Dodgy First Nations Voice Results and Low Voter Turnout
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 มี.ค. 2024
- A couple of weekends ago, South Australians (well, some South Australians) voted in the historic First Nations Voice Election, and now a couple of weeks later, the results are flowing in. (It’s a very sparsely populated state). On their homepage, you can view the results, and in this presentation, I’ll show you some of the results and how dodginess ensued.
There were a total of six electoral regions with only Region 1 - Central not yet counted (It’s the most populated region as it encompasses the capital city of Adelaide). I’ll analyse those results in a future video.
As an example of dodginess, I’ll show you the results of Region 2 - Far North. Here’s a map of Australia, and that greyed region is the Far North region of South Australia. In terms of land mass, the entire UK could quite easily fit into that region. It’s a massive area. How many people do you think voted? Well, here are the results: 305 total votes, four of which were informal. For this massive region, admittedly sparsely populated, only 300 or so people voted. How can this be?
Well, first of all, only those who identified as First Nations people were allowed to vote, a very questionable practice in my opinion. And secondly, voting in this election was not compulsory, which is at odds with every other state and federal election where voting is mandatory. Also, not to mention that in this entire massive region, there were only two polling booths. Imagine voting in the UK general election with only two voting booths, say one in Birmingham, and one in Edinburgh. It would be preposterous! Obviously, I’m having a bit of fun here.
To be fair to the Electoral Commission of South Australia, they did have a number of mobile polling booths, but I still feel that only 300 people voting was an incredibly low number.
And now the results, the dodgiest of all! I’ll put these into a spreadsheet, so it’s easier to do some calculations. Noting that there were seven positions to elect. So Mark Campbell with 70 votes got elected, of course, with the highest number of votes. Melissa Thompson was next with 52. Johnathon Lyons was third with 49 votes. Christopher Dodd was elected with 26 votes. Dharma Ducasse-Singer was also elected with 26 votes. So far so good. But hang on, what’s going on here? Dean Robin Walker was not elected, even though he got the next highest number of votes with 24. It looks like he got less votes due to preferences at 29 compared to Donald Fraser’s 35, despite Donald only getting 18 first preference votes. But the real oddity is Jonathon Fatt-Clifton who had the next highest votes at 14, but after preferences, he only got zero votes. All his votes were taken away from him, and instead, Dawn Brown was elected with less votes at 11. Why do you think this is? Why was Jonathon bumped and replaced with Dawn?
Well it becomes abundantly clear when you look at the election summary on the official website. “Number of positions to elect: 3 males, 3 females, and 1 any gender. Sorry Jonathon, you may have fit the prescribed ethnicity, but you are of the wrong gender! We can’t have five males representing the Far North. That would be unfair! Those 14 people who voted for Jonathon in the 400,000 square kilometre area that is the Far North, they’ve been robbed of their vote! This is unconscionable, is it not?
According to the website: “After the distribution of preferences, the following male candidates were elected. The following female candidates were elected, and, the candidate of any gender elected was: Donald Fraser”.
And just one more example, Region 6 - Yorke and Mid-North, which is the region north of Adelaide shown in grey. There were only 129 total formal votes in this region. So we can see that Raymond, Doug, Quentin, Joy, and Eddie were all elected somewhat fairly, noting that four of them are males, Joy being the only female. Sorry Rex, this has already turned into a sausage fest, so even though you got more votes than Kaylene, even after preferences, you don’t fit the prescribed gender. Your votes don’t count, and all those people who voted for you are completely disenfranchised. Same with you Ken, your big manly beard is not welcome here! Denise claims victory. Sorry, it looks like Denise actually beat Ken on preferences, so perhaps that was a fair one.
I haven’t analysed the rest of the regions, but I presume they’re equally dodgy. But is this not the natural consequence of identity politics? It’s no longer about who gets the most votes, it’s about who fits the prescribed ethnicity and gender. How far can this go until Australians say enough is enough? Anyway, I can’t wait to analyse the results for the Adelaide, Central Region, which has a huge number of candidates all vying for top dog. This is only some of them shown onscreen, as I couldn’t fit them all on. Who wins? You decide! Well, not you, but a handful of people will decide for you.
MUSIC
Allégro by Emmit Fenn
Would have cost the tax payer millions too.
Absolute joke.
10.4 million a yr is what we're paying for this shit!
As a running cost $10.4 but to get their approval for anything will cost a fortune. Remember in wa when they wanted $2.5 million to approve planting 50000 trees for charity. Corruption isn’t a strong enough term
But it's a state thing, so how is the state paying for it? The state can't levy income tax, so it must come from somewhere else.
And still Labor won the bi election in dunston last weekend with help from the greens. Preferential voting needs to be done away with across the whole of Australia.
@@simongross3122 "But it's a state thing, so how is the state paying for it? "
South Australia is a welfare state. It gets most of it's revenue from GST and Commonwealth grants which is the rest of us.
As a blackfella in Sth Australia I didn’t even bother because it was rigged from the start...
You probably could have taken the 20 or so votes you needed out for lunch and got a spot.
Ppl saw it for the bullshit it was long before the vote
You know it's rigged when brother Deano from Coober Pedy doesn't get elected and a bunch of fucken nobody's gets in.
@saltyaussie7702 - well mate, then you are more intelligent than most Australians. I don't see the need for either of us to welcome the other to the country we both inhabit, share and equally own. Cheers bro. Mitch, Victoria.
I reckon a lot of Aboriginal people thought the same. Those elected will rake in the money for themselves and do nothing for the Aboriginal people
the vote is NO
3,278 Aboriginal corporations
• 243 Native title bodies
• 48 Land councils
• 35 Regional councils
• 122+ Aboriginal agencies
• 3 Advisory bodies
• 145 Health Organisations
• 11 Indigenous Federal MPs
• 12 culturally important Indigenous days
• Taxpayers give $33 BILLION annually for 984,000 people (3.8% of the population)
• Expenditure per person in 2012-13 was $43,449 on Indigenous Australian compare to $20,900 on other Australians a ratio of 2.08 to 1 and increase from 1.95 in 2009. Australian taxpayers spend at least $100 million a day on direct support for Indigenous Australians every year or $39.5 billion of direct government expenditure every single year.
The figures are based on the 2017 Indigenous Expenditure Report produced by the Productivity Commission. Source: Professor Matthew Bennett, spokesman for the Sovereign Court of International Justice (SCIJ) and International Barrister with a 25+ year legal career and an expert on international law.
This 👆
What he said.👆
Well said but lefties don’t like the truth or the facts, let alone what is good for ALL Australian we have indigenous peoples from other countries that are not on welfare and who have contributed to Australia growth for a 100 years. The issue is do we want to be One United Nations or a country that is governed by majority groups ??
And it hasn't stopped them rioting in Alice Springs or shouting at bus stops.
We could give them a voice
But they woukd still hate us
Still protest every Australia day
And still commit crimes from birth
So a racist election for a racist position was held and no one came? SA needs a new parliament. This idiotic policy needs to be challenged in court as it goes against the United Nations anti racist policies.
No I’m pretty sure the UN says that indigenous trumps whitey and we all know you can’t be racist against whites in clown world
Racist? It was a shitty deal for everyone. Right result. Not Racist.
Deleting my comments? Or youtube censoring
Not racist, dear oh dear...
@@callanbrown7979 VERY racist in EVERY way.
What a waste on money and fudgery. 🙄
64.17% of South Australians said NO
This was passed as a piece of legislation before the nationwide voice referendum
You're doing really good work covering this dodgy business when nobody else is. Thank you
305 votes is ridiculous, no one can take that seriously.
Any other election that would result in an informal result with those numbers. And then to not elect the actual highest elected (because they were male)
I don't think many were taking it seriously before the number of votes was counted.
Although 300 is the same number of electors that the United Nations approved to vote in "The Act of Free Choice" that enslaved West Papua to Indonesia....
Biggest family wins the votes, right?. Not if your a quoter/woman, then the tribal shitshow starts.
Any other election that would result in an informal result with those numbers. And then to not elect the actual highest elected (because they were male)
My comment was deleted/shadow banned
Two or three years ago, my son passed all tests to join the RAAF as a fast-jet (F18) pilot. After passing all the tests, he was told "sorry, we don't currently have any positions available for white males". If he was "first nations" and/or female, he would now be flying them.
Tell them you're gay
Same for police or any other govt dept. qld police with a huge shortage of officers knocked back 2500 wannabe cops for being white males. They really should leave the inclusion part out. Dei my arse
This all comes as no surprise .
Same happened to me for a DPI job in NSW. I now identify as a first nation woman named beniqua, hasn't helped though
Why does decent white folks in Australia have to bow down to this crap.?
Thank you for bringing this to our attention. Without your research, the majority of the Australian people would never be aware of this monumental scam and abuse of taxpayers funds.
Sadly, I feel the majority of Australia still don't know about this.
@ashleyclout9010 The majority of Australia just don't care. There is this manufactured image of Australians as fiercely patriotic, but it is just a fantasy. They vote for personality - not policy, and most of them only vote because they have to. The politicians are very aware of this, which is why we now have a hopelessly inept prime minister who is hell-bent on bankrupting the country.
this is down right illegitimate.
And how much money was wasted for this rubbish. Lots
But don’t worry about fixing the housing crisis right this is apparently more important 🙄
10.4 Million
Enough is enough - for sure, we can say it 'til we're blue in the face, but what difference does it make? When the system is this corrupt, we're not really living in a first world country anymore. The decline is trickling along, and I'm not certain we can vote our way out of it....
voting was only ever a statist illusion of freedom.
We can vote our way out of it via the minor parties but getting that message through to the average voter is like trying to thread a needle with Iowa barb (Heavy barbed wire).
The French found a solution for this...
Voting our way out of anything is a thing of the past now that we are a minority in our own country.
No keep saying it until your black in the face..
I'm sth Ozzy and discusted this happened, labor greens and teals out ASAP
Disgusted* joking. Agreed.
Need more common sense in leadership. Not bullshit snowflake appeasing partys
despite SA being somewhat conservative in behaviour, for some reason they love to voter Labor.
You ask: How far can this go, before Australians say 'enough is enough?'' Didn't we already do that last year with the NO vote?! Democracy, Labor style.
That's right. And some folks way before that. My question is when are youtubers going to stop asking these stupid rhetorical questions.
Democracy, labor style turns out to be marxism
And Albanese is still the preferred prime Minister, Australia will never learn they just keep on believing.
@@branshippo7590 Labor will make Paul Keating's Banana Republic a reality.
The globalist left doesn’t want this. So it can’t happen one of the agendas fucked if I know which. Has something about “Native Self Governance”. And I believe it’s a Knockon from that. Yanks disrupting our way of life as usual. Long gone are the days of Joh Bjelke Petersen and the middlemen like Menzies. Even Peter Dutton I reckon he’d fold. Pauline Hanson and Bob Katter are the only ones still decent. Even then the elitists wouldn’t let them hold power look at Trump. Blind eye to the left Demonising to the point of insanity to the Right
Never seen government endorsed racism before wish I'd never voted for labour and I never will again
Well you’ve no one to blame but yourself. if you had of been paying attention they told you exactly what they wanted to do
@@garybates5505 mate you know they failed to live up to there promise and they never mentioned the voice before I voted but yeah they here until next election
The Voice ref was government endorsed racism
Unfortunately the Labour Party has turned into a left wing lunatic party, they have lost all their core Labour values.
incitement
A few of these aboriginals are ring-ins.
‘Ah Chee’ and ‘Fatt-Clifton’ have Chinese lineage and are Darwin family names. They aren’t locals.
Very few of them look like anything close to full blood aborigines, some look just plain white.
They are all mixed raced
LABOR as a Party are a Fn JOKE
But unfortunately people keep voting for them
@@kateabbott7919 what else have we GOT ? = not much .
Sure, but they’re better than Liberals who only exist to funnel tax payer money to other Liberal candidates in a circlejerk. And other party options for the right and left are all either too small or blatantly extremist. There’s no way to go up at this point just gotta hope and pray no one digs the country any deeper.
We no longer have a democracy - we voted no Voice
This was passed as a piece of legislation before the nationwide voice referendum
Anyone sick of the phrase "first nation".
They're not using indigenous much anymore as most of us white fellas are also indigenous to this land.
It's a term from the UN, look up UNDRIP, that's where all this nonsense is coming from
How would you describe them?
@elphyn Aboriginal?
@@Kurt0vMaybe, can be used interchangeably. Language evolves, some people will get upset regardless.
They threw a party and nobody came!😂😂😂
But they'll be collecting bags and bags of taxpayers' money thrown at them!
NO means NO 🤬
That's what I thought. West Aust actually said yes for less than a year then said no twice.
@gardengnome3249 What it really does is once they claim Aboriginals have rights to our own homes, The UN actually takes over Australia and proves our entire government is already a front for the New World Order Traitors
They normally call it rape if you ignore the NO......
Who gave Malinaukis theright to go ahead with this when the vote was a NO vote , he is corrupt.
This was passed as a piece of legislation before the nationwide voice referendum.
The South Australian labor government should be thrown out over this 36 people get "elected" with an extra 100 people as staff all at the expense of the taxpayer when they already have legally elected representatives in Parliament .We voted NO in the highest percentage in the whole country and Labor just ignored that and implemented this rubbish without any vote at all
Follow the MONEY.
How are they getting away with this. Must be money involved, what will the elected be paid ?
CCP doesn't give up 😢
Your tax dollars
Going by those numbers it seems only family and friends voted.
I'm indigenous in SA far north, and I would of voted for Dean Walker if there was any advertising or info on when and how to vote.
Was that supposed to read ‘only one family and friends voted’?
Australia is rooted.
Well this looks like it's off to a great start.
What a disgrace! All South Australians should be complaining to the Electoral Commission.
None of us could have seen this coming could we, I mean who'd have thought? Obviously the politicians didn't think.
By the way, what's indigenous about preferential voting and women at the top?
A tiny town in northern NSW had a woman being a pain at the ALC meetings and she was told to shut her mouth or else. The reason they gave her was that culturally she had no voice and no rights to speak on tribal matters unless it was women's business.
This whole thing is a sham.
Forgive my naivety, what's ALC? Aboriginal Local Council?
@@lewdubspersonalbest9070 Aboriginal Lands Council. The woman in question was actually told point blank she'd get a smack in the mouth if she kept interfering where she had no right to.
@@JohnWilliams-iw6oq thanks. Women's rights very much prioritised in traditional aboriginal culture.
@@lewdubspersonalbest9070 You're welcome, the people in question are Kamilaroi, I'm part Aboriginal but Wiradjuri which I don't claim as I think it would be immoral when I'm as white skinned as they come and don't live the lifestyle. I tried talking to the northerners and was told Wiradjuri are "Bad bastards". Needless to say I had a great laugh over that one.
I presume this election was just as important as the voice referendum, yet it wasn't compulsory voting? Where is Ray Martin when you need him, to insult all the people who didn't vote, just as he insulted all the 'no' voters during voice campaign? Ray Ray, where are you?
Hang on! Some candidates received no votes at all. You mean they didn't even bother to turn up and vote for themselves?
Well, if the polling booth was 1,000 kms away and a few other candidates were local or near to the polling booth, I wouldn't have bothered either. Looking at the voting results though, anyone who could be bothered could have shelled out to hire a mini-bus and taken a few friends and family for a drive and gotten themselves elected.
It takes more votes to determine your local schools captains than this.
The sooner people wake up to this woke non-sense the better.
10 votes wins a seat 😂😂😂 This woke BS has to stop
Sounds a lot like Managed Democracy to me! 🤣
Liberty
the Americans called it 'fortifying the election' when Biden cheated his way to the White House.
What a waste of time and recourses.
Sad: the reintroduction of formal segregation, never thought I would see this day
It's about time they fend for themselves just like the rest of us indigenous white people.
What a complete and utter farce. Taxpayers should get their money back. I have no words....
Peter malinauskas does it again? How much did this cost the state? Labor strikes again?
I was born and bred until 16 in Sth Australia. I have lived over most of it. I used to love it but when stupid puts 2 polling booths in an area the size of the United kingdom I can't help but laugh.
The people running this are adults aren't they.
Qld is bad enough Victoria is loony toons and Canberra is full of it, politicians for those that did not get my run on.
Sth Aust you win. Hey you do know West Aust cancelled their Aborigines ruling the state don't you?
Mass migration out of Sth Aust I am betting in the very near future.
When our house is paid off we will probably move to the West. My husband has family there.
Yep, same here. Once I'm done fixing my house up and getting my mortgage down, I'm out
I would say you are right.. not much better here in qld
Dodgy as F
And how much does each privileged person get paid for their new, vital role in society?
"Those who vote decide nothing, those who count the votes decide everything." - Joseph Stalin.
Thankyou for the presentations you deliver, they’re really awesome mate.
What a wonderful example of a failed social experiment!
man how good is Democracy, imagine voting for the voice and it failing but going ahead with it anyway......
Did the South Australian premier know that they lost the first vote when the country voted on it for the first time. Was he asleep.
Is each of these elected representative’s new role a full time job. If so what is their yearly salary. Do they get staff, offices and a Toyota Land Cruiser each.
Just curious about how much all this is costing.
Biggest joke out. Over 60% of South Australians said no to the voice, but labor went ahead and had a state one anyway. Totally rigged
This was passed as a piece of legislation before the nationwide voice referendum
@elphyn yep, and were we consulted before labor snuck it through. "No"
How is this responsible economics. Wasting our Fing taxes when people need medical help, housing etc.
It's because they can't read their own name.
It's great how Australian indigenous people are now lumped in with the rest of the worlds " first nations ". 😂
But Scotlands Celts are under a Muslim who hates them all.
And the British are not
The First Nation people of Australia are British.
@@tg5834 96% of Australians are first nations. 4% are conquered and should be grateful.
At least the candidate of any gender kept it somewhat in the realms of reality.
There should an official inquiry into this election, it sounds very dodgy to me ...but I am no longer surprised these days.
Can't believe they didn't have quotas for LGBTQI2+XYZ?#*
Omg thanks for bringing this to light. This whole thing is disgusting. Thanks for your work.
What the hell is an, any gender?.
russellritchings8082 • probably a heshe!!!
Each and every voter had parents who only met once.😡
We South Australians couldn’t have made it any plainer we didn’t want a voice or treaty or “truth”. Malinauskas went ahead with it and looks like it’s a shambles already. More money down the gurgler.
Don't worry fellow cynics, The ABC and MSM will decry this blatant disregard for democracy in every Australian home on tonight's news. Bonus captive audience in Alice Springs!
This country is screwed ! Not only in politics but most government and many private industries have "quotas" of how many women must be in certain positions to have a "gender balance." I have worked with many awesome women, some who were way better than a lot of men, but believe that employing or promoting people on the basis of a quota, not ability is destructive.
I live in Adelaide, and I didn’t get to vote because I am white. However, along with the majority of Australians, I voted against the Voice federally. But here we are...every state is bringing it in anyway. Dodgy.
Yes what was this vote about?I thought we already had it,?
Australia already said enough is enough. But the government doesn't care what Australians think. They just do what they want.
Can't wait for the next state and federal elections.
So we can vote a new party in and they can do the same thing because we are in a endless cycle of governments that do what they want no matter what the people want.
There is only one party when it comes to anything that matters. Any parties that step out of line get slandered until no one takes them seriously, and if they can still get numbers after that they get banned (see AfD in Germany, or what they're trying to do to Trump in the US with dozens of frivolous charges being brought against him)
What a scam, how much did taxpayers pay for this? Super dodgy..
South Australians voted, oh, some South Australians voted, mmm, actually a handful of South Australians voted. How come. Oh, because no one wanted this, except the few who would be part of the gravy train. Choo Choo.
They can’t make voting compulsory, because that would require a definitive determination of who is and is not ‘of indigenous origin’, which they know is both logistically impossible and politically dangerous ground. The entire undertaking is laughably flawed.
What are the salaries of these people?
Senator Antic as released the salaries on his u tube page
Something in the order of $11 million total spread to the tax payer up to $250k/yr salaried + $$ per meetings + seats.
@@yogibbear fuck me. I'm identifying as an aboriginal.
@@brontepetropoulos4755 I'll check it out, thanks.
Enough is enough NOW!
How much are they getting paid? Also which political party are they affiliated too?
Too much and globalists
Enough is enough. There I said it, now it will change without any disruption to the poor performance of the South Australian parliament.
Roughly 7,000 Aboriginals in each region.
What is a First Nations person?
Someone that comes from the first nation. You know, the nation that existed before all the others.
No such thing the Aboriginals were not a nation they were hunter gatherers our settlers were the
first nation!!!
The First Nation people of Australia are British.
Prove it.@@lucasroe2878
@@lucasroe2878 Technically nobody in the southern hemisphere is first nation..unless of course your are full blood Denisovan🤐
Shout out to this channel this is the shit the tax payer should be funding, not the abc
We said enough in the “Voice” at 64% said no and no seat was victorious for the yes campaign. S.A. was a resounding NO
This was passed as a piece of legislation before the nationwide voice referendum
we already said enough when the referendum was voted down this thing is bull and should not have happened
I’ve seen selections of primary school PE teams with more people voting and more integrity shown.
Wow.....just, wow......how ridiculous we have become as a nation when this farce is allowed to happen.....
A Vote for Apartheid and Racism.
Meanwhile the WHOLE of AUSTRALIA voted NO to enshrined RACISM.
South Australia the RACIST State.
When you say 'sausage fest,' you aren't talking about Sunday at Bunnings, are you. Great breakdown!
Since the Federal referendum forbade the Voice issue, it is therefore not allowed to be pursued by the States as the Constitution does not allow States to create laws outside of the boundaries of existing Constitutional Law.
So the South Australian and Queensland States that have decided to push past Federal Law, have now committed treason against the people of Australia under original and still existing Constitutional Law.
No laws have been lawfully created and signed into place since Queen Victoria died as per Constitutional and traditionally allowed activities of Parliaments, Governors and the Governor General.
Without correct recognition of new Monarchs, their Correct Style and Title, and their supply of Letters Patent, the government has fallen into anarchy for us, and a Coup DeTat for them since 22nd of January, 1901....the Queens death.
This is why they wanted the constitutional voice, because trying to organise the 100s, perhaps 1000s of individual tribes into something with a modicum of legitimacy and fair representation for all tribes is nigh impossible. It was far easier to enshrine it first and then work out the details later, if at all. Would anyone actually take this current debacle seriously from a legal and political standpoint?
In a recent book, "The Death of Democracy" the author describes how it (The Death of Democracy) occurs. It's called "The Salami Strategy." In which "a series of actions to remove or reduce something by small amounts over a period of time, so that people are less likely to notice any changes." Venezaustralia here we come.
There was no First Nation, only tribes that murdered each other.
Yes, another costly and dodgy thing done to us once again. Time for a new Government already!
The 2021 census recorded 43,000 indigenous residents in South Australia. 40% of whom were under 18 years old.
And white as Casper the ghost.
What will happen is "Indigenous conditions" will start being added to legislation. Big business will support all of it because they can afford the "indigenous tax" and negotiate directly with indigenous elders or get government concessions. Small business like market gardeners, small farms, independent fishermen and small mining companies will get hit hard by the "indigenous tax" and forced out of business and be taken over by the bigs. This is a wealth transfer process from the middle / lower upper class to the super rich, especially when it comes to land ownership. The average Aussie will only be able to buy 300m2 "dog box" blocks in towns and cities, all the acreage will be covered by Indigenous cultural heritage preventing Aussies from even planting a tree on their own property let alone making any money from the land.
Voice of identity over race. It grows more farcical.
Maybe they should provide a vote preference weighting scale, based on the blackness of the candidates. That would be fun.
There would be none.😂
This “indigenous people “ would not give a toss about a vote. Whatever the “outcome “ the Federal Government would claim 100% success
No, no, no!! No voice.
Great point.
Wonder if those who skipped over can sue based on discrimination of their gender.
Someone ought to let them know to file a class-action.
I’m Australian but I didn’t get information sent to me about where to vote 😢
What an absolute waste of money by that State 😂it’s like beating a dead horse 😂 and what were they elected to do? And gender was favoured ? That’s worse than racism
How are they finding out who is an abo. Or imitation abo.
Na it's all good just tick the box 😂
give it a year when the state falls apart. though all of australia is now fucked with this digital id bill that was fastracked. and the media said nothing.
I think I read somewhere South Australia has give or take 30,000 registered indigenous voters and a total of 3,600 cared enough to vote.
i don't really understand having a maximum number of each gender. we are not looking to tick off a checklist of inclusion, we're looking for good representatives and leaders, their gender has absolutely nothing to do with their ability, so the fact that it is such a HUGE deal is really shameful
How the f##k do preferences deduct from your primary votes?
Scam
This is a disgrace. 64% of South Australians voted against the national voice but the Labor Govt in SA couldn’t care less and now this is shown to be a complete rort. Remember this when next you vote.