You seriously inspire me. I have been too over critical of myself to the point where I don't release anything for years, and to see you nail this song in an hour just proves that capturing the moment is what music is really all about. Now we could take a picture of ourself and overly photoshop it til it's inhuman.. but we all need to live in the moment and just accept what is, and to fall in love with the imperfections of our creations. When we nit pick our work to death it ends up sounding lifeless. Thank you for opening my eyes.
Totally agree with what you say!! How ever there is also ROGER WATERS AND THE WALL with the invaluable contributions of the othe band members, they managed to produce that ROCK OPERA that is also ADMIRABLE LOT S OF SWEAT LOTS OF LOVE LOTS OF ANGST ... COMPOSITION
I have a weird video idea!!! Go outside, near a busy street or park or outside a store or something, leave a mic(or phone voice recording, which I use way too often for my music lol) on for an hour, and just sit there (or hide it and leave and come back) See what you can make with nothing but the sounds of carts squeaking, dogs barking, cars, voices, whatever!!! Hope you try this!
One of my favorite things from the long ago internet was a thing called “photoshop layer tennis”. 2 designers would send a photoshop file back and forth and had to keep building on what the last person did (within an hour I believe). Would love to see you all do something like that. Could either be spatial (person A does drums, then person B has to do chords on top of that, then person A does melody or whatever) or temporal (person A does an intro, then person B builds off that with the first verse, etc) or some mix.
The 64-Bit Kid It kinda does but it would be for wii dancing or something then it's going to be the new iconic song for 5 years😂just like the original wifi song lol
Rob- Making a song in 60 minutes. Andrew- Making a song in 59 minutes. TBA: Boyinaband- Making a song in 58 minutes. Roomie- Making a song in 57 minutes.
Making a song in 59 mins sets the bar pretty low. Who cares how long it takes; shouldn’t the goal be to make music that is genuine, intentional, and interesting?
Goal, what goal? We can't achieve anything too useful with art, so who cares what the goal is? Art is anything that would make you and other people smile, even a challenge itself is an art.
Making truly great timeless music is a process that takes a long time and requires a lot of emotional exertion. Like sure he made a decent beat and sang some corny lyrics over it. But I don’t think he really made a “song.” Making music nowadays is so simple in the digital realm but there’s no replacement for true talent. It’s easy to get a nice vibe. Y’all don’t have to get so defensive just cuz I have an opinion, god damn
The truth is that technology these days allows you to put your creativity immediately into a song of your own. You don't have to practice guitar or drums or piano for years to learn what music is, these days it just takes a few months to learn the music software in order to successfuly be able to produce short catchy songs. Acoustic music is more complex, but it can't be tweaked and manipulated until it sounds good like digital music software allows.
Gosh, I’m so glad I stumbled upon this channel. What a talented producer and musician!! You dump so much wisdom into every video; thank you for sharing your creativity!
The song turned out really good. You should refine it now that you are done to show the difference between an hour and limitless time. It would also help you for future challenges because you would know what to work on.
Roomie: OMG OMG I am better than Rob I am going crazy, is so rushed!!!! Rob Scallon: I can't this is too much!!!! Omg I'm running out of time Andrew: *chillin* yep this is fun, your move Rob
You could do a challenge with many musicians where instead of everyone using a single sample, one person uses a single sample, then the next samples the song made by the previous musician. Each musician samples the song made by the previous musician by sampling the song previous. :3
M Wadud The mouse has a right click and a scroll wheel. The magic mouse works the same way your phone does with the touch sensor and a certain area in a certian movement causes that action. For example if you tap the mouse 2 it zooms in. If you swipe your finger down the middle it scrolls.
I absolutely LOVED this video! It all felt like a documentary more than a well-edited video, coupled with non-static shots from many different angles, and that made it so much different in such a good way :D
this is absolutely amazing. this really shows andrew’s musicianship and creativity. he can do more in 59 minutes than i can do in a day. major props to him. he always inspires me and make me strive for greatness. definitely one of if not my top producers on youtube. such an inspiration.
Man i cant get enough of your channel. Love your videos! its amazing how in depth, entertaining and easy to understand you make stuff. TH-cam is the best source for inspiration for us creators! thank you for making so many great videos.
*I think when you force yourself to make a song in a certain amount of time it actually comes out easier, better and smoother because you worry to much about it being so good but when it’s like this you just have to make a quick song*
Glad I found this and similar channels. I don't do anything quite to this level but I sit on a lot of tunes/grooves and they never see the light of day because I always want to keep nitpicking. It's a hobby for me and a release from the day to day minutiae that can drag you down. Music is powerful in that way. Very inspiring.
There are lots of sites that host One Hour Compos (everyone makes a song in 1 hour following a common theme) every week, like Thasauce and Battle of the Bits. It's a lot of fun and it helped me get faster and more creative at composing!
This made me sad... ☹️ It felt like a short verse into a pre-chorus, and then the chorus never came... wishing it was “I made a song in 119 minutes” so I could here the chorus!!!
3:27 _"This is the Shaker I've been using for a couple of years. It's delicious Quinoa. Healthy. I think it's a complete protein. - dear quinoa, plz sponsor me"_ Hahahaha, I can't with you Andrew. Greatest sh*t ever. xD
sponsor him, quinoa
#quinoasponsorandrewhaung2018
But quinoa is a grain not a brand xD
it's actually clic but eh
Jordan Peckham and Mark grant,
The joke
Your head. XD (no offense)
Is there an effect that makes the thing at 11:58? I try using tremolos, but that doesn't seem to work so well. Thanks!
Hmmmm
I think I can do it faster
*R O M I E*
You are hereby challenged. Backing out is not an option
Use some of Robs vocal in your track but change it so its "I love Roomie"
Please romie
R A M I
“This will be so sad if it just cuts ou-“ AD PLAYS
I swear to god if this wasn’t intentional
Payton Woods lol same
Yeah 😂😂
yh llol
It’s called an ad stop
@@MrDanMaster oh wait really?!?!?!
An album in a day tho Andrew. That would be interesting haha
boyinaband did this once I think
Daniel Flores yea, the video to that is pretty funny, totally everyone should watch
OMG yes!
make an album in 23 hours to one up Dave
he would have to turn into aleksander vinter to do that
You seriously inspire me. I have been too over critical of myself to the point where I don't release anything for years, and to see you nail this song in an hour just proves that capturing the moment is what music is really all about. Now we could take a picture of ourself and overly photoshop it til it's inhuman.. but we all need to live in the moment and just accept what is, and to fall in love with the imperfections of our creations. When we nit pick our work to death it ends up sounding lifeless. Thank you for opening my eyes.
Jesus you're the one who inspired me
Pretty *_G E I_*
Totally agree with what you say!!
How ever there is also ROGER WATERS AND THE WALL
with the invaluable contributions of the othe band members, they managed to produce that ROCK OPERA that is also ADMIRABLE
LOT S OF SWEAT
LOTS OF LOVE
LOTS OF ANGST
...
COMPOSITION
ok boomer
..and thank you for opening my eyes with this comment. I've been going through the same thing myself, now I'm seeing it all different.
This sounds like something that would be in a super extreme difficulty Rainbow Road.
Omg yes
i was thinking that it sounds like something that would be playing in a club penguin disco (without the vocals)
That's so true
LMAOO facts
SenoritaPotatoes That or something like a Persona type game tbh
I have a weird video idea!!! Go outside, near a busy street or park or outside a store or something, leave a mic(or phone voice recording, which I use way too often for my music lol) on for an hour, and just sit there (or hide it and leave and come back) See what you can make with nothing but the sounds of carts squeaking, dogs barking, cars, voices, whatever!!! Hope you try this!
Well yeah but not as hard for Andrew lol Gotta make it tough!XD
I suggested something extremely similar a few months ago, my comment got a ton of likes but andrew didnt do it :/
Follow-up idea!!! Put a cheap mic on a cheap stand, and see what people sing/say into it!
uncreative . that's not nearly as creepy as it could be
yo that's a good idea
Roomie: Making a song in 58 minutes
Dave: Making a song in 57 minutes
CompuCat Then the cycle repeats until they can create music faster than light.
Ikr
(ﾉ◕ヮ◕)ﾉ*:･ﾟ✧
Rob is flipping tables.
Roomie is flipping galaxies.
"can't get there in a car"
elon musk might have something to say about that.
r'enbe 😂
BAHAHAHA
I love how this video is recorded like The Office
🤣 oh gosh yeah
Yeah lol
You've gotta be kidding me.
I couldn't make this in a year.
what a loser
Aw thanks!
Then just make music, experience makes it a lot faster progressively.
+Slay
Thank you! This is very true.
Keep doing it, have some hope
One of my favorite things from the long ago internet was a thing called “photoshop layer tennis”. 2 designers would send a photoshop file back and forth and had to keep building on what the last person did (within an hour I believe). Would love to see you all do something like that. Could either be spatial (person A does drums, then person B has to do chords on top of that, then person A does melody or whatever) or temporal (person A does an intro, then person B builds off that with the first verse, etc) or some mix.
Erik Kastner Amazing idea, but as you can see, 1 hour is way too much time 😂
I would love to see something like that!
Bumping this 🆙⬆
+
+
3:21 my guy gave "protein shake" a whole new meaning
😂😂😂 Sooooo true
In the next video,
Mastering a 59 minute song in 1 minute.
Those oohs!! AND DAT BASS DOE
Needs *M O R E R E V E R B*
I think the rush I felt when you played that dope bass fill with less than a minute left is what other people feel when they watch sports
Yes, and they say "let's do sports to it"
wow the filming and edit is so dynamic!! i love this format Andrew 😃
what ive been saying, he is a musical genius bit does not get enough credit for is editing skills
Agreed!
Pete Kudelin part of the handheld look
"you know what? i think i might just sing a wikipedia article!" if that isn't a mood, then idk what is...
Meanwhile I'm having a hard time getting a one take guitar cover recorded in 59 minutes....
Same,We can make it ! We just have to keep trying!
I legit love this track
That song sounds like something that would be on a wii sports game.
yeah bro
The 64-Bit Kid for me it sounds like when Mario gets a star in Super Mario or Mario Kart, its the same chord progression!
The 64-Bit Kid It kinda does but it would be for wii dancing or something then it's going to be the new iconic song for 5 years😂just like the original wifi song lol
The 64-Bit Kid well only the instrumental lol
I was thinking a Mario Kart track lol
"Can't get there in a car"
Elon Musk would disagree.
Okay but how did the car get there.
Chef Enthusiast drove upwards duh
Chef Enthusiast in a rocket
nao upwards might be the greatest thing I've ever heard
New song challenge idea: No time limit, but he only gets one take to record everything.
that’s smart
This song sounds like something from Mario kart Wii
Kaba The Wolf it's the part when you get a star lol
That's what I was thinking! Reminded me of the Wii and ds, and especially Mario stuff
If it was longer and faster, absolutely.
omg ikr i was getting rainbow road vibes lol
Yeah. I agree.
Roomie: 58 Minutes
Boyinaband: 57 Minutes
Some acoustic hobo guy: Half an hour
boyinband is not making any video for a long time
Rob- Making a song in 60 minutes. Andrew- Making a song in 59 minutes. TBA: Boyinaband- Making a song in 58 minutes. Roomie- Making a song in 57 minutes.
James Der Eventually Rob is going to have to make a song in 0 minutes
Mac Lethal: 40 minutes.
(he may not be in the group, but he did do 395 wpm - not 400 like the video title says if you pause - in the same vein)
James Der
i wonder if i should do 56 minutes.
Rami 58 mins
Jared Dines - 56 minutes
Stevie T - 55 minutes
Davie504 - 54 minutes
Rob Chapman - 53 minutes
for 59min it's a very cool and catchy song
Making a song in 59 mins sets the bar pretty low. Who cares how long it takes; shouldn’t the goal be to make music that is genuine, intentional, and interesting?
Goal, what goal? We can't achieve anything too useful with art, so who cares what the goal is? Art is anything that would make you and other people smile, even a challenge itself is an art.
Mister Pickles the goal is to make an entertaining video for his audience that expects him to make entertaining videos
Making truly great timeless music is a process that takes a long time and requires a lot of emotional exertion. Like sure he made a decent beat and sang some corny lyrics over it. But I don’t think he really made a “song.” Making music nowadays is so simple in the digital realm but there’s no replacement for true talent. It’s easy to get a nice vibe. Y’all don’t have to get so defensive just cuz I have an opinion, god damn
The truth is that technology these days allows you to put your creativity immediately into a song of your own. You don't have to practice guitar or drums or piano for years to learn what music is, these days it just takes a few months to learn the music software in order to successfuly be able to produce short catchy songs. Acoustic music is more complex, but it can't be tweaked and manipulated until it sounds good like digital music software allows.
Gosh, I’m so glad I stumbled upon this channel. What a talented producer and musician!! You dump so much wisdom into every video; thank you for sharing your creativity!
Looks at some of the best ideas
Make some serious beats
Makes really nice chord progression
* sings a Wikipedia article*
Please do a song that's one long request for quinoa sponsorship. And/or quinoa facts.
kmadcox yes
oh my god yes
Sounds like Mario Kart star item, and the lyrics it's about stars! Nice coincidence :P
Hell yeah I'm the first chord
JereFroFilms
Hello DM9
Sup first chord
Wtf... This guy can finish a song in one hour and I can't even decide what my drum loop will be in that amount of time. Bravo Andrew!
Roomie: *Running around and stressing at the 3 minute mark*
Andrew: “You guys just wanna watch an episode of friends?”
This is why I have my notification bell for this channel on
Should have sang about Roomie
Name *Rami
*Ramen
I agree, shoulda sang about roomie, I'm disappointed in your twitter followers for not suggesting that haha
But you should totally make a video of you singing a Wikipedia article. Any Wikipedia article will do, just, sing it.
OrangeC7
Omg i would love that XD
There is a random button on Wikipedia, so that’s doable.
Could be worth a whole album!
Double twist: first verse using a Wikipedia article; second verse using the same article translated with GT and sung by Malinda
I agree, Andrew plz do this
Rob made a 57min song. He threw so much shade at Andrew and Roomie
He actually didn’t through any shade at Andrew
In whole video - " i dont know what i should do "
after 59 minutes - "ahh we did it ! song is ready "
The song turned out really good. You should refine it now that you are done to show the difference between an hour and limitless time. It would also help you for future challenges because you would know what to work on.
This is honestly one of my fav from you. It's simple and catchy and the vocal humming is soothing as heck
Honestly this song is a jam!
+AYE BATYBOY
+GAYE BATYBOY
AYE BATYBOY Nobelium Uranium (No U) also, not very cool and good to say. Warm and bad.
AYE BATYBOY imagine if Kenny G's real name was Kenny Gay
On 0.75x speed it's even more awesome
That quinoa box = literally best shaker sound EVER
9:45 Ironically, an ad interrupted right when he said, "This is gonna be so sad if this just cuts out part-" XD
Genghis Grooves lol
omg that sound so amazing bro good job
Roomie: OMG OMG I am better than Rob I am going crazy, is so rushed!!!!
Rob Scallon: I can't this is too much!!!! Omg I'm running out of time
Andrew: *chillin* yep this is fun, your move Rob
Hah hah, so true!
That's why the song isn't good.
Which is exactly why Roomie swept the floor with them with "Own You".
Sounds like something from Nintendo maybe Mario kart wii
Hazzard G what? No.
Imagine the last rainbow road ever made with this song! THE FEELS
Sounds like the music that plays while your spectating someone in MKWII
star power up
I THOUGHT THE SAME
You could do a challenge with many musicians where instead of everyone using a single sample, one person uses a single sample, then the next samples the song made by the previous musician. Each musician samples the song made by the previous musician by sampling the song previous. :3
This sounds like it could be in Steven Universe.
No, just no, gosh no... please no
Nope
No
YAS
I like garnet
This guy is unreal.
You should put this on Spotify, it’s actually a really good song
Can't wait for Rawmee to upload "making a song in 58:59 minutes"
Super Skywalker *Ramen
you should have done a song in 59:59
why
@@tijmenhornstra9305 why not
@Dinmeraz78 why not
@Dinmeraz78 w n
Shady Cicada livestreams making mini songs in 10 minutes
Roomie next week: "Making a song in 58 minutes". Dave in two weeks: "Making a song in 57 minutes"
Has Apple laptop, mouse, and full keyboard then owns android phone
Rhoden Craig The mouse gets me. Like you would think the software he uses must make use of that right click
M Wadud The mouse has a right click and a scroll wheel. The magic mouse works the same way your phone does with the touch sensor and a certain area in a certian movement causes that action. For example if you tap the mouse 2 it zooms in. If you swipe your finger down the middle it scrolls.
Don't forget the amazing bottom charging port that makes the mouse useless when charging.
Rhoden Craig apple computers are better for producing music, so no matter what he likes, he will use that
M Wadud I don’t like the apple mouse too, the shape doesn’t conform to your hand
Write my thesis in a week.
Are related to Lucas Mendoza
But did you save?
*A serious program error has occurred.*
*Live will shut down after this message box is closed.*
8:20- *Him:Struggling to make it rhyme
Me:I gOT bArS FRom MaRS.
Damn impressive, Andrew! I was stuck worn songwriter's block until I saw this video!
Next on RoomieOfficial : MAKING A SONG IN 58 MINUTES
th-cam.com/video/13_mawXVXnY/w-d-xo.html
I FUCKING SAID IT
(yea it wasn't that hard to predict but anyway)
It sounds like an uncopyrighted song that I would buy
I absolutely LOVED this video! It all felt like a documentary more than a well-edited video, coupled with non-static shots from many different angles, and that made it so much different in such a good way :D
i love seeing producers in the zone trying to get things makes realise that i dont struggle alone
this is absolutely amazing. this really shows andrew’s musicianship and creativity. he can do more in 59 minutes than i can do in a day. major props to him. he always inspires me and make me strive for greatness. definitely one of if not my top producers on youtube. such an inspiration.
wait what the heck it's actually good
andrew i am sorry i doubted you
I thought the title said:
*"making soap in 59 minutes"*
I think you should definitely flesh this song out! Maybe have 2 verses, maybe a bridge but I think it could be something incredible by the end of it!
Man i cant get enough of your channel. Love your videos! its amazing how in depth, entertaining and easy to understand you make stuff. TH-cam is the best source for inspiration for us creators! thank you for making so many great videos.
it takes me an hour to record a 30 sec guitar solo. this is dope 🤘🏻
You're the reason why I still have hope for humanity.
Now I wanna see boyinaband makes it in 58 minutes
Congrats, you have 58 likes
Rafael Audi and roomie in 57 lol
This track is perfect for majestic causal! You should ask them to upload this amazing track! 🔥
Bruh I’ve been trying to make a song for almost 2 weeks and I got nothing
Haha same
same here
The song actually turned out pretty well!
#PreVideoDeletionLyfe
Simon The Human best tuber
Yup
Simon The Human Yeet
I just came across his channel 3 days ago and been on a binge watch. Andrew, you are so underrated. More power to you.
charmingdevil84
“Underrated”
*has 1.2 million subs*
charmingdevil84
“Underrated”
*165+ million views*
Oh no... a song in 59 minutes? Next on Boyinaband’s channel: a song in 58 minutes and then Roomie’s channel: a song in 57 minutes
10:34 that time isn't the original one. it moves more quickly than before which means it's only like 15 seconds, not 59 minutes
“It would so sad if this cuts out-“
*ad plays*
in 1 hour making better than musicians in months
Dude I love you. You're one of my biggest inspirations I hope someday I can be at least half as productive and genius as you are! You're the best!
Rob's next video:
Wrighting a song in 58 Minutes
LXavierW Bricks I hope so
Nah roomie
Writing* not Wrighting :D not to be an ass
Make a full version it’s like in space that just made me feel relaxed so i screen recorded it and played it over and over please MAKE FULL VERSION
*I think when you force yourself to make a song in a certain amount of time it actually comes out easier, better and smoother because you worry to much about it being so good but when it’s like this you just have to make a quick song*
Making a comment in 59 seconds
Evan Warkentin it says you made this comment 59 minutes ago lol
Making a reply I'm 58 seconds
This is basically an EDM hit
Lol
Andrew huang is not of this earth
He's of the stars.
Ascended.
earth is notof this andrew huang
Nathan Macgregor ok
Ye he is not better than roomie
Glad I found this and similar channels. I don't do anything quite to this level but I sit on a lot of tunes/grooves and they never see the light of day because I always want to keep nitpicking. It's a hobby for me and a release from the day to day minutiae that can drag you down. Music is powerful in that way. Very inspiring.
I love these videos, would love to see more of the process from start to finish! :))
11:02
Arion Prior there's a special place in heaven for ppl like you
Love you arion
#nohomo
wut..?
Arion Prior thx I didn't want to watch prep just song
You know you don't always have to say "No Homo", not trying to be rude or anything, I'm just saying
I spend 12 hours on a track and this man makes something better in 59 minutes. Subbed
that last bass line you added was superb
This song sounds like an extended version of Mario's invincibility theme.
PLEASE COULD YOU RELEASE THIS AS A SINGLE. i love it so much😭🔥
I hope the entirety of quinoa sponsores Andrew
i cannot even do that if you give me 10 years...
There are lots of sites that host One Hour Compos (everyone makes a song in 1 hour following a common theme) every week, like Thasauce and Battle of the Bits. It's a lot of fun and it helped me get faster and more creative at composing!
This made me sad... ☹️
It felt like a short verse into a pre-chorus, and then the chorus never came... wishing it was “I made a song in 119 minutes” so I could here the chorus!!!
3:27 _"This is the Shaker I've been using for a couple of years. It's delicious Quinoa. Healthy. I think it's a complete protein. - dear quinoa, plz sponsor me"_
Hahahaha, I can't with you Andrew. Greatest sh*t ever. xD
Fwrhdyvrthgfyh