Exactly...the screenplay was way too fast thst it didn't give time for the emotion to set up for the audience...and the tension building for every flight sequence was missing.... interval block was not properly paced...out of nowhere he annouced war...which was patchy
Result of copying baahubali. But kanguva visuals have too much of dark blue, grey tones. Baahubali is success because it has yeloow, green, red, orange tones maximum. Just compare baahubali trailer and kanguva trailer even today.
I wish you'd highlight the positives more. The VFX was commendable. Fantasy genre in Tamil is rare, let alone to this level, let alone by Siva of all people. If the criticisms feel more like bashing than constructive criticism, then it discourages any innovation or variation and we'll be stuck with cookie-cutter templates we've had so far, and then blame the industry for rehashing old scripts. Siva is my least favorite filmmaker but I feel like this film deserves a lot more credit than its receiving.
The film had a good potential to work on, I mean it must've been exciting to hear the story or to read it from the script but nothing worked on screen when it came to execution. For example the crocodile scene the scene starts abruptly without any setup, a simple scene of the boy getting into the water or a pov of the crocodile looking at the boy could be enough to setup the scene so that it could work. And mainly its time that Siva rethinks his whole idea of execution to conceive something that he has writtern.
For any form of art creation, technology can only assist as tool to elevate the creation but can never form the soul of art - then the creation fails there!
You covered all the portions Sudhir. Exactly what I felt when I watched the movie. Based on Siva's previous movies, I went with little expectation as I clearly know he give more importance to moving the scenes fast rather than build character details, ground potential etc. But didnt expect he would rush up the entire Kanguva portion very fast. Thanks to Suriya , his wonderful performance atleast made me through the entire movie. One humble request to all tamil film makers out there, please dont waste performer's hard work and time.
The worst part is he used ai in one of the first shots at the lab, like whats the difference between a tentpole film and a bedroom filmmaker, embarrassing
I liked the crocodile fight And the girls fight as you mentioned and the climax parallel between the past and present But the problem I felt is those are all seperate entities and not connected to the movie in not many ways
Kanguva has a good story but it seen through a hyper overkill " Enga annan velayudham vandutaar da " lens . Probably the most basketball played in a life since Vikram's I. 😂😂😂
அனைத்து சினிமா தயாரிப்பாளர்களும் படக்குழுவினர்களும் பணத்தை மட்டுமே மையமாக கொண்டு (PART12345) பல பகுதிகளை மனதில் வைத்து எடுப்பதால் வரும் பிரச்சினைகள் இதை புரிந்து படமெடுக்க வேண்டும் அல்லது இதைப்போன்ற குழப்பங்கள் வரும்
First 20 mins Francis portions ah cut panita overall movie supera iruku especially second half & climax 🔥 na thalapathy fan tha enaku padam pudichuruku nalaiku again poi parka pora ❤❤❤
First for directors should stop these part 2 scam if story truly needs it it can be done unnecessarily infusing a cameo to make a second part will make a movie disaster
பாஸு.. நீங்க ரொம்போ யோசிக்கறீங்க. சிவா படம் எல்லாம் பார்க்கனும்னா, மூளைய கழட்டி வச்சிடனும். கல்கத்தால படிக்கிற தங்கச்சி, வாரா வாரம் ரயில்ல ஊருக்கு வரான்னு சொன்னாரு அண்ணாத்தைல. டேய், வந்துபோகவே ஒரு வாரம் ஆகுமேடான்னு கேட்டா நீங்க சிவா படம் பார்க்க முடியாது.
I think a seasoned actor can’t decide a story, then also have to own the failure as well . Me or anyone will think a lot to atleast try a movie with Siva and ok even if the story is very good why to invest so much on a person who has given so much flops and I think Ajith shouldered the movie on his might and made the two movies successful. Vivekam la Ajith avaru body ku pota effort the director wasted .
Usually I don't believe one person's maximum capacity and he can't do much more than that thought he can learn in any pharse of his life and break that limit untill I follow siruthai Siva there is some limitations it's seems
there is no proper story it is random why bounty hunter...and wt about romans and is only surya can fight in the clan not others can...just a medium story
Movie sequel ideas are the biggest misfortune in Tamil cinema. The so-called major star-oriented films were created to amuse a diverse audience at the time. Now, the corporate studio's pan-India market adulation wants to incorporate an extended universe into all of its products. It does not make sense to me. Why would I attend a movie to find out what happens to the storyboard premises in the following film? I pay to watch that now. When a director comes to the studio with a story about a single subject, let him tell it as a standalone film. If they believe there is room for another notion in the same plot. They might invite him to write it after the standalone movie's release and receive a proper favorable reaction from viewers. The response to the INDIAN 2/ GOAT/ now KANGUVA films from the general public is a slap in the face of Tamil cinema's greedy producers; they believe the audience is stupid to accept whatever they film and put in theatres, and we pay for it since a major star appears in it. PH has a sick worldview. Now, they've experienced such a harsh and genuine response from audiences in theatres. They will never have the greedy attitude to produce and create a false promotion for return on investment again. When they believe THE STAR does not have the capacity to recoup their investment in a single role of a film, they try to cast other stars in the business or cancel the production if none are found. Don't develop a movie just to impress that star, then divide it into two parts and make us suffer in the theatre... Last but not least, everyone was aware of the industry's competitive nature. Who would produce the first 1000 crore film in Tamil cinema? That hunger drives everyone in the industry to develop pan-India films and market the fact that this is the ONE from our country who can accomplish such massive numbers. However, they overlooked one essential aspect: the storyline, fascinating screenplay, and larger-than-life characters required to achieve it. Spending time on that process of crafting is more important than spending a chunk money on your film.
Yes there are some connection issue especially in the beginning.. bu the movie is pretty good and entertaining to watch! Pls don't listen to others reviews, please watch and decide for yourselves
Why the child suddenly forgiving kanguva there is no proper scene for that forgiveness and what is the reason they went to that forest the forest is better than kanguva's village
Blud gives information about the aindheevu at 30th minute instead of in the opening for fucks sake tharkuri editor could easily saved the film if only a editor like philomin in this film it would be atleast a watchable one editor tharkuri is the villain of this movie
@@adityaks3380 then he didn't edit this film's final out for real because kandippa ipdi oru output vandhurukaadhu💯 Siva Paya than final out eduthurukkan😒
Lag is because avasaram from same type fight scene to another fight scene which is avasaram but the entire portion seems like lag because continuous fighting
Had to close my ears all throughout. I’ve never watched Sivas movie in the past. But I had hope that he may try something different. He didn’t have to try any thing different. Oru regularly story with regular direction kuduthurundhale podhum. Starting la irundhu cringe. Characters shouting constantly. Stopped following what was going on. Second hand embarrassment for a Tamil movie to be put on so many screens. Vantan ivalo negativity theva illanu.
@@Mahesh-p9j2eI was also watching da movie with my ears closed but what he is trying to say is very right...movies like GOAT are running successfully in theatres which had no story...mediocre acting...technically weak in all departments...visually bland and a horrible movie overall
Pls make video about what is causing kollywood to race to bottom with films like indian 2 and kanguva, when tollywood n sandalwood are racing to top with baahubali and kgf. Kollywood is supposed to be biggest south industry. Other fields like car making , top hospitals TN idustry players are leading. But hero-director-producer toxic culture is collapsing TN film industry. The reviewers should come up with yearly report on weak point of industry, publish it online for the major players and tn govt relevant ministry to see.
Honestly KGF doesn't have proper screenplay it's also looks a series of high points, but it worked for the rocky bhai vibes. You can replace KGF with Kanthara
See we have seen many unworthy movies but the way the sirutha naai and the whole team cheated us is not acceptable Siva 4 english words neraiya english movies paathutu manasula hollywood director nu nenaikuran these guys like DSP, SIVA & GNANAVELRAJA Must be thrown out of the industry
The best analyzed "Review" so far.
It had potential but his way of story telling failed to connect.
Simple story connected by b and c audience
But failed by intelligent a centres 😂
@@4kuhd-f4fb and c ah😂😂. Ella centrelaum padam utter flop da. Indian 2 itha vida better nu solranga😂
@@Oldvalyriaa Atleast Indian 2 Prequel Indian 1 was Industry Hit 😹
The day film makers stop jerking off to grand visuals and start focusing on sitting down and writing is the day everything will get better…
Facts bro
Unmai
The writing was there
The 5 clans and roman empires was the story with visuals
He didn't understand the story thats all
@@4kuhd-f4fOn that basis, he and most people who went to see the movie didn’t understand 🤷🏾. Whose fault is that?
In Tamil only... 😂
The shortest duration" late review" to my remembrance
Surya respects Kamal so much to save Indian 2 from being named ‘disaster of the year’
😂😂😂😂
😅😅😅
Disaster of the Year?
The film deserves to be celebrated
Show your grudge somewhere else
@@4kuhd-f4f deserves what? u need sleep
@@4kuhd-f4f ha ha is it so , stupid film I wasted my 660 rupees by watching this movie
Very sensible review 👍👍
Exactly...the screenplay was way too fast thst it didn't give time for the emotion to set up for the audience...and the tension building for every flight sequence was missing.... interval block was not properly paced...out of nowhere he annouced war...which was patchy
The most nuanced reviewer in tamil cinema❤
Super review
The day we stop making movies to glorify the Hero as a person, but to glorfy the story, that's when tamil movies will get better.
Then you need to watch malayalam movies mostly
@bodhisattva6308 yea, but even in Malayalam, not all movies are great
Result of copying baahubali. But kanguva visuals have too much of dark blue, grey tones. Baahubali is success because it has yeloow, green, red, orange tones maximum. Just compare baahubali trailer and kanguva trailer even today.
I wish you'd highlight the positives more. The VFX was commendable. Fantasy genre in Tamil is rare, let alone to this level, let alone by Siva of all people. If the criticisms feel more like bashing than constructive criticism, then it discourages any innovation or variation and we'll be stuck with cookie-cutter templates we've had so far, and then blame the industry for rehashing old scripts. Siva is my least favorite filmmaker but I feel like this film deserves a lot more credit than its receiving.
Failed to capture human emotions nu solringa! super.
Excellent film
Surya should have acted 3 movies in a year with movies like lubbar pandhu, etc., story based movies.. that should finish shooting in 30 days.
Surya assumes to be a Mass Star so he wont do such movies
The film had a good potential to work on, I mean it must've been exciting to hear the story or to read it from the script but nothing worked on screen when it came to execution. For example the crocodile scene the scene starts abruptly without any setup, a simple scene of the boy getting into the water or a pov of the crocodile looking at the boy could be enough to setup the scene so that it could work. And mainly its time that Siva rethinks his whole idea of execution to conceive something that he has writtern.
Was literally waiting for your unbiased review bro..
For any form of art creation, technology can only assist as tool to elevate the creation but can never form the soul of art - then the creation fails there!
You covered all the portions Sudhir. Exactly what I felt when I watched the movie. Based on Siva's previous movies, I went with little expectation as I clearly know he give more importance to moving the scenes fast rather than build character details, ground potential etc. But didnt expect he would rush up the entire Kanguva portion very fast. Thanks to Suriya , his wonderful performance atleast made me through the entire movie. One humble request to all tamil film makers out there, please dont waste performer's hard work and time.
Hello.
Could u review a movie called MINMINI
The worst part is he used ai in one of the first shots at the lab, like whats the difference between a tentpole film and a bedroom filmmaker, embarrassing
Had the same feel when I saw those shots about children being tested. It felt like an AI generated video
I liked the crocodile fight
And the girls fight as you mentioned and the climax parallel between the past and present
But the problem I felt is those are all seperate entities and not connected to the movie in not many ways
Kanguva has a good story but it seen through a hyper overkill " Enga annan velayudham vandutaar da " lens . Probably the most basketball played in a life since Vikram's I. 😂😂😂
Please correct the sound problem on your vidéos please
அனைத்து சினிமா தயாரிப்பாளர்களும் படக்குழுவினர்களும் பணத்தை மட்டுமே மையமாக கொண்டு (PART12345) பல பகுதிகளை மனதில் வைத்து எடுப்பதால் வரும் பிரச்சினைகள் இதை புரிந்து படமெடுக்க வேண்டும் அல்லது இதைப்போன்ற குழப்பங்கள் வரும்
First 20 mins Francis portions ah cut panita overall movie supera iruku especially second half & climax 🔥 na thalapathy fan tha enaku padam pudichuruku nalaiku again poi parka pora ❤❤❤
Ivana nambi padam paka poravangaluk advance RIP 😂
@@Oldvalyriaa apo nee already sethu poi tha comment potrukia 🤭 ila neraya per mari padame parkama olu vitu irukia da dvd paya 😆
Exceyly that's how i felt too... the movie is pretty decent
moolai valarchi kami pola
Nee vijay fan nu kandippa namburen.. Cringemax movue rewatch panra thairiyam vijay clown fans ku mattum thaan irukkum😂👍
First for directors should stop these part 2 scam if story truly needs it it can be done unnecessarily infusing a cameo to make a second part will make a movie disaster
Wonderful movie...I watched 2 times in theatres... don't believe negative reviews 😮
பாஸு.. நீங்க ரொம்போ யோசிக்கறீங்க. சிவா படம் எல்லாம் பார்க்கனும்னா, மூளைய கழட்டி வச்சிடனும்.
கல்கத்தால படிக்கிற தங்கச்சி, வாரா வாரம் ரயில்ல ஊருக்கு வரான்னு சொன்னாரு அண்ணாத்தைல. டேய், வந்துபோகவே ஒரு வாரம் ஆகுமேடான்னு கேட்டா நீங்க சிவா படம் பார்க்க முடியாது.
I think a seasoned actor can’t decide a story, then also have to own the failure as well . Me or anyone will think a lot to atleast try a movie with Siva and ok even if the story is very good why to invest so much on a person who has given so much flops and I think Ajith shouldered the movie on his might and made the two movies successful. Vivekam la Ajith avaru body ku pota effort the director wasted .
Sudhir watches FDFS and waits for two days to post the review, just to justify the show name😅
He didnt look like a bounty hunter at all.
Usually I don't believe one person's maximum capacity and he can't do much more than that thought he can learn in any pharse of his life and break that limit untill I follow siruthai Siva there is some limitations it's seems
3:18 திஷா பட்டாணி 🫛 varaanga
Bro .. Ungala maari reviewers a thaa.. Actress Jothika instagram la Harsh ah complaint pannittu irukkanga...
Neenga thaa Movie Flop Aakiteengannu..
Athukkum oru video potta nalla irukkum
She didn't talk about him kind of people. She clearly talk about the abusers
Yempa, yaaru pa athu review pannitu irukum bothu pinnala dum adikurathu? 😒
Oudated screenplay, emotions on the writing only not on the movie
there is no proper story it is random why bounty hunter...and wt about romans and is only surya can fight in the clan not others can...just a medium story
Movie sequel ideas are the biggest misfortune in Tamil cinema. The so-called major star-oriented films were created to amuse a diverse audience at the time. Now, the corporate studio's pan-India market adulation wants to incorporate an extended universe into all of its products. It does not make sense to me. Why would I attend a movie to find out what happens to the storyboard premises in the following film? I pay to watch that now. When a director comes to the studio with a story about a single subject, let him tell it as a standalone film. If they believe there is room for another notion in the same plot. They might invite him to write it after the standalone movie's release and receive a proper
favorable reaction from viewers.
The response to the INDIAN 2/ GOAT/ now KANGUVA films from the general public is a slap in the face of Tamil cinema's greedy producers; they believe the audience is stupid to accept whatever they film and put in theatres, and we pay for it since a major star appears in it. PH has a sick worldview. Now, they've experienced such a harsh and genuine response from audiences in theatres. They will never have the greedy attitude to produce and create a false promotion for return on investment again.
When they believe THE STAR does not have the capacity to recoup their investment in a single role of a film, they try to cast other stars in the business or cancel the production if none are found. Don't develop a movie just to impress that star, then divide it into two parts and make us suffer in the theatre...
Last but not least, everyone was aware of the industry's competitive nature. Who would produce the first 1000 crore film in Tamil cinema? That hunger drives everyone in the industry to develop pan-India films and market the fact that this is the ONE from our country who can accomplish such massive numbers. However, they overlooked one essential aspect: the storyline, fascinating screenplay, and larger-than-life characters required to achieve it.
Spending time on that process of crafting is more important than spending a chunk money on your film.
Damn
I liked this film so much. It's little loud so I used earlier poda and watched this amazing new attempt.
Gladiator 2 review
Yes there are some connection issue especially in the beginning.. bu the movie is pretty good and entertaining to watch! Pls don't listen to others reviews, please watch and decide for yourselves
Why the child suddenly forgiving kanguva there is no proper scene for that forgiveness and what is the reason they went to that forest the forest is better than kanguva's village
1:02 1:20
Nice movie.
Get a better microphone bro!
Blud gives information about the aindheevu at 30th minute instead of in the opening for fucks sake tharkuri editor could easily saved the film if only a editor like philomin in this film it would be atleast a watchable one editor tharkuri is the villain of this movie
editor passed away recently bro..try to show some compassion 🤧
@@TheQuestionDatabase I didn't knew it brother may his soul RIP🖤
Bro thallumaala editor bro avaru. Tharkuri lam illa ivaru.
@@adityaks3380 then he didn't edit this film's final out for real because kandippa ipdi oru output vandhurukaadhu💯 Siva Paya than final out eduthurukkan😒
@ajivalentino7953 that’s what am trying to say
Neenga avasaram avasaram nu soldreenga ...review niraya paeru lag lag ndraanga. May we get all the answers in part 2 🤞
Lag is because avasaram from same type fight scene to another fight scene which is avasaram but the entire portion seems like lag because continuous fighting
@freexpress5399 👍
I loved it but romba negativity.. it has its own flaw but ivlo negativity thevai ila
Had to close my ears all throughout. I’ve never watched Sivas movie in the past. But I had hope that he may try something different. He didn’t have to try any thing different. Oru regularly story with regular direction kuduthurundhale podhum. Starting la irundhu cringe. Characters shouting constantly. Stopped following what was going on. Second hand embarrassment for a Tamil movie to be put on so many screens.
Vantan ivalo negativity theva illanu.
@@Mahesh-p9j2eI was also watching da movie with my ears closed but what he is trying to say is very right...movies like GOAT are running successfully in theatres which had no story...mediocre acting...technically weak in all departments...visually bland and a horrible movie overall
Goat budget um kanguva budget um onna
@@Mahesh-p9j2eengalku illa embarrassment
Ott la paathutu miss pantom nu katharuvanunga appo theriyum
@@nikithageorge441yes same
Vijay oda salary ah vachi ivanga full padame yeduthutanga
KANGUVA :: Blockbuster 🔥
Dai😂😂😂
Producer ah asingama kekanu for the over hype
why re uploading
Pls make video about what is causing kollywood to race to bottom with films like indian 2 and kanguva, when tollywood n sandalwood are racing to top with baahubali and kgf. Kollywood is supposed to be biggest south industry. Other fields like car making , top hospitals TN idustry players are leading. But hero-director-producer toxic culture is collapsing TN film industry. The reviewers should come up with yearly report on weak point of industry, publish it online for the major players and tn govt relevant ministry to see.
Honestly KGF doesn't have proper screenplay it's also looks a series of high points, but it worked for the rocky bhai vibes. You can replace KGF with Kanthara
Let TN film fall n disappear…
Ounka pinati ethooo eriyudhu
Absolute horror and pathetic.
Still I have trauma
Bro You wasting 13:37 minutes successfully
Nalla potential iruntha movie, emotion connect agala due to own son illai, sound issues, goa portion overact, initial bad impression.
True
Kanguva..... Nalla padam dhan........ Indha negativity spread pandra alavuku mokka padam illa❤🔥
Dei loos-u
@Mahesh-p9j2e poda mental.... Poi goat pee sapdu
😂😂😂
Mokka padam dhan. 100 kodi collect pannum. 2000 kodi lam nakkum.
@@vignesh9161 2000 nu sonnadhu sarcasm.... Edhume theriyama vai vekka vandhuradhu🤣🤣
Please Conclude the opinions ..don't leave like question marks Sudhir...please..
Wherever needed tell the convinced and non convincing moments more..
One of the worst movies of this millennium. Period
One of the misunderstood film of this millennium and people started trolling without watching film just by seeing other's negativity....... Period
This is a reach
Apptiya sir your are worst reviewer of this millennium
@@hamsavarthanprabahar3276don't cry 😂😂 worst movie for the minellium than .. Utter waste
@@vijayanshenoy7859 cry more🤣
Worst audio quality bro! Be professional atleast
He's replicating the films audio ithu kuriyeedu
@nithishkumarbtechit1927 🤣 i see
Puli best sounds 😂😂😂
@@sujinDiren-qs6uw paithiya kaaran 😂 audio quality worst nu sonna, samanthame illama puli audio quality ya pathi pesitu irukkan, ipdi oru tharkuriya naa paathathe illa! 🤦🏻♂️
@@RogRebel hater’s ku Elam tappa than teriyum 🤣🤣
See we have seen many unworthy movies but the way the sirutha naai and the whole team cheated us is not acceptable
Siva 4 english words neraiya english movies paathutu manasula hollywood director nu nenaikuran these guys like DSP, SIVA & GNANAVELRAJA Must be thrown out of the industry
Suriya is overrated. He has not had a theatrical hit for last 12 years. Also Siva should retire.
You didn't know what is overrated word meaning
He didnt look like a bounty hunter at all.