A cool way to continue this would be to have everyone redo this while able to listen to it so we can hear what everyone heard in their heads for this idea, and the contrast between the two examples... idk just an idea
There's this really weird, but super faint sound effect that gets played a couple times in the background at that part. It's tricky to pick out and honestly I don't know how to describe it, you just got to listen to it and see if you can hear it.
@leo R Dave is laughing at the fact that when he was trying to design the sound for the dubstep growl, instead of making it bass heavy and over distorted it ended up sounding like a fly was zooming by lol
Trevor Bowman yeah he had this metal pole in his mouth (connected to the piano) so the sound would resonate through his teeth in to his body and inner ears
Jim Tsolakidis of course yes, but since we were talking about Beethoven i wanted to mention that metal pipe because it actually is a fact as long as i know
I just watched 4 dorky grown men make music that sounds like the stuff my music teacher trys to get the students at school to make, react to it, and then smush themselves on to a small couch whale silently fight over how much leg space they have. 10/10 gud video
WeenieMaster 69 Very good indeed, btw I didn't know you watched these kinds of videos. (If you are a reader and are confused, this person is my friend.)
Robs easily has the most potential to sound good with proper mixing, Roomie's actually does sound good I think. I actually like the "off" timing, I think it makes it more interesting. It'd make for a nice videogame soundtrack
I wonder how a slight alternative to this challenge would go. 10 minutes to listen and gather samples without any editing, then 50 minutes to compose something without listening.
the point is that macbooks are way to overpriced and for the price of 1,500 for 8gb ram and intel i5 with whatever amd graphics you could get a 16gb ram intel i7700k gtx 1060 atleast with money to spare
Monkey, if you don't know, it's a inside joke in his channel. A reactor to his "One guy, 43 voices" video mispronounced his name. Roomie watched his video, got triggered, after that the editor sometime adds the clip of him saying "Rami" Figure 1: th-cam.com/video/HXoQTFTFTho/w-d-xo.html
I love these, the first one really grabbed my attention, the second reminds me of an old indie fight boss scene, the third sounds like an off beat Pokemon beat but I really loved it, the last, reminds me of a cool hip hop type of song, kind of like gorillaz. I'd buy each of these if they were full songs.
Dave: - Ok, we've actually got like a...a very rough idea here... Andrew: - I'm finished. Dave: - Seriously? Andrew: - I'm just gonna get my headphones so I can work on my album. Dave: - WHAHAT? Love Dave's face HAHAHAHA ♥ Wish you guys could get together like this more often. You are so much fun!! I love this experiment and how everything turned out. I had Roomie's masterpiece stuck in my head for days HAHAHAHA
My favorite was Andrew's. The instrument/synth used for the main melody was a little funny but the melody itself and beat were great. Rob's was really good too. Actually I'm not sure which of the two were better lol. Dave and roomie, A for effort LOL.
I replied without existing in any timeline ever, without having any body parts, being blind, deaf, mute, disabled in every way possible, and I didn’t read what u wrote, nor did I ever learn to read or write and still don’t know how to, finally, i SuBcRiBeD tO pEwDiEpIe. *B̳E̳A̳T̳ ̳T̳H̳A̳T̳*
Roomie's sounds like a videogame level but with your character in the "one more hit and you're dead" warning mode.
Dude I had the same thought.
Who of them is Roomie
@@coitusinterruptus4226 the attractive sweden guy.
I thoughts Dave's sounded like a geometry dash level
.
i love that everyone used a slim macbook, but dave has his own bulky giant gaming laptop😂
LemonFuryRZ he's gonna need that for when he plays Roblox 😂
#AlienWareForTheWin
O respect that
yeah, i don't know about the portability, but it sure renders videos really fast
Scott Bruckner asus
Rob: Macbook
Roomie: Macbook
Andrew: Macbook
Dave: BEAST OF A GAMING LAPTOP OMFG
laptop*
@@sergiosolomon2250 A laptop that (likely) doesn't run Mac OS. So still a PC.
@@JackieTheCatfox a laptop is not refered to as a pc but if u were to a mac os is just as much as a pc as a asus laptop genuis
@@sergiosolomon2250 There, edited the comment, you happy now?
@@JackieTheCatfox yes
Everyone: *Making different sounds and knowing what to do in the editor*
Dave: I have no idea what to put or do
I love that they're all sitting there with their little Apple laptops, and Dave just has this MASSIVE Asus gaming laptop with no cares given
Yep
The smart one :P
Leviathan431 the gaming laptop is much much better than those over priced apple ones
Dave is smart. Be like Dave. Buy a windows pc, not a mac.
A cool way to continue this would be to have everyone redo this while able to listen to it so we can hear what everyone heard in their heads for this idea, and the contrast between the two examples... idk just an idea
4:34, they all have mac books and then there is Dave with that extra thicc laptop
AlbinoYoYo THICC
Looks like a laptop for gaming...
The only good Laptop
but its an rog brooooo
you know dave is the king when he has that beast fucking laptop
The second one was literally a dance dance revolution song
Really… i feel like im about to get r/wooosh:ed
@@jimbo2091 nah, his statement's pretty accurate
@@jimbo2091 R/wOoOSh
5:40
*Something funny happens that we non-musical mortals may never understand*
David: *laughs in music*
Leo R honestly wtf where they laughing at.
Ikr I don’t get it 😂
There's this really weird, but super faint sound effect that gets played a couple times in the background at that part. It's tricky to pick out and honestly I don't know how to describe it, you just got to listen to it and see if you can hear it.
It's just when they realize how weird it actually sounds with that faint sound effect. I found it funny at least
@leo R Dave is laughing at the fact that when he was trying to design the sound for the dubstep growl, instead of making it bass heavy and over distorted it ended up sounding like a fly was zooming by lol
The funny thing is that each person thought their own piece was terrible while everyone else thought it was good
Probably because they knew what it was "supposed to" sound like (how they had imagined it) and it didn't sound like that.
This was awesome, I especially loved the random synth line from Andrew
Andrew Pappas 666th like
Holy balls I didn't expect this to get so many likes to be honest, thanks
To me it's very Mystery Skulls. Just me?
*Nice beat*
7 seconds later: BEEEEWEEEEEE
IVE GOT A SYNTH! GUYS IVE GOT A SYNTH
Roomie accidentally created the rival to Tunak Tunak Tun
How cardi B makes her music
LMFAO
She can't even do it
extremely epic joke, bro. it’s funny because she makes music that you don’t like.
@@gumass4534 th-cam.com/video/NY4G-wgqQYM/w-d-xo.html
@@oryza1650 Damn really finessed him on that one
"to make the challenge more interesting we've got 3 successful youtube musicians and roomie here" *SAVAGE*
The laptop arrangment by them :
Mac,mac,mac,an asus ROG
Andrew: "Hi, I'm Dave from Boyinaband"
Viewers: 👀
i love that everyone is sitting here with their cute mac books and then there's Dave, with the fattest laptop on earth xD
habelebubele you should see acer's $9000 predator 21x LOL
Dave is the only one with a gaming laptop lol
Dhruv Chawla he's not the only one... I have one as well :)
Not in the video, are you?
0800sofa Boi
Dhruv Chawla ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh mahgod
Better than anything I'll ever do.
Cuarentaydos thank Work on it
Not with that attitude
You can at least do better than Roomie.
Second and the third song sounds just like the stuff I did when i started lol
Oh, hello.
Lmao davids's laptop is so much bigger than the rest
Well those look like like macbooks and he has a ROG gaming laptop so it makes sense
Dave knows where it's at.
Remember guys size doesn't matter
Should be called Beethoven Challenge
Ooooooh
Except Beethoven wrote on an actual piano, therefore he could feel the music
Trevor Bowman yeah he had this metal pole in his mouth (connected to the piano) so the sound would resonate through his teeth in to his body and inner ears
Havu Raivio No, he is right, when you play the piano or any other instrument you can feel the vibration it generates while generating sound.
Jim Tsolakidis of course yes, but since we were talking about Beethoven i wanted to mention that metal pipe because it actually is a fact as long as i know
Loving how everyone else has Macbooks, while David over here has a god damn Asus gaming laptop.
I just watched 4 dorky grown men make music that sounds like the stuff my music teacher trys to get the students at school to make, react to it, and then smush themselves on to a small couch whale silently fight over how much leg space they have. 10/10 gud video
WeenieMaster 69 music like that isnt very hard to make, playin an instrument requires more skill imo
NekoPlays02 you dont have to develope any technique, so it isnt as hard.
WeenieMaster 69 Very good indeed, btw I didn't know you watched these kinds of videos. (If you are a reader and are confused, this person is my friend.)
Robs easily has the most potential to sound good with proper mixing, Roomie's actually does sound good I think. I actually like the "off" timing, I think it makes it more interesting. It'd make for a nice videogame soundtrack
Friend: what kind of music do you listen To?
Me: 6:13
I was about to coment on that and how I listen to that kind of music
Is it only me or this would be good for a old school video game like water/beach area
@@pepega4373 i heard it more as a Factory theme
It's so cool😂😂
Literally me
*dave laughing gives me a reason to live, i swear to god.*
When you're the only one without a mac
When you the only one to like your own comment
Taya Dupouy true :/
Taya Dupouy when you try your best but you don’t succeed
his rog laptop is way better
*picture of slave master whipping slaves, but the slave masters face is windows and the slaves are macs*
I wonder how a slight alternative to this challenge would go. 10 minutes to listen and gather samples without any editing, then 50 minutes to compose something without listening.
noice profile pic
Zebster aka Zebia is a true intellect
im late, but that sounds pretty cool. maybe too easy.
Rosy Times3 30minutes to compose
Андрей Лукинов I mean that would be really hard, cause they would have to come up with lyrics and a catchy song, 50 mins is good.
I honestly think these were pretty good.
Except Roomie's.
Roomie's one was amazing.
GUYS I HAVE A SYNTH
booli boo SINT YUGHS HAYVAE
Lol
booli boo If you can't decipher it, I just scrambled the letters.
I noticed hahaha
Starting at 4:41 where they’re all bobbing their heads THAT HAS TO BE A NEW MEME where they listen to the most random bad music haha
Yes
This will receive vine
th-cam.com/video/FgrEZEq8rZ0/w-d-xo.html
Xander R SNL Jim Carey flash back
Roomie's music should be in a game called Roomie's Adventure
Dave’s song could be used for something like Mario kart 😂
Evan C I reckon Roomies could be used for That
all of them have macbooks, and then the one guy who uses the rog gaming laptop lol
AyD3em What is rog?
republic of gamers
AyD3em Ah, ok, thx.
That isn't a guy...
Ethan Hutchison you better be joking
I wonder who this Boyinaband person is, he looks like a super nice guy who would never abuse children!
wait what?
@@FrequencyFilthy yep
Elaborate
@@KV-oo3no it's a very long thing to try to elaborate--there are plenty of videos talking about it
9:23 straight up VIBING
I like how Dave actually uses a good laptop instead of a crappy MacBook
Ethan Mac books are one of the best computers for editing music , and loading high resolutions so for photoshop etc
the point is that macbooks are way to overpriced and for the price of 1,500 for 8gb ram and intel i5 with whatever amd graphics you could get a 16gb ram intel i7700k gtx 1060 atleast with money to spare
Yes, I too love using extreme gaming gear as I make beats.
Ethan I agree with you, but workstation PC's would be better for those tasks
HuMbLe_MoNk they're awful
we got three successful youtube musicians and boyinaband
Beethoven wants to: *know your location*
MUAHAHA
Beathoven
www.google.com/maps/@58.3428177,11.6909737,3a,75y,175.45h,80.22t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1svAymxK-EqVgBV4K31maHgw!2e0!7i16384!8i8192
all legends in one frame
Jolonto khalil's work ye
All legends in one frame + roomie. jkjk I love roomie.
Rob's is my fav, but they all kick ass. Roomies sounds like an old video game lol
Dave got such a thicc laptop which will destroy the puny MacBooks
Karthik Nair not gonna lie was looking for this comment lmao
Rommie’s one could be a Final Fantasy Soundtrack lol
Roomie's song: plays
Rob: Thoroughly disturbed
Who's that person again?
Oh it's Rami
Its roomie idiot
Monkey, if you don't know, it's a inside joke in his channel. A reactor to his "One guy, 43 voices" video mispronounced his name. Roomie watched his video, got triggered, after that the editor sometime adds the clip of him saying "Rami"
Figure 1: th-cam.com/video/HXoQTFTFTho/w-d-xo.html
Romi
Who's that idiot again ? O yea, its u
Woosh
Roomie’s song sounded like a video game theme 😂Dave’s was by far the best
It made me think about terraria lol xP
I love these, the first one really grabbed my attention, the second reminds me of an old indie fight boss scene, the third sounds like an off beat Pokemon beat but I really loved it, the last, reminds me of a cool hip hop type of song, kind of like gorillaz. I'd buy each of these if they were full songs.
Luther Black #116742 Nailed it!
Britpop Subliminals 07:30
Mac, mac, mac...
A S U S
yes
YEAHH!!! GO ASUS!!
Illegal Immigrant username checks out
LMAO i am watching on same asus that he has
GOD HAS BROUGHT ASUS REEEEE
"I feel like I'm being assaulted with bees"
I haven't finished the video yet, but I'm 99% sure Dave said this...
6:19 every one starts laughing but 6:48 Erveryone is still laughing and dave can not stop laughing
Dave: - Ok, we've actually got like a...a very rough idea here...
Andrew: - I'm finished.
Dave: - Seriously?
Andrew: - I'm just gonna get my headphones so I can work on my album.
Dave: - WHAHAT?
Love Dave's face HAHAHAHA ♥
Wish you guys could get together like this more often. You are so much fun!! I love this experiment and how everything turned out. I had Roomie's masterpiece stuck in my head for days HAHAHAHA
Stack 3 of those MacBooks and you’re left with
*A* *S* *U* *S*
DesiredFilm Iii
DesiredFilm I know right, he has a big ASS-US laptop, Am I right? (Oml that was BADD)
David Brown lol😂
I don't get it
Allen the width of Dave's laptop is 3x roomie, Andrew and Rob's laptops together.
s e c r e t v i d e o
woah unlisted?! We're special
Luigi64128 not anymore
The Comments:
99%: Beethoven
1%: TF IS THAT THUMBNAIL XDXDXD
jack flaps lol
Beethoven triggered
No one:
Andrew: Hi! I'm Dave from Boyinaband
#unlistedsquad thanks rob
The only real laptop there is the ASUS ROG
Kirito thats not a laptop its a lap crusher
is it a desktop crusher?
Rob: impressive music, even if he would have listened to it
The others: awful
4:53 look at boyinaband
Space Kitty omg lol
mangamostr wow so cool
and his fuckin gaming laptop
Space Kitty ii
4:53
5:56 how did the lamp move?? Ghosts??
rob's like the supportive friend in this lmao
he's like " i dig this guys it's not bad !!"
while the others are like either DYING or MOCKING
4 of my favourite people in 1 video... *BONUS*
Lemme tell u guys all the problems
Roomie: UWAA
Dave: BUWAHH
Andrew: some type of Singer Whale
...
I didn’t really want to do Rob
Roomie's was my favorite.
*S A M P L E*
*T E X T*
Yeah what's up
holy sample text
negative chill *OKAY*
negative chill -i killed a man-
Joji!!!!!!!!
Roomie's song playing in the "vlog" while he picks up toilet paper is so perfect in so many ways
Dave's sounded like a futuristic video game that could have their own episode in black mirror
boi it should be called the Beethoven challange
Mewi arts that made me exhale softly
Dave died of laughter when he showed his to everyone
*I LOST IT AT ROOMIE'S!!!*
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
So many likes!!
Me too😂😂
Neill Tuck.
Mine was Andrew's, "I GOT A SYNTH GUYS :D"
ME TOO!!😂😂😂
Neill Tuck *Rami**
Honestly they weren't that bad.
My favorite was Andrew's. The instrument/synth used for the main melody was a little funny but the melody itself and beat were great. Rob's was really good too. Actually I'm not sure which of the two were better lol. Dave and roomie, A for effort LOL.
ding dong your opinion is wrong
"3 successful musicians and Roomie"
Anyone else thought every song was a bop and a half??
Roomie's was the most interesting imo
One of the sounds in his song sounded like my old washing machine. but it was without a doubt interesting lol
Roomie's was my fave, I'd actually listen to that
SAAAAAMMMMEEE it just sounds like something from a cutesy video game soundtrack
Ur getting sent to adoption
he was never taught what laws there are
Love how cramped that sofa is lol
I WOULD BUY ALL OF THESE WTF
"It was like there was a band with like cool musicians and this guy is like 'I GOT SINTH!!! I GOT A SINTH GUYS!!1'"
accurate af 🤣
I actually love them. and Would love a full version of boyinabands
Yoh the "hi" voice crack at the start
And here we see the four genres, Rock, Dubstep, Hiphop and Roomie
CoreyGames LMAO
XD
Hate to be that guy but...
*iTs NoT rOcK iTs MeTaL!!!1*
@Wasabi Yeah but that's like saying country is a subgenre of music. Anyways, I still hate being this guy.
roomie was like videogame music kinda stuff.
I watched this video without listening.
Beat that
I read your comment without looking at it.
Beat that
Gamerix / Rix i liked your comment without being logged in
Beat *That*
@@timelordguardian7073 I opened TH-cam without a device
BEAT THAT
babywolfrl I REPLIED TO THIS COMMENT WITHOUT EVEN LOOKING AT WHAT YOU SAID!
BEAT THAT
I replied without existing in any timeline ever, without having any body parts, being blind, deaf, mute, disabled in every way possible, and I didn’t read what u wrote, nor did I ever learn to read or write and still don’t know how to, finally, i SuBcRiBeD tO pEwDiEpIe.
*B̳E̳A̳T̳ ̳T̳H̳A̳T̳*
beethoven did it without complaining. come on guys
louis hesketh lmao
"Beathoven"
*YEAH AIGHT*
@@IkaSchmika y'know like the Beatles
Its baetoven. Get it right.
@@sdiaz1681 don't know what you're on about.
"Hi, I'm Dave from boyinaband!"
Dave's fans: guys this seems a bit suspicious
*s u s p i c i o n*
Dum dum da doom doom
Right?! The hair isn't long enough smh
Dave Huang
Ａｎｄｒｅｗｉｎａｂａｎｄ
Makes you respect Beethoven.
BEAThoven cuz his BEATs are sick af
Yeah he was able to train himself to tell what the notes were from their vibrations before he went completly deaf.
@@Jaden0 Supa Hot FireOOHH OHHH OHHHH
What a legend. Glad yo wrote this in his honor 👍
What if Beethoven made dubstep?
Laptops:
Macbook pro 2015
Macbook pro 2013
Macbook pro 2017
48 hour gamer
👍🏻
I like how everyone has a macbook and then boyinaband has a gaming (edit: laptop)
Lol 😂
Lol
@Space Lettuce 232 sry bout it man, its just what I saw on the screen and you probably saw the same thing. Maybe that's why my comment is similar 😇
not a pc and maybe not a for gaming but yeah that's pretty weird
*gaming laptop
Roomie's sounded like a geometry dash song
MDK WATERFLAME OR 7FFF TO BE PRECISE
I think Dave’s sounded more like a geometry dash song xD maybe extra hard level
Liamimweix more like a tuber simulator song
@@zicoezmiro2951 f777*
also im pretty sure u just named all the artist u named. It sounds nothing like waterflame and only the bass like f777.
@@zicoezmiro2951 alright but there are more
I love how each of their laptops perfectly represent who they are
Roomie: as vanilla as they come.
D a v i d
@@mirceadraculov6515 his is super dirty too whats that mean 💀
0:10 To make it more interesting, we've brought three successful musicians and Roomie here
*everybody dies*
*WHEEZE*
TH-cam musicians*
noone cares abot you're gramer corecction
@@falcon5178i am agreed my friend
*roomie dies inside*
"To make the challenge more interesting we've got three successful youtube musicians and roomie here" LOL
Morbtsh FUNNY CAUSE HE HAS MORE SUBS THAN ALL OF EM
Do you mean rami?
dave's one sounds like a geometry dash level.
Finn I mean, it has the same chord progression as Stereo Madness.
Zeuz Music Yep true.
IKR that is what i felt
OMG YES
True
"I'm just getting my headphones to finish my album."
What a G
I was kinda hoping for someone to screw up pretty badly....they all ended up with a better track than mine when I hear it
"To make things more interesting, we've got THREE successful youtube musicians...and Roomie here."
Dude, that's evil!
_when did stating facts become evil_
@@SreenikethanI wow, edgy
Forbidden roast.