You both did an amazing job! Last time I watched the videos of you (Wintergatan) must be years ago. Last time I played Minecraft also years ago. And now I am sitting here, listening to this and remembering the time! And you just commented an hour ago. That's absurd! Thanks a lot. Can you guys tell which maschine took longer to create? I would guess the original but than I remembered the last 2 by 3 door i tried to build in minecraft.
i expected a noteblock cover of the marble machine song when I saw this video. what i didnt expect was a FUNCTIONAL recreation of the marble machine itself, holy crap
Can we appreciate the fact that He didn’t make a cover of the song, he made a functional in-game copy of the machine using gravel as marbles (you should use a block of sand, representing the black marble in the original video)
To be honest, I can understand it all, it IS simple.... just some gravel that fall trough strings that activate music that get sent back on top by pistons and slime blocks
I admire such people... Who can see "the whole picture" and, a the same time, not get overwhelmed by it, being focused on every little detail necessary to create the whole thing...
So much underrated because people don't know how hard doing this level redstone engineering in minecraft, I mean, forgot laser guns, space shuttles, or teleporting because this is way more hard
@@evernarten42 The comparator is like an observer block except the observer detects the updated block immediately. while the comparator detects the updated block but it gives/recieve a specific type of redstone power. im not too sure about this but this is from my experience from the past 😅😅
What blew my mind is the fact that the amount of gravel at the end is the exact number of gravel at the start, and in the same shape-NO GRAVEL WAS LOST DURING THE PROCESS!
To be fair, that part isn’t difficult so long as you have a computer that can run this without lag. The rest of it is definitely very impressive, though
So not only did you replicate the music, the marble feed, programming wheel... You even replicated the breakdown, and the mechanical noises... _WINTERGATAN WANTS TO KNOW YOUR LOCATION_
The reason it's so mysterious is because it's self-supervising. TH-cam doesn't know how it works much better than you do, because it uses some form of machine learning (and that's about as much as TH-cam has revealed, this system is a trade secret after all) to recommend videos. That system has access to massive amounts of data, and it gets rewarded for keeping people on the site for as long as possible. See this video by CGP Grey: th-cam.com/video/R9OHn5ZF4Uo/w-d-xo.html Disclaimer: I'm not associated with CGP Grey at all I just like his videos.
@@chexo3 i really hate that kind of comments. "OH the algorythmus is so shit" "OH yt 500 likes 3comments yt, ur trasg YT" and like "1st on vid" idk why these people are allowed to use internet
So many creative ideas in Minecraft, but this is simply mind blowing, I can't imagine how long this must've taken to make to replicate the exact notes in Wintergatan's video
Everyone literally needs to see this because first off redstone engineering is hard but as always there’s always that one kid. Good job sir this was very amazing👏👏👏👏👏
Already discovered. It is called: "process of training own white blood cells to detect and kill own cancer cells" our body is quite interesting biologicial weapon...
TIME-CAPSULE FOR ME: sup future me am i doing well? it's me 18 yo me. Am i getting enough exercise and eating well? do i have a relationship? did i get a job yet? was paramedic school a bitch and 1/2 or what lol? anyway nice talking to me be sure to break any mold of everyday life and have yourself a damn good one
There is alot to be said about the work here. i really hope that this isnt lost in translation, because I really want this person to receive this compliment very badly. not only did this person create a working marble music machine in the minecraft world, he did a shot for shot remake of the original video. Even the oart when he shuts the machine off and manually actuates the switches to make that tone. so big props to you. I could only imagine the amount of time you needed to create this and execute the video.
Building an amazing albeit insane contraption in real life out of wood and various moving parts is one thing. When somebody builds it in Minecraft with way too much redstone and various blocks to count, that just brings the number of insanely cool things humans can do with their power up by a million. I know you must have been tired after making this really cool machine in Minecraft, but I bet you were very proud of yourself when you did finish making it. To be honest, you should be proud! I am just beyond speechless about the fact that you put so much time, effort, and planning into creating this. You are so crazy talented, my friend. You did a great job at building this. Kudos to you!
Welcome to beautiful minecraft redstone gravel machine that is essentially wintergratan's marble machine its amazing glad if found this in my recommended
It never ceases to amaze me how there are people who will put tremendous amounts of effort into such small rewards just because they had an idea and wanted to make it a reality. And, I appreciate it so much.
@@lucassurgeon4122 and ILikeCHEEZ9 I'm sorry for the confusion I caused in my choice of words. With 'animation' I didn't mean the term in graphics. I meant the blocks going round and round, mimicking the marbles in the machine.
YES! Co cool :) thanks for making, didn't see this one until now!
Wintergatan Thank you very much for your wonderful machine! I worked to make it look like that! ;)
You both did an amazing job! Last time I watched the videos of you (Wintergatan) must be years ago. Last time I played Minecraft also years ago. And now I am sitting here, listening to this and remembering the time! And you just commented an hour ago. That's absurd! Thanks a lot.
Can you guys tell which maschine took longer to create? I would guess the original but than I remembered the last 2 by 3 door i tried to build in minecraft.
Wintergatan Hello
本物で草
L
i expected a noteblock cover of the marble machine song when I saw this video. what i didnt expect was a FUNCTIONAL recreation of the marble machine itself, holy crap
We have broken the 8 bit limit of likes on this comment
Anonymous User Let’s aim for the 32 bits limit... 2.147 Billion likes baby!
It’s not functional
@@AminTheKiller how is it not functional?
Holy crap indeed
See you guys in another year when the algorithm decides to recommend this
Just got recommended
Martin didn't see it until 3 months ago
TH-cam bullied me into watching this
See you friend
redline2466 I know right?
Can we appreciate the fact that He didn’t make a cover of the song, he made a functional in-game copy of the machine using gravel as marbles (you should use a block of sand, representing the black marble in the original video)
The black marble should be black concrete powder
Yes, this exactly!
you goddamn right
He did cover it though. You can't make those sounds in game lmao.
@@louisrobitaille5810 you can, there are 16 vanilla instruments for the noteblock including bell, bass, hat, and harp which were used here
should be 1 sand block in the gravel to represent that one black marble in original
l white and black concrete powder’d be good
Oh yeah!
The token black marble, if you will
@@BinaBearz 🤐😂🤣🤣
CheeseTruffles that didn’t exist a year ago I don’t think
You didn't just cover the song, *_You made a Minecraft version of the actual machine._*
You, sir, are amazing.
I was the 666th like 😈
Here, have one like
888 likes
@@sophiamariecruz987 887 now, did it just to prove you wrong >:)
Kinda just turned it into 1k. I feel proud
Coolest part about this is that you can technically build this in survival.
But gud luck
You should try
With 20 people it will still take a lifetime ) probably)
i mean he built it himself so with a group of people it might not take too long
@@VillagerManDude the building is fine, but you have to mine alot of materials. On top you need food and weapons (if not playing peaceful difficulty)
"So what instrument do you play?"
"...It's complicated..."
**yes**
True
Yesn't
I’m the whole band
He plays the minecraft
Mumbo Jumbo:
This redstone construction isn’t that complex.
The redstone construction:
69 likes i feel like im 9 yrs old
To be honest, I can understand it all, it IS simple.... just some gravel that fall trough strings that activate music that get sent back on top by pistons and slime blocks
@@Toni-vo5in The hard part is timing it all so it sounds like the music try doin that part
@@logicbugs9452 yup
@Antoine Larocque it’s really not,
I admire such people... Who can see "the whole picture" and, a the same time, not get overwhelmed by it, being focused on every little detail necessary to create the whole thing...
@M.Faathir Arsa Nope, just some observations made
@M.Faathir Arsa No problem ;)
@@Funknfritter of course I am :)
Masterpiece, it is.
haaaaa omg that was great
i love how you even recreated the breakdown
@Nightfury Matthew oh no
@@sanmarinocornedtuna5166 OH YES
that part was pretty cool
@@martinligabue He struck all the right keys.
You mean the "brakedown" ? xD
本人に認知されて賞賛まで貰ってるって本当に凄いし尊敬する
それはまさに私が思ったことでした。🙂
So much underrated because people don't know how hard doing this level redstone engineering in minecraft, I mean, forgot laser guns, space shuttles, or teleporting because this is way more hard
imma agree with u man this shit is more complicated than my simple redstone door AHAHA ( p.s. doesnt even work )
@@yumeteyus I still don't know what that triangle redstone thing does, and I'm playing minecraft for 9 years (like I was 8 y.o.first time I played Mc)
@@evernarten42 The comparator is like an observer block except the observer detects the updated block immediately. while the comparator detects the updated block but it gives/recieve a specific type of redstone power. im not too sure about this but this is from my experience from the past 😅😅
@@yumeteyus thx for the info
I'm a redstone master
What blew my mind is the fact that the amount of gravel at the end is the exact number of gravel at the start, and in the same shape-NO GRAVEL WAS LOST DURING THE PROCESS!
To be fair, that part isn’t difficult so long as you have a computer that can run this without lag. The rest of it is definitely very impressive, though
I mean that isn't real life. It shouldn't disappear. If its irl then yes, its an engineering success.
Unlike the original Marble Machine; in some cases, you could literally see marbles falling out.
@@key_after_key no its end lag the gravel doesnt fall out
I know! That little bit right there is so satisfying.
Martin would be proud of this Gravel Machine :>
Martin is proud of you man
This is mmx in minecraft. No flaws no nothing
He IS
what if it was made of *sand?*
Im proud
Kudos using the observer and rails to get individual traces without a space! I’d never have thought of that! Also great video!
Its widely used as it also doesnt cause lighting updates like redstone does so it massively prevents lag
This was absolutely insane, and i'm glad the algorithm recommended me this!
Zealous Being01 same here
Sometimes you have to love the algorithm 😆
I love how you imitated the real machine using gravel blocks and gravity. Nicely done. :D
So not only did you replicate the music, the marble feed, programming wheel...
You even replicated the breakdown, and the mechanical noises...
_WINTERGATAN WANTS TO KNOW YOUR LOCATION_
Wintergatan already knows their location. Check out the top comment.
@@AtomicBlastPony I have seen this.
He is a genius xD
When I pressed the like button on this comment, I single-handedly changed the like counter from 1.1K to 1.2K, I liked it that much.
すげーこれをマインクラフトで再現するとか天才かよ
きっと主さんめちゃくちゃ練習してそう
This masterpiece “released one year ago”
TH-cam: “seems like a good time to recommend”.
Huge wintergatan fan, nice.
Jadon Harper were at 69 likes I don’t wanna ruin it
The Bird there I ruined it myself
I got some good news for you!
The YT-Algorithm just found out that your video is amazing!!
good luck, and thanks for your beautiful build! :)
The reason it's so mysterious is because it's self-supervising. TH-cam doesn't know how it works much better than you do, because it uses some form of machine learning (and that's about as much as TH-cam has revealed, this system is a trade secret after all) to recommend videos. That system has access to massive amounts of data, and it gets rewarded for keeping people on the site for as long as possible. See this video by CGP Grey: th-cam.com/video/R9OHn5ZF4Uo/w-d-xo.html
Disclaimer: I'm not associated with CGP Grey at all I just like his videos.
Same
Peter or the other way around and have them all be sand and one gravel
@@chexo3 i really hate that kind of comments. "OH the algorythmus is so shit" "OH yt 500 likes 3comments yt, ur trasg YT" and like "1st on vid" idk why these people are allowed to use internet
@@xtal11111 relax man
OMG the gravel reuse system is mind blowing!
すげぇ
全自動じゃなくてしっかり演奏する部分も再現してる…
The fact that a masterpiece like this came out a year ago and has less than 100k views is just disappointing
224k
Wow, it tripled in a day,
You spoke too soon, huh?
The Algorithm is getting scary...
337k
Will be over 1M in a few days
This is seriously impressive. You've done some brilliant work that deserves more views
Parents: “Game is for kids”
That kid:
The Minecraft prodigy
The minecraft prodigy
The Minecraft prodigy
The Minecraft prodigy
lego works ahhhh
最近某界隈で音符ブロックが流行ってて昔マイクラでウィンターガッタン再現してんの見たなぁと思って調べたらこっち見つけて凄さにビックリした
マーブルマシンの趣旨さえも再現されてるの本当に凄い
1980: I bet there will be flying cars in the future
2019 Redstone Engineers "Well...we're almost there"
Redstone engineers deserve an official degree.
@Vidar G now there's honey if you want
Mumbo Jumbo: Cars? *TOWNS*
There is even a INFINITY POWER MAKER
2018*
cool
It’s him!
Yep
Hi ray
The least Liked verified comments
Geez guys. All he said was cool.
"Minecraft is only played by kids." My friends said
Never mind them, we are enough each others who know that fact isnt true!
He could be a kid
Vitaliq Then he must have been a legend!
I mean MINECRAFT is 1% player by dumb kids, 99% smart kids, and 100% adults smart
Slap his face.
まんま再現されてる..凄すぎる...
主さんめっちゃ頑張って演奏しとるやん…すご
配布ワールドだよ(？)
"you can do whatever you want with my music, just dont make it boring" -freddie mercury
What does that have to do with this
@@amilijoon communism
@slade good he says anyone can use his music for free if they don't make it boring
This isn't by Queen, is what @homsin means. So there. Also, this quote only applies to Queen songs anyway.
@@troykopczyk i know this song isnt by queen but i put it here because in this case wintergatan is an example of queen so i put that there
the fact that you went through the stress of performing the breakdown makes this video sooo much better. phenominal 👏 👏 👏
は？って思った人、本家を見てくれ！！！この再現度の高さがわかる！！！！
すごい！！！！！！！！！
こういうのホントに好き！！！！！！！
For blu~
本家から来た民です
Uh
"There are some bad things; please forgive"
Dude
Nothing as close to the perfection as your machine.
You deserve more views.
Redstone makers: Loads of subscribers
Noteblock music makers: Loads of subscribers.
Why not combine them both?
I mean noteblocks require redstone to make the music, so they kinda already are combined?
@@dandyrebellion I think what he mean is something like this
@@dandyrebellion you can do manual noteblock songs
So many creative ideas in Minecraft, but this is simply mind blowing, I can't imagine how long this must've taken to make to replicate the exact notes in Wintergatan's video
Just Some Guy without a Mustache i see you everywhere
I know right!
@@ckln7762 because he's Mistah. Zawarudo
NO
It's odd seeing so little likes on your comments
Everyone literally needs to see this because first off redstone engineering is hard but as always there’s always that one kid. Good job sir this was very amazing👏👏👏👏👏
これマーブルマシンのやつだよね
仕組みとかも再現してあるの天才すぎるし
砂循環してるのなんかかわいい(?)
自由落下ブロックとワイヤトリップを巧みに使った芸術作品ですよね…
てあるの天才すぎるし
砂循環してるのなんかかわいい
ッ
No offense I don't speak enchanting table
@@thebigblubrio5416 r/rareinsults
This guy will discover a cure for cancer but instead plays Minecraft
You say that like playing Minecraft isn’t equal to the other thing that wont be named
Priorities in check
Already discovered. It is called:
"process of training own white blood cells to detect and kill own cancer cells"
our body is quite interesting biologicial weapon...
He made the right call
Nah. Wintergatan is the one who would discover it
Teacher: come on guys, the test wasn’t that confusing!
The test:
This!
How to solve hard test.
1 focus on ez ones
2 after ez focus on what you know.
Your test plays music lucky
Haha! Yes! This is VERY funny! I have seen this many times before, yet it never fails to make me chuckle. Very clever, creative, and original!!!
I'm sorry but WTF is the link of your comment towards this video?
this is so lovely... you literally recreated a functional marble machine in mc.... what a labour of love
Teacher: So what instrument do you play?
Me: Yes.
me: Minecraft
LOL hell yeah
dead meme
The Gun!
I hope C418 will love this marble machine
Finally! A way I can tell my dad and mom video games do NOT cause violence
I feel bad for ya
@Anonymous 123 yeah stupid video game haters
Dang that is rough
It could be a bomb lol
Same except mine just limit my time even though I am using my creativity when I play games like minecraft.
When i saw the title: Nooooo you did not.....
After I watched the first 5 seconds of the video: ....wow, you really did it.
They really did it huh
me: *barely able to make a working piston door*
this dude:
Try bedrockedition
This looks more complicated than the wintergatan itself
I'm surprised noone has started a war yet... I would suppose they are on the same level though?
It's very debatable
Yoinker Man, war for what?
Because it is XD
fernando jose gonzalez olguin me? Yes i have
*MumboJumbo wants to know your location*
idk if this comment taken I just made it
Who?
A minecraft Redstone engineer
More like Levi Niha
@@thomasphillips885 Levi Niha, a musician who is recently into making music in Minecraft.
Someone should send this to Mumbo Jumbo
Shout out to all yall watching this 2 years from now after it was in everyone's recommended feed
Here I am!
@@megakaren2160 Awesome, a time traveller! What's the Bitcoin price in 2021?
@@charlesgoldt7943 yes
TIME-CAPSULE FOR ME: sup future me am i doing well? it's me 18 yo me. Am i getting enough exercise and eating well? do i have a relationship? did i get a job yet? was paramedic school a bitch and 1/2 or what lol? anyway nice talking to me be sure to break any mold of everyday life and have yourself a damn good one
Helloo
There is alot to be said about the work here. i really hope that this isnt lost in translation, because I really want this person to receive this compliment very badly.
not only did this person create a working marble music machine in the minecraft world, he did a shot for shot remake of the original video. Even the oart when he shuts the machine off and manually actuates the switches to make that tone. so big props to you.
I could only imagine the amount of time you needed to create this and execute the video.
As soon as nasa recruits all the red stone engineers we’lol be at the other end of the universe in no time
Actual insanity, I dont understand how one man can be so intelligent. You sir, have ascended above humanity
See you after 1 million views, you deserve to be remembered!!
再現出来るのも主もめちゃくちゃ凄いし音源の回路を作れるマイクラも凄い
Imagine being able to do something like this but with real world physics, Kappa.
How about marbles
Idk, is that possible?
@@therealsuper5828
was obviously never done before
You should find wintergaten...
@@aditiaputrakurniawan7173 wintergatan*
"Wintergatan has joined the server"
Hello Wintergarten.
"C418 has joined the server"
@@stresswaves01
*Minecraft soundtracks has joined the server*
@@artisticfox_vw *Moog City has joined the server*
The fact that someone took the time to make this is amazing by itself.
急にオヌヌメれらて気になって来たんだけど
主さんがんばっておりますなぁ
Building an amazing albeit insane contraption in real life out of wood and various moving parts is one thing. When somebody builds it in Minecraft with way too much redstone and various blocks to count, that just brings the number of insanely cool things humans can do with their power up by a million. I know you must have been tired after making this really cool machine in Minecraft, but I bet you were very proud of yourself when you did finish making it. To be honest, you should be proud! I am just beyond speechless about the fact that you put so much time, effort, and planning into creating this. You are so crazy talented, my friend. You did a great job at building this. Kudos to you!
Wintergatan: FINALLY! A WORTHY OPPONENT! OUR BATTLE WILL BE LEGENDARY!
す、すげー……再現度高すぎる………
砂利ブロックが本家の鉄球同様一周する仕組みになっているのが本当に凄いです！
The fact that Wintergatan is a Swedish band group and that Minecraft was created in Sweden blows my mind
Your Gravel Machine X is very cool.
この曲ほんと好き。というかこれを再現できる主ヤバすぎ。
日本人！
日本人だー！
やったー！同志がいる！
Welcome to beautiful minecraft redstone gravel machine that is essentially wintergratan's marble machine
its amazing
glad if found this in my recommended
Me: Well this probably isn't that complicated and I could do this myself
Also me: sees comparator
-no profit
"There are some bad things, but I worked hard so please forgive me" bro, you are a mastermind, dont worry
That's exactly the principle of the Marble Machine.
I'm impressed.
すごい再現率・・・！ 音もすごいけれど、それ以上にギミックに感動しました！
Mumbo Jumbo after seeing this masterpiece- Finally a worthy opponent.
"see the redstone is actually quite simple"
-mumbo jumbo in any of his redstone videos
Times are tough these days, people gotta make their own beat pads from Minecraft.
Respect from all of us redstone engineers
The amount of stress that is given out during the breakdown is immense
This is nothing short of genius. I would love to see more songs!
Fucking incredible! I was about to ask if Wintergatan saw it but I see his comment. So good, keep up the good work!
teacher: the homework isn't hard
homework:
@@Loosojsjks the homework is never beautiful :(
This is the best thing I ever saw in Minecraft. Nice job. Two of my favorites on the planet.
Absolutely amazing! You don't see tons of traditional redstone machines like this anymore, what with command blocks and data packs. I love it!
Amazing! I didn't think you could make noteblock memory this dense with observers. You got a new sub
I appreciate the time and effort and you've put into this. So amazing.
This is CRAZY! Top tier talent right here
This is a seriously impressive creation
I love how the person who made this payed soo much attention that they even included the MMX levers
え？！
プロやんwww
ここまでできる人初めての見た！！
再現率すご・・・そしてご本人降臨してる( ﾟдﾟ)
Andyさんの生放送から来ました。リピーターを使った演奏回路は海外にあったけど、marble machineのヴィジュアルを再現してしまうとは...まさに脱帽です。数百万再生されててもおかしくないのに、どうしてだ？？
全自動じゃなくて元ネタ同様しっかり操作してるのがいいね
原作も忠実に再現しようという執念がとても見える！見えるぞ！
absolutely the most marvelous and epic minecraft cover i have ever seen!! much epic Glory!!
This video can cure cancer?
-Absolutely not
This video is useful?
-No, but it's very cool :u
:u
:U
:U
:(_)
:\ __/
It never ceases to amaze me how there are people who will put tremendous amounts of effort into such small rewards just because they had an idea and wanted to make it a reality. And, I appreciate it so much.
I recently Made a 2x2 restone Door. Seems like i have quite a few things to learn...
This is SO INCREDIBLE! I'm in awe. Well done!!
すごい、すごすぎるマイクラで作ってしまうだなんて
これはとんでもない手間のものを……すごすぎて言葉が出ない
完全再現だすげぇ...！
I didn't see it until now. Wintergatan Wednesday!
Amazing work. Great detail for animation and the manual part!
This isnt animation man, he actually made this in the game and performed it
yea its not animation. redstone machines can do quite a lot. you can program really well in minecraft with redstone the right knowledge
@@lucassurgeon4122 and ILikeCHEEZ9 I'm sorry for the confusion I caused in my choice of words. With 'animation' I didn't mean the term in graphics. I meant the blocks going round and round, mimicking the marbles in the machine.