I bothered you
Great to see Jeongyeon, Nayeon, and Jihyo in top 10 for vocals.❤️
finally an unbiased and factual vocal ranking from somebody that actually knows vocal skill, thank you
You found someone who thinks like you, that's all. It was pretty badly done.
@@fleija482 I'm actually a multifandom and in my opinion, like the majority who saw this video, it's true, completely true. I think you were the person who does not want to accept reality and believes that everyone should think like you hahaha
@@Micaela.tw1 You're just another misinformed person.
@@fleija482 Actually, you´re just another misinformed person, I will pray for you to change😄🙏
I was really hoping Momo would get her Pink Lamborghini line for the rap section 😭 great video though! In a more objective sense, you did really good, and I definitely had a lot of “surprised yet agreeing” moments lol
The fact that Ning Ning is just a rookie who debuted last year and is in the #2 for vocals is so impressive...cant wait for her future performances
Yes!! as expected, The most unbiased queen!!
The lowest aespa member for vocals being at 12 we love to see it 🤩 (and there’s even debate that she’s better than Lia because her support is more consistent)
I think it's true, Giselle is slightly below lia and Karina is slightly above lia..They all have good vocals
Has Giselle ever hit a high note??
@@K4TSEYE most definitely but not rly in their songs
edit: and also, being a good vocalist is not necessarily about hitting high notes, it's about execution and technique. im no professional tho 🤠
@@tomasfangueiro4118 ouhhh thanks
@@K4TSEYE she never hit a high note but just to remind you that high note is not a reason to makes you a good vocalist.
Who are the Best Vocalists?
RV and aespa: YESSSS 💅
Irene queen of Visuals!
Momo first in the dance? I agree 100%
@@bubu.3322 Neither of Momo or Lisa dance skills are underrated. Both are hugely praised.
@@bubu.3322 sure buddy keep telling yourself that.
They're among the best in overall female idols, the other who I know and are on the same level or slightly better are Chaeyeon from Izone, queen Boa, Hyo from Girl's Generation, Minzy from 2NE1 , Chungha and Alexa.
that's right! even Lisa admits it!!
I think Lisa Is Better than her because Many dancers Have Confirmed That Lisa Is Very Good at Dancing and Has 10 at every thing and she is the first one while Momo is In the 6th
Thank you for having our Soojin in the thumbnail as Idle's representative🥺💜
Wendy 1st in vocal💙(SM Entertainment)
Soyeon 1st in rap💛(Cube Entertainment)
Momo 1st in dance♥️(JYP Entertainment)
That is a fact🤩
I think Winter is above Seulgi in vocal consider the fact that Winter have less issues on her mid belt than Seulgi.
With more material in the future, NingNing can arguably be place on the B- tier.
I don’t think Jihyo is in C+ tier, she suitable to be place in tier C since she’s is inconsistent with her C5.
I thought Wendy was still in B+ tier?
I think Ningning is C+ since she doesn't resonate ^^
@@rocioramilo4833 well if NingNing show her more ability of her supporting her head voice and show more of her agility and low she can.
Take Wendy for example she doesn’t really resonance but her head voice, agility and low boost her rank to the B+/A- tier
@@Dimyixx Yeah that's true, dunno if A but def B (I mean A idols as Ailee can't be compared with Wendy for a reason, even tho the diff is not that big)
The Video maker Make winter and seulgi Tie, I actually suprised why Winter is 5th while she has same tier as seulgi.
Yeah me too winter vocal is more and strong and powerful than than seulgi
Even Aespa main rapper and main dancer is a better vocalists than someone main vocalist, is a proof that Aespa has the strongest vocal line for 4th gen female group
@l actually they are but they rarely sing live which dissapointing for me
But They always lip syn hehehehe
But it isn’t true, since Karina and Giselle should be way lower, especially Karina but no hate
@l lmao ur funny dude
@@Komdej100 still they are the best ( alexa Play power by exo) anyways, watched their recent DCT stage encores and recording they did sang live.
My top 6 favourite vocalist 💕is
1) Rose
2) jihyo
3)wendy
4)nayeon
5)lia
6) jennie
wow, just being blink changes you and blinds people😧
People still get on a Lia for her dancing skills but she has truly improved so much and I love that for her.
In the dance section there's a missed opportunity:
You could have made Chaeryeong's Swalala transition into Lisa's😢
Otherwise good ranking like always
momo best dancer
@@jelijeli216 Lisa is best dancer she come on top
yes lisa always on top
yes lisa always on top
Karina in the top 10 for all 3 categories. All of the 72 people wow. She is real ACE.
She really good at dancing.
She raps very very well.
She good at singing i really love her voice.
She is very beautiful.
And her body shame is amazing!
Top 3 dancer's for me
1.momo
2.chaeryoung
3.lisa
same, but different order for me
Really not accurate
@@Saia_er I swear….😂
RV and Aespa are like the tower in vocal, BP Have some of the best female rappers, A lot of strong dancer on Kep1er.
I think many people would also put Winter very slightly above Seulgi and Jihyo in vocals because her mix is stronger but ig those 3 are interchangeable based on what you value.
This is judged from the technique huh 😊!
@@youmeeeeeeee Yes ofc
I agree with these because 3 of them has its strong and weak side yet they are close on each other. Like selugi her strength is her lower register the best among the 3 and she have a very good sense of pitch however in the mixed she is really struggling in her nasality and tongue tension. In Jihyo, her strength is also her lower register and dynamics and she isn't struggling in nasality like selugi. However she regressed and the quality in Bb4 and B4 is not as good compared to her other mixed register and also she is starting to suffer in tightness and not as open as before. In Winter, her weakness is her lower register which the worst among the 3 yet is still good in general however her strength is in her mixed register she is more open, doesn't struggle in her nasality and tongue tension, she isn't tight and she has a better placement among the 3. But in the end they are a really great vocalist with their strengths and weaknesses
@@youmeeeeeeee this comment is based on technique too.
@@rafaelm6181 jihyo is somewhat become more nasal tho since alcohol free era, her jaws start shapping as a stylistic choice but it's almost become a habit.
I agree with almost all your ranking as well ❤️ very unbiased
Hikaru in dance- agree she's definitely the best in kepler
Ningning and giselle in vocals- so accurate (for those who says that giselle's vocal is overated, it's acctually not. Although she didn't hit crazy high notes her vocal technique was pretty develop)
yeri is a better vocalist than many above her i said it
Same sentiments here😅
LOONA & GIDLE BEING A WHOLE DAMN PACKAGE >>>
Severely underrated though lettuce pray for a better ranking than this 🙏💀
I agree
Anyway, it's so funny to see some people down here keep yelling that Karina and Giselle is not a good vocalist with a NONSENSE reason like "they don't sing live", blah blah blah.
When the fact is, them both literally CAN produce support, a significant sign that prove someone is a developed vocalist, and something people that those say a better vocalist than Karina and Giselle CAN'T do, especially Karina who has potential to move up from Weak to Average to Average level, since she has not shown her full material yet.
Aespa = lip syn queen
@@Komdej100 lol, if this is the best thing you can do.
You know what? They're just can't accept the truth, that is.
Lip-syncing, yes, and? Does not change the fact that they are all developed vocalist.
Their performance at encore stage and several TV shows shows that, because at there, they're absolutely singing live.
@@Komdej100 Please You even can not spell it correctly.
Karina is more Save in Low average, She needs to Show Her vocal In variety shows and in the radios , Thats the only she can sing live.
I was gonna have a fit is Soyeon wasn't number 1 in rapping, she's our queen 👑👑
3RD GEN IS A ICONIC !!!
*Wendy* - The Vocal Queen 👑
*Momo* - The Dance Queen 👑
*Jennie* - The Rap Queen 👑
3 GEN QUEENS 👑
RED VELVET!
TWICE!!
BLACKPINK!!!
Yess ther are my fav gg☺
Jennie rap queen ?
Where is soyeon placed in your opinion ,I don't mean on Stan or beauty or popularity but talent ..no offence
@@wohoo_gi7838 I'm talking about 3rd Generation Groups
@@rdc.jy_piece okay
SOYEON- THE RAP QUEEN
Can’t wait to see Giselle to grow more as a rapper 😍🥰 she got so much potential
Ryujin being 13 in dance I was like 💀 but everyone have different opinions ofcourse.
😂me too.. i agree with all of these rankings except for that dance ranking of Ryujin.. just my opinion..she is better than Irene..
Or Lisa in 2….🤯
@@blackpinkandbtsaretheonefo3938 why? Momo deserve being top 1 she has better techniques, and did so many genre already🤷♀️
@@kokoiii_00 Professionals don‘t say so, I‘m sorry. And that‘s my opinion, what‘s my problem? It‘s obvious that Wendy is the best vocalist, but not obvious that Lisa is the best dancer? Hypocrites….
@@blackpinkandbtsaretheonefo3938 mmm, no lisa is not the best dancer
it's Momo
and I'm not saying
ur girl Seulgi is in top 5 on both Vocals & Dance. truly an ace!
she cant rap tho 🤮
@@heuniofied here we go again, a talentless trash as expected.
Imo she is a all rounder(no hate🤞🏻🤞🏻)
Nice job! Vocal top 10 is really accurate.
For the dance ranking there are somethings to correct.
Top 10 should be, based on idol dancing:
Hikaru (she is a better idol dancer) - Momo - Heejin - Seulgi - Lisa - Chaeryeong - Yeji - Mia - Jihyo - Yuna/Dayeon
I think the scores are a bit high, but these 10 are the best. Also i think E:U, Mina and Yves are too high, but i know you are trying to avoid hate. I recommend you to watch Kpop Dance Deep Dives videos, If you haven't watched it yet, her rankings are really accurate.
I think dayeon>Yuna,jihyo maybe Mia?
@@Devikapk3 in idol dancing, no.
@@luizizn165 i didn't understand
@@Devikapk3 idol dancing is a different style of dance, requires a different kind of movement, that's why some people say "X is a better idol dancer, while Y is a better overall dancer", although the term overall dancer shouldn't be used, the right term is open style
@@luizizn165 so dayeon is an overall better dancer
correction:
1. jennie better than jisoo cause she shows her shallow support sometimes, but really rare
2. mina and chaeyoung on the same level, F+ or E
I agree.
Jennie never show her Support ( even if it Very shallow ), But she almost close to supporting notes.
EU needs more rap lines. Sometimes I think their company is doubting the group when it comes to vocals and raps. Though Mia is a great vocalist, she's eating up all the lines (No hate to Mia, I'm blaming the company).
And its great to see someone who notices Momo's dancing skills. Queen deserved 1st spot
Agree all, except for rap, that Chaeyoung better than Giselle, EU and Lisa
1. Soyeon
2. Jennie
3. Chaeyoung
It is just my opinion but i think that it should be like this
1.Soyeon
2.Jennie
3.Lisa
4. Chaeyoung
5. E.U
6. Giselle
This video shows why yoo ji-min is my bias. She is in every top 10
Celebrating Kep1er on this ranking 🥳🎉 when most people say they don't have main vocal material,, y'all chaeyeon @top 6,, just ranked below sm girls.. itzy and kep1er members are indeed great dancers.. Aespa and RV are vocal queens.. yeri should be higher than some who are ranked above her ...nonetheless this ranking is really good and seems accurate..
For Rap I give it to jeon soyeon of Gidle..she is the Rap queen of kpop right now ! !
TOP 6 BEST VOCAL
1- Wendy
2- NIngning
3- Jihyo
4- Winter
5- Seulgi
6- Nayeon
Chaehyun ?
If you want to talk about an incredible level of talent in a group, you left out one obvious contender......Mamamoo!.....three of the four members are a match for the very top female vocalists in all of K-Pop, all are amazing dancers, great stage presence, all can rap, are mega-talented, and underrated group!
Such a shame that Iz*one disbanded if only their included here we can all see how the members are talented
There’s always aespa members in top 10 ✨ just shows how brilliant they are . Def the ACE of 4th gen gg
I think yeri deserves to be higher in dance and rap. Great video though, I mostly agreed with the rankings
I actually agree with this. I think Yeri's flow is much better than Joy's. The funny thing about Red Velvet though...the person who enjoys rapping and would probably rank higher than Irene? Wendy. Easily better rapper than all the other RV members, she even does the sub rapping but goes uncredited for it in a lot of songs (you literally see her do the sub harmonies to the rap on Queendom recording). Also when she covers Irene's rap in ICC is is FIRE.
@@earthcitty But red velvet official rap rank is 1. Irene, 2. Joy, 3. Wendy, 4. Yeri, 5. Seulgi
I really think that Bahiyyih has a born vocal stability, maybe she is not the best vocalist but has something that captivates
Nobody is talking about Karina, Giselle and Joy
Sub vocalist in top 15, VOCAL queens
I Already knew who will be #1 in Rapping and in Vocal and In Dance I thought it would be Tie but Yeah still agree...
For me:
Vocals
1. Wendy
2. Ningning
3. Winter
4. Jihyo
5. Seulgi
6. Jeongyeon
7. Nayeon
8. Karina
9. Rosé
10. Lia
Rap
1. Soyeon
2. Jennie
3. Lisa
4. E:U
5. Giselle & Chaeyoung
6. Karina
7. Hikaru
8. Dayeon
9. Ryujin
10. Yuna
Dance:
1. Momo & Lisa
2. Chaeryeong & Seulgi
3. Hikaru
4. Heejin
5. Yeongeun & Yeji
6. Yves & Mia
7. Dayeon
8. Karina & Ryujin
9. Soojin
10. Irene
Onda can’t be this low. She’s a hiphop dancer
Actually lisa 1st Dance cause she has been recognized by many dance professionals.
So is momo, so I don't get your point
@@nishtha2788 bcz lisa have more unique techniques swag personality than momo which make lisa better than momo in dance
@@kimjennie322 you have to look in other side, not because she is from blackpink, we shouldn't always judge her by the group, but by her abilities, because she is a very good dancer
I will show you with respect 🙂:
technique: Momo (9.7/10), Lisa (9.2/10)
energy: Momo (9.2/10), Lisa (9.6/10)
moves: Momo (9.5/10), Lisa (9.4/10)
controls: Momo (10/10), Lisa (9/10)
MOMO: 38.4/40
LISA: 37.2/40
conclusion: both are very good, only momo is a hair better, but I'm blink and lisa is better in energy, so we shouldn't get discouraged.
Hats off to the creator
You have the talent of recognise everyone's talent techniques
This ranking needs a lot of hard work great work!
I thought that I was only 1 who thought Jisoo isn’t that much better compared to Jennie in vocals
They’re on the same level for me but jisoo is more stable
@@K4TSEYE jisoo just sounds more stable cause her voice is deeper, but jennie is a more developed singer
@@K4TSEYE again, stable isn't a require for make a person a good singer nor a vocalist, Jennie is slightly better than Jisoo
Can someone explain why Jennie is better then Jisoo?
@@spheksophobiaurinal ?? If Jennie is more developed, does that mean she’s better? I don’t understand ur comment
This is one of the best ranking videos so far, you can tell it’s not bias influenced 🙏
The effort you put into this thanks
Wendy’s technique isn’t advanced enough for Proficient to Good. Her placement is still noticeably lacking compared to other Proficient vocalists like Taeyeon or Eunji. Even if she got consistency on Eb5 it would still be questionable to place her above if she still retains the same approach.
What is Jihyo doing in Average to Above Average? Even the High Averages are doing a much better job she doesn’t stand out much really compared to Mid Average girls. I’m assuming this is another of those Jihyo having B4/C5 misinformation haha but nah it’s not uncommon for Mid Averages to carry some support on C5’s really people just pay attention to her more that’s why they talk all about it but other Averages like Yuri, Jiwon, and especially Seulgi have shown more developed C5’s NGL.
I’d place Jihyo below both Winter and Seulgi. Winter’s approach is cleaner in general and she regularly produces forward belts in the A4/Bb4 area better than what Jihyo is usually putting out nowadays. Seulgi has more issues with tongue tension but her mid-range and lower range is still quite more developed.
Nayeon’s not bad but I don’t think she’s comparable to Karina her approach can get messy due to the tongue tension and nasality + she’s not as developed above G#4 well her overall grasp of support doesn’t seem to be developed as Karina’s in general. Jeongyeon should be in Weak to Average or whatever people call that tier nowadays she’s not that consistent with proper support.
Both Miyeon and Giselle has shown a better grasp of support than Lia it’s noticeable as well when you compare the clips you put out for those three but that’s as far as I go talking about the underdeveloped girls lol.
How aboyt Rose? Shes not weak than Karina t
@@mydearonthetop6139 she is. rose is only main vocal because blackpink is not vocally focused. if you placed her in twice, aespa, or even stayc she wouldn't be main vocal.
@@i2krhtd For technique they same D+ in this video too, but I'm pretty sure many prefer Rose voice than Karina, but karina very good to sub vocal sm
I disagree with the Giselle, Miyeon and Lia one. Most of the time Giselle is not supported or has little support. Miyeon has a better grasp than Giselle but Lia has a better support than those two, most times. It also doesn't help that Aespa's and g-idle songs fit their vocal ranges better so they don't have to strain as much as Lia does.
As a non-knowledgeable person in singing I love the detail in your comment, super interesting!
I think most of us know who will top those vocal, rap and dance ranking, no other group member can take the throne of Wendy, Soyeon and Momo right now 💖
i was so proud for Hikaru ranking 7th in rap and 4th in dance!! And i think hikaru's vocals could be better to. In next cb i hope she have more line in rap or vocal
Than you for searching, I know, sometimes singer that are underdeveloped can sound good, but doesn't mean they are THAT good, and for that reason que be confusing.
Momo for example, she is not as bad as people make seen, people act like she were the only bad singer in the entire kpop when there a lot of singers that are like her or even weaker.
And Lia from Itzy too, she is not bad singer in general, I think because she is from the big3 , in the main vocal position, in a group with great dancers = that she is an easy target to people to hate on her
not really related but im glad ppl are still putting soojin in these thypes of videos, i hope she comes back
AM I THE ONLY ONE EXPECTING WENDY IN RAP RANKING EVEN THO SHE DOESN'T HAVE A RAP POSITION.....MY GIRLIE IS PRETTY GOOD RAPPER IF YOU ASK ME
Nope, was literally waiting to see if she got the recognition she deserves for being the undercover Main Rapper.
I know Wendy will be first in vocal ranking
For rapping jeon soyeon is always in first
For dance i was confusing between momo and lisa
I was also hoping for visual 😂
Proud of Lisa for being 62 in vocal
but let's not forget that she is one of the best kpop dancers in 2nd place, we have to be very proud
@@Micaela.tw1true
@@Micaela.tw1 yesss
Finally, someone notices how talented a rapper e:u is
I was actually expecting Wendy to be in the rap ranking as well. She's Red Velvet's secret main rapper. She's probably better than Irene?
YES! Momo is dance queen!
@kwangya♡ Link?
@existiendo Lisa también ha recibido premios
YESSSSSSSSS it´s a fact, she is the "dance machine" and it's not for nothing
Mina ranking are so weird like she is way to low in vocal, she have shallow support if I’m not wrong (same with Chaeyoung by the way) but she is way too high in dancing, especially compared to her member, Jihyo, Sana and Nayeon are all better than her…
This is not based on technique and support, especially considering than at least half of them don’t have proper technique or even shallow support…
I totally agree with vocals but I think Mina is 2nd best dancer in Twice
i totally agree with your opinion on the vocal but in dance? no. compared to all the other twice members only her and momo has full body control that doesn't look stiff, overpowered and lacking at the same time. sana is a bit lacking on some parts, nayeon is strong yet stiff dancer and jihyo she overpower her dance moves that may somehow look stiff on their choreos maybe that's why she is ranked higher than the other 3.
@@duh7524 i think mina is a little weak in more hiphop based choreo since she's more fluid (used to be a ballerina) but otherwise, yeah. she's okay.
i agree with the vocal one. the vocal ranking isnt accurate at all. ryujin and shuhua are better than momo? michaeng that low when they obviously have better sense of support than several idols ranked above them.
Sana and Jihyo got ranking higher than Lead Dancer in their group😂
It's because they're better than lead dancers .............why are you being rude ???
Soyeon in a rap QUEEN👑
Debatably Aisha should be ranked higher in rap because of her first rap especially, her tone performance and rhythm was amazing
Staycs vocal ranking took me by suprise I love isa, Giselle out ranking half of the main vocalists is funny since sm vocalists are just built different
I'm not sure why Lisa is 3rd on rap above chaeyoung but okay 👌
because alot of people like lisa raps
@@camilahoover7111 yeah but this is based on technique though
@@GuysLuvJeonghan lisa also has that dont be stupid
@@camilahoover7111 bold of you to say that
StayC vocal ranking are mindblowing.
Isa=Sumin - Yoon - Seeun - Sieun - J.
Isa can be relaxed until G#4.
Pls do this again but with your new layout! Totally agree btw
I’ll try
@@Minty_Sana tysm!!!
I think my favorite top 10 vocals based on their technique (my version) are :
1. Wendy
2. Ningning
3. Winter
4. Miyeon
5. Seulgi
6. Rosé
7. Jihyo
8. Nayeon
9. Lia
10. Chaehyun
Based on technique and my version doesn't go together. It's either your opinion or based on technique because criteria of technique are same for everyone, you cannot change them.
@@ayeon5609 I think it's about tone preference
@@ayeon5609 that based on technique from my opinion
@@ayeon5609 maybe I should change my sentence "top 10 my favorite vocals based on their technique" so people don't get missunderstand
As fan of lot of group im not biased but in dance Lisa deserves number 1
let them bro everyone knows our lili is best in dancing
@@Natureisbeauty-b8uthe best dancer in black pink and one of the best dancer in all among all the gg not the best dancer in kpop whole industry she is not a above or she not a tier 1 dancer 😅and she not above most professional dancers so she even not the best dancer in the planet 😅
For me i just think kep1er and aespa winter can go above twice i think still underdeveloped they are very new groups however twice ha trained for a lot of years. 😅
True
That‘s not true aespa keeps being overrated
for style( or maybe tone?), i choose jennie 1st and giselle 2nd for rap. it’s just so satisfying in my ear. just my opinion btw
Yah same
9:30 finallyy queen gets recognition!! 😤😤
i love how sm artists literally start at top 40 in vocals-
22:49 camerawoman be floating lol
Chaeryeong, lisa & momo....now that is a ranking that's deserved
I don't think that lisa deserve the rank, she should have the first ranking
I am not letting other down but lisa and momo should have same ranking in the dance bcz they are the dancing machine of kpop
Don't hate ( it's my opinions)
And in vocals all have got correct rank and also in rap expect that lisa should be in second rank and soyeon and jennie in first place bcz jennie hasnot got much chance to show her rapping and how much can she rap fast. ( my opinion)
@@kimjennie322 Look at your name. Its giving me bias
jennie > jisoo, jisoo has a really damaging technique and jennie started to support.
She hasn’t supported *yet* , but she’s soooo close, she’s almost there.
@@seenjeans she supported one G4 in LSG encore
@@rinactx8170 its only once, We need her to shows G4 Supports, People will not include that As Support category but Its Jennie lucky moments.
I honestly think it’s because yg is stupid and don’t give jisoo parts that fit her voice, like why does she always have the same parts of rosé It don’t make any sense
@@anthonymagana3181 ya most of parts given to her is out of her range