tl5y - goodbye until tomorrow / i could never rescue you
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ต.ค. 2024
- the last five years (2014) dir. richard lagravenese
based on the musical by jason robert brown
cast
cathy hiatt - anna kendrick
jamie wellerstein - jeremy jordan
disclaimer: i own neither movie nor song, no copyright infringement intended!
![[Live] : ONE FIGHT NIGHT 25 วันนี้!! "อเล็กซิส vs รีเกียน"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/suVr9a6BM2g/mqdefault.jpg)
not to be dramatic but this is the saddest thing i've ever seen in my life
It is
No literally!
He blew me off with a heartfelt letter, I thought "I could do much better than that".
Sarah Shufelt I SCREAMED WHEN I READ THAT AND THEN TOLD MY MOM ABOUT IT SINCE SHE THOUGHT I WAS DYING OR SOMETHING AND NOW WERE BOTH SOBBING
MY FAMILYS A MESS
I realised that when listening to the musical a second time and it just made me feel so bad for her like she can’t catch a break
Oh jeez, and on top of that he also felt he needed to "take some time off to 'focus on his career'."
And she was starting to think that this marriage might work, and the second it entered her head…! This happens.
Wow!! I JUST got this 🤯 Nice insight
Okay but the coloring of this scene is gorgeous. Cathy is in glowing yellow and Jamie is dark and blue. Beautiful color choices
I just watched this movie and I love the symbolizim in all the colors
I completely agree... With the acting and singing chops on both Jeremy Jordan (That man could turn me straight as a ruler) and Anna Kendrick (She could bend right back out of shape again), I could see this sung on an empty stage without losing any of the impact.... But somehow that just makes the visual choices here look even more masterful... I love the touch with the lighting and colour contrasts too, and also the detail with Cathy wearing the same clothes in the beginning of the song when they're so obviously in love and then at the end, when he's remembering how he used to see her... It really just makes it hit home that their relationship so much more fragile than they thought...
whilst learning how to play this on piano i realized there was even musical subtext: cathy sings in the much more difficult (to play) key of B major, so that the key change brings jaime up to the much simpler C major. cathy puts herself through something much more difficult so that jaime can be in an easier spot.
I love this. Thank you for sharing your insight after playing the piece on the piano 🥹. It really is a beautiful, beautiful song. Captures what it feels like to be finally hopeful in love 🥹 and distancing yourself from it when it no longer serves you 😔
Watching this as an adult, the thing that gets me the most is housing. Jamie left Cathy underwater in a home she has no chance of affording even with roommates. She is months to a year at most from being homeless, and saddled with the weight of 4 years of stuff, with money she cant even access because jamie closed the bank accounts. Loving someone at its most base level means not hurting them, even when its better to leave.
yet another reason to hate jamie 😤
Probably reading too deeply into this but Cathy would've most likely gotten some type of alimony, so she wouldn't be completely dead in the water.
But yeah, it's a shitty situation to be in regardless.
@@thermos_kenn2492yeah, this. Jamie’s book wasn’t published until after they were married, so there’s no chance they signed a prenup. I doubt Cathy’s ever gonna have to worry about money again
FOR REAL!!! Also Jamie did not have to write a letter and just straight up leave. He could’ve left and told her because eventually they would’ve had to talk again to file for divorce like 😭
The last notes of this song were the same as the first notes before Cathy started singing Still Hurting. It's come full circle.
well I'm crying
@OB1 It makes me think that their wedding scene/song was the only point in their relationship where they matched. 🤔
@OB1 sad they had to add that since film-goers don't typically have the same intellectual investment as theater-goers do. Least of all a playbill to peruse while waiting for the show to start.
Well, not really ...
The last chord before the intro to Still Hurting was a G MAJOR 7th with G3 B3 D4 and F4 being played on the left hand, and F5 and D6 on the right hand ... The last note heard in the entire musical is a Bb3 ... So, no they are not the same note ...The note does exist in the last chord before Still Hurting, but it's a filler note ,the notes of focus are the G3 and D6 ... Cause they are the lowest and highest pitches heard ,all the in-between notes blend with each other to create harmony .The last chord before Cathy starts to sing is a C major , there's no Bb ... It's a nice though, but not true
When the same melody is used through the film like that it's called a light motif. Broadway/musicals tend to lean into them a lot (Rent, for example, uses the melody of Seasons of Love throughout).
When Cathy at the end just walks up the steps and can automatically tell something is wrong. Just, my heart.
Evelyn Lagnese I know right 😭😭
She likely didn't realize how she was abusing Jamie until that point
@@j.a.benavides4232 bad communications skills isn't abuse
@@j.a.benavides4232 And what about him?!! And what about him?!! He was preoccupied with his own success, snubbed his wife and ran away at the first opportunity instead of trying to save their marriage
I could never rescue you is such a heartbreaking line, this song kills me every time. The optimism Cathy has and the complete defeat Jamie shows devastates me!
Jack Richardson Isn't it spelt Cathy
I think it's made more emotional when you realize that "I could never rescue you" in the tune they danced to in the wedding scene, only the viewer doesn't know it then.
What always got me is that I never felt that Cathy wanted or needed to be rescued. She left her small town for me and was just trying to find her way and thought he would join her. Maybe it was the miscommunication of that aspect that broke them. I get teary at that line because of it. He just shut down at the end.
@@amandalovewell7573 I think an illuminating part of Cathy's character comes in Moving to Fast where Jaime says
"Some people analyze ev'ry detail
Some people stall when they can't see the trail
Some people freeze out of fear that they'll fail
But I keep rollin' on
Some people can't get success with their art
Some people never feel love in their heart
Some people can't tell the two things apart
But I keep rollin' on"
Thats basically Cathy's problem. When her career doesn't take off she starts to second guess everything, including her relationship with Jaime. I think that put a stress on their relationship that causes the initial demise of their marriage
Darwin Chavez I agree with that, but I think she also loved him more than he loved her. Also I feel like at the beginning they needed each other equally, and then as time went on she continued to need him and he didn’t need her anymore which drained both of them mentally.
The line "All I could do was love you hard and let you go" absolutely shattered me
ikr.
Cut to me in a blanket sobbing: “YOU NEVER LOVED HER YOU LOVED THE IDEA OF HER 😭”
Anyone who thinks Cathy did anything to warrant getting cheated on...I pity you.
You unhappy? Nut-up: break up.
And that dummy didn’t even face her. Left before she got home.
Lindsay Heath "he blew me off with a heart felt letter, I thought 'I can do better than That' "
No one should be cheated on but she also did wrong in the relationship and he still loved her. Neither had been innocent.
The Literary Queen that still doesn’t warrant a cowardly pack up and leave without explaining anything. he’s the worse one for ending it like that
The Literary Queen nobody should ever be cheated on
Monster Mash life and relationships are much more complicated than people wanna give them credit for. In reality, there are so many layers behind decisions like this. Whether they were right is highly questionable, but Jamie did have some reason for being upset and unhappy. How he vented that feeling sucked, and in the end he could’ve said goodby to her better, but at the same time, would it have been better if he looked her in the eye and told her he didn’t love her anymore?
When she’s walking towards him down the steps smiling and he’s backing away staring and broken is amazing choreography. It makes me just as sad as the actual song.
6:39. The look on her face. Young, hopeful, loving, expectant. Her whole life ahead of her and so freaking optimistic. Putting this at the end, after we know what happens, is like a get punch.
I do love the very end with the slow zoom on Jamie's face. It's almost like he's seeing Cathy the same way the audience is, at the very start of their relationship (see the fact that he changed clothes and she didn't), and he's remembering just how much he loved her at the beginning of the relationship and the look on his face makes it obvious that either he wants it to go back to the beginning or he knows that Cathy still thinks their relationship is the way it was at the beginning (you never saw how far the cracks had opened) either way he looks entirely crushed at leaving her. Heartbreaking scene and brilliant symbolism!
So freaking true and now I see this ending/their relationship in a brighter light.
I like how when she walks toward him down the steps he backs away in time and seems to struggle to meet her eyes: It's like he can actually see her and how much she loves him, and it's intimidating him. Or making him feel guilty. Good choreography.
Honestly, this movie and the musical itself are vastly underrated.
I know how she feels. They showed that well.
what really kills me is when Cathy says “I will keep waiting” while Jamie is saying “Goodbye, Cathy”
Nothing is more tragic than to wait in vain for the rest of your life.
No, that's okay. I didn't need my heart.
“Goodbye until I’m done thanking God” the way Anna sings it is so amazing
I feel like when they were on the steps singing to each other it represented how she had been waiting for him throughout the five years they were together, and how he had not been completely there for her(more focused on himself and his career.)
You may have an amazing voice Jamie but you still cheated.
😂
Yes but Cathy was an ass, her fault
Gracie Ferrieri accascuse me? Jamie’s not doing his role as a husband to Kathy first and foremost.
Dmitrious Castillo ya but Cathy overreacted a bunch when Jamie couldn’t give her enough attention even when he tried to make time for her, she also didn’t support him when all Jamie did was support her
@@grac110 all she did was support him, he was the one that never supported her. He never went to one of her plays and she went to all but one party AND encouraged him while he was writing his book LMAOOO
ok but anna outside probably listening to Jeremy belting inside whilst enjoying the sun, having fkin rapunzel glowing hair??? mood.
Permata Az and the fact that when he walks out she is not there and then when he turns around she's suddenly there. Did she just jump out from under the stairs?
Carlos Alejandro Alvarenga I’m pretty sure it’s supposed to be that he’s imagining her there.
It's past and present you guys 🤦
um hi everyone im talking abt when they are filming.... like in the moment.. ykno... not cathy and jamie.. ok stay sanitized
@@PermataAz25 oh lol
"Just close the gate" there's no gate, Cathy.
then build a gate and THEN close it
It wasn't night, either
My favorite part in this scene is when Jamie is in the house singing and you can see Cathy outside. The lighting and coloring captures the story BEAUTIFULLY. Jamie is in the dark where it’s cold, sad, and hopeless. Whereas, Cathy is outside where it’s warm, bright, cheery, and hopeful. Wow this movie and story are incredible
That's the thing, she never needed or asked to be rescued. During their whole relationship it was all about Jamie to Jamie. Jamie as the rebel (breaking my mother's heart), Jamie as the rescuer, Jamie who gets to cheat and walk away without explanation.
Everything about this movie is stunning. It’s a crime more people don’t know about it.
I dont think everyone would like it. I'm into musucals and this my least favorite.
@@nematoaddd Is it the genre of the music or did you not find it as entertaining?
@@nematoaddd I think that’s due to the fact it’s not a traditional sappy happy ending with a huge musical chorus belting about “haha we did it against all odds” this musical is reality and I think that’s why people hate it. And that’s why I love it.
I heard most of the songs were sung live in the film. That's amazing
All of them were.
Well in an interview with ET Canada, the interviewer said Anna and Jeremy admited that much of the singing was prerecorded.
And during the interview, the two were joking about the fact that Les Misérables was mostly live. Anna said that while doing scenes in a convertible like in "I Could Do Better Than That" "it would make no sense to even try to record live sound." Anna went on to say she didn't want to play into the gimmick just to say they did the whole thing live.
But in an interview with Fox 11 News, Jeremy didn't correct the interviews when they said the "singing throughout the whole movie live." It should be noted that that interview was derailed at times by the interviewers themselves. So it's safe to say that not all the songs were recorded live.
They're both Broadway Actors, so it makes sense, if they have the pipes, they have the pipes
I think they actually sang the songs while acting but obviously the songs they put on the film were studio recorded and not live.
I had a dream about this movie last night and somehow my subconscious remembered that it’s a musical, but didn’t quite remember the lyrics of the songs - so it made them up. Turns out, my subconscious is not up to Jason Robert Brown’s standards. So now I have this weird memory of watching a version of this movie where Jamie sings a song about cars for no reason. And also a scene where he and Cathy were on a ferris wheel. Dreams are weird.
user36able that sounds like grease my dude
rainingsunshine oh wow you’re right!
Jeremy Jordan does sing about cars in Bonnie and Clyde though haha!
UGHH I HATE IT BECAUSE I HAGE JEREMYS CHARACTER IN THIS BUT I LOVE JEREMY! It's just so sad seeing Jamie leave and then Kathy showing up at the house not knowing what is going to happen as soon as she walked in the house! He literally left her with nothing! He closed the bank account so she wouldn't even be able to have a place to live! IM CRYING SO MUCH RN
Jeremy’s voice during I Could Never Rescue You is gorgeous. The character is..well, we’ll leave that train of thought alone, but vocally, the part is perfect for him.
When their duet starts and the sun shows right over the tree line is absolute cinematography perfection
i love how she messes up Jamie's hair in her part of the song and in his part his hair is like super stiff and perfectly done it just shows how different the beginning of their relationship is and the end
(I love you Jeremy Jordan) I cannot stand Jamie. Cathy wasn't perfect but my god was she loyal
"You never knew I had run out of rope..."
Know what rhymes with rope? Hope.
Marion Sandström me😂😂
Marion Sandström shut up gay
You know what’s a deeper, more thought provoking and metaphorical lyric, as the song is called “I Could Never Rescue You” and is a metaphor for someone drowning or being in over their head? You know what saves someone when they’re drowning? A rope.
This show is smarter than you are giving it credit for.
@@bnorem09 You just made me really sad with this profound explanation.
Rope as in what you would hand someone to get them out of a hole.
I still wonder how long did they take them to get the shot with the sun in the right position... my favourite song 💖
+Em Arber me too!
It really makes the song! Its beautiful and heart breaking all at once!
you're right😀
maybe they edited it in
Sooooo, hate to ruin it for you but it’s straight out movie magic with a reflector that shines a warm sun-like light. That’s the only way they can achieve that since they normally need to retake scenes multiple times and the sun waits for no one.
At 6:58 I know that is a cut transition so there's definitely time for Cathy to move, but I have this hilarious image of Anna Kendrick awkwardly crouching down on the steps and like scootching out of shot and that is the only thing keeping me from absolutely having my heart ripped out
i hate that i read this but im kind of thankful pls 😭🤚🏼
You really saved all of us the heartache with this one 😂
I think they were both horrible spouses to each other. And also equally wrong. They both needed support and wasn't satisfied with the way each other was giving it. He was in the wrong by cheating and she was wrong by getting jealous of his success. In the end- they just weren't good for each other.
Yes, exactly. Two basically decent people who were horribly wrong for each other.
In all fairness, pretty sure he was worse for cheating
nah.
Yeah, the point was to show how both of them did wrong. Yet still ground the empathy to the characters.
I always looked at as this. Jamie and Cathy got on two different points in their career. While Jamie was breaking grounds. Cathy was still finding her niche. I never thought Cathy was jealous, more on the level of I am more than just his wife. And how Jamie wanted her to constantly go to interviews and basically be an aesthetic which is why she started questioning her role in his life. Jamie needed a partner to support and understand his career which is why most of the girls he cheated on were fans and why he eventually ended up with Alise, his editor. Things could have improved if Jamie had asked maybe not to give his wife the same questions or if Cathy had compromise.
Reading comments to tl5y videos is so interesting because so many people seem to have missed the point entirely. Neither are a villain, that's the tragedy.
I agree that both are flawed and both contributed to the downfall of the relationship, but most people have a serious problem with infidelity, and it’s really hard to find Jamie sympathetic as a result.
It’s not the least bit hard to see why many people walk away from this seeing Jamie as an irredeemable asshole and Cathy as a victim. The fact that the story ends with Cathy drenched in romantic optimism further leads a lot of viewers to emphasize more strongly with her too.
Whoever was wrong or right the thing was that they both loved each other so much but couldn't help from getting lost and separated in the end😢😢😢
It one of those realistic film which shows that things can go wrong even if there was true love which is so so sad
So yeah, just let me sweep up the shattered remains of what used to be my heart...
this was so my marriage---only it was the "last 18 years".
I'm a kid so I dont know much, but you couldnt possibly spend 5-18 years with someone and be completely unhappy, right? It could've been a complete waste of time, but there were good moments... right??
@@nicenicenice9229 usually when I marriage, especially a long one falls apart there is a slow buildup of emotion that leads to the divorce/end. there are almost always good moments and/or children tucked into the buildup that makes the person/couple stay for so long.
I am married 6 years, together with my spouse for 12. my parents divorced after 35 years of marriage so I saw theirs fall apart firsthand.
@@nicenicenice9229 My parents have been together for over 23 years and the absolutely hate each other. The only reason my dad stayed was because he loves his children and wants the best for us, and the only reason my mom stayed is because she's very dependent on other people to get by. (She's planning on moving out in April, though. 🤞🏼)
The moment when she hesitates for a moment at the end because she just knows her life is about to change.
Watched this so many times and I'm still not desensitized to the absolute PURE PAIN this brought me
Jamie: this is so sad alexa play the marriage waltz
I'm 15 and I have never been in a relationship but this hurts my heart so so much. Why do I feel like my marriage is ending and I'm falling in love at the same time. UG I have too much homework to be moping over this
This is the part I cried the hardest at.
The direction and art direction here is so wonderful and effective and it makes me sad that more people don’t know about this film. I knew the musical before the movie and was hoping they would do it justice and they absolutely nailed it, such a brilliant job all around. I just wish this got a wider promotion somehow.
One of the greatest musical theatre songs xxx
I would love to see a version of this movie with all the commentary of Jason Robert brown and the actors
the part that gets to me the most is "all i could do was love you hard & let you go"
and then as the song ends and he's walking backwards and remembering her, and at the very end jeremys voice breaks at the end of "goodbye" & his eyes are full of tears
I love this movie so much my two fave songs are this one and still hurting and see I'm smiling
That’s 3
5:20 that harmony is godly
If this was a short 8 minute film, it would win an Oscar! 👀
Where will they shove the songs?😜
The fact that's this was uploaded 5 years ago. I-
Say what you want about Kathy but Jamie is ultimately the one that killed the relationship. He got to a point where he put almost nothing in and blew her off at every single turn. He’s the type to gal in and out of love at the drop of a hat and when he falls he leaves for good.
I noticed that throughout the movie, you see the light and color gradually drain from the apartment
I think Jaimes part in the song just shows that he blames Cathy, that he couldnt do anything, despite Cathy always being there to support him he wants to give up and take an easy way out. Cathy is almost blindsighted as shes 'waiting for him til tomorrow' showing how she was there for him and he's just saying he couldn't do anymore, so by Cathy singing to him shes beckoning him to keep trying, especially when they sing directly at each other. I wonder if Cathy from the beginning is there to signify that he's trying to not feel guilty by saying their relationship was always doomed or perhaps that he 'still loves her'but he's only thinking of an early memory of her instead of facing thar he jasnt been there for the crushed Cathy now? Either way the songs so tragic and so symbolic beautiful full circle moment 😢
This story just hits home for me. I was with someone for 8 years, 7 of which we were engaged. And although our relationship started out great, the longer it went on, I slowly realized that we weren't meant for each other. I stayed longer than I should have, even when everybody told me that it was over. I did what I could to save us, but in the end, we went our separate ways. We ended things the day after my 31st birthday. It was pretty fitting. I gave her the entirety of my youth, and I was now going to have to navigate the next decade of my life without her. I'm still trying to find my way, but it's hard not to look back sometimes. I know we'll never get back together, but I don't regret a second of the life we shared together. It made me who I am, and I'll always be grateful for that.
he didn't even love her enough to leave the bank accounts open until she found a new place to live
I just realized that this video was uploaded *5 years ago* why is that so significant feeling to me
39 years ago my ex-wife would have been singing this song just like Anna did here. 21 years after the divorce "I'm Still Hurting".....And that devastating moment when the rings come off and are discarded as so much trash. It sucks, ya know?
“Leave this night clean and quiet,”
Cathy, it doesn’t look later than 5pm outside.
this duet breaks me so much
The “all I could do was love you hard and let you go” line...absolute bullshit haha. I mean the song is beautiful but Jamie cheated on her...you don’t do that if you loved someone, even if in the end you were just defeated. You don’t do that.
I keep seeing comments to this effect, and I think it's a bit one-dimensional. Perhaps it's more clear in the stage show, but Jamie is also a sympathetic character. This isn't a simple matter of good-person-meets-bad-person. Jamie and Cathy are two basically decent people who weren't even close to right for each other. There are many reasons people cheat, and many of them are complex ones that defy a simple "You don't do that" analysis. And I say that as someone who has been cheated on.
+DuetJay I appreciate your point but I disagree - Jamie's problem isn't his cheating it is his cowardice: coming to ohio when he intended to leave, leaving the letter when she knew how much the first hurt her. The problem is that Jamie saw Cathy as a character - she was this worshipful, exotic beauty who was defined by her moxie and primarily her love for him. Cathy allowed this letting her relationship validate her completely so when she didn't love up to either of their concepts - Jamie was disgusted and Cathy embittered. A terrible combination but what makes Jamie a tool is that he intentionally sought out a new partner who is literally defined by her lesser status ( one of the 'kids'). He's making sure never to be challenged again and I feel that he will play the magical clock ruse Every time he is required to depart from his fantasies. I think this is why this final scene is so stirring : he's seeing her for the first time outside of his narrative.
+DuetJay Also textually Jamie is a jackass " I didn't see a way we both could win" is the truest statement he could make. At least in this rendition, I believe, Jamie would be hugely threatened by success. I don't think they would have made it five years if it was Jamie struggling because he would never get through even one party.
he gives himself away with his declaration: “I will not fail so you can be comfortable, Cathy/I will not lose because you can’t win.” what a jackass/assclown like FUCK MAN.
Angelisa Hassan I agree yes, they are both at fault. Jamie, on the other hand, is more at fault than Cathy. It was clear from A Miracle Would Happen that he was not ready to marry her. By then, it was obvious to see that he would eventually cheat on her. He also chose to be elsewhere than to spend time with his wife on her birthday, especially when they would rarely have the time for each other. Cathy would attend to all of his parties and the one time she didn't, he got upset. In addition, he never went to see her when it came to her performances. It was easy for him and he got away with everything, so it only makes sense that she becomes jealous. Questions of resentment and female independence in her career caused her that sense of jealousy as well. It's not like she was asking for him to stop pursuing his career. In a way, he was drifting himself from her by finding love within the arms of another. The whole situation is too complex to analyze, although their relationship was bound to end anyway.
this is so heartbreaking it makes me feel physically sick to watch omg
its 230 am and i just woke up from my sleep to listen to this song and i just had to choreograph this song
Amazing performance
Thanks for uploading! this is my favorite song form the musical!
this is perfect, but heartrending
Deadass bawling my eyes out rn alone in my room watching this on repeat. Why do i do this to myself LMAOO
Ughhh I love Anna and Jeremy , Anna’s just amazing and Jeremy is just too adorable 😭😭😭
Maybe the best musical theatre song of all time.
That ending tho *_chefs kiss_*
Most heartbreaking part of the movie
Okay, to everyone, I should mention that Jamie, while him cheating wasn’t the right thing to do, Kathy (at least I’m the musical) got incredibly jealous of his career and every time she wasn’t casted she would take it personally and essentially go into a depressive state and Jamie would have a hard time dealing with that, and she also couldn’t handle not getting a callback so she would get so jealous of how happy and successful Jamie was at these parties and want to spend time with him which is why he says “I could never rescue you” because he knows how sad it made her when she didn’t get casted so he was trying to save her and make her believe in herself and her abilities (the song if I didn’t believe in you) and by the end he says that once he finds a single room of his heart she sends out battalions to destroy it which essentially means that she had to make sure she was the only one he focused on and I know cheating isn’t the right thing to do ever but from Jamie’s perspective, when at times she would literally become unresponsive and incredibly depressed, it would become too much. But there’s something to think on, hopefully this redeems Jamie in the slightest!
Let's not forget that Jamie seemed to WANT to cheat on her long before he actually cheated. Also, as someone who almost never gets cast in anything, I understand Cathy's pain. It's not like she ever tried to sabotage Jamie. That would have been a different story.
It's different to most romance films because the couple doesn't get back together in the end
Brb imma cry in a corner
Can someone explain to me why does jamie have to carry that bag even thought it probably have wheels on it?
Mj Ewan So he can feel the weight of his choices and its consequences
Gabriel Adami this is the best comment I've ever read in my entire life😂😂😂
The first scene shows Cathy weeping as well as angry becuase Jamie was able to leave her without he rpermission. The end of the movie shows the opposite Jamie was a gifted person who developed a succesfull career. He seemed so in control of his faculties. However here we see that Jamie had faced the first threat to his ego. jamie is in his own mind in that scene and this is subtil. Jamie was not the good guy and adventurerer that he wanted to see himself to be, Jamie failed as a husband, he failed as a lover and he failed as her freind. Instead of conquering his personal life the way he had conquered his external world. Jamie was a coward. He rebelled in adultery. He brelled terms of her birthday. He ran away and had everything moved out before she got home from her birthday in Ohio. Worse yet, he has his love pack his things. Seriously was he too much of a wimp to pack his bags? How unconfortable was he making the new girl feel? This seems to set up his destined future cycle, He sees the ideal girl that he fell in love with. He knows that he has failed to love and you wonder if this is the rest of his life. Cathy will always wonder of the injustice. But as fate would have it he is punished by the haunting of her image the rest of his days
why does this have to go so hard it’s so sad 😭
Shows how Jamie only loved the version of her from 5 years ago and Cathy loved him with the full belief of his potential.
Makes me cry every time
in my opinion they were both equally bad until jamie cheated
Why?
If you’ve lived this, you know
I have, for the last five years
My fiancee of five years left me this October. I know.
@@hannahlynn8028 Mine did too! Another scarred me worse. You get it. Sending love 🤍
Awww..anna's face look cute at 3:03 😍
I was having a perfectly good day. Then I clicked on this video. Now my day is sad
its exactly i dont wanna fall in love, too hurts at the end no matter what reason.
I'm not crying... You're crying...
After this movie I haven't hated a fictional man _so_ much 😭
Although they both had a lot of love for each other, the relationship is extremely toxic. Cathy is far too dependent on Jamie and he isn't dependent enough on her. He feels fulfilled by his job whereas she is completely dissatisfied with hers. There's no balance there.
when it ends on the first couple notes of im still hurting. omg its full circle
this song is very good. I like but too sad
Love the movie...love the song!
I love Anna Kendrick she”s so petty and beautiful and so nice I love her acting in the last five years and singing in her movie and just love her.
You have changed Jamie admit it. You can not put the blame on her.Yes, she had some mistakes but you cheated on her. This is not acceptable ...
This makes me bawl my fucking eyes out, years later. It’s just so fucking sad.
to say goodbye in
a letter is so cowardly to me
First date with Anna Kendrik wearing cargo shorts? yeah not happening
I've just seen this last night.
I just don't get it. I need help because my heart is shattered.
And I'm still hurting (no pun intended)
basically, Cathy is telling the story backwards while Jamie is telling the story from the start until the end. I know this is late lol
Yes. It starts with Jamie at the beginning and Cathy at the end, but the second time we see them get married it flips again so we end with Jamie at the end and Cathy at the beginning
My heart was on sale at the dollar tree, but your coupon said $1 off, so I guess so..
I AM BACK TO CRY ONCE MORE
A bittersweet, but realistic ending.
Considering Brown based Jamie and Cathy on his own failed marriage, I guess