@@tanis3639Pixar lol but yes, you’re correct- I never understood why “great movie” was supposed to be “meant for everyone”. It’s a common thing for detractors to say. Only children’s movies are genuinely ‘meant for general audiences’.
@@firmasyahrian2483why does one of the greatest films have to be for everyone? There are so many great movies, that objectively I can acknowledge are absolutely amazing movies, but just not my taste, doesn’t take from its greatness though.
Another interesting thing about Phantom Thread’s audio is that you can clearly hear the dialogue - allowing the audience to decipher and understand what the characters are saying. This was a confounding revelation for Nolan.
Nolan's favourite part was the toast scene. In his next film he will cast only toast. Warbutons is the lead actor, Hovis is the supporting actor and many other Bread extras will appear in the film.
This is my favorite Paul Thomas Anderson movie. It has the most sharply defined characters and the clearest narrative arc of any of his movies. It explores the power struggle and codependence that exists in many relationships. These are things we've all probably felt in relationships but you rarely see explored on screen. It's also darkly funny.
This is a perfectly fitting review to understand what Nolan values in movies. He cares about the experience in a theater, the visuals, the sounds, the spectacle.
i was thinking myself very odd in rewatching this film three times to catch every nuance from the three leads. i’m so glad that i am not the only obsessive fan 😉
@@ogeidiasUnfortunately, equality allows for opinions, that is to visibly account for (a female director's) presence, yet disregard them as a subject for praise. Them's the breaks, kid. (And though I'm sure Gerwig wholeheartedly appreciates your support...she might not appreciate being the impetus for your political agenda.)
@@ogeidiaswell shes not on that level, pta and nolan are some of the best filmmakers of the century and del toro is amazing as well. Shes just not there yet, no shame in that bro not everything is sexist
I think a mark of a great film is that you can watch it many times and enjoy each screening. I have re-screened Phantom Thread many times. There's just something about the film, maybe for me the biggest pull is the nonstop incredibly beautiful cinematography. But of course there are so many others things to enjoy as well. Master filmmaking.
Something about the laughter in this room reciting Woodcock is incredibly refreshing. I remember seeing it in theatres and was in complete stitches for most of it while most of the audience was quiet. Like a lot of PTA films its stunning, poignant and deep but it's also just deliciously hilarious. PTA has such a great skill in mocking masculine self seriousness. It appears in so many of his movies, men with such a high perception of themselves that basically makes them a zoo creature in there realities. There's reason and merit to some of those inflated egos but they are also removed from time and space in a pathetic way. Woodcock one of the most fun those prototypes. He's insufferable and stands for so much waspy bullshit but he's also endearing to the viewer maybe because we see his blinders even if he doesn't. And by the end what a way to get put in his place. What a film.
All of thosr movies except Dunkirk came out at the end 2017 so i count them as 2018 movies myself because that is when i saw them. I went back through my list and 2018 was a really great year for movies.
I decided to watch Phantom Thread with my wife one night. I'm a 35 year old male so the topic of the movie does not really interest me really at all. I was blown away by how amazing the movie is. I enjoyed it thoroughly and of course, DDL is such a powerhouse in that movie.
The real topic of the movie is the power struggle and codependence at the heart of many relationships. It's also about the personality and needs of the artist. It's not about dressmaking at all. I suspect PTA was depicting some of his own relationships in a roundabout way.
Greta is a relative newcomer but she is incredible. Little Women and Lady Bird are some of the best features of the last decade or so. She has every right to be there.
So Christopher Nolan apparently DOES recognize good sound design when he hears it - unlike what he does with his own movies 😄 (I know this opinion is polarizing)
Funny he drew attention to the gun scene because it doesn't work. DDL desperately trying to improvise and ending up saying the same bizarre thing over and over. I don't know why it was left in.
beacuse thats how arguments work in reality, you stumble , miss your words , sound childish when you are in heat . its afterwards you build up flawless arguments in your head
@@kwdwnThat’s so true! It actually bugs me in movies when characters can all spontaneously say just the right thing in just the right way, especially quickly back and forth like in an argument. Very few people actually do that in real life.
Phantom Thread is one of the greatest films of all time, with absolutely outstanding performances by all.
I wouldn't call it that because it's not for everyone. Absolutely great film, but not for everyone.
@@firmasyahrian2483 ...but then is anything, film or otherwise 'for everyone'? 😉
@@tanis3639Pixar
lol but yes, you’re correct- I never understood why “great movie” was supposed to be “meant for everyone”. It’s a common thing for detractors to say. Only children’s movies are genuinely ‘meant for general audiences’.
@@firmasyahrian2483”great” and “not for everyone” are not mutually exclusive.
@@firmasyahrian2483why does one of the greatest films have to be for everyone? There are so many great movies, that objectively I can acknowledge are absolutely amazing movies, but just not my taste, doesn’t take from its greatness though.
the music of Phantom Thread was amazing
Guitarist from Radiohead
Jonny Greenwood…composer
It's always a pleasure to watch two masters appreciating each other's work
Nolan is overrated
@@bat1579 your overrated
it is! especially knowing that they're about the same age, its actually pretty awesome to see that they're so tight
I loved Phantom Thread. It seriously surprised me at how much I enjoyed it.
There's something oddly comforting about it.
better and better the more you see it. took me a few
Same, I didn't think I'd like it...but boy was I wrong. I loved it. This is one of few movies that I instantly wanted watch again.
Another interesting thing about Phantom Thread’s audio is that you can clearly hear the dialogue - allowing the audience to decipher and understand what the characters are saying.
This was a confounding revelation for Nolan.
it would be the toast scene though, no? 👀
Nolan's favourite part was the toast scene. In his next film he will cast only toast. Warbutons is the lead actor, Hovis is the supporting actor and many other Bread extras will appear in the film.
Nolan did that on purpose ! Clearly you’re just a child just discovered movie last week
Very salty about Nolan 😂
Never had a problem hearing nolans dialogue. Definitely a you problem.
This is my favorite Paul Thomas Anderson movie. It has the most sharply defined characters and the clearest narrative arc of any of his movies. It explores the power struggle and codependence that exists in many relationships. These are things we've all probably felt in relationships but you rarely see explored on screen. It's also darkly funny.
Same.
Del Toro is an absolute unit.
😂😂😂😂
Nolan later stated that he wished the characters voices had been drowned out by music so that they were barely audible
Touche
Lmoa this is paul thomas anderson film not nolan film 😅
I don't understand why he does that and what's the point of it making the dialogue mix barely audible isn't any aesthetic whatsoever.
@@disisfunny88whoosh
I had no issue w that movie at all and even less so with Oppenheimer 💁🏻♂️
I could watch Christopher Nolan impersonate Woodcock from PT all day.
Bwahahahahaha
The real villain of Phantom Thread is the extremely capable sound designer.
Excellent!
seriously. I love all the creaky floors and reverberation in the rooms.
Nolan did that on purpose ! You don’t know anything about Nolan’s movie
@@jackdolah2031 ugh Nolan bros
@@marknewbold2583nolan haters r salty af
This is a perfectly fitting review to understand what Nolan values in movies. He cares about the experience in a theater, the visuals, the sounds, the spectacle.
PTA is the best director working today
Nolan is.
@@frankpoole8645you’re 9
you're pretentious. good luck at film school your b rated garbage will probably impress the other stuck ups@@bat1579
Villeneuve says hello
i was thinking myself very odd in rewatching this film three times to catch every nuance from the three leads. i’m so glad that i am not the only obsessive fan 😉
Still a robbery we didn't get more than 20 minute video for a panel with PTA, Chris Nolan and Del Toro..
Of course you'd ignore the only female director on the panel.
@@ogeidias lol nice
@@ogeidiasUnfortunately, equality allows for opinions, that is to visibly account for (a female director's) presence, yet disregard them as a subject for praise.
Them's the breaks, kid. (And though I'm sure Gerwig wholeheartedly appreciates your support...she might not appreciate being the impetus for your political agenda.)
@@ogeidiaswell shes not on that level, pta and nolan are some of the best filmmakers of the century and del toro is amazing as well. Shes just not there yet, no shame in that bro not everything is sexist
That could be any director that’s at her level and they wouldn’t be slotted in the same praise as the other 3.
I think a mark of a great film is that you can watch it many times and enjoy each screening. I have re-screened Phantom Thread many times. There's just something about the film, maybe for me the biggest pull is the nonstop incredibly beautiful cinematography. But of course there are so many others things to enjoy as well. Master filmmaking.
I really wish Christopher Nolan had made a movie with Daniel Day Lewis
Greta Gerwing sitting there cracks me up
Something about the laughter in this room reciting Woodcock is incredibly refreshing. I remember seeing it in theatres and was in complete stitches for most of it while most of the audience was quiet. Like a lot of PTA films its stunning, poignant and deep but it's also just deliciously hilarious. PTA has such a great skill in mocking masculine self seriousness. It appears in so many of his movies, men with such a high perception of themselves that basically makes them a zoo creature in there realities. There's reason and merit to some of those inflated egos but they are also removed from time and space in a pathetic way. Woodcock one of the most fun those prototypes. He's insufferable and stands for so much waspy bullshit but he's also endearing to the viewer maybe because we see his blinders even if he doesn't. And by the end what a way to get put in his place. What a film.
All of thosr movies except Dunkirk came out at the end 2017 so i count them as 2018 movies myself because that is when i saw them. I went back through my list and 2018 was a really great year for movies.
What a fun family he has. Calling someone Mr. Woodcock for being controlling, bullying is a great inside joke.😄
I decided to watch Phantom Thread with my wife one night. I'm a 35 year old male so the topic of the movie does not really interest me really at all. I was blown away by how amazing the movie is. I enjoyed it thoroughly and of course, DDL is such a powerhouse in that movie.
The real topic of the movie is the power struggle and codependence at the heart of many relationships. It's also about the personality and needs of the artist. It's not about dressmaking at all. I suspect PTA was depicting some of his own relationships in a roundabout way.
One of those movies I can watch 3 times in one day and not get bored. I sometimes keep it playing in the background while I do other things 😂
They don’t know they are made of duality so they.
Game recognize game.
Three legendary directors, and Greta Gerwig.
😂😂
Lady Bird was better than Dunkirk and Phantom Thread. Greta absolutely deserved to be there.
Greta is a relative newcomer but she is incredible. Little Women and Lady Bird are some of the best features of the last decade or so. She has every right to be there.
don't underestimate her
Greta who
game recognize game
One fabulously wealthy film director stroking the ego of another extremely wealthy film director - great stuff!
My nikka focusing more on krk krk than the film
❤
This is fucking catnip to me.
So Christopher Nolan apparently DOES recognize good sound design when he hears it - unlike what he does with his own movies 😄 (I know this opinion is polarizing)
His sound design is fine. Your ears just suck.
ooooooooh.😂😂
Funny he drew attention to the gun scene because it doesn't work. DDL desperately trying to improvise and ending up saying the same bizarre thing over and over. I don't know why it was left in.
beacuse thats how arguments work in reality, you stumble , miss your words , sound childish when you are in heat . its afterwards you build up flawless arguments in your head
@@kwdwnThat’s so true! It actually bugs me in movies when characters can all spontaneously say just the right thing in just the right way, especially quickly back and forth like in an argument. Very few people actually do that in real life.
Greta seems totally disinterested
Greta Gerwig sitting there like the lost child that she is.
Nolan's "Oppenheimer" and PTAs "There Will Be Blood" and "The Master" seem like cousin films. Nolan must have been heavily influenced by PTA.
And Greta couldn't look any more bored. Lady Bird wasn't that great, sweetheart lol
Yes it was, better than all of the 2017 movies by them
Bored? She laughs, she nods, she is obviously listening to what he says. I think you just wanted an excuse to shit on Ladybird.
thats cute@@3ndifo
Your misogynist comment has transported me back to the 1950s just as well as the movie being discussed in this video.
Lol you 100% get no bitches
So he can appreciate good films he just doesn't make them himself.
it's always Nolan haters with the most gratuitous shit takes 😂
100%. Nolans films are bland, uninteresting waffle.
@@dominicparker-tc7sb we Will agree to disagree, Nolan's name is etched into the history of cinema forever, regardless.
@@nicolaslabra2225 this is very true and he's exceptionally talented, I can't take that away from him.
He makes good films, you just can't hear what anyone is saying without headphones.
One fabulously wealthy film director stroking the ego of another extremely wealthy film director - great stuff!
Their wealth is well deserved
@@LichenAndMoss So you're saying that wealthy societal elites releasing these two directors from the confines of normality is well deserved?
The confines of normality? I dont know what that means. I just dont think there's anything wrong with making money off of their art. @@commonwunder