Expert Clarke that said on numerous occasions that Russia was running out of ammunition and the spring 2023 failed counter offensive would be a great success.
In 2022 the comments were: Clarke is so great he should have his own show. Now the comments are: that guy had it all wrong how dares he open his gutter again?
USA here. I have been to GB many times and it is obvious Russian bots are all over Sky News. The average Brit I have met is reasonable and supports Ukraine. Happy holidays across the pond.
14 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา +44
Really im from the uk anx dont know anyone who supports them, all i ever here is we have plenty of aid for ukraine bit our own country is falling apart, as for michael clarke he hasnt got one thing right since this started
Cheers harley - ignore the bots below - my conversations in the pub confirm your view. The majority of the UK citizens I meet are fully behind Ukraine and against the Kremlin Mafia State
Did not even touch the fact Russia is capturing hundreds of km squared every month and more and more every month. Pokrovsk is now basically cut off and Ukrainians running out of men and the need of 18 year olds . Such bias it’s crazy 😊
@@JA-gz6cjNo side is winning. Sure, Russia is “winning” on the ground but the whole situation is awful for them. Ukraine on the other hand is being sacrificed by the West. At least Russia is “somewhat” self-sufficient, Ukraine’s future looks bleak.
@@mtolive2-y2s let’s be honest it did no damage, we all know Russia had ballistic missiles so the effect of that missile had no effect on the battle field actually 0 effect in the battle field
@rytiskurcinskas7179 I don't believe the US and NATO would be unwise enough to accept Putin's proposal for a technological military duel against the Oreshnik missile.!
Anybody who points out to the ridicolous predictions Clarke produced since 2022 is a BOT. If British troops were dying this war would end in a week. Who cares when Ukraimians are dying in thousands. Clarke, Johnson and Starmer should come and fight.
Washington post reported that no long range missiles left with any western countries and no industrial capacity to make the same.Planning to outsource from china 😂
@@burns281981 ‘its’ is a possessive pronoun and is acceptable to use that way in a sentence just as ‘sure are’ isn’t grammatically great but acceptable.
@burns281981 that's a pathetic attempt, mate😂. Even if I was a bot. It doesn't change the fact that Ukriane controls 480 km2 in kursk, from 1200 claimed. So that's above 60% loss.
There is no positive spin for either side . But what is fact is that putin started this mess thinking it was going to be another crimea take over and both nations have suffered
@@mikedon5205who cares if the nation suffered? At the end of WW2, the soviets suffered the most casualties and yet they had the largest most powerful army in europe. Did it cause population to disasterously drop 60 years after the war? Yes it did because some generations had lost 80% of their men. According to Ukrainian sources, Russia's fighting forces in Ukraine numbered 670K at the start of 2024. Now they estimate them at 700K. Despite taking heavy losses, they are replacing their troops faster than the Ukrainians can kill them. At this rate, once Ukraine (who is the most battle hardened and experience army in Europe) falls, the rest of Europe will be in serious danger from an even larger, even more militarized, even more battle experienced, Russia army that will have Ukrainian prisoners and forced conscripts as part of their ranks, along with potentially the North Koreans, Iranians, and Chinese.
@mikedon5205 NATO have failed with their Project Ukraine. But it's basically a military industrial complex funding club so at least the order books are full.
I can't think of any mistakes that Putin made, except invading, tanking the Russian economy and getting tens of thousands of his own people killed every few months.
They have a war economy which is an unfolding disaster. Look at their interest rates and inflation. Look at their GDP and how much they spend daily on the war. Sanctions are strangling their economy and it’s getting worse every month.
It's common for war time economise do well cause of the amount of spending short term. Give it year and the russian economy will over heat. It's getting very warm now and the government is struggling to keep a lid on it 💣
incorrect, Russian economy is being falsely supported by a "war economy" propelled by government spending and which now accounts for 30% of the entire GDP. This can't be sustained. Inflation is now rapidly growing and will soon spiral out of control. War economies cannot sustain real economies as they are not market driven but driven by government expenditure. Hence any perceived growth is not actually real growth.
who’s we? America doesn’t even love themselves dealing with the immigrants and homelessness issues so wtf makes u think they care about some struggling country if they can’t care for themselves? 😂
Siberia Airlines Flight 1812 Siberia Airlines Flight 1812 was a commercial flight shot down by the Ukrainian Air Force over the Black Sea on 4 October 2001, en route from Tel Aviv, Israel, to Novosibirsk, Russia.
@@maryginger4877 Even Putin claimed an S-200 missile could not have possibly shot down flight 1812. In Putin's own words, Ukraine did not shoot down flight 1812.
Yes? Ukraine is 1000 days into a war that Russia hoped would be over long ago and Ukraine is still independent. Russia has lost thousands of men and equipment and gained destroyed villages
@@peterharma8937and that's why Ukraine retreats everywhere at the fastest pace in 2 years 😂😂😂😂😂. Dude: talking to your pal at the pantry on Monday morning and talking to anyone else are 2 different games
Michael Clarke is total the wrong person to provide an objective assessment. Ukraine is loosing and a cease fire is irrelevant. A final agreement is needed not a ceasefire..
Yes alot of this propaganda comming out of ukraine , talking about how great there doing is really not helping. I actually think it is making things worse. Does anyone else think ukraine entering kursk was one of there biggest mistakes? It seems like alot of ukraines best trained and well equipped troops with some of the better western equipment are tied up in kursk and the russians don't seem overly worried about taking it back anytime soon, apart from throwing a couple hundred north Korean troops at it.
Russia is not a “great power” with a GDP of around 2000 billion US dollars. That is about 1/10th of the combined GDP of the EU-27 (about 20 000 billion US dollars), or approximately the same size as the Nordic countries combined. The size of the US economy is about 27 000 billion US dollars or more than 13 times the Russian economy. Compared to other BRIC countries, Russia is behind Brazil (2200 billion US dollars), distanced with some margin by India (3600 billion US dollars), and only around 10 percent of the Chinese economy (17 800 billion US dollars). The outcome of the war is not in Russias hands.
The GDP of Russia for 2020 is: $1.47 T The total GDP of NATO members plus the new members of Sweden and Finland is approximately $40.9 trillion (2020). The total GDP of NATO members plus the new members Sweden and Finland plus Japan, South Korea, Australia and New Zealand is approximately $47.5 trillion (2020), 30 times the Russian GDP. Russia is an economic dwarf compared to Europe, compared to the USA and obviously compared to NATO.
@@Pironi28 BRICS have zero economic integration. Taking them as a collective isn’t useful in any way. India will never ally with China as an example. Russia alone is economically weak.
This so called expert kind of reminds me of experts claiming Biden to be as wise and sharp as ever. Either he’s clueless or assuming that audience is clueless. Perhaps both
The people who think Russia is in a great position ignore the the casualties, ignore the desperate supply lines from Iran, China, and North Korea, and ignore the army of poor, desperate fools from around the world who they recruit with empty promises.
People who think Ukraine is in a good position ignore the enormous casualties, the lack of munitions, the dwindling donations from other countries and the failure of the recent mobilization attempt.
Russia’s military recruitment has been increasing for 3 years and is at its highest level. If a cease fire is negotiated it will be heavily in favour of Russia at this point or they will likely keep fighting as they take more land everyday. It may be sad but the truth hurts some times.
Yep Ukraine is winning, millions living in exile, millions dead, a fifth of the territory now in Russian hands, a destroyed economy, yep they’re doing fine !!
Ukraine war remain me of the Iraq invasion by US under false justification, Russia at least has a point in not wanting NATO (US) bases on its borders. In a hypothetical situation what would US do if China or Russia start building bases on its borders? Remember the Cuban missile crisis?
@alexandrkolodiychuk6583 your assessment cannot be dented. But. Fact remains. Russia has badly mauled Ukraine. The length and breath of Ukraine has been bombarded. Half the nation is without electricity and water supply
Who broke first the Budapest memorandum? RuSSia. After that, Minsk shouldn't exist. Also, agreements pointed with a gun never should happen. That was the Minsk agreement dh
Treaties broken by Russia 1. Budapest Memorandum (1994) - Violated (Annexation of Crimea) 2. Treaty of friendship with Ukraine (1997) - Violated (Annexation of Crimea, war in Donbass) 3. Minsk Agreements (2014-2015) - Violated (Continued support to the separatists in Ukraine)
@@YouTalkingBolox7949 how that happened? US hasn't expanded at all. Also, all the countries have the right to have any allies they want. Who is russia to define who is your friend?
What is this, a year end review for a war series on netlix? These ”analysts” and ”experts” are still not taking this seriously, i dont see them pushing for expanding military facilities, recruitment, training, going to the gun ranges. All the talk about ”preparing” yet no action taken at any point.
Austria had a kind neutral status as Finland, which is long overdue and which is used to hide behind. They are not in Nato, if I remember correctly, so they don’t count when talking about mischief in Nato.
Ukraine has suffered massive casualties and is dragging people out of cars and sending them to the front. Ukraine is short of everything from small arms, artillery, ammo and vehicles. Russia on the otherhand has 35,000 men volunteering a month, has no shortage of equipment, has a massive 10-1 firepower advantage and thats without the 5-1 drones advantage, 1500 FAB glide bombs a month and missiles. Yet they have suffered more losses and are losing, but advancing along almost the entire front? Someone is telling untruths?
They're not even Russian or trolls. Just modern day snowflakes. Thankfully the people in the past had more balls are we'd be sure sprechen ze duetsche right now
NATO will step up patrols in the Baltic Sea region as Finnish investigators work to investigate whether a Russia-linked ship sabotaged undersea cables there this week, the alliance's boss has said. I wonder why they did nothing after Nord Stream got blown up? 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Professor doom Michael Michael Clark, not one single analysis went his way, from leopard game changers to Himars to its a stalemate n Russia is out of missiles n Russia is bleeding out, 😂
So Michael Clarke's map summary of 2024 only shows the extent of Russian gains up to.. August? - Conveniently omitting the significant advances made in the past 4 months, with key Donbas city in Pokrovsk on the brink of capture.. at least tell the truth! For more neutral and accurate daily updated mapping of the war, see DPA: th-cam.com/video/LDTm7FZXQ4I/w-d-xo.html
@@chrisrishermn it's not concerning that people can hold a variety of opinions nor is it that they have the freedom to express them. It's concerning that we still have people trying to police what other say under the threat of being tarred and labelled as X Y or bot.
Yep, plus that they cannot replenish their losses of their tanks, vehicles, ships, planes back to the good old days. And the west is still providing Ukraine daily.
Expert Clarke that said on numerous occasions that Russia was running out of ammunition and the spring 2023 failed counter offensive would be a great success.
why ask for troops and ammunition from N Korea then?
@@rui569why supply Ukraine with weapons, a Foreign Legion, funding, training, intel, etc? Surely, the Ukrainians are "winning"......right?
Yes, and he was right. That's why Russian casualties are much higher than Ukraine's. They keep sending unarmed teenagers and convicts to the front.
@@rui569 Why assume Russia would fight alone against entire NATO backed army then?
@@cks7709😂
He said thousand have been killed, more like hundreds of thousands
This professor do more propaganda than explain what really goes on🤣
Facts
@@Cryptid71 propaganda, fact loses in war
can‘t see and hear propaganda here. listen and watch befor writing
Still fooling the fools.
The expert analysis.. Misguiding the public for the last 3 years 🤡
True, proper gandalf
Spot on mate well said
Couldn't be more wrong, bot.
@@thegamingmastermind2200 and yet the English in the comments have been saying he delivers with such command even though content is BS.
😂😂😂
In 2022 the comments were: Clarke is so great he should have his own show. Now the comments are: that guy had it all wrong how dares he open his gutter again?
From showels and old tanks from museums to Oresnik missiles. Pretty good evolution one must admit.
Another common copy and paste from the bots.
Yes, indeed, in parallel with the transition from T90 M tanks to electric scooters, golf carts, passenger cars, motorcycles and bicycles.
One mustn’t agree with such silly prepositions.
@@peterharma8937 fighting a war in golf carts is borderline comedic.
Exactly! Just like the transformation of Russian ships into submarines in the Black Sea. LOL!
Giving Ukraine everything it needs to win this war and Ukrainian integration into NATO and the EU is the west’s best self defense.
the "military expert" refused to show an updated map of this war. He offered a small sample of territory gained by Russia back in August.
Military Summary, Weeb Union or DPA
U do realise thats sky new themslves that make it not mike?
Last year the russians have gained only 1% more of the land of Ucraine. From 16% to 17%!
Show us a map of Kursk too, comrade. & Syria.
Why is Putin so afraid of NATO?
Professor Clarke deserves Ukrainian citizenship
A lot of propaganda .
😂 says Ivan bot
So the reality suddenly is propaganda?
Defund the war
Russian bots finally realizing Russia lost this war?
From those famous lefties.... Sky News??
Good review by Professor Michael Clarke, who is a prominent expert, regarding the war between Ukraine and Russia.
Sarcasm ?
@@Muirton66 No, reality.
@@peterharma8937 Ah OK, I presumed it was sarcasm .
Clarke a propaganda stooge. Sky a propaganda outlet
Name a single of his previous predictions on the war that come to be true.
A look back at the war in Ukraine 2024 😂😂. Seriously what is wrong with these people.
USA here. I have been to GB many times and it is obvious Russian bots are all over Sky News. The average Brit I have met is reasonable and supports Ukraine. Happy holidays across the pond.
Really im from the uk anx dont know anyone who supports them, all i ever here is we have plenty of aid for ukraine bit our own country is falling apart, as for michael clarke he hasnt got one thing right since this started
Found the bot
@@juliuskresnik198ha ha😂
I'm, and, don't, hear, but, hasn't. Get some education.
Cheers harley - ignore the bots below - my conversations in the pub confirm your view. The majority of the UK citizens I meet are fully behind Ukraine and against the Kremlin Mafia State
Did not even touch the fact Russia is capturing hundreds of km squared every month and more and more every month. Pokrovsk is now basically cut off and Ukrainians running out of men and the need of 18 year olds . Such bias it’s crazy 😊
Because Ukraine is 600,000 km2
@@kcccc5682 Not for much longer, the entire eastern front is collapsoing except Siversk
@@maryginger4877 Yeh , they said that 2 years ago.
Now Ukraine has invaded Russia.
Russia is losing 50 troops per sq.km that they capture.
They still have a long way to go.
So per this old man, Ukraine is winning.
Correct
Yeah I don't think anyone takes what he says seriously anymore, Sky just wanna say they have an expert giving the exclusive in-depth analysis
If Ukraine loses all four oblasts, drastically reduces its army and sign neutrality; MSM will still find a way to call it a win.
they are
@@JA-gz6cjNo side is winning. Sure, Russia is “winning” on the ground but the whole situation is awful for them. Ukraine on the other hand is being sacrificed by the West. At least Russia is “somewhat” self-sufficient, Ukraine’s future looks bleak.
i see prof clarke, i smash like button
Same. He's really good and the Russian bots seem to have it out for him. Anybody Russian bots hate, is automatically cool in my book. LOL
The full story of the Russo-Ukraine conflict in 2024 cannot be told without mentioning Russia's ORESHNIK missile.
@@mtolive2-y2s let’s be honest it did no damage, we all know Russia had ballistic missiles so the effect of that missile had no effect on the battle field actually 0 effect in the battle field
@rytiskurcinskas7179 I don't believe the US and NATO would be unwise enough to accept Putin's proposal for a technological military duel against the Oreshnik missile.!
It carried no warhead.
what "oreshniků, the litlle old thing?
LOL! It's not a technological breakthrough of any sort nor did it change the war at all.
So many Rusbots trying to discredit Clarke shows that he's on the right track.
Dear oh dear
@@ProcaviaCapensis-ts8ub cope harder Ukrobot
That statement is either hilarious sarcasm or gross ignorance. I can’t tell which it is!
🎯
Anybody who points out to the ridicolous predictions Clarke produced since 2022 is a BOT.
If British troops were dying this war would end in a week.
Who cares when Ukraimians are dying in thousands.
Clarke, Johnson and Starmer should come and fight.
Washington post reported that no long range missiles left with any western countries and no industrial capacity to make the same.Planning to outsource from china 😂
😂😂😂😂😂
The North Korean Troops in Kursk is a lot like Ukrainian Democracy. Everybody talks about it but we've never actually seen it
Ghosts from Pyongyiang.
North Korean troops are turning into red vapor sadly.
Denial, denial…
Zelensky now polling at 11%
Collecting Norc POWs now 😊
Ukriane lost 60% of its kursk territory not 40%
"Its kursk" region goes to show a lack of English skills. Bots sure are dominating the comments on this video.
@@burns281981 ‘its’ is a possessive pronoun and is acceptable to use that way in a sentence just as ‘sure are’ isn’t grammatically great but acceptable.
@@burns281981 Hail! Bot334 from Brazil checking in... LOL
They took 100% of it first.
@burns281981 that's a pathetic attempt, mate😂. Even if I was a bot. It doesn't change the fact that Ukriane controls 480 km2 in kursk, from 1200 claimed. So that's above 60% loss.
Clarke is the best analyst on Television. Ignore Russian commentary on here!
To be totally honest about it he must be one of the worst, he appears clueless at times.
He couldn't analyse a cup of coffee ya whopper.
Don't ignore your quality Russian commentary replies
He's old drunk that can't go 2 sentences without telling a lie.
Try harder dude.
Here's comes the positive spin!
There is no positive spin for either side .
But what is fact is that putin started this mess thinking it was going to be another crimea take over and both nations have suffered
@@mikedon5205who cares if the nation suffered? At the end of WW2, the soviets suffered the most casualties and yet they had the largest most powerful army in europe. Did it cause population to disasterously drop 60 years after the war? Yes it did because some generations had lost 80% of their men.
According to Ukrainian sources, Russia's fighting forces in Ukraine numbered 670K at the start of 2024. Now they estimate them at 700K.
Despite taking heavy losses, they are replacing their troops faster than the Ukrainians can kill them.
At this rate, once Ukraine (who is the most battle hardened and experience army in Europe) falls, the rest of Europe will be in serious danger from an even larger, even more militarized, even more battle experienced, Russia army that will have Ukrainian prisoners and forced conscripts as part of their ranks, along with potentially the North Koreans, Iranians, and Chinese.
@mikedon5205 NATO have failed with their Project Ukraine. But it's basically a military industrial complex funding club so at least the order books are full.
Russia is retreating forward and Ukraine is advancing backwards 😂
😂😂 💯
At this rate, Putin may take Kyiv by the time he's 100 years old.
😂
😂
I lose a brain cell every time I see this or "3 day operation" line..
Catastrophic for Ukraine, Kursk incursion being the highlight of Nato-guided folly.
Highlight? Ukraine has had 45k casualties in Kursk since Aug 6th. Hardly a highlight
@@mickser101 highlighted catastrophe.
I can't think of any mistakes that Putin made, except invading, tanking the Russian economy and getting tens of thousands of his own people killed every few months.
North Koreans are too strong.
The zelensky like Hitler sent his best SF his best tanks and armour to kursk....
The zelensky like Adolf...
It Has Faild...😭😭😭
Professor Michael Clarker said Russia only had enough munitions for 5 weeks and that was over 1000 days ago. What happened?
Heard of N Korea and Iran?
He is saying Russian economy is in trouble but world bank and Is IMF says the economy is growing at more than 3%
This is because they had a recession and are coming out of that.
They have a war economy which is an unfolding disaster. Look at their interest rates and inflation. Look at their GDP and how much they spend daily on the war. Sanctions are strangling their economy and it’s getting worse every month.
It's common for war time economise do well cause of the amount of spending short term. Give it year and the russian economy will over heat. It's getting very warm now and the government is struggling to keep a lid on it 💣
incorrect, Russian economy is being falsely supported by a "war economy" propelled by government spending and which now accounts for 30% of the entire GDP. This can't be sustained. Inflation is now rapidly growing and will soon spiral out of control. War economies cannot sustain real economies as they are not market driven but driven by government expenditure. Hence any perceived growth is not actually real growth.
War economy temporarily increases gdp. Just inevitable that the economy is in trouble as they have lost European market and cost of war
Prof John Mearsheimer w/ Judge Napolitano - US Taunts Russia
Mearshimer is a loon. he thinks Iran should have nukes. & he also said Putin would not invade in 2022. wrong.
Can't wait to watch this propaganda
RT is probably more your thing then
@@flowpipe banned from watching it in the ‘free west’….
@@flowpipe Tells more thruths than all the western media put together ya whopper.
@@samcook159 🤣
@@mikedon5205 List the lies/propaganda it told today?
Would love to see the current map.
Check in att ISW.
We love Ukraine ❤🇺🇸🇺🇸
Why?
NO
who’s we? America doesn’t even love themselves dealing with the immigrants and homelessness issues so wtf makes u think they care about some struggling country if they can’t care for themselves? 😂
We ?? What an idiotic comment.
💙💛💙💛💙💛🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦
Ukraine fights on battlefield
Russia fights civillians...including foreigjn airliners
Siberia Airlines Flight 1812
Siberia Airlines Flight 1812 was a commercial flight shot down by the Ukrainian Air Force over the Black Sea on 4 October 2001, en route from Tel Aviv, Israel, to Novosibirsk, Russia.
@@maryginger4877 Even Putin claimed an S-200 missile could not have possibly shot down flight 1812. In Putin's own words, Ukraine did not shoot down flight 1812.
@@maryginger4877account made when special military operation started
So if Russians are fighting civilians who are the Ukrainians fighting on the battlefield goofy?🤡🤡🤡
@@Goon556ghosts
23 minutes of pure cope
M. clark is a guy detached from reality!
he's a joke even in the UK
North Korea: still no absolute proof of fighting on the front line. What Clarke said is not fact checked. It may be true but may be wishful thinking.
Professor Clark is amazing analyst
I smell putler-trolls in the comment section
There is a bigger smell of people who struggle with opinions that differ from theirs.
But.....but we were told Nato is winning the war in, tell me some more Nato bot?
@@CrookeRogozinsky NATO isn’t materially involved in the war, bub.
@@NeutralinoRight the country giving them guns and money to fight isn’t involved. That’s funny
@Neutralino Who say so Nato bot?
I take it ukraine are still winning then?
😂😂😂😂😂
Yes.
Yes? Ukraine is 1000 days into a war that Russia hoped would be over long ago and Ukraine is still independent. Russia has lost thousands of men and equipment and gained destroyed villages
How could Ukraine not win? There are 52 countries supporting the war effort.
Ukraine is dying
Clarke is a great man thanks for keeping us in the know without crap👍
😂
😅
Yet all the information was the most positive spin I've seen
I'm sorry but I want to see maps
Watch it again
DPA is a neutral and very accurate mapping channel with daily updates :)
th-cam.com/video/LDTm7FZXQ4I/w-d-xo.html
10:53 😂. Ukraine is not going to have an army when this war is over 😂.
Ukraine has a stronger army now than when Russia launched its 3-day special military operation in February 2022. For Russia, it is the opposite. .
@@peterharma8937 how is that so? Give logical explanation instead of wishful thinking
@@peterharma8937and that's why Ukraine retreats everywhere at the fastest pace in 2 years 😂😂😂😂😂. Dude: talking to your pal at the pantry on Monday morning and talking to anyone else are 2 different games
The world is watching Russia get weaker and weaker every day.🇺🇲🇺🇳🇺🇦
🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
Michael Clarke is total the wrong person to provide an objective assessment. Ukraine is loosing and a cease fire is irrelevant. A final agreement is needed not a ceasefire..
People who barely speak English make for poor comments in English.
Correct but we have alot of MSM fanboys watching Sky News who believe this BS and that Ukraine is winning.
Clarke brilliant and accurate assessment as always keep it up, Oh in your dreams😅
loosing?
Hey Clarkley, so russians ran out of missiles, shovels ? and now economic situation ?
Yes alot of this propaganda comming out of ukraine , talking about how great there doing is really not helping. I actually think it is making things worse.
Does anyone else think ukraine entering kursk was one of there biggest mistakes?
It seems like alot of ukraines best trained and well equipped troops with some of the better western equipment are tied up in kursk and the russians don't seem overly worried about taking it back anytime soon, apart from throwing a couple hundred north Korean troops at it.
It seems to really upset Putin propagandists.
Interviews ALEXANDER MERCOURIS FOR TRUTH!
The Kremlin propaganda megaphone?
I'm not sure any of the 'War Pundits' have got much right. ✌🏼🌍
Neutrality Studies w/ Gabriele Krone Schmalz - German journalist exposes Ukraine/NATO lies
Boris Johnson scuttle better peace agreement, now Ukraine will get worst deal 😅😅
😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂
Ukraine? Never heard of her
Russia is not a “great power” with a GDP of around 2000 billion US dollars. That is about 1/10th of the combined GDP of the EU-27 (about 20 000 billion US dollars), or approximately the same size as the Nordic countries combined. The size of the US economy is about 27 000 billion US dollars or more than 13 times the Russian economy. Compared to other BRIC countries, Russia is behind Brazil (2200 billion US dollars), distanced with some margin by India (3600 billion US dollars), and only around 10 percent of the Chinese economy (17 800 billion US dollars). The outcome of the war is not in Russias hands.
The GDP of Russia for 2020 is: $1.47 T
The total GDP of NATO members plus the new members of Sweden and Finland is approximately $40.9 trillion (2020).
The total GDP of NATO members plus the new members Sweden and Finland plus Japan, South Korea, Australia and New Zealand is approximately $47.5 trillion (2020), 30 times the Russian GDP. Russia is an economic dwarf compared to Europe, compared to the USA and obviously compared to NATO.
Brics are bigger than the G7 And without the excessive debt. The US/G7 are in decline accept it !
@@Pironi28 BRICS have zero economic integration. Taking them as a collective isn’t useful in any way. India will never ally with China as an example.
Russia alone is economically weak.
Money helps, but it does not win the war
Top class advert
There will be no negotiations or peace deal without Washington giving Zelensky the nod, this has been the problem since day one.
Nonsense
No negotiations are necessary. The war ends when Russia goes home
@@Joshpox Says the official Ukrainian spokesperson
Nothing about the large desertions on the Ukrainian side.
Or the lines of Russians volunteering to fight
Ukraine winning
Great presentation 👏
A man has appeared in court charged with the murders of two women in on Christmas Day... Comment here... As U can never on sly news videos...
This so called expert kind of reminds me of experts claiming Biden to be as wise and sharp as ever. Either he’s clueless or assuming that audience is clueless. Perhaps both
The people who think Russia is in a great position ignore the the casualties, ignore the desperate supply lines from Iran, China, and North Korea, and ignore the army of poor, desperate fools from around the world who they recruit with empty promises.
Crimea and donbas would never return to Ukraine, when compared to Ukraine, they are in far more better position.
People who think Ukraine is in a good position ignore the enormous casualties, the lack of munitions, the dwindling donations from other countries and the failure of the recent mobilization attempt.
Russia’s military recruitment has been increasing for 3 years and is at its highest level. If a cease fire is negotiated it will be heavily in favour of Russia at this point or they will likely keep fighting as they take more land everyday. It may be sad but the truth hurts some times.
Yep Ukraine is winning, millions living in exile, millions dead, a fifth of the territory now in Russian hands, a destroyed economy, yep they’re doing fine !!
Spot on! 🎯
Ukraine war remain me of the Iraq invasion by US under false justification, Russia at least has a point in not wanting NATO (US) bases on its borders. In a hypothetical situation what would US do if China or Russia start building bases on its borders? Remember the Cuban missile crisis?
Ukraine was nowhere close to joining NATO.
Now Russia has Norway as a NATO member on it's borders.
Own goal by Russia.
Nobody was building bases in Ukraine. The USSR were actively building nuclear silos in Cuba. Notice any difference?
@@JonSmith-wg8mr 2008 Bucharest conference.
So Putin is not interested in the mineral wealth in the Dobas, NATO is just an excuse much like Russian people in the Dobas.
Finland now in NATO with American bases. It just shows what a strategic genius Putin is!
The fact that nobody talks about the forbidden book called The Gilded Nexus of Prosperity speaks volumes about how people are stuck in a trance
Link please
@@Lincs3765 FOMO bait. Life sucks deal with it
Any book worth reading wouldn't have such a stupid name
How idiotic.
I choose to follow Prof Clark he is real but also realistic
No mention about destruction of power plants electricity grid. The fall of big towns . Oreshnik. Clark cannot speak honestly
Yes, 5 people 35 goats 15 dogs😂😂😂....
He doesn't work for Putin. Why mention all the successful attacks on civilians?
30% occupied 3 years ago, 18 % occupied 2 years ago, 18% occupied today
@alexandrkolodiychuk6583 your assessment cannot be dented. But. Fact remains. Russia has badly mauled Ukraine. The length and breath of Ukraine has been bombarded. Half the nation is without electricity and water supply
20:08 lies and lies .....who broke the Minsk agreement made 2014???
Who broke first the Budapest memorandum? RuSSia. After that, Minsk shouldn't exist.
Also, agreements pointed with a gun never should happen. That was the Minsk agreement dh
@@moshoodoladokun9960 both sides broke the Minsk agreement
Treaties broken by Russia
1. Budapest Memorandum (1994) - Violated (Annexation of Crimea)
2. Treaty of friendship with Ukraine (1997) - Violated (Annexation of Crimea, war in Donbass)
3. Minsk Agreements (2014-2015) - Violated (Continued support to the separatists in Ukraine)
@@teolemon7716 The US broke the agreement by expanding to the east
Educate yourself
@@YouTalkingBolox7949 how that happened?
US hasn't expanded at all. Also, all the countries have the right to have any allies they want. Who is russia to define who is your friend?
Replace Clarke. He is a propagandist
What is this, a year end review for a war series on netlix? These ”analysts” and ”experts” are still not taking this seriously, i dont see them pushing for expanding military facilities, recruitment, training, going to the gun ranges. All the talk about ”preparing” yet no action taken at any point.
TELL US WHY THE USA HAS 46 BIO LABS IN UKRAINE, WHAT ARE THEY FOR ?
Slava Ukraine!
Brave & Kind 💯
So, is clarke saying Russia losing
Hopefully it’s a good 30 minutes plus deep dive and not a 3-5 minute skim the surface. Then maybe a look into options to get the best for Ukraine
Top comment the rest may as well not have bothered until it’s begun
"Expert Clarke" has been wrong with his predictions since the start if the war. Useless, really!
Western media fantasy😂😂😂😂😂 welcome back to reality😂😂😂😂😂
There are no more Russian trolls ! Now people finally woke up to see that media was lying to us telling us Ukraine was winning 😂
The Alt-media said Ukraine was finished in 14 days in 2022. & that Putin would not invade in 2022.
Another troll
The ORESHNIK is the standout changed EVERYTHING EVERYWHERE
Hey Clarkey, Is Russia still out of Missiles??????
Austria had a kind neutral status as Finland, which is long overdue and which is used to hide behind. They are not in Nato, if I remember correctly, so they don’t count when talking about mischief in Nato.
Ukraine has suffered massive casualties and is dragging people out of cars and sending them to the front. Ukraine is short of everything from small arms, artillery, ammo and vehicles. Russia on the otherhand has 35,000 men volunteering a month, has no shortage of equipment, has a massive 10-1 firepower advantage and thats without the 5-1 drones advantage, 1500 FAB glide bombs a month and missiles. Yet they have suffered more losses and are losing, but advancing along almost the entire front? Someone is telling untruths?
Yes, just somehow didn't achieve any goals in three years of war :)
So with all these advantages , how much territory has Russia gained in the last 12 months ?
Less than the Russian territory gained by Ukraine.
@@davidlloyd2583 100% facts. The Ukie fanboys in full cope mode
old data?
@@ProcaviaCapensis-ts8ub Russia has done what it's wanted to do. While the west has been pushing Ukrainian soldiers under Russian massed artillery.
Ukraine: the rock n roll years 😄
The number of Russian trolls in the comments is impressive
A day without coping is a day wasted Ukraine supporters 😂
Cope harder.
Its just the number of Ukrainian trolls has fallen, its like football when the team is not doing well the interest diminishes.
They're not even Russian or trolls. Just modern day snowflakes. Thankfully the people in the past had more balls are we'd be sure sprechen ze duetsche right now
NATO will step up patrols in the Baltic Sea region as Finnish investigators work to investigate whether a Russia-linked ship sabotaged undersea cables there this week, the alliance's boss has said.
I wonder why they did nothing after Nord Stream got blown up? 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Ukraine needs to stop this and give up, they're gonna run out of people long b4 Russia does
not before russia runs out of north koreans
Ukraine will NEVER GIVER UP. NEVER ........
@@ht9763 “ fortress bakhmut will never surrender”……..😂
Keep dreaming.
Long live ukraine! 💙💛💙💛💙💛🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦
No evidence of North Koreans anywhere? We can picture people on earth from space, yet we cannot get pictures of north Koreans.
Russian soldiers themselves have posted vids
lots of videos avaliable
@@Peter-lb8pv ye they’re not even hiding it anymore
@@Cav-z1ynot really, actually it was Russians from asian regions like Buryatia they just trolled western news 😂
There's lots of videos around not hard to find
Check the sneakers of the journalist 😂
Professor doom Michael Michael Clark, not one single analysis went his way, from leopard game changers to Himars to its a stalemate n Russia is out of missiles n Russia is bleeding out, 😂
Why are North Koreans fighting for Russia ?
lol at least someone can see clarke for the lies he tells.
can we call is disinformation and have him tried? or is that reserved for pro anti west?
Awesome to see the bots out in force. Hmm 😮
Mr Clarke come here for his humiliation??
Almost all his prediction goes wrong miserably
Always good for a laugh, sky journalism.
Biased journalism 😢
Funded by military industrial complex to keep funneling money out of the pockets of the tax payer to the coffers of the elite.
Thanks Michael! Always on top
Misleading people lol
Propaganda
RT
With social media propaganda doesn’t work anymore
Came here for the comedy. Was not dissapointed :)
So Michael Clarke's map summary of 2024 only shows the extent of Russian gains up to.. August? - Conveniently omitting the significant advances made in the past 4 months, with key Donbas city in Pokrovsk on the brink of capture.. at least tell the truth!
For more neutral and accurate daily updated mapping of the war, see DPA:
th-cam.com/video/LDTm7FZXQ4I/w-d-xo.html
The amount of russians in the comments is worrying.
They aren't Russians. That is probably even more concerning!
Many many many of us here in the west support Russia, we have woken up to the lies from the western establishment.
No we're not ! UK born and bred ! We shouldn't be involved in Ukraine and people like me are more concerned about what is happening in the UK.
They're hilarious though! Russia is losing the war that they and their dictator started so they're so mad and Clarke really sets them off. LOL
@@chrisrishermn it's not concerning that people can hold a variety of opinions nor is it that they have the freedom to express them. It's concerning that we still have people trying to police what other say under the threat of being tarred and labelled as X Y or bot.
Great back and forth between Kamali and Prof.Clarke! The professor always delivers a concise picture with the panache i've come to admire.
😂😂😂😂 your sarcasm is amazing
Everything that comes out of Clarkes mouth is delusional, expect the opposite every time 😂
More nonsense from a person with no quals
He's actually one of the best Western analysts. Very balanced.
He said that Russia would take Odesa somewhere next year.
Professor Clark finally got something right. It is indeed, 2024.
He is not even close to delusional. He is correct.
I’ve lost count of the number of times Professor Clarke has been badly wrong. If it’s intentional it’s propaganda, if it’s not is it incompetence?
Ukraine will be victorious ❤🇺🇦
Sure they will and Zelensky and his missus will skip merrily through the near mature barley towards a setting sun.
💙💛💙💛💙💛🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦
30% occupied 3 years ago, 18 % occupied 2 years ago, 18% occupied today
Putin started his imperialist invasion with armoured columns 40km long. Now Russia uses 1 Lada, a Golf Buggy and 12 North Koreans on e-bikes..
ps the e-bikes have now been downgraded to scooters
Yep, plus that they cannot replenish their losses of their tanks, vehicles, ships, planes back to the good old days. And the west is still providing Ukraine daily.
Keep dreaming.
@@GodwinGodfather wakie
Yes but that rusty Lada is still advancing against the Abrams and Leopards. Kurakhove is about done for.
What about orishinic missals.orishinic is the best missal