One thing you didn't mention in the history section that may be worth noting is that in 2021 Birkenstock was bought by the private equity arm of LVMH, or LVMH Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton. They own a *ton* of luxury brands like Fendi, Tiffany jewelers, Princess Yachts, Off-White, TAG Heuer, and Bulgari. That's just not a company I trust to make good, quality products, rather than trading off a brand's reputation to sell fancy junk -- especially when there's an investment to get a return on.
welp that explains why their quality nose dived. first pair of Birks lasted 10 years. bought a pair last year and they were junk by fall. They dont have rubber bottoms anymore. It's the garbage foam everyone uses now.
cant say much about the other brands but bulgari did make a really cool insanely thin automatic watch which is something that takes a lot of effort to invent and isnt their name just slapped onto a watch
This explains why the repair shop I use warned me against another pair. I am heart broken because I love mine. Nothing else I have ever worn is that comfortable.
As a materials engineer, I really appreciate your testing standards. That gives a more accurate overview of the shoe rather than just use and feeling👍👍
I am happy to see you calling some of this stuff out. I grew up very poor and having shoes fall apart when wet and being filled with cardboard made me feel so cheated when the shoes were not cheap.
By the number of his viewers, I bet it's a lot more than that. Probably in the millions. His review saved me from buying a pair of work boots that were over $300.
Absolutely! Him and Nick from Stridewise are the only 2 channels you need to educate yourself about boots in particular--but Nick and Weston, at times, do other product reviews as well. Jackets, pants/denim, wallets,watches, etc. Great channels.
Word! I was on the verge of buying a pair of Birkenstock boots he has reviewed earlier. Saved me some money. Soured me off the brand TBH.😅 Don't like being taken for a ride by these corporate types who think they're smarter than you just coz they can play with words. Fake ass people, man. This channel is really useful.
@@amanasd26 a lot of people watch it for product review before or after they buy something. That’s how I even found out about this guy and is why I ordered a pair of JK work boots instead of the store bought danners or thorogoods
@@amanasd26 He convinced me that my next boots should be from Redwings heritage line. Assuming they keep the balance of quality and price by the time I'm ready to buy another pair of boots. My Ariats have over 700 miles on them and have no sign they will fail me any time soon, so it's going to be a bit I think.
I bought a pair of Birkenstock QS500 steel toe boots because of the wide toe box. Bought in November and with 2 months all of the steel toe was exposed with the leather torn apart. For context I work in a warehouse, no adverse weather, alot of walking but no real impact on the toes. Would not recommend for a second
On a different topic, I bought a pair of Jim Green Razorbacks because of your video from a while back. I am extremely happy with them (I did change out the crummy factory insoles for more squishy ones). Thanks for doing what you do. Not only are your videos entertaining, they are helpful.
I'm a ballet teacher, thanks for the ballet shot in the feet strengthening section! Just adding to some information here, ballet dancers are much more likely to be hypermobile, especially in the feet/ankles, and they need to strengthen their feet because of their body type anyway, regardless of what shoes they ultimately wear in their day-to-day just to avoid injuries like twisted ankles etc. A lot of us like a slightly more supportive shoe for street shoes, because it's like a break for us lol. I personally prefer boots and shoes with ankle support after being on my feet all day in what are essentially socks.
I bought mine--a pair of Stalon pull-ons. I loved the fit from the moment I put them on. But, after probably not more than 30 light everyday wearings (no wet, big mileage walking, stooping/crouching, running, climbing or anything like that) one of the soles just broke straight across the ball of my foot. The lugs on the sole are still square, but now the gum sole and the cork footbed/last are broken like the San Andreas Fault--this boot was defective. Birkenstock USA said too bad. We don't do warranties. They were kind enough to give me advice on finding a cobbler, however. I've had many pairs of Birks over the years, and never torn one up like this even after long use. By not backing me up on this one pair, they lost a lifelong customer here.
Got those birks boots from the 1st video from a local overstock place for $60. For that price they were ok but wore out in about a year. Now, the foot beds are in my jim green Razorbacks and let me tell you... THAT'S a helluva match. If you can get just the beds it might be a good idea to pop them in something that isn't garbage.
Had a similar experience, got the cork/suede footbed from a Birkenstock shoe which was pretty trash, but the insole is incredible in other shoes. But I couldn't find a way to buy just the insole/footbed :/ if anyone who works there sees this please just release the cork/suede insole
@@williamthompson8591 birkenstock has replacement footbeds available. They usually run $20-60. They're easy to find online but you can email birk and get them direct.
@@aceman1126 I've seen some replacements but not with suede and cork specifically. Most have synthetic fabric on top instead of suede, there's a leather one with foam. I'm particular to cork and suede specifically, which isn't listed on their website haha
I’ve owned the Marton for the last two years. They’re great shoes but as you’ve said, they’re just a lace-up sandal. One point I feel was overlooked is...they are in no way waterproof or water resistant. Honestly, I don’t wear them in the slightest rain. That being said, I love them. I’ll buy them again...if they’re not discontinued.
Ok so I own a few pairs of Birkenstocks and I do have the BS Birks from this video. As someone who just wants to keep his feet warm and dry throughout the cold months, they do exactly what I need. Yes I kinda knew they were overpriced going in, but I don't regret buying them. You hold boots to much higher standards and I commend you for it. It's fascinating seeing the insides. Keep up the good work, but thought you might want to hear a slightly different perspective 👍🏻
I love my Martons! Been wearing Arizonas for 20+ years and the Marton made sense to me for all the reasons you said. I know how it will fit and there’s no surprises hidden inside.
I’ve owned Stalon’s for about 3 years now and all of what you said is correct. Luckily, I have a habit of being good about conditioning my boots, so I’ve only experience *minimal* cracking 💀
Great video! I own actually own both Vivo Barefoot shoes and these BS Stalons;) I bought the Birkenstocks AFTER prior warnings in your other videos👀 I was looking for Chelsea / slip on style boots with a roomy toe box and didn’t find many alternatives besides the Stalons. Plus…I got them on sale for €122, which I think is a decent price. Because despite the obvious flaws (and lies😬), they’re pretty darn comfy!
I worked for a Birkenstock distributor years ago, it had highest volume retail sales of Birks in the US ( Key West ). Did all the repairs and orthopedic modifications for the store as well. I've also worn them for about 40 years now. I never tried any of the shoes back when I worked at the store, but by the looks of what I see in your video, the quality of the construction has definitely fallen off :(
I’ve got some from 15 and 20 years ago and Boston’s construction has stayed relatively the same regarding leather and cork. EVA slightly different. Just grabbed the Martons!
Do you have any experience with Birkenstock’s insoles? I’m wondering which would be the most like the Arizona footbed, so I can put them into a pair of boat shoes.
@@12cc90 When I worked for them, all the footbeds were actually identical, didn't matter if it was a Boston clog or the Arizona 2-strap. Only the leather uppers were different. I can't say if this is still true, but would think so
Thanks for the reviews and teardowns Weston! The Birmingham looks like a really nice boot on the outside, but after seeing the teardowns, I'll proceed with caution when it comes to Birkenstock boots.
I have 2 pairs of Birkenstock Timmins boots, black and tan. It’s an older style, no longer available, with an unusual design more like a leather shoe with a wool felt upper. They have the traditional Birkenstock removable cork & leather lined footbed. I’ve found them extremely comfortable and durable, very happy with them. I believe I paid about $125 after they had been discontinued. I like the feel of Birkenstock shoes and own many pairs, Montana being my favorite. I also own and appreciate well crafted heritage boots including Red Wing & Grant Stone. Looking forward to getting a pair of Nicks or Franks too.
The sandal one is actually a good idea. Maybe a bit expensive for what it is, but their sandals are durable and long-lasting (except the easy to replace sole of course), so I wouldn't have reservations about longevity. The medium priced model is a ripoff, it's a budget boot/shoe for twice the price.
I'm really glad you made this video. I love birkenstock sandals and I wear their sneakers (which obviously aren't the best construction cause they're sneakers bur they have a cork insole so they're really comfortable) and I've considered getting a boot. I'm really glad I don't own a boot yet because now I know I'd much rather get the mocktoe than one of the other styles, because even though it's very simply constructed, it's gonna have the feel of an Arizona and be fixable with cork sealant and stuff in the same way an Arizona is.
Those leather walets are awesome and to be able to customize is awesome. I've had one of those for years then the string gave out. I should order another one.
Thank you so much for this review!! The Marton is what I've been wishing Birk would make for years! Picked up a pair, very happy with it. You're absolutely right about the 'oiled' leather being quite dry. Hot-stuffed the leather with a couple of generous layers of fiebings, and it's a lot happier. Thanks again for you do! Good entertainment, and sound advice.
@@RoyalJesusChrist The footbeds of their sandals and slippers are, but that's just about it. I'm just glad they didn't move their entire operation to China, like so many other shameless European brands have done.
lol true, but i recently caved and got a kyoto sandal and the Bend low sneaker from the outlets for dirt cheap, and their actually pretty comfy. their boots are obviously trash from this vid. but their sneaker quality is actually nice
From the boot pro, hearing you say you'd need a new boot if you kessed up the front of the vamp, leads me to believe you forget the uppers are almost always salvageable. If you have good uppers, its a good way to get a NW boot, for about 3 to 400 depending on then company, vs 6 to 800 plus. Still having broken in uppers. Even way cheaper than that, if you go with some type of local cobbler who just enjoys the craft, and it's out to gut you wallet.
The Marton is imo where Birkenstock should have started and stopped with their boot entry. A few chukka options and 3 eyelet closed shoes with the same sandal footbed are all great options. The leather on the Marton can easily be conditioned like the leathers on the London and Naples models.
Yeah the fake cork layer is a real deceiver IMO too. I own a pair of the last reviewed boots (that you royally bagged on) and they're pretty much the sandal with an upper too. Crazy wide and the cork insole; you can't really go wrong if you're a birk person, big comfort and little style is definitely what youi're after
Man I just missed barefoot February, but the Flux adapt runner seems interesting. No support, zero drop, and a wide toe box like a barefoot shoe, but still has cushioning to make it a proper road running shoe. So, not exactly barefoot, but no support either.
I have red wing Thorogood moc toe Thursday sneaker and I also have the birk Marton it is very light weight so I just applied some mink oil to condition the leather it’s actually very comfortable it may not be as heavy duty but for walking around especially for my fast paced walking job it does the job well I don’t need it to be a heavy duty or dirty environment the support and comfort is on point for 170 it maybe overpriced it shoulda been more like 149 but yea it’s very light weight so far no rips just some wrinkles but that is because I didn’t conditioned it for like 3 months till now I’ve had it it for about 3-4 months we’ll see how they last I will like about 3 years maybe
Great vid. Have been following your channel for a couple of years. At this point I check in before I buy a shoe. Fantastic content. Keep up the good work.
Can someone tell me where can I get one of those knife which he is using to cut the boot apart? (14:37 mark) I am trying my re-sole my own shoes, and I need a knife to cut of the rubber edge. Thanks
Those Birkenstock sandal footbeds are 100% replaceable. I've been looking for a Birkenstock cobbler to restore my 21 yr old Bostons and Arizonas and have seen the option for a complete new footbed, as well as cork repair and of course resoling.
I have the Marten roast, the last pair. Had them for 5 years, and they are still fine. Feels like good quality and very comfortable. I love the materials, I just wish they had used vegetables tanned leather
I've got the Birmingham Slip On and they're very comfortable but the upper is separating from the midsole in multiple places after only a month of owning them. The stitching is fine it's just the part that's glued that has separated. Birkenstock customer support has been great and they're happy to replace or return them. Just trying to decide whether to return or exchange them.
At some of those prices I expect more. Rock Roosters are under 200 and they use decent materials. No reason why Birkenstock can't use good materials on all these boots.
I’m got 2 pair of bostons.. last pair I bought in July 2022 and the front rubber sole was separating from the foam that attaches to the shoe. I’ve been on Reddit following Birkenstock owners and been noticing crappy quality control reports from birky owners lately.
I'm a "city boot" kind of footwear consumer :) I have a pair of Johnston & Murphy Alpine boots that have lasted about 3 years and around a thousand miles, but the leather is cracking around the forefoot. I wear them on a mix of sidewalks and the gravel and dirt trails around town. I like the look a lot better than the synthetic-mashup look that most hiking boots have.
Be interesting to know your view on the Stalon Sandcastle colour. Looking at that sole in the Birkenstock images it appears to be full-on cork. I note also that the Sandcastle colour is only in the regular width, the others also are in narrow.
I was about to say that yes haha, just got them a couple weeks ago. I wear barefoot shoes most of the time so the "normal" safety shoes my company gave me were giving me some back pain even after half shifts, I really didn't think I could combine those two worlds but the birks really saved my ass. Removed the cork too and put in some good enough matching insole from a pair of xero shoes
@@haroldvonschwartzenstien3581 How's the upper and sole holding up on the QS700 after 1.5 years? I think they will be my next safety boot. I'm really getting into the zero drop and wide toe box footwear. I'd love it if Weston would do a review/teardown on one.
I can vouch for the black oiled leather Birk "Naples" moccasins. Original footbed, Eva midsole and rubber outsole. Looks and feels really nice. Way better looking than the Bostons.
The blue insole is the burko athletic insole and the one that's all cork is the burko classic insole, at least that's what they used to call them 3 years ago when I worked at a store that sold Birkenstocks in the insoles. The athletic one is designed to give you a sneaker like feel to whatever you're wearing they don't last as long but the arch support in them is really good.
I bought the Birmingham boots, they were great as not many boots have a wide enough toe box to accommodate the type of orthotic I need. Decided to go for them after watching your review. Sadly one of the lace hooks sheered off after only two weeks.
I have the Stalons, I bought them around black friday for a bit more than 90$. I bought them expecting the quality to be mediocre because I have seen the teardown of another Birkentock boot that you did but the big discount got me. I don't wear them much (once a week at most). The main positive thing that I can say is that they are really comfortable. However, they are definetely not worth the full price.
I do agree tho I woulda like for them to use a little bit more thicker leather on that and also the pictures seemed like the leather was more ruffed up like a aged look but when I got them they looked straight orange brown color another flaw is that it does stain my socks with like a brown orange color every time so if yal get that make sure yal get brown or black socks because it does it to my gray Nikes
Thank you for your video! as an unfortunate owner of the Stalon boots (got them in January 2022 here in Germany), I now understand why my 170 euro boots got a puncture in the sole within a few months of owning them and now have a 3 cm gash in the sole that makes my socks wet whenever I step in a rain puddle. And why the leather has started flaking at specific stress points within one year of owning them. I will stay away from Birkenstock boots in the future.
i bought a pair of birkenstock boots, as i need the toe space and cant wear sandles all summer. fan of the sandles and the boots are comfy for everyday wear but yes they are made with fake liner
i bought the martin. super comfortable went for my usual Arizona size. but recommend you go one size up.... as my outer toes rub against the front of the shoe
That’s cool that you mentioned Birkenstocks are on the same spectrum as Barefoot shoes. I love Birks for the wide toe box, support, comfort, and fun styles. However, they are limited in some ways (like not many flats or dressier styles) and there’s the issue of them being bought out, QC issues. I haven’t really been able to find wide toe box as well as support. I have overpronation so can’t do Barefoot. I guess I could put an overpronation insert into a Barefoot shoe? If anyone has any recs let me know.
I'd buy the mocasins because they are what they seem to be. The sandals are great, the boot doesn't cost much more than the sandals. I'd rather have a pair of JK 300s for $20 more than the Horween Birks.
Bought a pair of Birkenstocks couple years back having swore I Never Never Never would having seen my boss sport those noxious open toe Sandler 314 days a year. Ugly BUT the Moc Boot with Wool uppers caught my eye and then my feet equating to my Heart. Comfort beyond belief AFTER INITIAL leg stretch period. I loved them had a apprentice cobbler Referral and he Jacked them up. No luck locating like boots til now. I may risk the Martin's look similar. Thank you. You da Man
I'm sure you have done a video on leather treatments and conditioners. I regularly use Nikwax leather wax for smooth leather for waterproofing and conditioning. How does that compare to the other products out there? I just ordered a new pair of leather oxfords for work and want to make sure I take care of them as soon as I take them out of the box.
I don't know about their boots, but their sandals were painful to walk on...with those horrible ridges and contours.. then I got a pair of Bata Quovadis, which was only 1/4th of the cost , and had aperfectly contoured sole. If you can get them then I suggest to do a blind test of Bata Quovadis and Birkenstock.
hi Weston! Thank you very much for this video! I was really, really hoping (and commented in one of your older vids) that you will cut the Birmingham in half. I love Birkenstocks sandals and lately their boots because of the really wide toebox - they do not squish my toes. I own a pair of Brysons and they are quite comfy, although I do not believe them to be high quality and worth their money. I would really love to see you cut them in half, although they would be similarly constructed to the stalons just with the eva sole of their sandals. However I ordered the Birminghams a couple of months ago a I was looking for a tough boot. The price is steep and I found the tongue to be really really disappointing. All in all I returned them as I was not feeling paying so much money for something that doesnt convince me. And after watching this review I have to say - the cut midsole combined with the wavy inner part of the sole kind of throws me off. If they have had skipped those two I might have reconsidered but now I am not so sure... Combine it with the abomination of a tongue and I dont think I want them. I might consider the chelsea version though as i does not have a tongue and is a bit cheaper. Cheers and keep up the good work!
I would love to see you cut into some of the Birkenstock sneakers, like the Bend and Oswego styles! They have some cork showing along the edge and I wonder if it’s also purely for style rather than throughout the whole sole.
I think it'd be cool if you compared their claims to what is really in their shoes. For example, they'll usually say their shoes are leather lined but with this much pseudo fake leather can that even be trusted?
I wore a pair of Stalons all last winter (practically daily) and they were very comfortable, kept my feet dry, and were warm. BUT...the sole did wear out showing what looks to be the inner void through one of the lugs. So now it looks like this sole cant be replaced, only repaired. So which chelsea style boot would you recommend that is NOT BS??
I want some review on the boot brand kodiak. They mostly have work boot, but they have the kodiak 8 inch McKinney. With steel cap or no cap They are 179$ cad +tx Like 150$ USD I realy like them they are confy and sturdy for my use. But i've always wonder about the conception of those, for the price.
Well, for that 350$ I'd get myself maiusa Thursday Logger boots, for those chelsey boots which are 200$, I already have Redback's Bobcats and would choose them over any other, and the cheapest and the most original ones I would try,cause I have the same sandals and love em!
I have like 8 pairs of Birks, all full cork footbed, sandals, clogs, shoes, etc. The age range is 30 to 6 years old. Periodically you do have to replace footbed. Can you replace the footbed on the Marton? ❓
Test Alico's Guide boots. They're easily the most heavy duty boot I've ever found. Made in Italy with 3mm "Perwanger" leather. Took about 6 months for me to even break in...I'm curious how they would stack up!
Purchased a few shoes and boots because of your videos, so thank you for what you do. If you ever do another sneaker video, I'd love to see you rip apart those Big Baller Brand basketball shoes from a few years back lol.
This is what you should have done with the RM video (though understandable it may be too costly). Compared the comfort craftsman to the classic (leather sole) and then maybe one of their lace up boots
Do you have to use a knife to start cutting the boot in half or can it ALL be done with a band saw? What's the significance of the the Cut Centered Score? Thanks for clearing up those two questions I ponder with each of your boot reviews. Cheers!
I think your dream boots are made of steel...x'DD wow... I have them and are really resistant... and excellent for my feets, which is the main reason why I decided to buy these. I had also Kickers Kickstoner for years and are as resistant as these Binkerstone Birmingham lace... but it is true that they are not military quality (I had also Segarra, military quality for years and years... not just sewed but also SCREWED x'DDD)
For arch march id love to see some Italian hikers like the la sportiva mountaineering boots that my families tree company switched over too and some zamberlans
I'd love to see a similar video breaking down boots from LL.Bean. I know you've done their duck boot, but I'm curious as the the quality of their work boot and heritage style boots.
Get a high quality wallet, belt or MORE in the Rose Anvil shop here - bit.ly/44jXLNu
One thing you didn't mention in the history section that may be worth noting is that in 2021 Birkenstock was bought by the private equity arm of LVMH, or LVMH Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton. They own a *ton* of luxury brands like Fendi, Tiffany jewelers, Princess Yachts, Off-White, TAG Heuer, and Bulgari. That's just not a company I trust to make good, quality products, rather than trading off a brand's reputation to sell fancy junk -- especially when there's an investment to get a return on.
thanks for mentioning, came here to also add this.
welp that explains why their quality nose dived. first pair of Birks lasted 10 years. bought a pair last year and they were junk by fall. They dont have rubber bottoms anymore. It's the garbage foam everyone uses now.
cant say much about the other brands but bulgari did make a really cool insanely thin automatic watch which is something that takes a lot of effort to invent and isnt their name just slapped onto a watch
@@joshmayne2853 yeah... I'll be resoling my Arizona with Vibram soles, the stock sole is definitely the weak link in the construction
This explains why the repair shop I use warned me against another pair. I am heart broken because I love mine. Nothing else I have ever worn is that comfortable.
As a materials engineer, I really appreciate your testing standards. That gives a more accurate overview of the shoe rather than just use and feeling👍👍
As a person who has noticed that some things are tougher than other, I appreciate the testing standards
I am happy to see you calling some of this stuff out. I grew up very poor and having shoes fall apart when wet and being filled with cardboard made me feel so cheated when the shoes were not cheap.
This might be the only channel on the internet where you get sympathy for such minor adolescent footwear trauma
This guy is single handedly saving people thousands of dollars 🤙
By the number of his viewers, I bet it's a lot more than that. Probably in the millions. His review saved me from buying a pair of work boots that were over $300.
Absolutely! Him and Nick from Stridewise are the only 2 channels you need to educate yourself about boots in particular--but Nick and Weston, at times, do other product reviews as well. Jackets, pants/denim, wallets,watches, etc. Great channels.
Word! I was on the verge of buying a pair of Birkenstock boots he has reviewed earlier. Saved me some money. Soured me off the brand TBH.😅 Don't like being taken for a ride by these corporate types who think they're smarter than you just coz they can play with words. Fake ass people, man. This channel is really useful.
@@amanasd26 a lot of people watch it for product review before or after they buy something. That’s how I even found out about this guy and is why I ordered a pair of JK work boots instead of the store bought danners or thorogoods
@@amanasd26 He convinced me that my next boots should be from Redwings heritage line. Assuming they keep the balance of quality and price by the time I'm ready to buy another pair of boots. My Ariats have over 700 miles on them and have no sign they will fail me any time soon, so it's going to be a bit I think.
I bought a pair of Birkenstock QS500 steel toe boots because of the wide toe box. Bought in November and with 2 months all of the steel toe was exposed with the leather torn apart. For context I work in a warehouse, no adverse weather, alot of walking but no real impact on the toes. Would not recommend for a second
On a different topic, I bought a pair of Jim Green Razorbacks because of your video from a while back. I am extremely happy with them (I did change out the crummy factory insoles for more squishy ones). Thanks for doing what you do. Not only are your videos entertaining, they are helpful.
I did the same, but African Rangers. I love them.
@@KB3AOL Agree the African Rangers are amazing....except for that stock insole. Its so painful.
Thanks for the support, we are working on a PU moulded leather lined insole. We should start rolling that out into stock later this year.
@@_faultee_ Thanks for the support, we are working on a PU moulded leather lined insole. We should start rolling that out into stock later this year.
@@JimGreenFootwearOfficial will you sell the insoles separately so we can replace in existing shoes?
I'm a ballet teacher, thanks for the ballet shot in the feet strengthening section! Just adding to some information here, ballet dancers are much more likely to be hypermobile, especially in the feet/ankles, and they need to strengthen their feet because of their body type anyway, regardless of what shoes they ultimately wear in their day-to-day just to avoid injuries like twisted ankles etc. A lot of us like a slightly more supportive shoe for street shoes, because it's like a break for us lol. I personally prefer boots and shoes with ankle support after being on my feet all day in what are essentially socks.
Yep ankles and foot stability for me hypermobile EDS
I bought mine--a pair of Stalon pull-ons. I loved the fit from the moment I put them on. But, after probably not more than 30 light everyday wearings (no wet, big mileage walking, stooping/crouching, running, climbing or anything like that) one of the soles just broke straight across the ball of my foot. The lugs on the sole are still square, but now the gum sole and the cork footbed/last are broken like the San Andreas Fault--this boot was defective.
Birkenstock USA said too bad. We don't do warranties. They were kind enough to give me advice on finding a cobbler, however. I've had many pairs of Birks over the years, and never torn one up like this even after long use. By not backing me up on this one pair, they lost a lifelong customer here.
Got those birks boots from the 1st video from a local overstock place for $60. For that price they were ok but wore out in about a year. Now, the foot beds are in my jim green Razorbacks and let me tell you... THAT'S a helluva match. If you can get just the beds it might be a good idea to pop them in something that isn't garbage.
Had a similar experience, got the cork/suede footbed from a Birkenstock shoe which was pretty trash, but the insole is incredible in other shoes. But I couldn't find a way to buy just the insole/footbed :/ if anyone who works there sees this please just release the cork/suede insole
@@williamthompson8591 birkenstock has replacement footbeds available. They usually run $20-60. They're easy to find online but you can email birk and get them direct.
@@aceman1126 I've seen some replacements but not with suede and cork specifically. Most have synthetic fabric on top instead of suede, there's a leather one with foam. I'm particular to cork and suede specifically, which isn't listed on their website haha
I’ve owned the Marton for the last two years. They’re great shoes but as you’ve said, they’re just a lace-up sandal. One point I feel was overlooked is...they are in no way waterproof or water resistant. Honestly, I don’t wear them in the slightest rain. That being said, I love them. I’ll buy them again...if they’re not discontinued.
Treat them
Where can you purchase these in the U.S. ?
Keeping companies on their toes! THE MAN
Ok so I own a few pairs of Birkenstocks and I do have the BS Birks from this video. As someone who just wants to keep his feet warm and dry throughout the cold months, they do exactly what I need.
Yes I kinda knew they were overpriced going in, but I don't regret buying them.
You hold boots to much higher standards and I commend you for it. It's fascinating seeing the insides.
Keep up the good work, but thought you might want to hear a slightly different perspective 👍🏻
I love my Martons! Been wearing Arizonas for 20+ years and the Marton made sense to me for all the reasons you said.
I know how it will fit and there’s no surprises hidden inside.
Thank you so much for bringing this up in video. I hope Birkenstock do something to upgrade the quality of their Boots.
The cut diagrams are a fantastic addition!
I’ve owned Stalon’s for about 3 years now and all of what you said is correct. Luckily, I have a habit of being good about conditioning my boots, so I’ve only experience *minimal* cracking 💀
Great video! I own actually own both Vivo Barefoot shoes and these BS Stalons;) I bought the Birkenstocks AFTER prior warnings in your other videos👀
I was looking for Chelsea / slip on style boots with a roomy toe box and didn’t find many alternatives besides the Stalons.
Plus…I got them on sale for €122, which I think is a decent price. Because despite the obvious flaws (and lies😬), they’re pretty darn comfy!
You're doing the lord's work with these tear downs 🙏
Keep doing what ya'll do!
I especially loved the BS UGGs has been doing
UGGS aren't even real ugly boots... Made by dickies a yank company with cheap materials in chinna... Real ugly boots are made in Oz
@@royalalloy3471 It's not about their looks; it's the abysmal construction and ridiculously cheap soles, etc for the astounding price they ask
Love the aggressive skepticism. These shoe prices are starting to get out of hand.
I worked for a Birkenstock distributor years ago, it had highest volume retail sales of Birks in the US ( Key West ). Did all the repairs and orthopedic modifications for the store as well. I've also worn them for about 40 years now.
I never tried any of the shoes back when I worked at the store, but by the looks of what I see in your video, the quality of the construction has definitely fallen off :(
Sad to hear
I’ve got some from 15 and 20 years ago and Boston’s construction has stayed relatively the same regarding leather and cork. EVA slightly different. Just grabbed the Martons!
Do you have any experience with Birkenstock’s insoles? I’m wondering which would be the most like the Arizona footbed, so I can put them into a pair of boat shoes.
@@12cc90 When I worked for them, all the footbeds were actually identical, didn't matter if it was a Boston clog or the Arizona 2-strap. Only the leather uppers were different. I can't say if this is still true, but would think so
Thank you so much for this. I have learned so much from you. You do excellent work.
Thanks for the reviews and teardowns Weston! The Birmingham looks like a really nice boot on the outside, but after seeing the teardowns, I'll proceed with caution when it comes to Birkenstock boots.
I have 2 pairs of Birkenstock Timmins boots, black and tan. It’s an older style, no longer available, with an unusual design more like a leather shoe with a wool felt upper. They have the traditional Birkenstock removable cork & leather lined footbed. I’ve found them extremely comfortable and durable, very happy with them. I believe I paid about $125 after they had been discontinued. I like the feel of Birkenstock shoes and own many pairs, Montana being my favorite. I also own and appreciate well crafted heritage boots including Red Wing & Grant Stone. Looking forward to getting a pair of Nicks or Franks too.
The sandal one is actually a good idea. Maybe a bit expensive for what it is, but their sandals are durable and long-lasting (except the easy to replace sole of course), so I wouldn't have reservations about longevity. The medium priced model is a ripoff, it's a budget boot/shoe for twice the price.
Yup, it's like winter Birkenstocks for those of us who can't pull off the wool socks and sandals look.
I'm really glad you made this video. I love birkenstock sandals and I wear their sneakers (which obviously aren't the best construction cause they're sneakers bur they have a cork insole so they're really comfortable) and I've considered getting a boot. I'm really glad I don't own a boot yet because now I know I'd much rather get the mocktoe than one of the other styles, because even though it's very simply constructed, it's gonna have the feel of an Arizona and be fixable with cork sealant and stuff in the same way an Arizona is.
I love the graphics with the components that you flashed up!
Those leather walets are awesome and to be able to customize is awesome. I've had one of those for years then the string gave out. I should order another one.
Thank you so much for this review!! The Marton is what I've been wishing Birk would make for years!
Picked up a pair, very happy with it. You're absolutely right about the 'oiled' leather being quite dry. Hot-stuffed the leather with a couple of generous layers of fiebings, and it's a lot happier.
Thanks again for you do! Good entertainment, and sound advice.
Rose Anvil is the Project Farm of footwear. I enjoy his very honest and straightforward reviews.
Finally a TH-cam video sponsor I actually use and can say is good quality.
the real value of Birkenstock is that you can tell others that you have a Birkenstock
Das ist deutsche Wertarbeit vom feinsten du Yankee Doodle! Hahaha!
Like anything
@@Alan-9819 They arent even made in Germany
@@RoyalJesusChrist The footbeds of their sandals and slippers are, but that's just about it.
I'm just glad they didn't move their entire operation to China, like so many other shameless European brands have done.
lol true, but i recently caved and got a kyoto sandal and the Bend low sneaker from the outlets for dirt cheap, and their actually pretty comfy. their boots are obviously trash from this vid. but their sneaker quality is actually nice
From the boot pro, hearing you say you'd need a new boot if you kessed up the front of the vamp, leads me to believe you forget the uppers are almost always salvageable.
If you have good uppers, its a good way to get a NW boot, for about 3 to 400 depending on then company, vs 6 to 800 plus.
Still having broken in uppers.
Even way cheaper than that, if you go with some type of local cobbler who just enjoys the craft, and it's out to gut you wallet.
The Marton is imo where Birkenstock should have started and stopped with their boot entry. A few chukka options and 3 eyelet closed shoes with the same sandal footbed are all great options. The leather on the Marton can easily be conditioned like the leathers on the London and Naples models.
Yeah the fake cork layer is a real deceiver IMO too. I own a pair of the last reviewed boots (that you royally bagged on) and they're pretty much the sandal with an upper too. Crazy wide and the cork insole; you can't really go wrong if you're a birk person, big comfort and little style is definitely what youi're after
Man I just missed barefoot February, but the Flux adapt runner seems interesting. No support, zero drop, and a wide toe box like a barefoot shoe, but still has cushioning to make it a proper road running shoe. So, not exactly barefoot, but no support either.
I have red wing Thorogood moc toe Thursday sneaker and I also have the birk Marton it is very light weight so I just applied some mink oil to condition the leather it’s actually very comfortable it may not be as heavy duty but for walking around especially for my fast paced walking job it does the job well I don’t need it to be a heavy duty or dirty environment the support and comfort is on point for 170 it maybe overpriced it shoulda been more like 149 but yea it’s very light weight so far no rips just some wrinkles but that is because I didn’t conditioned it for like 3 months till now I’ve had it it for about 3-4 months we’ll see how they last I will like about 3 years maybe
Great vid. Have been following your channel for a couple of years. At this point I check in before I buy a shoe. Fantastic content. Keep up the good work.
Can someone tell me where can I get one of those knife which he is using to cut the boot apart? (14:37 mark)
I am trying my re-sole my own shoes, and I need a knife to cut of the rubber edge.
Thanks
Those Birkenstock sandal footbeds are 100% replaceable. I've been looking for a Birkenstock cobbler to restore my 21 yr old Bostons and Arizonas and have seen the option for a complete new footbed, as well as cork repair and of course resoling.
I have the Marten roast, the last pair. Had them for 5 years, and they are still fine. Feels like good quality and very comfortable. I love the materials, I just wish they had used vegetables tanned leather
I've got the Birmingham Slip On and they're very comfortable but the upper is separating from the midsole in multiple places after only a month of owning them. The stitching is fine it's just the part that's glued that has separated. Birkenstock customer support has been great and they're happy to replace or return them. Just trying to decide whether to return or exchange them.
I find it interesting that, in my opinion from this video, the cheapest of those three boots is the best one. I do like their sandals.
They make the best sandals, period.
However, they really struggle to make decent slippers and boots.
That's the only acceptable boot they make.
The rest of their boots are absolute crap relative to price point.
At some of those prices I expect more. Rock Roosters are under 200 and they use decent materials. No reason why Birkenstock can't use good materials on all these boots.
I’m got 2 pair of bostons.. last pair I bought in July 2022 and the front rubber sole was separating from the foam that attaches to the shoe. I’ve been on Reddit following Birkenstock owners and been noticing crappy quality control reports from birky owners lately.
I saw that too, I was going to buy some Boston's finally but the QC stuff threw me off
I'm a "city boot" kind of footwear consumer :) I have a pair of Johnston & Murphy Alpine boots that have lasted about 3 years and around a thousand miles, but the leather is cracking around the forefoot. I wear them on a mix of sidewalks and the gravel and dirt trails around town. I like the look a lot better than the synthetic-mashup look that most hiking boots have.
Be interesting to know your view on the Stalon Sandcastle colour. Looking at that sole in the Birkenstock images it appears to be full-on cork. I note also that the Sandcastle colour is only in the regular width, the others also are in narrow.
Funny enough... The QS700 from birkenstock is the best barefoot steel toe boot I've found once you remove the cork insole😂
Brilliant boots, I can’t recommend them enough
I was about to say that yes haha, just got them a couple weeks ago. I wear barefoot shoes most of the time so the "normal" safety shoes my company gave me were giving me some back pain even after half shifts, I really didn't think I could combine those two worlds but the birks really saved my ass. Removed the cork too and put in some good enough matching insole from a pair of xero shoes
How long have you had them? Do they last?
@@chrishettinger8211 about a year and a half and still going strong, I'm in them daily on various sites in all sorts of conditions.
@@haroldvonschwartzenstien3581 How's the upper and sole holding up on the QS700 after 1.5 years? I think they will be my next safety boot. I'm really getting into the zero drop and wide toe box footwear. I'd love it if Weston would do a review/teardown on one.
I can vouch for the black oiled leather Birk "Naples" moccasins. Original footbed, Eva midsole and rubber outsole. Looks and feels really nice. Way better looking than the Bostons.
I tried a pair an hour ago, your video comes on point ! They feel exactly like the sandals to wear !
The blue insole is the burko athletic insole and the one that's all cork is the burko classic insole, at least that's what they used to call them 3 years ago when I worked at a store that sold Birkenstocks in the insoles. The athletic one is designed to give you a sneaker like feel to whatever you're wearing they don't last as long but the arch support in them is really good.
Can you make a video about buying insoles separately for boots and shoes? Seems like some boots and shoes are high quality, but the insoles suck.
Interested on the “Moc Toe” Birkenstocks… I’ve enjoyed my Bend Lows and Mids sneakers
@@marcserrano8878 thanks for the heads up!
I bought the Birmingham boots, they were great as not many boots have a wide enough toe box to accommodate the type of orthotic I need. Decided to go for them after watching your review. Sadly one of the lace hooks sheered off after only two weeks.
I have the Stalons, I bought them around black friday for a bit more than 90$. I bought them expecting the quality to be mediocre because I have seen the teardown of another Birkentock boot that you did but the big discount got me. I don't wear them much (once a week at most). The main positive thing that I can say is that they are really comfortable. However, they are definetely not worth the full price.
I hope the UK Black Friday deals are that generous lol.
I do agree tho I woulda like for them to use a little bit more thicker leather on that and also the pictures seemed like the leather was more ruffed up like a aged look but when I got them they looked straight orange brown color another flaw is that it does stain my socks with like a brown orange color every time so if yal get that make sure yal get brown or black socks because it does it to my gray Nikes
Thank you for your video! as an unfortunate owner of the Stalon boots (got them in January 2022 here in Germany), I now understand why my 170 euro boots got a puncture in the sole within a few months of owning them and now have a 3 cm gash in the sole that makes my socks wet whenever I step in a rain puddle. And why the leather has started flaking at specific stress points within one year of owning them. I will stay away from Birkenstock boots in the future.
once again, a great analysis & education. thanks, weston!
That Every Man Jack's conditioner worked great on my Birkenstocks. Thanks!
i bought a pair of birkenstock boots, as i need the toe space and cant wear sandles all summer. fan of the sandles and the boots are comfy for everyday wear but yes they are made with fake liner
i bought the martin. super comfortable went for my usual Arizona size. but recommend you go one size up.... as my outer toes rub against the front of the shoe
That’s cool that you mentioned Birkenstocks are on the same spectrum as Barefoot shoes. I love Birks for the wide toe box, support, comfort, and fun styles. However, they are limited in some ways (like not many flats or dressier styles) and there’s the issue of them being bought out, QC issues. I haven’t really been able to find wide toe box as well as support. I have overpronation so can’t do Barefoot. I guess I could put an overpronation insert into a Barefoot shoe? If anyone has any recs let me know.
I'd buy the mocasins because they are what they seem to be. The sandals are great, the boot doesn't cost much more than the sandals. I'd rather have a pair of JK 300s for $20 more than the Horween Birks.
Bought a pair of Birkenstocks couple years back having swore I Never Never Never would having seen my boss sport those noxious open toe Sandler 314 days a year. Ugly BUT the Moc Boot with Wool uppers caught my eye and then my feet equating to my Heart. Comfort beyond belief AFTER INITIAL leg stretch period. I loved them had a apprentice cobbler Referral and he Jacked them up. No luck locating like boots til now. I may risk the Martin's look similar. Thank you. You da Man
I'm sure you have done a video on leather treatments and conditioners. I regularly use Nikwax leather wax for smooth leather for waterproofing and conditioning. How does that compare to the other products out there? I just ordered a new pair of leather oxfords for work and want to make sure I take care of them as soon as I take them out of the box.
Great video! Everything in a birk boot review I was looking for!
I had the Stalon and the sole tore through on under a years time but the removable
Insole is so good I still use it lol
I don't know about their boots, but their sandals were painful to walk on...with those horrible ridges and contours.. then I got a pair of Bata Quovadis, which was only 1/4th of the cost , and had aperfectly contoured sole. If you can get them then I suggest to do a blind test of Bata Quovadis and Birkenstock.
hi Weston! Thank you very much for this video! I was really, really hoping (and commented in one of your older vids) that you will cut the Birmingham in half. I love Birkenstocks sandals and lately their boots because of the really wide toebox - they do not squish my toes. I own a pair of Brysons and they are quite comfy, although I do not believe them to be high quality and worth their money. I would really love to see you cut them in half, although they would be similarly constructed to the stalons just with the eva sole of their sandals.
However I ordered the Birminghams a couple of months ago a I was looking for a tough boot. The price is steep and I found the tongue to be really really disappointing. All in all I returned them as I was not feeling paying so much money for something that doesnt convince me. And after watching this review I have to say - the cut midsole combined with the wavy inner part of the sole kind of throws me off. If they have had skipped those two I might have reconsidered but now I am not so sure... Combine it with the abomination of a tongue and I dont think I want them. I might consider the chelsea version though as i does not have a tongue and is a bit cheaper.
Cheers and keep up the good work!
I would love to see you cut into some of the Birkenstock sneakers, like the Bend and Oswego styles! They have some cork showing along the edge and I wonder if it’s also purely for style rather than throughout the whole sole.
I think it'd be cool if you compared their claims to what is really in their shoes. For example, they'll usually say their shoes are leather lined but with this much pseudo fake leather can that even be trusted?
I wore a pair of Stalons all last winter (practically daily) and they were very comfortable, kept my feet dry, and were warm. BUT...the sole did wear out showing what looks to be the inner void through one of the lugs. So now it looks like this sole cant be replaced, only repaired.
So which chelsea style boot would you recommend that is NOT BS??
I live for the bisection. I am down with the Martons, I want a shoe with a thick cork mid- sole
I want some review on the boot brand kodiak.
They mostly have work boot, but they have the kodiak 8 inch McKinney.
With steel cap or no cap
They are 179$ cad +tx
Like 150$ USD
I realy like them they are confy and sturdy for my use.
But i've always wonder about the conception of those, for the price.
Well, for that 350$ I'd get myself maiusa Thursday Logger boots, for those chelsey boots which are 200$, I already have Redback's Bobcats and would choose them over any other, and the cheapest and the most original ones I would try,cause I have the same sandals and love em!
These findings are truly dismaying. Only the moc-toe one is what I would have expected from the brand. Thank you for doing this.
Haha, two weeks ago I searched your channel exactly for the Birminghams! :D
Too late, got me some Red Wings instead.
cannot wait for more videos for Arch March!
I have like 8 pairs of Birks, all full cork footbed, sandals, clogs, shoes, etc. The age range is 30 to 6 years old. Periodically you do have to replace footbed. Can you replace the footbed on the Marton? ❓
buy the classic ones! i've mine since 15 years, maybe longer and they are still fine. Btw. resoling is no problem for a good cobbler.
Are you talking Classic sandals?
Test Alico's Guide boots. They're easily the most heavy duty boot I've ever found. Made in Italy with 3mm "Perwanger" leather. Took about 6 months for me to even break in...I'm curious how they would stack up!
Any Chance you could cut up the QS 700 boot they also make
Can you cut a Double H ice boot in half I wear them for work and want to see how they are built I’d appreciate it
I'm a fan of the Birk sandals; I wear the Boston for house slippers.
Also, kudos on the segue to your video sponsor! 😄
I am very happy with my Birkenstock lace up work boots they are comfortable durable and do the job
It's kind of amazing how closely the outsole of my VTrail 2.0 mirrors the footbed of the birks.
Purchased a few shoes and boots because of your videos, so thank you for what you do. If you ever do another sneaker video, I'd love to see you rip apart those Big Baller Brand basketball shoes from a few years back lol.
This is what you should have done with the RM video (though understandable it may be too costly). Compared the comfort craftsman to the classic (leather sole) and then maybe one of their lace up boots
another thing i discovered about the martin shoe is narrower than the sandals. so not the same size. and no its not a narrow fit it regular.
We need more guys like you and that tanner dude ! Thanks so much
I could use a little advice on a pair of Uggs suede and taking care of them
thanks
Please do a review of Rujo boots. I just got the Trace in yesterday and they are my favorite so far!
Love your review Weston. You're killing it
ngl I saw these before and I was wondering if you will ever cut them open, and you have :D thanks for the video!
Do you have to use a knife to start cutting the boot in half or can it ALL be done with a band saw? What's the significance of the the Cut Centered Score? Thanks for clearing up those two questions I ponder with each of your boot reviews. Cheers!
So glad to stumble upon another video just in time
I think your dream boots are made of steel...x'DD wow... I have them and are really resistant... and excellent for my feets, which is the main reason why I decided to buy these. I had also Kickers Kickstoner for years and are as resistant as these Binkerstone Birmingham lace... but it is true that they are not military quality (I had also Segarra, military quality for years and years... not just sewed but also SCREWED x'DDD)
For arch march id love to see some Italian hikers like the la sportiva mountaineering boots that my families tree company switched over too and some zamberlans
Gotta say, that was one of the smoothest ad transitions I have ever seen.
I'd love to see a similar video breaking down boots from LL.Bean. I know you've done their duck boot, but I'm curious as the the quality of their work boot and heritage style boots.