Ranking the Star Wars Opening Crawls
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 ต.ค. 2024
- Head to squarespace.com... to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain. Thanks to Squarespace for sponsoring this video!
Schaff ranks the Star Wars opening crawls I guess!
Editor's Channels:
Pappy G: / @pappyg3187
Mordo: www.youtube.co....
VillagerBoy: www.youtube.co....
Goop: / goopvideos
CGF-Movies: / cgfmovies
SpaceTree: / spacetreestudios
Citizen HAL: / @2manymovies
Shooting Films: / thesonicandmario100
Patreon: / schaffrillas
Twitter: / schaffrillas
Redbubble: www.redbubble.....
Reddit: / schaffrillas. .
Esteemed $5+ Patrons:
aheaney15
Alexandra
Andre Gutierrez
Andrew Young
Ashley Forrest
BATMAN
CG Lemonade
Charlotte M
Childish Memphino
ClownDuck
Cole Jackson
Crimson Court
Danmccould
Dman990099
Dr Noe Context
Emily Allen
Flan
Gabi Christie
Ian Seebach
Jacob Baum
Jacob LaBossiere
Jake G
Jonathan Kermanian
Joseph
Justin Gonzales
Leif Bradshaw
Logan McQuaid
Matt Fernandes
Michael David Rose
Milky
MirrorWqve
Nessie
NoneLovesMe
Olivia Mendel
Peter Hollens
Pierre Desbrieres
Prismabunny
Put 9-Volt in Smash Bros. Please
Quetzal the Snek
rEactor
Reagan DeFriece
RoscoesDad
Ryland Tews
Sassy
Scott St Jean
Seth Howell
Soloco
Suarez
SuperJimmy978
Tailored Muffin
That Guy Named Rai
Uncultured Swine
Vellum Tony
Vintage
Volianer
Wafflegamr
Out of literally everything Star Wars related that this man can review, it was impossible for the opening crawls to have crossed my mind
Lol true yeah bruh
Yeah. Thought He’d ranked the movies themselves…
@@Driggsdamonstah can’t wait for him to review the Last shitwalker. It’s basically a cinematic fan fiction written by Disney (his words not mine).
@@emoji3266 it’ll be fun seeing him rip apart my least favorite Star Wars Movie
what's with all the bots? They keep appearing everywhere
Yeah but the best CLOSING crawl is when Anakin screams “I HATE YOU!” while on fire.
Such a good crawl.
I hope this gets more likes
@@thecouchpotato3429 thank you I try
True!
Underrated comment
His form was a little off but I agree
Imagine being a soldier getting called into the briefing room and hearing "somehow, Hitler returned"
🙋🙋🙋🙋♀️🙋♀️🙋♀️
You must travel to Argentina to uncover his location.
The Boys From Brazil in a nutshell even though it was good.
That's not an accurate comparison, Hitler wasn't a force welder with access to ancient Sith magic and cloning. Besides, Star Wars is fictional. Papatine retuning doesn't effect OUR universe.
Yeah, that's a pretty good comparison. He poisoned himself, shot himself in the head, then his corpse was burned. A death in that scenario is just as unquestionable as in Palpatine's case.
Alright so he's ranked the score and the opening crawls for every star wars movie, now he has to rank the movies based on best use of the wilhelm scream
I actually really want that
YES! INDEED HE HAS!!
or ranking them based on their best use of "I have a bad feeling about this"
This
He would probably end up ranking the "I have a bad feeling about this" in the future
Fun fact: The opening crawls were painfully tedious to shoot in the original trilogy. This is because the text was on one big cel on the floor they slowly panned the camera on. They had to redo the shot every time the camera went ever so slightly off center.
Now, they're done digitally because every video editor has the effect as a preset.
Interesting!
Sometimes I forget how old the original Star Wars movies are. It didn't even occur to me that the text crawls would have been a practical effect
@@OptimusPhillip nearly everything was practical, I think primarily what was digital was things like explosions and blaster bolts/lightsabers, although often stuff like the lightsabers were a combination of practical and digital.
@@zmanrockz6358the extent of computer graphics in a new hope was basically the diagram of the Death Star when the rebels laid out the plans to bomb the exhaust port. Everything else, from lightsabers, blasters and explosions to starships and aliens, was either practical effects or manipulation of the physical strip of film to create special effects shots.
Damn that's kinda depressing to think about how pioneers in the field of cinema worked so hard to perfect their craft, only for the same effect to be shot out of a powerpoint text transition a few decades later
I love how George Lucas was inspired to do something that seemed outdated in 1977 and managed to make it one of the most recognizable things of all time.
It was literally because Brian de Palma complained about the beginning and why we should care about the rebels
That is why Star Wars is one of the biggest cinematic masterpieces of our time.
I’ve heard he got into a major disagreement with the director’s guild of america who wanted traditional credits. He was so determined to include the opening crawl that he quit the guild
Too bad he only made two and a half good movies
Until J J Abrams ruined it.
Thank you schafrillas, for rating and reviewing things that literally no one else will. I think I speak for everyone when I say your reviews have filled a hole in our hearts that no one else can
For example, let’s talk about Sid the Sloth in Encanto. Schaffrillas really needs to bring this up.
You speak for me certainly.
Now he just needs to rank every Illumination movie... 😈
@@gaspoweredpick Schaffrillas:A suprise to be sure and a not so welcome one at that.
THIS 🙌🏻
27:05 Obviously Leia got so good at resisting that she had no choice but to start resisting the Resistance
ayyy phineas and ferb
Finally its here th-cam.com/video/dQw4w9WgXcQ/w-d-xo.html
I mean its clear how palpatine managed to send that message to the entire galaxy, he just used his opening crawl powers to send a bunch of gigantic floating words throughout space.
This is an underated comment.
Logic
Imagine trying to explain that as an astronomer
I can't find a flaw with this logic.
OMG! I can see this coming out of Spaceballs, as using the opening crawl to alert the galaxy that they’ve returned is a legit scheme I can see Spaceballs using in a sequel.
The other thing I just noticed, the first line of Return of the Jedi is,
"Luke Skywalker has returned to-"
But then In The Force Awakes, the next movie chronologically, the first line is,
"Luke Skywalker has vanished."
That's so good and I'm not even sure if it was intentional or an accident.
I don't think JJ Abrams Is smart enough to think about that
it’s like poetry it rhymes
Knowing Disney Star Wars, it had to be on accident
27:34 I feel like they could have made the republic's uselessness more of a deliberate point with a line like "Frustrated by the Republic's lack of action, General Leia Organa organizes a brave RESISTANCE."
Then... once the Capital System is destroyed... the RESISTANCE ceases being a "Resistance" as it's formally folded into the Republic Navy...
There's no way in they should have been called the resistance. The First Order is the resistance in this instance. Oh that rhymes.
No joke, when I first saw "The Dead Speak!" in the theater, I laughed out of joy. That's exactly the kind of fun corny writing you would find in an old sci-fi film crawl. And then immediately after, when I read that Palpatine was alive, my heart sank. I've never gone from 100 to 0 so quickly when watching a film.
Exactly, I mean Star Wars has the freaking Wilhelm scream
Definitely
Yeah
Dark empire, even if I never liked It, did It far Better
When first saw Rise of Skywalker and I saw the words “The dead speak!” I was actually a little intrigued in a way. It just sounded so ominous to me. Keep in mind this was back when I was a sequel trilogy defender. Before I came to my senses and realized how bad these movies really were. Now I just see it as a dumb line. Maybe if properly built up with a clear plan from the beginning it would’ve had more of an impact but it was just another bad line in a whole movie full of bad lines.
@willpower8289 why did you go from being a sequel defender to not?
Didn’t expect a ranking on these but I like the idea!
Schaff please figure out someway to block these bots. They’re getting REALLY annoying…
Ha ha
69 likes
Star Wars fans DO criticize everything
Haha 420 likes
"A surprise to be sure, but a welcome one."
26:45 Rian actually did say repeatedly in interviews that until the reveal, no one had guessed the title he had chosen, despite the fact that he said it was "staring them in the face." It was planned, not a coincidence.
I’d point out that the whole thing is a call back to ROTJ, where Yoda says that Like will be the last of the Jedi.
@@Quirderph So, one with the force, the 'Like' button is.
This is a fantastic video but I keep getting distracted by the fact that I don’t know which movie is his least favorite
Yeah, I wonder which one it is? We have nooooo idea
It’s stiiiill a mystery
Same with which one is his favourite
I was so pissed when it was revealed that Palpatine return from the dead was revealed in the opening crawl, I'm glad you ranked that one last.
Actually, it was revealed in a fortnite event
No. I am not kidding
@@RedDeadDepressionist dude fr?
@@yaboy8834 he’s not lying
Delete your channel already, the video reached 20 comments, ur done
@@RedDeadDepressionist someone got fired for that. Whether it was someone at disney or epic games idk.
I dont really watch Star Wars that much but my dad does. He likes to extremely over analyze the crawls and he basically says the same things you do. Guess you are objectively right about everything. Even my 43 year old dad agrees
Lmao.
Show this to your father
Is he cute
@@MaxiemumKarnage keep dreaming Miley Cyrus
For one of the first things we see in the Star Wars movies, it's kinda cool seeing a ranking on them.
I remember seeing TFA in theaters and reading "Luke Skywalker has vanished". I felt a little *ping* in my heart(I had gotten into SW that year and he was my favorite character of the original trilogy) and I thought to myself "oh...so that's why he wasn't in the trailers or on the poster..."; it made me very sad.
It is a surprisingly powerful line for being so simplistic
I love that "Luke Skywalker has vanished" fits the whole first line. Didn't really think about how brilliant that was before.
The only thing I might also change you didn't say is change "There are heroes on both sides" - good but misinterpretable - to "Both sides have their heroes", which still sets up a dichotomy between the sides while making them both personable and rationable. The Separatists aren't pure evil, they're a SIDE, with beliefs and people who risk their lives to defend them. The new line works well with "Evil is everywhere", too - leaving you really wondering who is "good" and foreshadowing Palpy.
Edit: I'm not saying the Separatists are GOOD, but they aren't just "Oooooo we're evil", especially to those nowhere near the top.
Except without going into the clone wars there are literally no good seperatists and it's almost impossible to tell what they actually want
The Separatists are arguably worse than the Empire in all of their iterations, enslaving countless populations that they control and forcibly industrializing many peaceful planets.
There are heroes on both sides is nowhere near as bad as both sides have their heroes, that one is the one that actually sounds bad and like it’s all black and white
The movies never demonstrate that there are heroes on both sides though.
I love when the separatist leader says that they were promist peace, right before Anakin, now Vader, kills him. It shows that they were never pure evil, but that they had differing opinions and were willing to use more extreme and violent measures than the Republic
I’m very eager to know how this ended up being 36 minutes long, looking forward to this
Lmao just saw that same here
Yay Star Wars! I fucking love Star Wars!!! For the most part.
“I’ve been looking forward to this”
At least 6 minutes of it is just on Rise of Shitwalker, no questions asked
First 5th is JUST Rise of Skywalker lmao
Schaff is really the master of doing pretty SUBVERSIVE ranking videos that you don’t usually see people doing.
I’m really disappointed since it doesn’t have all the characters jumbled up together in the thumbnail.
Next time baby!!
Ouoh... yeayah
A lot of hardcore Star Wars fans probably already know about this fact, but it is interesting to note that Brian De Palma and Jay Cocks were heavily involved in rewriting the opening crawl for A New Hope. The original title crawl created by George Lucas was supposedly too bloated and confusing, so De Palma and Cocks changed it to be more concise and understandable.
God, this just makes me feel incredibly nostalgic for 2015-era Star Wars.
same
It’s so sad the last Jedi and rise of skywalker ruined the franchise
@B money lmfao
@B money I am going to assume that this is sarcasm.
The hype was real. Kinda sucks that The Force Awakens is not good
I actually liked how TPM's seemingly normal/peaceful/diplomatic crawl lulls you into a false sense of security like it does with the Jedi protagonists in the film, before being caught by surprise that there's actually an invasion going on and more than meets the eye.
It's a great use of corporate language to hide how a corporation behaving as a state is disguising truly horrific actions.
same
Yeah me too I quite liked it, I like how it seems so routine and shows how the Republic is big and unwieldy, and doesn't know what's really going on at Naboo
@Tesco People talk about how 'uhhh, taxation?' is in this film when it's literally mentioned twice in the entire film (the crawl and the Senate).
The taxation isn't the main issue and conflict - the threat to Naboo is. That's why Sidious appears, the Jedi are attacked, and the invasion begins within minutes of them boarding the ship.
@Tesco Plinkett: "TPM has no main character"
Ensemble casts : "Am I a joke to you?"
You know he’s good when he keeps us hooked by talking about words for 30 minutes
If schaff was my English teacher, I'd be a much better student.
Literary critics/booktubers: 👁👄👁
"I used the words to discuss the words."
Wait until you find out books exist
I never realised how funny the sentence “hoping to resolve the matter with a blockade of deadly battle ships” is
It’s like, “hoping to negotiate with a horde of killer chainsaw robots”
We hope to resolve the matter with a nuclear warhead
sounds like the US tbh
I think that was the point, it was meant to sound ironic.
Honestly, if my enemies knocked on my door with a horde of killer chainsaw robots, I would start negotiating real quick.
I love how in literally all these Star Wars ranking videos Rise of Skywalker always manages to be at the bottom
Because he is biased hypocrite
@@kracken1894 LOL How? That Movie is BEYOND atrocious. He's NOT a "bIASed HypOcRiTe" at all here.
@@kracken1894 Or maybe its just that the movie is terrible in most ways, even many of the sequel fans agree the movie its quite a mess, Im not a big fan but I appreciate episodes 7 and 8 for what they were trying to do but 9 is a mess that tries to introduce concepts that were never there to begin with, tries to tie in too many plot points because previous movies couldnt be bothered to do so and just overall has too many conveniences that do not make much sense, and all of that bleeds into other aspects like the opening crawl for example, the fact they had to put the Palpatine revival there because they knew they didnt had the time to show it onscreen
@@Gadget-Walkmen Lmao yes he is. All the complaints he had about the title crawl were present in Episode 3's crawl and he just made some BS excuses as to why it's good. He is biased as hell stop simping.
@@josepablobonillajimenez6297 Most of the concepts were there to begin with and those "conveniences" are present in almost all of star wars. The movie is fine, you guys are just blinded by bias.
One tiny thing I wish was different in Revenge of The Sith’s crawl is have “Chancellor Palpatine” in all caps as a way of foreshadowing him becoming The Emperor and turning Anakin to the dark side. Thanks to you, I’ll never be able to view these crawls the same way again
He’s ranking everything except Illumination because he doesn’t want too.
But you can’t escape the Illumination ranking James.
It is i n e v i t a b l e.
Perhaps he's waiting for the Mario movie to come out first
The apotheosis is upon us
@@one-onessadhalf3393 *didja hear the word?*
what's the word?
**finger snaps**
You hit the nail on the head with General Grievous, I am still confused with this character even after all these years. A droid monstrosity pops up in the last movie and we're supposed to just fear him all of a sudden.
But I presume the actual battle on Coruscant was included in Lucas' original 4 hour cut, that's why the trimming
He actually appeared before this in the 2003 cartoon, and was honestly incredibly terrifying. They then, for some reason, proceeded to nerf him, and now he's this pathetic bastard.
@@Kwiitchi blame George
@@Kwiitchi that wasn’t actually George Lucas’ vision for the character, as he didn’t oversee much of the development of the cartoon. The truest recreation of Lucas’ vision for the character is, believe it or not, that which appears in the sequels.
Edit: *PREQUELS NOT SEQUELS AAAAAAHHHHHHHH*
@@aduckwithayoutubechannel the sequels...?
@@Kwiitchi Grievous's whole MO is striking quickly and unexpectedly and then retreating. Like literally his character is written around retreating. That's the only reason he survived so long.
I've heard some people that don't like "Episode IV: A New Hope" say that it makes the crawl worse because originally, the changes of the music lined up with the paragraphs appearing onscreen
This is the main reason the crawl of the '77 film is the best - the sound and visuals marry up perfectly. None of the later crawls managed to replicate that piece of art.
With regards to the Empire opening crawl, I think the implication is that Luke was leading the crew that actually found Hoth as a rebel base. You know just like how Hera was in charge of the ghost crew when they found Chopper base. At least that's my read of the situation
how about "A group of freedom fighters with their hero Luke Skywalker."
My brother and I have been rewatching all the Star Wars films before I return to college later this month. We actually talked about how some crawls are really good and others are ridiculous and they dump a crazy amount of vital exposition. Glad to see Schaff cover this topic!
I love how schaf uses the word chicanery in all of his videos lately. He started doing it right after his better call Saul video and that was the name of his favorite episode
he orchestrated it! schaffrillas!
Now that he's done the crawls, I'd love to see James' take on the opening scenes of each film. It might seem a bit gratuitous after the crawls, but in my opinion, a few of these are some of the most iconic scenes in film.
Revenge of The Sith opening scene number 1 all the time 🔥
Revenge of the Sith is first place. There, there's the entire list
@@therublixcube3052 The original Star Wars competes pretty heavily with it I'd say. But it's definitely up there.
Like A New Hope
I. AGREE.
This video has been up for 22 seconds, and I can already say that if “The Dead Speak!” isn’t dead last, then it’s “War!”
*its treason then
Oh great, a new variation of "Finally, it's here" bots.
@@FrahdChikun I hate these bots so much and youtube refuses to do anything about them
Sure its kinda weird to have palpatines kidnapping in the crawl, but imagine if the opening to episode 3 wasnt that epic shot of the battle
You could still do the epic shot but instead, we could follow the battle towards the ground and see Grevious land to kidnap Palps
@@lonebattledroid4474 The pacing would still be a bit odd as there would have to be some sort of a time jump between the kidnap and them succesfully recovering him. If its resolved too quick, the fact that he's kidnapped at all wouldn't hold much weight.
I think the shot could've been there, just not the opener. I think opening on Grievous absolutely wrecking some clone troopers would've been very impactful. It introduces him as a character and the things he's capable of, making him less of a baffling addition to the story. You could also make the audience jump which would be fun imo lol
And with the opening on Grievous slaying the clones would've be a thematic rhyme with new hope's opening
Honestly, it's fine. At this point we just think of the chancellor as a weakling, so it's expected that some general of the opposition got to kidnap him. We don't really need to know how it happened. Then, it is revealed that he's actually really powerful, but also in kahoots with Dooku, so, again, it makes even more sense that he got captured.
33:00 One indicator of how fantastic that one paragraph is is that they made an entire movie out of it.
Too bad that movie sucked.
@@korvo3427 L opinion
One flaw with the ROTS one you didn't mention is it probably has the most inaccurate statement in any of the crawls.
"The Republic is crumbling!" In context it isn't referring to moral degradation or corruption, it is explicitly referring to losing the war in military terms, that the republic is faltering against Dooku's forces... that the war is causing a struggle, either militarily, logistically or economically. but we don't see much, if any of that at all in the movie... Coruscant is... seemingly entirely unaffected, we don't even see any of the lingering damage from the recent attack!
it's probably the most pristine recent battleground in film/TV history.. and senators are on open-topped platforms attending operas a couple of days later...
comparing to the source of inspiration, old newsreels, The USA looked more affected by WW2 in a visceral sense, nightlife diminished, bond drives, signs that the war was HAPPENING and had both direct and indirect effects on the homefront, but Coruscant had enemy boots on the ground, a battle of incomprehensible scale happening right in it and above it. The entire setting of Coruscant should have felt like London during the Blitz in this movie, but it doesn't and it feels like the crawl is just lying to you.
This is the Star Wars content we totally didn’t know we needed
The Backstroke of the West has a very underrated opening crawl
The war came!
The republic encountered
Two squares fight the vehemence
The improbity fills the world
The space general of the alliance is skillful
Kidnap the D the speaker the conduct
The proper abruption alliance troops tries
Ratio prosperous drive with the
Episode I
THE PHANTOM MENACE
Turmoil has engulfed the Galactic Republic. The taxation of trade routs to outlying star systems is in dispute.
In addition to this, the trade federation has clearly violated zoning regulations and refuses to pay the fine. Instead they have taken the issue to court, sending their best lawyers.. to litigate the... zzzzz
Aw, you fell asleep during the best part.
"sending their best lawyers to litigate the matter. With swords. Made of frickin' laser beams."
@@imveryangryitsnotbutter better call maul
@@imveryangryitsnotbutter but one of them is an higher hill incarnated and an hologram dude is speaking
I remember that one Rogue One teaser where they single out that segment form the New Hope crawl and put those battle sounds over it. Chilling stuff.
Wait, they did that? Where can it be found?
@@StopmotionSamurai th-cam.com/video/w9BuyiFvLJA/w-d-xo.html I think its this one
@@StopmotionSamurai th-cam.com/video/w9BuyiFvLJA/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=Deathstar%27sRandom i think this is it :)
In regards to Empire, I think it would have been good to say Leia was the one leading the rebel group as she had much much more control, even being in the command center when evacuating Hoth.
Yeah I thought that too but I guess the crawl is meant to highlight Luke as the main character
@@twicejaeger6997 While I can see that, it still feels weird because I feel Leia and Han were more focused on in Empire than the other original movies, and therefore feels at least one of them should be mentioned in the crawl
My favorite part was when the Phantom of the Menace crawl said “It’s JarJarin’ Time” right at the end, and then immediately cuts to imperial droids getting Jar’d on.
Well, my favorite part of the crawl was when the Droids said "It's Roger Roger Time" and proceeded to Roger Roger all over Binks
Ok.
i did not think we could get almost forty minute out of nine opening crawls but here we are, and i'm not disappointed
Only using Backstroke of the West clips for the ROTS reference is subtle gold
Until recently, when playing the LEGO Star Wars complete saga, I finally understood that "the phantom menace" refers to Palpatine/Sith and how he is the menace behind the curtains, like how you can't see a ghost/phantom. Before that I actually had no idea what it meant and never 'cared' enough to look it up, even though I perfectly knew the meaning of the words, just couldn't relate it to anything.
The man made an almost 40 minute video out of just the opening crawls of the star wars movies. Respect
When the opening crawl said "its starring time" i really cried, truly one of the wars ever
When Han Solo said "Solo Mode activated", one of my favorite SW moments
Starb
@@newsaxonyproductions7871 I love that this meme is stilll going
@@Dgjserffft I personally find it annoying as hell, morbius doesn’t deserve so much attention. Also it’s just boring in general
@@myrealusername2193 -🤓
The capitalization issue of #9 is pretty much a huge issue I have that nobody else cares about in the newer Diary of a Wimpy Kid books
That's exactly what I was thinking! I hate how they write every other word in all caps in the newer books.
Seeing Schaffrillas overanalyze the opening crawls gives me life
You should rank all of the SW character’s names. Can’t wait to see what he thinks of Jedi Master Sha’a Gi!
Haha, good idea! Star Wars has a couple of strange names.
That would be a 6 hour video if it was literally every name lol. It would be cool to make a list of the best ones
There's a character that's called "Glup Shitto" if I'm not mistaken
@krisscihist6737 isn’t there a Star Wars character just named Cloud?
What about Ima-Gun Di? (Jedi that literally dies in the only CW episode he appears in)
This man's dedication to ranking everything Star Wars related except for the Star Wars movies themselves truly makes him a force to be reckoned with
Edit: oh yeah, Letterboxd exists my bad
Rate of lightsaber colors (and said inconsistency of such since the series gets the blue and green savers confused), when?
He will in TH-cam one way or another.
He is the Force to be reckoned with.
I personally think that the opening crawls for The Mandalorian, Obi Wan, and Boba Fett were the best ones. They were short and concise and didn't give too much exposition of too much value (Unlike "Somehow Palpatine returned"). Good stuff Disney
Wait, the shows didn't have opening crawls. Is this a joke or did I watch something else?
wait- 'somehow palpatine returned' is REAL?
@@SwizzleDrizzl oh yes, it's horrible. It's like "they fly now".
@@SwizzleDrizzl It’s about as real as palpatine returning. Which is very real if you don’t know.
@@SwizzleDrizzl It's a real line, not part of the crawl though.
Thanks Schaff. I’ve been having a rough time lately, and watching you hilariously rank the SW Crawls made me feel better. Keep on with your awesomeness
Weird he didn't mention the Purple CGI Elephant that just randomly showed up in the 6th movie's crawl
I thought “War!” was a cool opening to RotS’s crawl. It was the first time I saw an exclamation mark in one of them, indicating that it was something to be taken seriously.
As someone who's never bothered to read a Star Wars crawl a day in my life I find this video to be very informative so thanks.
I would like but silly goofy ahh Reddit number be funny 69 lmao
@@NAFProjects Now you've made a damned fool of yourself.
His creativity when it comes to what to review and rank is absolute gold
I gotta give your editing props, it's really improved over the last year.
I think my favorite crawl is Rouge One because it didn’t have one. It immediately sets a different tone and tells you that this movie isn’t going the same direction
Big fan of RLM and I love the occasional references you make to them (including the less obvious homages like specific lines delivered with specific inflections). I think it is because of RLM that I got your C-3PO ranking video recommended to me. After that I made it here, and this sealed it - you've got a new subscriber. Keep up the great work!
After this video
I am 100% convinced this dude can overanalyze and make a half hour long video on any animated media in existence.
Here, he outright said that The Empire Strikes Back is the best Star Wars movie, with which I wholeheartedly agree. It is my favorite movie as well.
While not my favorite (that's Revenge of the Sith), Empire Strikes Back truly is the best Star Wars movie in every conceivable way
@@christonadams9046 I dunno. It doesn't really work well as a standalone, considering it has no real proper beginning nor end.
Hence why I always defer to A New Hope.
I don't think that's an unpopular opinion, though. Even if your favorite is another movie, like A New Hope, Return of the Jedi, or Revenge of the Sith, I think most people will agree that Empire is objectively the most well-crafted.
@@minicle426 umm yeah, because it's something called, a sequel. I would a sequel not be great if it doesn';t work as a standalone? That's like saying the two towers and return of the king are not good cuz they don't make sense without fellowship of the ring. Like duuh.
@@mihaimercenarul7467, reminds me of people saying endgame sucks because it doesn’t work as a standalone when it’s not meant to be a standalone
You should rank every movie based on how good r2 and 3po are in that movie since they’re the only ones in all 9
Yes
I love how you used the version of the A New Hope crawl that doesn't even say "A New Hope." I also noticed you used the original versions of the explosions of the Death Star and Alderaan.
Huzzah! A Man of Quality!
@@IbilisSLZ LOL That's NOT the case of at all as the original explosions of the Death Star and Alderaan are VASTLY better than the original completely so!
@@Gadget-Walkmen Erm.... you compare original explosions with original ones....
@@IbilisSLZ I mean the special editions explosions are done better than the original ones from impact effects done much better! Simple as that!
@@Gadget-Walkmen I kinda disagree, I know it's just space opera not full sci-fi, but „simpler” explosions from non-special edition look more realistic.
Another point about the use of capitalization is that the earlier movies only capitalized the important named stuff, like you would when first encountering a character in a screenplay, so it works,
Rise of Skywalker just threw that screenplay-esque capslock out the window by capitalizing "revenge".
I like the aspect of it that you have to wait for the text to scroll so you can really take it in, kinda like how we have to wait for the bojack season 6 review
IMO, the reason the first crawl reads so much better and so differently from the others (forgetting for a moment that it's the first) is that it was originally *six paragraphs* but Lucas let Brian de Palma and Jay Cocks rewrite it. Those guys sadly never wrote anything else for Star Wars again but damn if they didn't NAIL the franchise's very first impression on its audience.
I don't think anyone would ever say ANH's crawl is anything less than perfect. It has an unfair disadvantage being the intro, however they give you enough to know what's happening and filling you in on what's going on without having to see anything else.
The one thing about Return of the Jedi's crawl I didn't hear mentioned is how it pumps the twist. "When completed, this ultimate weapon will spell certain doom...." but ACTUALLY (note the appropriate caps) the Death Star does not need to be completed to spell certain doom for them, making that twist so much more shocking. Anyway, very fun video, thanks!
It is a bit of a longer read, but Labyrinth of Evil does a good job introducing Grievous and describing the beginning of the Battle of Coruscant
This type of fun, yet wacky content is exactly why I’m subscribed:))
I always love when you do Star Wars content it’s great
Same here. This is the way.
Yes.
Though I may not agree with all of his ideas, hearing Schaff rant about stuff like this is almost always entertaining
@@newsaxonyproductions7871 agreed! Especially with Ralph breaks the internet.
@@newsaxonyproductions7871 I totally agree
I can't wait to see how he ranks WAR! and THE DEAD SPEAK!
Interesting idea for a video, love it! I mostly agree with your take, my only major critique is that the Force Awakens’ crawl doesn’t really establish what the New Republic is. Considering the movie doesn’t either, it makes sense why this is, but that should have definitely been a priority when building on the established world. Same with the First Order, which is necessary since they are the main antagonists of the trilogy.
Otherwise, I never noticed that connection between Return of the Jedi and a New Hope, such strong storytelling!
TLDR
9. Episode 9 the rise of skywalker 2:24
8. Episode 8 the last jedi 7:39
7. Episode 1 the phantom menace 10:52
6. Episode 2 attack of the clones 13:52
5. Episode 5 the empire strikes back 16:39
4. Episode 3 revenge of the sith 21:10
3. Episode 7 the force awakens 25:15
2. Episode 6 return of the jedi 28:30
1. Episode 4 a new hope 32:00
Some people might interpret this as Rise of Skywalker ranked at the top.
@@caelincoolz5814 I'd agree with you if they hadn't numbered them, unless you interpret 9th place as being 1st then their should be no confusion.
Lol
I like when he said “It’s crawlin time”
Love how the edit at 0:37 looks like something you actually would see in the star wars universe.
Funny shiney crab posts once again!
Yes, a wholly original ranking of one of the things that makes Star Wars so iconic! I too think A New Hope's opening crawl is the best one for many reasons, several of which you just mentioned. Sets up some of the lore, excites the viewer, & is worded perfectly. And it's all gift wrapped by a fantastic opening sequence. So glad I'm subscribed to this guy!
You actually forgot to include the actual best opening crawl of the whole series, man. It goes like this:
“Corneria. Fourth planet of the Lylat system. The evil Andross turned this once thriving system into a wasteland of near extinction.
General Pepper of the Cornerian army was successful in exiling this maniacal scientist to the barren, deserted planet, Venom.
Five years later, General Pepper noticed strange activity coming from Venom. James McCloud, Pigma Dengar, and Peppy Hare of the Star Fox team were sent to investigate. Upon their arrival, Pigma betrayed the team, and James and Peppy were captured by Andross.
Peppy barely escaped Venom and returned home to tell James' son Fox about his father's fate.
A few years have passed. Andross has again invaded the Lylat system. General Pepper has turned to a new Star Fox team headed by Fox McCloud to save Corneria and free the Lylat system, once again.”
Jokes aside this shit is really good tbh
God I wish Star Fox didn’t flounder as a franchise
@@emblemblade9245 it… didn’t?
Star Fox Zero flopped, but the franchise still has a huge history and it hasn’t been long enough to be considered “dead”. IMO we might even see something from it in the next direct or something
I love the Crawl in Revenge of the Sith: “War!” Gets me every time!
Reminds me of the Game of Thrones Lore line, "Rebellion!"
Imagine if the opening crawl of Rise of Skywalker actually was Papa Palpatine’s message to the galaxy. It would be a great way to change the status quo with it being the last movie in the saga
This is a 30 minute video. Truly a Schaff moment
Ok I really loved this video, not mentioning my love for Star Wars, I loved the descriptions, the comparisons, the references and the editing in this one. It was overall very entertaining and funny
I love that rise of skywalker will do the worst at everything, not even sure if it could be considered a running gag 😂
2:18 | Star Wars Infinites: The Rise of Skywalker
7:29 | Star Wars Infinites: The Last Jedi
10:49 | Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace
13:45 | Star Wars: Episode II - Attack of the Clones
16:34 | Star Wars: Episode V - The Empire Strikes Back
21:03 | Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith aka *THE best Star Wars movie of all time! Yup, I said it!*
No, Schaffri. The movie is awesome. Get over it.
25:04 | Star Wars Infinites: The Force Awakens
28:18 | Star Wars: Episode VI - Return of the Jedi
31:53 | Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope
Tf is star wars infinites? Also nah empire is the best
@@BatmanForever1995. I looked it up and from what I can tell SW Infinities is a non-canon book trilogy so oof (tbh I kinda agree tho)
Nah empire is better
Your analysis on ANH’s crawl was spot on!
Schaff is doing anything he can to stall ranking the Illumination movies
Honorable mention: the opening crawl for the KOTOR games. Gives context to the games perfectly.
The capitalization in the opening crawl in Rise of Skywalker feels like someone just copied it straight from the script without changing it from that syntax. I screenplays, characters and important places or phrases are capitalized the first time they are introduced. It felt like that was the vibe, but they never did it before so it was extra weird.
The fact that a sequel trilogy movie made it to top3 is impressive.
I’m not surprised considering how much he loves The Forces Awakens.
It was good
Schaff loves force awakens so it’s not surprising
Atleast it was the best on of the three movies
It shouldn't have though, since it's got serious world-building issues. Why is the Republic; the Resistance?
I missed the opening credits of Rise of Skywalker, and I can say that it was pretty much essential to understand the movie.
Schaf is an English teacher's wet dream. Makes an entire 36 minute video essay on... the title crawls? And still keeps it interesting?
Schaffrillas is gonna wait until April 1st and actually rank the movies just to mess with us.
a 30 minute video about opening crawls is exactly what i need while i clean my carpet; thank you schaffrillas!