@@jeffthompson1869when it comes to Suno and Udio yes I think the vocals in Udio are better. I think Suno writes better songs than Udio though. As for Mureka, they are still developing but have some unique features that make sense to me. Let’s see where they go next.
I'd love my own melodies, lyrics and voice to be input and then used to morph etc. I like to think that is not too far away. I have excellent results on Donna AI with my own lyrics from my own songs after regenerating a few times.
Thanks for the informative video Does the Ownership Certificate give you the right to use a Content ID on TH-cam? Can I distribute via DistroKid instead?
The results certainly sound like the sort of 'professional song' we're used to hearing in mainstream popular music but it seems self evident that if the source materials are from historical analysis there can never be any real innovation?
Can someone tell me which format of a cover photo is when you are releasing a song on mureka platform because they are just telling me , "image format is incorrect" have tried PNG, Jpeg, pdf all showing the same
Sure, and I'm sure that will always stay during rehearsals and sessions with my band. But I for one spend many more hours in the studio by myself and then it's a great way to generate some quick ideas that may be worthwhile to further develop.
Mureka claims you can release the song on platforms for sale but the cover photo cannot upload all the format PNG, jpeg and pdf are declined what format are they accepting?
@@LanewoodStudios Ja it’s been to much like cheating for me unless I can full fully customise it from the bare bones , I know what you think played it ur self but I’m only a singer but with loads of ideas !
vocals sound great although it stole if i could rule the world by coldplay , udios great very short songs like 30 seconds but doesnt extend well and does not to stick to lyrics this is alot better at sticking to lyrics
Tried that a while ago in combination with RipX DAW. Was not too impressed at the time. Suno was really the first one that seemed usable to me. But maybe Stable Audio has improved as well.
@@LanewoodStudios For basic tracks Stable Audio is not very good, but it really came alive when I used longer description, for example a 500 character description of a cinematic ambient/dramatic drum piece worked really well. Stable Audio/Udio are about crafting the perfect prompt.
@@LanewoodStudios suno quality is very good , if they can increase the prompt characters limit from 120 and 200 to around 500 to 800 with the same quality then that will be a good leap forward
Bir şarki yaparken şarkının ritmini biz seçelim melodiyi kendimiz seçelim.sesleri biz seçelim.veya amatör mp3 kaydini verelim o kendi profesyonel çalsın bizim sesi klonlasin
The problem arises since these AI programs have the right to release copyrights for sounds? They appear overnight as gods with full rights in music who ask for money, that will never happen guys :)
@@LanewoodStudios I don't care about their development, i wonder what they dreamed of thinking that they have the right to offer licenses to songs. Is there a global music department that gives companies the right to decide what music is authentic and release usage rights to producers? They appear overnight and ask for money as if the music is an object and belongs to them, it looks more like a scam.
@@LanewoodStudios They can no longer make money with plugins, now they come up with this AI nonsense. How stupid they can be to say that they have the right to license music as if they invented music lol.
Well if you write a song the copyright is automatically yours. You can register it so you have a record of it but the copyright of anything you create is automatically yours. What the AI music generators are saying that if you ‘create’ a song using their tooling the copyright is still yours if you are a paying subscriber. If you are not paying they keep the copyright of the song. This is all separate of the discussion that their AI was probably trained on copyrighted music to begin with. But if you yourself listen to a copyrighted song, are inspired by it and create something similar, the copyright is still yours. Unless you have directly ripped of the melody or something. That is why there discussions are so difficult.
@@LanewoodStudios The only place he could survive these AI algoritms would be in daws, Logic has an algorithm that generates the elements from the root and lets you edit them in all their depth. It is much healthier to put element upon element to build your own story than to receive a final result of poor quality like here, the quality of the song made with Logic in 15 minutes is net superior and the most important thing is something real that comes from you. Cubase lets you use any sound from Mediabay in the key and musicality of the project if you're really just starting out and don't know how to make your own samples.
this one is really bad compared to Suno and Udio - it doesn´t even care about the music style you type - the results are totally unmusical nonsense - a waist of time.
Well, if it relies on a reference track to produce good output why even have the other options or basic mode. All I got on basic or using other prompts was the opposite of the style I had selected, a jumble of words that didn't follow the lyrics, and out of tune vocals. Disappointed after my first tries. But I'll try the reference track option and see if that changes my mind.
@@DmitryIvanovDfcreative that’s annoying. Did not get that myself but there may be still a big then. Maybe your uploaded file was much bigger than the ones I tried.
It looked so promising, but delivered crap. If I want Metal, I don't want Punk or Indie styles that it comes up with. 6 free isn't enough if it doesn't give you anything you like. It needs exclusions, things you don't want it to add. Oh well, that's the 5th Music Ai I've seen and so far the worst. Combine MusicFX and Mureka and it might start getting somewhere decent.
Well I think all AI platforms do not allow you to commercially distribute free tier generations. You have to pay for that first. But then you have commercial rights, is how I read it.
So let me know your thoughts on Mureka AI. And if you like it, click the link to sign up for Mureka and get free credits to try it out!
bit.ly/3BNNYp5
It sounds like a slightly weaker version of Suno. The vocals sound synthetic to me. Udio is phenomenal on vocals.
@@jeffthompson1869when it comes to Suno and Udio yes I think the vocals in Udio are better. I think Suno writes better songs than Udio though. As for Mureka, they are still developing but have some unique features that make sense to me. Let’s see where they go next.
I don't want a completed song, I want a band member. 'Here's the guitar part I wrote, please supply the bassist's part'
That’s a cool idea actually, especially for music production. We may get there sooner than you expect!
Toontrack?
@@slawaschwed the drums on that self produced track? I think it was yes.
@@LanewoodStudios Toontrack's "Audio Tracker" makes both drums and bass, it's also an "AI" process ))
exactly
OMG this is not just a game changer..this is a miracle 😊
You sound like a thumbnail 😉
Udio is the best right now. My page is a testament to this.
@@stevencasteel they do have the best voices I think. I like the songs that Suno comes up with better though but it’s also a taste thing of course 😉.
I am a new user of Mureka It definitely is nice . It gives me a great song i wanted.
Great!
Thanks for the video, what is the situation regarding rights with the paid subscription ?
@@isham16 according to Mureka they’re yours.
Thank you, I find this site quite interesting so I will give it a try . Thank you for this well organized review.
i'm happy they still sound like very bad mp3 but it is still impressive
Yes we can still improve on this in our studios 😉.
14:10 this version was great!
@@nolow_life 👍😎
I'd love my own melodies, lyrics and voice to be input and then used to morph etc. I like to think that is not too far away.
I have excellent results on Donna AI with my own lyrics from my own songs after regenerating a few times.
@@StratsRUs haven’t tried that one yet.
Thanks for the informative video
Does the Ownership Certificate give you the right to use a Content ID on TH-cam?
Can I distribute via DistroKid instead?
@@kennethlua4928 you can just register it as your own song.
BTW, I only got 6 credits to play with, total
I don’t get 6 credits per day
If had a "my voice" generated model, was almost perfect..!
Lots of programs can do that. Split vocal stems the use something like ace studio
great stuff
Thanks!
The main question is - can you upload and make your own voice? Instead of just limited list of voices
At the moment not yet. But seems like a good update.
The results certainly sound like the sort of 'professional song' we're used to hearing in mainstream popular music but it seems self evident that if the source materials are from historical analysis there can never be any real innovation?
I don't know. Are most of us not doing similar things as human songwriters?
Can someone tell me which format of a cover photo is when you are releasing a song on mureka platform because they are just telling me , "image format is incorrect" have tried PNG, Jpeg, pdf all showing the same
I have not used that myself but maybe someone else has the answer for you.
I want to add AI vocals to my instrumental club track in the key of the track. Anyone knows what app does that?
@@Bartetmedia perhaps try Audimee!
There’s nothing like making music together. Besides it’s still very much like a copy of a copy of an original…if you listen carefully.
Sure, and I'm sure that will always stay during rehearsals and sessions with my band. But I for one spend many more hours in the studio by myself and then it's a great way to generate some quick ideas that may be worthwhile to further develop.
Mureka claims you can release the song on platforms for sale but the cover photo cannot upload all the format PNG, jpeg and pdf are declined what format are they accepting?
Not sure. Someone else had the same question. Maybe someone else knows.
This is so much better than Udio or Suno, OMG, this is the best AI music generator !!!!
Which aspects make it so much better for you?
Lol if you ref one of their metal songs, i can hear clearly Marilyn Manson on that track. I would assume they don't have coyprights about him...
Interesting, which MM song are you hearing in which example?
Anyone know what is the maximum length of a song that Mureka AI can generate?
I don’t but maybe someone else can help you.
Can you export the stems as midi ?
I did not see that option at the moment. You would have to generate the stems in Mureka and then convert those to midi in another program.
Shame all audio to midi still sucks
@@LanewoodStudios just be handy to customise it more and take it back to basics
@@evieruth01yes it would be very useful if you want to re-produce these tracks.
@@LanewoodStudios Ja it’s been to much like cheating for me unless I can full fully customise it from the bare bones , I know what you think played it ur self but I’m only a singer but with loads of ideas !
vocals sound great although it stole if i could rule the world by coldplay , udios great very short songs like 30 seconds but doesnt extend well and does not to stick to lyrics this is alot better at sticking to lyrics
Glad you liked it!
Can you download a video from Mureka?
I think it's all about audio at this time!
I have yet to see anything beat Stable Audio
Tried that a while ago in combination with RipX DAW. Was not too impressed at the time. Suno was really the first one that seemed usable to me. But maybe Stable Audio has improved as well.
@@LanewoodStudios For basic tracks Stable Audio is not very good, but it really came alive when I used longer description, for example a 500 character description of a cinematic ambient/dramatic drum piece worked really well. Stable Audio/Udio are about crafting the perfect prompt.
@@LanewoodStudios suno quality is very good , if they can increase the prompt characters limit from 120 and 200 to around 500 to 800 with the same quality then that will be a good leap forward
Bir şarki yaparken şarkının ritmini biz seçelim melodiyi kendimiz seçelim.sesleri biz seçelim.veya amatör mp3 kaydini verelim o kendi profesyonel çalsın bizim sesi klonlasin
?
So what part do you play? Oh, that's right, you play the none musician with no pride.
I’m a guitar player in my band Awash whose music I produce as well.
The problem arises since these AI programs have the right to release copyrights for sounds? They appear overnight as gods with full rights in music who ask for money, that will never happen guys :)
It’s all relatively new so we’ll see how it develops in the future.
@@LanewoodStudios I don't care about their development, i wonder what they dreamed of thinking that they have the right to offer licenses to songs. Is there a global music department that gives companies the right to decide what music is authentic and release usage rights to producers? They appear overnight and ask for money as if the music is an object and belongs to them, it looks more like a scam.
@@LanewoodStudios They can no longer make money with plugins, now they come up with this AI nonsense. How stupid they can be to say that they have the right to license music as if they invented music lol.
Well if you write a song the copyright is automatically yours. You can register it so you have a record of it but the copyright of anything you create is automatically yours. What the AI music generators are saying that if you ‘create’ a song using their tooling the copyright is still yours if you are a paying subscriber. If you are not paying they keep the copyright of the song.
This is all separate of the discussion that their AI was probably trained on copyrighted music to begin with. But if you yourself listen to a copyrighted song, are inspired by it and create something similar, the copyright is still yours. Unless you have directly ripped of the melody or something. That is why there discussions are so difficult.
@@LanewoodStudios The only place he could survive these AI algoritms would be in daws, Logic has an algorithm that generates the elements from the root and lets you edit them in all their depth. It is much healthier to put element upon element to build your own story than to receive a final result of poor quality like here, the quality of the song made with Logic in 15 minutes is net superior and the most important thing is something real that comes from you. Cubase lets you use any sound from Mediabay in the key and musicality of the project if you're really just starting out and don't know how to make your own samples.
Where is the bit where you actually enjoy making music?
@@fattyboombatty7736 when you reproduce these tracks with real instruments.
Mureka souds like Suno. Not Very HiFi.
@@Trescaracterescomominimo yes I can understand what you mean.
this one is really bad compared to Suno and Udio - it doesn´t even care about the music style you type - the results are totally unmusical nonsense - a waist of time.
@@lumpielump3576 did you try with a reference track, which is really their main way of prompting?
@@LanewoodStudios no, I didn´t. will try it - thanks
Well, if it relies on a reference track to produce good output why even have the other options or basic mode. All I got on basic or using other prompts was the opposite of the style I had selected, a jumble of words that didn't follow the lyrics, and out of tune vocals. Disappointed after my first tries. But I'll try the reference track option and see if that changes my mind.
Mureka seems like a piece of Chinese ... low-quality product. Tried uploading my reference song and the page just hangs.
@@DmitryIvanovDfcreative that’s annoying. Did not get that myself but there may be still a big then. Maybe your uploaded file was much bigger than the ones I tried.
It looked so promising, but delivered crap. If I want Metal, I don't want Punk or Indie styles that it comes up with. 6 free isn't enough if it doesn't give you anything you like. It needs exclusions, things you don't want it to add. Oh well, that's the 5th Music Ai I've seen and so far the worst. Combine MusicFX and Mureka and it might start getting somewhere decent.
I think their text promoting is relatively new so maybe still needs some improvement. Their main way of prompting is by providing reference audio.
The copyright terms are very bad. No clear permission to distribute free tier works and anything you upload is theirs too
Well I think all AI platforms do not allow you to commercially distribute free tier generations. You have to pay for that first. But then you have commercial rights, is how I read it.
@@LanewoodStudiosI didn't mean commercially. Suno allows you to distribute basic tier stuff as long as it isn't monetised
@alejandrofernandez3478 ah ok, then I understand what you mean.
Quality is Bad.
As with the other services, I'm sure it will improve over time.