Why can't Singapore make it to the World Cup? | MS Explains
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 มิ.ย. 2024
- A famous footballer once said that even if Lionel Messi played in Singapore, he would not have changed the Singapore Premier League. But what exactly is wrong with Singapore football?
Have an interesting video idea? Send us an email at video@mothership.sg
LET'S CONNECT!
-- Facebook: / mothershipsg
-- Twitter: / mothershipsg
-- Instagram: / mothershipsg
-- Tiktok: / mothershipsg
-- Telegram: t.me/mothershipsg
🔔 Click on the bell icon to be the first to watch our videos! 🔔
![[MPD직캠] 베이비몬스터 치키타 직캠 4K 'LIKE THAT' (BABYMONSTER CHIQUITA FanCam) | @MCOUNTDOWN_2024.6.13](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/h99J4vWm7Ew/mqdefault.jpg)
I was a Thai ex-pat that had worked in Singapore for 10 years. I follow local football regularly and went to watch SPL and SG's NT matches from time to time. The first time I arrived in Singapore 10 years ago, I was dumbfounded that none of the clubs and even the league were privatized. It makes no sense as a Thai since we believe SG is more business mind than us. We privatized the league and all the clubs in 2009 and look what the Thai League has become. Thai League is now in the top 4 of East Asia according to the latest ranking from the AFC. Meanwhile, SPL (former S League) who was the number one league in SEA is ranked lower than Myanmar. And to this day, only LCS is a private club in the league. What an irony.
When no one owns the league or club, no one cares about their performance. The clubs will participate in the tournament just for the sake of participation. They don't care where they rank because that won't affect them in any way. The same goes for the league. Why bother making the league more profitable when it won't affect their KPI? That is how the Thai League managed to cull away amateur clubs. If Singapore wants to improve, just needs to start by privatizing the league and I guarantee you will see a huge difference.
I agree, if someone like a Sky bought the league it would be much more exciting and aspirational for people within the country. The first person/business to buy a SPL club will dominate for a long time.
The Singapore players are given 8 month contracts!.
and now LCS is going through budget cuts because its parent company is Shoppee lol
FIFA gives its affiliates millions of dollars if they have an organised football league.Quality does not matter ..
@@andii256 i didn't even know they were owned by Shoppee lol
even if you are a talented singaporean junior footballer overseas, and playing at the barcelona academy, debuting at the age of 16 in the camp nou stadium, your career will still be wrecked because of 2 years national service. The best Singapore can do is hand out passports to 25 Brasilians who never played for their national team and hope to qualify for world cup.
Not to mention the ten years of reservist after that LOL
Yes that's very true. Can forget about football if govt doesn't prioritise it.
@@deedee-bh2lb the goals being set are just flowery talk, deep down they themselves also know it won't happen, it is just to show the public that they are doing something when they really aren't
@Andy Ng yes. Sad but true. Its something to keep the folks in FAS busy with 🤣
@@deedee-bh2lb bunch of old folks who reminiscence about their kampung football days to decide the future of Singapore football. Money plays a huge role...see Fifa and arabs money.
Rooting for Jurong FC, Sembawang Rangers, Woodlands Wellington, SAFFC that include Yishun Sentek Mariners and Keppel Monaco to make a comeback to the league in the future..which also include promotion and relegation system that can make the SPL more competitive rather than today which is more likely 'Syiok Sendiri'....
After seeing how Morocco got a national holiday for beating portugal, i'm convinced that FAS is doing everything it can to prevent Singapore from going to the world cup so that the govt doesn't have to give a whole month off when they finally do qualify.
Even Schooling won gold medal in 2016 Olympics there wasnt even a day off for everyone, talk about a month off😂
I agree with the point about footballing culture, many people have their careers hindered by academic results and NS. I've had classmates who were barred from playing in competitions due to poor grades even if they are the teams star player, the priority on grades instead of development in football is also a result of the aforementioned lack of job security.
I feel that NS is also a major factor, the age we go into NS is prime development years for a football player, look at how many players in Europe's top leagues made their debuts in their late teens, or in their early 20s, CR7, Messi, Mbappe, Rashford, Becks, Lampard and many others. Look at Ben Davies, who got signed by Fullham, who jumped ship to Thailand because of NS.
Lies again? Marine Soldier Lazy Students
When you have to work full time to compete instead of training full time, you get lousy players. Also importing a few pin pong player to play and win medals is easier.
Look at South Korea. There's tons of SK players in Europe. Quite a few of them already did their military service and went to Europe in their mid 20s. Going to military service did not hinder their progress one bit. Even Son Heung Min did his for three weeks despite having an exemption because he won a gold medal for South Korea.
I'm still unable to understand why Sg can't be more flexible when it comes to NS for these players. Just let them serve at a later age like Kr. I don't even mind if they serve after they retire from football in their early/mid 30s. I believe a mid 30s professional player will still be fitter than your average teenage recruit.
It's a mindset that we in Singapore that we have is academic excellence and not sports excellence especially in team sports. All we want is individual sports excellence , that's why team sports are so neglected
that is one of the reason, but the main reason is players have to work and train and not train full time, while imported players from china get to train and paid lots of money.
Good point
Useless sinkapour, "academic excelelnce" still can produced so many disgusting atittude Gen Z and strawberry generation
If academic CMI, just focussed on the ineterest for sports lah. Just like the smart alecs of Singapore too high IQ to go to school already so got homeschooled and go to university at young age
I think Singapore doesn't take advantage of the European clubs coming to play in your stadium during their Asian tours. Japan and UAE hosted so many Club World Cup events and they saw advantage in it, that's why they're consistent at least in Asian stage. Singapore must do what those countries do to promote football and hopefully can talk much in Asian stage.
Cb lah World Cup, SEA games cannot get gold...Build national stadium so big...International games play at Jalan Besar...Talented players development screwed up by NS...Let them defer la like Song Heung Min...Then the best is....Japan spend BILLIONS to get to their status now...Singapore spend ikan bilis how to qualify?
cause unproven that spending money on local will get quick result, that why they import ready made china players for ping pong. They rather spend millions on foreign talent than support locals if they can. If top tiers player from europe willing to come SG they sure spend the billions on them.
Singapore also does not have the population. You want to develop talent, but where you want to find the humans for that lol. Need to ask singaporean amoi to make more babies la. That's why nowadays you see Spore athletes with mainland China name at the olympics.
@@zhen86 Then what is the point,if we are just going to get all foreign talent to play for us,develop our players as much as we can instead,as long as one of us can make it to top teams, we are more than happy
Has the FAS explained what led to the failure of Goal 2010, the subsequent Roadmap, the national ambition to win the SEA Games gold in 2015 in Singapore and its current state of performance malaise?”
On top of that, Mr Raymond also raised questions in terms of government investment in the sport, asking “Is football worthy of the taxpayers’ contributions?”
He called on the government to reveal how much the GOAL 2034 project would cost taxpayers and also investing more in and developing other sports that Singapore might excel in instead of football.
Football is the most watched sport in the world. If you wanna put Singapore on the map in terms of sporting achievements, there is no doubt that this is the sport to invest in. The question is how serious the government is (this time round) to push for WC qualification? Past failures has shown that Singapore's attitude towards any sports is one where they try to invest as little resources as possible and hope to achieve the maximum outcome. To put it in other words its to "hope for the best".
The argument that Singapore should consider "developing other sports that Singapore might excel in..." is flawed imo. How would we predict which sport we would excel in? Based on past results? Or targeting sports with a large pool of foreign talents readily available to be naturalised again? If we are talking about priviledged; individualistic sports such as archery, bowling, golf etc, then i would argue that in order for one to be able to partake in these sports, one would already have adequate financial resources. Futhermore, the pool of talents in these areas to choose from would be small, since the barrier to entry for these sports is high.
I feel we should focus on a sport which Singaporeans has the most interest in. (Do a census or something.) This way we would have a greater pool of talents to choose from, and its also easier to rope in people who actually like the sport, but are sitting on the fence due to the lack of current career prospect.
FIFA just announced the WC in 2026 will consist of 48 teams from 32 teams, to increase their income. Maybe in 25 years when greedy FIFA increases to 120 teams, Singapore will have a chance to qualify.
Then get whacked hard 20-0 by other big teams🤣
120 team also no chance. Singapore ranked 160.
@@TommashelbyeeeRight now 160, when lower ranked teams get to travel and play against, we will rightfully fall down to the 200s
@@Tony.L9793ow 20-0 can drop a nuke in codm already
in your dreams my guy, singapore will never ever go to world cup
Easy, because Singaporean Chinese feels too “good” to play football. If more Chinese have interest to play football, maybe our selection pool would be bigger.
Last time we had Thai national players (Kiatisuk, surachai etc) and Iranian (Hamid Reza, Kharpour) World cup players playing in the SLeague, now, we have to go Thailand for example, to play in League 2. We are lacking behind eversince.
When selection is based on merits, only then can we make talk about making it to the World Cup. Now, you need an uncle or a famous father to get into the team.
I grew up with even more idiotic selection processes. For school selection, the coach (fucking ironic was the uncle of one of the playere) set a selection process by physical fitness. Which doesnt sound bad, but, the fitness he looked at, was pull ups. The guys who do the most pull ups, start first, the rest on the bench. There was more stupid thing involved but im not surprised the country hasnt gone far in football
Yeah, basically lack of professionalism and corruption that is prevalent in singapore football.
The biggest problem is that there is no joined up thinking or coordination between the school system, the clubs FAS, and Min Defence.
1.There are lots of good fields in the schools but they are locked up every weekend and not available for kids to have a kickabout.
2. FAS is totally powerless to do anything and have not contributed anything positive to Singapore football for many years. They are a bunch of amateurs.
3. Once a decent player makes it through the club academy there is no coordinated strategy of how to assist them thru their National Service commitments. So they miss 4-6month navigating BMT and then arranging any release from their unit to get permission to play football. Then they might have full duties and miss training and matches.
No-one is looking at the big picture and thinking of solutions.
A- open some school fields in each neighbourhood to use FOC for local kids to play.
B- arrange any national sportsmen (whatever sport) to have, say, light duties 9am-3pm so they have some time in the day to dedicate to their sport.
C- hold FAS accountable- what is their 5 year plan with yearly and quarterly milestones?. Most office holders are just talking cock and shaking leg... not producing any results.
D- age group coaches at U14 to U18 to watch more schools matches and scout for new players. Some boys at the Sports School get too complacent. We need more competition for places. Install a national scouting database like they have in other countries like Holland and USA to track all players progress.
Mr Raymond goes on to ask about the state of local football in Singapore, including hard data on how many people follow the sport. He noted that Sports Singapore data shows that running, swimming, and cycling all rank higher on the Sports Participating Index as compared to football.
Smau sports yg u mentioned smau adalah berunsur individualistic based sports.hmmm
Really don't see our SG football developing any further even our FAS president Bernard Tan not even in the football industry or field before he joined the FAS ( the FAS literally just hired some paper CEO to just come and manage and talk some nonsense about achieving this and that with no ideal and efficient goal, fyi if they really do care about SG football should have already started the Unleash the Roar project decades ago lol )
2:04 was a really good point. No other person has made this point before apart from Soh Rui Yong. Good job Mothership!
The biggest hinderance is NS. We gotta to revamp how national athletes serve. They are already serving the nation by representing it. We should look at how South Korea does it. Son Hueng Min went for basic military for a few months.
1:09 this was not too much of a problem compared to when LionsXII was still alive. Its the fact that we’re playing against the big teams in Malaysia while only having a full Sgrean squad that made me feel like I had a belonging both in Football and the country. Its the fact that there is a friendly but historic rivalry with our Causeway country that made me love football here but it’s all gone now.
Lan Jiao lah
@@Scambuster491 bruh
@@Scambuster491 DIAM LHHH CINA KOMUNIS OIIII
One only needs to look at Joseph Schooling to understand why. Only a titan achievement of his allowed the deferment, and short it was. To qualify for the world cup, you need at least 11 Fandis to be born in the same era, pray to heavens their parents all send them elsewhere for training like Europe, pray all of them don't give up citizenship, and pray and hope all of them miraculously win some competition in ASIA. Then the ball can roll, and the whole team will have hope to defer and hopefully train and be better. Any misstep is back to army and poof goes world cup dreams. Size is an excuse, see Slovenia. NS see South Korea and their deferment age till 30. Reality is, I have more hopes of striking Toto than Singapore even qualifying for world cup. When we can even beat Vietnam and Thailand clean and fair and consistent in SEA games then let us talk. When our priority is clearing land for more housing for more humans for more GDP growth at all cost, I think team sports like soccer will never be a priority.
yes and its only a deferment, not even a exemption, maybe not a total exemption but a shortened version like South korea eg. Son
That's too much praying.
J League had a lot of support and most importantly, tons of FAN SUPPORT. You'll also need a lot of money, i.e. sponsorships; Japan has lots of the conglomerates putting money in and I doubt companies here would do much.
The acting, and the dialogue.......so much better than Channel 5 drama stuff
Football is well loved in Singapore but at the end of the day, no one wants to go all out to be a pro footballer, that is why it isn't well developed. We cant even beat Indonesia and Laos who we used to dominate We cant even beat Taiwan whose people are more focused on baseball and basketball. We cant even beat Guam whose population is like what, so much smaller than ours. We even lost to a Japan university team. Our people are just too focused on academic results and specialised jobs instead of doing career in sports. Don't say world cup, we are already struggling in SEA games. All the instagram posts are about 'hard fought draws', 'great fight from Lions', 'unlucky Lions', etc.
But I do really like the employment of Japanese coaches because Japan can really play good passing football and they are brave to stay in this brand of football even up against stronger opponents. I did see improvement in our players but well this passing and possession football need to start from young. Hope we can build a strong team of youngsters to compete in SEA again. At least we are no longer resorting to useless long balls.
We need a complete overhaul… too many of these so called junior coaches have hidden agendas like securing school team contracts… another bunch are just egomaniacs and yes, the kid will have a great chance of making the team as long as the dad is an ex player or is bros with the coach… look at all the age group results, more than 90% losses and we are losing to teams like Cambodia, Timor Leste, Laos… forget the Thailands and Vietnams… we are at least 3 generations behind now…
have been my dream to become pro but it so hard when you don't have proper facilities I just want to give up but there is that one piece of me say to keep going that motivate me
At this stage and era, I had rather be an E-Sport player
Haiyo, don't waste money la..😂 SG still values academic performance and NS liabilities over any sports programs.
By inviting DPMM back to SPL, you know FAS is not interested in developing football in the long term. So waste time.
singapore should see how small country like iceland managed to be in the world stage instead comparing with japan
SG going to world cup.... Gosh... Don't make my toes 😂, look at what happened to Joseph Schooling.... Who would want to complete in and sports in SG....
make a academy called “bluelock” and do similar things. soon will have a great team.
but our lock confirm kena picklock
Pls lor, when we prioritise ns over football, obviously we cui wad.
Quite surprised it isn’t mentioned as a reason here. Ns is a major factor in striking a blow to almost , if not, all male sport careers.
GO GO GO SG!!!
Firstly,Hope Fas help and assist warrior fc back to the league .The clubs still in paying their debt in installments.FAS need to increase local teams at least 8 to 10 excluding Young Lion,Brunei Dpmm,Albirex.More Local teams in the league will produce more football talents for Singapore national team.Hope in the future,Geylang International FC can be privatised by City group.Please bring back warrior FC.That club hold many history and sad to see their downfall because of financial issues.Why japan football is good because their Japan government is willing to spent billions of their money and invest in their football and infrastructure.Zeon Zoysia grass is a must for all spl clubs.Improve field is the first priority for Unleash The Roar Project .
1st thing is to invest in SPL with sustainable money. Facilities also another factor. Without proper facilities and right world class coach to help them, how they qualify world cup? Even now ASEAN cup also hard to achieve.
“It was also a way for the Government to have Singaporeans embrace foreigners in our midst, and for them to help us win football’s greatest prize.”
However, this lofty goal would end up being a bitter disappointment as The Lions failed to secure medals in the SEA Games, or make it to the semi-finals of the regional Tiger Cup tournaments after winning in 1998, let alone qualify for the World Cup.
Around 2004 after the national team saw a change in management and the change of FAS presidents, “The Goal 2010 project was dropped like a tonne of bricks,” wrote Mr Raymond.
singapore dont have the street setting needed for youth to develop the sport, when everywhere is just high rise hdb and spotless offices
FAS existed as a front just to operate jackpot rooms for decades that's all. Football was just a front.
When I was playing youth level there were players that were just unbelievable at football, but with the then $30 coe allowance what a joke alot of players dropped out went to vice cus they had to survive Singapore isn't a cheap country, imagine I put the energy I put into football to start a business or work gamble invest,. Singapore football will never prosper unless u take care yours kids aka your youth level players best part is even the nfa players are very largely neglected once they get injured.. imagine a normal club player
Also while it is good for local players to ply their trade aboard, I'd rather see them playing in leagues like Japan/Korea's 2nd tier or even 3rd tier, or 3rd/4th tier of Europe top 5 league systems or 2nd tier of 'weaker' European leagues like Portugal, Holland etc than the leagues in our neighbouring countries.
Not true what Jita singh says....even if pep and klopp together became national team of singapore tomorrow for 2 years, singapore still wont qualify for wc
Singapore itself has no great talents like Messi or Ronaldo
I'm sure Singapore cannot even win a single SEA Games Football Gold or the ASEAN Cup from now to 2034. And yet they target a World Cup entry 😂
The former politician from Singapore People’s Party recounted roughly two decades of Singapore football history, starting with the remark by former Prime Minister Goh Chok Tong in 1998 who said, “Maybe if we change our immigration criteria to bring in top football talent and make them citizens, then one day we too can get into the (World Cup) finals.”
Very difficult. It’s not just abiut scholarship. It’s also the whole package, like you said. What are the chances of becoming pro?
Your knowledge along in this video is enough to run FAS
A Vietnamese here. Wanna share some with you guys.
First, I’m pretty sure that the problem is not with Singapore’s population. It may look small, but if you nurture them good enough you can still put up a decent team with homegrown. Which you used to do in the 90s (Tiger Cup 98 never forget).
Secondly, you are clearly lacking grassroot capabilities. No,I’m not talking about stadiums. With that amount of land area having that much stadiums is impressive. I’m talking about the coaches level in general. P.E. teachers are most of the times chosen to be the school’s football team manager. The problem is, most of them is not even paid properly and are just glorified janitor. There’s also not much coaching courses offer to them. Which didn’t quite help Singaporean youngsters at school, where they spent most of their times, even if they choose football they get coached by Sunday League level manager. Which led to terrible youngsters. And as building a high-level youth academy in Singapore is not quite practically possible, building youngsters from schools seem the most possible for Singapore.
Thirdly, S-League can’t even serve the main objective of a domestic league system properly: to develop local football. They can spent money helping an developmental Japanese side, a Bruneian royal team and a shambolic failure of a football academy attend the league, but not the local teams with actual fans. How can a league that pick foreign clubs over local clubs improve local football standard? Unbelievable.
Finally, the FAS. The goddamn FAS. They make our VFF look like angels. I wonder if they have even kick a ball before. Yet they pick unrealistic goal.
Our leaders only want quick result, thus the importing of China players in Ping Pong. if Top tiers ready made players from Europe say they want to play for SG, our G will straight away get 100of millions to get him to play and claim credit like they nurture him from young.
Maybe players (and their family members) can explore opportunities to train with more established academies. Read about the journey of Japanese international player - Kazuyoshi Miura. He searched for opportunities further afield and returned to help them develop.
Something struck the nerves of the higher ups in FAS thus the reupload?
1) Children in big footballing nations like England see football as an actual career choice. Football is make or break for them, they dedicate their entire livelihood to football. Us Singaporeans are more focused on school and education, football is a side gig for us.
2) Singaporeans have it too good, and that’s not a bad thing, most Singaporeans are financially stable or at least live in HDBs. Most of the top players come from poor backgrounds, living in slums and rural areas. Football was their only choice to get their family out of poverty, leading to there being a drive to succeed, which is something that Singapore doesn’t have.
Just some other points:
First of all, NS. Second of all, lack of interest in the local league. As a Singaporean who loves football, I have never and probably will never watch the SPL. It only has 8 teams and while I am inexperienced in the SPL it probably has the footballing quality of the National League in England. Why watch the local league and not any of the popular leagues, EPL, La Liga, Bundesliga? Last of all, we prioritise school over sports, which isn’t bad thing but it has some issues. I had a friend who was the star player on my school basketball team (not football but same rule applies) who got into the Zonal Final, coincidentally he came to school late that day and since he had come to school late two times in the past month, he had to stay back after school to clean the toilets. Long story short, he didn’t get to play the final and we lost.
What about Ns?
Wait for FIFA to increase the number of countries to qualify from 48 to 200.
we need either 11 Fandis in the starting 11
or find a truckload of players with SG heritage, naturalise them to don the Reds
then we may have some miracle chance to move up from current status of Asean San Marino to Asean Italy.
I think football in east asia is just a disappointment. Not counting the middle east and Oceana, the only asian teams that made it to the world cup were always japan and korea. Even china a big country struggling to qualify.
We have good clubs, we have good players. 😂😂 Might as well add -> "I'm sorry if I'm a bit arrogant but we have a top manager😅"
bro no one expects this tiny country to be at the world cup
Cannot lah. In SG every kid need educational cert to atleast survive with a roof and food😂 Dnt matter what is your talent. Sports? Arts? Music? Throw away your dreams. Get that Cert.
Reupload?
With the proper training, management etc..
it definitely is :)
Singapore cant even make it to Asian cup, havent learn how to walk wants to fly, can wait long long for world cup
Took down the original video to make the anonymous player look more "anonymous"......and re-uploaded it. Nice move mothership
everyone forgot about Goal 2010.
Who is that player
"emotional damage" GCT
Pls lah. Aim for Asia Cup first. And with every 16-21 year old boys kena NS, fat hope to let football thrive here. Just make the league semi-pro.
Lack of proper footballing system and they don’t even let kids play on void decks
Mystery : Difficult and impossible to explain or understand.
But in Singapore's case, it's not a mystery.
Forget football, we should encourage a bigger Street Fighter culture
Instead of coming up with Lions12 nonsense. FAS/Govt should get big corporation to adopt a club each for long term. Sign those Marquee Players like J League back then and also like US Major League now. This will bring the fans back, this will help the local SPL, the national team and also keep some national players here. Bringing in thosebforeign teams can bring you so far.
An era is gone, only dreams remained, past glory to be written, the talks continuous,,,,,,,
Even if SG has the greatest coaches and facilities, our local footballers still won't help the country qualify for WC....we need immigrants from Europe/South America/Africa to play in our national team in order to go far
But don't forgot NS is so big leh once incoming how dare to reject NS huh?know can't win football cup
Thailand no ns also not qualified for wc
@@xcre8ionx good Thailand no NS. Football training system all day long hard work. Thailand already did in the final winning AFF cup2022 liao
Football in Singapore cannot make money.
1) No sporting culture (compare our attendance to local games at a varsity / professional level vs overseas) i.e. people just don't care about local sports
2) First contact of sports is in school with teachers in charge of CCAs who could care less about the bigger picture / whether they are grooming the next superstar. These teachers also usually do not play the sport and are 'arrowed' to teach that CCA. They do not have a passion to actually coach.
3) Sports not being a viable career path
4) no safety net if sport career fails
5) focus on education / cost of living
6) small land mass - if a kid wants to train football over the weekend they have to book a court, even if it's in their own school (which will probably be used by adult weekend warriors)
7) National Service
1) No sporting culture or no local sporting culture?
@@zhen86If you want to get into semantics then yes, we don't have a 'local' sporting culture
I won't be the least surprised if the best players we have today is either a CEO, a doctor, a lawyer, an engineer, or IT manager or professor in one of our universities etc. But they are what they are in their respective professions and are not professional footballers in one of our local clubs for obvious reasons. And I won't be the least surprised if someone is able to mobilise a team from these various professions to take on the national team, and beat them. The best players we have are not those in the national team. To have the best team we can possibly have, we must be able to attract them to take up professional soccer as a career. And in the context of Singapore, that is a non-starter. It is the same problem we have with culinary skills. The best cooks are not those already running a food stall or working in a kitchen in our hotels and restaurants. The best cooks are those who will occasionally put on an apron to cook for friends and relatives at home for leisure, recreation and entertainment. To cook for fun and personal gratification is one thing. To cook for a living is something else. And which these freelance cooks are not prepared to do.
I like the first part he said..
Jita Singh is right. Education is more important. Defence is more important. Who can say that this shouldn't be the case
Education and ns not important...singapore need to be open minded
Should the State remain steadfast in its goal to qualify for the 2034 World Cup, Mr Raymond asked who would lead such a project which involves multiple ministries- Ministry of Education, Ministry of Defence, Ministry of Home Affairs while being led by the Ministry of Culture, Community and Youth.
Mr Raymond concluded that while Singapore may have the interest to channel into achieving such a goal, it might not have the wealth or even the size.
NS will crush any hopes of developing quality youth players
As a Vietnamese, I think this problem is rooted to all SEA countries besides Thailand, who I think only underachieved this past few years to not qualify in the 3rd round qualifying of the World Cup last year due to losing key games, they clearly have enough power to even beat Vietnam and be the team in the 3rd round qualifying. The problem of the entire SEA and how they can't get to the world cup with their national team boils down to grass roots being very very terrible for every single team in SEA to the point where there will never be a clear path to becoming a pro footballer. Adding to that, the Eastern culture for the most part care only for your academic grades, and so football will never be considered as a job that is either lucrative or even secure.
Người Việt này ;))))))
There is a saying in Vietnam these days: “Thailand is the king at ASEAN, Vietnam is the leader of ASEAN in continental level and Indonesia is a joke that both of them laugh at.” . At funny as it is, Thailand did perform better when they are at the upper hand, while Vietnam perform better when we are the underdog. Every Vietnam’s manager except for Calisto make the deadly mistake of trying to get the upper hand against Thailand, we can’t really blame them though as the fans always want to stomp Thailand after all these humiliation for years. We are clearly not built for it even on history. However when it comes to continental competitions, where we are definitely the underdog, we play like an underdog and hit stronger teams. Most Thailand’s manager in this era, on the other hand, make the deadly mistake of not playing like an underdog against Asian powerhouse. In Southeast Asia, where they are clearly better than most of the teams there, their playstyle would work. The other teams, they don’t even have an established playstyle like Vietnam or Thailand, why even bother?
Increase the salary and job security, players will come.
Same with badminton
Sorry had to chuckle at the opening line of setting a target to qualify to world cup by 2034. What are those ppl setting up the target smoking, so detached from reality lmao. If they plan to HOST the world cup as way of qualification, then thats one thing (still dont see it tho ,sorry SG)
Even Indian Football has been facing the same issues.
YESsssssss, Youth League is a very good ideally, PLEASE TAKE NOTED THAT : please fellowing those country like other european and south america..for their Youth League or School league, they been set up the same rule that, during their Youth Tournament all team they are allowed to change their player IN & OUT any time they want, ( it just exactly like those NBA Basketball rule) It just make sense for all team player that been having chance to play to CONFIDON, offcouse when the player been play for first 15mins, been take out by the coach time, (not straight going back to their changing room) next,,,,,the coach need to advices and teach then what to do for those player for their next RE-ENTEN FIELD.
174 Mammoth!
We need to support local talents and local teams, not bring foreign teams to use our league as a B league.
Singaporeans love football but probably our leaders do not. Its as simple as that. Investment in sports require passion and having a vision.
We should get into the business of selling footballers. That’s probably the fastest and most viable way to improve our football. At the end of it, it’s still about money.
the thing is who want to buy our players?
@@zhxnwxi. as of now is no one… i’m saying if we want to improve Singapore football, i feel this would be a viable route.
not that bad lahh . . . at least we are better than our causeway neighbour . .
imagine a poor messi born in singapore, the poor messi will never play for singapore because team is not selected based on performance but by famous uncle connection
the poor messi will be doing grab food now
Let’s be honest, even with the unleash the roar, it’s isn’t enough to be even an Asian power house. Look at the stadiums, field, equipment, infrastructure. FAS and the government can’t be bothered to upgrade them and yet still dare talk about 2034. Even 2010 World Cup vision was a failure.
Singapore football ⚽ is behind in system, structure and function for at least 25 to 30 years!!!! We can only dream of producing players like what both Japan and South Korea have already done!!!! It might take longer in producing a Singapore Ronaldo or Messi or Neymar Jr or a Sholes or Beckham or a Stevie G!!!! During my younger days playing football i was in,. saw a team of smart, skillful and talented young boys trained by a very experienced and knowledgeable coach who used to play for Singapore in his much younger days!!!! But they played a different style of football most local teams played that was known as kampung football!!!!! These young local boys were playing more of a European style of football, thought by their dedicated coach!!!!! But at last, jealousy was the main factor that prevented the majority of the team from entering the FAS school boys team!!! Jealousy than by the FAS in the 1990's, by a team of secondary school boys from Catholic schools from the east side defeating teams who had more experienced and skilled who were playing in national schools divisions as well as RC zone teams!!!!! Too bad they have all gone their own ways, if given the chance i think they would have helped grow the football culture earlier then!!!!
Don't waste time ah. Ur NS eats away the most crucial developmental period of a youth player's growth. What more our work/study first system strangles and asphyxiates the life out of individuals here
Japanese companies have a system of sports and work balance system for those who aspire to continue their craft/discipline and would give time off to train whilst working.
We don't even have say, our SPF/SAF/SCDF having a system whereby the athletes can sign on to balance both. In the very first place, the government doesn't give two hoots about supporting sport UNTIL absolute results happens (Schooling great example) and then oh let's jump on the bandwagon
It is just so sad to see all the potential talents fizzle away into oblivion
Education and ns not important...singapore need to be open minded
@@ZuLiAnO_FaRhAn Not in the eyes of the SG government. Thats why we wont ever qualify for World Cup
@@ZuLiAnO_FaRhAn all they care about is NS and Education, they dont care about the people
I hope there's Singaporean TMJ who can save S'pore football...
Singapore football is way too slow by world standards from goalkeeping to forwards. That is why they always cannot make it
As of June 2023. There are about 561330 Malays, 374860 Indians, 3072310 Chinese and 140750 others in Singapore. I know what u want to say. It's inrelevant. The team now make up more than 90% Malays and indians from a pool of 930+k people. Barely 30% of the Chinese population. I love football from a young age. All my peers play basketball so I go training alone. The football coach spoke in malays and players racism play a big part. Malay always think chinese as more inferior compare to them but did we beat china? I believe most Chinese boys love football had the same treatment. I know there are Chinese players in sg squad but even the most well known spend most time on the bench. You have a pool of potential talent in that 3mil pool but malays players and coaches didn't show class as majority. I always loved football the most. I was forced to switch to a more Chinese cca, basketball to represent my school. I just play for fun as I didn't really interested. When Chinese go for football training. unless we speak Malay if not it feel more like a quarantine than a group training. It's ok if Singapore did badly. After all which country ever succeed when the majority race didn't even care for it. You can replace the Chinese players with foreigners. Look at previous record and you will know. Yes most legends are malays, bcos you guys nv fully dig up that 3million pool of potential Chinese players. Want to win in asian competition? World cup? There must not be more than 40% malays and indian and not more than 50% in the starting 11. We have about a little more than 4mil local real citizen in sg. How you want to get sponsor when 3mil not even interested?
Let say now we start to groom the 3mil Chinese local players the same way how now the players were treated without racism and biased. In 20-25 years later. Malay player will not exceed 10% in national squad. You guys got a chance bcos Chinese don't want to be bullied. Still don't understand?
You want to win something? No more than 4 malays in the starting lineup and no Malay only language in the team. I been call cheena babi so many time bcos they think I don't understand. You guys is wasting that 3mil pool of Chinese talent. fyi Malaysia came in 2nd for the most racist country in the world. You guys know what you're capable of.
Lastly those Malay encik coaches，you know why you got the job? Bcos no Chinese want a salary of 2k, otherwise you more likely to be security guard.
As a Chinese majority in sg, we're often taught to give in to Malays and practice racial harmony. You ever tried hanging out in school with malays. They behave properly when they alone. When the gang come all suddenly power become dragon ball Goku. I nv forget I went to my first ever training in primary. Was boycotted already quite sad. In the dress room my clean shirt all was thrown over the place. School shoe lost and have to wear my boots home. I cannot imagine if Chinese is the minority. Sick.
Dont waste time n resources...
If we join Malaysia cup, maybe I might watch again if not, plse dont waste time...
Extremely difficult. Even countries with more than 1.4 billion people and no National Service like India and China cannot qualify and you expect Singapore to be able to do so. China literally spends way more than Singapore on its sports programs too. When you have individual sports, every now and then with a bit of luck, you get a genetic freak who goes and breaks the Olympic record in an event like Joseph Schooling did. But the chance of simultaneously having like 20+ (11 starters + substitutes and reserves) genetic freaks at one go is impossible. We don't have the culture. We don't have the financial incentives (salary relative to living cost). We have NS. We have a ridiculously small population (though this is actually less of a problem since Iceland qualified with a population of 334 thousand, but India and China can't with 4230 times the population, which is unfathomable to even comprehend).
So Japan has 20+ genetic freaks all the time? its the system in China that failed. In india, there is no interest in Sports other than crickets.
Iceland with just 300k population just laugh to this statement 🤭
FAT HOPES!!!! SG better withdraw from all football events. don’t waste any more time. cut your losses. after all we don’t put in the kind of efforts on the national level, on the training n coaching level, and only have mediocre players
2 issues. Money and NS.