This is one of your best redesigns you've made imo. Truly makes it actually pretty decent looking. Still, I would like to see the side changed as well as that is definitely an issue with the current design. Also the front and rear don't quite match each other, front is a rigid and quite straight design while the rear is a lot more organic, kind of becomes two ideas fighting with each other.
Now you made a Land Rover Velar in the front hahaha. The diagonal lines are a graphic move that’s coming from a few of their previous concepts. A cross hatch they’ve become infatuated with
Man... for the longest time, I did not receive any suggestions by YT for your channel. Caught myself the other day, "Wonder what happened with @TheSketchMonkey?" Even when subscribed! And then all of a sudden got a short and whent to your channel. Still active! You were my relief during Covid. Love to see you are still active! Stay safe, broda!
Front looks so much better 👍I wonder if the aftermarket will come up with something like this. Rear also an improvement, but it still doesn't feel completely right to me
I really like the first gen X3. I've to admit its design is indeed a bit quirky but in a well thought of way - if that makes any sense. I prefer it over most modern car designs. It looks high quality and therefore pricey but also like it would get some work done with the plastic protection at the bottom and the wheel arches. Cool car Edit: what I really don't like, not just with BMW but with all of the German manufacturers is the moment in design where the head lights started to touch the grill
I like the rear redesign but I don't like the front
4 หลายเดือนก่อน
I feel what impacts the bulbous look more are the side panels not having any sharp/sporty lines and the weird non-circular wheel arches. I'd like to see how you would incorporate those in your redesign
The redesign is cool and i coyld accept it if that were the official design.. Though the front fascia looks like an F90 M5 blew up tall, which isn't a bad thing. It's nice 👍🏻👍🏻
in couple of hours you have created something much more superior to what bmw design department has been working for few years. congrats - you alone are better than dozen of 22 year old colleague graduates for some reason sitting on bmw's payroll
I love the rear end redesign of yours but honestly I love the front end of the original… it’s actually more funky and less static than your own front end redesign
I think it looks great too, the shape of the rear looks good and reminds me a bit of the back of the G02 X4. The front looks better than I thought it would.
Congratulations on the redesign! You could also have removed the vertical division in the front lower intake that BMW now seems to put in every car. And make the wheel arches graphics more traditionally round instead of the squarish thing that BMW is putting now. 2018’s X3 was perfect design! Thank you for removing the black plastic below the kidneys. That thing alongside the lower vertical division are two of the works things of recent BMWs!
I always enjoy your videos and appreciate your perspective. I have a 2020 X3 and love the looks and performance of the vehicle. My only concern is the horrible stiff ride. I put on aftermarket springs, which helps, but make sure to do a full test drive as the ride is quite jarring. Other than that I love my car.
this is why YOU should be head of design for BMW love most of your redesigns, also you made me understand why I like a design and what conflicts when i think something was off
I understand your logic but I feel like it just makes the car more boring and generic. Lines don’t always have to be symmetric and aligned. Look at modern art, modern interior design etc and I think you will start to see what BMW was thinking. I think their execution is not perfect but at least it looks new and different.
While I don’t hate the outside of the new x3 your design has a lot more confidence, some changes I would maybe have done differently myself, but the original design just has so much doubt and uncertainty.
Like your redesigned of the X3 which has improved it. Didn’t have issue with design of grill, just that something wasn’t right with the overall design. Rear lights are fine, but the interior does not works. The out going model was classy whilst this new car fails to keep the subtle design.
Great redesign, i would have liked a chamfer for the grill as well, or atleast a very small seperation between the grill and the headlights with body colour. Or I guess i just don't like the LEDs in the grill, it should just be blacked out.
Congrats, you made the front end look like the new Lincoln Nautilus…. I’m glad BMW has differentiation between models and they’re taking risks. They could be like Audi or MB where you can’t even tell what model it is until you get up close.
I promise you. This guy is not smarter than those BMW designer engineers! 😆 You have to move on my friends! And that is why BMW keeps selling more and more cars every year. Besides them offering more and more features, it’s the modern clean look that’s on the 2025 that will increase sales even more! 😉
This redesign is a rare case where I personally think the before design looks better even though I dislike what BMW has done too. Just the overall shape of it makes it void of any improvements.
@Thesketchmonkey I would like to see a redesign of the Nissan Titan based on the first generation Titan. Nissan is planning to end production of the Titan this summer and cancel the truck. I would like to see what a new one using the original design might look like, hopefully it will get their attention and create some hope for this Nissan fan.
This redesign is so much better to look at. I was so much annoyed by that headlight slightly poking the kidneys. It annoyed the hell out of me. Hopefully BMW starts from the scratch and think again about their designs. I used to love BMW but now I just can't help but see them as just an automotive product.
I like your design, but it's less aggressive look. The front looks more massive and it competes with X7 😂 I like the new grille design even if it's not connecting perfectly. In the back, I like both tail lights, but your curvature looks better. My fav X3 is actually G01 LCI because of the tail lights. The original lights are too big, too weird.
i really think that the design will age just fine, just like the current x5 that people hated or the newest 5&7 series. BUT my problem is, it looks too crossover-ish instead of an SUV. For some reason, it just looks small, more like an X1/GLA level.
5 series looks like crap compared to the 7 series, the 5 series looks like being designed by a Japanese, especially the inspiration comes from a Honda Accord for the front fascia, and a Toyota Camry at the rear
Please review/redesign the 2025 M5. They’ve made it look like a Kia Forte had a forbidden love-child with a brick. Well, maybe not exactly like that, but it looks more like an Asian sedan now, at least in my opinion.
Funny enough when you put the redesign next to the original design... The original design looked just how a BMW would look, it looks so BMW i don't know how to explain it, it looked more BMW than the redesign
I was originally a potential buyer of the new X3, but when I saw the design of the X3, my first reaction was, oh, it's really ugly. I won't spend a penny on it
You said it yourself, the X3 looks like a minivan and you made it look like a small SUV, which looks great. The black plastic on the first gen looks tactic, military, land rover-ish, and I kinda like it
This looks like it could be an X1 like it looks soft and cartoonish. Your redesign makes it look more stately like an X3 should. These cars are pushing 60k they shouldn't look like an X1.
The weirdest part to me is the from the rear three quarter view… the back glass is too small and the D-pillar is angled weird almost like the XM. Also no wheel arches makes the side look bland like ugly iX
I normally agree with your redesign but even you putting 2 led housings is old and making the head lights sooo big is very late 2000’s we do have to remember that even in there first x3 was funky and aimed for youth and playful and so called more affordable If you wanted a more serious design pay more and get the x5 I believe its youthful playful and colours a more in trend then your x5 At the end of the day its a bmw and it looks better then the Chinese brands and there being unique which most brands copy each other
I see every change you made and understand that it looks cleaner. But it’s looks like the generic version of their design. Theirs just has that extra touch that says “hey.”
BMW lost it with the design lately. I don't think even your re-design saved the front end. When you cleared the mess, the front end turned into Range Rover. Rear re-design really saved it though. Don't even get me started with the interior, what a mess
Modern BMWs need to be seen in person. The design choices they make don’t reflect when in videos. BMW is doing what Lexus did starting with the 4th gen GS back in 2012. Make heavily designed cars that spark curiosity and emotion as ultimately that is what sells. Part of getting a luxury car or any product is the image it exudes. BMW has the performance and newfound reliability to back up its designs, Lexus has reliability to back up its designs. You can’t really blame them tho, bc the numbers have really shown that the actual customer base likes these designs choices. I have to say that i am starting to see a bit of the spindle grill in modern BMWs. The black detailing under the kidneys is getting pretty annoying and lazy gotta admit
Your redesign is the better looking. But still because it's based on the BMW actual redesign, it looks too angular, too EV-ish. Not feeling it. The shape and dimension of the overall vehicle is also awkward. They made it longer and lower. Station wagon vibes instead of the sporty SUV.
Hi Marouane, I have been watching all of your videos on the new BMWs lately, and I have an overall observation ( I do not have any academic knowledge in design, but I love to sketch cars and am a petrolhead). I agree with all of your opinions and comments regarding BMW's recent design language. I mean, there is not really any room for disagreeing-- the new BMW designs are obviously hideous! However, your damage control sketches aren't working that well, either. For example, this particular one didn't work out IMO. Despite all your reasonings behind the edits being spot on, it ended up looking bland. My theory is that these BMW designs are irrecoverable. Underlying the weird graphic, these are weirdly shaped: there is no curve anywhere. The 'industrial' looks creating the impression of sheets of metal being pressed together, and no distinct stances, also lines and shapes bending abruptly without any flow. BMW is deliberately trying to create a design language that stands out specifically because it is unelegant, brazen, and disruptive. I think BMW is well aware that anyone who grew up seeing 80s, 90s, and 2000s BMWs and having an emotional bond or attraction towards BMWs will be simply repulsed. Maybe they have a different breed of customers to which these cars appeal. I mean, we live in a world where Tesla trucks are also selling like hotcake! I would say that if you want to redesign these abominations, please also consider reshaping and correcting the odd lines. For example, BMW tried to give the new M2 the same wide body kit shape as the E30 M3 and failed poorly I would say. Meanwhile, Audi made a brilliant homage to the Audi 90 GTO though their RS6 GT (almost the same can be said for the Ferrari Daytona--> Dodici Cilindri). I would be super thrilled to see you redesign the M2 like that: properly reshaped and restructured to make it look like a perfect reimagination of E30 M3, or this X3 reshaped to have more curves and flowing lines.
Don’t mind the new design concept but Love the clean look of the redesign. BMW needs more stability in their designs
The original BMW design looks so good! love the new X3
@@jjjjjjj3376 You must be kidding lol
You made it look like a Buick from the early 2000s
Yeah, agree. A bit too American imo
Yeah but it already looked like a Buick
😀🤣
This is one of your best redesigns you've made imo. Truly makes it actually pretty decent looking. Still, I would like to see the side changed as well as that is definitely an issue with the current design. Also the front and rear don't quite match each other, front is a rigid and quite straight design while the rear is a lot more organic, kind of becomes two ideas fighting with each other.
I like the new x3. Your redesign makes the car look more static imo
Nahh BMW makes BMW look more static xD
In the front the redesign looks more static indeed, I also like this new X3
If the 2025 X3 looked anything like the redesign, I would have definitely purchased it ! great work !
Great rear design. Much less cluttered and adding some harmony in the design, one of the key characteristics of BMWs in the past.
Now you made a Land Rover Velar in the front hahaha. The diagonal lines are a graphic move that’s coming from a few of their previous concepts. A cross hatch they’ve become infatuated with
Man... for the longest time, I did not receive any suggestions by YT for your channel. Caught myself the other day, "Wonder what happened with @TheSketchMonkey?" Even when subscribed! And then all of a sudden got a short and whent to your channel. Still active! You were my relief during Covid. Love to see you are still active! Stay safe, broda!
Front looks so much better 👍I wonder if the aftermarket will come up with something like this.
Rear also an improvement, but it still doesn't feel completely right to me
I really like the first gen X3. I've to admit its design is indeed a bit quirky but in a well thought of way - if that makes any sense. I prefer it over most modern car designs. It looks high quality and therefore pricey but also like it would get some work done with the plastic protection at the bottom and the wheel arches. Cool car
Edit: what I really don't like, not just with BMW but with all of the German manufacturers is the moment in design where the head lights started to touch the grill
I really don’t like the new X3 design. Have a 2020 X3 M40i. Sticking with it.
I think you should send your redesign to BMW to make them realise how badly they screwed up . Well done !
I like the rear redesign but I don't like the front
I feel what impacts the bulbous look more are the side panels not having any sharp/sporty lines and the weird non-circular wheel arches. I'd like to see how you would incorporate those in your redesign
The redesign is cool and i coyld accept it if that were the official design..
Though the front fascia looks like an F90 M5 blew up tall, which isn't a bad thing.
It's nice 👍🏻👍🏻
in couple of hours you have created something much more superior to what bmw design department has been working for few years. congrats - you alone are better than dozen of 22 year old colleague graduates for some reason sitting on bmw's payroll
I love the rear end redesign of yours but honestly I love the front end of the original… it’s actually more funky and less static than your own front end redesign
I agree fully
Hot take: The new X3 looks great. It's the pinnacle of futurism and it's going to stay good-looking for a very long time.
no
For Chinese Market yes
@@uzisol ah now it makes sens lmao
I think it looks great too, the shape of the rear looks good and reminds me a bit of the back of the G02 X4. The front looks better than I thought it would.
These modern interiors have made me appreciate the new Bugatti Tourbillion
Congratulations on the redesign! You could also have removed the vertical division in the front lower intake that BMW now seems to put in every car. And make the wheel arches graphics more traditionally round instead of the squarish thing that BMW is putting now.
2018’s X3 was perfect design!
Thank you for removing the black plastic below the kidneys. That thing alongside the lower vertical division are two of the works things of recent BMWs!
I always enjoy your videos and appreciate your perspective. I have a 2020 X3 and love the looks and performance of the vehicle. My only concern is the horrible stiff ride. I put on aftermarket springs, which helps, but make sure to do a full test drive as the ride is quite jarring. Other than that I love my car.
Also in my eyes a huge huge improvement!
this is why YOU should be head of design for BMW
love most of your redesigns, also you made me understand why I like a design and what conflicts when i think something was off
Amazing redesign!
I understand your logic but I feel like it just makes the car more boring and generic. Lines don’t always have to be symmetric and aligned. Look at modern art, modern interior design etc and I think you will start to see what BMW was thinking. I think their execution is not perfect but at least it looks new and different.
The color and the frontend, the new X3 definitely looks like a capybara on the road.
While I don’t hate the outside of the new x3 your design has a lot more confidence, some changes I would maybe have done differently myself, but the original design just has so much doubt and uncertainty.
Like your redesigned of the X3 which has improved it. Didn’t have issue with design of grill, just that something wasn’t right with the overall design. Rear lights are fine, but the interior does not works. The out going model was classy whilst this new car fails to keep the subtle design.
I like the 2018!
Reintroduce cover for rear cup holders, draw cover to centre console and the means to drop seats
Much better - it looks a properly integrated design
BMW needs to have you redesign their entire lineup. So much better and more “BMW”
I totally agree the 2018 generation it’s definitely the best looking
Great redesign, i would have liked a chamfer for the grill as well, or atleast a very small seperation between the grill and the headlights with body colour. Or I guess i just don't like the LEDs in the grill, it should just be blacked out.
Congrats, you made the front end look like the new Lincoln Nautilus…. I’m glad BMW has differentiation between models and they’re taking risks. They could be like Audi or MB where you can’t even tell what model it is until you get up close.
I promise you. This guy is not smarter than those BMW designer engineers! 😆 You have to move on my friends! And that is why BMW keeps selling more and more cars every year. Besides them offering more and more features, it’s the modern clean look that’s on the 2025 that will increase sales even more! 😉
This redesign is a rare case where I personally think the before design looks better even though I dislike what BMW has done too.
Just the overall shape of it makes it void of any improvements.
Feels a lot better, but not a big fan of the crashed headlights, feels less aggressive and more static.
@Thesketchmonkey I would like to see a redesign of the Nissan Titan based on the first generation Titan. Nissan is planning to end production of the Titan this summer and cancel the truck. I would like to see what a new one using the original design might look like, hopefully it will get their attention and create some hope for this Nissan fan.
So you reckon you can design a better BMW than BMW? Would love to see your original car designs.
Hey can you the ND3 miata, specially the rear end. Thanks.
I love the 2022 one
This redesign is so much better to look at. I was so much annoyed by that headlight slightly poking the kidneys. It annoyed the hell out of me. Hopefully BMW starts from the scratch and think again about their designs. I used to love BMW but now I just can't help but see them as just an automotive product.
Your version looks so much better. The 2025 was a mistake
I like your design, but it's less aggressive look. The front looks more massive and it competes with X7 😂
I like the new grille design even if it's not connecting perfectly.
In the back, I like both tail lights, but your curvature looks better.
My fav X3 is actually G01 LCI because of the tail lights. The original lights are too big, too weird.
You have to work for BMW. Your design is way better than theirs. They should make everything they can to get you on their team!
i really think that the design will age just fine, just like the current x5 that people hated or the newest 5&7 series. BUT my problem is, it looks too crossover-ish instead of an SUV. For some reason, it just looks small, more like an X1/GLA level.
5 series looks like crap compared to the 7 series, the 5 series looks like being designed by a Japanese, especially the inspiration comes from a Honda Accord for the front fascia, and a Toyota Camry at the rear
Please review/redesign the 2025 M5.
They’ve made it look like a Kia Forte had a forbidden love-child with a brick.
Well, maybe not exactly like that, but it looks more like an Asian sedan now, at least in my opinion.
in my opinion, the redesign is looking comfortable at present but BMW maybe catches the next two years? btw the new X3 is way better than 5 sedan
Exactly that thing looks like a Accord and a Camry mashed up, plus the 7 series looks decent after seeing the new 5 series
i dont know about you but for me the new design does not give bmw vibes and the redesign gives skoda x range rover vibes
I have to admit I like the original headlights more than the redesigned ones.
The front looks 10x better now.
I like BMW is going towards clean design. I like new X3.
Great redesign
Nah man the redesign looks horrible, WTF
@jjjjjjj3376 the car overall just looks ass! It still doesn't look good but it definitely looks better
So you basically made BMW X7 before facelift?
Nice!
why didn't you redesign the m50 version
Just as you said, X3 is always the weird child 😅
Funny enough when you put the redesign next to the original design...
The original design looked just how a BMW would look, it looks so BMW i don't know how to explain it, it looked more BMW than the redesign
I was originally a potential buyer of the new X3, but when I saw the design of the X3, my first reaction was, oh, it's really ugly. I won't spend a penny on it
So much better.
BMW are truly lost 😢
You said it yourself, the X3 looks like a minivan and you made it look like a small SUV, which looks great.
The black plastic on the first gen looks tactic, military, land rover-ish, and I kinda like it
Bmw is starting to look like GTA V cars
BMW should hire you and fire whom ever is designing their cars these days sheesh!
„Chamfer“ mentioned in this video: 4 times
wow you made it look like a vw Touareg or some kind of Q8 in the front....noooot pretty :D
I don't mind the front of the new one, or your design. But that rear end is a lost cause not matter how hard you try lol
Redesign > Production
Not a fan of the original design, but I like yours even less it gives me beaver vibes like the infamous IX
The 2018 model looks the best, by far. As of lately, BMW has lost its design mojo big time.
This looks like it could be an X1 like it looks soft and cartoonish. Your redesign makes it look more stately like an X3 should. These cars are pushing 60k they shouldn't look like an X1.
I believe someone from BMW is sabotaging the company 😅
The weirdest part to me is the from the rear three quarter view… the back glass is too small and the D-pillar is angled weird almost like the XM. Also no wheel arches makes the side look bland like ugly iX
I like your redesign way better, but bmw made that thing way too beefy..lol😂
I normally agree with your redesign but even you putting 2 led housings is old and making the head lights sooo big is very late 2000’s we do have to remember that even in there first x3 was funky and aimed for youth and playful and so called more affordable
If you wanted a more serious design pay more and get the x5
I believe its youthful playful and colours a more in trend then your x5
At the end of the day its a bmw and it looks better then the Chinese brands and there being unique which most brands copy each other
It looks so much better now
You have inspired me so much that I look at cars and try to make some changes on things that annoys me 😅
Thanks my mentor
All X3's look good except the 2025.
The E83 still looks the ugliest to me
I see every change you made and understand that it looks cleaner. But it’s looks like the generic version of their design. Theirs just has that extra touch that says “hey.”
More spaceships from
BMW
I like your deisings better than this version of the X3 2024
BMW lost it with the design lately. I don't think even your re-design saved the front end. When you cleared the mess, the front end turned into Range Rover. Rear re-design really saved it though. Don't even get me started with the interior, what a mess
Hyundai lookin headlights killed me but looks great other wise
bro you just turned it into the non-Msport version
Onloy thing I would've kept is the kidneys the same size
Modern BMWs need to be seen in person. The design choices they make don’t reflect when in videos. BMW is doing what Lexus did starting with the 4th gen GS back in 2012. Make heavily designed cars that spark curiosity and emotion as ultimately that is what sells. Part of getting a luxury car or any product is the image it exudes. BMW has the performance and newfound reliability to back up its designs, Lexus has reliability to back up its designs. You can’t really blame them tho, bc the numbers have really shown that the actual customer base likes these designs choices.
I have to say that i am starting to see a bit of the spindle grill in modern BMWs. The black detailing under the kidneys is getting pretty annoying and lazy gotta admit
You make the design go backward in time lol
Factory one is more original, those headlights are now too big and doesn't fit
That redesign is *CLEAN!*
❤❤❤
redesigned front looks like an Skoda lol idk why
The 2025 X3 has a bloated/puffy face, and overall messy design features all over the body.
Even the old X2 M-design looks better than this!
Bro just made a 5 Series SUV and calls it a redesign 😂
Your redesign is the better looking. But still because it's based on the BMW actual redesign, it looks too angular, too EV-ish. Not feeling it.
The shape and dimension of the overall vehicle is also awkward. They made it longer and lower. Station wagon vibes instead of the sporty SUV.
current BMWs look like a 5yo was asked to draw them from memory
Before redesign:🤡
After redesign:😈
10 times better
Original = NO
Redesigned = HELL NO
I absolutely hate all these new BMW designs… it pisses me off. I guess I won’t be getting a new one anytime soon.
Hi Marouane, I have been watching all of your videos on the new BMWs lately, and I have an overall observation ( I do not have any academic knowledge in design, but I love to sketch cars and am a petrolhead). I agree with all of your opinions and comments regarding BMW's recent design language. I mean, there is not really any room for disagreeing-- the new BMW designs are obviously hideous! However, your damage control sketches aren't working that well, either. For example, this particular one didn't work out IMO. Despite all your reasonings behind the edits being spot on, it ended up looking bland.
My theory is that these BMW designs are irrecoverable. Underlying the weird graphic, these are weirdly shaped: there is no curve anywhere. The 'industrial' looks creating the impression of sheets of metal being pressed together, and no distinct stances, also lines and shapes bending abruptly without any flow. BMW is deliberately trying to create a design language that stands out specifically because it is unelegant, brazen, and disruptive. I think BMW is well aware that anyone who grew up seeing 80s, 90s, and 2000s BMWs and having an emotional bond or attraction towards BMWs will be simply repulsed. Maybe they have a different breed of customers to which these cars appeal. I mean, we live in a world where Tesla trucks are also selling like hotcake! I would say that if you want to redesign these abominations, please also consider reshaping and correcting the odd lines. For example, BMW tried to give the new M2 the same wide body kit shape as the E30 M3 and failed poorly I would say. Meanwhile, Audi made a brilliant homage to the Audi 90 GTO though their RS6 GT (almost the same can be said for the Ferrari Daytona--> Dodici Cilindri). I would be super thrilled to see you redesign the M2 like that: properly reshaped and restructured to make it look like a perfect reimagination of E30 M3, or this X3 reshaped to have more curves and flowing lines.
They do have design problems, always liked BMW but they have lost it a bit