A lot of these coins are good, but some don’t feel difficult enough, or are too easy to find. For example, the Polargeist coin is very obvious and the Time machine coin isn’t difficult enough for the seventh level in the game. It isn’t too huge of an issue and I think they are all good improvements nonetheless.
Thanks! I agree that I am not super proud of some of the improvements I made. However, I still hope at least all 10 coins were made better than their original versions.
Robtop doesn't like it when we make levels with coins that are too secret, while he himself makes levels with coins that are very secret and beyond reason. Robtop be like: "it's also called a secret coin, which means getting it is also secret, while your level uses user coins, which means it shouldn't be too secret and should look a little"
0:54 meanwhile using 1.3 platforms in your revised dry out coin 😂 I don't blame you, just keep that in mind. I personally would replace them with the regular slabs, but that's just me
I used those platforms because most coins released before 1.3 featured them. It would be different if I used a mechanic like a jump ring or pad that wasn't introduced yet, but it's just a platform.
@@GDGroundflower now that you mention it, I can see why you did that, it's just that I would personally use regular slabs seeing as dry out is a 1.0 level, & I also just found what you said at 0:54 a little contradictory with what you did with that coin. I do that more than I should tbh
“The pink pad or pink orb wasn’t introduced yet” Explain why using the xStep slab thingy that appears in the ball parts of xStep (which wasn't *introduced* yet) is ok for stereo madness 3rd coin, and most the coins you revamped in this video (dry out 1st coin, cant let go 1st coin, Time Machine 3rd coin.) (no offense, just a question)
I was trying to stay consistent with other Geometry Dash coins. Several other coins use that block, so I thought it was okay. It would be different if it was a game mechanic like an orb or jump pad, but it's just a platform.
Imo, Clutterfunk 3 was fine. Gameplay could've been better. But it being a secret is why it's good. You can't call a secret coin a secret coin if it's in the middle of the screen and pretty easy to get. The coins are optional, and should be harder than the main path to get, and a secret. Secrets in games are usually rewards you get for exploring when you didn't need to, so having it down there makes completely sense with the idea of it being a secret. You could've improved just the route to get it instead of moving it. And, to all GD players, don't make coins easy to get or some key to pick up like Deadlocked 1. Coins are rewards for doing something challenging or finding a secret like 1-ups in Mario.
Not all secret coins are secret. In fact, in most official levels the coins are out in plain sight. I agree that coins should have difficulty which makes them feel good to get, but that difficulty doesn't always have to come from being hidden.
You could make a taunting coin at the end of a path that is a couple of seconds long, and add a slightly visible "crack" in the gameplay. The key to getting the coin is pieceing those two clues together and fall at the right spot into an alt path.
Your version of time machine 3rd coin is not that good, why make hard gameplay with reversed ship for new players if they try to get it. And no im not saying that the levels you did are going to be experienced by new players but still pretty bad version. Not being mean or toxic but its really not that good.
Okay, I get where you're going with this. But from my perspective, coins need difficulty to feel rewarding to the player. Besides, it's optional. So if you're not experienced enough with ship flying, don't go for the coin.
gotta love how the thumbnail has the polargeist 3rd coin changed into a free coin at the end of time machine (which is supposed to be fixing the coin somehow...)
Some of these coin improvements are really good, but some aren't and are too easy to collect. Which is ironic since that was your main complaint for coin number 1 in Clubstep.
@@TJ-hg6op The Clubstep one is an improvement. But I'm talking about the other levels. Most notably Dry Out, Base After Base, Can't Let Go, and Clutterfunk. I think these coin "improvements" that OP made now have the same problem as Clubstep coin 1 had before. I think the coins are too obvious, and are easier than the main path. And the one in Electroman Adventures barely changed.
As much as I want to say these are Cologne-approved, I feel like he'd still complain on one aspect: the difficulty. Where's the challenge? Where's the spice? In my opinion, the only decently good ones here are Time Machine's 3rd, xStep's 2nd, and Electroman's 3rd; the rest are pipsqueak as hell. For example, you pointed out that Can't Let Go 1st has no gameplay, but your improvement only added a single jump, and an easy one at that. Sorry for the blabbering btw. The coins are good effort, but if you're gonna make a sequel, I do hope you make the improvements much tougher.
This is going to be a weird idea but I think it would be cool if the position of the coins randomises each attempt, and there will be like 5-8 coin paths with only 3 of them being the correct one. Since taking the wrong coin path won't kill you, it wouldn't cause any notable harm doing so. Edit: Second thoughts, this is a stupid idea
Wait, wait. If you complete back on track and stereo madness but never got any of the coins, do you have to get the coins from the previous level you completed? Well like Polargeist 3rd coin has gravity portals and jump pads but you already completed Dry Out. So, what's the matter? Well Can't let Go's 3rd coin has the purple or pink jump pad but Jumper introduces upside-down ship, so it does matter!
Ah yes, has a ton of unintroduced mechanics, way too hard for a normal, and had blind jumps. That isn’t just hard, its bad design. Though I do think the new one is a bit too easy and could’ve included a yellow orb.
And some of these coins also look freer than they should be. Like you said, coins are supposed to be rewarding when you made them obvious and I think should be moved to different spots in a level and have their paths harder than the main path
24 may refer to: 24 (number), the natural number following 23 and preceding 25 one of the years 24 BC, AD 24, 1924, 2024 Chromium, an transition metal in the periodic table 24 Themis, an asteroid in the asteroid belt 24 frames per second, a common frame rate in film and television 24 (TV series), an American show depicting the events of a single day in 24 real-time episodes per season 24: Live Another Day, a 2014 continuation of the original television series 24: Redemption, a 2008 television movie related to the television series 24: The Game, a 2006 video game based on the television series 24 (Indian TV series), an Indian TV series based on the American show of the same name 24 (2001 film), a Czech thriller film 24 (2016 film), an Indian Tamil film 24 (soundtrack), the album of the 2016 Tamil film 24 (2021 film), a Singaporean art film
Coins don't necessarily have to be secret. They can be challenging, hidden, or both. But having coins that are completely off screen or have little to no visual indicators is unfair.
They are called secret coins, they are supposed to be hidden cuz they are called SECRET coin, they are not supposed to be hard, just hidden, it just makes no sense if you put a hard, SECRET coin in a level, when they are supposed to be SECRET, not hard. Just think about it
Plenty of official levels coins aren't secret at all. In fact, most of them aren't. A coin can be either hidden and secret, or visible and challenging.
@@thecanadianguy-tcg The original version of the video featured the Time Machine song, but I had to cut it out after the video released. I could have included a piano remix of Time Machine while producing the video, but it's too late now. Unfortunately, there's no remix of Time Machine in the TH-cam music library.
@@GDGroundflower i know lol it was a joke also i just wanna say your videos are very entertaining and i love your content and if i remember correctly i was around when you only had 1k subs
![[GD] Groundflower](http://yt3.ggpht.com/jdaOEDGza0KHvlz_G3i326upYjE3onve8gi7xCWjiv0a606h8QSqmvCBvqvWfNQOuMrDcMKsTA=s48-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj)
good improvements :)
Hi
Thanks! 💚
yo cob
if you like this reply you will get 1 mana orb in gd
@@ObnoxiousToast if I dislike do I lose 1?
5:00 portals are upside down to hide the particles
Wow, rob didn't even want players to find this...
I was about to say this but ok, and I don't know how those players still don't know why those gravity portals are upside down.
Really? I still think that makes the coin path a lot less aesthetically pleasing though.
yes
@@GDGroundflower Well yes, but those were the resources available to hide coins in 1.6
A lot of these coins are good, but some don’t feel difficult enough, or are too easy to find. For example, the Polargeist coin is very obvious and the Time machine coin isn’t difficult enough for the seventh level in the game. It isn’t too huge of an issue and I think they are all good improvements nonetheless.
Thanks! I agree that I am not super proud of some of the improvements I made. However, I still hope at least all 10 coins were made better than their original versions.
Nice job bro
Robtop doesn't like it when we make levels with coins that are too secret, while he himself makes levels with coins that are very secret and beyond reason.
Robtop be like: "it's also called a secret coin, which means getting it is also secret, while your level uses user coins, which means it shouldn't be too secret and should look a little"
i know right 😂
"Ya, I'm not a coin, I'm a cube." - Partition while he divorced his other half of his icon. 😢
Don't ask.
bro what does this even supposed to mean 😭
@@GDGroundflowerit’s an average partition fan, don’t blame then!
@koshinNasir what is a dot dot dash sequence 😭
Me 2😭
Bro is not gd cologne
you're right. i'm the SUPERIOR gd cologne 👀
@@GDGroundflowergroundflower remember me
I am the first lvl on gd
@@GDGroundflowerimferior
@@GDGroundflowergd perfume
I Know I Have Cube 102 But 1:22 Just Turned My Audio Off For Some Reason 😭
He Got Copyrighted
GD Cologne would be proud
agreed. I made this video with him specifically in mind 😊
4:11 this clip helped me know the path for it. I'm *NOT* joking
6:37 you made the coin easier than the normal path despite complaining about robtop doing it earlier
Not really. It requires quick reaction time and you have to hit the orb at a relatively precise timing to get back onto the pain path.
It has extra gameplay so no, it isn't easier
This guy is taking out his inner gd colonge
i love gd groundflowah
0:54 meanwhile using 1.3 platforms in your revised dry out coin 😂
I don't blame you, just keep that in mind. I personally would replace them with the regular slabs, but that's just me
I used those platforms because most coins released before 1.3 featured them. It would be different if I used a mechanic like a jump ring or pad that wasn't introduced yet, but it's just a platform.
@@GDGroundflower now that you mention it, I can see why you did that, it's just that I would personally use regular slabs seeing as dry out is a 1.0 level, & I also just found what you said at 0:54 a little contradictory with what you did with that coin. I do that more than I should tbh
Ehhhhh, some of them are too revealing. Clg 3rd coin was very obvious, wouldve liked to see something at the end like you did with time machine
So you're making sure you can't see any coins? Fair enough
Thanks for the feedback! If I do a video similar to this in the future, I'll try to keep this in mind ;)
These are gd colon approved
I sure hope so 🥺
“The pink pad or pink orb wasn’t introduced yet”
Explain why using the xStep slab thingy that appears in the ball parts of xStep (which wasn't *introduced* yet) is ok for stereo madness 3rd coin, and most the coins you revamped in this video (dry out 1st coin, cant let go 1st coin, Time Machine 3rd coin.) (no offense, just a question)
I was trying to stay consistent with other Geometry Dash coins. Several other coins use that block, so I thought it was okay. It would be different if it was a game mechanic like an orb or jump pad, but it's just a platform.
Mom: We have GD cologne at home
GD cologne at home:
aww thanks
At home means someone is joking of something being good🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
@@quartzmarker actually I'm pretty sure they meant I'm living in your walls because I'm at your home
@@Eliiscool1500 I see your in my walls
@@Eliiscool1500 AHHH HELP AAAAÆÆÆÆÆEE
Fake blocks haven't been introduced yet 5:54
Those blocks have been around since 1.0, they were literally used in the first coin of Stereo Madness
The best one is probably either xStep or Time Machine, but you included the new slabs in some of the levels like time machine so ehh
I agree. Those 2 are also my favorites!! ;)
Imo, Clutterfunk 3 was fine. Gameplay could've been better. But it being a secret is why it's good. You can't call a secret coin a secret coin if it's in the middle of the screen and pretty easy to get. The coins are optional, and should be harder than the main path to get, and a secret. Secrets in games are usually rewards you get for exploring when you didn't need to, so having it down there makes completely sense with the idea of it being a secret. You could've improved just the route to get it instead of moving it. And, to all GD players, don't make coins easy to get or some key to pick up like Deadlocked 1. Coins are rewards for doing something challenging or finding a secret like 1-ups in Mario.
Not all secret coins are secret. In fact, in most official levels the coins are out in plain sight. I agree that coins should have difficulty which makes them feel good to get, but that difficulty doesn't always have to come from being hidden.
@@GDGroundflower thats valid as well
You should improve the 1st coin in back on track. It’s literally the 3rd coin in polargeist one but easier.
Maybe in another video if I decide to do it ;)
Ngl good vid🎉 and nice improvements😊
Thanks!! So happy you like it ;)
You could make a taunting coin at the end of a path that is a couple of seconds long, and add a slightly visible "crack" in the gameplay. The key to getting the coin is pieceing those two clues together and fall at the right spot into an alt path.
Your version of time machine 3rd coin is not that good, why make hard gameplay with reversed ship for new players if they try to get it. And no im not saying that the levels you did are going to be experienced by new players but still pretty bad version.
Not being mean or toxic but its really not that good.
Okay, I get where you're going with this. But from my perspective, coins need difficulty to feel rewarding to the player. Besides, it's optional. So if you're not experienced enough with ship flying, don't go for the coin.
2:03 why does everyone hate this coin I don't get it
1:32
4:23 I once accidentally found it because I was on mobile and couldnt spam that hard
And accidentally let go
case in point!
0:11 I remember having to do this 😭😭
*Wake up, the new Groundflower video is out!!!*
And in record time too! :3
Man is the new gd colon 😂 Great Video!
Thanks! I tried my best to replicate GD Colon's style of videos for this one ;)
gotta love how the thumbnail has the polargeist 3rd coin changed into a free coin at the end of time machine (which is supposed to be fixing the coin somehow...)
bro obviously did not watch the video 💀
@@GDGroundflower never said that I did (although I'm watching it right now)
good video
@@NotBest713 Thanks! I always try my best 💚
Some of these coin improvements are really good, but some aren't and are too easy to collect. Which is ironic since that was your main complaint for coin number 1 in Clubstep.
Well the new clubstep one looks definitely harder.
@@TJ-hg6op The Clubstep one is an improvement. But I'm talking about the other levels. Most notably Dry Out, Base After Base, Can't Let Go, and Clutterfunk. I think these coin "improvements" that OP made now have the same problem as Clubstep coin 1 had before. I think the coins are too obvious, and are easier than the main path. And the one in Electroman Adventures barely changed.
Thanks for the feedback. If I do a video similar to this in the future, I'll try to keep this in mind ;)
Both paths of 6:33 are the same difficulty…
Sorry! If I do a video similar to this in the future, I'll try to keep this in mind ;)
xstep is literally just gd cologne
Kind of. I definitely took a lot of inspiration from colon in this video 🤣
@@GDGroundflower + Ig he is the coin guy
As much as I want to say these are Cologne-approved, I feel like he'd still complain on one aspect: the difficulty.
Where's the challenge? Where's the spice? In my opinion, the only decently good ones here are Time Machine's 3rd, xStep's 2nd, and Electroman's 3rd; the rest are pipsqueak as hell.
For example, you pointed out that Can't Let Go 1st has no gameplay, but your improvement only added a single jump, and an easy one at that.
Sorry for the blabbering btw. The coins are good effort, but if you're gonna make a sequel, I do hope you make the improvements much tougher.
Thanks for the feedback! If I decide to make a sequel, I'll definitely keep these tips in mind ;)
4:46 holy shit is that pursuit by shiribon as the background music
Yep! I used soundtracks from several different games throughout this video. You can check the description for the google document of all songs used.
finally, an actually good fixing gd coins video, a lot of these coins are great ideas, although a few are way too easy i'd say
Thanks!! That's fair, I was focusing on trying to make the coins less terrible, I didn't really care about the difficulty really
@@GDGroundflower honestly fair enough, i'd rather have an easy coin (but not easier than the main path) then a coin you can't even see!
are you copying gd colon?
I obviously took some inspiration from GD Colon but I didn't copy him by any means
Colon 4:06
BRO IS A GD COLONGE RIP OFF
gd cologne but better*
Robtop needs to see this!
imagine he comments "agreed" and goes back and changes every coin LOL
This is going to be a weird idea but I think it would be cool if the position of the coins randomises each attempt, and there will be like 5-8 coin paths with only 3 of them being the correct one. Since taking the wrong coin path won't kill you, it wouldn't cause any notable harm doing so.
Edit: Second thoughts, this is a stupid idea
Great video bro !!!
Thanks!! 💚
GD Cologne will be happy
indeed. i shared this video to him, so hopefully he decides to comment soon.
Wait, wait. If you complete back on track and stereo madness but never got any of the coins, do you have to get the coins from the previous level you completed? Well like Polargeist 3rd coin has gravity portals and jump pads but you already completed Dry Out. So, what's the matter? Well Can't let Go's 3rd coin has the purple or pink jump pad but Jumper introduces upside-down ship, so it does matter!
Most players beat levels in order!
I think in game design, it's good practice to introduce things in the order the game is meant to be played.
I got tricked by the pink pad too 😅😅
i probably got tricked at one point yeah 🤣
nice improvement and video
Thank you!! 💚
Base after base 1st coin: So I’m a good coin now?
I only had room to fix 10 coins in this video... maybe in a future video if i decide to make a sequel ;)
We need this in the game
agreed.
the random subtitles at the first 2 seconds of the video
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I think a couple were to obvious, but other then that I agree!
this video is awesome, idk how you dont have more subs.
Thank you so much!! 💚
Bro is copying from gd colon😠
there's a fine line between copying and taking inspiration
@@GDGroundflowerFR
/summon gdcologne
i love gd cologne
Now fix user level coins!
nooo!! not the recent tab 😭
Gd colon with extra steps
that's how you know my plan is working 😈
Thay are called "secret coins" for a reason...
Secret coins can still be secret while having visual indicators.
How do you not have more subs? This is so good
Thank you so much! These are the kinda comments that motivate me to keep making videos 💚
We know bro is doing this for gd cologne's mental health.
absolutely correct.
you are NOT gd colon
But he is better give me the balls
For Me The Dry Out 1st Coin Is Very Easy I Never Miss It.
Interesting. For me, I always forgot where it was lol
Gd Colon but different
true LOL
Bro is ruining Mr favorite coin, base after base coin #2
Discord ping 0-0
👇
haha get pinged loser 😈
(joke)
1:22 where did the music go
I had to remove the music for copyright reasons lol
Do you have the ids for these?
No, sorry. You can try making your own coin improvements if you want! It's super fun ;)
GDColon will happy if RobTop change all the F tier coin to be A tier
true. i sure hope gd colon sees this.
Your cant let go coin has a swag route where you can jump on a hanging block with a spike
yeah, probably. thanks for pointing that out!
Polargeist 3rd coin isnt bad, its just hard. Couldve nerfed it but you had to make it worse
Ah yes, has a ton of unintroduced mechanics, way too hard for a normal, and had blind jumps. That isn’t just hard, its bad design. Though I do think the new one is a bit too easy and could’ve included a yellow orb.
@@TJ-hg6op atleast polargeist had actual game tech
Is this a joke???
@@Cahrssomething no?
@@proxyrhine Game tech introduced in a terrible way.
Nice vid
Thanks! I always put in the effort to make my videos as entertaining as possible ;)
Gd cologne should see this!
I shared it with him! Hopefully he will, soon.
You used the Xstep blocks before they were introduced :/
And some of these coins also look freer than they should be. Like you said, coins are supposed to be rewarding when you made them obvious and I think should be moved to different spots in a level and have their paths harder than the main path
It's just some blocks
Thanks for the feedback. If I do a video similar to this in the future, I'll try to keep this in mind ;)
@@GDGroundflower ok, sorry if I sounded rude
@@advance64bro no, not at all!
Go dream to be the secret coin king when gdcolon is the secret coin king buddy...
Colon does not own coins 😭
1:23 WHY DOES NO ONE TALK ABOUT THE AUDIO CUT-OFF
copyright lol
coin
coin
Wake up!!!!!! New video!
new video indeed. thanks for watching! :3
2:04 he sais “coin number 30”
bro you still had to hold on dry out
I guess. At least this time the coin is visible.
geometry dash coins are so..😡😡😡
constructive critiscm!11!!!11!!
Its like 💀💀💀
OMG gd colon's twin is that really you?!?!?!!
hi it's me gd grunflowr
24:00:00
💀 wut
24 may refer to:
24 (number), the natural number following 23 and preceding 25
one of the years 24 BC, AD 24, 1924, 2024
Chromium, an transition metal in the periodic table
24 Themis, an asteroid in the asteroid belt
24 frames per second, a common frame rate in film and television
24 (TV series), an American show depicting the events of a single day in 24 real-time episodes per season
24: Live Another Day, a 2014 continuation of the original television series
24: Redemption, a 2008 television movie related to the television series
24: The Game, a 2006 video game based on the television series
24 (Indian TV series), an Indian TV series based on the American show of the same name
24 (2001 film), a Czech thriller film
24 (2016 film), an Indian Tamil film
24 (soundtrack), the album of the 2016 Tamil film
24 (2021 film), a Singaporean art film
My mind is frying
@@GDGroundflower 0-0 *brains explodes from knowledge*
Gd colon will be happy
indeed. i love gd cologne
@@GDGroundflower I love gd colon
UNDERATED 101
Thank you so much!! 💚
but its true
I mean, they're called *secret* coins for a reason, right?
Secret coins can still be secret while having visual indicators.
I loooove GD cologne
why is 1:22 muted
copyright reasons ;(
@@GDGroundflower ok :(
Honestly I'd make the coins invisible SO ITS
Actually secret thats the POINT OF THE Coin
Coins don't necessarily have to be secret. They can be challenging, hidden, or both. But having coins that are completely off screen or have little to no visual indicators is unfair.
They are called secret coins, they are supposed to be hidden cuz they are called SECRET coin, they are not supposed to be hard, just hidden, it just makes no sense if you put a hard, SECRET coin in a level, when they are supposed to be SECRET, not hard. Just think about it
Plenty of official levels coins aren't secret at all. In fact, most of them aren't. A coin can be either hidden and secret, or visible and challenging.
Bro got the idea from gd colon☠️
let's just say i love gd cologne
Groundflower what’s up do you remember me?
possibly. where do i know you from exactly?
1:23 why did it silent
copyright reasons
@@GDGroundflower🎹: Am I a joke to you?
@@thecanadianguy-tcg The original version of the video featured the Time Machine song, but I had to cut it out after the video released. I could have included a piano remix of Time Machine while producing the video, but it's too late now. Unfortunately, there's no remix of Time Machine in the TH-cam music library.
@@GDGroundflower time machine 2 is a remix
@@Rafael_gamer320 Unfortunately, it's not available on the youtube library
Blud is not gd colonge☠️
believe it or not gd colon doesn't own coins
Doesnt matter
@@Pop_Club_TV I didn't copy any video, steal any assets, or anything. Is simply taking inspiration from one of my favorite TH-camrs such a crime 😭
@@GDGroundflowerI’m with you side man these kid don’t understand what is inspiration
Inspiring is not copying am I right?
I love gd cologne
i love gd cologne
WEEEEEEEE love gd cologne
Much better
Thank youz :3
37 views in 37 minutes, bro (sorta) fell off 😭
my videos always grow really slowly in the beginning. don't worry. this video will hit it big.
@@GDGroundflower i know lol it was a joke also i just wanna say your videos are very entertaining and i love your content and if i remember correctly i was around when you only had 1k subs
@@GDGroundflower also i feel like Colon will comment on this video...
@@cup-sh Thank you so much! Also, I really hope Colon comments as well ;)
bro, eziest sub in my life i think
thanks so much!! 💚
You forgot back on track
I only covered the top 10 worst coins (in my opinion) in this video
I agreed😊
are you colons twin???
i wish 😭
Yoooo hi groundflower
haii! :3
@@GDGroundflower haya ohaya
Not bad
Thanks!! I'm happy you like :3