‘This is becoming a joke’: Warren Mundine savages SA Voice
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 ก.ย. 2024
- Leading ‘No’ Voice referendum campaigner Warren Mundine has labelled South Australia’s state-based Voice as a “farce”.
South Australia's version of the Voice to Parliament has just held its first election with only nine per cent of Aboriginal adults choosing to vote.
“This is becoming a joke,” Mr Mundine told Sky News host Andrew Bolt.
“These Labor premiers and chief ministers - they are just pushing this line ... that Aboriginal people want these things.
“The whole thing is a farce ... they should be focusing on the real issues that are happening in remote and regional Australia.”
Shame all the paid "experts" have never worked in their lives or even met a indigenous person
Some of us have met too many...
I would say thats close to the truth.. in Alice Springs where is Burney and Langton ... millionaire talk festers ... ?
@trevorbramich4849 at least Stan is an actual aboriginal, unlike Ray
Ringland. App
@@dodgeboy9052 100%! They're out of the poverty cycle so couldn't care less about their supposed people.
Thank you, Warren Mundine. In the climate today, it is difficult and risky to speak truthfully. And you do this, more than anybody I know.
Warren looking after himself
Yes, he is sensible and honest, but so are Jacinta Price, Kerryn Liddle, Wesley Aird and Anthony Dillon. Wish I had someone like one of them standing for election in my electorate.
I was born in Alice Springs. The worst thing the government ever did was give special treatment to specific races. All it achieved was tension. It made both black & white people feel like they were of lesser value. I've had this conversation 1000 times and the answer is always the same; the special treatment needs to go. Base it on "needs" just like Mr Mundine says.
Totally agree. I worked in Tennant Creek for about 2 years with Ab health. I met up with some guys from NorForce (army reserves in the NT). They often commented, that as soon as people put a uniform on & fell into the military role, blacks, whites & all in between worked harmoniously together without any issues. Deep tribal rivalry/feuds evaporated.
Pauline said it 27 years ago and got called a racist. She's the trail blazer, give her the credit.
Totally agree. But special favoutism based on race makes the lefty Greens woke social justice warriors feel better about themselves. That's all that matters, right?😮
Well said ‼️👍
Spot on Sammy
Majority of Australians vote against it last year, 90% of indigenous South Australians didn’t vote in this election, what part of Australians not wanting this divisive voice are politicians struggling to understand?
90 percent of aboriginal people voted no bullshit another immigrant lying😂
@user-fk8xi9rb6s 9% of indigenous people voted hence why people were elected with between 6 - 11 votes. If 90% voted then the indigenous population in South Austalia must be around the 200 mark 🤣🤣
@@DamienMarlowe less than 10% of eligible voters voted in the elections for the SA Voice... This is what the original comment was referring to.
Unfortunately the "woke wan - - rs" of the South Australian Government and Bureaucracy only accept the "voice" thay want to hear instead of the vast majority.
@@DamienMarlowe Bro can you count?
And albos mass migration will make things much worse
Denmark in chaos with swarms of illegals
‘Profound impact’: How Australia’s immigration boom could reshape how the nation votes.’
The ALP is purposely flooding Australia with Laor voters and ruining our way of life forever.
Analysts have broken down why the soaring cost of living isn’t the only major change Australia will see after the unprecedented immigration boom.
Australia’s rapid immigration rates could have a significant impact on politics Down Under in the coming years, with new research heralding a hard slog for the Liberal Party.
Australia has just experienced a record influx of overseas migrants that has both boosted the economy and made it harder on first homebuyers, mainly in the capital cities, boosting the population by 2.4 per cent almost overnight.
Separate annual data released by the ABS for the 2022-23 financial year showed that Australia’s capital cities grew by an unprecedented 517,000 in the year to 30 June 2023.
Melbourne (167,500) led the nation’s population growth last year, followed by Sydney (146,700).
The economic reality of half a million new residents has now set in, and pundits on both sides of the fence are calling for a solution as Australia’s next generation faces a roadblock amid crippling rent rises.
Economists have been sounding the alarm about Australia’s world-beating immigration levels for months now, with population numbers “soaring out of control” at the same time the housing construction industry faces a crisis.
But Kos Samaras, Director at Red Bridge Group Australia, says the impact is more complex than solely the cost of living.
“They’re having quite a profound impact on the way this country is going to be shaped over the next 10 years,” Mr Samaras, who previously worked as Labor’s Victorian Deputy Campaign Director, told 3AW today.
“We have already got, in Melbourne alone, over 60 per cent of the population have a parent who was born overseas.”
Mr Samaras said the lion’s share of new arrivals in Australia are coming from China, India and the Asia-Pacific. The recent spike in permanent residents has now seen that group make up one seventh of the Aussie population.
Citing research conducted by RedBridge, Mr Samaras said 80 per cent of the Indian diaspora in Victoria were more likely to vote Labor.
“That could change over time, as we saw with the post second World War European migrants,” he said.
“Their parents were very, very clear Labor voters. I would argue their offspring are now, very much like every other Australian, largely swinging voters, but most of them actually vote Liberal.”
The economic reality of half a million new residents has now set in. But the many changes it will bring to Australia will take years to develop.
“That could change over time, but in the next 10 years, that’s going to be a very difficult problem for the Coalition to be confronting.
“These migrants are very into private house insurance, independent schools, but they do value health and education. They come to this country for those two attributes in particular. That’s a side of politics Labor ‘owns’ quite comfortably, I would say, in the two major states of NSW and Victoria.
“That’s the attraction, but that could change over time.”
Mr Samaras claimed the “look of the major political parties will need to change” as Australia becomes more and more multicultural.
“If you look at Victoria, at the state level, it’s overwhelmingly monocultural. Not many Indian Australians or those from the Asia Pacific in Parliament. That over time will need to change.
“We know that particularly younger voters within these new communities are very aware of who represents them.
“So if the Labor Party -- who are the ones benefitting from this -- keep farming up people from a particular background, it could create some problems,” Mr Samaras said.
The “look of the major political parties will need to change” as Australia becomes more and more multicultural.
The recent election of Vietnamese-born Independent Dai Le in Sydney’s Fowler electorate is proof attitudes are beginning to change, according to Mr Samaras.
“It’s largely a Vietnamese and Arabic community, and that’s where Labor put up Kristina Keneally as their candidate, and she lost a super safe seat.”
Typically, it takes a new migrant “about four years” before they become Australian citizens and enrol to vote, with those from Indian backgrounds more likely to enrol over Chinese-born citizens, who “tend to wait a bit longer”.
Data released last month showed a net increase of 55,330 migrants in January, the highest January intake ever recorded and more than double the 21,000 recorded last year.
“We smashed that out of the water and all it tells you is net overseas migration surged higher than its peak from mid last year and this 375,000 target is going to be absolutely obliterated,” economist Leith van Onselen told 2GB radio on Saturday.
“It’s just another sign that population numbers are out of control and it’s coming at the same time as housing construction is collapsing.”
Former NSW Premier Bob Carr also slammed Australia for running the highest rate of immigration in the world.
“I’ve been trying to get Australians to understand that we do not need to have the highest rate of immigration, in proportion to our population, in the world,” Mr Carr told Sky News.
Data released last month showed a net increase of 55,330 migrants in January, the highest January intake ever recorded and more than double the 21,000 recorded last year.
“There’s no other country doing this. We’ve got third-world rates of immigration and we don’t need it. I just wonder why this is the only economic model we’ve got - to force feed population growth, to run the highest imaginable immigration intake, and to condemn our big cities to a relentless chase to keep up in terms of infrastructure. We don’t have to do it to guarantee Australia’s prosperity. In fact, it’s a pretty lazy way of running an economy.”
The former Labor Premier, who famously declared in 2000 that Sydney was “full”, said studies of mass migration into the UK showed there was “no economic benefit conferred on the existing population”.
“You could say that those who moved to the UK and found jobs did well, but there was no benefit to the UK itself, there was no benefit to the existing population,” he said.
“And I suspect that similar studies would show that to be true here. If you run remorselessly high immigration decreed by bureaucrats in Canberra year on year, you’re just making it harder for existing people, many of them migrants themselves, to get into home ownership or decent rentals. You’re producing a housing crisis.”
Jacinta Price and Warren Mundine would be ten times better than any current Labour Minister, hands down👍✅
😄😂 How hilarious and deluded of you.
🧟 zombie at work.. LoL
Name anyone who's better than Senator Price and Warren Mundine before you exhale more hot air😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Ringland. App
@@Peter-p5u8t Everyone would be better than both Price and Mundane...traitors to their own people.
SA Premier your insistence on this Voice will be the end of you at the next election, you're a one term Premier.
I hope so, but there’s a lot of people like his silly grinning mug and look no further.
How many gumbys do we have to put up in government making inane laws
There's a lot of tanned politicians around these days I notice.
Stupidity is on the rise. All to bring this country to its knees.
We're getting closer to Idiocrocy become a reality. Stupidity is ruling. (electrolytes, it's what plants crave)
@@srobertson4083 You are correct and if you bothered to research you'd see that you are the biggest idiot of all.
Mundane owns a mine and cares nothing for his own people...he is another greedy bastard like Jacinta who also cares nothing but for themselves!
So wake up please!!!
Warren Mundine, a voice worth listening to.
Always, along with lovely Jacinta.
😂
@brianmorris8045
😂 Deluded
😂😆😂 how deluded you are🤣😆
@@markhopper8179The Voice federally was a farce, and was dividing the country, and so is the SA version. And Mali thoight the Aborigionals would come to vote in great numbers. I am not going to ler a few, run my state, and tell me what to do. Virtue signalling is a joke. And that's all both those exercises, besides the money, was a waste of time. 64% Sth. Aussies voted against the federal Voice, and stuff all turned up to vote for the SA version and still the premier didn't get it. As for Maher, the pretend Aboriginal, he didn't get it either!
I Always agree with Warren Mundine.
Good man.
Warren Mundine. Legend.
Thank you Mr Mundine for speaking out and revealing this charade.
The white man seems to think they know the best way for aboriginals.
All citizens of Australia should be treated equally. sure the Aboriginals are free tostart up their own voice but it should be separate from government and parliament and completely owned and run by them
White man - that's highly ambiguous now. I'm not Caucasian but I've met supposed aboriginals whiter than me.
@@Gusto0172absolutely
And paid for by them too
"The white man seems to think they know the best way for aboriginals."
Just so we're clear, what is qualification for being 'White' or 'Aboriginal'?
Does a half caste-caste get to chose? Or does someone else choose for them? What about a 1/4? Or a 1/8? How about 1/16?
At what point does it become no longer claimable? Can you still claim victim status if you are 1/32th Aboriginal? 1/64th?
And when we say White, is that only British? What about Spanish or Greeks are they White?
This is the problem with race-based policies. Many people are no longer one or the other, so it creates division where it didn't previously exist. And the longer it goes on the more ridiculous it becomes.
We're all Australians, the law should treat everyone equally.
@@Gusto0172 There seems to be more and more indigenous people with curly red hair and freckles these days
This bloke is gold. Warren spot on as usual.
No means *NO* SA gov!!
@@HyperVaccinated
Racist ? Nah Mate, a Realist !
Vote labor out in SA tear up this voice rubbish,needs not race Warren speaks the truth.
Why are they still walking around with ‘yes’ on their T shirts?Australians are struggling and the government is ignoring the results of the voice.Alice Springs is a disaster zone and the Labor government is doing nothing.They are totally out of their depth.Stop this over migration and fix the economy.Take control in Alice.
Excuse me John Howard started all the trouble in the whole of the Northern Territory.Warren Mudine is a puppet for the white people
The intervention is the problem but you stupid white people can't see that I live in Alice Springs and there's nothing wrong with Alice Springs
as a 5th generation born South Australian of Prussian/Irish descent in their 50's, I wonder if my children and grandchildren will ever be welcome in the home that their ancestors built for them? Because in the few years I've been here, I've watched the State be run into the ground by incompetent politicians that have sold off all the Utilities, driven manufacturing overseas, wasted money hand over fist on various infrastructure projects that achieve very little and normally have to be redone or blow out on budget costs and have turned the place into a 3rd world refugee camp!
Good on you Warren!
And Jacinta Price gave the Virtue Signalling Labour a serve as well. Well done.
Consultation, consutation and more consultation. Effective isn't it.
The great white elephant, ATSIC, underscored that. "The Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Commission was the Australian Government body through which Aboriginal Australians and Torres Strait Islanders were formally involved in the processes of government affecting their lives, established under the Hawke government in 1990."
Jacinta and yourself should be head of a committee to look into where these billions of dollars have gone
Because it sure hasn’t gone where it should have
The elites just get fatter
Call the government out Mundine they waste so much money and it’s not helping the people that need a helping hand . Your a legend mate keep it up 🤙
Voice is a joke and ALP
If this is a joke I can tell you I am not bloody laughing. This does not promote harmony but breeds resentment. I resent like hell that my tax money is being wasted on pure rubbish. I thought that all Australians were equal? What a sick joke. There are so many that need fixing but they are swept under the carpet. Vote ONE NATION IF YOU WANT CHANGE.
SA voice IS A SAD JOKE !!!
expensive, and pointless, just like a lot of government decisions over the years, both Labor and Liberal.
Proposed and sponsored by left leaning white Australians and then those same people were excluded from voting and it all fell apart. Can't help but chuckle at that fact.
😂😂😂 I forgot to laugh
I'm indigenous and my people come from there..Only want treaty for money land and wealth like the greedy Whiteman did in history..your mob!you greedy race of man!.
Of course your speaking or not even texting to a abo dog low Life like me!
Worked in NSw schools for 23 years and that is spot on. NEEDS not race.
Enough of this race based politics. Australia is one nation. There are not multiples nations in this country. It is Australia. We are all Australians. 😎👊👍🇦🇺
That whole mob is a joke.
But dangerous. cheers
Yes Warren, people like yourself and Jacinta communicating with tribal elders are the voice of necessity for attacking the real issues of today's indigenous people. Real representatives ready with a feet on the ground, hands on help to anyone asking for help, thankyou for listening to your people again.
mundine is too weal, jacinta is not
The two most sensible men on Australian media offering a sage,constructive debate.
Mundine yes, Bolt definitely not.
@@paulveenings6861For some Bolt is a polarising figure but his discussions are interesting and he definitely passes the Pub Test🥃🥃🍷
@@davidcarrol110 only if that pub is Connections.
Must be watching something else
If it makes no sense someone is getting rich. follow the money.
Every. Single. Time.
Check Warren's bank balance
Good to see ya Mr Mundine. Hugs for ya big fella :)
Well said Mr Mundine.
Since when is 6 vote a majority??????
When you have seven people in your family.
Conclusively demonstrates the farce it is. 6 votes!
Or perhaps 11 in the family and only half dared to vote. and while the money was spent, a record number of people are ramped at hospitals@@kathyjova98
That race box needs to be removed. Problem solved.
Same old
Pretend their helping
While stealing the money
The scam keeps going on
Dna testing
Bit like palestinian refugee status
State Governments also need to hold a Referendum before make changes to their Constitutions.
What a bunch of clowns
Exactly- where are their priorities!
How much wealth they can grab before they retire on their lifetime taxpayer pension is the only priority of politicians.
So agree with Mundine. Stop this divide on race concentrate on crime and cost of living. Crime is crime it doesn’t matter the colour of your skin
Well, at least SA LABOR solved the Ambulance ramping crisis.......oh....wait! Is that the same A.G. that won't answer questions on his English ancestry as well?
It's not very constructive to start questioning politicians on their heritage. SA Labor are worse than useless, this is indisputable, but why must those who oppose these clowns, stoop to their level?
@@cerealport2726
It is a simple question that was put to him in open media . It is also a fact he will not answer
@@markrobson6375 fair enough, I still think it's not a constructive question to ask.
@@cerealport2726
I disagree. If a person claims to be Aboriginal they should have to verify that fact. Especially if it is for political gain or benefit.
It's true in order for us stand as one in the future we need to build the Culture of unity otherwise every year the division will get wider.
Good on you Warren.
Everyone should tick the box. We are all indigenous to somewhere.
Yeah you will we get nothing for free boy
Only aboriginals in SA were allowed to vote...2% approx. Obviously Mali wasn't looking at SA's 64% vote against the Voice that was voted against by the 61% of Australian voting public.
I look forward to a day I can work alongside an Aboriginal bloke from Central NSW as well as a Chinese immigrant, Italian etc as fellow Aussies, I don't want an Australia where we have to bow the the Aboriginal like he is of a superior class, this is stupid
Good on ya Warren.
Warren Mundine, for PRIME MINISTER.!!
Lol 😂
Malanouskas is a joke. SA let him know what this bs voice is to them when it was put up by Albo. Maybe he should fix the hospital bed and ramping problems down here instead of this bs.
One country One flag...
😮 yes but which flag.
Southern Cross or stay with our blue white and red true Australian flag, of course
No I don't really like the British flag as an Aboriginal but I do love the Russian flag 😎
I have one question. My understanding of elections in Australia is that it is compulsory that every adult citizen over 18 votes. So what happened here? You were only allowed to vote if you "identified" as Aboriginal/Indigenous so how is this in accord with our Constitution? Is it possible to render this "election" as invalid because it did not follow the rules of our democracy and Constitution?
Real elections are compulsory, State elections aren't.
That this is happening in SA tells you everything you need to know about that state. Basket case.
Smart man is Warren Mundine. I agree with him it's one big joke❤
Warren Mundine for PM
NO MEANS NO ! Silence !
SA VOICE? No doubt fully supported & perhaps, if not fully, then partially underwritten by Albo & his grubs....on behalf of ALL Australian taxpayers! What an idiotic initiative by Malinauskas OUTSIDE what the majority of South Australians voted for federally. Complete indifference to the majority in his state .... just because HE thinks it's the right thing to do?
Good on ya Warren. NEEDS.
The things we all need to live makes the smartest sense.
Stop wasting money and get to helping the people of Australia who need help most.
It's ridiculous the time and money wasting.
You Australian?
@@mikeanderson7549 yep Certainly am.
A divided family will fall.
So will a divided country will fall.
But the average Australian is waiting for everyone to do their thing and work togther much easier then bickering.
It's the norm this shows that Labor is so out of touch with the majority of Australians. And with the Referendum and now the poor out come in SA only aprox
9 % voted of the SA indigenous population ,all Labor has achieved is a larger divide, this Labor government needs removing
💯 right Warren ❤
So of the 'yes' campaign and all of its money was for absolutely nothing, i will accept peter paying all of is taxpayers our money back out of his own pocket and accept his resignation. If he doesnt care to listen to the wishes of the people who elected him then he doesnt deserve the job nor the paycheck.
On ya Warren - keep up the good work.
The SA government should be booted out. It was voted out.The voice was voted out a year ago
The thing is, Gubberment signed up to UNDRIP some years back, so, we have Gubberments now which are controlled by that 'agreement'.
For the record on South Australia's non-compulsory Indigenous Voice Referendum
Just under Nine Percent of those eligible to vote 30,000 bothered to do so 2619
Only Indigenous SA and Torres Strait Islanders were eligible to vote
The Referendum was deemed a failure but representatives who were elected some on just votes were elated
SA First Nations Voice will be comprised of 12 representatives selected from the 46 members elected of six Local First Nations Voices across the state.
South Australia became the first jurisdiction in the country to pass legislation for an Indigenous Voice to Parliament one which probably will ever be repeated in any other State or Terririty
45 thousand houses vacant....‼️ laundered money 🤑 for some..
Albosleze the most devicive PM ever....he can't shake this one of...a grown man going to a 13 year old girls concert...‼️🤦
Get stuck in Warren, give Labor what for.
They discust me.
How much did this joke cost the taxpayers???
This program is small. About 0.2% of South Australia's overall Budget. For context the SA government spends about 5 times on the racing industry
Reminds me of a Bee Gees song.
I started a joke and Australia just kept laughing. Oh if i had only known that the joke was on Albo.
The Labour Party and the liberal party both need to go nether of them are working for the people of Australia they are working for global interests
I think we should have had a referendum for the digital ID rather than this waste of time… what’s the point in voting in the first place if they were just going to ignore it and move forward with it anyway
Warrens telling porky pies....again 😮
No wonder those 2 guys are smiling $$$$
Well the UN doesn't think its a joke as they keep at it...
Mundine tells you how it is. Legend
Truth telling yes ...
Targeted needs based help would have been easier to implement if the Voice had got up. Warren Mundine doesn't represent all indigenous Australians. He continues to rubbish the Voice which the majority of aboriginals wanted.
Just about the best comment on here
Thanks Mr Mundine
makes me feel proud of my home town
Viewing from UK - Warren is Mr Commonsense
South Australians didn't want it. We had it shoved down our throat by Labor
Mundine and Price, should help with the Islam problem's in Australia.
Im from Townsville and i need help locally also. The elders aren't listening.
1 nation 1 flag
Yeah the Chinese flag no British Empire flag 😊
Mundine? Has he paid back his shareholders yet from his failed mining venture?
Is he still sponsored by the Atlas Network?
Thankyou to the Mundine family. Great Australians getting on with their lives like all us other Aussies.
Good onya Mr Mundine! Keeping it real! Keeping what should be in constant focus front & centre! 👍
Hope you all dealing with the black Messiah that Putin released. ❤
Warren, you are a champion for ALL AUSTRALIANS.👏👏👏The tax dollars need to be spent on genuine infrastructure, Health Services, Unbiased Education and in Australia. Not supporting some political grandstanding on issues somewhere else.
Seems NT got $230M in Aboriginal mining royalties last year. You wonder why people have no houses and or live in tents.
South Australians have never been known for Common Sense!
You’re talking about the government. South Australians didn’t want this.
Genius is the European who created a name for mundine as he proudly calls himself.
"Indigenous " is the creation. Why would this black Australian cling to the European creation is baffling to me. One reason i could think of is that he is, bless his soul, trying his hardest to make sense of things. Everyone is saying "aboriginal," so it must be correct.
Just don’t visit SA anymore 🤷♂️ see how they will do in a few years no more money payouts for BS 🤔🤷♂️💩
Applause for Mr Mundine 👏👏👏 commen sense must prevail 👏👏👍❤
As Warren said, 'the failure of the last 50 years'.
Unite us …..the voice will always divide us!
NO means NO. And its not a joke. I am sick of this crap
With respect gents the issue is not really about Aboriginal people its about being able to eventually coral the population into tightly controlled 15 minute Cities, living in pods and eating bugs.