Here is Ashneer Grover's point of view on Tax

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ธ.ค. 2024

ความคิดเห็น • 2.1K

  • @gursharandhillon2931
    @gursharandhillon2931 ปีที่แล้ว +2184

    He is absolutely right, in India paying tax is a charity where you don't expect anything in return. In charity, at least you earn some goodwill.

    • @veerupay4117
      @veerupay4117 ปีที่แล้ว

      Y?
      U dont use roadways
      U dont use health care scheme
      U dont have bank account
      U dont have police protection
      Army is not protecting the border
      Dont just blindly comment
      Do some research

    • @Terahydron
      @Terahydron ปีที่แล้ว +9

      Lol

    • @Gigachad101-i8g
      @Gigachad101-i8g ปีที่แล้ว +48

      Phir do Mudi ko vote 😂😂

    • @allenshorts4076
      @allenshorts4076 ปีที่แล้ว +23

      Baki to koi tax he nhi leta 😂

    • @teriyankiking9183
      @teriyankiking9183 ปีที่แล้ว +95

      ​@@Gigachad101-i8gdena toh modi ko hi hai ...baaki sab party toh kisi Layak nahi hai

  • @ThDaniel
    @ThDaniel ปีที่แล้ว +1094

    He is right. Tax payers pay at-least 20% to 30% tax, and from the balance net income we have to pay GST on every purchase.
    Politicians eat this hard earned money, corruption and freebies are looting the tax payer.

    • @HALLvsTON
      @HALLvsTON ปีที่แล้ว +18

      Flat 18% gst on every single purchase is like you are paying additional 4-5 months for govt and remaining one month is for hospitals, travel I.e stuck in traffic and some sleep at night. And year ends..😂

    • @HINDUTVASAVARKAR
      @HINDUTVASAVARKAR ปีที่แล้ว +4

      If you don't pay your basic things will raise because govt has no funds to maintain state national

    • @avi_singhal15december
      @avi_singhal15december ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Bhai subsidies to achcha baat hai
      Hamara paisa hamare paas hi ara hai

    • @Buddha_mgtow
      @Buddha_mgtow ปีที่แล้ว +15

      @@HINDUTVASAVARKAR bhai vo sab politicians ke Swiss Bank me jata ha bas

    • @samueljohn1800
      @samueljohn1800 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      It's 40%

  • @AshishGupta-np3ld
    @AshishGupta-np3ld ปีที่แล้ว +966

    I know there are many accusations on him regarding his work at BharatPe, but what he just said now takes BALLS to do. Massive respect

    • @somitn1218
      @somitn1218 ปีที่แล้ว +10

      You mean Bharatpe?

    • @VOWwwa
      @VOWwwa ปีที่แล้ว +13

      Definitely Balls and no vision from macroeconomics point of view. He of all people should realise that, UPI(no commission on each transaction) was started because of govt funding, otherwise we would still be using payment gateway of VISA(1-5% commission on each transaction), Mastercard(1-5% commission on each transaction), AMEX(1-10% commission on each transaction) etc. And Bharatpe caters to Medium to Small Business whose major consumers are the people who travel in metro/railways, use govt subsidiaries in some form. Even Grofers delivery network was built on delivery riders relying on govt subsidiaries. Startup founders are earning crores because crores of people are using their products which brings funding.

    • @sassproton
      @sassproton ปีที่แล้ว

      You mean G-Pay?

    • @zenjm6496
      @zenjm6496 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @@VOWwwa Let's see how long UPI will be free.

    • @Narendersingh-id5ng
      @Narendersingh-id5ng ปีที่แล้ว +2

      balls apka matlab aand

  • @Tradewithdipesh
    @Tradewithdipesh ปีที่แล้ว +352

    Government should give more benefits for the one who pay more taxes...for eg. Free tolls, concession on fuel, subsidy for children education and medical expenses for the high tax payers

    • @soumyas5576
      @soumyas5576 ปีที่แล้ว +10

      then those benefits will only be given to the upper class rich people,everyone else won't get those benefits

    • @uditraj8290
      @uditraj8290 ปีที่แล้ว +46

      @@soumyas5576 haa to jo Imcome Tax bharega obahi enjoy karega

    • @uditraj8290
      @uditraj8290 ปีที่แล้ว +17

      But bhai Jara socho Yaha Garib Garib ki Rajneeti krne wale kya karenge 😆 😂 phir bolenge Desh bech diya

    • @Tradewithdipesh
      @Tradewithdipesh ปีที่แล้ว +17

      @@soumyas5576 upper class ke paise se baki sabko Jo milta uska kya... upper class India mei sach mei Charity kar raha hai badle mei kya milta usko...kisano ki tarah loan maaf nahi hota unka 😂...ek toh itna income tax dete upar se har cheez pe GST alag se..bachhe ki jaan loge kya

    • @aditsaini5094
      @aditsaini5094 ปีที่แล้ว

      Boht mehanat kro india se bhag jaao. Going to poor African countries. Live there like a king. Fuck taxes

  • @RD-ij2sz
    @RD-ij2sz ปีที่แล้ว +356

    Problem is : Only salaried people have to pay taxes as compulsion . Rich and Poor will evade / avoid / not required to pay taxes. Most businesses and non salaried people pay taxes to the false minimal extent so that they don't get attention of tax authorities .

    • @amazingdude9042
      @amazingdude9042 ปีที่แล้ว +8

      Really ?? I paid 55 lac in taxes last year. Looks like tax evation to you ??. Majority of income tax is paid by higher income people. Get out of your victim mentality.

    • @soumyas5576
      @soumyas5576 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@amazingdude9042 i don't think if u paid 55 lacs in taxes u will be here commenting with a fake account on youtube,stop fooling people,u incel

    • @rowdybadshah8471
      @rowdybadshah8471 ปีที่แล้ว +12

      @@amazingdude9042 lol you do this to everyone 😂

    • @rowdybadshah8471
      @rowdybadshah8471 ปีที่แล้ว +16

      If you have a problem then quit your job run a business.
      Usually people can't bcoz in salaried job you might have work pressure not tension of business failure or loss, you have increments, bonus, allowances, perquisites, Sunday's, public holidays, Paid leaves, business tours, vacations, pension, gratuity, leave encashment, VRS, deduction U/S 16 etc

    • @amazingdude9042
      @amazingdude9042 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@rowdybadshah8471 True. these low wage fkers thinks that every rich person has it easy going and only they are the victims. banchad their small brain can't think anything else.

  • @milanashara
    @milanashara ปีที่แล้ว +972

    Indian Tax is punishment for salaried for not becoming entrepreneur or Starting business or staying in India.

    • @AbhishekSingh-xq5ue
      @AbhishekSingh-xq5ue ปีที่แล้ว +51

      And one more thing for not being corrupted.

    • @debasishpanda7238
      @debasishpanda7238 ปีที่แล้ว +25

      Dogla adani kitna deta hai tax

    • @bdh6754
      @bdh6754 ปีที่แล้ว +8

      Its bigger punishment on those who are truly declaring their income whether its salaried or not. How do you know that all businesses are not paying taxes? If you are business you need GST and when you claim GST, govt already knows. And finally if that business under declares then IT dept is coming. Only those that dont have GST are those that are very small scale ones. So dont blurt blindly that only salaried are screwed. There are salaried people like car drivers, etc. who may not be paying any taxes.
      The comments are related to direct taxes which is what is the main pain point of every direct tax payer and this video and for/against who is and not paying taxes.

    • @risenshine7381
      @risenshine7381 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      ​@@bdh6754 It's not completely true they are paying Indirect taxes to business' so don't say some people don't pay taxes everyone pays tax. Thats how the taxation is created in every country.

    • @haritejanamala4595
      @haritejanamala4595 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@risenshine7381 so everyone has salaried ones also.

  • @sumitkumar-wg7wx
    @sumitkumar-wg7wx ปีที่แล้ว +897

    Ashneer is so right, middle class is fucked up.....

    • @anjanmondal8363
      @anjanmondal8363 ปีที่แล้ว +23

      And govt didn't took tax from rich people a huge amount. Now they are taking it from middle class😢😢

    • @akshitpandey9860
      @akshitpandey9860 ปีที่แล้ว

      @s middle class are the one who pay taxes . Get your facts right

    • @vaibhavthakur9234
      @vaibhavthakur9234 ปีที่แล้ว +16

      @s bhai india mein sab hi apne ko middle class bolte ha . 2lakh per month kamane wala bhi apne ko millde class bolta ha aur 40000 per month wala bhi, aur bhai middle class sirf 250 million ha india mein jo ki 75 percent to bilkul bhi nhi ha.

    • @vaibhavthakur9234
      @vaibhavthakur9234 ปีที่แล้ว +12

      @@anjanmondal8363 rich se tax jab indian govt proporitionate amount lene lagti ha to rich bande citizenship hi change karne lagte ha. Indian middle ko poor banaye jarha ha . rich aur poor dono ko subsidies ha middle class vo subsity pay karti ha

    • @vigilant.
      @vigilant. ปีที่แล้ว

      Abey chutiye jaada tax middle tax bhrta h kyoki population k hisaab se dekh to 2 lakh- 25k per month 50 k month 1 lakh per month vaala bhi apne aap ko middle class hi samajhta h

  • @MrPreet23
    @MrPreet23 ปีที่แล้ว +464

    He is making absolutely sense … You are doing charity for government

    • @abhirb12
      @abhirb12 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      Toh karna kya hai ye bhi toh bata do

    • @MrPreet23
      @MrPreet23 ปีที่แล้ว +16

      @@abhirb12 Ask modi the chaiwala or sit only Raman I meant Nirmala Sitharaman

    • @abhirb12
      @abhirb12 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@MrPreet23 : lanat hai tere humour par.. jab joke karna aata nai toh mehnat kyun kar raha hai chotu..pehle apna 5th std khatam karle phir aa idhar comedy karne..sit raman???? Hat mc

    • @rishiupadhyay5565
      @rishiupadhyay5565 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      Absolutely Non sense He is talking. They wants world class infra for their business and also don't want to pay tax.

    • @MrPreet23
      @MrPreet23 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      @@rishiupadhyay5565 What is the benefit you are getting by paying GST and where is money invested … What about PM modi fund …. If international developed countries are asking for GST they provide free healthcare

  • @SuganthanMadhav
    @SuganthanMadhav ปีที่แล้ว +843

    He is absolutely right. I moved out of India when I paid 8.5L as tax last year with no returns.

    • @erwinsmith5796
      @erwinsmith5796 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      Where are you now ?

    • @amazingdude9042
      @amazingdude9042 ปีที่แล้ว +97

      I paid 55 lax last year. Will still stay in India.

    • @sagarshah6883
      @sagarshah6883 ปีที่แล้ว +44

      ​@@amazingdude9042You guys are changing my intention to be in India and work for India. 🥲

    • @kunal779
      @kunal779 ปีที่แล้ว +61

      @@amazingdude9042 55 lakhs why joking bro what was your total income? what job you do?

    • @हरि_राठौड़
      @हरि_राठौड़ ปีที่แล้ว +208

      @@kunal779 Bhai iske username se lagta hai ki ye 55 lakh tax deta hoga
      phekne ki bhi sima hoti hai😂😂😂😂

  • @flaminmongrel6955
    @flaminmongrel6955 ปีที่แล้ว +68

    He is not even talking about land registration fee in a land where it's already too expensive they charge about 10-20% of the amount in most cases.

  • @LifeGeneralist
    @LifeGeneralist ปีที่แล้ว +565

    He is right.
    Govt should make sure Businessmen pay the right tax (not under-report income) and Farmers earning above certain bracket pay tax

    • @amitkale7197
      @amitkale7197 ปีที่แล้ว +33

      Everyone should pay 20% simple.
      Nothing is free and should never be.
      If anyone wishes to live in this country.. just pay for it in form of taxes.

    • @suhaskamath94
      @suhaskamath94 ปีที่แล้ว +60

      His issue is not with paying tax, other countries have taxes upto 45%, but the talking about the benefits which a taxpayer should get like healthcare, security etc

    • @ashutosh1016
      @ashutosh1016 ปีที่แล้ว +17

      ​@@amitkale7197but truth is everyone isn't paying 20% ...middle class is paying more than 50(indirect incl) and rich class so earn the max doesn't even pay 20%(just ca things ) inequality exist coz the rich class in India doesn't fuc*** car of law (which is also a shit)bas thode paisa khila do ya court me case le jao sbko pta hai budhha sa judge hoga jo sirf tareek deta rhega and saalo saal sirf case chota rhega . foreign countries me hum sirf baki chizo ko dekhte hai ki yeh acha voh acha falana acha but us sbke piche yhi reason hai ki waha law strict hai (corruption toh hr jagah hai ) but still india se toh lakh guna acha hai yaha toh fir tak register na kre .sbko vip ki tarah rhna hai bss (mla mp hi itne hai 500+ kya hi expect kr skte hai ab)

    • @erwinsmith5796
      @erwinsmith5796 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      ​@@ashutosh1016 yr tum hath milao 🤝🤝 ek dum correct baat boli hai

    • @abinavjain3
      @abinavjain3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Bro what? Hamne 3-3 4-4 crore laga rakhe hai tab toh paisa ata hain and full risk and giving employment to so many people directly also indirectly … for business tax should decrease more

  • @ranganathpolur
    @ranganathpolur ปีที่แล้ว +76

    Someone should file PIL on IT Dept. Why everything cannot be on indirect taxes. No Direct tax.

    • @manvendrasingh2243
      @manvendrasingh2243 ปีที่แล้ว +28

      Be that someone

    • @prodig1389
      @prodig1389 ปีที่แล้ว

      Mad..cho..sarkar hn humari

    • @sexyface007
      @sexyface007 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      ​​@@manvendrasingh2243 Bahaya usse Judge ki salary bhi sabke direct taxes se he aati hai. No Govt employee direct or indirectly will ever go against punitive taxes on average people. That's why it doesn't matter which party forms the Govt, as the general public will always suffer through huge taxes.

    • @soumyas5576
      @soumyas5576 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@sexyface007the govt can stop collecting direct taxes from people. I don't know what u are saying

    • @sexyface007
      @sexyface007 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@soumyas5576 do tell everyone what you are claiming and why the Govt has not done it?

  • @rajatsingh3195
    @rajatsingh3195 ปีที่แล้ว +185

    India should adopt mass taxation policy rather than elite taxation policy and lower GST so that upper middle income and middle income population can get some relief

    • @muditydv
      @muditydv ปีที่แล้ว +11

      Everyone already pays GST😂

    • @pruthvirajchavan-patil380
      @pruthvirajchavan-patil380 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@muditydv nahh he is trying to be over edjucated

    • @Edward4Plantagenet
      @Edward4Plantagenet ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Then who will pay Tax?
      Poor or shareholder Rich?

    • @rajatsingh3195
      @rajatsingh3195 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @@muditydv mass taxation policy means income tax payment In China most of the people pays income tax rather than higher GST. Eventually, this increases the demand of Goods and services & leads to economic growth ,people also become responsible towards public properties ,in west people are very responsible towards public property because most of people pays income tax so they have psychology of protecting public property

    • @rajatsingh3195
      @rajatsingh3195 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@Edward4Plantagenet lower middle income should pay 5% of earned income as income tax instead of paying upto 5-18% of gst in so many things Middle class should pay 10-15% upper middle class should pay 15-25% and rich should pay 30-40%
      If rich rich shareholders are earning hefty dividends then they should pay tax accordingly

  • @p4umce
    @p4umce ปีที่แล้ว +117

    This very true especially in our country where you have no free education and health care, paying 30% direct tax and 20% indirect tax in everything+20% cost of living means basically you earning 30% only as savings. But atleast in countries like US, UK, Canada etc.. they provide free world class education and health care. Here the remaining 30% also goes in healthcare, education , housing etc.. basically we have become labourers for these crook politicians.

    • @Seriesnfun
      @Seriesnfun ปีที่แล้ว +21

      Free education and healthcare in US ?? You livin under a rock or something bro??

    • @soumyas5576
      @soumyas5576 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@Seriesnfun India is just a B grade USA

    • @p4umce
      @p4umce ปีที่แล้ว +10

      @@Seriesnfun in US education is not free but very minimal for it's own citizens, which is almost free as per their per capita income. But in Canada? In Germany? In UK? In UK upto 20 yrs even dental claims are free. Bro i am sure i am not living under the rock, but you definitely do.

    • @PRASHANTSHARMA-pz3lw
      @PRASHANTSHARMA-pz3lw ปีที่แล้ว

      ​@@p4umce th-cam.com/video/Kll-yYQwmuM/w-d-xo.html

    • @PRASHANTSHARMA-pz3lw
      @PRASHANTSHARMA-pz3lw ปีที่แล้ว +12

      Us healthcare services is one of the expensive in the world 🌎

  • @thinkbig5936
    @thinkbig5936 ปีที่แล้ว +53

    This is what every corporate employee feels.

  • @PiyushKumar-ru6io
    @PiyushKumar-ru6io ปีที่แล้ว +170

    I think he is just talking about income tax and not taxes on commodities.

    • @nishant9972
      @nishant9972 ปีที่แล้ว +34

      he said about gst at end

    • @DannycageGhostrider
      @DannycageGhostrider ปีที่แล้ว +23

      Agar tax nahin lega to Kumar ko reservation kaise milega? Free ka Mal ghar mein delivery kaise hoga Uske UPSC karne ke bad salary kahan se lega

    • @blastard5539
      @blastard5539 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      ​@@DannycageGhostrider Meeda will be appropriate term😮.

    • @vipint3694
      @vipint3694 ปีที่แล้ว

      ​@@DannycageGhostrider another gobar logic.
      Most of Indian pay tax as indirect taxation

    • @prateektiwari687
      @prateektiwari687 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      He mentioned in start that it is about tax payer

  • @HarshitDaftary
    @HarshitDaftary ปีที่แล้ว +257

    Agree. That’s why people are leaving India. One of the reason of brain drain.

    • @AS936-q3x
      @AS936-q3x ปีที่แล้ว

      Jana bhi chahiye.....deshbhakti jae gadhe ki gaand me.. saale anpadh log humara Paisa khae isliye hum mehnat kare...ye kaha ka rule hai.......jao jakar kisi aur Desh ki growth ke liye mehnat Karo.

    • @HarshitDaftary
      @HarshitDaftary ปีที่แล้ว +56

      @@aadhikaavya Agree but What is the meaning of superpower if majority of citizens are struggling for basic requirements and aren't happy like China.

    • @HarshitDaftary
      @HarshitDaftary ปีที่แล้ว +20

      @@aadhikaavya Correct, we are going with the same approach and that's the reason why we are suffering with brain drain.
      If we keep losing our talent we will continue struggling. We will have to change policies and approaches to hold talent.

    • @AS936-q3x
      @AS936-q3x ปีที่แล้ว

      @@aadhikaavya before concluding just get the reality check and ask yourself is India is going to be superpower in your lifetime considering people around you and the way politics works in India....if you want to live better life go and contribute your efforts to some other countries they either value it or atleast you won't get the feeling your own people fucking your life and enjoying themself on your money they looted via tax...

    • @HarshitDaftary
      @HarshitDaftary ปีที่แล้ว +13

      @@aadhikaavya government heard you. All tax benefits are lost in new tax regime. 😃 seems Ashneer is right that middle class is neither using government school nor hospitals and agricultural loan. Additionally we have to pay GST on everything which is additional tax. There is no motive to pay tax or invest in government schemes like insurance, nps, ppf for working professionals

  • @JaiHind23298
    @JaiHind23298 ปีที่แล้ว +75

    Very well said , govt is looting salary middle class 😡😡😡

    • @suraj0909
      @suraj0909 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Haan bhai sadak और बाकी infra, security, army ये सब तो free me आते होंगे.

    • @RelaxxxMind
      @RelaxxxMind 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      ​@@suraj0909सरकारी कर्मचारियों के वेतन और पेंशन, सरकारी ऋण पर ब्याज भुगतान, सब्सिडी आदि 1% मे ही काम हो जाता है चोमू 🖕बाकी 99% पैसा करप्शन मे ही जाता है‌ तु किसी न किसी सरकारी विभाग से जुडा होगा इसीलिए सरकार की इतनी चाट रहा है
      Salary and pension of government employees, interest payment on government loans, subsidy etc. is done in just 1% Chomu 🖕 the remaining 99% money goes into corruption. You must be connected to some government department, that's why you are licking the government's boots so much.

    • @Harsh427741
      @Harsh427741 6 หลายเดือนก่อน

      ​@@suraj0909 Tu dede sale

    • @modellocomotiveworks2215
      @modellocomotiveworks2215 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

      ​@@suraj0909 जाहिल आदमी पहले जाकर इनकम टैक्स के बारे में जान
      डेटा उठा

    • @modellocomotiveworks2215
      @modellocomotiveworks2215 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      ​@@suraj0909
      कौनसा इंफ्रा कौनसी सड़क
      नए के नए पुल पानी में बह जाते हैं

  • @flaminmongrel6955
    @flaminmongrel6955 ปีที่แล้ว +127

    India is one country where I would support the argument in favour of tax evasion by middle class and even other "thefts" which I see as "reclamation" I don't have the balls to do it but I am happy to hear about it in form of rumours every now and then about some guy doing it.

    • @soumyas5576
      @soumyas5576 ปีที่แล้ว

      lol the services & development done by the govt. is already so low,once everyone evades paying taxes u will get no services & development at all

    • @rowdybadshah8471
      @rowdybadshah8471 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Save as much as you can, anyway only small portion is utilised for betterment of the society, but if caught be ready to face things

    • @flaminmongrel6955
      @flaminmongrel6955 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@rowdybadshah8471 i think everyone is already doing that wherever they can.

    • @sanketsolanki7225
      @sanketsolanki7225 ปีที่แล้ว

      😂😂

  • @MrTech153
    @MrTech153 ปีที่แล้ว +12

    I see a lot of unnecessary debate going on in the comments,
    the problem is not with paying tax
    It's two things
    1. A small percent of the society actually pays tax, poor people don't pay, rich find loop holes
    2. You don't get anything after paying tax, your paying 40% ( indirect + direct) and what do you get in return....nothing.
    Majority of the tax collected is just to stuff the pockets of curropted politicians and civil workers.
    Govt doesn't support you on anything for shit
    Can't get anything done, basic health care, education or even justice
    If you want to get anything done you have to pay bribe, be it in police station, be it court or even something as basic as a passport office, rto office

  • @mayurchavhan8590
    @mayurchavhan8590 ปีที่แล้ว +41

    In Norway, you pay 50% tax but you will get free healthcare, school and other services. In India you'll get broken roads, less security, high petrol tax, expensive healthcare and if some party provides free services to tax paying people they will call "free ki revadi" where politicians gets free discounts on everywhere and gets black and corruption money (tax payers money) for services where pays their salary from our tax.

    • @yuanzim9605
      @yuanzim9605 ปีที่แล้ว

      Revdi deke kejru delli me aur congi Karnataka me AA Gaye.....tumhe khud revdi chahiye Gyan kisko de raha hai

    • @speedawayyspeed9736
      @speedawayyspeed9736 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @@yuanzim9605 Kyu Common public ko kuch accha mil rha hai to hajam nahi ho rha ?? ya phir BJp haar gayi iska dukh hai?? Aur kyu na chahiye revdi sirf tax dete det mar jaaye kya log?? ye politicians corruption scams karte hai tab koi nahi bolta kuch bhi.

    • @SOULCITY1313
      @SOULCITY1313 ปีที่แล้ว

      ​@@yuanzim9605bsdk revdi nhi chaiye tere baap ka mrjayenge ilaj ke psese nhi hooane ke chalte sahi rahega ya Delhi me free me hospital service thik rhega aur bro revdi kya ye basic services government ki zimmedari hoti h

    • @Raut-warrior
      @Raut-warrior 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Bcoz 25% of our population is useless

    • @_wrl_
      @_wrl_ 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Exactly. And politicians have imparted the word "freebies" into public dialogue through WhatsApp and other propaganda mediums. So that people won't ask for any facilities and will give bad words to politicians that do give any facilities.

  • @raghunandanmutalikdesai299
    @raghunandanmutalikdesai299 ปีที่แล้ว +88

    I fully agree with Ashneer ji. Simple statement of facts without sugar coating in the name of Nation building.
    I'm not against paying tax, but it should be equitable to all.
    In a country of 130cr plus population, not even 5% are paying taxes and poor Naukarishuda people are shouldering the burden of entire population when it comes to paying taxes.
    Ideally, there should not be a double whammy for taxation. Salaried people are paying taxes on income as well as in the form of GST on almost everything.
    Why there can't be only one tax, common for all? Let there be no income tax, only consumption tax.

    • @soumyas5576
      @soumyas5576 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      tell that to your favourite modiji

    • @harishkondhalkar1359
      @harishkondhalkar1359 ปีที่แล้ว +9

      @@soumyas5576why ??? Your favourite is Gandhi ji or what? Apake Gandhiji ne failaya huwa 75years ka raita hi yeh jo hum bhugat rahe he..

    • @Edward4Plantagenet
      @Edward4Plantagenet ปีที่แล้ว +3

      सबके लिए एक समान tax, 🤔 LoL
      जो व्यक्ति कमा ही 1-5 लाख रहा है, वो क्या ही IT देगा?
      ~5% (7 करोड़) लोग ही 7 लाख से ऊपर कमा रहे है। 140 करोड़ चमन चूजों को पालना है।
      Infrastructure बनाना है।

    • @soumyas5576
      @soumyas5576 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@harishkondhalkar1359 I don't what you're even talking about & Gandhiji? he's been dead since 1947 so how does that even work lmao,what raita has he spread since 1947? Modi is the pm so obviously he can bring this change,not anybody else,so get a brain

    • @soumyas5576
      @soumyas5576 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@harishkondhalkar1359 Again you haven't said what raita Gandhiji has spread. i think u are talking about the gandhi family,so mention who u are talking about clearly & what raita they have spread which Modi & bjp couldn't solve in 9 years of his rule,also have you forgot the 13 years of BJP Sangh rule from 1990 to 2004? Gandhi family hasn't ruled for 75 years lmao

  • @rrrr3666
    @rrrr3666 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +7

    1:25 On top of this, 60% Seats in Prestigious College are reserved for Categories insted of Merit and on top of that Reserved Candidates get even lowering in Fees, on top of that all these colleges are being funded by our paid Tax.

  • @asaikumar2002
    @asaikumar2002 ปีที่แล้ว +18

    On the top of that, there is no encouragement for personal investments. The 80C is struck at 1.5L. That needs to be increased. BC, school fees for kid alone is 1.5L these days

    • @santoshasinger1
      @santoshasinger1 ปีที่แล้ว

      Wait for couple of years till the new tax regime becomes the only tax regime and 80C is scrapped off.

    • @religionofpeace782
      @religionofpeace782 ปีที่แล้ว

      That's where the problem of middle class is. They marry and bear children. Want to live a life of financial freedom and all sorts of freedom, atleast stop having kids.

  • @SomakesavuluKundooru
    @SomakesavuluKundooru ปีที่แล้ว +30

    Worst is you have to pay extra cess on tax and pay fine if you don’t pay advance tax on time.

    • @erwinsmith5796
      @erwinsmith5796 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Wow 😲 wonderful

    • @Tate525
      @Tate525 ปีที่แล้ว

      Bachpan mai jokes marte abb government tax pe tax maregi, CESS is the realization of that, so much taxes that this country has become living csspool of bureaucracy.

    • @nitinkapoor1369
      @nitinkapoor1369 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@Tate525 cess is on selective commodities most well known eg is car

  • @sameerdureja6126
    @sameerdureja6126 ปีที่แล้ว +34

    He is so right... We get increased CTC but in hand salary is like same as before...we are earning to pay tax only.

  • @abhilashray380
    @abhilashray380 ปีที่แล้ว +19

    This video was edited, before this video starts he said a good point that "the taxes you pay, goes in govt. Hospitals, schools, transports and other govt facilities jo aap waise bhi nhi use karne wale". Which is enough to clarify that specifically the Indian education system should allow an individual to get education for free.

    • @justplay6315
      @justplay6315 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      There is not even a single govt school in our area let alone a choice between private and govt

    • @justarandomguy4844
      @justarandomguy4844 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@justplay6315 i think it depends on where you live. Why would the govt build a govt school in a wealthy locality when it knows no rich guy would send their kids to govt school?
      Dharavi is 5-6 km away from where my school used to be, and there were 2 govt schools located nearby

  • @shariqhasankhan
    @shariqhasankhan ปีที่แล้ว +22

    Bhai baat yeh hai ki jitna tax hum log bharte hain agar us hisaab se suvidha bhi mile to janta ko itna nahi khatkega. Lekin yahan par hum log jitna bhi tax bharte hain jis hi buniyaadi suvidhaoN ke liye woh bahut him kam milta hai.. Aur yeh kisi ek party ya sarkaar ki kami nahi hai...Koi bhi party ya sarkaar ho...jitna tax vasoolte hainus hisaab se koi khaas facilities nahi milti hain
    Roads ki condition dekh lo...aaye din videos aate hain ki falaane sheher mein logo ne apne haatho se hi poori road ukhaad di kyonki itni ghatiya quality ka maal laga tha banaane mein...P
    Jo roads ukhad nahi rahi hain..unmein har 100 metes mein 15 potholes mil jaayenge aur aaye din accidents hote hain..
    Bridges aur flyover collapse hone se dozens ki maut ho jaana ek aisi cheez ho gayi hai jisko sab ne ab lagbhag normal hi maan liya hai.
    Pehle congress ki sarkaar thi tab bhi aaye din road ukhadne aur flyovers/bridges tootne ki khabarein aati rehti thi..
    Education ka standard sabko pata hai..aur Health infrastructure to nil bata sannata hai hi.
    Safety naam ki koi cheez nahi hai..
    Road par nikal jao raat mein ...aadhi se zyada street lights kharaab milengi...
    CCTV camera installation nahi hain main points par ..aur jahan hain wahan aksar kharaab pade rehte hain...
    Again, yeh BJP time mein aisa hi hai aur congress time mein bhi aisa hi tha...aur doosri parties ke time bhi aisa hi hota hai...
    Yeh chirkut neta khud free ke aalishaan sarkaaari bunglow mein rehte hain, electricity ka hazaaro ka bill inka free hota hai, kahin aana jaana ho to gaadi aur pterol free...ji huzuri ke liye 10-20 naukar, chowkidaar, gardener, cook.. sab free... Parliament jaate hain to khaana itna subsidized ki ekdum free samjjho..
    Aur humse kehte hain ki aap log LPG ki subsidiy chod do...

    • @MadaraUchiha-23
      @MadaraUchiha-23 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      aree yrr alas ke chlta tere comment nhi pdha

    • @Jazz-0-7
      @Jazz-0-7 ปีที่แล้ว

      Spot on bhai 💯% agreed

  • @akashbohra6798
    @akashbohra6798 ปีที่แล้ว +8

    Hats off , he is absolutely correct, I wont even talk about other cities, lets talk about Mumbai, being financial capital, there are no proper roads, no metro yet , i cant even travel in local trains or bst buses comfortably , escalators don’t even work , imagine the situation of senior citizens,even the basic transportation sucks , this was the least to expect as a citizen

  • @yahudi7253
    @yahudi7253 ปีที่แล้ว +31

    We need to
    1) stop glorifying poverty
    2) stop having kids, specially if you don't earn much

    • @ST0ICSAGE
      @ST0ICSAGE ปีที่แล้ว +1

      What's there in poverty to glorified about? And people having too much kids are least educated one; good luck talking sense in to them

    • @ShreHar-dz2id
      @ShreHar-dz2id 10 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      ​@@ST0ICSAGEwhat he meant by stop glorifying poverty is stop making people believe that being mediocre I'd OK.

  • @shaffin786
    @shaffin786 ปีที่แล้ว +29

    In return we get ghanta and we always live insecurity and hopeless after retirement

  • @arnab_barman
    @arnab_barman ปีที่แล้ว +162

    Ashwin spitting facts as always

    • @TheBhagwaBoy
      @TheBhagwaBoy ปีที่แล้ว +113

      Ravichandran Ashneer ko khilana tha final mai

    • @anakingaming3687
      @anakingaming3687 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@TheBhagwaBoy 🤣

    • @rameshrnayak
      @rameshrnayak ปีที่แล้ว

      OP has mentioned that Ashwin is spitting facts as always....😂😂😂

    • @sarkataa
      @sarkataa ปีที่แล้ว +6

      That's why he was dropped from playing eleven 😂😂

    • @Jones1236-p
      @Jones1236-p ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Ashneer is a Greedy businessman.

  • @subrojyotidey9081
    @subrojyotidey9081 ปีที่แล้ว +11

    Very well said....he understands our pain.

  • @DesiFunnn
    @DesiFunnn ปีที่แล้ว +3

    As a salaried tax payer, I completely agree to this. 5 months of salary goes to govt in return for nothing.... That's why businessmen find ways to evade taxes. Even if they buy drink beer, they show it as office party expenses on which no income tax is applicable.
    25 lakhs cars are bought every year in India, but according to finance minister, there are only 15 lakh tax payers in India with income above 10 lakhs.

  • @NitinKhandelwal-ng3ut
    @NitinKhandelwal-ng3ut ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Just filed IT return with 13 lakhs tax, no rebate... worst without any return also with lots of loan to pay back...

  • @mngupta2711
    @mngupta2711 ปีที่แล้ว +72

    पैसा सरकार का और शरीर भगवान का ....

    • @sreenivaskampala
      @sreenivaskampala ปีที่แล้ว +1

      😀

    • @atmarampanduranga6719
      @atmarampanduranga6719 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      Tum sirf atma ho vats.

    • @rvind000
      @rvind000 ปีที่แล้ว

      Sharir Dharti maa ne loan diya hai.

    • @hardikparbhakar7845
      @hardikparbhakar7845 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@atmarampanduranga6719 isiliye atma ka tax bhi bharo abse 25% fy 22-23 aur tax return k liye bhi apply karo

    • @RaptorRoyale
      @RaptorRoyale ปีที่แล้ว

      shareer khud ka hota h

  • @UR_spongebob
    @UR_spongebob ปีที่แล้ว +14

    Having a software business moved in UAE,no taxes here although living cost is bit high but extremely safe place,great people and visit India with clean money without tax .....

  • @youtourists
    @youtourists ปีที่แล้ว +15

    Problem is not tax, problem is only 4% people are paying tax to 96% are enjoying. There are many people who earn good but on papers they are BPL

    • @davelawson2564
      @davelawson2564 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      hey mooron. even poor pay gst

    • @knowledge-21234
      @knowledge-21234 ปีที่แล้ว +7

      ​​@@davelawson2564 there are more than 1 lakh farmer earning 1 crore but pay 0 tax why socialism sucs

    • @davelawson2564
      @davelawson2564 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@knowledge-21234 go do farming . nobody stopped you

    • @knowledge-21234
      @knowledge-21234 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      @@davelawson2564 easy bro I am telling you there are many rich people not paying tax, because they will play victim card and will raise khalistani flag over parliament like farm protest

    • @davelawson2564
      @davelawson2564 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@knowledge-21234 stop complaining . if someone is not paying tax by farming , you can do it too.

  • @vickyAlways
    @vickyAlways ปีที่แล้ว +28

    20-30% is income tax rest is Indirect tax on each item we purchase or service we use
    These.are.not taxes but government's OPEN-LOOT
    Bina facilities ke itna tax to kisi bhi Developed countries tak mein nhi lagta hai
    Even savings are TAXED to make politicians RICH & public POOR.

    • @mokshmehta6134
      @mokshmehta6134 ปีที่แล้ว

      True. M bhi commerce student hu, abhi 12th m aya , abhi pata lag raha h sab.
      9/18/27% tax on each item + lund jaisa income tax
      If you earn under 5 lakh per annum no income tax
      Above 10 lakhs 20% income tax
      Above 15 lakhs 30%.
      100 years of life span m se 30 gov par ja raha h.
      Solution ye h, ameer hoke full research krke achhe law wali foreign m chale jao. Bhen ki chut itna tax lete h, kuch development to dikha nhi.
      Ye gov bas IT cells pr dhyan deti h propaganda k liye. India m achhe politicians h hi nhi. Isliye public ko aur UNITE hona chahiye jhagde k bajaye, taaki 4 baat seekhne ko mile ya ek dusre k kaam ajaye life m

    • @vickyAlways
      @vickyAlways ปีที่แล้ว

      @@mokshmehta6134 a taxpayer has to pay taxes from 2.5lakh if u cross above 5 lac had hai 20,833rs se upar ki income se tax dena start kro. Is salary pe single aadmi survive nhi kr pa rha hai aur bhikhmangi sarkar tax loot rhi hai aur neta hr mahine 4-6 lakh ki legal salary le rhe hai aur hazaro free facilities such as each month 15000rs for mobile bill. Is the Govt serious 🪦🪦!!!! Uske baad lifetime pension free multiplied by how many times they won.
      Is sabke baad bhi in bhuke nange netao ka pet nhi bharta croro arbo rs ke scam n corruption krte hai Shamelessly aur ilaj ke liye foreign jaate hai.
      Thu hai aise political system pr jo middle class ko gareeb aur politicians ko super rich bnata hai!!!

    • @vickyAlways
      @vickyAlways ปีที่แล้ว

      @@mokshmehta6134 kaunsa development kiya aajtak kisi bhi sarkar ne?
      School sab private ja rhe hai majbori mein aur wahaan loot machi huyi hai
      Hospital private jana padhte hai
      Clean water ke liye RO lagane padhta hai
      Bijli ke liye inverter
      Police ko ghus deni padhti
      Govt offices mein bina Rishwat diye kaam nhi hota
      Hotel mein khao to tax,
      Ghar mein koi bhi saman repair karwao to usmein bhi tax
      Highway Roads banane se bachne ke liye sarkar ne us pr bhi unlimited TOLL-PLAZA laga diye TAX ke liye
      Koi plot kharido to usmein bhi tax aur use becho to usmein bhi tax aur na becho ghar banao to us par bhi tax
      Koi bhi saman kharido us pr bhi tax
      MEDICINES tax pr 18% tax laga rkha hai
      Iske baad Income pr bhi TAX
      Bachao to usmein bhi tax
      Bank mein dalo to usmein bhi tax
      Stock ya Mutual fund mein lagao to nuksan ho gya to public bhare nuksan pr agar kamai ho gyi to usmein se sarkar ko tax do
      Tax tax TAX!!!!
      Aur is tax se neta khud ko malamal krte hai croro ki properties bna lete hai aur public ko bola jaata hai aur TAX DO.
      Pta nhi government ki is HAFTA-WASOOLI ke liye protests kyu nhi hote hai !!!!!!

    • @vickyAlways
      @vickyAlways ปีที่แล้ว

      @@mokshmehta6134 thoda correct krta hun:
      5-10 lac 20%
      Above 10- 30%

    • @Edward4Plantagenet
      @Edward4Plantagenet ปีที่แล้ว

      @@mokshmehta6134 , अबे चुजे, बस कर।

  • @mallikarjunv5560
    @mallikarjunv5560 7 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Dear Bro, More people from IT back bround needs to talk like this in many forum where Govt. will listen and make the chnages.

  • @godaddy9837
    @godaddy9837 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Don’t forget you have to pay officers too so that your work is done without delay cause if you don’t they are so pety they will make an enemy of you so basically tax is around 50% or even more in some businesses the officers does not care if you are paying tax cause the officer knows he has you by the balls and you can’t do anything to him/her.

  • @proudhindustanihindu2725
    @proudhindustanihindu2725 ปีที่แล้ว +25

    That's why it's said being educated does not means being learned also.....both are much different from each other....this man is a perfect example of this

    • @sarthaksharma4816
      @sarthaksharma4816 ปีที่แล้ว

      Aap samjha do sir phir

    • @Sara97_
      @Sara97_ ปีที่แล้ว

      Difference between business man and a CA

    • @vancedadder
      @vancedadder ปีที่แล้ว

      Hindu bhai aap he samjha do kaha dikh raha hai humara tax ka paisa...election time ke freebies me? Statues aur parliament mai? free education ya healthcare mai? tax returns mai? kaha EXACTLY?

    • @nitinkapoor1369
      @nitinkapoor1369 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@Sara97_ bhai woh ashneer hi aisa hua
      ca toh uske papa bhi hai

    • @RishabJagota
      @RishabJagota ปีที่แล้ว +2

      You literally provided no rebuttal to his point and just attacked him on his educational background

  • @abhishekmoondra7126
    @abhishekmoondra7126 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    Finally a educated person who knows about tax❤❤❤

  • @hiteshsaxena1553
    @hiteshsaxena1553 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Tax rates are much higher in some European countries but there the government does provide good health care, children's education, world class infrastructure e.g. roads, reliable electricity and good quality water, public transport etc.

  • @kunalk.6658
    @kunalk.6658 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    On top of that Govt is doing privatisation so will get no benefit from those sector which has been already became private

    • @speedawayyspeed9736
      @speedawayyspeed9736 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      And the thing is public itself is praising govt to go pvt these fools don`t understand that govt is giving off it`s responsibilities in the name of privatization. Public ko samaj hi nahi hai kisi cheez ki.

  • @Maanav-fv3hk
    @Maanav-fv3hk ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Bruh, It is the dumbest statement anyone could make. Here’s why :
    1. Let’s consider a high net worth individual (A) here. Let’s say his taxable income is 1000 crores . Now,
    • Under the current tax system and slab rates, he will be required to pay roughly around 400crores as taxes. Now, if his personal expenses including GST amount to roughly 100crores, he’ll be left with 500crores as his savings.
    • Now if we consider Ashneer’s proposed tax rate, A will be required to pay ₹200 crores as taxes ( flat 20%). Thus, the disposable income in his hands will INCREASE by a filthy 200crores.
    2. Now, let’s consider a low income individual (B). Let’s say his taxable income comes to ₹1.2 lacs for the entire year. Now,
    • Under the current tax system , he will Not be required to pay any tax since he falls under the Basic exemption limit (BEL). Thus, his tax expense is 0. Now if we consider his personal expenses + GST to be around ₹96000, he will be left with ₹24000 as his savings.
    • Now let’s consider his situation under Ashneer’s proposed system. In that case, he will be required to pay tax at flat 20% since Ashneer mentioned that the flat tax rate should apply to every individual regardless of their income. So, if B pays 20% tax now, he’ll have to pay ₹24000 as taxes only. Leaving him with 0 savings ( 1.2L - 96000(expenses + GST) - 24000(Tax).
    If this will be his situation, how will he survive? How will he take care of his family incase any emergency situation arises? With absolutely 0 savings, how will he sustain himself and if he has kids to take care of, how will he manage ?
    Just getting annoyed by the tax rates and overlooking such critical factual points is complete stupidity. Please open your eyes, use your own head and stop getting influenced by such fame seekers.

    • @RishabJagota
      @RishabJagota ปีที่แล้ว

      Except high networth individuals don't pay taxes majority of direct tax payers are middle class salaried employees and dt is roughly 51% of total govt revenue, this has been said multiple times in parliament and news papers please educate yourself

  • @em_india
    @em_india ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Some political party should declare tax removal for salaried class as freebie, free electricity and water to kisaans and bpl. Just by doing this they will win the coming lok sabha elections in 2024. To compensate for income deficit, increase indirect taxes on luxury goods.

  • @rishabhsharma3908
    @rishabhsharma3908 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Totally agree with him. Indian tax system is so biased against the people who pays.

  • @amitphayde8721
    @amitphayde8721 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Add also properly tax, registration tax,car registration tax,cess and you start wondering why we are working

  • @ayushmishra91
    @ayushmishra91 6 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Literally man my dad is salaried and tax has fucked up the finances really bad.

  • @halcyonskills
    @halcyonskills ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Thinking this only never like to work more. The way he said may be rude but 100% true. We want 20% tax rate for anyone earning.

    • @DannycageGhostrider
      @DannycageGhostrider ปีที่แล้ว

      Income tax should be a state subject. And there should be zero percent income tax

    • @muktapidasingh6697
      @muktapidasingh6697 ปีที่แล้ว

      Presently only 2-3% indians fall under 20% tax rate. No govt can tax other 97% they don't want to lose election

  • @lostlove3392
    @lostlove3392 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Roads, trains, government hospitals, etc are made by this tax. But, yes. Even if you earn less you can get these benefits.

    • @shujahmohammed9173
      @shujahmohammed9173 หลายเดือนก่อน

      We don’t see all this in India. All the tax is being looted by Feku 😂

  • @AndipPoddar
    @AndipPoddar ปีที่แล้ว +8

    Damn ! he has the guts 👍 Massive respect.

  • @Wjwji-82
    @Wjwji-82 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Let's assume we are going to invest. If we make a profit, the government will take capital gains tax. If we incur a loss, the government has already taken income tax.

  • @roopeshmesta456
    @roopeshmesta456 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    He is absolutely right... The reason why young people dnt want to do business is because of the tax and parents encourage them to do government jobs .. kaam karo ya na karo salary toh tum ko Milne hi hai

  • @chan90s
    @chan90s ปีที่แล้ว +7

    He totally ignored the macro-economics. Govt should make from somewhere to pay govt employees and do developmental works.

    • @SuganthanMadhav
      @SuganthanMadhav ปีที่แล้ว

      No he ignored senseless people like you. Have you ever paid tax more than 5L per year? If not, don’t talk

    • @golpokaku
      @golpokaku 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

      What development you found in last 5 years?

    • @divyanshsingh594
      @divyanshsingh594 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

      ​@@golpokaku my area got an expressway which cut my travel time atleast 30 minutes and I get almost 24 hours of electricity now which wasn't case in previous governments and lots of potholes and broken roads have been repaired atleast in my area where I live,for me government of India is developing india and I can see it, but sure it might not be case in your area

  • @dalinsixtus6752
    @dalinsixtus6752 ปีที่แล้ว +72

    Excellent advice,still I know many of you know this and still pretending we are in ' Acche din ' 😅

    • @Aniruddha606
      @Aniruddha606 ปีที่แล้ว +23

      We are paying taxes since 1947.

    • @alanjohn2675
      @alanjohn2675 ปีที่แล้ว +7

      @@Aniruddha606 compare tax rates.. Also inflation also indirect taxes with respect to what we are actually getting.. Also one of the reasons the current gov came in power was the previous mentioned issues now don't resort to whataboutism be an adult

    • @dalinsixtus6752
      @dalinsixtus6752 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      @@Aniruddha606 lol 🤣🤣🤣 Indirectly you are pointing that the present govt did nothing in terms of controlling and managing taxes 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 ' Acche din ke acche vichaar '.Lekin 1 dollar aaj 82 rupees hogaya hai 1947 se compare matth karna 🤣🤣🤣

    • @DannycageGhostrider
      @DannycageGhostrider ปีที่แล้ว +12

      ​@@alanjohn2675 yes compared before GST tax rate and after GST tax rate. During Indira Gandhi's time people used to pay 90% tax. And compare India's tax rates with European countries in India we have less taxes than Europe. Without tax India will become Pakistan. Thanks to GST we do not pay double tax to state government

    • @dalinsixtus6752
      @dalinsixtus6752 ปีที่แล้ว +8

      @@DannycageGhostrider 🤣🤣🤣🤣 0 logic Andbakht 🤣🤣🤣 other European countries are providing facilities like education,healthcare , No GST taxes ...etc for citizens paying taxes not like Indian Govt chanting 'Go corona,corona go' during pandemic. If returns are satisfactory then taxes are good but in India returns are worse from govt

  • @srikantb87
    @srikantb87 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    It's not what Ashneer is saying it's what the people are commenting is the difference. People with money like Ashneer are not happy with paying taxes and the people not so rich middle class who are commenting on this video are happy to pay taxes without even complaining in the name of nation building. Ironically for all infrastructure projects govt pays money to big companies to develop them and still ask people to pay toll and and road tax. And still people don't complain!!

    • @Dheeraj71192
      @Dheeraj71192 ปีที่แล้ว

      that is total loot. nothing will happen apart from complaining here.

  • @Vini-yx5hx
    @Vini-yx5hx ปีที่แล้ว +1

    How to claim back the TDS which is cut in Salaries (Form16) from Gov. ?
    Any Ideas?

  • @srijantanwar3245
    @srijantanwar3245 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    my father told me exact thing but he also said that freedom for using your own money comes with price that is TAX

  • @em_india
    @em_india ปีที่แล้ว +5

    To the honest tax payer there should be some percentage rebate in Road Tax, Toll Tax, Property Stamp Duty etc. Tax dene ka koi to direct benefit hona chaiye.

    • @Tate525
      @Tate525 ปีที่แล้ว

      Hai na contractor ko benefits, aam janta gayi maa chdne.

  • @SumitPal-vn8iq
    @SumitPal-vn8iq ปีที่แล้ว +8

    It's really funny that everyone playing middle class card without even realising income below 5 lac in a financial year is tax exempted, anyone earning 10+lac in a year is not a middle class anymore.
    Apart from that everyone one wants world class infrastructure and other services either free or at a very low cost.
    Lastly it's better not to believe anyone just because they are a part of a billion dollar enterprise.

    • @yuanzim9605
      @yuanzim9605 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Funny thing is that these so called salaried class which mostly work in Bangalore gave vote to Congress because of free revdis that were sponsered by their own tax money.....

    • @sohammehta5216
      @sohammehta5216 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Tax bharne k liye taiyar hu lekin kis world class infrastructure aur services ki bat kar rhe h aap

    • @SumitPal-vn8iq
      @SumitPal-vn8iq ปีที่แล้ว

      @@sohammehta5216 you should open your eyes and look around,highly doubtful that you're a social being, let alone paying taxes

    • @sohammehta5216
      @sohammehta5216 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@SumitPal-vn8iq Medical, Education, Roads koi bhi government controlled service batado jo India ki world class h? Agr acha jawab h toh bina personal attack kiye please enlighten me 🙏 Nahi toh Internet par batameezo k muh lgne ka mujhe koi shauk nahi h

    • @SumitPal-vn8iq
      @SumitPal-vn8iq ปีที่แล้ว

      @@sohammehta5216 sir itna din baad reply kiya kohi sikhake bheja apko?

  • @premansdheevar4410
    @premansdheevar4410 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    Atleast someone thinks and talk about taxpayers pain.

  • @sainishilpa2
    @sainishilpa2 18 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา +1

    Absolutely Right 👍

  • @BadGuy-bb1ut
    @BadGuy-bb1ut ปีที่แล้ว +1

    कोई नहीं कूदेगा, भारतीय को गुलामी की आदत हो गई है 🙏

  • @inspiringmuslim
    @inspiringmuslim ปีที่แล้ว +3

    His honesty and intellect is amazing ❤

  • @Randomcomment7699
    @Randomcomment7699 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    Great video.. tax (30) ( 3 months) + emi - prin + int (40) (4 months) + health , car, education, misc (20) (2 months). === max remaining 3 months ( savings ( mf charges) , drinks, donations….. )
    Repeat until 60
    Then ready for death 😢

  • @SoulPulse-b7b
    @SoulPulse-b7b ปีที่แล้ว +5

    Taxes are everywhere not just in India.

    • @ayushgarg70
      @ayushgarg70 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Public infrastructure and civic amenities are shit in India

    • @SoulPulse-b7b
      @SoulPulse-b7b ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@ayushgarg70 new infra is better but yes shit also has a bill

  • @nehanperwaiz6779
    @nehanperwaiz6779 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Middle class is suffering..no salary hike but gst hike plus income tax hike for salaried workers

  • @infinow
    @infinow ปีที่แล้ว +1

    40% is just direct tax. On the remaining 60% you still have to pay indirect tax which can be upto 28% and on many things there are cess which take indirect tax to 50% and on petrol diesel 100%
    After all direct and indirect taxes you are left with around 45% (assuming you are in the highest tax bracket)

  • @jayeshrathod3099
    @jayeshrathod3099 ปีที่แล้ว +20

    what's your opinion on Ashneer ???
    looking forward for a concrete opinion!!!

    • @MadaraUchiha-23
      @MadaraUchiha-23 ปีที่แล้ว

      bhai chutiya h ye isse kuch nhi pta tax sirf un bndo ka lgta h jinki incom 5 lac per annum se jyada h aur bina tax ke development nhi hoti

    • @utkarsh4798
      @utkarsh4798 ปีที่แล้ว +28

      trying to stay in news,invested heavily to maintain a pr image so that has a lifelong passiveincome by sasying controversial stuff

    • @AIprodmagnet
      @AIprodmagnet ปีที่แล้ว +9

      Street smart and Aggresive capitalist

    • @amitkale7197
      @amitkale7197 ปีที่แล้ว +9

      ​@@AIprodmagnet
      Like it or not.. he is right...❤
      Logics...

    • @Texttalk3794
      @Texttalk3794 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      free ka gyan bhai, aur kuch nahi. same Ashnir will be Kejriwal after election . Tax goes to freebies politics and corruption

  • @dikkibhaddas
    @dikkibhaddas ปีที่แล้ว +13

    Even people who think they are not in tax bracket are paying close to 20%tax indirectly,
    at the same time as they don't pay tax, so the rate of interest at which they will borrow will also be high.
    So directly or indirectly 40% toh jayegahi,😔

    • @muktapidasingh6697
      @muktapidasingh6697 ปีที่แล้ว

      They don't pay 20%. You should also include sasta ration, sasti bijli, other govt schemes for poor and lower segment people. Effectively they pay 0 tax

    • @googLi-mm1id
      @googLi-mm1id ปีที่แล้ว

      ​@@muktapidasingh6697 please learn to use your brain.😂

    • @siddharthbhawsar2557
      @siddharthbhawsar2557 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @Muktapida Singh Bhai problem is not free/subsidized food, houses, etc.
      Now politicians have started paying helicopter money, direct account transfers, anyone living after 10 years will know harmful effect of it. Increased inflation, high fiscal deficit, high taxes and what not.

    • @dikkibhaddas
      @dikkibhaddas ปีที่แล้ว

      @@muktapidasingh6697 Even if they are getting free electricity, 60% of the time there is power cut apart from Delhi.
      They get free education and mid day meal where no teacher comes to school .
      They get free treatment where they are treated like beggar's and even after standing in line for 5hrs they only get to hear come tomorrow
      They get free ration where the rice is so hard it can't be bitten.
      They get free house where the roof starts leaking after 6 months.
      And I can go on and on.
      And even after all that they give indirect taxes because they don't have any choice.

  • @jashagarwal8277
    @jashagarwal8277 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    As a CA aspirant, at some point you can say lowering tax slabs but following Ashneer comment is totally madness, Believe me this will go against the progressive taxation system and now business people will find more lucrative ways to escape the system, who were the original target as said in history of tax

    • @Itsokay12349
      @Itsokay12349 ปีที่แล้ว

      Yehi to dikkat haina bhai middle class ko relief doge to ameer wale bach jyenge unko pakdoge to middle class fasjyega

    • @surjanarayangorai8241
      @surjanarayangorai8241 ปีที่แล้ว

      Bro you are doing CA.. and I am also doing CA CS.. problem is with so much complexion on Direct Tax
      If the Govt says I will take only the GST then I think people will give tax easily.. but the problem arises with double taxation.. one as per IT Act nd another with GST

    • @nitinkapoor1369
      @nitinkapoor1369 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@surjanarayangorai8241 toh bhai inflation toh achi hi hoti hai to extent
      bhai yr tohda economics grp 2 inter ki foundation ki and plus 2 mein pharha hai

    • @surjanarayangorai8241
      @surjanarayangorai8241 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@nitinkapoor1369 yes Inflation is good mai vi bhott padha huu CA mai CS mai

    • @nitinkapoor1369
      @nitinkapoor1369 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@surjanarayangorai8241 toh fir apna point hi contradict kr rha hai

  • @hiteshwarjindal421
    @hiteshwarjindal421 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

    charity companies kr rhi hai salaried employees nahi as their value is the actual take home money !!! not the ctc .. !! company knows how much take home js ur dekand and worth!! and they formulate ctc accordingly!

  • @Mansingh0911
    @Mansingh0911 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    its not for cherity
    its for neta
    if it's for cherity you will be happyily give it

  • @sear6851
    @sear6851 ปีที่แล้ว +8

    Most of our tax money is used to give away free stuff during elections but this had stopped to some extent after 2010 in most states but AAP and parties in South again started revadi culture to defeat BJP and now even BJP has started doing it. Poor people are happy but the country is suffering. Giving away free stuff except foodgrains and necessities should be banned ASAP.

    • @himanshurai2854
      @himanshurai2854 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Completely agree with you. I am a bjp supporter but I am tired of free revdi culture. Even BJP is doing this.

    • @speedawayyspeed9736
      @speedawayyspeed9736 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@himanshurai2854 You people are just against common public getting any basic facilities taht`s it. When honest Tax payers money is looted in the form of multiple scams going into the pocket of politicians be it of any party then it is fine ... That dosen`t cause suffering to this country right?? When banks waive off or write off the loans in lakhs crores then it is fine then country won`t suffer but only when someone gets a Meagre releief or say in return by govt then it is problem then it will take us to stone age. Go and see how much common public gets in return from govt in other countries the thing which you are calling freebies these are basic necessities and every govt in form of reward gives their citizen back that`s how it goes.

  • @piyushsharma6607
    @piyushsharma6607 ปีที่แล้ว +11

    Hume kya hum toh nil tax bracket mein aate hai

    • @akshaytakkar6747
      @akshaytakkar6747 ปีที่แล้ว

      Tumhare jaiso ke liye hi hum jaiso ko tax bharna padta hai

    • @dalinsixtus6752
      @dalinsixtus6752 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Gareeb log ke gareeb vichaar 😅😅😅 Tabh bhi shops,petrol, accesories mein bhi GST kat tha hai uska kya mere bhai 😂😂😂

  • @southpaw1122
    @southpaw1122 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    At some point even US had taxes like this. India is a developing country. And it depends on people who are able to earn to help others to be able to earn by providing subsidized education and infrastructure.

  • @Trytobebetter-gq3ge
    @Trytobebetter-gq3ge ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Ha sir taxes bohat hai
    Income tax+ IGST + netaji ke honeymoon ka bill + government employees ki galiyan +no good roads

  • @SumitKumar-by2kh
    @SumitKumar-by2kh ปีที่แล้ว +1

    most absurd is capital gain tax.......you earn profit u give tax to govt...u bear loss...govt has nothing to do with yr losses!

  • @Texttalk3794
    @Texttalk3794 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    same Ashnir will be Kejriwal after election . Tax goes to freebies politics and corruption

    • @dalinsixtus6752
      @dalinsixtus6752 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      Still better than Present Indian govt , ' Fools filled ministry '

    • @Texttalk3794
      @Texttalk3794 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      @@dalinsixtus6752 any logic or "just a hater statement ? "

    • @dalinsixtus6752
      @dalinsixtus6752 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@Texttalk3794 logical men can understand it in a single read 🤣🤣🤣 do visit dehli govt schools and hospitals , freebies like electricity to public is far better than buliding temples and statues

    • @muktapidasingh6697
      @muktapidasingh6697 ปีที่แล้ว

      ​@@dalinsixtus6752 temples are not building from tax payers money

    • @Texttalk3794
      @Texttalk3794 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      If you use your brain you can understand, Freebies are political agenda, to win next election. That makes people lazy and society suffer. Temple are required for the spiritual well-being of the society. If you enjoy freebies, why are you crying in other comments you mentioned. Is there a reason you hate temple ? And, yes Fools laugh without any reason.

  • @PiyushKumar-y6i
    @PiyushKumar-y6i ปีที่แล้ว +3

    I would say if everyone is paying tax for at least 10℅, then it would be a greater tax collection than that of 10℅ middle class who only pay taxes

  • @SP-sf4pv
    @SP-sf4pv ปีที่แล้ว +3

    The problem of high tax will reduce by implementing proper tax collection and distribution system. Many people in india currently do not pay tax by leagal or illegal means which is the problem.
    People in comments suggesting govt to give special benefits to tax payers which may sound fascinating but that will increase the burden on govt. That burden will be transferred either to the poor or the same tax payers by some other way. In a country like india outright tax relaxation is not possible for now but the system needs some reforms which should be discussed and demanded. This may give us some relief.
    Ab rahi baat charity ki, social responsibility bhi kuch hota hai. Waise hi india me itni inequality hai aur ye ashneer ji jaise baat kar rahe hai ye seedha tax payers ko non tax payers ke khilaf bhadkana hai. Agar problem hai to proper solution ki baat karo aise baith ke comment karne se kuch nahi hoga.

  • @anisurfer84
    @anisurfer84 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    No wonder younger generation doesn't want to work 9-5 private jobs. Salaried class should push for reservation and special benefits in education, health, water, groceries, electricity, transport and even entertainment. We are paying effectively 37% tax, we should get the appropriate benefits.

  • @angshukNag
    @angshukNag ปีที่แล้ว +1

    The tax that we pay is consumed by people who don't pay tax (Mostly by corrupt politicians and whatever is left after that, by non taxpayers). That is I think the primary reason why it is a punishment. We don't get anything fruitful in return since the number of people not paying tax vastly outnumbers the number of people paying.

  • @sangramkale3243
    @sangramkale3243 ปีที่แล้ว +10

    If citizens don't want to pay taxes then how the government would function? You can complain about the bad quality of services that the government provides . Taxation is the only way government get money to function and that is very basic economics. It's surprising that the brilliant businessman like Ashneer Grover has such a mediocre notion that taxes are bad.

    • @benutomar
      @benutomar ปีที่แล้ว

      Watch his entire interview... He has given an brilliant solution too....

    • @benutomar
      @benutomar ปีที่แล้ว

      th-cam.com/video/kLwHHwEOC08/w-d-xo.html

    • @lion_0077
      @lion_0077 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Bhai ho isliye ki vah tax chori mein uske upar case chal raha hai aur uske company walon ne bhi uske per kese thok diya hai, company mein gadbadi karne ka... Isliye vah government per apne frustration Nikal Raha hai...
      Aap per yah bat bhi Satya hai ki India mein bahut kam log hi tax date hai or vah logo ke upar hai jyada boj badta jaraha hai..😭😭😭

    • @lion_0077
      @lion_0077 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@benutomar watch it,it is not practical at all, in ground reality Indian 90% people not give any tex to government, only 2 to 5%
      person give tax, that's why it is not practical....

    • @SuganthanMadhav
      @SuganthanMadhav ปีที่แล้ว

      Then forfeit the voting rights of non tax payers, they decide the government and then we need to fund the government?

  • @CrimsonShadow304
    @CrimsonShadow304 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    biggest reason why I want to leave this country asap

  • @0mmm
    @0mmm ปีที่แล้ว +1

    definitely true , in Europe tax might be high but atleast they get medical insurance good education for everyone, in India we pay tax still we will never these facilities

  • @anonymous-ze5fg
    @anonymous-ze5fg ปีที่แล้ว +1

    This is called "Mann ki baath", absolutely he is speaking the truth.

  • @sujitchorge
    @sujitchorge ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Now time comes ashneer want to go in to politics.
    He will change tax to no taxation at all.

    • @awisin871
      @awisin871 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      Tax were suppose to give some facilities to taxpayers as well,in India taxpayers on contrary punished as there is no one to save them from education fee and medical terrorism. Once they fall for whatever reason,his family fall straight into poverty

    • @alanjohn2675
      @alanjohn2675 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      corporate taxes have been consistently decreasing over years and none of these corporates pass on these savings to their employees i.e the middle class. While the taxes levied on middle class is increasing every year see the trend? The middle class doesn't avail public healthcare, school etc etc because either they're sh*t or too overcrowded so they have to spend a part of their income on these services too (where private sector hits them hard with their inflated prices). The salary hikes doesn't correspond with the 'actual inflation' in our economy, because of the fudging to hide the real inflation. In the end the middle class is left with miniscule saving one can have without any real policies to look out for them.

  • @adityatomar8287
    @adityatomar8287 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Its taking a very small view of things. We pay taxes and thats the reason we have roads, metros, security. Etc. Govt is working and it helps in bringing investments etc. Which help people in getting jobs. Favourable investments conditions are provided by govt. Imagine a situation like syria. Do you think we will have better life then.

    • @mjacobim
      @mjacobim ปีที่แล้ว

      You can also imagine about Europe, America etc.

  • @amankanwar3244
    @amankanwar3244 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Guys don't fall for this
    The only problem in India is buisnessman like him does'nt need to pay tax and all burden of tax falls on middle class families. And he is asking what does government provides to tax payers here I'm listing some :
    1) from where does the money come to buy defense equipments and pay army personnels.
    2) ISRO is government space agency and we all know what it does and also from where it receives funds.
    3) there is law,order and administration , from where does the come to fund it . ITS ALL TAXPAYERS MONEY.
    There are many more , just ask yourself first before agreeing to what he says .
    Taxpaying is an old system which was buid to run a nation or kingdom and it has survived the test of time.
    There are taxes in every country, yeah i know many will give me example of dubai here where there is no tax but dubai has its own way of collecting money that is through fines, very huge fines.
    The only problem in India is that buisnessman like this fellow has found loopholes in the system by which they save themselves to pay taxes. Government should make incentives of collecting money from these kind of people who have money to buy all kind of luxuries but not to pay tax.
    Now many will say my money my wish, yeah thats correct but we are also a human society and we have are duties towards society.
    Many will also say that there are corrupt politicians who take taxpayers money but not paying taxes is not a solution this problem. We need to find a different solution to that. We have to learn from other countries where corruption is low and how they achieved it.

    • @singh_lki
      @singh_lki ปีที่แล้ว +1

      rightly said brother

  • @yousufbaig821
    @yousufbaig821 ปีที่แล้ว

    Saare hard working salaried Indians ki dil ki baat kehdi Ashneer ne. I would love to meet you once bro!

  • @hemrajshaqawal4188
    @hemrajshaqawal4188 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Very well said, let's come together, raise our concern in all social platform. It's a really Punative tax system. Also this a one of the big reasone behing brain dranage from india as all employee got nothing after paying so much of tax.☹️

  • @it_012aniketgondane8
    @it_012aniketgondane8 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Sarkar ko koshna toh tik hai par India ki bahut badi population jo tax bracket ke andar kamate hai wo bhi tax nhi bharte yahan koi bhi dhoodh ka dhula nhi hai 😂😂

  • @AmirNasir
    @AmirNasir ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Ashneer bhai ED k liye biyani bnwa k taiyyar rho.

  • @Anmol4824
    @Anmol4824 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    He is absolutely right. Middle class is shrinking and lot of tax burden is only on white collar workers.
    govt. need to broad the income tax base.

  • @justarandomguy4844
    @justarandomguy4844 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I know what he said is completely right, Indian taxpayers dont get even 0.001% in return for what they pay. But I wish, instead of crying or complaining about the high taxes, someone would stand up and give a practical solution to reduce the burden on middle class and widen the tax base
    Everyone is criticizing the tax system and how unfair it is, but not one person has given us a way to get out of it. Instead of complaining about the problem, finding an alternative solution should be our aim
    Like I think that one way to reduce the tax burden would be to start taxing political parties and farmers earning above 20-25LPA. Even if a standard amount of 10,000 is collected from these farmers and political parties, tax revenue would increase by hundreds of crores at least.
    But ofc, it's not a realistic solution because these kind of exemptions ensure votebank. Plus, farmers would riot on the streets if they are taxed (we saw what happened with the new farm bill)

  • @dindian5823
    @dindian5823 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Problem is tax terrorism
    Has any crime branch asked government officers how they can afford to educate their children abroad or go on joy rides abroad when a small msme guy is getting his hands dirty all his life and still can't build himself a house

  • @nityanandbhardwaj8991
    @nityanandbhardwaj8991 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Whatever he has said about tax of india, these all things rajeev dixit has explained very well. Indian tax senerio makes thief to Indian people. This tax rule came from British government ,that time Indian politicians had shown dream to indian people to make good country but due to bad luck no one politician could change tax policy. Every government keep on following same theory of tax .when governments are asked they give reply ,we are developing country so we need to collect more revenue which comes from tax .