Mobile Ticketing - Bonus Video - Day 75 - Sheffield to Retford
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ต.ค. 2024
- It’s the 20th July, and this special bonus video was created in collaboration with Trainline, who challenged us to leave our All Line Rovers in our pockets for the day and try out mobile ticketing for the first time to see how they work.
We started at Sheffield and also drop into the National Railway Museum at York along the way.
Trainline sponsored the creation of this video, however all views expressed by us in relation to the Trainline product are our own and based on our own experiences during the challenge.
Trainline Website: www.thetrainli...
For more information about mobile tickets and etickets with Trainline: www.thetrainli...
Download the Trainline Mobile App here: www.thetrainli...
The National Railway Museum: www.nrm.org.uk/
Geoff and Vicki are visiting ALL 2,563 national railway stations in Britain - view the progress map and loads more information about the project on the website at: allthestations....
ROUTE: Sheffield - York - Gilberdyke - Selby - Leeds - Doncaster - Mexborough - Doncaster - Retford.
My paper ticket never runs out of battery
I do though. I can get up 15 minutes later if I use this app and don't have to queue up to pick up my ticket from the machine at the station.
My non-trainline bought ticket never costs money to collect
Quite. I've had two phones breathe their last breath on a train, let alone run out of battery.
exactly! also Mobile Ticketing is not ready in like 80% of the country!
Don't you have sockets in trains over there?
The trainline, just like all the other ticketing apps, apart from being more expensive. Nice of them not to charge a booking fee for on the day travel. Be nicer if they didn't charge a booking fee at all...like everyone else 😬
Agreed. I refuse to use TTL after their blatant profiteering by trying to sting customers for hidden charges that none of the TOC websites have. (Of course, as no-one makes apps for Windows Phone, it's something of a moot point for me :-( )
Robert Parnham I use the northern rail app. It's pretty good and shows you all types of tickets you could buy for that particular journey
Yep. DON'T USE THE TRAINLINE PEEPS! Use any train company's site as they don't charge you a booking fee.
I checked out trainline for a trip from London to Crewe return, and it wanted to charge me a booking fee.
So I went with takethetrain (I think, the one with the frog, anyway), and there was no booking fee. I won't be using trainline ever.
My fee was only 70p I don’t mind paying 70p to have the ticket on my phone no waiting around at the machine and the app shows all the information I need platform train times ext
That ticketline guy is overly jolly.
I don't like it.
Train line proving to be a fantastic tool for rail users in 2020 ♡
Held up a line of frustrated travellers once when trying to scan the barcode at a ticket barrier. Eventually a ticket inspector came to the rescue with their paper ticket, so never did that again. Also I've never had a paper ticket run out of battery.
I use mobile tickets for short journeys only in case my phone dies. Most of the guards that I have shown my conductor to never really check them, I think they know at this point, if you have the ingenuity to buy a mobile ticket then you've probably bought the correct ticket.
Hi Tim I use Arriva Trains Wales mobile tickets as there don't change a booking fee
Mobile ticketing is the future, but i'm still not paying the trainline's stupid booking fee's.
Anyone else find the bloke from the Trainline bloody irritating?
Say no to drugs, kids.
I'm definitely going to fund Vickie to do a, All the Castles.
Is it gonna happen? Love Vicki
Can’t get enough of your videos! Great job!
I’ve had mobile ticketing on my regional rail (NJ Transit) available for a while and use it all the time. All trains are non-reserved, so no seat booking, but the app is free to use (you use a cc to purchase your ticket). With the coming of COVID-19, a train-loading feature has been added. The other NY metro area systems (Metro North, Long Island RR) have similar apps. The Amtrak app (also free) does allow you to book a seat. And, I believe, they’re finally going to enable this system on the NYC subway system (MTA). Please stay healthy and be safe!!
One pacer to rule them all, one train to find them, one line connects them all, and all the statins bind them, in the land of Moorthorpe where the shadows lie 3:10 .
On my trip to England last August I bought all my tickets on that app. Highly variable prices: buying early and being flexible about times helped.
Did make it to York and the Museum.
Love the videos even if I haven't commented on all of them. I'm not convinced by this trainline thingum though, they're well known for charging a fee for booking tickets whereas TOCs don't, their mobile tickets aren't available on Southern and they don't offer the Southern £2 child fares so many journeys that could have used these would be more expensive through the trainline. Perhaps Tim could ask one of his colleagues to investigate this. Mobile ticketing will surely be the future though.
As All-line Rovers with a Two Together Railcard has been used on days other than this one, I hope that other tickets have been purchased when either travelling before 0930 Monday to Friday, or when travelling alone to meet up again at another station?
Hi Tim. TTL app always fails to recognise destinations for services which split further down the line, and it drives passengers nuts and sends them into a confused panic (I'm a guard, so witness this so much). I'll give you an example, search for a train from Waterloo to Farnborough main. There are two an hour and during the Waterloo upgrade works, the train splits at Woking, front part to Alton, rear to Basingstoke. However the TTL app shows none of these calling stations between Woking and Basing, as TTL app only sees this as a service to Alton.
Happens during any weekend engineering works too, and again causes confusion. Also TTL app would wrongly tell me my service from Farnborough to Waterloo terminates at Woking. Which is wrong, it actually attaches and continues on. The poor ad-hoc weekend traveller usingTTL app becomes seriously confused with miss-information.
National rail app does it correctly as does the SWT app. However given the popularity of TTL I really hope this can be addressed, as it's otherwise great! Cheers Tim.
Well what about if your on a line that hasn’t yet implemented mobile tickets
11:07 I have this exact struggle many times, Howden to Huddersfield being my regular service and having to change at Selby with awkward connection times. Also cannot use mobile ticketing from Howden station, which also doesn't have a ticket machine. Which means I have to have my tickets ordered through the post or buy on the day from the conductor.
The problem at Selby is that the Hull-Selby-York service is irregular (as is the Hull Trains service that also calls at Howden) and so it will never play nicely with the hourly connections to the west. I think that Northern do have plans to make this service more regular, but I don't know how long we'll have to wait for it...
Wow an app that makes fares more expensive than they already are! Let's download it! said no one ever...
Ooh. Twenty minutes of video. I'll put on a cup of tea before I watch this one.
What video is Doncaster station in?
I absolutely love how every video starts with a smile. I suppose every day wasn't quite so jolly but I'm glad you are enjoying yourself on the whole.
Ringing the Mallard Buffer brought to mind a lost art of the old steam railways, Wheeltappers!
Its been much improved and resculptured over the years, but when I first moved to Yorkshire in the late 20th century, the landscape around Moorthorpe was rather Mordor-ish too
But why can't you get All Line Rovers through mobile ticketing?
And I noted the 'on the day' caveat to the no booking fee claim... Any advance tickets through them do charge a fee 😒, go direct through the train company...
My iPhone 3GS and iPhone 5 would regularly run out of battery. Then I swapped the 5 for a Samsung S7 EDGE. I have never once run out of battery. Even after a long day at a music festival taking photos and videos. Plus, back up batteries are small enough to fit in a pocket for emergencies and hold their charge for weeks if not months.
I love your videos but turned this shameless advert off after a couple of minutes. The Trainline is a rip off - most TOC's sites and apps don't charge a booking fee for any tickets!! Key message of this video - don't use the Trainline :)
trainline, who charge you a booking fee! (apart from the day of travel - but can you get advances on the day? I'll let you guess the answer to that one!) Always buy from your local TOC who don't charge fees at all!
Hi cjmillsnun, Advance purchase tickets have recently been made available on the day of travel by some operators, where this is possible the advance tickets are often unavailable at the station, only online, so our app, or the TOCs version would show the advance purchase tickets. It can work up to 15mins before travel in some cases.
Except of course Virgin West Coast APOD were listed as being available at stations in the press release, and I have personally sold a TPE APOD at a station.
The guy sitting behind me on Virgin West Coast had bought a ticket on his mobile but reinstalled his app after his outward journey during his stay in Glasgow. Although he could show the confirmation email to the guard, the app had lost his ticket and he was charged at penalty fare of something like £150. I won't trust any of those apps for that reason.
I think that was the Virgin app, which may or may not be different.
Interesting that Trainline haven't responded to that one... Major weakness in the whole concept.
It does say whenever you reinstall an app that you are deleting all the data with it, including any tickets. So if you decide to reinstall an app for no reason with a ticket on it that you plan to use it's likely that you'd have to pay for it again
Anyone else would choose not to reinstall the app half way through the journey. Bit of a silly thing to do really
Dear Geoff and Vicki and Trainline...
What happens if your phone runs out of battery? What excuse would you make as the guard bends down and asks for your ticket. Furthermore this would be impossible among stations in farther corners of Britain where mobile data services are poor, then the purchasing part would become defunct. Anyway, enjoyed the video!!
Hi Imagine further, you don't need WiFi once your ticket is downloaded to your phone, so loosing signal wouldn't be a problem. There's also an even newer type of ticket is available on some routes called an eticket (another challenge for the next adventure perhaps!). The eticket can be printed or used as a barcode so if you don't think your phone battery is going to last there is that alternative. There's some more information about the different digital tickets here: www.thetrainline.com/information/mobile-tickets
Yep, I do print at home when I can (for example I've been doing it for German rail journeys for about a decade, but I'm sure the remaining non print-at-home majority of the British network will catch up soon) but I'd never depend on a battery-powered device to store a ticket where there's a fine payable if I can't produce it on demand.
I checked in for a flight online a couple of years ago, but when I got to the airport and opened the app, it had crashed and the boarding pass I'd previously obtained had disappeared, so I had to go to the check-in desk instead. This turned out to be a blessing in disguise as I then discovered I'd brought an expired passport rather than my current one and I still had time (but only just) to arrange for a friend to collect and bring the correct passport to me. So: app-based ticketing is unreliable (but sometimes that's OK).
Paper tickets aren't exactly risk free either. I wish I could say I'd never lost any, but... When you have mobile tickets, there's an easy solution for your problem - have a spare battery. Costs as little as 10 quid for a cheap one, gives you months of worry-free days out. I'm with the above commenter - having lived in Korea, the aversion to app-based here ticketing is mystifying.
I always carry a spare battery when I have a mobile ticket, but the HSL app which allows travel on all local transport in the Helsinki area is absolutely terrible, and often crashes when buying a ticket.
Does anyone know if you can pay with google pay (previously android pay) like apple pay on the iphone?
I also guess this won't work for travelling to stations that don't have a barcode scanner.
There's a fish tank at Bradford interchange in the ticket office...shame you miss it..
It's sooo expensive over 77 quid for 3 adults and 1 child peterborough to Bury St Edmunds and it takes longer. It won't cost me that to drive door to door. I love trains but pricing is ridiculous
You can get a Family & Friends railcard for just £30 a year. It takes a third off adult fares and 60% off kid's fares when you are travelling with at least 1 Adult (16 and over) and 1 Child (up to 15). This would make train travel great value for you and your family.
Thing is, if I don't have a paper ticket what am I going to use the 2nd pocket in my #allthestations Oyster Card holder for? 🤔
That's brilliant bit it would have been £9 cheaper buying 2 singles from Sheffield to meadowhall then 2 singles from meadowhall to York using your 2 together railcard has it would be after 0930 at meadowhall.
Top stuff, split tickets is a great way of getting a bargain!
I've tried split ticketing websites, but splitting into peak and off-peak legs didn't work. Doing it myself, I could pay £58.50 for CBG->NOT at 0901 on a weekday; or £33.40 if I split it myself at Stamford. I'm sure these websites will improve in the future.
Would love to use mobile ticketing.
Sadly though mobile ticketing doesn't work with the combined rail/Metrolink tickets I usually buy. Metrolink trams do mobile ticketing. Northern rail do mobile ticketing. But never works with the other. One day, maybe one day...
Just use Virgin trains. Same price and never any booking fees 👌
Was that your phone ringing during the interview Geoff? ;)
I think that Geoff should record the sound the buffer maid and turn it into his tea 'ding' noise on his channel.
The northern m-ticket app will do the job without paying booking fee.
Great video as always but I will never, ever use the trainline to book tickets...
Ah yes - must also ‘activate’ the etickets! I was on the Carnforth-Lancaster train last Christmas, and had Forgotten to Activate the Ticket ... shouldn’t have done that, should I? But it was all right, as the conductor did it for me with a smile!
The train line does not work on non-UK mobile phones. The Southern app is much more useful. I used it recently to buy greatly reduced tickets in Wales and the Midlands.
Hi Robert, there is Trainline Europe if you want to book for non-domestic journeys. Here: www.trainline.eu/
Trainline: Actually more interested in using my non-UK phone to purchase UK tickets.
It's not because a device is non-UK, it's down to the device being Google certified or not. If you're using an imported device from China for example then apps like TheTrainline will fail to work because the OS isn't certified by Google.
Can't wait for when mobile ticketing is rolled out on the new south western railway franchise. It'll be SO much easier for blindy's like myself. Oh and hi Tim!
My response to Tim: "Maybe I like the misery!"
Another reason for people to walk about with their head bowed bumping into us paper ticket holders :(
Loved the Video! Pity the ending wasn't "All the Tickets, All of Them" :P
Oof, that was a bit in your face, eh.
Lived in Germany and Austria for years and genuinely had no idea this hadn't been around for 10 years already in the UK. Is everyone really buying from machines?
What's a "booking fee"? ;-)
Something about brexit etc.
A booking fee is an additional price that you have to pay when you book online and is the main way that ticket selling companies make money. There is a different booking fee depending on the website. I hope this was helpful.
This was an advertisement right?
'this special bonus video was created in collaboration with Trainline' - Make your own mind up. And personally I'm fine if it is.
Oh yes most definitely.
It seems a little dishonest to be touting TTL as though they are the only ones doing this if some/most/all of the TOCs have their own apps offering similar functionality ... especially given TTL's dodgy practices of loading extra charges on, they are not a company that I would feel comfortable promoting.
I'm sure people who travel a lot by train already know this and book through virgin, transpennine, national rail, etc. instead.
But TTL cover ALL of the networks. Besides, they never said it was the only app in the world like it. Just one they'd come across.
Eastrington, "One person got off!!". I was half-expecting two men in white coats to step out and lift him or her back on to the train again!
I have lived Slovakia for work .It cost 2.55 euroes to travel to Bratsavia .that £1.80 .that is the distance of 50k or reading ,
The issue with mobile tickets isn't that the tickets or ticketing app drains your battery. It's that I lack the organizational skills to always have my phone charged until the end of my return journey. If I have the last train home, 6 times out of 10 my phone is empty at least part of the journey.
Thanks for doing a #vikkiexplores in Cross Gates!
In 30 years, this will be an entertaining throwback video akin to watching Tomorrow's World connecting via 300bps acoustic modem...
In 30 years the electricity grid will have collapsed due to net zero and there''ll be a shortage of materials with which to manufacture smartphones and electronic devices.
Not sure if Mexborough's the only station with fish, but Ebbsfleet International's got a couple of palm trees on the concourse!
I prefer the southeastern the key card. Smart travel minus the Hassel of needing a WiFi connection. And I just tap and go. No booking fees ever and season ticketing!!
theres nothing wrong with paper ticketing. if its not broken, dont fix it.
Except for the fact it's hugely wasteful and loads of paper gets discarded regularly because of it and you could easily forget it when you're rushing to get the train. Much easier just to remember my phone and a battery pack then I'm fine
The Zero point at York Station is the point where the mileages are calculated from for the North Eastern Railway not the London and North Eastern Railway as mentioned by Tim. The first part of the ECML mileages are from Kings Cross to York is 188 miles. Zero at York to the Scottish boarder is 69.5 miles and from there on the mileages are calculated from Edinburgh back to the English boarder which is 54.5 miles.
the hub of railsway should be birmingham new street
4 years later "Hello Tim!!!!!"
No semaphores at Staddlethorpe junction now :(
Next time you do Gilberdyke you need a famous meat pie from Newport butchers.
Mythbusting: Mexborough smells like toasted teacakes as there is a bagel factory about 5 minutes walk away.
Tim’s farmer’s tan ❤️🌞
Bob’s ding! 🔔 😎
Paper rickets don't run out of power.
Raiker rickets no run out power. Velly good!
I have never and will never use mobile ticketing. It's not the same at all. Having a physical memento is part of travelling - something with which you look back at memories and keep as a result. What's more the app does not advertise nor is it possible to use it for rover tickets that can make your travelling much cheaper.
No point to E Tickets. What happens if you phone dies, I suppose you just buy a paper ticket? 😁
no thanks i'd rather buy my tickets from the train operator direct...
I agree
Nice video to start the morning! I love it, Geoff and Vicki!
I'd love if that system could be rolled out here in America, but I'm not holding my breath.
Spencer O'Dowd Amtrak has mobile ticketing through their app. Even the Amtrak paper tickets are just a bar code now.
HI TIM
HI JAMES
All very convenient but when you complain about station ticket offices being closed it's because with more and more people buying mobile and online tickets the TOCs will reduce ticket office hours or even close them.
A train station that sells one ticket a day is going to close, online tickets or no.
starlinguk not everybody is tech savvy and rely on a human to assist them and answer any queries they have. witnessed it myself recently on a southern service where there was no onboard supervisor.
Dunno where you live Rob but where I am in Northern's rail territory actual staffed stations are very few and far between - even at heavily used stations. If they had ticket offices most of them probably closed 30+ years ago. Our nearest station doesn't even have a ticket machine.
Can't see what difference electronic tickets would make to station staffing. All they would do is save me buying one from the guard.
30 lb's is 13.636 kg
james m Also 30lbs /is/ "real money" 😀
hello greetings from Mobile pronounced Mo-Beel USA
Hello! I don't think I have commented on a TH-cam video before. Anyway, I have now. I should probably do a railway channel.
I did wonder if it was the amazing Tim Dunn in this video but I didn’t connect you as it says you was from the Trainline
Has no idea where Gilberdyke was either.
Checked googlemaps to find it's got a Costcutter & a Boots! Just 5 mins from the station
As for things changing
-end of semaphores and signal boxes. Some lines you have travelled on are being scrapped shortly.
-last of British Rail rolling stock being replaced
-end of locomotive hauled or push pull trains (cumbrian line excepted) as DMUS and EMUS are better efficiency wise.
The documentary you have undertaken has captured all of this before all the above takes place
What if the battery on your device runs out before you arrive and you can't get through the barrier?
I hear they're working on a backup system so that if the phone isnt present for whatever reason the ticket can still be retrieved in a paper format
Woo Sheffield!
Hi Tim I love train s
Gah, you didn't show Wressle! I lived there for a year, in a house at the end of the Hull-bound platform. And yet, despite the platform being at the end of my garden, on most days I had to cycle to Howden or Selby to catch a train because so few actually stopped there. Once had to walk home from Howden, and on one occasion on the way home from Leeds, I had to change at Brough...travelling through Wressle to get a train in the opposite direction that stopped at a sensible time! Ah, trains, eh. Your comments in Selby about none of the connections seeming to match up, I can identify with!
Oh; and it always rains in Gilberdyke. I think!
So _that's_ how you're supposed to use the fingerprint button! It's no wonder mine has never worked (until now?)...
I like the "tick" but I hope that the final station/video doesn't end with just a tick. That would be sort of anti-climactic.
I work on the railway, and have no end of people saying 'trainline says my train is at xxx, so where is it.??' Times are often wrong, platforms are regularly wrong... sorry trainline, but you need to pull your socks up.
Hi Grenfell Road, our updates come from the NRE feed for live times and cancellations, this is updated by the TOCs themselves, so it is likely any discrepancy is from a change at the station, close to the journey departure time, and therefore hasn't made it into the feed yet. We're always making improvements to our service though, so please tell anyone to flag with us if this happens, advance thanks.
NRE? TOCs? Please don't use jargon.
Sorry Chris, NRE stands for National Rail Enquiries and TOC stands for Train Operating Companies.
I have a question, for trains with reservations will it show which carriage has less or will that feature be coming
Wow just 97 Stations left, nice! I wish you to a good Journey, keep it up👍
Greetings from Germany
We are told not too use our phones in the quiet carriage so how do we show our mobile tickets to the guard? lol
12:33 We should use the app so Tim can make a living.
You asked for it... "HI TIM!" There you go... happy are we now. Where are we off to next. Oh, I see... it says in the title, silly me.
OK, but Trainline charges more if you're in the US & trying to buy tickets in the UK!
Hi Tim,
I'll defo look into it as maybe the extra cost of tickets via fees is worth the slick app experience!
Generally I find the TOCs own apps quite clunky
Hi Tim!
hi!
Jeff's always surprised people are getting on and off... yes, the North of England has people. A lot of people. Who also need to get around, even though the services are appalling.
Don't understand why everyone's so upset. I have used Trainline for about four years now and after sporadically using other ticketing apps for a limited time I always go back to Trainline because it works the best. The information is always correct, the features work better and it does more. Great app!
Julian Lewis most franchises use the same data, yet when you buy with a franchise you don't pay a fee.
Because every ticket sold by Scamline can be purchased from any train companies website or ticket office for cheaper and without fees. They're a scam site.
Don't use trainline it charges a booking fee, TOCs don't and some give rewards for booking with them.
This is the day I unexpectedly bumped in to Geoff and Tim between Garforth and Leeds :-) however Vicki had alighted to do her Vicki Explores segment :-( - maybe another time??
Oh and Bradford Interchange also has a fish tank too
wheel tapping, the orgins of the term that something is "sound", used predominantly in areas by people who would of done the wheel tapping :)
Vicki laughed at your joke geoff....marry her NOW!
Can I marry Tim? ok, that's too bold. Can I at least travel with him by train and just chat? ok. I'll shupt up now.
could you use the app for rovers and rangers?
I have just got your t-Shirts