Everything Wrong With Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood in Almost 50 Minutes
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.พ. 2025
- 👕 SUPPORT THE CHANNEL BY GETTING SOME MERCH! 👕
crowdmade.com/...
PASTICHE OF CINEMASINS' " #EverythingWrongWith " SERIES.
Under the belt of #BioWare #SonicChronicles follows the adventure of Sonic and his many friends into the world of RPGs. While personally, I think it was a rather poor attempt, I would love to see the Sonic world tackle another RPG, preferably one with better music and combat this time.
🎮 GAME TIME: 17:28:51
⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹
🌙 SLUBSCRIB! ⭐
/ charriii5
☀️ SLUBSCRIB TO Skylar Tourai! ☀️
/ @vaporthefox9
🔴 TWITCH CHANNEL! 🔴
/ charriii5
☄️ FOLLOW ME! ☄️
/ charriii5
🔶 BECOME MY PATRON! 🔶
/ charriii5
🎥 SLUBSRIB TO CINEMASINS! 🎥
www.youtube.com...
🌕 Check out EWW Sonic Battle! 🌕
• Everything Wrong With ...
♬ Endslate Music ♪
Stuck [2A03+VRC6] (MistSomething)
⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹═⊹
STAY AWESOME NYA'LL!
~PATREON~
-Achilles Rhoads
-Aeon3Valefore
-Belsheber Rusape
-Brok Holliday
-Chull33
-Emily Rose
-Harrison Donovan Lichtenberg
-HeetHootSkyat
-HK-47
-Kelia
-Jonathan1482
-Lezz
-LoverofStuff
-MaximumAustin
-Naruto and sasuke vlogs
-Nathaniel Bandy
-Rachel Rafferty
-Seamus Yossarian
~CHANNEL MEMBERS~
-Mimi Peach
-max954
-Achilles Rhoads
-Master Onsagen
-Charles Aran
-Elliott Sanchez
-Timmy Turner
-tom perzelan - เกม
There is an AMAZING group of devoted fans of this game that have been working on a Reimagining of this game and you should totally go follow them. They post frequent updates and it's shaping up to be so much better than the original: twitter.com/SonicChrRI
Wow your female voice is laughable
Metal Sonic being excluded is another sin! (Although, given the use of Gizoids, I understand.)
How was this posted 5h ago
They also have a TH-cam channel
I loved playing through the story of this game, problems aside, it’s the closet the games felt to the comics in tone. I would love this to come back in a better way.
Charriii5: “I doubt that anyone’s FIRST Sonic game was Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood.”
Me: *Awkwardly raises hand*
First Sonic DS game for me.
Same
I apologize that this was your first experience with the Blue Blur
same.
same
Amy:*gets knocked out*
Sonic: *runs over*
Sonic: Are u okay
Amy: *wakes up*
Amy: I hAvE a BoYfRiEnD
Sonic:*knocks her out again*
*Perfect Chaos is destroying Station Square*
*I HAVE A BOYFRIEND!*
@@cliffturbo2146 perfect chaos stops destroying everything just to laugh in her face, calling it now, that's what would happen.
Shadow: I got to go now I got to keep my promise to Maria and You
Amy: I have a boyfriend
Shadow: I said promise not no
You know what never mind
Every high school girl in a nutshell.
She deserves to be knocked out if she's just gonna say 'I hAvE a BoYfRiEnD' when Sonic's trying to look out for her.
Does anyone else appreciate the fact that he draws each thumbnail instead of like just having a generic photo of the content it has? It makes it feel more unique y'know? That alone deserves a like
A reverse sin
I thought someone else drew them, but it's cool knowing what really happened
True but I can’t like every video
I agree
And not only is it more unique than a random picture, thr drawings are really good too
I would like to draw just well, something acceptable. For me, that would be enough (and drawing like grand Luna would be like a Virgin's blessing made reality, but we all know that is not going happen).
I love how in this game, Eggman had to be encouraged to repress his violent urges.
shadow telling sonic "this isn't about you" sounds like an angry ex
Ken Penders ranting that he owns the rights to the Shade character also sounds like an angry ex.
Tsundere?
@@leobardosantano8813god, no
Amy is like that type of girl that would state "i have a BF" even when its not mentioned in school
Btw love the voices for the characters, the female characters made me think of game grumps
What about those people who did the voice over parody of sonic 06 like the “omega smoking weed” one to name a few 😂
@@bi0hazard921 Snapcube?
"Yes, yes sure, but I want you to know that I have a boyfriend."
I kinda thought she already did that.
"Hi, I'm Amy Rose the Hedgehog. That's my FULL name because Sonic is my fiance."
"We're not married, you crazy bi-"
S P R E A D T H I N.
Monika: When that happens, don't forget to save your game!
Tails: Are you challenging me?
Character Tails.exe deleted.
Monika: Better luck next time Fox Boy.
@@runningoncylinders3829 and she the peed on the moon
@@jaxixteen That explains the background in her solo segment of the game.
Best comment
You're too kind. X )
I like how every time a character gets hit, it makes a stock throw up sound used in old Newground animations
I knew I heard that shit from somewhere
That wouldn't be the last time that stock throw up sound would be used in a AAA game; Dead Island used it too.
What doesn’t make sense is how the actual heck Scylla and Charyb, two actual literal ROBOTS, make that noise when hit
We’re al the Gizoids built that way?!
Oh, my Gaia… I knew it was used in this game and in some TerminalMontage videos, but I didn’t know it was a stock sound!
Peak sound design. Surprised it wasn't the horni bonk sound.
Take a shot every time Tails asks you to save the game.
I see you took his advice about the profile pic lol.
@@NarratorSama heck yeah
You did it. You crazy (son of a) bitch, you did it.
It takes one to create an absolute sea of people with that as their picture, honestly applaude you my dude
Knuckles (in the mid-2000s = 2010s, specifically SCTDB): I can totally guarantee that you, Sonic, are not going to save this game because of how jealous you are of Dexter that he can treat her more like a queen than you! :P
Took me a whole minute to realize that there was someone else voicing Shade while I just thought that Charri’s female voice impression was just that damn good
"I doubt anyone's first Sonic game was Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood"
This was my first Sonic game. It was the only Sonic game at the local rental.
I can't believe you guys paid multiple times to play this game.
I'm sorry.
I'm so sorry my dude... hey if it makes you feel better, my first Sonic game was Sonic Lost World and Blast... yeah fuck Sonic Blast.
Same, this video unlocked a really distant memory. I’m not a sonic fan but this made me fan girl lool
My second Sonic game was 06... technically, since I never played any Sonic game, but 06 was the second one I've watched a let's play of. Said let's play was more of a "let's hate" since every episode had a title starting with "I hate".
Oh and the first game was Sonic CD. And the first Sonic piece of media for me was Sonic Underground.
Yeah, it was confusing. _Very_ confusing.
"After this game's ending, the heroes all notice that Eggman is up to no good again, and Sonic agrees to head out by himself and stop him while the others recuperate, thus kicking off the events of Sonic Unleashed."
-- My personal headcanon
That... Would actually be pretty good
But since Ken Penders was a shit dude we can't have that
My headcanon is that this game is set before Sonic Forces and its canon comics, which is why Green Hill Zone is a wreck at the beginning.
@@SuperMase9X noooo way this Is before Forces
Really too much of a Stretch for green hill and no real meaning Silver hasn't helped them here
@@Mepphy99 I mean this game doesn't establish where it takes place in the continuity, so you could just easily say it takes place a good deal of time after Lost World.
The canon comics (namely the ones with Infinite and Team Chaotix, perhaps Knuckles as well) also establishes that the start of Sonic Forces wasn't when Eggman's recent scheme actually began.
@@SuperMase9X ok but the start of this game has Sonic "gone for a long time and Eggmann dead"
Sonic Lost world finale doesn't really gita with that. Unless there Is another Plan they didn't show us, which Is a bit stupid.
And anyway the point Is why Silver didn't appear here to help but in Forces he Is there
Ngl the “favorite color” question always cracks me up
Reminds me of Monty Python The Holy Grail.
@@runningoncylinders3829 I see it.
That does make me wonder though, is there anywhere else in the Sonic canon where Tails' favorite color is mentioned? I'm genuinely curious now . . .
Ok then, what is Your favorite color then makoto?
@@leobardosantano8813 oh ha ha very funny Leobardo (it’s blue)
Tbh you gotta admit the dialogue is one of the high points in this one, this is a game where you can ACTUALLY take Knuckles seriously, something that I missed since the Adventure days.
Or treat anyone whatever you want. Since you choose to interact.
What About Adventure 2?
No
@@Mepphy99 I mean, obviously that too, hence why I said missed.
@@DeltaBlazin Hey Always best to ask
Shade and her clan: *Expands Sonic Adventure lore, tells about the origin of Emerl with potential of Shade to become a decent Shadow-like character in the series
That one Archie ex-writer: "I'm about to end this girl's whole career"
GOD FUCKING DAMMIT PANDERS!!!
Its funny because a day after this video was uploaded, Penders claimed that Shade belongs to him.
But obviously Penders is an idiot.
@@SuperMase9X Penders is STILL like that. I'm surprised he hasn't been hired by nintendo since they ad him have a LOT in common when it comes to their products being mentioned and shown they don't benefit from.
@@thedesensitizedsympathizer5307 Nah, Nintendo's blunders aren't really from malicious intent, just shortsightedness and doing things because they can without thinking about whether or not they should.
@@StarlightMagician True, but I was just making a joke.
Tails: on our team, we avoid violence when we can, eggman
Sonic battle: excuse me?
Punching bag!
Hello cream, I'd like you to meet Emerl, someone as violent and horrific as you.
Literally almost every sonic game ever
Sonic Heroes: I know we have different goals and thus we could just move on, but I think we should fight instead.
@Rodolfo Ramos it's metal overlord if I remember correctly
Juan "Johnny" Ortiz: JESUS THIS MUSIC!
I like Somecallmejohnny
Eyyy a Somecallmejohnny fan.
I don't watch him but I loved his 19-21 years and counting animations
Juan “Johnny” Ortiz: Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood for Nintendo DS is a good game.
@@dr92hmc99X
Juan “Johnny” Ortiz: I can’t believe I said that.
I like how Amy looks like she is either cringing or just very disappointed all the time
45:16
I'm doing my part!
perfection
Perfect SnowEdwin
Thank you for taking my place
@@moofusgoofus np
bro you still didn't change it
I ADORE the attention to detail in how you voice act the characters. In EWW Battle, your Sonic was based on Drummond, in here and EWW Rivals, it's based on Griffin, and in EWW Colors DS, it's based on Smith. GENIUS!!!
EWW, a bug!
@@xyrongonzalez3833 Everything Wrong With a Bug? What the little poor fella did to end here?
And Tails still sounds like if a man tried voicing Queen but gave up halfway through.
@@psychie8625 Oh so that's what felt weird to me; his Sonic impression always change to a different VA that corresponds to the game, but his Tails impression is always Adventure era Tails.
Which, yea, makes sense, it's the only times he was voiced by boys, so it's easier to do an impression of that than to mimic either of Tails' "modern" VAs (who are both women; although I am personally a fan of both of their work there).
@@Hugo-yz1vb Too many eyes.
*Ding!*
How come some bugs don't really have blood?
*Ding!*
Cant believe no mention of hhow busted Cream the Rabbit is. Cream is an optional character, but is soooooo worth it. One of her abilities restores PP to the entire party, *including cream.* If you upgrade that ability enough, she gets more PP than she uses, so the 8PP cost isnt too bad.
Also, one of the chaos you can randomly get is almost as overpowered as Cream. Ferox removes the touch screen prompts for POW moves, so you cant mess them up. Literally every character benefits from this, but Cream is the best choice, due to the above ability.
That’s my favorite character for ya
Why is cream so good in most of the game she appears?there is also sonic battle
That's why I put Ferox specifically on her, currently playing Chronicles, can you get more than one Ferox in the game?
@@sens1395And Sonic Advance 2 and 3.
Oh man, I remember eagerly awaiting the sequel to this game.
It- It could... still happen... right?
Unless Penders kicks the bucket or puts his ego aside, we could be waiting a loooooooong time. 😭
@@izzy1356
Aww, Penders' involved? Shit.
@@Meteorite_Shower lol check his Twitter. Literally hours after this video came out he starts ranting saying that he "owns" Shade.
@@SuperMase9X Penders is like an ex-boyfriend that reacts violently when someone tries to date the girlfriend he no longer goes out with.
Well yeah maybe not one by bioware but maybe SEGA or sonic team
This is the game that made Ken Penders go all insane
And he flipped his shit over shade
And now Shade will never come back.
@@SpeedDemonPowerage98 it's a shame that when he won the lawsuit, he took Shade with him. I didn't think that he made shade. I just thought that he took all characters HE made. I would love to see Shade return like Silver did. Both characters are great characters from bad noncanon games. Yet silver gets to come back but not Shade? Nothing against Silver. I like him but it would be cool if Shade returned in a future game.
@@beatziegraham6928 I agree cuz Shade would be a major part of Knuckles’s stories. Plus Shade was the only good thing to come from chronicles and that’s undeniable personallly despite how bad chronicles was Shade kinda saved it for me plus her boss fight against her in blue ridge zone was kinda difficult cuz she had an absurd Evade rate like some very specific Nocturnus enemies and Echidna Rush Knuckles & Shade’s duo move deals absurd amounts of damage if you equip Shade with the Nocturnus Blade you can get from a shop in the Chron colony in the twilight cage. And I was guilty of assuming Perci in Boom was Shade. When she was first shown with Sticks I believe.
@@SpeedDemonPowerage98 Yea
"You decided to go away for a while. Not me"
I never realized it but that might be a reference to Wild Canyon's lyrics.
"This is Knuckles, and I'm back. I've been away for a while"
“That was the final boss? That’s the most pathetic thing I’ve ever seen!”
Dark Nebula: Allow me to introduce myself.
Kirby and sonic fan. A rare breed no doubt.
Please. At least Dark Nebula was at least a fight. Not two series of QTEs. XD
@@leobardosantano8813you have yet to meet me who is a Kirby,mario,sonic,Pokemon,digimon,subnautica, and Zelda fan
Fanbase: We want a Sonic RPG.
SEGA: We have a Sonic RPG at home.
Sonic RPG at home:
The game is so bad, not even drastic emu can handle it
Fans:we want an rpg.
Ken penders:lol lawsuit time.
Well I don’t want one. I don’t like RPGs so I’m biased.
@@Phoenix_Blader_93 DeSmuME can. Heck, it even handles it better than my R4, who always gets stuck after saving, forcing me to do a hard reset (at least, it keeps the game save). If I want to complete the game, I have to transfer my safe file to the computer and complete it there.
@Violets Are Blue Like which ones? I want to try some.
The strangest thing about this game is that they put an ‘s’ at the end of ‘chronicles’ like this game was going to be so great that it would start a new series.
Clearly that went well.
Well, it could have, if Ken Penders didn't prevent a sequel from happening.
I think the fact that this game even had a subtitle already indicated it was meant to have sequels.
well there is Puyo Puyo ChroniCLE, so...
and some people even call it “Puyo Puyo Chronicles” (the dark brotherhood)
Sad thing is, I personally would've loved for a sequel. Well, a sequel that fixes all the issues I had with this game. Sonic really could've had his own RPG spin off series like Mario with the Mario & Luigi games or even Paper Mario. What a waste...
23:30 Probably Tikal. She has the ability to show people her memories/teleport people to the past so it wouldn't be too out of the question for Tikal to teach him about their history.
I'll never get tired of hearing Charriii's Eggman impression.
42:38 easily one of my all time favorite lines from Charriii. The delivery is so fucking good.
5 sins in 30 seconds, this is gonna be fantastic
It should of started with 10 sins before the first second.
@@ligtningdog6399 You aren’t wrong
42:38 don’t mind me
@@prorocco6449 I don’t mind.
LOL
"Scnorft" Best freaking spelling of that sound ever.
You have 69 likes so I can't give you another one
@@styler8940 Hehe, funny number.
I gotta admit, though, having the characters themselves saying the credits of the game is really endearing to me. Can't say I've seen a game do that before.
Sometimes I honestly forget Charriii is doing almost ALL of these voices. His acting is that good.
Missing sin: Salesman named Sal.
At least it is not called Wes.
@@danielaguilarrodriguez1091 true
Because he's a Salaryman?
My ultimate guilty pleasure game. I fucking love this game.
Flux Goodra I love watching it but I’d probably hate playing it
Same, I know the bad sides of things but still liked it, remember playing and replaying so many times as a kid
Overall, it's a pretty cool story that could've set the tone and mythology many Sonic fans needed. The only thing that ruined it at this point was the gameplay, the musics and He-who-shall-not-be-named
Honestly same, i genuinely loved this game and still do, only thing we can all mutually agree sucks is the music though
@@taurock9689 definitely ganna have to disagree with you there the story is as basic and as you can get from RPG game.
19:28 Fun Fact: my first Sonic game was "Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood", followed by "Sonic Rush"
Rush was awesome
Sonic Rush was my very first Sonic game.
Sonic Rush wasn't my first game, Sonic Rush *Adventure* was (which I never beat).
1:27 Tails: "A group of criminals called The Marauders took him."
Me: "James, Sirius, Remus, and Peter??"
Is this from Worms Forts?
@@danielaguilarrodriguez1091 Harry Potter
That's what I thought too!
Sirius you little-
@@danielaguilarrodriguez1091holy shit even *I* don't remember stuff like this and I've played Worms Forts as a kid ._.
33:21
You're really not going to sin this?
"We don't fear the Zoah and their energy weapons."
"We do fear the Zoah's secret energy weapon."
This game's biggest sin was starting the Ken Penders shitshow that cancelled the Archie comics.
Honestly, I don’t think anyone expected someone to do something so stupid as to sue a company for playing homage to their storyline.
Guy is petty as sin.
@@viruschris3160 Don't forget ugly as sin.
Oh yeah THAT was certainly something that happened *Cough*
It didn't just fuck over the comics. Sonic's story as a whole got fucked over by that lawsuit. It's the reason all of the sonic characters lost their personalities from this point on and became something like teen titans go.
@@NarratorSama Wasn't it more like in terms of personality having to "alter" what was establish to align more with the game versions' personalities?
Sadly, SEGA/Sonic Team mandates what goes into the comics now which is why characters like Shadow are stuck in this "weird" place even when the writers want to develop them further.
So yeah, screw Penders. Sure, we got an amazing IDW series out of it and I love new characters like Tangle and Whisper, and the new villains Dr. Starline and Mimic.
Sonic's story and lore is such a mess.
this games amy in a nutshell:dont talk to me dont even think about talking to me dont even think about doing anything to me i have a boyfriend if you ask me a question i will mention my boyfriend at least once dont flirt with sonic and ask why if i have a boyfriend because i will make a obvious lie on why you shouldnt flirt with sonic
Amy :BoYfRiEnD
Everyone else in the game: o k e y
It's soundtrack comes to mind first for me even though I don't mind it
The soundtrack is fine (I also like the comic book aesthetic to the cutscenes), the sound design however... yikes!
@@lynxfresh5214 I don't mind the soundtrack but it just sounds like they made a bad midi in a couple of minutes. It sounds like a placeholder lol
Meh... I see how a reinstrumentation would make the soundtrack bearable if not decent, but in its current state it's mediocre.
The title screen músic...
Ewww...
GrounderSez
Apparently Bioware lost the files for the original soundtrack, so we got these midis as a replacement.
Would explain why the opening, final boss, and boss themes sound cleaner than everything else.
18:34 You know what makes this even worse? Blue Ridge Zone is Bridge Zone, which means Sonic's been there. Also Bridge Zone is connected to Green Hill and Tails remembers Green Hill in this game.
Whoa, whoa, whoa, Bridge Zone? Like from Sonic 1 on the Game Gear?
Some days I wonder: is this game even real? It feels like a fever dream. It's like a bizarre flash game where they aged up the characters and made them use dark humor and innuendos.
And then I check to see that yes, it was real.
And then I cry.
If charriii is doing tails, and tails sounds like Miss Piggy, *HE MUST BE MISS PIGGY IN DISGUISE*
Poor Shade she will (likely) never appear in another game or any form of Sonic media thanks to Ken throwing a hissy fit and Sega's mandates.
Yet another character that just got thrown away while most of the remaining cast are either cheerleaders, one-dimensional and/or flanderized.
Especially considering that all things considered she doesn't seem half bad as a character.
At least we won't have to see Shade become flanderized.
@@EdnaKonrad4MVS *Are you sure?*
Hot take: I actually like this game. Finished it, like, 3 or 4 times back in the day.
Same I literally bought a ds lite to play this and a few other games... but you gotta admit, first playthrough kinda sucks considering how few rings you get.
I did like it but didn't like the cliffhanger
Exactly that. This game was my first Sonic and RPG game I played and I absolutely love it. Back in the day I didn't know English so I skipped most of the dialogues and instead imagined what they would say.
Edit: I was very disappointed when I found out later that it didn't get a sequel. Maybe the game is bad for the most people, but they still should have ended the series.
THIS OPINION IS NOW FACT TO ME.
Same. I wished they ended the story properly, I liked Shade as a character and I wanted to know more about her people's backstory, but eh...
"That's awfully convenient" capitalized by the picture related to the comment being Sonic winking at the player. Bravo, Bioware.
I'm sure there's a technical/logistical reason why they didn't, but it'd be cute if Tails kept his own "saves" and instead of telling the player to save, he was mentioning that he was making his own save. And then "Tail's Save" could just be a cute way of recontextualizing auto-save backups.
I think everyone didn’t ask u to do this , yet u did. Mad respect
Somewhere in the world, Ken Penders is fuming.
Ken penders suffering brings me joy.
@unspeakable Flame 2 Thanks to him a lot of characters like Scourge aren't coming back.
He actually made a tweet *hours* after this video came out ranting about how he "owns" Shade.
@@SuperMase9X he's insane.
@@shadowthedestroyer2241 He's basically a real-life Eggman when it comes to the Sonic franchise at this point, albeit without the likeable traits.
"I doubt anyone's FIRST sonic game was Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood"
hahaha, yeah, definitely not my first sonic game
Boi what a bad way to get into the series lol.
@@midamida887 funnily enough, I was disappointed at the other sonic stories after playing this one
(it wasn't my first, but my third, having played the 2 rush before this)
Mine was Heroes. They had the game in McDonalds and on Mario Kart: DD's bonus disc.
It was some darn good marketing thinking about that.
I still adore Heroes.
It was a bit difficult for me to be the first game when I am the same age as Charriii (born in 1996) and I started playing Sonic in 2005.
@Generic Username Mine was Sonic X at 360p on TV around 2004-2005.
40:33 No I'm pretty sure that's Bug Arm, in fact later it is Big Arm, still they did still massacred our boy.
"PIck up all the rings you missed again." What a great motivator to replay the game again.
Knuckles sounds like Jesse Mccree xD
Eyyyyy Tails, how you doing buddy?
Ya a bit.
You wacth charii5 🤯
Oh, I didn't know you watched this ;-;
Also, what do you think of Chariiis voice acting for you? :>
Will we ever get a southern Spanish Knuckles (speaking a bit like a gypsy), like the one SonicBlueKnight used to do?
been waiting a while for this one, thanks Charrii. Also it's Big Arm not Doomsday Zone.
Hearing it just now, and yeah, that's totally Big Arm. The music is a bit distorted so I wasn't sure if I just wasn't hearing it right.
Technically, it is Final Boss, from Sonic the Hedgehog 3.
@@danielaguilarrodriguez1091 True
“Finally a worthy opponent” *is literally killed in one round of combat*
45:16
Ok, I got ya.
Brother! (or sister)
46:59
You can *hear* the big ol' smile on charrii's face here i love it- its fucking adorable
“Marauders” is actually the nickname that Tails and the others gave the Nocturnus Clan, because...well...I guess they just didn’t know what else to call them at the time. In their minds, it’s probably just a temporary nickname until they find out what they’re actually called.
Edit: Also, since Tikal basically lives in the Master Emerald, it’s entirely possible that she’s the one who told Knuckles about the story of his ancestors’s war with the Nocturnus Clan, but I admit, this is just me speculating. I mean, she was around back then when it all happened, so she would definitely know how it all played out.
I mean, let’s face it: Knuckles’s family is gone and the only ones who were around back then during the war are Emerl, Chaos and Tikal herself. Emerl fought in the war, but he lost his memory several times over and he’s been destroyed and rebuilt as Gemerl, so he definitely doesn’t remember anything about back then, so, he wouldn’t be able to tell Knuckles anything. Chaos, on the other hand, does remember the war, but he’s antisocial and mute, not to mention that he probably dislikes Echidnas (except for Tikal, obviously), so he probably wouldn’t care enough to tell Knuckles about it. Tikal, however, not only remembers the war, but she actually trusts Knuckles and his friends, so she’s the only one who would actually want to tell Knuckles about the past and whatnot. So, yeah, it had to have been Tikal who told Knuckles about the Nocturnus Clan, because there’s nobody else who could’ve done so or even wanted to do so.
The nocturnas clan is a retcon they weren't mentioned in SA1
@@newdawnhorizon9879
Well, no, it’s not really a retcon, because there’s nothing in SA1 that could directly contradict what we see in this game and vice-versa. If anything, it’s more about filling in some story blanks, because even back in SA1, the great war between the Echidna tribes was still mentionned even back then.
@@eon1014 I still consider it a retcon
@@newdawnhorizon9879
No, no, no, you don’t get it. By definition, a retcon is a later modification that is brought to a story that directly changes and contradicts previously established material to modify the story. Sonic Chronicles is NOT a retcon, because it doesn’t directly change anything about the story of SA1. If anything, it adds more stuff to the already established story without changing how it originally was. Sure, the Nocturnus weren’t directly mentionned by name back then, but it WAS mentioned that the Knuckles clan went to war with another, unnamed enemy tribe, which drove them to desperation by seeking the power of the emeralds, which then ended with them getting wiped out by Perfect Chaos. The events of SA1 haven’t been changed or altered. The only difference now is that the enemy tribe, instead of being nameless, now has a name and a story of it’s own. And again, none of it contradicts what has already been established. It just adds more stuff to it, without changing it. Like I said, filling the blanks.
Think of it like this: If SA1 is the story of Knuckles’s tribe, then Sonic Chronicles is the story of the other tribe that was unnamed and unknown until now.
@@eon1014 Ergo its a retcon
I'm surprised he went threw this without talking about the ken penders law suit that littering lead to the Archie sonic comic having a continuity Purge before They were ended and then IDW picked it up for a reboot I'm not kidding
The Archie Comics ending was actually due to Archie having licensing issues with the Worlds Unite crossover.
Actually I was only talking about the lawsuit and the impact it had on the Archie comic story and characters I dint say anything about it being responsible for it ending the comic before IDW took over I didn't tell you this way back because I kept forgetting
At least IDW is pretty good.
Well, he can't really sin this game for the stuff that happened after this game came out since it's not necessarily relevant to here.
Why would he bring up something that happened AFTER the entirety of this game's lifecycle?
This felt like the closest we've ever gotten to a game with an archie storyline, I honestly enjoyed it. Too bad we'll never see a sequel. If it's one thing I feel that this game got right, it was the dialogue. It was just very interesting seeing all of the different dialogue options with the other characters, would have been cool to see it voiced. I'd love to see something similar some day.
I think in the Voxai Colony puzzle you have to hit the switches when the floor flashes once, and do nothing if it flashes twice. That sounds incredibly obvious on paper, but in practice it's confusing.
On a side note, I had no idea Tails had that many save reminders. It seems most of them are programmed to not appear if you have saved recently. He's obsessed.
I'll say this about this (abysmal) game; the characterization of the respective characters was pretty good compared to the usual.
Well, remember, this game was released in September of 2008, just two months before Sonic Unleashed. That game has what I consider the best characterization of Sonic, tied with Black Knight and Frontiers. So the “usual” at the time was actually pretty good. Then two years later, the usual went to hell in a hand basket.
The biggest sin of this game is that Shade never appeared ever again any other games after this.
Blame Ken Penders for that.
Exactly I miss Shade that is all.
Well this game is supposed to be in the end of sonic timeline
that is a "shadme"
@@carbonneau5630 wait for real?
I feel no shame for enjoying this game
Me too. Probably past experience, but I still enjoy for what it delivers.
Your comment has the honor of being professionally agreed with
Tf
Amen to that, I still enjoy playing it from time to time
It is a good game. Fuck this neckbeard and his fans who parrot while probably not even having played it
Fun fact: in the spanish translation, the snarky response in the tutorial is Sonic yelling that he doesn't want Amy to feel better.
Shade is the girl who's actually a 4000 year-old demon lord from an alternative dimension in this anime.
Maybe time is different in the twilight cage?
I like the Southern accent you used for Knuckles! Makes his cowboy hat make more sense
Ah yes, the return of "Eggmans Robots"
Honestly I liked this game, what I didn’t like was the complete disregard of an actual ending and openly letting nothing come of it
Well I think the game was going to get a sequel but copyright garbage stopped it
I mean, Ken originally sued Sega because the writer of this game basically wrote the same story he did. Couple that with the poor reception and it is pretty clear why they never let the devteam make a sequel.
Don't you hate when something ends on a cliffhanger
@@mariajimenafigueroa233 Yes, heck Boom Knuckles hates it
"Please my furry friends. After You! Ha ha ha ha!!!" That line made me laugh more then it should of. 😂👍
"Stop reminding me, I'll save when I'm ready."
20:51 "We try to avoid violence when we can Eggman" left me wheezing 🤣
i really like how in recent Everything Wrong With videos, you’ve been acting out the lines, it’s really funny and also reminds me of the videos you made of you dubbing SA and SA2!
Knuckles: My mind is strong. I'm not worried.
Chariii5: *heavy scnorft*
Also Knuckles: Gets mind-controlled anyway
Tbh, this game needs a sequel. I simply don't like that they left on a cliffhanger like that...
DOUBT IT! Because A.) KEN PENDERS, B.)Bioware is bought out by EA, and C.) This game didn't sell well enough to warrent a sequel.
@@TheArceusftw No need to be rude about it. I just want the story to continue, even it's in Traditional Sonic game fashion.
@@waynemidnight7454 Dude, I wasn't being rude.
TheArceusftw Well tbf you said "doubt it" in all caps, they could have taken that as being a rude tone if that wasn't your intention.
12:39 That is the most "Hello Kitty Girl" response I have ever heard in a videogame
8:16 is literally the only part I can't stop laughing about
He's vibin' like a motherfucker 😂
Part of me really wamt them try making an rpg again. However considering Sega seems to be struggling just to make a sonic game that performs well, i wont hold my breath.
Agreed, tbh making a Sonic RPG should be a non-issue thanks to Sega's own experiences (the Phantasy Star franchise) and owning Altus (the JRPG kings behind the Persona franchise).
Too bad Sega is one of the most mismanaged gaming companies out there with it's flagship IP (thanks to a floating island full of issues, that have already been covered in numerous vids across YT).
Tl;dr: Sega US and Sega JP haven't "gotten along" in years.
Funfact : when i got the mission for bringing back the boy to his family , i didn't bring him back and i was with him in space
Charii: "I doubt anyone's first sonic game was sonic chronicles"
Me whos first sonic game was sonic chronicles: 👁👄👁
👁👄👁
Mine: Sonic Colors 😎
Mine was unleashed
Mine were Sonic Advance 2 and Sonic CD.
You poor soul
I hope that the group doing a reimagining don't have any issues with legal stuff, especially since Shade got axed due to a certain high horsed "artist"-
What happened?
@@frostbite_1244 It's generally a long story, but a former Archie Sonic writer by the name of Ken Penders made a copywrite claim against this game for copying content he made for the Archie Comics.
This eventually led to Sega changing up their entire story-telling approach, which has led to the Archie Comics getting a continuity reboot (the comics got cancelled altogether later on because of licensing fees for a big crossover). Because this game was heavily involved, Shade and Imperator Ix were essentially put on a bus.
Penders continues to brag about how he's affected the franchise on his Twitter page, including a recent post saying that he "owns" Shade because of a vague likeness she bares to one of his characters.
The kicker is that this guy is also making his own comic called "The Lara-Su Chronicles", which is essentially a comic featuring Echidnas except their species names have been changed. It even features a Knuckles knock-off called "K'nox". So essentially, he's a bigot and a hypocrite.
The Sonic community has a shared hatred for this man.
@@SuperMase9X well that sucks...
@@SuperMase9X what a jerk
Yeah, Penders is a complete twat.
You know this is gonna be good when there's already 9 sins before we get to Charriii's voice acting
The idea of having the characters praising the people that made the game started off cute and charming at first, but went on for so long that it turned into an annoying circlejerk.
Should’ve just done regular credits instead
If only we had a sonic rpg that played like the Mario and Luigi rpg’s
It's clear Sega doesn't know how to handle turn-based RPGs. Except for Shining Force, but that was a bit of a more tactical RPG.
@@Loner098 Bioware made this game. It's literally mentioned several times in the video.
@@sauvagess Well then I guess Sega must *love* rushing the Bioware developers to make an awful game like this one; just like Nintendo. But of course, this could just be a theory.
@@Loner098 this wasn't rush, it was incompetency.
@@sauvagess Sega *is* kinda like EA though by picking quantity over quality with their games, so it would make sense. But if it really was incompetency, then why does Nintendo like to butcher some of their video game series?
40:36 "listen to how you've massacred my boy" describes...most of the music in this game. The one I found most annoying was the massacre of Genesis Diamond Dust for the city
And that's not even Doomsday Zone in the first place. That is the non-100% Final boss theme
48:33 chariii5 said Thomas and friends my life is complete
I love how Charriii5 used a Brooklyn accent for the construction workers
Or a british sounding accent for the Overmind aliens..
10:16 Wait I do have a question since he mentioned that there wasn’t voice acting, is he doing the VA himself (with others for different characters ofc) because if so he should have added vocals for sarcasm
Let it go, let it go, let it go
Nope can’t let it go, DING
I think this game needs a sequel, or at least another proper Sonic RPG.
Two RPGs are not enough (yes, I am counting Battle as an RPG)! And please, Sega, make it available for DS too!
It did but cancelled because EA bought BioWare.
True, but Ken Penders' rektquit and lawsuits as well as BioWare being purchased were the reasons this game never get its sequel... officially.
We can create our own sequel game anyways.
Me sees the title:
Also me: Ah shit here we go again
Ill have 2 Number 9
Number 9 large
Number 6 with extra dip
Number 7
2 Number 45s
One with extra cheese
And a large soda
@@pixeluka5809 oh get some fried potatoes for me
10:24 Since you forgot….
BIIIIIG THEEEEE CAAAAT!!
The Sonic impression is so good
I assume you did the voice overs for most of the characters. They were pretty good, i think Sonic, Robotnik and Knuckles sounded pretty close to how they do in the games the most. You do a pretty good Dr Robotnik. Is it just me that gets annoyed when they refer to super sonic as a separate person. It probably is.
This game is one of my guilty pleasure, and favorite games on the Nintendo DS. I'll always remember finding Shadow's theme an absolute banger and not minding the horrible music being played during battle.
I love the horrible music
I don't mind the music. I like how op cream is in this game. She's the perfect healing character.
"What's your favorite color? Don't walk away from me, Tails! We NEED this lore!"
Maybe, the same color as his fur...?
Okay I know this comment is two years old but the wiki says that tails’s favorite color is orange. So you’re probably right.
Amy did the whole "I have a boyfriend" thing before it was a meme
“It’s Doomsday Zone from Sonic 3!”
(Inhale)
IT’S
CALLED
BIG ARMS!!!!!
But seriously, awesome video! Just that little nitpick! 😉