Leaving out the obvious fact that he wasn't around for most of my life, I can't believe I've got to 62 and not heard this stuff! I found it by accident - it's the best accident I've ever had!
I took me 57 damn years, this sounds so much like Leonard Cohen one minute then Bruce Springsteen and then goddamned if it isn't just the pure genre shattering genius of Justin Vernon.
Check out all his albums and check out volcano choir too. That's his other band. Unbelievable. He has become my favorite artist and im a working musician. Not saying this lightly. He's the man
That harmonica is God-like. To be honest, I actually kind of prefer this version to the original. This is road trip music through and through. Half-hoping that he records this at some point. I also really have to point out how much I love that he sings the last line into his harmonica to make it sound like it's distorting and fading. God I love this man.
This is one hell of performance! I love how he's always changing his way of playing those limited number of songs. It's been 8 years and I still could listen to every song forever, and that's because they're still in evolution. Thank you, thank you, thank you!
I love this guy's songwriting. It's just this super deconstructed imagery. It sounds exactly like a memory. Not too much detail. Just a vibe or presence. Half spoken words. All of it. Absolutely brilliant .
hehe Schadenfreude is when someone is getting hurt and you're laughing about that :D (Schaden = damage, freude = joy) I'm sorry but we germans neither have a word for this sadly happy feeling (although I'm longing for one)
This version of Calgary absolutely destroys me, wringing out my heart like a dishrag full of water.... I just cried at work. Such a range of emotions.....good God.
this is the kind of music that stops everything around and brings you tears of...beauty. What a pearl, what a soul, what a musician. I'm happy we live on the same world.
One of three songs that give me the feeling like I'm listening to it for the first time all over again every time I hear it. The original is great but this...this haunts me
As much as I love the album version (as well as some other live versions), this one blows all the others out of the water. I was absolutely floored the first time I heard/saw this. Given that it's Justin Vernon, I shouldn't be surprised by the quality of anything he touches, but DAMN. This is what perfect music and musicianship sounds like.
Absolutely in love with this version. He created a completely new song, which is equally as good as the original. I wish I had half as much vision as this man has.
When I grow I wanna Bon Iver so much!! Just when I found the acoustic version of Calgary & deemed it the best version I find this harmonica blessed performance. Long Live Justin Vernon! Long live Bon Iver !!
This is probably the only time I have heard that old DeYarmond Edison sound fused with the Bon Iver we are used to. I thought this version worked incredibly
Justin Vernon.... you are one of the most wonderful, beautiful, musical souls on this planet. Your music takes many of us to different places. Forever grateful for you.
Going through a break up right now, with what was and is the best girl I've ever met. Days are weird and numb. Some better, some worse. This song has been on my head through the last days on loop. Can't say it's helping very much but at least gives me company through the hard times. Thank you Bon Iver ❤️
40 years forward, I'll be sitting with my grandchildren and telling them how this amazing classic track is timeless and I still enjoy it till this day, and watch the reactions on their faces when they discover this track and start listening to it with their friends and starting to be into "classic music" Hahahaha.
What I most like about justin is those little details (like the transition between his voice and the harmonica 5:37), which definitely achieve perfection and is present in every song this guy produce
This was already an incredibly beautiful and emotional song but that harmonica just melts my heart. Combined with an acoustic guitar and his voice just brings tears to my eyes. Thank you for everything you give us, Justin.
Justin, You take me back to the first place I fell in love in. Your voice takes me back to being 18, in college, in Seattle. Hearing you sing brings back the images of the ocean, the laughter I had with friends, and rhe beauty of the Pacific Northwest. You take me back.
i like his lyrics, you cant really understand what its about without very carefully listening to it over and over, and then still it doesnt tell you what its really about, it relates to you specifically.
Leaving out the obvious fact that he wasn't around for most of my life, I can't believe I've got to 62 and not heard this stuff! I found it by accident - it's the best accident I've ever had!
Andrew Taylor damn right :)
I took me 57 damn years, this sounds so much like Leonard Cohen one minute then Bruce Springsteen and then goddamned if it isn't just the pure genre shattering genius of Justin Vernon.
same heard it one week then by total chance were playing 10 miles away unreal
Never too late ❤️
Check out all his albums and check out volcano choir too. That's his other band. Unbelievable. He has become my favorite artist and im a working musician. Not saying this lightly. He's the man
Here's to everyone who listenes to Bon Iver on the regular! Love you all!
Isaia Molina I see you.
Back at you!!
LOVED him for years and an will for eternity.
~ Talent to the moon.
No expiration date.
☮💖☀️☮💖☀️☮
Imagine the full Bon Iver album stripped like this!!!
Genius, just plain genius. So much skill, so much emotion, so much life. Justin Vernon is truly a revolutionary, one of a kind.
The first word that came to mind for me was "genius". I scrolled down and You beat me to it. Haha!
That harmonica is God-like. To be honest, I actually kind of prefer this version to the original. This is road trip music through and through. Half-hoping that he records this at some point. I also really have to point out how much I love that he sings the last line into his harmonica to make it sound like it's distorting and fading. God I love this man.
I actually feel like this is the definitive version of this song
YES! The voice-thru-harmonica ending was the most genius/splendid thing I've seen/heard in a minute
The most influential artist of the decade
You should listen to the Ghost of Tom Joad album of Bruce Springsteen, full of that kind of harmonica music.
Yamsmos very lovely words man God bless
This version is one of the most hauntingly beautiful songs I have ever heard
This is one hell of performance! I love how he's always changing his way of playing those limited number of songs. It's been 8 years and I still could listen to every song forever, and that's because they're still in evolution.
Thank you, thank you, thank you!
I keep coming back to Bon Iver even if I'm feeling sad or happy: It's truly music at its best
Carola Puddu same
I love this guy's songwriting. It's just this super deconstructed imagery. It sounds exactly like a memory. Not too much detail. Just a vibe or presence. Half spoken words. All of it. Absolutely brilliant .
This guy makes me feel sadly happy.
Well said. Bravo.
Schaden freude I think? Some German phrase I don't remember
hehe Schadenfreude is when someone is getting hurt and you're laughing about that :D (Schaden = damage, freude = joy) I'm sorry but we germans neither have a word for this sadly happy feeling (although I'm longing for one)
Much love from South Africa
This version of Calgary absolutely destroys me, wringing out my heart like a dishrag full of water.... I just cried at work. Such a range of emotions.....good God.
its incredible how many octaves he has in this song, so beautifully arranged!
Word
Talent to the moon.
Verified.
No expiration date.
☮💖☀️☮💖☀️☮
this is the kind of music that stops everything around and brings you tears of...beauty. What a pearl, what a soul, what a musician. I'm happy we live on the same world.
Ingrida B. Gotta agree. There is genius in this mans art.
One of three songs that give me the feeling like I'm listening to it for the first time all over again every time I hear it. The original is great but this...this haunts me
This is undeniably the definitive version of Calgary. MAN
its my favourite version of calgary😍
As much as I love the album version (as well as some other live versions), this one blows all the others out of the water. I was absolutely floored the first time I heard/saw this. Given that it's Justin Vernon, I shouldn't be surprised by the quality of anything he touches, but DAMN. This is what perfect music and musicianship sounds like.
Listening to this before bed has become a bit of a ritual for me.
jezussss...this guys singing just ripped my soul out...just simply 5 min of pure magic music....well done!
Absolutely in love with this version. He created a completely new song, which is equally as good as the original. I wish I had half as much vision as this man has.
Wow!! the current Dylan/Bruce/Leonard---but better,truly!! I am in my 70's and have seen/heard them all.He is the real thing, and also Midwestern!!
bless you
Paul Kubic you should look up Fleet Foxes and Father John Misty. Check 'em out
I love you Paul, thank you for all you have said my guy 🤤❤️
When I grow I wanna Bon Iver so much!! Just when I found the acoustic version of Calgary & deemed it the best version I find this harmonica blessed performance. Long Live Justin Vernon! Long live Bon Iver !!
Words fail to describe how amazing this is. Thank you
This is probably the only time I have heard that old DeYarmond Edison sound fused with the Bon Iver we are used to. I thought this version worked incredibly
This version of Calgary is the best accident of the year. And that harmonica is just gold. Thanks!
Justin Vernon.... you are one of the most wonderful, beautiful, musical souls on this planet. Your music takes many of us to different places. Forever grateful for you.
my heart is so full. thank you, bon iver.
Going through a break up right now, with what was and is the best girl I've ever met. Days are weird and numb. Some better, some worse. This song has been on my head through the last days on loop. Can't say it's helping very much but at least gives me company through the hard times. Thank you Bon Iver ❤️
Excellent camera work, I'd have to say.
This version is so pleasant to my ears and fits my mood on point to the core right now. Real and crispy
Keep coming back to this one. Easily the best performance ever recorded 🙂🙏
Perfect. His best version by far.
this song will make you just watch and listen even though you know every lyric. truly a masterpiece. bon your the man.
Thanks for sharing, i've got the chills from such a beautiful performance.
My daughter’s favorite. So thankful they played it for her in Atlanta 2022!
brought me to tears!!!!!! true GENIUS
speechless. just… speechless.
Bon Iver Live Performances Are Life Changing
SOBBING THIS IS TOO BEAUTIFUL
One of the most genuin, genious and gorgeous preformances ever!
the ending...
Incredible .
Wow, Great Rendition! Particularly That "Swolen Orange and Light Let Through" is Fucking Brilliant !
"there's a fire going out"
That "swollen orange..." line is my favorite right along with the "Just have to keep a dialogue". So powerful!
That outro.......Blimey!
40 years forward, I'll be sitting with my grandchildren and telling them how this amazing classic track is timeless and I still enjoy it till this day, and watch the reactions on their faces when they discover this track and start listening to it with their friends and starting to be into "classic music"
Hahahaha.
please don't stop posting these live videos!
What I most like about justin is those little details (like the transition between his voice and the harmonica 5:37), which definitely achieve perfection and is present in every song this guy produce
Mon dieu que c'est beau...que c'est pur. Big Love.
I'll never forget that night!
there the best iv ever seen every single song is amazing work brilliance brilliant
Man that dude's got a voice.
(understatement of the year, thank you)
This makes me so happy to see Justin peform like this. Was sorely missed at Eaux Claires this year!
This was already an incredibly beautiful and emotional song but that harmonica just melts my heart. Combined with an acoustic guitar and his voice just brings tears to my eyes. Thank you for everything you give us, Justin.
Oh my god!!! I love this so much! Thank you for sharing this!
How am I only finding this nowwwwww WOWOWOW He never ceases to amaze me. Holy Justin Allmighty< 3
Wow. What a performance. Just wow.
I can't stop listening. Hauntingly beautiful.
beauty in the eye of this beholder mwah xxx
Now, if Justin would finally just come to Calgary, that would be perfect.
afetbinttuzani They've been to Calgary. I saw them play Calgary in Calgary for the first time. It was magical.
What!?!?! When? :'-(
afetbinttuzani like 2011or 2012?
Justin,
You take me back to the first place I fell in love in. Your voice takes me back to being 18, in college, in Seattle. Hearing you sing brings back the images of the ocean, the laughter I had with friends, and rhe beauty of the Pacific Northwest. You take me back.
this is my religion.
Tyler James Blair and I said we are not gonna yet sorry for the long trip
Amen
No doubt one of the most amazing performance ever!!!!
Full of magic
Mon Dieu , que c'est beau !!! J'adore Justin Vernon , bon iver....
I wish this was on Spotify 😢
This is incredible! I prefer it to the original because of the vulnerability and rawness, and the harmonica is a nice touch as well. WOW!
i like his lyrics, you cant really understand what its about without very carefully listening to it over and over, and then still it doesnt tell you what its really about, it relates to you specifically.
I think that some of the lyrics give it away. Sounds to me like it's about a past lover
I was only for to die beside
4:42 so much soul
This guy's frikkin incredible
Best version ever!
Love all the live uploads from this! Keep them coming!
That harmonica though. ..
Great performance. And great soundwork, Xandy Whitesel! I'm glad you're listed in the credits. Nice work.
Swollen orange light let through, your one piece swimmer stuck to you aaaaahhhhhhhh
He sang that part right when I read your comment. It was serendipitous.
@@mammontustado9680 i love when that kind of thing happens. Glad to contribute to a serendipitous moment.
Peace for mind....so talented and Gifted
This is just beautiful.
4:40 gave me goosebumps.
beautiful
The only thing keeping me alive right now. God life is hard
hope you are still around
Incredible rework
Thankful for this
Pure bliss
Me encanta este músico es muy completo tiene un talento increíble
Geniusz. Mistrz. Kocham!
perfect song!
Just amazing
melhor vídeo do mundo
love
=heaven
nice I like ur voice
Reminds me of Bruce Springsteen - I'm on fire, such an excellent version!
Almost forgot to listen to this today
Arni Lochner lol wow
So much better than the original, wish there was a studio version of this
Can somebody please tab this out!!
This song made me start playing harmonica
This version of Calgary sounds a lot like Chris Rea - Looking For the Summer. It took me away to my childhood.
This song man. This song. I'm so angry the way this makes me feel but i fucking love it. I don't know.
wow...
Very similar to 'Song for a Lover of Long ago' I wonder if he had this in mind when re-creating this song.
Who hoo I'm from Calgary!
The best six minutes of my life
this is what falling in love sounds like