ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ก.พ. 2019
- "Civilisation is not frozen in time. The narrative that we Indians have not borrowed any thing from other cultures and civilisations is absolutely false. The historical fact is that various assimilations of food, clothing, knowledge, architecture and cultures have enriched our own culture," argues Delhi-based historian, Sohail Hashmi in a conversation with Pervaiz Alam.
Sohail Hashmi is known for conducting heritage walks in Delhi and around. During one of his heritage walks in Tughlakabad, Delhi, he spoke about 'Hindostan Ki Kahani' - a series of short films- he has been presenting in the digital space.
Discussing his series, Sohali Hashmi says, "A debate is raging in India about who is an Indian and who is not. What constitutes Indian food, language, music, Hindu architecture and Muslims architecture. The ongoing debate is political in nature with an aim to create divisions among people, and has no scholarly or academic basis. However, my series looks at this debate with a historical and academic perspective.
'Hindostan Ki Kahani' is available on Anhad Media's TH-cam page.
The interview with Sohail Hashmi was recorded on 30 January, 2019, in New Delhi.
Camera: Sajid Raza Khan
Editing and Online Production: Dhyan Akshat
![[UNCUT] The Loyal Pin ปิ่นภักดิ์ EP.3 (3/4)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/733LDfWIyc8/mqdefault.jpg)
Sir, I'm a student of ayurved ...And 'anar' has been mentioned in our books written around 2000 years ago as a fruit named 'दाड़िम'.
You said babur brought it but we knew and been using this fruit for ages.
Ye jihadi historian hai
In one words he want to said their is no civilisation before 700...
totlly a lie
Not at all! He is saying foreigners introduced new things and on return borrowed so many things from India. For example, the Muslim architecture borrowed heavily from the Hindu architecture and vice versa.
open mind your correct
Poor old man revealed his bias when he told "People who call themselves vegetarian" .....He wants to say that these vegans don't have rich cultural heritage and almost every good food they eat nowadays is borrowed.....Anyway to expose this old man just ask him why shouldn't Article 370 of Indian Constitution be abrogated and the population mixing be allowed in J&K, we people will enrich Kashmiri culture and also learn their culture......I am 200% sure that this old man will Seek isolated culture for Muslim dominated areas
"Civilisation is not frozen in time. The narrative that we Indians have not borrowed any thing from other cultures and civilisations is absolutely false. The historical fact is that various assimilations of food, clothing, knowledge, architecture and cultures have enriched our own culture."
@@CINEINK very correct....We do believe in assimilative culture but unfortunately our Muslim brethren in Kashmir want to deny their fellow Indians a chance to assimilate ..... Shouldn't there be assimilation of culture in Kashmir too ? Or u have different standard for Hindu culture being open to assimilation and Muslim culture being isolated
According to them Afghanistan and Arabs were more civilized people.
No, not at all. You got it all wrong. He's saying foreigners introduced new fruits/veggies/architecture/culture/customs and the same foreigners too back a slice of India - India's knowledge/food/culture etc. This happens all over the world. This is how it has happened in every country. Do you have another theory?
PS: Thanks for your comments. We respect your engagement with us. Perhaps, Cine Ink on TH-cam is the only channel where each and every comment is responded to. But we do remove and report comments which violate the basic decency norms. No swearing words please, no attack on any religion, cast & colour, and no sexist & misogynistic remarks against women please. Thanks.
You can also engage with us through our various platforms on social media such as: facebook.com/cineink/
twitter.com/cineinknews
www.cineink.com
Please subscribe. Thanks.
No. He is saying that it is all give and take.
@@dilipthombre4806 Excellent sir
really impressed
@Manchester United
so INDIA was civilised since 5000 yrs
spread from
Afganistan GANDHAR
to BRAHMDESH (MYANMAR)
and kashmir to
shrilanka
Saurabh Singh - you are so uneducated! It’s beyond understanding! He is saying that the world is a confluence and the only thing you got from this is that “ Afghanistan and Arabs were more civilized “ . Stop being so defensive
RUSSIANS EXCAVATED SOUTHERN UZBEKISTAN IN 1940SAND TOLD THE WORLD ABOUT Kushan sLALITADITYA in FARGHANA valley and Budha Stupas there.See Tashkent museums 2 halls .. Let Indians know it and visit ANGKOREVAT Combodia Bali Vietnam also. WE HAD SO MUCH SIR
.
You are right. The point here is that cultural cross pollination is a two way street. We are enriched by others and we did the same to other cultures. This makes us neither pure nor impure but distinct flavors of life, that needs to be celebrated.
Excellent vlog. Very macro, assimilating, broaden view. A knowledgeable facts.
Kudos 👍 for keeping History alive and authentic 👏 🎉
बहुत सुंदर
Very nice and enlightening discussion. Cineink, you need a lot of appreciation and kudos for taking on difficult (politically speaking) subjects and putting it out in a way it educates, not animates people. Keep up the good work. You have your task cut out.
India will greatly enrich large parts of central asia,as a super power,
I salute your great endeavour, Suhail Hashmi Sahab. May God the rationality prevail.
Thank you very much Pervaiz Alam Sahab for bringing to us yet another magnificent programme. Wish you all the best.
We salute you for watching most of our programmes for great interest. Thanks, Sir.
Excellent interview
All these terms only make divide
Actually these terms(islamic/hindu architecture) are made for division by the english
Khatri ji, thanks. Cineink has been producing audio podcasts and some of these podcasts have become very popular. Please listen to our podcast series, Aam Naama, Police Adalat Aur Insaaf, Bharat: Hindi Kahaniyan, Britain: Hindi kahani, Ilm e Shayari and other radio programmes on TH-cam and other podcasting networks, including Spotify and Apple iTunes. Thanks.
Hybrid Culture and interaction say bath aagay barti, Mughals kahi kay bhi ho. They gave a lot to India, one cannot compartmentalize people
which is happening in India dividing people and architecture and many other aspects. History, culture and lives are getting distorted.
Babri Masjid and many other Mosques, temples, forts, gardens, bridges, markets, old sites of interest like Durgahs, saraye, and old highways. are all our rich HERITAGE..In European countries they preserve it like treasures , Aur India may they just want to target to break, feel jealous, EERSHA, and want it gone!! SOOCHO. BABRI MASJID WAS A NISHHANI OF OUR HISTORICAL ARCHITECTURE. So Also the statues of Buddha of Bamiyaan..... Afsoos.
Hashmi sahab kurte ki ijaad kab aur kahaan se hui?
"ہندوستان کی کہانی" سہیل ھاشمی کے تعارف کا شکریہ۔
amalaca is the symbol of Indian gooseberry
Sohail bhai is a public enemy no. 1... he is teaching common sense, rationality , logic and critical thinking.
So vegetables , fruit, kumra - sitar, food and architecture only defines richness of a civilization. Someone needs to quantify i.e. contribution vs damage the middle eastern invaders brought to this land apart from certain food and architecture aspects, what about destroying temples ,barbarism and forced conversions . Learn to appreciate the native culture ,land and your own roots , perhaps arif mohammed khan and tarek fateh like muslims are very few. Please get out of your monotheistic lens and stop undermining everything.
This could be a question on what the ancient Indian civilisation with incredible diversity and richness contributed to the world? A lot, is an answer in just two words.
This means we were junglee before Muslims came to this country
No! But some people from the what app university on this timeline can not even check the facts on the net. Just google and find out the origin of various things. Please do not shoot the messenger. Can you do that, Sir?
Thank you....for enriching our knowledge
Thanks for watching.
@@CINEINK want to work with you.
@@kumarsoni.h Itna aasaaN nahiN lahu rona....
Shukriya Soni ji.
Oh ji asan to pet bharna b ni hai aaj Kal , PR saanu Dil se journalist han, apka kaam pasand aaya to laga bahut kuchh aap se seekh sakta hun.
@@kumarsoni.h Tuadda swagat hega. Tusi dasso, ki chaande o..? Please let us know how we can help you.
Very Informative
Ver informative, this topic is very well explained in Discovery of India.
Great! You mean the book or TV series?
GREAT>>>GREAT>>>>GREAT
British imperialism was imperialism, but Islamic imperialism was a cultural exchange programme.
Thanks for watching Cineink programmes. Recently, we have launched Cine Ink Podcasts in Hindi and Urdu- available on Apple, Spotify, Google, TH-cam and other major digital platforms, including www.cineink.com.
Sirji to make dilution by selective fact we can not underestimate what we had always in food & habits but it is kind of aggression which make changes weather food or cultural ethos or architectures special when ever visiting kutumb minar which converted in grave & toms they were manidr jain mandir, in north y all mandir & local structures were demolished & make them vanished either Nalanda which is burn more than month or taxila which is in Pakistan but no clue now a days people have questions
devvrt tiwari
cinek will not respond your comment
because you had posted bitter truth of history
dilip thombre what is true that I had mentioned over their we believe in culture & heritage value but that should be respected every side
@@devvrattiwari2620
even a small piece of truth can not digested by these hypocratic chanel
you are correct
tiwariji
Very informative
You are a discerning viewer. Thanks for watching, Shubhra Sood. Love you.
कंधार और अफगानिस्तान भी भारत का ही हिस्सा थे ये बोलने में जुबान गल जायेगी इन दोनों की।।
बिलकुल थे! पर जो सच है वह मान्ने में क्या झिझक। दुनिया भर में संस्कृति का और विचारों का आदान प्रदान होता है।
एक तरफा इतिहास तो मत पढ़ाओ भाई। आपकी बात सही है कि सभ्यताएं निरन्तर अपने अंदर परिवर्तन लाती है। लेकिन कुछ तो बात रही होगी पुरानी सभ्यताओं में भी वो भी उजागर करनी चाहिए आप जैसे बुद्धिजीवियों को।।
आपको सुहैल हाशमी की कौनसी बात आपत्तिजनक लगती है? उदाहरण दीजिए।
Very informative. This is a good way to present supporting evidence to convey the main theme.
Indeed, informative. Thanks.
Sohail Hashmi shoro may kahay. No culture or cities and people flourished on their own is so correct not only in foods but many aspects ye nahi bolay, Boli, languages, clothes, tools, animals, administration, musical instruments and many others., . Bohot bada sach hai, India has closed off in many ways as people do not read world History, Global issues of war, refugee crises, trauma, global art and exchange of ideas
new ones, new philosphers bolo kon hai, NAHI MALOOM.
Fantastic explanation -SIR-- really nice
Thanks and welcome.
Please subscribe to this channel by clicking the image of Bell above. Thanks.
Great talk
He come in Ramanujan college
आप ने पहचान लिया? वाह। Thanks. Cineink has been producing audio podcasts and some of these podcasts have become very popular. Please listen to our podcast series, Aam Naama, Police Adalat Aur Insaaf, Bharat: Hindi Kahaniyan, Britain: Hindi kahani, Ilm e Shayari and other radio programmes on TH-cam and other podcasting networks, including Spotify and Apple iTunes. Thanks.
We need same composite culture in kashmir valley. We need to defeat Stone Pelters and end the GundaRaaj in kashmir valley so that everyone can live there in peace.
Totally unfair to suppress 8 million Kashmiris in the name security. Gross violation of their human rights.
Thanks for real knowledge
It is so much knowledgeable
Yes, he is.
Politician are behind this discussion. They have their vested interest to divide and rule policy.
बौद्ध मठों में गुंबद है वो नहीं बताया ये हमेशा आधी बात बोलते हैं और मंदिर और मठों को तोड कर उन की सामग्री से मस्जिदें बनी हुई हैं
Interesting, you say that. Since you have mentioned of hindu temples, please read a book- The Myth of the Holy Cow, - by D. N. Jha who was former Professor of History at the University of New Delhi, and is the author of Revenue System in Post-Mauryan and Gupta Times Economy and Society in Early India, The Myth of the Holy Cow, Early India, Rethinking Hindu Identity, and Against the Grain: Notes on Identity, Intolerance and History.
Prof. DN Jha writes that before the arrival of Islam in ancient India, hundreds of Budhist and Jain temples were demolished by the Hindus.
History is cruel.
@@CINEINK हा हा हा दुनिया का सबसे शांति प्रिय धर्म इस्लाम है हिंदू और बौद्ध में अंतर क्या है बौद्ध धर्म तलवार से नहीं फैला है अगर हिंदू बौद्ध धर्म के विरोध में होते तो अहिंसा के बल पर कैसे फैल गया अपना ये एक तरफा इतिहास अपने जैसे बंद दिमाग के लोगों को पढाया करो जो सवाल नहीं उठाते सवाल पूछते ही ये नकली इतिहासकार भागने लगते हैं
@@CINEINK we can refer thousands of bookS..... western as well as Indian which describes in details how Islam arrived in India and elsewhere . You don't. Need any book just watch what happened to bamyan in 21st century. Please visit ajanta and allora you will find jain, Boddh and hindu temples which shows (pre and post islam) we don't have culture of destroying idols temples and libraries.
@@current_affairs885 बौद्ध धर्म तलवार से नहीं फैला था लेकिन भारत से इसको मिटाया तलवार के दम पर ही गया था और इसका सबसे बड़ा श्रेय पुष्यमित्र शुंग को जाता है जो एक कट्टर ब्राह्मण शासक था।
@@simplyias3628 बौद्ध धर्म और हिंदू धर्म के बीच में अंतर क्या है अधकचरी जानकारी बहुत खतरनाक होती है एक लाइन लिख दी और बुद्ध धर्म खत्म हो गया
I appreciate kind of promptness u had with ur viewers which is rare 👍👍👍
Good
Civilization is not frozen in time but Islam throw you back in 7th century 🤣
You need to read a lot, Sir. We all acknowledge how Hindu scholars such as Aryabhata, Kanada, Varahmihir, Brahmgupta, Charaka, and Sushruta contributed in the advancement of Science and Technology, followed by modern Indian scientists who went on to win noble prizes. Let's be proud of their achievements. However, you seem to ignore the fact that Muslims have also contributed immensely in all fields. Surprisingly, you have no idea how Muslim scholars borrowed so many new ideas from the Hindu scholars.
Just read an excerpt from an article by Keith Devlin in The Guardian, a respected newspaper in London:
Today, mention of the word Islam can, to some, conjure up images of terrorists flying planes full of people into buildings, all in the name, they say, of God.
In an equally sad vein, the word Baghdad brings to mind Saddam Hussein. Both images are as unrepresentative as they are understandable, a sad reflection on the ease with which a handful of fanatics can hijack not just a plane but an entire cultural heritage and its associated religion.
For those of us in mathematics, the sadness is even greater. For the culture that these fanatics claim to represent when they set about trying to destroy the modern world of science and technology was, in fact, the cradle in which that tradition was nurtured.
For all present-day mathematicians and scientists are children of Islam.
Early in the 9th century, the Abbasid caliphs adopted a deliberate approach to the cultural and intellectual growth of the empire. They established the House of Wisdom, an academy of science, and gathered manuscripts in Greek and Sanskrit, and scholars who could understand them.
Important Greek and Indian mathematical books were translated and studied, leading to a new era of scientific creativity that was to last until the 14th century. One of the first Greek texts translated was Euclid's classic geometry text Elements.
This had a huge impact; Arabic mathematicians then adopted a very Greek approach, formulating theorems precisely and proving them formally in Euclid's style. Like Greek mathematics, which was defined more by the common language in which it was written and carried out than the nationality of the practitioners, Arabic mathematics was determined largely by the common use of Arabic by scholars of many nationalities, spread throughout the Islamic Empire.
One of the earliest and most distinguished of the Arabic mathematicians was the 9th century scholar Abu Ja'far Mohammed ibn Musa Al-Khwarizmi, an astronomer to the caliph at Baghdad. His full name can be translated as "Father of Ja'far, Mohammed, son of Moses, native of the town of Al-Khwarizmi".
Al-Khwarizmi wrote several enormously influential books. One, in particular, describes how to write numbers and compute with them using the place-value decimal system we use today, which had been developed in India some time before 600 AD.
This book would, when translated into Latin 300 years later, prove a major source for Europeans who wanted to learn the new system. Today, we know it as the Hindu-Arabic system. It is taught to schoolchildren worldwide.
Many translations of the book began with the phrase " dixit Algorismi " ("so says Al-Khwarizmi"), a practice that led to the adoption in medieval times of the term "algorism" to refer to the process of computing with the Hindu-Arabic numerals.
"Algorithm" is an obvious derivation. Another of Al- Khwarizmi's manuscripts was called Kitab al jabr w'al-muqabala , which translates roughly as "restoration and compensation".
And, this is how Algebra came into being. Here's the link: www.theguardian.com/science/2002/sep/05/research.science2
Pervaiz bhai
Kudos, hats off. We are BBB alumni I listner u broadcaster. Request to upload more informative posts... Thanks 👍👍👌🙏
Great to know Iqbal Fazli Sahab. I love my followers from the BBC days. Do you know, lots of prominent Fazlis come from Dibai, UP? Are you one of them?
Please keep in touch.
Pervaiz Alam
Insaniyat maujood hai bande iska ho ehtraam..
Allah ishwar ek hai sab me rameh hai ram..
Very informative sir.. Aise aur episode bnaye..
Insaan ko hi insaaniyat nazar aati hai.
Janab..jab itna Mila jula hai to.fir 1920 se 1940 1947 ke darmyan educated elite Alag tehzib ka Pure Muslim Pakistan kyon banana chahtee the. Villagers to saath hi rahna chahte the.. AVADH WEST UP.dekhiye....Jab vo alag ho gaye Majhab ke nam par..to Afsos Kya Karna....Bharat me HUMPI Tanjore Kerala Karnataka Madura Khajuraho Konark Rural BENGAL Modhera ASSAM Nepal ke Mandiron ke
Architecture ko gaur se dekhiye..Kuch Alag NAZAR Ayega..Delhi exam alag hai..Maine Samarquand Bukhara khiva Turkey Greece Rome Tuscany CHINA Japan kee Imarton ko dekha hai .Moghuls me concept Central Asians liya hai Samarkand ki Masjidon me Wooden floor hai.va Hauz BHI khubsoorti se bane hai..1947 ke bad ki generations ko 12th centuary se pahle ka BHI samajhne mela harz.hai.Britishers
Ne enlighten kiya ...Silk pearls jewels ka bhi jikra keejiye ...Hindustan BHI an kuch aur Tabdeeli chahte hai
.
@Prodipto Roy
भारतीय जंगली थे
नंगेभुखे
जंगलो मे भटकते थे
फिर अल्लाऊददीन खीलजी
बाबर जैसे महान समाजसुधरक और साधुसंत
भारतीयो पर दया करने के लिए
अरब और कझागिस्तानसे चले आये
यहाँ के मनुवादीयोने ऊनको रोकने की कोशिश की
पर सभी मनुवादी राजा हार गये
फिर पाचसौ साल तक
सारे भारतीयो को
खिलजी बाबर गझनवि और ऊनके अनूयायीयो ने मुफ्त की
रोटी कपडा मकान शिक्षा और रोजगार दिया
लेकीन एहसान फरमोश भारतीय ईस बात को नही मानते
ईससे बंगाल मे बैठे हुए
कम्युनिस्ट भाईयो के नाजुक दिल पर गहरा आघात हो रहा
है
कीतने दुखी है
ईन एहसानफरमोश भारतीयो पर माओ की तरह
सारे बुर्झ्वा को हटाकर नयी क्रांति करना चाहीए
जैसे चीन मे माओ ने कितने मिलीयन लोगो को मार दिया था
भारत मे वैसे भी जनसंख्या बढ गयी ऊतनाही राष्र्टीय जनसंख्या कम करने काम हो जाएगा
Good information
Aap vaastav mein Bahadur hain. Thanks for watching Cineink programmes. Recently, we have launched Cine Ink Podcasts in Hindi and Urdu- available on Apple, Spotify, Google, TH-cam and other major digital platforms, including www.cineink.com.
Great Video.. So much information.. loved it.. Thanks CINEINK..
Thanks. Please subscribe to this channel- Cineink- on youtube for important programmes. Thanks.
Yadi hindustan me kuchh bhi nahi tha to ye videshi invedor india kyon aate the?
our rich fertile land
Ye sare invader bharat quon aaye. Quon ke bharat ek bahot amir ilaaka tha. Maan liya ke yaha kharbuze aur anaar nahi the lekin aur chize thee.
Naangi dosheezayein thein.Bhai hamaray zooq o shoq evolve nai hova tou bhar sai anay waly hum sai achy thy tou ounkay laye tariay chal paray . Khalaq e khuda tou bhai tang nazar nai hoti ousko jo acha lgta apna laiti
india mein different type ki spices hai north to south east to west toh saab bahar sa aaye
Yes, some of them. Please do read on the origin of various vegetables and fruits on the net. Sir, world's knowledge is in your domain. You must find a credible website. You don't have to believe the politically motivated hand outs.
Look what we found on the net: Spices and herbs (e.g., black pepper, cinnamon, turmeric, cardamom) have been used by Indians for thousands of years for both culinary and health purposes. Spices indigenous to India (e.g. cardamom and turmeric) were cultivated as early as the 8th century BC in the gardens of Babylon (Sinha, 2003; Tapsell, 2006).
Susruta, an ancient surgeon (around 4th century BC) used white mustard and other aromatic plants in bed sheets to ward off malignant spirits. He also applied a poultice from sesame to post operation wounds which may have acted as an antiseptic.
Medical writings of Charaka (1st century) and Susruta II (2nd century) referenced spices and herbs. Susruta II also used spices and herbs such as cinnamon, cardamom, ginger, turmeric, and pepper for healing purposes. Spices such as cardamom, ginger, black pepper, cumin, and mustard seed were included in ancient herbal medicines for different types of health benefits. In Ayurvedic medicine, spices such as cloves and cardamom were wrapped in betel-nut leaves and chewed after meals to increase the flow of saliva and aid digestion.
Jeera, cumin, and Shah zeera, though common now, came from the middle East and Egypt. Kalounji from Iran and Turkey. Green chilly, tomato, potato, are new world crops discovered by the Portugese in 15th century and brought to Europe which colonists brought to india. Hindus dont add these to sattvic food. I think India only had ginger, haldi, pepper and rai or sarso, plys numerous spices like jakhia, unknown in North India now. Population migrations brought the other spices to the subcontinent. Hing came from middle east. so too tez patta, almonds, kishmish, saffron, gulkand. Roses themselves are Persian.
Spices were never found out of Indian subcontinent. If any ,they were completely different. stop making your lieful dubious history.
@@prodiptoroy830 Saffron kidhar sai?
@@abbasgondal6691 Kripya Mohan Rao ke lekh mein dekhe. Par ye nishchaya hai ki Iran ka saffron mahshur hai. Mongol army ise Spain aur doosre European desh mein le gaye.
Hamara kuch hai bhi itihaaskaar sahib, ya hum hi jahil the
No, he's saying we borrowed certain things from the outside world and they too borrowed from us. This is true!
PS: Thanks for your comments. We respect your engagement with us. Perhaps, Cine Ink on TH-cam is the only channel where each and every comment is responded to. But we do remove and report comments which violate the basic decency norms. No swearing words please, no attack on any religion, cast & colour, and no sexist & misogynistic remarks against women please. Thanks.
You can also engage with us through our various platforms on social media such as: facebook.com/cineink/
twitter.com/cineinknews
www.cineink.com
Ignorant bigoted Indians think a Muslim must be lying. Hindus had a phobia of iron tools touching clothing. the needle was polluting. so only unstitched clothes were used. even now in ritual dress Hindus use unstitched clothes. If you want to verify the veggies list read a Hindu writer Mohan Rao. My only doubt is about the pumpkin, kumra. there's no doubt about the gifts of South America to the world in the form of potatoes, tomatoes, chillies and capsicum. your Naan, tandoori roti, Chhole bature come from Afghanistan - visit the IITF sometime and see for yourself. Origin of Apples is Kazakhistan. Cherries and peaches from Iran. read Babar - nama. Khubani, Alu Bukhara are obviously from his birthplace in Fergana, Uzbekistan.
Abe ye aise hi bolte Hain...read the books of Rajiv Malhotra.
@@prodiptoroy830
भारतीय जंगली थे
नंगेभुखे
जंगलो मे भटकते थे
फिर अल्लाऊददीन खीलजी
बाबर जैसे महान समाजसुधरक और साधुसंत
भारतीयो पर दया करने के लिए
अरब और कझागिस्तानसे चले आये
यहाँ के मनुवादीयोने ऊनको रोकने की कोशिश की
पर सभी मनुवादी राजा हार गये
फिर पाचसौ साल तक
सारे भारतीयो को
खिलजी बाबर गझनवि और ऊनके अनूयायीयो ने मुफ्त की
रोटी कपडा मकान शिक्षा और रोजगार दिया
लेकीन एहसान फरमोश भारतीय ईस बात को नही मानते
ईससे बंगाल मे बैठे हुए
कम्युनिस्ट भाईयो के नाजुक दिल पर गहरा आघात हो रहा
है
कीतने दुखी है
ईन एहसानफरमोश भारतीयो पर माओ की तरह
सारे बुर्झ्वा को हटाकर नयी क्रांति करना चाहीए
जैसे चीन मे माओ ने कितने मिलीयन लोगो को मार दिया था
भारत मे वैसे भी जनसंख्या बढ गयी ऊतनाही राष्र्टीय जनसंख्या कम करने काम हो जाएगा
@@prodiptoroy830 koi tou hai Jo aqal ki baat krta Thank God
Informative presentation by Sohail Hashmi an JNU analyst. Nathan Sekhar Sydney Australia..
wah!!! jyan ke bhandar h sir ap...
Nice
Thik hi hai Chaman ke angoor, Kandhar ke anaar hi kahe jaaye the.
Kuchh to log kahenge...logon ka kaam hai kehna. Thanks.
before Buddhist rulers like Ashoka Hindus and particularly Vedic Brahmins ate beef. read Aitariya Brahmana where Vedic lawmaker Yagyavalkya wins a debate in the court of Raja Janak. he is gifted the 1000 cows promised to him. when Janak expresses his anxiety about the cows' fate, Yagyavalkya says: I know I shouldn't (eat them). But if the flesh is tender, I will." Beef was the best flesh to be offered to Gods, Brahmins and guests in the Vedas. ignorant Hindu mobs now lynch people on suspicion of using beef of food. our elected heroes go abroad and hug confirmed beef eaters like Obama, Trump, Abe, Macron, Lula, the list is too long. For vegetarians, read Amarakosha, a catalogue of things which also lists common Indian vegetables in Buddhist times such as the patol, various gourds, sweet potato, rice and barley. Wheat btw, comes from Ethiopia and the Middle East. Tea from China. eithet we want to remain ignorant or we study a bit before insulting genuine scholars.
prodipt
if dont know
interpritation sankrit language
dont misinterprit
meaning as
told of communist university
to defame history
of INDIAN CIVILISATION &CULTURE
PHILOSOPHY
what a shame
INDIAN brains have been utilized to defame our own civiization culture traditions and history
and philosophy
Chaman is in balouchistan
hassan ali yes, Its a part of Pakistan...
Ladh ke liye tha Pakistan, hans ke leinge hindustan... Inshah Allah
Perhaps then you'll rename it to Goodistan@@syedmuradhamadani2880 Mujhe nahi pata ki aap kahan se ho but I know that you will never know what freedom feels like. You're not free and you will never be free of these limits you've imposed on yourself willingly. You will always be bound by them and you will never be free.
This guy is hugely misinformed. Leaving after wasting 10 minutes of my life. N 1 minute writing it.
Any reason, Sir?
Which info/ fact did not meet your approval
@@rajeevgopal806 One hope that's a question!
Prove him wrong?????
@@zohaibhasan3332 With logic and facts. Thanks.
Cinevision is very high degree forum. Very few likes? What it reflects...
Prejudice
and for Muslims jitni marzi chaploosi kr lo milna kuch nai.
Thanks for watching. Please subscribe to Cine Ink here on youtube.
Thanks for watching. Please subscribe to Cine Ink here on youtube.
Nasir Kamal salempur deoria
Shukriya Nasir.
Sirji bahut khub.
What do you expect from such people
Nothing or perhaps a lot!
@@CINEINK good funding from isi ,good job
Sirji u r absolutely correct, keep spreading knowledge
Me AAP Ki Baat Se Sehmat Nahi Hu,,Are Bhai Bharat To Iran,Aur Iraq Takk Fela Huva Tha,,Bahut Baada Tha Bharat,,Jo Aaj Bhi Bola Jaata Hai,,Bharat Khand,,
Balky bhai sari dunya aur asman mein jitny golay hein sb ko bhat bolty thay but kiya krein gao motar ka nasha kr kr k sb khoo diya sk sad
@@abbasgondal6691 Tumhare Baap Dada Bhi To Isme Shamil The,,Tum Log Bhool Bahut Jaate Ho,,Ex Hindu,,
@@kapildave5361 Ji but ab hum jahan hein khush hein Kam az kam untouchable tou nahein hein
@@abbasgondal6691 Actually Tum Logo Ko Bahut Galat Faimi Hai,,Me Really Jaana Chahata Hu Ki,,Tum Ne Gondal Kyu Likha,,Badi Mehrabani Hongi,,
Thanks for watching. Please join this channel- Cine Ink - here on TH-cam to get advance information about our programmes in Hindi and Urdu.
chacha aap bhi pehle muslim ni thha, aapke ancesstor hindu the...
eis mein kiya burai hai agar ous nai gao mot peena chour diya hai. laiken apki itlaa k liye he's Hashmi aur hashmi arab nasal hai not indian. Sb bkwas krny k bjaye ap yeh socho k ap k dharam ko log q chourtay hein
Bahut Bahut shukria Hashmi ji 🙏
Shukriya aapka bhi. Please subscribe to this channel- Cine Ink- on TH-cam to get latest info about such programmes in advance. Thanks.
lekin buddhist stupas bhi gumbad ki tarah hote the
Islam se pahle Hindu the
Absolutely correct! He also says how Hindu architecture impacted on Islamic architecture.
PS: Thanks for your comments. We respect your engagement with us. Perhaps, Cine Ink on TH-cam is the only channel where each and every comment is responded to. But we do remove and report comments which violate the basic decency norms. No swearing words please, no attack on any religion, cast & colour, and no sexist & misogynistic remarks against women please. Thanks.
You can also engage with us through our various platforms on social media such as: facebook.com/cineink/
twitter.com/cineinknews
www.cineink.com
We also got Jihad and ghajwa-E-hind from outside which we need to send it back :)
Great idea!
Tegor ka ek bahin or bhabi ye introduce kiya. Tegor brahamma samajka tha.
Sitar god Laxmi ke hath me me tha Wahi se Nikla h
It was Veena, perhaps, and not a sitar. We stand corrected. Sitar is a Persian modification.
Zabardast
#vertexeventsdubai
Dubai ne keh diya to bus saabit hua zabardast. Please subscribe to Cine Ink here on TH-cam to get free videos on topical themes. Thanks.
Mandr manir hota hai
Khayali poulav dekana he toh iss episode ko deko haas haas kepagal ho jayege 😂😂😂😂😂
OK. Thanks.
Invaders aaye humare logo ko maara humnein fir bhi apna religion nahi choda. Unke cultures say bhi cheejain li but invaders nay jo genocide kiya hume ussay problem hai.
Thanks for watching.
PS: Thanks for your comments. We respect your engagement with us. Perhaps, Cine Ink on TH-cam is the only channel where each and every comment is responded to. But we do remove and report comments which violate the basic decency norms. No swearing words please, no attack on any religion, cast & colour, and no sexist & misogynistic remarks against women please. Thanks.
You can also engage with us through our various platforms on social media such as: facebook.com/cineink/
twitter.com/cineinknews
www.cineink.com
What’s the point of this interview? Trying so hard to prove that one should not be proud of their civilization, Indian civilization, whatever way people express it. The world DOES NOT acknowledge Indian civilization or India. For the most part. For the common western junta, India is the land of snake charmers, IT and bothersome call centers. Being ruled by outsiders who settled in India but trace their roots somewhere else and remain segregated, they will take several generations to really be integrated into the concept of a nation state. In a world of nation states, everyone needs a a thought to feel proud of themselves. Everything in this world, every thought is borrowed. What is really original? The most popular Italian food is all borrowed; poor Italians don’t feel proud of who you are as we are going to do another vlog with this dude! Maybe we should go back and find out that those same borrowed concepts were borrowed from India. Giving Indians a reality check, eh? Integrate Mr. Historian, not segregate thoughts.
Rajiv Bhai, the point is simple; Sohail Hashmi is responding to those who have suddenly discovered a puritanical streak to outcast XYZ from the Indian culture/Indian history. They have reduced the argument to this - What's Indian and what's not Indian. Some of them have started purging Urdu words from Hindi calling them foreign influences. He's integrating them by saying hey you can't even make out what's Indian and what's not. So, stop this nonsense.
Sometimes, we interview people who are in the news. Find more about his series on the net.
I hope when you replied “stop this nonsense”, it was a generic comment for those who pursue puritanical BS. Just to be clear what I commented is not nonsense.
The question I raise is to highlight the fallacies about countering statements from the uneducated, by someone who has facts and figures on his fingertips and portrayed as learned and Mr. Historian. Everyone is searching for an identity; what is the Indian identity? It’s certainly not the puritanical BS, or the borrowed one as implied by Mr. Historian, but the amalgamation of 7000 year inhabited history. Indian food is spicy not because of the red chilies, but the spices in it which the western world cane looking for in the 1600s. So say it as it is. India is richer for its diversity, and diversity is the new spice which enriches is as who we are.
Couldn't agree with you more. Diversity is India's strength. The outcome of that ancient civilisation with its great diversity is great music, great culture, great cuisine and great architecture!
Bhakatoo ko Kaun samjhaye.
Bhakt ko uske haal pe rehne deejiye. Apna paighaam mohabbat hai jahaan tak ponhche.
Musalman our sikh hindu sa azadi siraf talban kee tra la sakta hain verna gulami kee zindgi un kee un ka bachon ka nseeb ha
To Tere Ko Roka Kiss Ne Hai,,Tu Shuroo To Karr Khata Hum Karenge,,Saale Ex,,Hindu,,
@@kapildave5361 Shoudar k bachy tou khud b tou untouchable hai
@@kapildave5361 Bari Mherbani bhai kbi aewo khushbu laga k
Then you are not Indian
All seven generations are Indian but who the hell are you issue certificates?
indian -yes ; bharatiya - hell no !
Chaman is in Pakistan.
But it was one country before 1947!
Chaman in slaying means bewaqoof Chaman border pai hai afg Pk donu taraf.
@@CINEINK I couldn't understand why Indian Muslims hate PK Jb k hum suba shaam concerned rehty ap k liye duayein mangty. And most of u guys celebrated curfew in Kashmir it was shocking for me.Mein nai tou bhot sarun sai no more rabta even they knew that my whole family lives in IOK they teased me with the statments of amat shah and RSS goons. Why are you guys so sick and scared.Scene kiya hai I couldn't comprehend
I don't understand as to why the PK Muslims are so sick and hate Islam and Muslims. Why do foundations of PK consist of lies, more lies, cowardice, hypocrisy??? Why did they have their Qaid who was a pork eating, wine drinking anti religious man his entire life, whose only daughter married a non muslim, had non muslim children, never even stepped in Pakistan (except for India/Pakistan match some fifty years later) and lived her life in India. Why did Pakistanis hate muslims so much that they killed almost 3 million Muslims in Bangladesh considering Bengalis as black, lowly people from low lying areas, and raped 200,000 women within a few months so that there could come out newer breed of non Bengalis out of these Bengali Muslims? Why have they always hated the Muhajirs so much that they killed and maimed entire Karachi for years on? Why do they hate the Baloch Muslims so much that they consider entire Balochistan as a rebellious region and killed the Bughtis and other Baloch to this day?? Why do they hate the Pakhtuns so much that they still consider them to be traitors and hence want to kill the PTM?? Why do you hate the Sindhi Muslims so much that you don't even consider them to be functional muslims not worthy of anything except being animals good enough to be kept as slaves???
And finally why do you hate the Kashmiri Muslims so much that the only time you are energized is when the Kashmiris are killed, raped, murdered?? It seems as if you are so happy when tragedy strikes them that entire Pakistan goes into a frenzy. It seems you wait for such tragedy to take place because this is the only way in which your impotent paki army can sell out the blood, tears, respect, honour, and soul of the Kashmiris in return of some pennies that you can get out of the West. The paki army is at best a mercenary army to collect some bheek from the West in lieu of the blood, tears, honour and soul of the Muslims everywhere around the world and in Pakistan too like they did in Waziristan (Zarb-e-azb) and at worst they are a dispecable cowards exactly like the Sanghis in India.
My brother in Islam, why are the Pakistanis such haters of Muslims and why have they always used, misused, abused, disabused Islam to get bheek from anywhere and everywhere exactly as the Sanghis in India do with Hinduism??? Why do you hate Islam so much exactly as the Sanghis hate religion in general and Islam/Hinduism in particular?? What let's you as a nation and as a people to be such parasite upon the muslims of your own country and Muslims everywhere around the world exactly as the Sanghis are parasites upon the Indians??
What is it that makes you so sick, wretched, mean and disgusting exactly like the Sanghis??
@@pamtam1 das kilo tatti kam khaya kro pathan sb
Islam dushman channel hai.
Islam dushman? Kaise?
The criticism that you've received from two opposing directions is evidence of your neutrality @@CINEINK Kuchh log decide nahi kar paa rahein hain ki aap kis taraf ho. I was able to find you because of the Author of Military Inc. She had been mentioned by Tahir Gora so I had to look her up to find this channel. Then I saw that interview of Owais that you had chosen to conduct in front of Jama Masjid. Sohail is a freaking legend I've been following him for a while no one else can inform you about culture, food and architecture as passionately as he does. I had also noticed Yogendra Yadav in one of your videos. Is that you whispering the name of the channel in the beginning of the video?
P.S.: I'm going to save you the trouble of pasting the footnote template:
" Thanks for your comments. We respect your engagement with us. Perhaps, Cine Ink on TH-cam is the only channel where each and every comment is responded to. But we do remove and report comments which violate the basic decency norms. No swearing words please, no attack on any religion, cast & colour, and no sexist & misogynistic remarks against women please. Thanks.
You can also engage with us through our various platforms on social media such as: facebook.com/cineink/
twitter.com/cineinknews
www.cineink.com " You had added this at the end of many of your comments in the comment section of another video. I have been binge watching your videos all night thanks for taking up all of my time😡!
Kuch bhi tamoto chod ke baki sabhi chijh hindustani tha ye joot bol rahe he
Why do you have to trust this man? Please google your question.
@@CINEINK ok I will reply you point to point with proof on this topic. Actually I am businessmen little busy. But I will explain you soon
Whan you Google any news mostly search on trusted website & person. In India there is list buyers person on outside funding. Even historian also.
@@p.m.malusare9162 SubhanAllah
@@p.m.malusare9162 Biusness man sb Angriazi b India ki zuban thee700 saal phely kuch log England ja basay kuch brahmin sufaid rangat walay tou phir yeh wahan ki language bn gye