Peace, brother! And many thanks for your excellent video! Please allow me one question concerning the context of 2:238. I fully agree that the context is very important. And it makes sense, what you said about 2:238 and the verses before. But you did not mention the next verse, i.e. 2:239, which belongs to the context, too. How do you understand verse 2:239 in connection with the topic of the verses before - and even after them (until 2:242)?
Several time I see verse salat involve stand, and this one involve prostrated is that not a ritual? 4:102 And when you are among them and lead them in prayer, let a group of them stand [in prayer] with you and let them carry their arms. And when they have prostrated, let them be [in position] behind you and have the other group come forward which has not [yet] prayed and let them pray with you, taking precaution and carrying their arms. Those who disbelieve wish that you would neglect your weapons and your baggage so they could come down upon you in one [single] attack. But there is no blame upon you, if you are troubled by rain or are ill, for putting down your arms, but take precaution. Indeed, Allah has prepared for the disbelievers a humiliating punishment.
I follow the Quran alone. However, I pray the 5 daily prayers. Unfortunately, many Quran only Muslims have become just as extreme as many traditional Muslims. They have become anti-tradition. The purpose of following the Quran alone is to liberate people from the superstitions, and other bad things that where the result of the hadiths as well as restoring the honor of the prophet Muhammad's reputation which has been slandered by hadiths. It was not to undermine the good traditions such as prayer, fasting and charity.
It would be respectful to acknowledge the work of Sam Gerrans (Quranite) and using his translation for this presentation. Sam does a much better job of explaining this as he actually did the work.
@@avnisekiraqqa3365 you have bias approach. Please read the context and apply it to the message of the Qur’an as a whole. Its not easy, believe me I know. It took me over 2 years to learn how to study the Qur’an without preconceived notions.
If Quran by itself is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
Excellent analysis. The translators of the Quran, have done a great injustice to the Quran. They, as far as I can see have brought in Christian concepts and used those to translate Quranic Arabic!
th-cam.com/video/_cAB-tm-u9M/w-d-xo.html Please comment below if you need me to cover any verse related to Salat or post your questions below. Thank you.
Near the conclusion of the video, you mentioned that people have devised their own ways to perform Salat. Could you please elaborate on this? Are you suggesting that individuals have created the rituals of Namaj themselves? Isn't it Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) who taught us the proper method of performing Salat? Could you clarify this point?"
Selam, thank you for the video sir. Can you explain Soera 5:6 about the wudu before ‘the duty’ . Why must we wash certain parts before upholding a duty, staying closely to gods rules ? 🙏
Hi IMHO the Qur’an does not deal with such trivial things as washing the body or what one may or may not eat. Religions deals with such things. The Qur’an addresses to the rational mind that already know what is personal hygiene. You dont need to learn such mind how to wash your face. The purpose of the Qur’an is to increase the moral values and encourage the recipient of the message to do researches, study the laws and apply the results to his own benefits. In order to actually understand certain message, one must translate each word and analyze/apply the contextual value of the verse or group of verses. Taking this into account one could conclude that the transmitter of this message wants to encourage the participants to clean their minds and give the message a chance judging by the facts, non-bias approach. And if there is an obstacle it must be resolved rationally for the benefit ot both the individual and the community. This vers also, like the entire Qur’an, promotes common sense and logical reasoning. And that is one of the main features of SunatullAllah. Regards
@@adnandizdarevic6989 Hi, Quran does Literally ! deals with “details” like washing some parts of the body, what is forbidden to eat and a lot of other “ldetails “… ??? 🙏
@@semracalik3040 why would something be created at all if it is forbidden to consume? why do you think pork is forbidden? I emphasize again that in my opinion, the Qur'an does not speak of this. Translation is manipulated
Primary salat of man is to serve god alone..ablution in koran is like baptism in christinaty..if u sincerely want to approach the duty from now on (ie to serve god alone) then fist clean ur self and dont be int0xicated meaning u know what u r saying(ie u r in ur mind) U can also check this video out th-cam.com/video/3C0Nq1vhh6w/w-d-xo.html
Fabulous work. Quranic word Salat wrongly translated as Namaz as Persians word resulting misguidance and keeping us away from our duty to Allah and serving humanity. Salat is system where the whole Deen Islam revolves. Namaz rituals may be a smallest component of Salat System but shouldn't be done as Zorestranians Rituals.
You have copied Shabbir or G A Perwaiz. Both were WRONG 100% on this point. Namaz rituals are NEVER component of Salat. Namaz Rituals is that IDOL Worship in which Sunni and Shia has converted Kaaba into an Idol, and they prostrate to that Idol in five Namaz rituals which were imported from Zoroastrians, and then were validated through forgery of hadith of Miraj-Buraq. *Verse 2:177 tells that Rituals facing Qibla are NOT GOOD DEED. Several verses like 2:115, 57:4, **50:16** tell that God is Omnipresent. That means: God is not confined to any Cube or to any specific direction. All directions belong to Him. Therefore; His Omnipresence, makes all Physical directional rituals NULL AND VOID* 5 daily Rituals = Pure Idol Worship = Shirk 100%
@@abdar-rahman6965 No, the timing of their prayer is zoroastrianism. You can search up 5 duhs or prayers of Zoroastrianism. The physical movements is not zoroastrianism but Pagan Surya Namaskars.
*Who are الْمُصَلِّينَ the Musalleen ?* Is it those who observe the ritual prayers ? Lets find out. 70:19 Verily, man is created with an anxious disposition. 70:20 When they are afflicted, they complain, 70:21 And when good touches him, withholding [of it], 70:22 Except الْمُصَلِّينَ the MUSALLEEN. 70:23 *Those in their SALAT (صَلَاتِهِمْ) who are CONSTANT (دَائِمُونَ).* 70:24 *And They (Al Musalleen) are those who assign a certain share of their money/property (أَمْوَالِهِمْ)* 70:25 *for the needy (لِلسَّائِلِ) and the deprived (وَالْمَحْرُومِ),* 70:26 *And (Al Musalleen are those) who acknowledge/accept as true (يُصَدِّقُونَ) the Day of Judgment (بِيَوْمِ الدِّينِ),* 70:27 *And (Al Musalleen are the ones) who are afraid of the torment of their Lord,* 70:28 the punishment of their Lord is not something for them to feel secure of, 70:29 *And (Al Musalleen are the ones) who guard (حَافِظُونَ) their modesty* 70:30 Except from their spouses or what they possess rightfully then indeed, they (are) not blameworthy, 70:31 but whoever goes beyond this is a transgressor; 70:32 *And (Al Musalleen are those) who honor their trust and promises(وَعَهْدِهِمْ),* 70:33 *And (Al Musalleen are those) who testify to what they have witnessed (شَهَادَةَ),* 70:34 *And (Al Musalleen are) those who, on their SALAT صَلَاتِهِمْ keep a guard يُحَافِظُونَ,* 70:35 such people will receive due honor in Paradise. Further Clarification of ayahs 70:22-34 *Spending Wealth, Charity* 70:24 They (Al Musalleen) are those who assign a certain share of their money/property (Amwālihim أَمْوَالِهِمْ). 70:25 for the needy and the deprived, Clarification : [107:1] Do you know who rejects the deen [107:2] Who turns away the orphan [107:3] And does not encourage the feeding of the poor. [107:4] So woe to those "LILMUSALLEENA" لِّلْمُصَلِّينَ [107:5] [But] who are heedless of their "SALAT" صَلَاتِهِمْ [11:87] They said: "O Shu'ayb, does your SALAT order you that we leave what our fathers served, or that we do not do with our money/property (Amwālina أَمْوَالِنَا) as we please? It seems only you are the compassionate, the wise!" [9:103] Take from their money/property(Amwālihim أَمْوَالِهِمْ) a charity (صَدَقَةً) to purify them and develop them with it, and make SALAT with them; for your SALAT is a tranquility for them; and God is Hearer, Knowledgeable. *Belief, Qualities:* 70:26 (And Musalleen are those) who acknowledge the Day of Judgment, Clarification : [27:3] Those who establish "SALAT" and contribute towards purification. *AND THOSE WHO ARE CERTAIN ABOUT THE LIFE-TO-COME.* [4:162] who perform the "SALAT" diligently, and contribute towards purification, *AND BELIEVE IN ALLAH AND THE AFTERLIFE* *Guarding Ones Modesty* 70:29 (Al Musalleen are the ones) who preserve their chastity 70:30 except from their spouses and those whom they rightfully possess [through wedlock], for which they incur no blame Clarification : [29:45] Recite, what has been revealed to you of the Book and establish "SALAT". *Indeed, "SALAT" prohibits immorality and wrongdoing,* and the remembrance of Allah is greater. And Allah knows that which you do. *Fulfill Pledges, promises:* 70:32 (Al Musalleen are those) who honor their trust and promises, Clarification : [2:177] ...establish "SALAT", and contribute towards purification, *AND FULFILL THE PLEDGES/PROMISES MADE BY THEM.* *Truthful Testimony* 70:33 And (Al Musalleen are those) who testify to what they have witnessed (بِشَهَادَاتِهِمْ), Clarification : [5:106] O you who believe, witnessing (شَهَادَةُ) shall be done if death is approaching one of you and a will is being made, by two among you who are equitable. If you have gone forth in the land, and death is approaching, then any two may suffice - if you have a doubt regarding them, then detain them after making the *SALAT,* and they will swear by God: "We will not purchase with it any price, even if it was from a near relative, *AND WE WILL NOT CONCEAL THE TESTIMONY (شَهَادَةَ)* of God, else we are of the sinners." *Guard the Salat* 70:34 *And (Al Musalleen are) those who, on their SALAT صَلَاتِهِمْ keep a guard يُحَافِظُونَ,* Clarification : [6:92] And this is a Book which We have sent down, blessed, authenticating what is between his hands, and that you may warn the capital of the towns and those around it. And those who believe in the Hereafter believe in it, *AND THEY GUARD THEIR SALAT.* Salat is not a ritual prayer. Quran(الْقُرْآنِ) Alone(وَحْدَهُ) Peace
thanks brother. and this is my understanding regarding Salah. There is no ritual prayer in the Qur'an under study. The ritual prayer times 3 or 5 a day do not match the world in which we live. There are inhabited areas in the world that do not rise or set the sun for a month and two months, it is all night or day. The second question is what is the benefit or logic of ritual prayer. Let me simplify the subject of ritual prayer. There are people and a king rule them , the king decided to put rules to organizes the people and puts laws and regulations for the people, so he wrote the constitution book and put everything in it. The people took the constitution and did the following: The people took the constitution and went to the king and read the constitution upon him 3 or 5 times a day with some movements. Is this the case with ritual prayer? I would like you to clarify the topic regarding the timing and the logical benefit of ritual prayer. Did we not understand the concept of Salat/prayer in the Qur’an??? The meaning of the word SALAH صلاة in the Quran mean to connect The Fajr and Isha SALAH in this verse ﴿يا أَيُّهَا الَّذينَ آمَنوا لِيَستَأذِنكُمُ الَّذينَ مَلَكَت أَيمانُكُم وَالَّذينَ لَم يَبلُغُوا الحُلُمَ مِنكُم ثَلاثَ مَرّاتٍ مِن قَبلِ صَلاةِ الفَجرِ وَحينَ تَضَعونَ ثِيابَكُم مِنَ الظَّهيرَةِ وَمِن بَعدِ صَلاةِ العِشاءِ ثَلاثُ عَوراتٍ لَكُم لَيسَ عَلَيكُم وَلا عَلَيهِم جُناحٌ بَعدَهُنَّ طَوّافونَ عَلَيكُم بَعضُكُم عَلى بَعضٍ كَذلِكَ يُبَيِّنُ اللَّهُ لَكُمُ الآياتِ وَاللَّهُ عَليمٌ حَكيمٌ﴾ [An-Nūr: 58] they have nothing to do with the ritual prayer, according to the context of this verse, God speaks at three periods a day for the people of the house to ask permission before entering and communicating with you, so the Salaat Alfajer صلاة الفجر mean the beginning of connecting and Salaat Alashaصلاة العشاء mean the end of connecting with the people of the house and also when you put your clothes from ALTHAHIRA الظهيرة and the word ALTHAHIRA does not mean noon it has the meaning of get away or to disconnect and these words Alfajer الفجر, Althahira الظهيرة and Alasha العشاء have no Relationship to night and day. What do you think about this and what is your answer? .......... also to know the meaning of (اقيموا او اقم الصلاة) (aqimuu or aqim alsalat ) establish or establish Alsalat , if we know the meaning of ( إقام ) ( 'iiqam ) in the next verse the word (فَأَقامَهُ) (wa'aqamah) has clear meaning ﴿فَانطَلَقا حَتّى إِذا أَتَيا أَهلَ قَريَةٍ استَطعَما أَهلَها فَأَبَوا أَن يُضَيِّفوهُما فَوَجَدا فيها جِدارًا يُريدُ أَن يَنقَضَّ فَأَقامَهُ قالَ لَو شِئتَ لَاتَّخَذتَ عَلَيهِ أَجرًا﴾ [Al-Kahf: 77] (77) So they set out, until when they came to the people of a town, they asked its people for food, but they refused to offer them hospitality. And they found therein a wall about to collapse, (فَأَقامَهُ) (So he set it up) . [Moses] said, "If you wished, you could have taken for it a payment." (فَأَقامَهُ) (so he set it up) so the meaning of (اقيموا الصلاة) (aqimuu alsalat ) will be to set up or to correct or to improve the way of communication with Allāh by contemplating with His Book and implementing His commands, also the meaning of (اقيموا الصلاة) (aqimuu alsalat ) to set up or to correct or to improve the way of communication with every human interaction between people, between the government and people, or between people and the government. (اقيموا الصلاة) (aqimuu alsalat ) is a continuous adjustment,set up, correction and improvement the way of communication between you and Allah and between you and people,government... also between each other like governments and Countries.
Near the conclusion of the video, you mentioned that people have devised their own ways to perform Salat. Could you please elaborate on this? Are you suggesting that individuals have created the rituals of Namaj themselves? Isn't it Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) who taught us the proper method of performing Salat? Could you clarify this point?"
Although your explanation of the Salat according to the Quran is better than some others of similar intention, however there is something which is not quite right. It is where you wrote, "Duty as a general concept (Hope, patience, petition) Personally, I think the English words "hope" and "faith" are incompatible with the Quran. The English word "Hope" means a feeling of expectation and desire for a particular thing to happen but the Quran does not encourage following your desires and feelings, for example: 6:116 And if thou hast obeyed most of who are on the earth, they will cause thee to go astray from the way of God. They follow nothing but opinion and they only guess. Faith is an irrational belief in something that is logically impossible but the Quran encourages you to always use "aqal" to reason it out. So, obviously your "DUTY" to Allah cannot rely on your "hope" or "faith." Not if you use the Quran as the sole guide. After all there is no doubt nor crookedness in the Quran, right? The Quran also describes itself as "a clear Book!" As an example, please consider this verse: 22:31 becoming Hunafa lillah (strictly Unitarian to Allah) - not associating partners unto Him. For whoever associates partners to Allah, it is as if he has fallen from the sky and the birds snatch him or the wind blows him to far-off places. So, if you read the Quran then would you rely on "hope" and "faith" of the birds or the wind to carry you to safety? Or, are you assured that you would fall to the ground by the pull of gravity. And, Gravity is measured by the acceleration that it gives to freely falling objects. At Earth's surface the acceleration of gravity is about 9.8 metres (32 feet) per second per second. Thus, for every second an object is in free fall, its speed increases by about 9.8 metres per second. Another of your concepts that doesn't quite sit right by me is when you say something like, "... petition to God..." Tell me... would you petition a God who says... 3:29 Say, “Whether you conceal what is in your hearts or reveal it, it is known to Allah. For He knows whatever is in the heavens and whatever is on the earth. And Allah is Most Capable of everything.” Maybe you might feel like you must petition to your God... but the One True God of the Quran is already aware of what you conceal or you reveal. So, is there a need for you to still petition the All Knowing God? salam.
Peace, Shukri Yusof! I like your comment, but concerning your statement "Maybe you might feel like you must petition to your God... but the One True God of the Quran is already aware of what you conceal or you reveal. So, is there a need for you to still petition the All Knowing God?" I would like to ask you: How do you understand 2:186: "And if My servants ask Me, surely I am near, I answer the prayer of supplication ..."?
@@gunnar4230 The first part of 2:186 are explained by these 2 verses: 50:16 And certainly We created man and We know what whispers to him his soul, and We (are) nearer to him than (his) vein jugular. 56:85 And We (are) nearer to him than you but not (do) you see, The second part is a tad more tedious because of the translation you chose, i.e. "prayer of supplication" which is totally incorrect! Please note the Arabic for that portion of the verse is: أُجِيبُ دَعْوَةَ ٱلدَّاعِ إِذَا دَعَانِ Please also note the root word "Dal-Ayn-Waw" is used 3 times as in: 1. دَعْوَةَ 2. الدَّاعِ 3. دَعَانِ Basically, you could translate it to: I respond to "the call of the caller who is calling to Me." So, that includes ALL of MANKIND, irrespective of whatever division & sub-division other humans have divided us into. Furthermore, there is NO "special way" , by way of language, ablution, ritual, mannerism etc., to place that "call" of the "caller" when that "caller" is "calling" on the One True God. Read these 2 verses very slowly and try to understand each word: 10:22 He enables you to travel on land and sea, until-while they are sailing on ships and rejoicing in favorable winds-a storm arrives, and waves come towards them from all directions, so that you think you are facing death. Then they cry out to God in all sincerity, claiming faith in Him alone: "If You save us from this, We will be truly thankful!" 10:23 Once He has saved them, they return to being corruptive on earth in defiance to the Truth. People! All your outrageous deeds will be counted against you; your enjoyment is limited to life in this world. Then you will return to Us, and We will confront you with everything You have done. Actually, you could even be travelling on an airplane and you go through turbulence or the plane is trying to land during a raging storm. Do you "call out to your God?" Yes, we, all mankind, do it regardless of our preferred religion... did you use any special way to "petition" your God? Was it with any specific words, or language? or ritual? or just something instantaneous that goes on in your heart? And, when we land... safely... each and everyone of us tend to assume our personal God has answered our "Du'aaa" or perhaps the skill of the pilots/traffic air controller, or... But... what about all the other passengers? There are other verses that speak about "God answering your call/du'aa/prayers," of course. Go read them in the Quran. peace.
@@shukriyusof2104 Peace and many thanks for your detailed feedback! I agree with you. But note that the word دعا has many meanings - according to the context. It includes supplication, too.: In 1:5 we ask for help نستعين. And the following two verses 6 and 7 are supplications, too - in my view. Furthermore, we find in the Quran supplications, for example in 2:286. Therefore, I agree with your remarks in your answer to me. But on the other hand, I also understand from the Quran, that Allah invites us to supplicate and to ask Him. And I mean with "us" all of mankind. Peace and regards!
@@gunnar4230 Yes, you can give many meanings to a foreign word but that foreign word only has one original meaning. Okay, ley us agree that "Du'aa" also includes supplication. Now, tell me where does the Quran give details on how to perform this ritualistic supplication that the revered religious scholars have formulated for their blind followers? It is akin to the "Salat," isn't it? They have invented it as a ritual prayer but that is NOT what the Quran says! The same with "du'aa" ... they, the Sectarians, have invented the ritualistic supplication complete with rituals and chants to go along with it... But that is NOT what the Quran says! Anyway, once you understand who & what God is... then... every call/wish/supplication/request/prayer you make/say/do is to Allah... and, you don't need to give it any special terminology or attach repetitive superstitious rituals complete with special chants repeated at certain times, on certain nights, during certain months... you know where I am going with this, right? Just keep reading the Quran and it will come to you... verily, it is Allah who teaches you the Quran. salam.
Salam. How do you explain this verse of Salah is not Ritual prayer? 4:102] When you are with them, and lead the Contact Prayer (Salat) for them, let some of you stand guard; let them hold their weapons, and let them stand behind you as you prostrate. Then, let the other group that has not prayed take their turn praying with you, while the others stand guard and hold their weapons. Those who disbelieved wish to see you neglect your weapons and your equipment, in order to attack you once and for all. You commit no error, if you are hampered by rain or injury, by putting down your weapons, so long as you remain alert. GOD has prepared for the disbelievers a shameful retribution.
Context:muslims are doing jihad/rescue mission(ie to save/rescue believer from wrongdoers) Now they r in enemy and negotiating "And when you are among them(i.e enemy), uphold thou the duty for them(i.e beievers u came to save); then let there stand a number of them(i.e enemy)with you, and let them take their arms; then when they have submitted(believers to u), let them(i.e believers) be behind you and let another number come(i.e enemy) that has not performed the duty(i.e not handed you the believer captives), and let them perform the duty with you(i.e hand you the believers); and let them take their precautions and their arms. (Those who ignore warning(aladina kafaru) wish that you would neglect your arms and your equipment, so they might assault you in a single assault; but you do no wrong if there is a hindrance to you from rain or you are sick, that you lay aside your arms; but take your precautions: God has prepared for the false claimers of guidance a humiliating punishment.) (4:102)
This is praying in group in which others are on guard to prevent from attacking them while praying is in progress. When the first group did the last prostration, they move out allowing the other group to come in and perform the same until all is done praying. In other words, there is no limit in the rakaats of every salat (prayer) you are doing (17:107-111)
I agree with some of your explanation about Solat, but the thing is, you have not covered the ONE NOUN in Q2:125. God did give the RITUAL CLEARLY in many ayah. the first and foremost is in Q2:125. Also i totally agree that the spiritual is more important (understanding the solat) but the RITUAL is there. it is explained in stages, and BY ALLAH, I have studied it, the ritual first step is in Q2:125. That is the simplest explanation of HOW to pray. It covers ALL THE RITUAL MOVEMENT of THE SOLAT and IT IS tightly connected to THE RITUAL of Ibraheem. The SOLAT is not INVENTED by people after Prophet Ahmad, but GOD had made a COVENANT with IBRAHEEM, hence in the context of Ibraheem, he was the APPOINTED as AN IMAM for ALL THE PEOPLE or MANKIND. These are the MANASIK of Millat Ibraheem. The Hajj, The Sa'i, and The Qurban and THE SOLAT. if you look and study the word solat in Quran, the last step is in SURAH Al-ISRA. the last five verse. It clarifies how to pray. It is only TWO rakaat every time. This is what i found in the Quran about the RITUAL solat. 1. Q2:125 - The way to pray (Examples of praying / standing, bowing and prostration) 2. Q4:43 - The prohibition of prayer (you cant do the ritual if you DON'T KNOW WHAT YOU SAY) - its not general duties, it is about SAYING things to GOD. 3. Q5:6 - The preparation (this in my view does not fit the 'duty', because its a RITUAL thing to wash your face before prayer. 4. Q11:114 - Time of Prayers (this also could not fit the generic meaning of 'duties', cause your "duties" are not only to be establish at two ends of the DAY (fajr and maghrib). 5. Q17:78 - Explain in detail of Maghrib time (its the same with fajar / twilight) 6. Q17:79 - The Nafilah (Isya prayer) is the additional prayer 7. Q17:110 - The tone of prayer. if you fit in the duties, then the commanders of armies could not perform their duties. so this is ritual solat. the last five ayah of surah Al-Isra, in reverse from Q17:111, 110, 109, 108 and 107 is confirming the RITUAL at Q2:125 you see physically from the MAQAM of Ibraheem. Q17:111 - Sayings before you do the TAKBIR. Q17:110 - Calling of GOD's Name (ArRahman) which He taught us the ALFATIHAH as the oft-repeated (or twice) Q17:109 - The Bowing (rukuk - please not that it does not mentioned about SUJUD in this ayah) Q17:108 - Saying in between the Rukuk and SUJUD Q17:107 - Then the SUJUD. The last part is THE key for our SUJUD. God is telling us that THOSE before us, whenever the ayah is recited THEY BOW DOWN in SUJUD!!. so that is what THE RITUAL SOLAT. cause every time you recite Al-Fatihah, GOD is communicating to you INSTANTLY thru HIS MESSENGER when you read The READING. then after that, YOU BOW and SUJUD. Repeating the second rakaah, Alfatihah, then GOD speaking to you, LITERALLY HIS WORD is RECITED upon you!! then you fall down in bowing then SUJUD!! notice that, THERE IS ONLY TWO rakaah of any solat (with audible recitation), whether it is in Fajr, Maghrib, or Isya. The additional rakaat that is silenced, im quite sure it was added later. The Zuhr and Asr prayer are NOT included. Im not saying its wrong but I dont pray Zuhr and Asr. I leave GOD to judge those who pray Zuhr and Asr. so, to say it is duties, im not against it. But if you are saying that it is NOT RITUAL and the ritual was "invented", well i think you are wrong. Im very sure it IS ALSO ritual. May Allah Guide us all.
further more, what is your DUTIES that you say of in FAJR and ISYA?? in Q24:58??? waking up?? brushing your teeth? in fajr?? its not generic. what is your duties after ISYA? when is ISYA?? sleeping is a duties? so, the AURAT is not speaking about following closely before FAJR?? you were sleeping. When you put in "duties" it becomes so vague. WHAT are you duties spesifically BEFORE FAJR?? i dont think the explanation of "following closely" or "duties" fit in the "aurat". Fajr time is the TWILIGHT.. hence it is when you woke up. its your PERSONAL TIME not duties. same thing afte ISYA.. what are the duties. the Quran is consistent, but your are forcing THE MEANING of SOLAT as ONE MEANING. EVERY one knows, one word could be used in many ways, for instance THE HAND.. does GOD say to MUSA, what is in your hand means physical hand?? what then when GOD say BY HIS HAND??? is THAT NOT CONSISTENT??? you see, YOUR DEFINITION of CONSISTENT is actually FLAWED. so it is not just DUTIES.. it is also RITUAL.
@@kyedean9698 Everything you wrote has already been answered. All you need do is to search the YT channels. Anyway, to cut to the chase, your whole argument falls flat when you just understand ONE basic point, and that is: #1. What is the Quran? If you believe that the Quran is a book of magical divine chants then, you would think that "whenever the ayah is recited THEY BOW DOWN in SUJUD!!..." And, by SUJUD who have been schooled to go down on all 4s with your forehead firmly pressed to the ground. Now ask yourself, do they, and you of course, go down on all 4s with their forehead firmly pressed to the ground EACH & EVERY time they hear the aya being recited to them? Do you understand the whole Quran? Do the 1.2billion Sunnis/Shiites etc., understand what is being recited to them when they go down on all 4s with the forehead firmly pressed to the ground? What if you are in a state of the man-invented "ceremonial impurity" and you hear the Quran being recited to you, do you go down on all 4s with your forehead firmly pressed to the ground while facing a stone idol in a town the latter day Arabs have named Makkah? When Mo Salah scores a goal he goes down on all 4s with his forehead firmly pressed to the ground... does he hear the Quran being recited to him? Or, is he facing the stone idol in the Arabian desert while he goes down on all 4s with his forehead firmly pressed to the ground? It all sounds ridiculously silly when you say and describe the rituals that you do in everyday language, doesn't it? But, that is what you get when you follow the footsteps of the Satan. salam.
@@shukriyusof2104 "Everything you WROTE has already been ANSWERED???" LOL! nothing has been answered by YT channels. AHAHAHAHAH.. again YT channels??? what effing channels answered my questions?? you dont know??? and without SHAME you ask me to search YT Channels without giving any specifics??? ahahahhaha.. ARE YOU DUMB??? 1. My argument falls flat??? what??? which argument?? are you trying to BULK-UP all my arguments and renders it as "FLAT" by your stupid hashtag question??? 2. I DONT BELIEVE QURAN as a BOOK of MAGICAL divine, thats your stupid assumption on other people. 3. what 4S??? care to explain? please dont quote the stupid bukhari or any of the six books hadeeth. IT IS NOT RELEVANT. 4. "Everytime ayah is being recited" it is CLEAR to me, it is talking about SOLAT. there are 84 ayah containing the word SOLAT akhi. Please study them first before jumping in and putting yourself as a person who know much more about the Quran than me. 5. Do I understand the whole QURAN??? who does? you??? ahahahhahaha??? by your question I ALREADY KNOW u have not studied anything about AlQuran. 6. FOOTBALL is not part of the ritual SALAT, are you STUPID?? what does it have anything to do with the RITUAL SOLAT??? 7. THE RITUALS are from IBRAHEEM. "Take from the MAQAM of IBRAHEEM as musolla / place of worship (example of how to PRAY). Q2:125 I may have been following the footsteps of SATAN, I can admit that. Im not infallible. YOU on the other hand, are not following satan, but SATANS follows you. you ARROGANT SOB. Walaikum salam.
The primary meaning of sujud is submit second meaning to prostrate the primary meaning of ruku is humility second meaning is to bend. There is most likely no ritual prayer in the Quran.
Selam sir, can you also do a video about ‘ ruh’ . We were told that we have a body and an eternal soul that Allah blew of his own by the creation of Adam. ? 🙏
@@semracalik3040 I would say it's referring to the evidence-based knowledge of the Quran. Allah has made accessible to THEM of it's knowledge, very little.
I noticed u r not answering questions of ur listeners, my question remain unanswered. I want to confirm how many obligatory prayers do we perform. D Sunni has 5obligatory & many nawafil prayers. Some say Wusta s a night prayer about an hour after isha. Actually i'm confused, what i understood, f not found in d Qur-an s not from God, f not from Allah who will reward in hereafter of ds Sunni's dhuhur, asar, & maghrib salawat, will Allah reward ds though not included in His legislation? Pls. Reply.
Peace brother. Thank you for this video and well done for your research. I know about the effort it takes to undertake the research and then present it. I have one question which I was unable to be clear about from your research: You focus quite heavily on how al-salaat means "duty" but then you also suggest that it means to "petition" God. It wasn't clear to me where in the Quran it suggested that al-salaat means to "petition" God. Would appreciate some clarity. Peace be upon you, brother 🙏 Munib
Judging by the beginning of the video it looks like you got your ideas from Sam Gerrans, I recommend his translation by the way. Duty seems to fit best all contexts but where God says salla that doesn’t seem like duty for example God says “They did not Salla” not sure how duty fits there but then again you could say salla means performing your duty but it just seems odd to me that salla 1 arabic word would be translated like that. Peace
Yes. Full credit to Sam. He has done a superb job in translating The Quran. I have it in the description also. My goal is try to co continue research as learning is a journey. Regards.
Hello, do you not see how pretenders (ie Quran only research) agree with each other like it reaffirms their ego. Do you not see they act like hyenas around a lion (the lion is you). You are correct 'They did not salla (duty)'. Salat does not mean duty. There is no pray in the so called Qu'ran (it's not a noun). God does not need anyones pray. How can a creator ask for something (like for example your duty) when he has everything and owns everything. It doesn't make sense. Salat simple means follow, which is independent and dependent on the individual and his profession. So a police officers salat is to uphold law, a lawyers salat is to uphold human rights and if we salat (follow) what is the teachings in this book which is God's laws, which in turn is God's natural law. Someone who sallah thus follows God's natural law is an individual who is a sovereign man.
Salla I think means "turn towards (God's guided direction/the guidance to follow closely/duties). There is a verse that describes it as an antonym of "turning away".
Brother in VERSE 2-125 ALLAH tells us to establish pray from the MUSSALLHA of IBRAHIM which is located in MECCA, and this pray was established in the time of IBRAHIM. So, ALLAH goes further than explaining the pray format 'he tells us where to get this format to witness the pray. The prophet MUHAMAD was told to follow the religion of IBRAHIM. The standing place of IBRAHIM is not only one monotheism but also a physical place in masjid al-haram. Because all prophets followed one monotheism. 'This is where many people are in difference amongst the QURAN alone followers 'This five pray format was happing since the time of IBRAHIM. Please look into this and reply back to me.
Didn't moses and Jesus follow Abraham, why they only pray 3 times a day ? In torah and gospel it's only find 3 times prayer ,Qur'an also only mentioned 3 name prayer
@@zullyfeehilly8968 The MUSSLLAH of IBRAHIM which is located in MECCAH is for all times and we are told to get our pray from there 2-125.. Also, in 17-78 ALLAH tells us to establish SALAH pray at the declining of the sun. The sun starts declining at noon 12-00 clock afternoon which will cover the ZAUHIR and MAGRIB..If ALLAH tells you to pray before sunset and before sunrise and at night. Then which SALAH are we meant to do in 17-78 'so brother after studying and studying i have come to know from 2-125 that the SALAH format which is happening in MUSSALH of IBRAHIM the standing place of IBRAHIM is for all times. Where we can witness the pray. Also, MUHAMAD SHIEK the famous QURAN alone scholar and other QURAN alone SUBMITTERS PROSPECT channel are doing the five prays because QURAN is telling us. i myself used to do three prays but since i have been told by the verses i corrected myself. We do not want to be like the mainstream sects 'who do opposite from QURAN. Because if we do not change are ways, we be doing what mainstream sects do. Rejecting the verses, we have to correct our self. Because the five pray format is not found anywhere in HADITH start to finish. Mainstream are lying about the prophet getting prays from the trip to heaven. This five prays format is from God the pray when you stand behind imam. But the fake SUNNAH pray is never behind imam. And all imam anywhere around the world will only recite the verses of God loud. But when you're in RAKOOR sitting down you only say the shahada from QURAN and never say Muhamad or Ibrahim in your pray. The pray is only for God. And when you have finished then pray for the prophets.
VERSE 2-125 NEVER tells us to establish pray=Ritual from the MUSSALLHA of IBRAHIM but VERSE 2-125 tells us to deliver Divine Message from the MUSSALLHA of IBRAHIM وَٱتَّخِذُوا۟ مِن مَّقَامِ إِبْرَٰهِـۧمَ مُصَلًّى Musalla=The place from where Divine Message is dilivered
@@abdar-rahman6965 Every command from Allah is continuously observed in real-time on the earthly plane, and this perpetual witnessing remains unalterable. The words of Allah, firmly embedded in the world, cannot be changed. We are instructed to "TAKE" from the sacred space where Ibrahim once stood-the Place of Contact/Prayer, where the Imam leads the congregation in prayer. Don't put your interpretation, just believe in the words of Allah by observing.🙏
I have been struggling to have a clear understanding of what you are trying to say, I don't agree with your description of Salat as following something closely., Salat is descriptive exercise clearly explained in the Quran. in Q22v26 Allah told Ibrahim to prepare His house (Kaaba) for those that will circle round it, that will STAND, KNEEL AND PROSTRATE IN WORHIP (SALAT). Salat means to Stand (Qiyam), Kneel(Rukuh) Prostrate (Suju). Allah went further to explain that you wash part of your body before approach Salat. Q5v6 Q28v45 Recite part of Quran to establish Salat. Q17v78 Dont shout during your Salat (While reciting Quran) or be silent but seek a middle course. Q17v79, End your Salat with Alhamdulilah, not by saying Salam. Alaykum to Left & Right. If Salat means follow closely are you going to do Wudu before you start following ???? Its misleading to say Salat is not a Ritual exercise but to follow closely. There are more evidences in the Quran that shows that Salat is a Ritual Prayer. and there are only 3 Salat in the Quran and not 5, namely Fajir, Ishai, Wustah. Salam
@@deanfbs6968 Read Q 17v110 Where Allah (SWT) is telling us about Solat, "Dont shout while reading Quran in your Solat nor be silent but seek a middle course" in the next verse Q17v111 and say Alhamdulilah" that has begotten no son.....etc. You end it by giving praise to Allah. Even Allah taught us to give thanks after eating Q2v172. Praise is given to Allah at end of everything, That is the tradition of Allah. There is no greeting of angel on the left and right in the Quran. Solat is for Allah alone, no greeting or mentioning of anyone's along with Allah Q72v18. Salam
Musalmam jo kahen. Mera manna hai ke Allah ka zikr aur ebadat tanhayi mein karni chahiye. Masjid mein nahi. Kiyonke wahan use Masjid walon ka firqa aur tareeqa anna hoga.
aapake maan se islam nhi chalta. islam nabi SAW ke kehne aur unke tareeqe se chalta hai. Firqa m kon jaane bol rha h. sirf quran aur sunnat ko folloow karo.Masjid m namaaz padhna compulsory h muslim men ke liye
It would be interesting to know how many times we should pray according to Quran only. My religious teacher came to the conclusion that there are 3 prayer times mentioned: fajr, maghrib and isha..
Pozdrav Ako smijem reci, problem je sto se prilazi odredjenim temama kao da vec znamo nesto o njima. Meni je dugo trebalo da se rijesim toga i da pridjem Kuranu kao poruci o kojoj ne znam apsolutno nista. I stvarno je tesko. Preporucio bih ti da citas kao knjigu o kojoj ne znas nista, drzis se konteksta i onda polako pocinjes obradjivati odredjene teme na osnovu tog konteksta.
@@adnandizdarevic6989 Hvala Bogu sto sam naisla na nekoga sa nasih prostora ko razmislja na slican nacin kao i ja. Tek kada sam pristupila Kur'anu kao neko ko nema nikakvog znanja o religiji i pocela da ga citam kao da ga citam prvi put, dobila sam odgovore na neka dotadasnja pitanja koja su kod nas tabu tema.
Different connotations of word Salat have slightly different meaning in Quran which also depends on the context. Salat Wusta is "Duty about Family=Central duty". When verse 2:177 tells that Rituals are not a Good deed; then after saying so, about duties; this verse talks first of all about services to family/relatives وَءَاتَى ٱلْمَالَ عَلَىٰ حُبِّهِۦ ذَوِى ٱلْقُرْبَىٰ Salat >> Establish Divine System; Stick to Divine law; Dua, Mindfulness of God/meditation upon God, to support others, Meetings/Ijtamah of Salat like Friday and like in 4:102 meetings about War strategy. Salat has NO ANY RELATION WITH RITUALS. Good deed=Philanthropy; NOT RITUALS >> 2:177
Read the second half of 9:5 and read 9:6. It’s clear these verses are based on historical context but even back then the didn’t just kill everyone. It’s the Hadith that says Islam spread by the sword
Quranic internal context shows: 9:5 is relevant to defensive war, and Quran permits war only in defense 2:190 or to free oppressed people from an Oppressor 4:75
During Salat, Why do they greet the Prophet (S) as if he were sitting right in front of us? Salat is supposed to neither loud or too soft but a middle tone is advised. Why do we then go through Salat quietly during two Salats in the Masjid and during all at home? We are not supposed to attend Salat if our minds are messed up and we don’t know what we are saying. Other than Arabs most Muslims recite memorized verses of the Quran and not even aware what they mean! Seems to me during the life of the Prophet, Salat sessions were held where Quran would be shared. In those days they did not have printed Qurans all over besides Quran was being revealed in stages and shared with the community. Regarding the Salat sessions of the Mushriks, we are told there is a lot of whistling and clapping (but no substance)!
Yes there was no internet, tv, phones, social media and stuff. So they made salat sessions to spread the message. They read and learned the Quran. That is my take
Brother to follow Quran perfectly you will have to go whom quran come upon i mean messenger, allah teach to messenger prayes like how , stop making foolish your followers
Apostolic Christians meaning Catholics or Armenian christians Coptic Christians Oriental orthodox Eastern Orthodox Church of the East and Greek Orthodox I'll pray three times a day.
@@thesignsofgodareamongyou8306 if you were catholic you know they have three Mass a day morning Mass noon mass night Mass they go with the three prayer times you weren't a practicing Catholic if you were catholic.
@@TheJackjack Pretty sure there’s nothing like praying 3 times a day in the bible so either way its a innovation like alot of the bible itself, you said I wasn’t a practising catholic, that itself shows that you are ignorant and arrogant, you don’t even know me and you are quick to judge, i went church almost every sunday and not once did the priest mention anything about praying 3 times a day, i was babtised, I finished communion, i went bible studies guess what no 3 prayers mentioned.
I just did some quick research on this and it is a mess, it seems like there are sects inside of the sect itself, the prayer days vary from 1 times a day to 7 times day, i guess your group of catholics subscribe to the idea of praying 3 times a day, so it’s a bit like the sunni muslims inventing the idea that God asked them to pray 5 times when in fact He never said to pray specifically 5 times, except the sunni “muslims” actually do have tradition book called hadith which makes it understandable why they pray 5 times a day, catholics can do the same with the bible which doesn’t specifically tell them how many times to pray but there are passages such as in psalms which one can pick out to create a tradition based on the passage to pray 3 times a day but that is in no way a command from the bible to pray 3 times a day. PS You also got the reason I’m a ex catholic wrong, the reason why I’m a ex catholic is because i studied the bible and i came to know from research that it is extremely unreliable and contradictory therefore cannot possible be from The God, Lord of all Creation. Peace.
اسلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته I just came across your video. One must keep in mind that prophet’s job is to help the people to connect with their creator. Although I don’t agree with all Ahadiths but we mustn’t throw the baby out with the bath water. You have shed some light partially the meaning of ص ل و but didn’t explain further down on Lanes lexicon that mentioned the words prayer and divine worshiping action. Meanwhile you fail to point out that Arabic words often have a wider rays of spectrum. Like example is the word رب no translation can do full justice in its true meaning In any case one must follow his messenger PBUH and what he did. Within limits im Allah’s command. And there is no doubt about how/many prayers prophet PBUH offered. This topic is vast and one can point out both Quranic and authentic logical Ahadiths throughout islamic texts. Please try not to promote to disregard the teachings and the action of Mohamed Ibn Abdullah ibn abdulMutalib our beloved prophet PBUH whom we love and cherish as the best of all mankind.
All stories of Sunnah and Hadith are Fabricated tales. No Rituals in Quran. Quran tells in 2:177 that Rituals are not a Good deed but Good deed is Philanthropy. Have you read whole Quran? You never. Quran makes very clear in following verses that Duty assigned to Rasool by God was NO MORE than to deliver Quran clearly. This is why: Rasool and all his companions left behind only written Quran; not Sunnah not hadiths. 39:41, 6:107, 29:18, 5:92, 5:99, 3:20, 24:54, 42:6, 42:48, 64:12, 16:64, 2:213, 39:41, 18:110, 28:56, 72:21, 2:272, 48:2, 27:92, 50:45. 12:111, 16:89, 17:12, 6:114, 10:15, 6:19, 13:40, 3:80, 75:19 Meaning of following Messenger is to follow that Book which he left behind for us and that is ONLY Quran 6:19, 10:15, 6:114, 28:85 قُلْ أَىُّ شَىْءٍ أَكْبَرُ شَهَـٰدَةً قُلِ ٱللَّهُ شَهِيدٌۢ بَيْنِى وَبَيْنَكُمْ وَأُوحِىَ إِلَىَّ هَـٰذَا ٱلْقُرْءَانُ لِأُنذِرَكُم بِهِۦ وَمَنۢ بَلَغَ أَئِنَّكُمْ لَتَشْهَدُونَ أَنَّ مَعَ ٱللَّهِ ءَالِهَةً أُخْرَىٰ قُل لَّآ أَشْهَدُ قُلْ إِنَّمَا هُوَ إِلَـٰهٌ وَٰحِدٌ وَإِنَّنِى بَرِىٓءٌ مِّمَّا تُشْرِكُونَ
People who think they are clever, and understand the Quran better than the Prophet Muhammad (Sallallahu alaihe wa sallam) are people who have gone astray.
Prophet left for you only written Quran. So if you want to relate any thing with Prophet; talk only from Quran; NOT FROM FABRICATED BOOKS which were forged after the death of Prophet
quran is GOD's words, relayed by the prophet. we do not follow prophet's words because God himself threatened muhammad if he dares say anything beyond what God wants him to say: Move not your tongue with it, [O Muhammad], to hasten with recitation of the Qur'an. Indeed, upon Us is its collection [in your heart] and [to make possible] its recitation. So when We have recited it [through Gabriel], then follow its recitation. (Surah 75:16-18) And if Muhammad had made up about Us some [false] sayings, We would have seized him by the right hand; Then We would have cut from him the aorta. (Surah 69:44-46)
Salamu Alaykum brother/sister. I just want to sincerely advise and gently remind you that our Quran does not need support from any other book. L’Lah mentions in numerous ayat that it is a complete guide, clear, and fully explained / fully detailed. Nothing left out or omitted, and no doubt therein. Meaning salat action and everything we need to know is in there. Our Nabiyy would not of done it any differently than the way of the revelations that came straight to him. We either believe in all of the Ayat of the Kitab or we have disbelieved if we even turn away from just one Ayat. L’Lah will guide who He wills, innahu Al-Ghafourur Raheem. Don’t take any chances. Ask for quidance sincerely and be patient. Salamu Alaykum.
if you equate man made hadith with the words of Allah then you are a shirk, not a muslim, read the Quran and see chapter 7 verse 52: ,,We have given them a scripture that is fully detailed - with knowledge, guidance and mercy for the people who believe''. Chapter 39 verse 27: ,,We have cited for the people every kind of example in this Quran that they may take heed''. [2:41] And believe in what I revealed, confirming what is with you; and do not be the first to deny it; and do not exchange My revelations for a small price; and be conscious of Me "Shall I seek other than God as a source of law, when He has revealed to you this book FULLY DETAILED?" (Al Quran #6:114)
@@abdar-rahman6965 I dont need to prove it from quran because quran is not the only source. teachings and action of Muhammad SAW and quran togehter is islam
Mashallah. Otherwise why wudu? Ghusl? Face to Mecca? Why stand raise your hands, bow, and prostrate? Why return to the normal salat after being in horse ride riding away from an enemy? He is indeed misleading himself.
Peace, brother! And many thanks for your excellent video!
Please allow me one question concerning the context of 2:238. I fully agree that the context is very important. And it makes sense, what you said about 2:238 and the verses before. But you did not mention the next verse, i.e. 2:239, which belongs to the context, too. How do you understand verse 2:239 in connection with the topic of the verses before - and even after them (until 2:242)?
Several time I see verse salat involve stand, and this one involve prostrated is that not a ritual?
4:102 And when you are among them and lead them in prayer, let a group of them stand [in prayer] with you and let them carry their arms. And when they have prostrated, let them be [in position] behind you and have the other group come forward which has not [yet] prayed and let them pray with you, taking precaution and carrying their arms. Those who disbelieve wish that you would neglect your weapons and your baggage so they could come down upon you in one [single] attack. But there is no blame upon you, if you are troubled by rain or are ill, for putting down your arms, but take precaution. Indeed, Allah has prepared for the disbelievers a humiliating punishment.
I follow the Quran alone. However, I pray the 5 daily prayers.
Unfortunately, many Quran only Muslims have become just as extreme as many traditional Muslims. They have become anti-tradition. The purpose of following the Quran alone is to liberate people from the superstitions, and other bad things that where the result of the hadiths as well as restoring the honor of the prophet Muhammad's reputation which has been slandered by hadiths. It was not to undermine the good traditions such as prayer, fasting and charity.
It would be respectful to acknowledge the work of Sam Gerrans (Quranite) and using his translation for this presentation. Sam does a much better job of explaining this as he actually did the work.
Islam is not a religion. It’s a deen (dept)
Exactly. And majority which follows their Clerics blindly; does not understand this very Important Point which you have mentioned
Excellent 👍
Tellas quranic centric uou sed that no ritual in quran wat e bout sura 5 vers1 bers2 its wan word ther its men ritual
@@avnisekiraqqa3365 you have bias approach.
Please read the context and apply it to the message of the Qur’an as a whole.
Its not easy, believe me I know. It took me over 2 years to learn how to study the Qur’an without preconceived notions.
@@adnandizdarevic6989 indeed, studying the Quran having removed preconceived notions and confirmation bias is indeed a big challenge.
If Quran by itself is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
Excellent analysis.
The translators of the Quran, have done a great injustice to the Quran. They, as far as I can see have brought in Christian concepts and used those to translate Quranic Arabic!
th-cam.com/video/_cAB-tm-u9M/w-d-xo.html
Please comment below if you need me to cover any verse related to Salat or post your questions below. Thank you.
Can salat mean Contact
Salat is one of the most important parts of Islam, and without it, a great part of Islam disappears. Unfortunately you dismantled it.
Brother you nicely explain. But it will be fulful if you please explain the ayah no. 2:239 & 4:102.
Near the conclusion of the video, you mentioned that people have devised their own ways to perform Salat. Could you please elaborate on this? Are you suggesting that individuals have created the rituals of Namaj themselves? Isn't it Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) who taught us the proper method of performing Salat? Could you clarify this point?"
It’s not a contradiction to understand salaat as duty and prayer at the same time.
Selam, thank you for the video sir. Can you explain Soera 5:6 about the wudu before ‘the duty’ . Why must we wash certain parts before upholding a duty, staying closely to gods rules ? 🙏
Wsalaam. I have this topic already on my list. Thanks. Will be making a video soon .
And what about 17:101 ? Please explain also 🙏 may Allah bless you
Hi
IMHO the Qur’an does not deal with such trivial things as washing the body or what one may or may not eat. Religions deals with such things.
The Qur’an addresses to the rational mind that already know what is personal hygiene. You dont need to learn such mind how to wash your face.
The purpose of the Qur’an is to increase the moral values and encourage the recipient of the message to do researches, study the laws and apply the results to his own benefits.
In order to actually understand certain message, one must translate each word and analyze/apply the contextual value of the verse or group of verses.
Taking this into account one could conclude that the transmitter of this message wants to encourage the participants to clean their minds and give the message a chance judging by the facts, non-bias approach. And if there is an obstacle it must be resolved rationally for the benefit ot both the individual and the community. This vers also, like the entire Qur’an, promotes common sense and logical reasoning. And that is one of the main features of SunatullAllah.
Regards
@@adnandizdarevic6989 Hi, Quran does Literally ! deals with “details” like washing some parts of the body, what is forbidden to eat and a lot of other “ldetails “… ??? 🙏
@@semracalik3040 why would something be created at all if it is forbidden to consume?
why do you think pork is forbidden? I emphasize again that in my opinion, the Qur'an does not speak of this. Translation is manipulated
How would do you washing before Salat sessions?
Primary salat of man is to serve god alone..ablution in koran is like baptism in christinaty..if u sincerely want to approach the duty from now on (ie to serve god alone) then fist clean ur self and dont be int0xicated meaning u know what u r saying(ie u r in ur mind)
U can also check this video out
th-cam.com/video/3C0Nq1vhh6w/w-d-xo.html
Example: Salat means: also Ijtamah of Salat like Ijtamah of Friday. Before joining that Ijtamah/Meeting, do Wudhu or Ghusal if needed 5:6
please can you check surah an-Amal 27 Aya 7 and al Qasas 28 Aya 29 (تصطلون ) this is also salat check lisan al arab dictionary
👍gr8 vid so informative. Thank you brother
Thank you.
Fabulous work.
Quranic word Salat wrongly translated as Namaz as Persians word resulting misguidance and keeping us away from our duty to Allah and serving humanity. Salat is system where the whole Deen Islam revolves. Namaz rituals may be a smallest component of Salat System but shouldn't be done as Zorestranians Rituals.
You are correct. Muslim are in dilema !
You have copied Shabbir or G A Perwaiz. Both were WRONG 100% on this point. Namaz rituals are NEVER component of Salat. Namaz Rituals is that IDOL Worship in which Sunni and Shia has converted Kaaba into an Idol, and they prostrate to that Idol in five Namaz rituals which were imported from Zoroastrians, and then were validated through forgery of hadith of Miraj-Buraq. *Verse 2:177 tells that Rituals facing Qibla are NOT GOOD DEED. Several verses like 2:115, 57:4, **50:16** tell that God is Omnipresent. That means: God is not confined to any Cube or to any specific direction. All directions belong to Him. Therefore; His Omnipresence, makes all Physical directional rituals NULL AND VOID*
5 daily Rituals = Pure Idol Worship = Shirk 100%
@@abdar-rahman6965 No, the timing of their prayer is zoroastrianism. You can search up 5 duhs or prayers of Zoroastrianism. The physical movements is not zoroastrianism but Pagan Surya Namaskars.
@@abdar-rahman6965 🙏💯
Can you elaborate the fasting substitute
*Who are الْمُصَلِّينَ the Musalleen ?*
Is it those who observe the ritual prayers ?
Lets find out.
70:19 Verily, man is created with an anxious disposition.
70:20 When they are afflicted, they complain,
70:21 And when good touches him, withholding [of it],
70:22 Except الْمُصَلِّينَ the MUSALLEEN.
70:23 *Those in their SALAT (صَلَاتِهِمْ) who are CONSTANT (دَائِمُونَ).*
70:24 *And They (Al Musalleen) are those who assign a certain share of their money/property (أَمْوَالِهِمْ)*
70:25 *for the needy (لِلسَّائِلِ) and the deprived (وَالْمَحْرُومِ),*
70:26 *And (Al Musalleen are those) who acknowledge/accept as true (يُصَدِّقُونَ) the Day of Judgment (بِيَوْمِ الدِّينِ),*
70:27 *And (Al Musalleen are the ones) who are afraid of the torment of their Lord,*
70:28 the punishment of their Lord is not something for them to feel secure of,
70:29 *And (Al Musalleen are the ones) who guard (حَافِظُونَ) their modesty*
70:30 Except from their spouses or what they possess rightfully then indeed, they (are) not blameworthy,
70:31 but whoever goes beyond this is a transgressor;
70:32 *And (Al Musalleen are those) who honor their trust and promises(وَعَهْدِهِمْ),*
70:33 *And (Al Musalleen are those) who testify to what they have witnessed (شَهَادَةَ),*
70:34 *And (Al Musalleen are) those who, on their SALAT صَلَاتِهِمْ keep a guard يُحَافِظُونَ,*
70:35 such people will receive due honor in Paradise.
Further Clarification of ayahs 70:22-34
*Spending Wealth, Charity*
70:24 They (Al Musalleen) are those who assign a certain share of their money/property (Amwālihim أَمْوَالِهِمْ).
70:25 for the needy and the deprived,
Clarification :
[107:1] Do you know who rejects the deen
[107:2] Who turns away the orphan
[107:3] And does not encourage the feeding of the poor.
[107:4] So woe to those "LILMUSALLEENA" لِّلْمُصَلِّينَ
[107:5] [But] who are heedless of their "SALAT" صَلَاتِهِمْ
[11:87] They said: "O Shu'ayb, does your SALAT order you that we leave what our fathers served, or that we do not do with our money/property (Amwālina أَمْوَالِنَا) as we please? It seems only you are the compassionate, the wise!"
[9:103] Take from their money/property(Amwālihim أَمْوَالِهِمْ) a charity (صَدَقَةً) to purify them and develop them with it, and make SALAT with them; for your SALAT is a tranquility for them; and God is Hearer, Knowledgeable.
*Belief, Qualities:*
70:26 (And Musalleen are those) who acknowledge the Day of Judgment,
Clarification :
[27:3] Those who establish "SALAT" and contribute towards purification. *AND THOSE WHO ARE CERTAIN ABOUT THE LIFE-TO-COME.*
[4:162] who perform the "SALAT" diligently, and contribute towards purification, *AND BELIEVE IN ALLAH AND THE AFTERLIFE*
*Guarding Ones Modesty*
70:29 (Al Musalleen are the ones) who preserve their chastity
70:30 except from their spouses and those whom they rightfully possess [through wedlock], for which they incur no blame
Clarification :
[29:45] Recite, what has been revealed to you of the Book and establish "SALAT". *Indeed, "SALAT" prohibits immorality and wrongdoing,* and the remembrance of Allah is greater. And Allah knows that which you do.
*Fulfill Pledges, promises:*
70:32 (Al Musalleen are those) who honor their trust and promises,
Clarification :
[2:177] ...establish "SALAT", and contribute towards purification, *AND FULFILL THE PLEDGES/PROMISES MADE BY THEM.*
*Truthful Testimony*
70:33 And (Al Musalleen are those) who testify to what they have witnessed (بِشَهَادَاتِهِمْ),
Clarification :
[5:106] O you who believe, witnessing (شَهَادَةُ) shall be done if death is approaching one of you and a will is being made, by two among you who are equitable. If you have gone forth in the land, and death is approaching, then any two may suffice - if you have a doubt regarding them, then detain them after making the *SALAT,* and they will swear by God: "We will not purchase with it any price, even if it was from a near relative, *AND WE WILL NOT CONCEAL THE TESTIMONY (شَهَادَةَ)* of God, else we are of the sinners."
*Guard the Salat*
70:34 *And (Al Musalleen are) those who, on their SALAT صَلَاتِهِمْ keep a guard يُحَافِظُونَ,*
Clarification :
[6:92] And this is a Book which We have sent down, blessed, authenticating what is between his hands, and that you may warn the capital of the towns and those around it. And those who believe in the Hereafter believe in it, *AND THEY GUARD THEIR SALAT.*
Salat is not a ritual prayer.
Quran(الْقُرْآنِ) Alone(وَحْدَهُ)
Peace
Then why did the sahaba and prophets wives pray so much?
Musalleen = Who follow Divine law
Can we have a demonstration Video to have more clear example?
thanks brother.
and this is my understanding regarding Salah.
There is no ritual prayer in the Qur'an under study.
The ritual prayer times 3 or 5 a day do not match the world in which we live. There are inhabited areas in the world that do not rise or set the sun for a month and two months, it is all night or day.
The second question is what is the benefit or logic of ritual prayer. Let me simplify the subject of ritual prayer.
There are people and a king rule them , the king decided to put rules to organizes the people and puts laws and regulations for the people, so he wrote the constitution book and put everything in it.
The people took the constitution and did the following: The people took the constitution and went to the king and read the constitution upon him 3 or 5 times a day with some movements.
Is this the case with ritual prayer?
I would like you to clarify the topic regarding the timing and the logical benefit of ritual prayer.
Did we not understand the concept of Salat/prayer in the Qur’an???
The meaning of the word SALAH صلاة in the Quran mean to connect
The Fajr and Isha SALAH in this verse
﴿يا أَيُّهَا الَّذينَ آمَنوا لِيَستَأذِنكُمُ الَّذينَ مَلَكَت أَيمانُكُم وَالَّذينَ لَم يَبلُغُوا الحُلُمَ مِنكُم ثَلاثَ مَرّاتٍ مِن قَبلِ صَلاةِ الفَجرِ وَحينَ تَضَعونَ ثِيابَكُم مِنَ الظَّهيرَةِ وَمِن بَعدِ صَلاةِ العِشاءِ ثَلاثُ عَوراتٍ لَكُم لَيسَ عَلَيكُم وَلا عَلَيهِم جُناحٌ بَعدَهُنَّ طَوّافونَ عَلَيكُم بَعضُكُم عَلى بَعضٍ كَذلِكَ يُبَيِّنُ اللَّهُ لَكُمُ الآياتِ وَاللَّهُ عَليمٌ حَكيمٌ﴾
[An-Nūr: 58]
they have nothing to do with the ritual prayer, according to the context of this verse, God speaks at three periods a day for the people of the house to ask permission before entering and communicating with you, so the Salaat Alfajer صلاة الفجر mean the beginning of connecting and Salaat Alashaصلاة العشاء mean the end of connecting with the people of the house and also when you put your clothes from ALTHAHIRA الظهيرة
and the word ALTHAHIRA does not mean noon it has the meaning of get away or to disconnect and these words Alfajer الفجر, Althahira الظهيرة and Alasha العشاء have no
Relationship to night and day.
What do you think about this and what is your answer?
..........
also to know the meaning of
(اقيموا او اقم الصلاة)
(aqimuu or aqim alsalat )
establish or establish Alsalat , if we know the meaning of
( إقام )
( 'iiqam ) in the next verse the word (فَأَقامَهُ)
(wa'aqamah)
has clear meaning
﴿فَانطَلَقا حَتّى إِذا أَتَيا أَهلَ قَريَةٍ استَطعَما أَهلَها فَأَبَوا أَن يُضَيِّفوهُما فَوَجَدا فيها جِدارًا يُريدُ أَن يَنقَضَّ فَأَقامَهُ قالَ لَو شِئتَ لَاتَّخَذتَ عَلَيهِ أَجرًا﴾ [Al-Kahf: 77]
(77) So they set out, until when they came to the people of a town, they asked its people for food, but they refused to offer them hospitality. And they found therein a wall about to collapse, (فَأَقامَهُ) (So he set it up) . [Moses] said, "If you wished, you could have taken for it a payment."
(فَأَقامَهُ)
(so he set it up)
so the meaning of
(اقيموا الصلاة)
(aqimuu alsalat )
will be to set up or to correct or to improve the way of communication with Allāh by contemplating with His Book and implementing His commands,
also the meaning of
(اقيموا الصلاة)
(aqimuu alsalat )
to set up or to correct or to improve the way of communication with every human interaction between people, between the government and people, or between people and the government.
(اقيموا الصلاة)
(aqimuu alsalat )
is a continuous adjustment,set up, correction and improvement the way of communication between you and Allah and between you and people,government...
also between each other like governments and Countries.
Near the conclusion of the video, you mentioned that people have devised their own ways to perform Salat. Could you please elaborate on this? Are you suggesting that individuals have created the rituals of Namaj themselves? Isn't it Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) who taught us the proper method of performing Salat? Could you clarify this point?"
Although your explanation of the Salat according to the Quran is better than some others of similar intention, however there is something which is not quite right. It is where you wrote, "Duty as a general concept (Hope, patience, petition)
Personally, I think the English words "hope" and "faith" are incompatible with the Quran.
The English word "Hope" means a feeling of expectation and desire for a particular thing to happen but the Quran does not encourage following your desires and feelings, for example:
6:116 And if thou hast obeyed most of who are on the earth, they will cause thee to go astray from the way of God. They follow nothing but opinion and they only guess.
Faith is an irrational belief in something that is logically impossible but the Quran encourages you to always use "aqal" to reason it out.
So, obviously your "DUTY" to Allah cannot rely on your "hope" or "faith." Not if you use the Quran as the sole guide. After all there is no doubt nor crookedness in the Quran, right? The Quran also describes itself as "a clear Book!" As an example, please consider this verse:
22:31 becoming Hunafa lillah (strictly Unitarian to Allah) - not associating partners unto Him. For whoever associates partners to Allah, it is as if he has fallen from the sky and the birds snatch him or the wind blows him to far-off places.
So, if you read the Quran then would you rely on "hope" and "faith" of the birds or the wind to carry you to safety? Or, are you assured that you would fall to the ground by the pull of gravity. And, Gravity is measured by the acceleration that it gives to freely falling objects. At Earth's surface the acceleration of gravity is about 9.8 metres (32 feet) per second per second. Thus, for every second an object is in free fall, its speed increases by about 9.8 metres per second.
Another of your concepts that doesn't quite sit right by me is when you say something like, "... petition to God..."
Tell me... would you petition a God who says...
3:29 Say, “Whether you conceal what is in your hearts or reveal it, it is known to Allah. For He knows whatever is in the heavens and whatever is on the earth. And Allah is Most Capable of everything.”
Maybe you might feel like you must petition to your God... but the One True God of the Quran is already aware of what you conceal or you reveal. So, is there a need for you to still petition the All Knowing God?
salam.
Peace, Shukri Yusof!
I like your comment, but concerning your statement
"Maybe you might feel like you must petition to your God... but the One True God of the Quran is already aware of what you conceal or you reveal. So, is there a need for you to still petition the All Knowing God?"
I would like to ask you: How do you understand 2:186: "And if My servants ask Me, surely I am near, I answer the prayer of supplication ..."?
@@gunnar4230 The first part of 2:186 are explained by these 2 verses:
50:16
And certainly We created man and We know what whispers to him his soul, and We (are) nearer to him than (his) vein jugular.
56:85
And We (are) nearer to him than you but not (do) you see,
The second part is a tad more tedious because of the translation you chose, i.e. "prayer of supplication" which is totally incorrect!
Please note the Arabic for that portion of the verse is: أُجِيبُ دَعْوَةَ ٱلدَّاعِ إِذَا دَعَانِ
Please also note the root word "Dal-Ayn-Waw" is used 3 times as in:
1. دَعْوَةَ
2. الدَّاعِ
3. دَعَانِ
Basically, you could translate it to: I respond to "the call of the caller who is calling to Me."
So, that includes ALL of MANKIND, irrespective of whatever division & sub-division other humans have divided us into. Furthermore, there is NO "special way" , by way of language, ablution, ritual, mannerism etc., to place that "call" of the "caller" when that "caller" is "calling" on the One True God.
Read these 2 verses very slowly and try to understand each word:
10:22 He enables you to travel on land and sea, until-while they are sailing on ships and rejoicing in favorable winds-a storm arrives, and waves come towards them from all directions, so that you think you are facing death. Then they cry out to God in all sincerity, claiming faith in Him alone: "If You save us from this, We will be truly thankful!"
10:23 Once He has saved them, they return to being corruptive on earth in defiance to the Truth. People! All your outrageous deeds will be counted against you; your enjoyment is limited to life in this world. Then you will return to Us, and We will confront you with everything You have done.
Actually, you could even be travelling on an airplane and you go through turbulence or the plane is trying to land during a raging storm. Do you "call out to your God?"
Yes, we, all mankind, do it regardless of our preferred religion... did you use any special way to "petition" your God? Was it with any specific words, or language? or ritual? or just something instantaneous that goes on in your heart?
And, when we land... safely... each and everyone of us tend to assume our personal God has answered our "Du'aaa" or perhaps the skill of the pilots/traffic air controller, or...
But... what about all the other passengers?
There are other verses that speak about "God answering your call/du'aa/prayers," of course. Go read them in the Quran.
peace.
@@shukriyusof2104 Peace and many thanks for your detailed feedback!
I agree with you. But note that the word دعا has many meanings - according to the context. It includes supplication, too.:
In 1:5 we ask for help نستعين. And the following two verses 6 and 7 are supplications, too - in my view. Furthermore, we find in the Quran supplications, for example in 2:286.
Therefore, I agree with your remarks in your answer to me. But on the other hand, I also understand from the Quran, that Allah invites us to supplicate and to ask Him. And I mean with "us" all of mankind.
Peace and regards!
@@gunnar4230 Yes, you can give many meanings to a foreign word but that foreign word only has one original meaning.
Okay, ley us agree that "Du'aa" also includes supplication.
Now, tell me where does the Quran give details on how to perform this ritualistic supplication that the revered religious scholars have formulated for their blind followers?
It is akin to the "Salat," isn't it?
They have invented it as a ritual prayer but that is NOT what the Quran says!
The same with "du'aa" ... they, the Sectarians, have invented the ritualistic supplication complete with rituals and chants to go along with it...
But that is NOT what the Quran says!
Anyway, once you understand who & what God is... then... every call/wish/supplication/request/prayer you make/say/do is to Allah... and, you don't need to give it any special terminology or attach repetitive superstitious rituals complete with special chants repeated at certain times, on certain nights, during certain months... you know where I am going with this, right?
Just keep reading the Quran and it will come to you... verily, it is Allah who teaches you the Quran.
salam.
Salam.
How do you explain this verse of Salah is not Ritual prayer?
4:102] When you are with them, and lead the Contact Prayer (Salat) for them, let some of you stand guard; let them hold their weapons, and let them stand behind you as you prostrate. Then, let the other group that has not prayed take their turn praying with you, while the others stand guard and hold their weapons. Those who disbelieved wish to see you neglect your weapons and your equipment, in order to attack you once and for all. You commit no error, if you are hampered by rain or injury, by putting down your weapons, so long as you remain alert. GOD has prepared for the disbelievers a shameful retribution.
Context:muslims are doing jihad/rescue mission(ie to save/rescue believer from wrongdoers)
Now they r in enemy and negotiating
"And when you are among them(i.e enemy), uphold thou the duty for them(i.e beievers u came to save); then let there stand a number of them(i.e enemy)with you, and let them take their arms; then when they have submitted(believers to u), let them(i.e believers) be behind you and let another number come(i.e enemy) that has not performed the duty(i.e not handed you the believer captives), and let them perform the duty with you(i.e hand you the believers); and let them take their precautions and their arms. (Those who ignore warning(aladina kafaru) wish that you would neglect your arms and your equipment, so they might assault you in a single assault; but you do no wrong if there is a hindrance to you from rain or you are sick, that you lay aside your arms; but take your precautions: God has prepared for the false claimers of guidance a humiliating punishment.)
(4:102)
@@mewying5184 but this doesn’t match with what he said. It talked about prayer and you’re talking about something else…
This is praying in group in which others are on guard to prevent from attacking them while praying is in progress. When the first group did the last prostration, they move out allowing the other group to come in and perform the same until all is done praying. In other words, there is no limit in the rakaats of every salat (prayer) you are doing (17:107-111)
@@Anonymous-yw7uj you are precisely right. This talks about praying (salat) and not other things.
How do you explain this verse of Salah means Ritual prayer?
Number of Rakat? Salat has no any relation with Rituals=Idol Worship
I am Quran only Muslim looking for community! Where do I find study groups I can join!
You can’t they don’t exist because Allah is with the Muslims not the Quran onlys
@@onnixchaney8797 ❤️🔥
@@onnixchaney8797🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@onnixchaney8797 Allah literally said the majority is most likely wrong.
@@JoesphTalin And his messenger said my ummah will not gather on misguidance
I agree with some of your explanation about Solat, but the thing is, you have not covered the ONE NOUN in Q2:125. God did give the RITUAL CLEARLY in many ayah. the first and foremost is in Q2:125. Also i totally agree that the spiritual is more important (understanding the solat) but the RITUAL is there.
it is explained in stages, and BY ALLAH, I have studied it, the ritual first step is in Q2:125. That is the simplest explanation of HOW to pray. It covers ALL THE RITUAL MOVEMENT of THE SOLAT and IT IS tightly connected to THE RITUAL of Ibraheem. The SOLAT is not INVENTED by people after Prophet Ahmad, but GOD had made a COVENANT with IBRAHEEM, hence in the context of Ibraheem, he was the APPOINTED as AN IMAM for ALL THE PEOPLE or MANKIND. These are the MANASIK of Millat Ibraheem. The Hajj, The Sa'i, and The Qurban and THE SOLAT.
if you look and study the word solat in Quran, the last step is in SURAH Al-ISRA. the last five verse. It clarifies how to pray. It is only TWO rakaat every time.
This is what i found in the Quran about the RITUAL solat.
1. Q2:125 - The way to pray (Examples of praying / standing, bowing and prostration)
2. Q4:43 - The prohibition of prayer (you cant do the ritual if you DON'T KNOW WHAT YOU SAY) - its not general duties, it is about SAYING things to GOD.
3. Q5:6 - The preparation (this in my view does not fit the 'duty', because its a RITUAL thing to wash your face before prayer.
4. Q11:114 - Time of Prayers (this also could not fit the generic meaning of 'duties', cause your "duties" are not only to be establish at two ends of the DAY (fajr and maghrib).
5. Q17:78 - Explain in detail of Maghrib time (its the same with fajar / twilight)
6. Q17:79 - The Nafilah (Isya prayer) is the additional prayer
7. Q17:110 - The tone of prayer. if you fit in the duties, then the commanders of armies could not perform their duties. so this is ritual solat.
the last five ayah of surah Al-Isra, in reverse from Q17:111, 110, 109, 108 and 107 is confirming the RITUAL at Q2:125 you see physically from the MAQAM of Ibraheem.
Q17:111 - Sayings before you do the TAKBIR.
Q17:110 - Calling of GOD's Name (ArRahman) which He taught us the ALFATIHAH as the oft-repeated (or twice)
Q17:109 - The Bowing (rukuk - please not that it does not mentioned about SUJUD in this ayah)
Q17:108 - Saying in between the Rukuk and SUJUD
Q17:107 - Then the SUJUD.
The last part is THE key for our SUJUD. God is telling us that THOSE before us, whenever the ayah is recited THEY BOW DOWN in SUJUD!!. so that is what THE RITUAL SOLAT. cause every time you recite Al-Fatihah, GOD is communicating to you INSTANTLY thru HIS MESSENGER when you read The READING. then after that, YOU BOW and SUJUD.
Repeating the second rakaah, Alfatihah, then GOD speaking to you, LITERALLY HIS WORD is RECITED upon you!! then you fall down in bowing then SUJUD!!
notice that, THERE IS ONLY TWO rakaah of any solat (with audible recitation), whether it is in Fajr, Maghrib, or Isya. The additional rakaat that is silenced, im quite sure it was added later. The Zuhr and Asr prayer are NOT included. Im not saying its wrong but I dont pray Zuhr and Asr. I leave GOD to judge those who pray Zuhr and Asr.
so, to say it is duties, im not against it. But if you are saying that it is NOT RITUAL and the ritual was "invented", well i think you are wrong. Im very sure it IS ALSO ritual. May Allah Guide us all.
further more, what is your DUTIES that you say of in FAJR and ISYA?? in Q24:58??? waking up?? brushing your teeth? in fajr?? its not generic. what is your duties after ISYA? when is ISYA?? sleeping is a duties? so, the AURAT is not speaking about following closely before FAJR?? you were sleeping. When you put in "duties" it becomes so vague. WHAT are you duties spesifically BEFORE FAJR??
i dont think the explanation of "following closely" or "duties" fit in the "aurat". Fajr time is the TWILIGHT.. hence it is when you woke up. its your PERSONAL TIME not duties. same thing afte ISYA.. what are the duties.
the Quran is consistent, but your are forcing THE MEANING of SOLAT as ONE MEANING. EVERY one knows, one word could be used in many ways, for instance THE HAND.. does GOD say to MUSA, what is in your hand means physical hand?? what then when GOD say BY HIS HAND??? is THAT NOT CONSISTENT???
you see, YOUR DEFINITION of CONSISTENT is actually FLAWED. so it is not just DUTIES.. it is also RITUAL.
@@kyedean9698 Everything you wrote has already been answered. All you need do is to search the YT channels.
Anyway, to cut to the chase, your whole argument falls flat when you just understand ONE basic point, and that is:
#1. What is the Quran?
If you believe that the Quran is a book of magical divine chants then, you would think that "whenever the ayah is recited THEY BOW DOWN in SUJUD!!..."
And, by SUJUD who have been schooled to go down on all 4s with your forehead firmly pressed to the ground.
Now ask yourself, do they, and you of course, go down on all 4s with their forehead firmly pressed to the ground EACH & EVERY time they hear the aya being recited to them?
Do you understand the whole Quran? Do the 1.2billion Sunnis/Shiites etc., understand what is being recited to them when they go down on all 4s with the forehead firmly pressed to the ground?
What if you are in a state of the man-invented "ceremonial impurity" and you hear the Quran being recited to you, do you go down on all 4s with your forehead firmly pressed to the ground while facing a stone idol in a town the latter day Arabs have named Makkah?
When Mo Salah scores a goal he goes down on all 4s with his forehead firmly pressed to the ground... does he hear the Quran being recited to him? Or, is he facing the stone idol in the Arabian desert while he goes down on all 4s with his forehead firmly pressed to the ground?
It all sounds ridiculously silly when you say and describe the rituals that you do in everyday language, doesn't it?
But, that is what you get when you follow the footsteps of the Satan.
salam.
@@shukriyusof2104 "Everything you WROTE has already been ANSWERED???" LOL! nothing has been answered by YT channels. AHAHAHAHAH.. again YT channels??? what effing channels answered my questions?? you dont know??? and without SHAME you ask me to search YT Channels without giving any specifics??? ahahahhaha.. ARE YOU DUMB???
1. My argument falls flat??? what??? which argument?? are you trying to BULK-UP all my arguments and renders it as "FLAT" by your stupid hashtag question???
2. I DONT BELIEVE QURAN as a BOOK of MAGICAL divine, thats your stupid assumption on other people.
3. what 4S??? care to explain? please dont quote the stupid bukhari or any of the six books hadeeth. IT IS NOT RELEVANT.
4. "Everytime ayah is being recited" it is CLEAR to me, it is talking about SOLAT. there are 84 ayah containing the word SOLAT akhi. Please study them first before jumping in and putting yourself as a person who know much more about the Quran than me.
5. Do I understand the whole QURAN??? who does? you??? ahahahhahaha??? by your question I ALREADY KNOW u have not studied anything about AlQuran.
6. FOOTBALL is not part of the ritual SALAT, are you STUPID?? what does it have anything to do with the RITUAL SOLAT???
7. THE RITUALS are from IBRAHEEM. "Take from the MAQAM of IBRAHEEM as musolla / place of worship (example of how to PRAY). Q2:125
I may have been following the footsteps of SATAN, I can admit that. Im not infallible. YOU on the other hand, are not following satan, but SATANS follows you. you ARROGANT SOB.
Walaikum salam.
The primary meaning of sujud is submit second meaning to prostrate the primary meaning of ruku is humility second meaning is to bend. There is most likely no ritual prayer in the Quran.
@@Queen-kz4zo Do u fall down according to 17:107 with Chin ? Allah said Lil Azkan ?
Selam sir, can you also do a video about ‘ ruh’ . We were told that we have a body and an eternal soul that Allah blew of his own by the creation of Adam. ? 🙏
Subscribed :)
May Allah guide you and us insallah
Wsalaam. Noted. Thank you.
Ruh means Message or Messenger.
@@moedot7 selam, how does that fit in Isra 85 ? Thank you 🙏
@@semracalik3040 I would say it's referring to the evidence-based knowledge of the Quran. Allah has made accessible to THEM of it's knowledge, very little.
I noticed u r not answering questions of ur listeners, my question remain unanswered. I want to confirm how many obligatory prayers do we perform. D Sunni has 5obligatory & many nawafil prayers. Some say Wusta s a night prayer about an hour after isha. Actually i'm confused, what i understood, f not found in d Qur-an s not from God, f not from Allah who will reward in hereafter of ds Sunni's dhuhur, asar, & maghrib salawat, will Allah reward ds though not included in His legislation? Pls. Reply.
Peace brother. Thank you for this video and well done for your research. I know about the effort it takes to undertake the research and then present it. I have one question which I was unable to be clear about from your research:
You focus quite heavily on how al-salaat means "duty" but then you also suggest that it means to "petition" God. It wasn't clear to me where in the Quran it suggested that al-salaat means to "petition" God.
Would appreciate some clarity.
Peace be upon you, brother 🙏
Munib
Petition is to request, ask Allah for something.
Judging by the beginning of the video it looks like you got your ideas from Sam Gerrans, I recommend his translation by the way.
Duty seems to fit best all contexts but where God says salla that doesn’t seem like duty for example God says “They did not Salla” not sure how duty fits there but then again you could say salla means performing your duty but it just seems odd to me that salla 1 arabic word would be translated like that.
Peace
Yes. Full credit to Sam. He has done a superb job in translating The Quran. I have it in the description also. My goal is try to co continue research as learning is a journey. Regards.
Hello, do you not see how pretenders (ie Quran only research) agree with each other like it reaffirms their ego. Do you not see they act like hyenas around a lion (the lion is you). You are correct 'They did not salla (duty)'. Salat does not mean duty. There is no pray in the so called Qu'ran (it's not a noun). God does not need anyones pray. How can a creator ask for something (like for example your duty) when he has everything and owns everything. It doesn't make sense. Salat simple means follow, which is independent and dependent on the individual and his profession. So a police officers salat is to uphold law, a lawyers salat is to uphold human rights and if we salat (follow) what is the teachings in this book which is God's laws, which in turn is God's natural law. Someone who sallah thus follows God's natural law is an individual who is a sovereign man.
@@thebookwithnotitle7687 excellent
Salla I think means "turn towards (God's guided direction/the guidance to follow closely/duties). There is a verse that describes it as an antonym of "turning away".
@@thebookwithnotitle7687 explain what kaba is.
Brother in VERSE 2-125 ALLAH tells us to establish pray from the MUSSALLHA of IBRAHIM which is located in MECCA, and this pray was established in the time of IBRAHIM. So, ALLAH goes further than explaining the pray format 'he tells us where to get this format to witness the pray. The prophet MUHAMAD was told to follow the religion of IBRAHIM. The standing place of IBRAHIM is not only one monotheism but also a physical place in masjid al-haram. Because all prophets followed one monotheism. 'This is where many people are in difference amongst the QURAN alone followers 'This five pray format was happing since the time of IBRAHIM. Please look into this and reply back to me.
Didn't moses and Jesus follow Abraham, why they only pray 3 times a day ?
In torah and gospel it's only find 3 times prayer ,Qur'an also only mentioned 3 name prayer
@@zullyfeehilly8968 The MUSSLLAH of IBRAHIM which is located in MECCAH is for all times and we are told to get our pray from there 2-125.. Also, in 17-78 ALLAH tells us to establish SALAH pray at the declining of the sun. The sun starts declining at noon 12-00 clock afternoon which will cover the ZAUHIR and MAGRIB..If ALLAH tells you to pray before sunset and before sunrise and at night. Then which SALAH are we meant to do in 17-78 'so brother after studying and studying i have come to know from 2-125 that the SALAH format which is happening in MUSSALH of IBRAHIM the standing place of IBRAHIM is for all times. Where we can witness the pray. Also, MUHAMAD SHIEK the famous QURAN alone scholar and other QURAN alone SUBMITTERS PROSPECT channel are doing the five prays because QURAN is telling us. i myself used to do three prays but since i have been told by the verses i corrected myself. We do not want to be like the mainstream sects 'who do opposite from QURAN. Because if we do not change are ways, we be doing what mainstream sects do. Rejecting the verses, we have to correct our self. Because the five pray format is not found anywhere in HADITH start to finish. Mainstream are lying about the prophet getting prays from the trip to heaven. This five prays format is from God the pray when you stand behind imam. But the fake SUNNAH pray is never behind imam. And all imam anywhere around the world will only recite the verses of God loud. But when you're in RAKOOR sitting down you only say the shahada from QURAN and never say Muhamad or Ibrahim in your pray. The pray is only for God. And when you have finished then pray for the prophets.
@@MuslimforAllah. Is Quran depends on hadith??
VERSE 2-125 NEVER tells us to establish pray=Ritual from the MUSSALLHA of IBRAHIM but VERSE 2-125 tells us to deliver Divine Message from the MUSSALLHA of IBRAHIM
وَٱتَّخِذُوا۟ مِن مَّقَامِ إِبْرَٰهِـۧمَ مُصَلًّى
Musalla=The place from where Divine Message is dilivered
@@abdar-rahman6965
Every command from Allah is continuously observed in real-time on the earthly plane, and this perpetual witnessing remains unalterable. The words of Allah, firmly embedded in the world, cannot be changed. We are instructed to "TAKE" from the sacred space where Ibrahim once stood-the Place of Contact/Prayer, where the Imam leads the congregation in prayer. Don't put your interpretation, just believe in the words of Allah by observing.🙏
This is a wrong interpretation. Where is the context of Hadith, they explanation by Prophet? Are you claiming you are a Prophet? Stop this nonsense.
How many obligatory salat do u perform in a day?
3
Don't fall for this kufr.
5 are cited in quran
The ones that say 3 dont account all verses
@@rubencaballerollamas2176please indicate the verses
I have been struggling to have a clear understanding of what you are trying to say, I don't agree with your description of Salat as following something closely., Salat is descriptive exercise clearly explained in the Quran.
in Q22v26 Allah told Ibrahim to prepare His house (Kaaba) for those that will circle round it, that will STAND, KNEEL AND PROSTRATE IN WORHIP (SALAT).
Salat means to Stand (Qiyam), Kneel(Rukuh) Prostrate (Suju).
Allah went further to explain that you wash part of your body before approach Salat. Q5v6
Q28v45 Recite part of Quran to establish Salat.
Q17v78 Dont shout during your Salat (While reciting Quran) or be silent but seek a middle course.
Q17v79, End your Salat with Alhamdulilah, not by saying Salam. Alaykum to Left & Right.
If Salat means follow closely are you going to do Wudu before you start following ????
Its misleading to say Salat is not a Ritual exercise but to follow closely.
There are more evidences in the Quran that shows that Salat is a Ritual Prayer.
and there are only 3 Salat in the Quran and not 5, namely Fajir, Ishai, Wustah.
Salam
Brother Salamoon Alaikum. Can you kindly give the Quranic reference where it is said 'end your salat saying Alhamdulillah '. Thank you
@@deanfbs6968 Read Q 17v110 Where Allah (SWT) is telling us about Solat, "Dont shout while reading Quran in your Solat nor be silent but seek a middle course"
in the next verse Q17v111 and say Alhamdulilah" that has begotten no son.....etc. You end it by giving praise to Allah.
Even Allah taught us to give thanks after eating Q2v172. Praise is given to Allah at end of everything, That is the tradition of Allah.
There is no greeting of angel on the left and right in the Quran. Solat is for Allah alone, no greeting or mentioning of anyone's along with Allah Q72v18.
Salam
Quran is CONSISTENT, does not mean SOLAT is all DUTIES. thats your interpretation of CONSISTENT.
What is Quran only? Never heard about this.
they are Kaafir who rejects prophet Muhammad SAW and follow their own desires
Sola means you read Quran and understand.
True
Yes Dr eloborate further ...
Eg 17:110
Noted.
@@QuranAlone so?
Musalmam jo kahen. Mera manna hai ke Allah ka zikr aur ebadat tanhayi mein karni chahiye. Masjid mein nahi. Kiyonke wahan use Masjid walon ka firqa aur tareeqa anna hoga.
aapake maan se islam nhi chalta. islam nabi SAW ke kehne aur unke tareeqe se chalta hai. Firqa m kon jaane bol rha h. sirf quran aur sunnat ko folloow karo.Masjid m namaaz padhna compulsory h muslim men ke liye
Hi
It would be interesting to know how many times we should pray according to Quran only. My religious teacher came to the conclusion that there are 3 prayer times mentioned: fajr, maghrib and isha..
Pozdrav
Ako smijem reci, problem je sto se prilazi odredjenim temama kao da vec znamo nesto o njima.
Meni je dugo trebalo da se rijesim toga i da pridjem Kuranu kao poruci o kojoj ne znam apsolutno nista. I stvarno je tesko.
Preporucio bih ti da citas kao knjigu o kojoj ne znas nista, drzis se konteksta i onda polako pocinjes obradjivati odredjene teme na osnovu tog konteksta.
@@adnandizdarevic6989
Hvala Bogu sto sam naisla na nekoga sa nasih prostora ko razmislja na slican nacin kao i ja. Tek kada sam pristupila Kur'anu kao neko ko nema nikakvog znanja o religiji i pocela da ga citam kao da ga citam prvi put, dobila sam odgovore na neka dotadasnja pitanja koja su kod nas tabu tema.
There are 3 prayers namely:
1. Fajr
2. Wusta
3. Isha
@@adnandizdarevic6989 Trenutno ne poznajem nijednu osobu sa balkana koja vjeruje samo u Qur'an, a ne u hadise, kako se mogu upoznati?
@@SamraBosna268.
Interesting you're using Sam Gerran's translation of the Quran. I thought even many Quranists rejected him.
Truth is: Sam Gerran's translation carries tons of tampering like we see in all other translations too
Salah is salah. We recite the quran. Not sure what this is about?
salat comes from sila wich means contact... silatrahim contact with family
Different connotations of word Salat have slightly different meaning in Quran which also depends on the context. Salat Wusta is "Duty about Family=Central duty". When verse 2:177 tells that Rituals are not a Good deed; then after saying so, about duties; this verse talks first of all about services to family/relatives
وَءَاتَى ٱلْمَالَ عَلَىٰ حُبِّهِۦ ذَوِى ٱلْقُرْبَىٰ
Salat >> Establish Divine System; Stick to Divine law; Dua, Mindfulness of God/meditation upon God, to support others, Meetings/Ijtamah of Salat like Friday and like in 4:102 meetings about War strategy. Salat has NO ANY RELATION WITH RITUALS.
Good deed=Philanthropy; NOT RITUALS >> 2:177
I thought it was going to be shown start to finish practically
Can you explain the versus in Surah 9.5 only from Quran? Without Hadith you Quran only people should be massacring the world
Read the second half of 9:5 and read 9:6. It’s clear these verses are based on historical context but even back then the didn’t just kill everyone. It’s the Hadith that says Islam spread by the sword
Quranic internal context shows: 9:5 is relevant to defensive war, and Quran permits war only in defense 2:190 or to free oppressed people from an Oppressor 4:75
During Salat, Why do they greet the Prophet (S) as if he were sitting right in front of us? Salat is supposed to neither loud or too soft but a middle tone is advised. Why do we then go through Salat quietly during two Salats in the Masjid and during all at home? We are not supposed to attend Salat if our minds are messed up and we don’t know what we are saying. Other than Arabs most Muslims recite memorized verses of the Quran and not even aware what they mean!
Seems to me during the life of the Prophet, Salat sessions were held where Quran would be shared. In those days they did not have printed Qurans all over besides Quran was being revealed in stages and shared with the community.
Regarding the Salat sessions of the Mushriks, we are told there is a lot of whistling and clapping (but no substance)!
Yes there was no internet, tv, phones, social media and stuff. So they made salat sessions to spread the message. They read and learned the Quran. That is my take
Brother to follow Quran perfectly you will have to go whom quran come upon i mean messenger, allah teach to messenger prayes like how , stop making foolish your followers
Get to straight point instead of talking in circles
Apostolic Christians meaning Catholics or Armenian christians Coptic Christians Oriental orthodox Eastern Orthodox Church of the East and Greek Orthodox I'll pray three times a day.
Not sure if that’s true, im a ex catholic and never heard or seen anyone praying 3 times a day we went church once every sunday.
@@thesignsofgodareamongyou8306 that's why your ex Catholic
@@thesignsofgodareamongyou8306 if you were catholic you know they have three Mass a day morning Mass noon mass night Mass they go with the three prayer times you weren't a practicing Catholic if you were catholic.
@@TheJackjack
Pretty sure there’s nothing like praying 3 times a day in the bible so either way its a innovation like alot of the bible itself, you said I wasn’t a practising catholic, that itself shows that you are ignorant and arrogant, you don’t even know me and you are quick to judge, i went church almost every sunday and not once did the priest mention anything about praying 3 times a day, i was babtised, I finished communion, i went bible studies guess what no 3 prayers mentioned.
I just did some quick research on this and it is a mess, it seems like there are sects inside of the sect itself, the prayer days vary from 1 times a day to 7 times day, i guess your group of catholics subscribe to the idea of praying 3 times a day, so it’s a bit like the sunni muslims inventing the idea that God asked them to pray 5 times when in fact He never said to pray specifically 5 times, except the sunni “muslims” actually do have tradition book called hadith which makes it understandable why they pray 5 times a day, catholics can do the same with the bible which doesn’t specifically tell them how many times to pray but there are passages such as in psalms which one can pick out to create a tradition based on the passage to pray 3 times a day but that is in no way a command from the bible to pray 3 times a day.
PS You also got the reason I’m a ex catholic wrong, the reason why I’m a ex catholic is because i studied the bible and i came to know from research that it is extremely unreliable and contradictory therefore cannot possible be from The God, Lord of all Creation.
Peace.
All hullabaloo…..This knowledge sounds interesting to the traumatized in religion, but only leads to insanity
What is your ijaza?
اسلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
I just came across your video. One must keep in mind that prophet’s job is to help the people to connect with their creator. Although I don’t agree with all Ahadiths but we mustn’t throw the baby out with the bath water.
You have shed some light partially the meaning of ص ل و but didn’t explain further down on Lanes lexicon that mentioned the words prayer and divine worshiping action.
Meanwhile you fail to point out that Arabic words often have a wider rays of spectrum.
Like example is the word رب no translation can do full justice in its true meaning
In any case one must follow his messenger PBUH and what he did. Within limits im Allah’s command. And there is no doubt about how/many prayers prophet PBUH offered.
This topic is vast and one can point out both Quranic and authentic logical Ahadiths throughout islamic texts.
Please try not to promote to disregard the teachings and the action of Mohamed Ibn Abdullah ibn abdulMutalib our beloved prophet PBUH whom we love and cherish as the best of all mankind.
All stories of Sunnah and Hadith are Fabricated tales. No Rituals in Quran. Quran tells in 2:177 that Rituals are not a Good deed but Good deed is Philanthropy. Have you read whole Quran? You never. Quran makes very clear in following verses that Duty assigned to Rasool by God was NO MORE than to deliver Quran clearly. This is why: Rasool and all his companions left behind only written Quran; not Sunnah not hadiths.
39:41, 6:107, 29:18, 5:92, 5:99, 3:20, 24:54, 42:6, 42:48, 64:12, 16:64, 2:213, 39:41, 18:110, 28:56, 72:21, 2:272, 48:2, 27:92, 50:45. 12:111, 16:89, 17:12, 6:114, 10:15, 6:19, 13:40, 3:80, 75:19
Meaning of following Messenger is to follow that Book which he left behind for us and that is ONLY Quran 6:19, 10:15, 6:114, 28:85
قُلْ أَىُّ شَىْءٍ أَكْبَرُ شَهَـٰدَةً قُلِ ٱللَّهُ شَهِيدٌۢ بَيْنِى وَبَيْنَكُمْ وَأُوحِىَ إِلَىَّ هَـٰذَا ٱلْقُرْءَانُ لِأُنذِرَكُم بِهِۦ وَمَنۢ بَلَغَ أَئِنَّكُمْ لَتَشْهَدُونَ أَنَّ مَعَ ٱللَّهِ ءَالِهَةً أُخْرَىٰ قُل لَّآ أَشْهَدُ قُلْ إِنَّمَا هُوَ إِلَـٰهٌ وَٰحِدٌ وَإِنَّنِى بَرِىٓءٌ مِّمَّا تُشْرِكُونَ
What is he trying to understand us 😂😂
Salat is one of the most important parts of Islam, and without it, a great part of Islam disappears. Unfortunately you dismantled it.
Salat is not any brand of Rituals
People who think they are clever, and understand the Quran better than the Prophet Muhammad (Sallallahu alaihe wa sallam) are people who have gone astray.
What an irony, Quranists do not believe in saying of prophet's word but trust in arabic dictionary.😂😂
Prophet left for you only written Quran. So if you want to relate any thing with Prophet; talk only from Quran; NOT FROM FABRICATED BOOKS which were forged after the death of Prophet
quran is GOD's words, relayed by the prophet. we do not follow prophet's words because God himself threatened muhammad if he dares say anything beyond what God wants him to say:
Move not your tongue with it, [O Muhammad], to hasten with recitation of the Qur'an. Indeed, upon Us is its collection [in your heart] and [to make possible] its recitation. So when We have recited it [through Gabriel], then follow its recitation. (Surah 75:16-18)
And if Muhammad had made up about Us some [false] sayings, We would have seized him by the right hand; Then We would have cut from him the aorta. (Surah 69:44-46)
hadith Muslims are advised to perform salat (prayer) like prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) quran is supported by hadith
Salamu Alaykum brother/sister.
I just want to sincerely advise and gently remind you that our Quran does not need support from any other book. L’Lah mentions in numerous ayat that it is a complete guide, clear, and fully explained / fully detailed. Nothing left out or omitted, and no doubt therein. Meaning salat action and everything we need to know is in there. Our Nabiyy would not of done it any differently than the way of the revelations that came straight to him. We either believe in all of the Ayat of the Kitab or we have disbelieved if we even turn away from just one Ayat. L’Lah will guide who He wills, innahu Al-Ghafourur Raheem. Don’t take any chances. Ask for quidance sincerely and be patient. Salamu Alaykum.
if you equate man made hadith with the words of Allah then you are a shirk, not a muslim, read the Quran and see
chapter 7 verse 52: ,,We have given them a scripture that is fully detailed - with knowledge, guidance and mercy for the people who believe''.
Chapter 39 verse 27: ,,We have cited for the people every kind of example in this Quran that they may take heed''.
[2:41] And believe in what I revealed, confirming what is with you; and do not be the first to deny it; and do not exchange My revelations for a small price; and be conscious of Me
"Shall I seek other than God as a source of law, when He has revealed to you this book FULLY DETAILED?" (Al Quran #6:114)
Prophet never prayed 5 Rituals? Prove it from Quran, and tell me number of Rakat of your rituals in Quran?
@@abdar-rahman6965 prophet Muhammad SAW existed in real life. prove it from quran?
@@abdar-rahman6965 I dont need to prove it from quran because quran is not the only source. teachings and action of Muhammad SAW and quran togehter is islam
You are misleading yourself and those who follow you. Ritual Salat exists in the Quran.
Mashallah. Otherwise why wudu? Ghusl? Face to Mecca? Why stand raise your hands, bow, and prostrate? Why return to the normal salat after being in horse ride riding away from an enemy? He is indeed misleading himself.
@@QuranforTheWest None of those are there but I’m sure you don’t care
That’s s lie there’s no such thing as a ritual in the Quran.
Number of Rakat of your Rituals in Quran?
Read 11. 87