Agreed. There are others who try and end up looking like they're playing a part and are not genuine. Amy is truly genuine, honest and knowledgeable. This is why i am hooked on her videos. thank you Amy :)
@@bushchat28d I follow her also.......she is one of my other favorites. My musical training is zilch, but my love for music and understanding is great.
Nearly 200 songs by Queen , not a bad one among them. They are the background music to my life and nobody that I've never even met , have had a such i big effect on me. Ive thoroughly enjoyed your analysis and joy in discovering Queen all these years later. Thank you
Yes! I can agree with that, no bad songs Even love "hot space" it was different in Ways but still quality and they were a great part of my life also, and a learning experience as a musician, I really enjoy Her reactions and personal analysis From her knowledge of music. 😊
3:29 Hi Amy, you wonder why the press talks about "gimmicks" when they discuss Queen. Well, you've got to know that the music critics hated Queen back then! They were into very simple Punk music and other very repetetive Rock. Queen was too theatrical for the critics, they didn't find Queen 'cool'. They prefered 'street credibility' over compositions. It was often more or less grudgingly that they admitted that Queen's music had musical sophistication and substance to it. Fortunately the public decided otherwise, and made sure that Queen became superstars.
After so much negativity, ignorance and bias against Queen over the years by ill-informed, pompous critics , I'm so glad a musician with the pedigree and insight that Amy possesses is showcasing their unbelievably rich, exotic and wonderful music. Know any critics music? Thought not....
I love hearing why people don't like something. You need to listen to people who don't like what you like. "Know any critics music?". Amy Shafer is a critic and I don't know any of her music. You aren't saying anything with that question.
Here's something you might have missed in the live performance. The second time Freddie gets up from the piano, the lead guitarist plays a sustained note then leaves the stage. He's having some issue with his guitar. Freddie watches him leave not knowing why and has to improv till he's back, hence the audience participation. Freddie hears a few notes isolated notes from Brian - in keeping with the tune they're playing - and looks over to see Brian. Brian must give him a nod or something because Freddie immediately starts into the 10 x 'find me somebody to love' and Brian was back at the mic in time for his backing vocal. None of whatever happened detracted from the performance, even though Freddie had to unexpectedly wing it with 'I didn't see this coming" going through his mind - but I doubt whether anyone in the audience even noticed, and most who watch the live vid don't notice. I'm going to suggest another which other people might have already suggested, or which Vlad might have lined up on your list of 50. (I only found you tonight so haven't seen everything you've done.) I'm suggesting you watch Queen at the Live Aid concert in 1985 and then watch Fil on the Wings of Pegasus channel explain exactly why their performance was as it was. Btw, I know nothing about classical music but I'm loving that you're exploring Queen and you are most interesting to listen to, with your background in classical training. All the best :)
The call and response is almost pentecostal; the response is supporting the singer/speech-giver by providing him with the mental strength to continue the emotional journey that is the sermon!
I do hope Brian, Roger and John get told by someone to watch this analysis. It will give them a true sense of their legacy, and how a deep respect and appreciation for Queen's music will only continue to grow and grow as the years pass.
Myself being an old recording/mixing engineer... it still blows me away to this day at how good the backing vocals are for the way they've recorded it. Freddie, Roger, and Brian just stood around 1 microphone, which is very hard to do, rather than recording each voice separately. Of course, they layered it many times to make it sound big and full but, their pitch is fantastic. Anytime I have a clients that want to record vocals like that, it rarely turns out how they're expecting it to. Inevitably, there's always at least one person that's out of key each pass to ruin the take. I just end up recording some of them separately and building it up from there. Queen are consummate professionals.
@@stacer1962 Back then, you only had 24 tracks. You did as much as you could live so you didn't have the bounce the tape as much. Freddie would always do many overdubs on his own but, groups would definitely stand around one mic often for a couple of takes if they were trying to get a choir sound out of 3-4 guys. The slight pitch variation is what makes it sound big.
Yes queen backing vocals were amazing, and addition the fact each Member individually sang each note of a chord then combined it to have 3 Different voices for each note. I was always fascinated with that technique 😊
If only we had more conservatory music teachers that could showcase and embrace this type of music with such open minded passion and quirky curiosity without possessing any fixed favoritism or bias. Ms. Shafer's balance of contextual understanding in her musical analysis - mixed with her wide-eyed, almost child-like wonder at the music itself - warms my insides and fills my eyes with happy tears... Godspeed, Amy and Vlad...
You are 100% correct. Yes, Queen can be flamboyant, campy, and a touch silly (and they can truly rock in the classic sense) but that is Freddy just being Freddy. He was all of those things and he is never truly "playing a part" the way an actor may do. Everything came straight from the heart. There were times I thought the Beatles were silly for the sake of being silly. I never once felt that with Queen. I do hope you get to '39!
@@79BlackRose It may appear that way but there was actually a darker story behind it. Freddie created the song, because one of the warnings or side effects from the Aids medication was forgetfulness and psychiatric problems. Freddie was really afraid of these side effects, so he created this more humorous song to deal with this issue, luckily it wasn't a problem for him. But the song is actually making light of a very dark situation, Freddie often took this type of approach to darker themes.
The gospel-religious, suitable for a church aspect of the song is perfect not just because of it’s basic sound, but also because it is, in essence, a prayer.
There are plenty of famous rock bands that can make a lot of noise, but having had the privilege of seeing Queen live many times I don't know of any 4 piece that can make an absolute orchestrated rhythmatic wall of sound that makes some sort of musical sense as well as they can live... just amazing what 4 people can do. No wonder they are considered probably the best live band ever.
first, I want to let you know that yours is the best analysis of the song that I've heard. Yep, Freddie was accused of gimmicky or camp song writing, etc, but you know, many of his closest friends remind us that Freddie was camp when he was comfortable around them. So, he was being himself. Also, listening to Somebody To Love studio version (or watching the Official Video Version, which is the same recording) is the best way to get the introduction to the song. To hear it how Freddie planned it, rich with vocal harmonies and multi-layers. Then my next favorite is watching the version you did. While, of course in concert, Queen didn't play recordings or backup so they could not give you the multi-layer harmonies, what they did give you was straight-up knock you out of your seat performance! Freddie gets the crowd going with audience participation. Rather than hand-claps, they use drum beat and bass slaps. It's live live live. No clicks. No auto-tune. Glad you experienced both versions.
I think it’s important not to put much weight into what magazine rock critics have to say like the statement of using gimmicks. Most of the time the magazine critics are total hacks that know nothing about real music. Many of them tried to make it themselves, failed and then would seek to put down successful musicians to make themselves appear superior.
Concur. Rolling stone is probably the worst, but yillage voice and cream are right up there. I find the well known critics to be pretentious snobs. One of the few I really liked back in the day is Lenny Kay ( lead guitarist Patti Smith group) his enjoyment of the music comes through in his reviews. I also used to like the short 1 paragraph reviews of lesser known groups in rolling stone and spin during the early to mid 80's. Again they were written by people who liked the music not someone trying to show how much smarter they were then us.
Well... that was just awesome, thank you Amy and a big BIG , thank you to Vlad for including the live version , a wonderful decision. It wasn`t just Vlad who was excited in anticipation. The song didn`t disappoint Amy , and the reaction didn`t disappoint us ! oh no , not at all.
Freddie really loved Aretha Franklin, Brian May said 'I think he wanted to BE Aretha!' This song is in hommage to her. As everyone will say...Please, even if it's in your own time, watch the Montreal 1981 live version of this, and to get a further comparison, Milton Keynes 1982. This perfectly exemplifies how Queen never treated a song quite the same in each concert, and very rarely as it originally sounded in the studio. Thank you
So very glad you also saw the live Montreal version. Your comment about how tight and competent the band members are live on stage. Notice when Freddie gets up from the piano the second time and walks toward the front of the stage to interact with the audience, he looks back and you can briefly see Brian May walking to the back of the stage. Brian is going to repair a broken guitar string. Freddie leads Roger and John in an improvised segment to cover for Brian’s absence. The shot expands and you see John slapping the bass and you see Freddie look to the back of the stage, sees that Brian has completed his repairs and continues with the song and you see Brian come back into the shot. The band was so well rehearsed and so tight that they “communicated” with each other with little looks and was able to follow Freddie’s lead seamlessly.
I think that happened in Milton Keynes during Dragon Attack. Normally, Brian May begins his solo immediately after the second verse is finished. At the Bowl, since a string on his Red Special snapped by that point in the song, he gave Deacon and Taylor an extra bar while he grabbed a replica of his guitar to resume playing. It sounds so natural that one in the crowd would fail to notice, especially since the studio recording also includes the brief break in the melody.
@@Inverse_to_Chaos Yes, that was another incident. John was able to briefly replicate his bass solo that was on the studio version. They were so well in tune with each other that they were easily able to cover for each other.
Brian didn't break a string there. He is still using his red special and there's no way anyone can change a string in 10 seconds. As much as I love Queen, you're noticing things that didn't happen.
Hi. Have you ever seen the movie Lord Of The Rings: The Fellowship of the Rings. There is a scene where Gandolf arrives and Bilbo says "Your late". Gandolf replies "A wizard is never late, or early, he arrives precisely when he means to." Queen are like that. No, there are no gimmicks. Everything is precisely where it needs to be. The call and response, sometimes the response comes before the call. They are Queen, they can do that, they make their own rules. Thank you for acknowledging John Deacon, his bass work is always brilliant. Oh, and the drum on this track is spectacular, as is the guitar! I think you might enjoy The Millionaires Walt, from the same album. There is even a little bit where Freddie speaks in a faux German accent!! And the bass on that track is beyond excellent! Edited, this is the first time I have watched you, and I just checked and found you have already done Millionaires Waltz, I'm going to watch that now!!!
The thing I love most about this song is the constantly changing interaction between Freddie and the choir. They alternate constantly, but every time in a slightly different way. Different rhythms, sometimes call & response, sometimes emphasising, sometimes interrupting, sometimes the choir announces what the solo is going to sing, sometimes they follow him. Sometimes the solo has the lead, sometimes the choir. It keeps changing and keeps getting more and more interesting. And that live performance! Roger Taylor pulling the choir entirely on his own much of the time (sometimes with Brian May, but let's be honest, Roger did most of the work there). Roger is in my opinion the most underrated singer in rock. He s fantastic, great range, and I think he actually has a more stable, reliable voice than Freddie, though not quite that magical edge or the soul that Freddie has.
I want to share my admiration for the band Queen, who I consider to be one of the most incredibly talented bands of all time. In my opinion, their versatility, uniqueness, and ability to play together in perfect harmony are second only to The Beatles. I believe that each member's contribution to the music is invaluable and helps propel the song forward, like perpetual motion. I particularly want to give a shout-out to John Deacon, the bassist, for his outstanding work in every song, including taking the lead in some parts, which often goes unrecognized. He is a true musical genius, just like the other band members, Freddie, Brian, and Roger. It is remarkable how every band member contributes to the momentum and keeps the song moving in the right direction. This particular song is my favourite, and it holds a lot of personal meaning for me.
You very much understand Freddy already. That IS just genuinely him! He all by himself is the very definition of dynamic, and then when you add the dynamics of his amazing band mates, it is quite a lot! Quite a lot of awesome!
The album version is excellent, but be sure to check out the Live in Montreal version from 1981 - absolutely fantastic, and showcases Freddie's mastery of the stage and Roger Taylor's excellent backing vocals.
8:11 a tiny thing that is actually very important... Freddie is insecure, the band is reassuring... He sings Someday, the band sings One-day... just a nice example of how deep these lyrics go...
The experience of facing something genuine has no substitute. To feel the inner true of another self through his art is as hard to explain as it is easy to experience.
The so-called Billboard music critics were just a bunch of pompous "no it all's". They always panned Queen, but the band's lasting popularity is the world's validation of Queen's genius.
So cool to see a classical musician utterly engrossed in the music of Queen. I had a smile on my face for the whole reaction, just awesome. I would love to see Brian, Roger and John watching your reaction Amy as I'm sure they too would have similar smiles. Well done and belated congratulations on your 100k subs milestone too :-)
Freddie Mercury and Queen are sort of like Cinderella. Under appreciated in the 70's - and found their full glory as the rest of civilization caught up to their 20 years ahead of them time. Now - 30 years after Queen became popular - the whole world recognizes Freddie as the greatest Rock Singer of all time - and perhaps the greatest showman ever. Freddie is simply an - ALL TIME - personality in the long-long history of the world.
I hope you've included the Highlander soundtrack in your Queen selections. Apparently the forthcoming re-make will include the original Queen soundtrack.
Didn't know there was a re-make in the works, but I'm not at all surprised since 99% of movies in the last 20 years are re-makes and never very good re-makes. But at least the movie soundtrack will be EXCELLENT!
@@davidrichards6509 Yeah, Chad Stahelski, the director of the John Wick series is currently in charge. Besides being a long term stuntman, Chad is also a martial artist with extensive experience in Filipino Martial Arts. Many people don't realize that fencing and knife fighting in Filipino culture is as developed as in say Japan, so the movie should be VERY good.
ปีที่แล้ว +6
Hey! This time, my address is for Vlad. Thank you, man. I love you. Discovering, like Amy does, Somebody To Love by Queen without that live version would be blasphemy. As I said earlier here in comments, I believe that absolutely every song by Queen was created with the stage in mind, even if twisted and worked for the studio recordings. I wish you all the best. Cheers!
Thank you for this wonderful reaction, and a big thank-you to Vlad for arranging the surprise live version reaction! I had a sneaking suspicion that might happen! :) These Queen reactions have really made the weekends more enjoyable!
Roger om Drums and vocals live is unreal when they played this live - drives the song so well and takes over the lead chorus at the end with voice reversals with Freddie - outstanding !
Starting with the Official recording (this one) is great!! Then go to the live one in Montreal in 1981 as a follow up will please you. Every time Freddie does a concert, he sings the songs differently and the two concerts, one in Montreal and the other at Milton Keynes in 1982 are just amazing. I love watching your reactions.
I agree. The way Brian’s guitar emulates Freddie’s voice at times is underestimated brilliance. Freddie’s vocals are unmatched but Brian manages to continue his melodies with clever guitar solos.
I love how accomplished musicians describe a piece of music like a chef describing every flavour of a delicious meal no one else can taste or an architect describing a building no one else can envisage without drawing a picture!
Freddie really was always looking for that one special somebody to love. Living in a boarding school thousands of miles from his parents affecting him for the rest of his life. Yes, this is his real feelings
It would be great if you could set up an interview with Brian May - he's very humble, intellectual and my guess is he'd love your analysis, knowledge and enthusiasm.
There was only one Freddie Mercury. He lived his nickname through his music with all of his passion and emotion. He must have been a very contagious person to work with. His energy fed the other bandmembers and the four of them together even rose above his sizzling energy. The sum of their parts multiplied the outcome. Mathematical this is impossible. So may we call it magic? But true magic, not the trickery by a magician, but magic that goes beyond the powers of man. It seems as if they were inspired by Freddie, and then their combined inspiration again fed them all as well. An explosion of artistry as a result. The same effect occurred when Freddie met and worked with montserrat Caballé. The utter inspiration we can witness, is so far out there. I am glad how you presented Freddie at the start of the song hitting this one note, that triggered an outpoor of emotion, so well presented within the production, arrangement of this song. It all came together here. This is why this particulair Queen song is so magical to me. Again, magic as in 'not from this world'.
Yes, he sure was and is an inspiration. I’d like to add though that there was already magic between Brian and Roger, you can tell by listening to Smile. What a band, what talents!
Playing an instrument well on your own is something. Playing well together with another musician is something else. Bands like Queen have musicianship on another level, and yes, that definitely shines through in the live clip.
Vlad, show Amy the footage from Live Aide. There's a clip where he has the entire audience of 72,000 people following his vocal cues and it's just amazing! But she should react to the whole performance, they completely stole the show!
I can't begin to tell you how much I appreciate your appreciation of this song! Not only does it offer a sort of validation for my deep love of Queen (not that I feel the need for that validation), but your analysis has given me an entirely new layer of appreciation for the song.
One of my absolute favorite reactions from you. When you put your hand on your chin and just smiled. Lost in the joy and wonder of Freddy and Queen. He definitely found somebody to love in all of us loving him and his legacy. Your reaction was priceless. Thank you for all you do!
Hi 👋 Mrs. Amy. Yes, that’s what it did to me the first time I listened to it…it’s absolute genius and perfection in its apparently simplicity, compared to more lively classical music. When I first listen to “tunnel of love” (very luckily🍀 by my powerful Walkman headphones) from Dire Straits, I had kind of a such a pleasant thrill. It happened many years ago and I didn’t have a clue for it at that time. Few days ago I watched a reaction video of that song and the TH-camr said at the end of the track: “that’s the closest thing to sex you can have by your ears” and I immediately remembered that sensation. I mean, these perfect and timeless songs translate themselves naturally and almost automatically into kind of physical pleasure for people sensitive to music (in your case also profound connoisseurs of it) as we are. Here is why I asked out loud for “the prophet song” reaction. Because of its clever and powerful crescendo storyboard, it’s theatrical and visionary acoustic (but also visual, as you also said) scenes. Anyway, how is it possible that 4 young men has been such an artistic volcano 🌋 for more than 30 years? I personally struggle to think it’s really possible without a deep, deep, deep talent and inspiration. I ❤ Queen so much, so excuse me for the long comment.
Thank you Vlad for having her watch the live version also! It's one thing to make greatness on a studio track that you can do all this cool layering and retakes. It's another thing to bring it live and get the whole crowd invested. Just like going to church on Sunday!
Your explanation od Freddie’s passion and “all in” way of performing was so on point. Some are uncomfortable with it. Me…. My heart explodes with every listen ( especially live performances ). Thank you for going on this journey.
Since Amy is concentrating upon listening with her expert ear and knowledge, then at least listening to the Montreal version is well worth the experience. Freddie's performance in front of an audience always seemed to add "thousands of volts of electricity" . So Amy, I do enjoy your reactions and insights; I am not the only one who would love to see you react to the Montreal Somebody to Love, either listening, or even better watching this wonderful performance. The studio version that you are about to release your comments on is great of course.
And the next one who should insert their foot into their mouth and eat their words, because they are eager to jump onto videos and commenting without watching them first. If you had done that, you would not have written this comment...
Freddie Mercury couldn’t find his love until he was 38. It was a matter of time and experience for him to maintain a successful relationship lasting 6 years until his final breath. 💞
I've learned after 58 years that being alone doesn't have to mean loneliness. You can find and feel loneliness in a relationship. I've found to be comfortable within myself is more important than to be uncomfortable along with another person. Yet, I'm still waiting for that special person who thinks I'm special too. Being able to truly love yourself is a special relationship in it's own. Faults, warts and all. I still wake up and I still hope and keep on trying. Nothing beats a failure, but a try.
@@rodneygriffin7666 Thanks for the advice as I’m only 21 and also on the rainbow. Earlier this year, I read Jim Hutton’s semi-autobiographical work that described his relationship with Mercury, and since he was diagnosed as tabloids exposed his previous relationships, he became increasingly private and did not socially interact outside of his friend zone and band. He must have felt ostracised by those who betrayed him, to the point where he didn’t know whom to trust. I think Hutton’s presence helped him emotionally as he knowingly got closer to his death bed. I still hope I find the right people to be around, and this song always encourages me to get up and go searching. :-)
With regard to the 'Gimmick' aspect of the contemporary review in 1976.... For some context Amy, The American press in newspaper and magazine media HATED Queen at the time for the most part. Us fans at the time (I was 13 when this came out) couldn't understand what it was these reviewers were listening to?!! I always found their diversity of styles to be a strength that few other bands could approach. Many of the reviews were very toxic and spiteful. Screw 'em all!
I guess that everyone that’s watches you wish’s we were vlad the absolute joy and pleasure the excitement of getting to share something for the first time with your friends is one of the best feelings ever. Vlad is def my hero for doing this for you
Something I particularly noticed is that after the crescendo and Freddy's voice fading out, the players all come back in one at a time like a curtain call, and they are all rigidly bound to the beat, while Freddy's voice isn't bound to the rhythm at all for the entire rest of the work. It's as if he has set himself free after all.
I was eagerly waiting for this reaction, the studio version, and thank you for the amazing surprise at the end, watching to the brilliant live performance. 😍 Freddie was a passionate guy, he was full of emotions, feelings, and he was able to set them into music, sadness, happiness, anger or the desire to love, to be loved.
Don’t know how many Queen fans think of this as their favorite Queen song but I have since I first fell in love with it… and Queen and especially Freddie. Like others I keep a Top Five Queen Songs in my mind ( heart ) This song is ALWAYS number one no matter how the other 4 might change. Not sure you know this was also Freddie’s favorite song of all the songs he wrote. He had good taste 😂
This song can make me tear up it's so great. Its like a beautiful stream of consciousness. So glad you've heard it now. Drummer Roger Taylor is the high voice in the mix. Guitarist Brian May is an astrophysicist and built his famous guitar with his dad with wood from an old fireplace. Such unique tone.
She was able to almost guess what the official video for this song looks like, Freddie on the piano playing the opening note before starting to sing, I love this video with images from the studio
Growing up as a huge rock fan, been a witness through the evolution of punk, hardcore and metal, savoured every genre and subgenre of rock music from the late 80's to the 2010's, and im proud to say my love for it all started with a single Queen record that my dad used to have.. and that vould be the first record i would play from cover to cover..
You are the best review channel I have seen on TH-cam.?Thank you and please keep going.
Agreed. There are others who try and end up looking like they're playing a part and are not genuine. Amy is truly genuine, honest and knowledgeable. This is why i am hooked on her videos. thank you Amy :)
lol holy cannoli the length of this reaction & I’m here for it.
I know you don’t necessarily
do it, but live of this song is a must.
I'd agree but you should check out "The Charismatic Voice" which is similar but from the perspective of an opera singer :-)
I got into watching reactions due to vin and sori because they are Uber Christian reactions to “death metal “ she knows her musicality
@@bushchat28d I follow her also.......she is one of my other favorites. My musical training is zilch, but my love for music and understanding is great.
this song, live in montreal 1981, absolutely fantastic
Nearly 200 songs by Queen , not a bad one among them. They are the background music to my life and nobody that I've never even met , have had a such i big effect on me. Ive thoroughly enjoyed your analysis and joy in discovering Queen all these years later. Thank you
Yes! I can agree with that, no bad songs
Even love "hot space" it was different in
Ways but still quality and they were a great part of my life also, and a learning experience as a musician, I really enjoy
Her reactions and personal analysis
From her knowledge of music. 😊
3:29 Hi Amy, you wonder why the press talks about "gimmicks" when they discuss Queen.
Well, you've got to know that the music critics hated Queen back then! They were into very simple Punk music and other very repetetive Rock. Queen was too theatrical for the critics, they didn't find Queen 'cool'. They prefered 'street credibility' over compositions. It was often more or less grudgingly that they admitted that Queen's music had musical sophistication and substance to it.
Fortunately the public decided otherwise, and made sure that Queen became superstars.
After so much negativity, ignorance and bias against Queen over the years by ill-informed, pompous critics , I'm so glad a musician with the pedigree and insight that Amy possesses is showcasing their unbelievably rich, exotic and wonderful music. Know any critics music? Thought not....
Punk music...is the response to Queen ,other progressive rock ,...which got away from pure Rock n Roll
We could play the music but never had a singer to fill it out, so it became rehearsal fun.Never heard any musician denegrate Queen.🎼🎼🎼
Robert Palmer and Crissie Hynde come to mind.
I love hearing why people don't like something. You need to listen to people who don't like what you like.
"Know any critics music?". Amy Shafer is a critic and I don't know any of her music. You aren't saying anything with that question.
Never seen anyone badmouthing Queen’
Come for the reaction … Stay for the master class in music composition ❤❤❤
Your enthusiasm is infectious; I bet your students have such fun!!!
Here's something you might have missed in the live performance. The second time Freddie gets up from the piano, the lead guitarist plays a sustained note then leaves the stage. He's having some issue with his guitar. Freddie watches him leave not knowing why and has to improv till he's back, hence the audience participation. Freddie hears a few notes isolated notes from Brian - in keeping with the tune they're playing - and looks over to see Brian. Brian must give him a nod or something because Freddie immediately starts into the 10 x 'find me somebody to love' and Brian was back at the mic in time for his backing vocal. None of whatever happened detracted from the performance, even though Freddie had to unexpectedly wing it with 'I didn't see this coming" going through his mind - but I doubt whether anyone in the audience even noticed, and most who watch the live vid don't notice.
I'm going to suggest another which other people might have already suggested, or which Vlad might have lined up on your list of 50. (I only found you tonight so haven't seen everything you've done.) I'm suggesting you watch Queen at the Live Aid concert in 1985 and then watch Fil on the Wings of Pegasus channel explain exactly why their performance was as it was.
Btw, I know nothing about classical music but I'm loving that you're exploring Queen and you are most interesting to listen to, with your background in classical training. All the best :)
The call and response is almost pentecostal; the response is supporting the singer/speech-giver by providing him with the mental strength to continue the emotional journey that is the sermon!
I do hope Brian, Roger and John get told by someone to watch this analysis. It will give them a true sense of their legacy, and how a deep respect and appreciation for Queen's music will only continue to grow and grow as the years pass.
I think Freddie would have been really moved to hear all of her thoughts on his music.
@@69MucciI'm missing Freddie so much
Myself being an old recording/mixing engineer... it still blows me away to this day at how good the backing vocals are for the way they've recorded it. Freddie, Roger, and Brian just stood around 1 microphone, which is very hard to do, rather than recording each voice separately. Of course, they layered it many times to make it sound big and full but, their pitch is fantastic. Anytime I have a clients that want to record vocals like that, it rarely turns out how they're expecting it to. Inevitably, there's always at least one person that's out of key each pass to ruin the take. I just end up recording some of them separately and building it up from there. Queen are consummate professionals.
@@stacer1962 Back then, you only had 24 tracks. You did as much as you could live so you didn't have the bounce the tape as much. Freddie would always do many overdubs on his own but, groups would definitely stand around one mic often for a couple of takes if they were trying to get a choir sound out of 3-4 guys. The slight pitch variation is what makes it sound big.
Yes queen backing vocals were amazing, and addition the fact each
Member individually sang each note of a chord then combined it to have 3
Different voices for each note. I was always fascinated with that technique
😊
Fascinating! Such talent!
Best Queen song ever!🏆
Queen is nothing if not pure joy
If only we had more conservatory music teachers that could showcase and embrace this type of music with such open minded passion and quirky curiosity without possessing any fixed favoritism or bias. Ms. Shafer's balance of contextual understanding in her musical analysis - mixed with her wide-eyed, almost child-like wonder at the music itself - warms my insides and fills my eyes with happy tears...
Godspeed, Amy and Vlad...
I ECHO your remark, MrVictor!! GREAT REACTION, AMY & VLAD!! HUGS from Texas!!❤❤❤
Freddie was just such a brilliant composer
His piano playing is fabulous too but nobody ever seems to mention it!
i love the way queen always interweave and layer the choral elements of their music. magic. always magic.
For me, this really is one of the most incredible songs EVER made
I didn't think that I would have an hour+ to view this, but it was worth the time.
You are 100% correct. Yes, Queen can be flamboyant, campy, and a touch silly (and they can truly rock in the classic sense) but that is Freddy just being Freddy. He was all of those things and he is never truly "playing a part" the way an actor may do. Everything came straight from the heart. There were times I thought the Beatles were silly for the sake of being silly. I never once felt that with Queen. I do hope you get to '39!
Have you listened to (and seen the video for) I'm Going Slightly Mad. That is the quintessential silly song and video.
@@79BlackRose It may appear that way but there was actually a darker story behind it. Freddie created the song, because one of the warnings or side effects from the Aids medication was forgetfulness and psychiatric problems. Freddie was really afraid of these side effects, so he created this more humorous song to deal with this issue, luckily it wasn't a problem for him. But the song is actually making light of a very dark situation, Freddie often took this type of approach to darker themes.
@@ZENOBlAmusic It is still a silly song and video.
Freddie... ❤
There's a live version where he holds the note on "me" ("anybody find meeeeeeeeeeeeee....) for an unreasonably long time.
At 8:06 that strange high note that we can think is Brian's guitare is actualy Roger's voice doing a high "yeaaaah".
This song has a pushing and pulling within it musically that just feel like this sound is breathing - in and out - it has a life of it's own!
Imagine coming out with this gem right after Bohemian Rhapsody.....
Nailed it! A music to be played on all eras. I really miss Freddy. Life took him too early.
The gospel-religious, suitable for a church aspect of the song is perfect not just because of it’s basic sound, but also because it is, in essence, a prayer.
FM had one of the best voices of his generation
There are plenty of famous rock bands that can make a lot of noise, but having had the privilege of seeing Queen live many times I don't know of any 4 piece that can make an absolute orchestrated rhythmatic wall of sound that makes some sort of musical sense as well as they can live... just amazing what 4 people can do. No wonder they are considered probably the best live band ever.
I saw them live twice. The only band that might challenge them for that title would be Rush.
@@wmason1961 fair comment, but I think queen have it on the amount of diversity in their music. Always moving.. but not always good!
@@1carusjohn32 All Queens music is good! Of course this is subjective. I'm fascinated how many genres they delved into - not afraid to try anything
Freddie's favourite Queen song. He said Somebody To Love is better created song than the Bohemian Rhapsody.
That's like saying nothing at all.
first, I want to let you know that yours is the best analysis of the song that I've heard. Yep, Freddie was accused of gimmicky or camp song writing, etc, but you know, many of his closest friends remind us that Freddie was camp when he was comfortable around them. So, he was being himself. Also, listening to Somebody To Love studio version (or watching the Official Video Version, which is the same recording) is the best way to get the introduction to the song. To hear it how Freddie planned it, rich with vocal harmonies and multi-layers. Then my next favorite is watching the version you did. While, of course in concert, Queen didn't play recordings or backup so they could not give you the multi-layer harmonies, what they did give you was straight-up knock you out of your seat performance! Freddie gets the crowd going with audience participation. Rather than hand-claps, they use drum beat and bass slaps. It's live live live. No clicks. No auto-tune. Glad you experienced both versions.
I think it’s important not to put much weight into what magazine rock critics have to say like the statement of using gimmicks. Most of the time the magazine critics are total hacks that know nothing about real music. Many of them tried to make it themselves, failed and then would seek to put down successful musicians to make themselves appear superior.
Concur. Rolling stone is probably the worst, but yillage voice and cream are right up there. I find the well known critics to be pretentious snobs.
One of the few I really liked back in the day is Lenny Kay ( lead guitarist Patti Smith group) his enjoyment of the music comes through in his reviews.
I also used to like the short 1 paragraph reviews of lesser known groups in rolling stone and spin during the early to mid 80's. Again they were written by people who liked the music not someone trying to show how much smarter they were then us.
You might like to check out some live performances. Roger Taylors drum solos are fantastic. Tjhey have performed with a gospel choir at least once.
Well... that was just awesome, thank you Amy and a big BIG , thank you to Vlad for including the live version , a wonderful decision. It wasn`t just Vlad who was excited in anticipation. The song didn`t disappoint Amy , and the reaction didn`t disappoint us ! oh no , not at all.
This reaction video/music lesson picked up more than 1,000 views while I was watching it.
Freddie really loved Aretha Franklin, Brian May said 'I think he wanted to BE Aretha!' This song is in hommage to her.
As everyone will say...Please, even if it's in your own time, watch the Montreal 1981 live version of this, and to get a further comparison, Milton Keynes 1982. This perfectly exemplifies how Queen never treated a song quite the same in each concert, and very rarely as it originally sounded in the studio. Thank you
Montreal. I agree, but then Freddie live is always better. More... lived in? Some singers are only complete with an audience.
Yes. The live version from Montreal is Freddie knocking it out of the park. It’s a must watch.
Watch to the end
Yeah, clearly someone commented without watching the entire video. ;)@@matt80535
@@matt80535Yep, I posted the comment before the video came out, not thinking that the live bit would be included! So glad it was!
So very glad you also saw the live Montreal version. Your comment about how tight and competent the band members are live on stage. Notice when Freddie gets up from the piano the second time and walks toward the front of the stage to interact with the audience, he looks back and you can briefly see Brian May walking to the back of the stage. Brian is going to repair a broken guitar string. Freddie leads Roger and John in an improvised segment to cover for Brian’s absence. The shot expands and you see John slapping the bass and you see Freddie look to the back of the stage, sees that Brian has completed his repairs and continues with the song and you see Brian come back into the shot. The band was so well rehearsed and so tight that they “communicated” with each other with little looks and was able to follow Freddie’s lead seamlessly.
Watch The Who live... Keith moon takes cues from Pete Townsends swinging of the guitar neck and foot stomps.
I think that happened in Milton Keynes during Dragon Attack. Normally, Brian May begins his solo immediately after the second verse is finished. At the Bowl, since a string on his Red Special snapped by that point in the song, he gave Deacon and Taylor an extra bar while he grabbed a replica of his guitar to resume playing. It sounds so natural that one in the crowd would fail to notice, especially since the studio recording also includes the brief break in the melody.
@@Inverse_to_Chaos Yes, that was another incident. John was able to briefly replicate his bass solo that was on the studio version. They were so well in tune with each other that they were easily able to cover for each other.
Brian didn't break a string there. He is still using his red special and there's no way anyone can change a string in 10 seconds.
As much as I love Queen, you're noticing things that didn't happen.
Hi. Have you ever seen the movie Lord Of The Rings: The Fellowship of the Rings. There is a scene where Gandolf arrives and Bilbo says "Your late". Gandolf replies "A wizard is never late, or early, he arrives precisely when he means to." Queen are like that. No, there are no gimmicks. Everything is precisely where it needs to be. The call and response, sometimes the response comes before the call. They are Queen, they can do that, they make their own rules.
Thank you for acknowledging John Deacon, his bass work is always brilliant. Oh, and the drum on this track is spectacular, as is the guitar! I think you might enjoy The Millionaires Walt, from the same album. There is even a little bit where Freddie speaks in a faux German accent!! And the bass on that track is beyond excellent! Edited, this is the first time I have watched you, and I just checked and found you have already done Millionaires Waltz, I'm going to watch that now!!!
The thing I love most about this song is the constantly changing interaction between Freddie and the choir. They alternate constantly, but every time in a slightly different way. Different rhythms, sometimes call & response, sometimes emphasising, sometimes interrupting, sometimes the choir announces what the solo is going to sing, sometimes they follow him. Sometimes the solo has the lead, sometimes the choir. It keeps changing and keeps getting more and more interesting.
And that live performance! Roger Taylor pulling the choir entirely on his own much of the time (sometimes with Brian May, but let's be honest, Roger did most of the work there). Roger is in my opinion the most underrated singer in rock. He s fantastic, great range, and I think he actually has a more stable, reliable voice than Freddie, though not quite that magical edge or the soul that Freddie has.
He was amazing- person, voice, performer and soul. He was gone much too soon.
Still painful… he was gone way too soon 😔💛
Changes in tempo and volume (dynamics) are not gimmicks, they are music!
I want to share my admiration for the band Queen, who I consider to be one of the most incredibly talented bands of all time. In my opinion, their versatility, uniqueness, and ability to play together in perfect harmony are second only to The Beatles. I believe that each member's contribution to the music is invaluable and helps propel the song forward, like perpetual motion. I particularly want to give a shout-out to John Deacon, the bassist, for his outstanding work in every song, including taking the lead in some parts, which often goes unrecognized. He is a true musical genius, just like the other band members, Freddie, Brian, and Roger. It is remarkable how every band member contributes to the momentum and keeps the song moving in the right direction. This particular song is my favourite, and it holds a lot of personal meaning for me.
Thanks for watching the live performance.
Queen - White Queen, A Night at the Odeon - Hammersmith 1975 ❤
. . . you have an intuition beyond the ordinary!
Mercury's voice range was INCREDIBLE.
Now my life is complete!
You very much understand Freddy already. That IS just genuinely him! He all by himself is the very definition of dynamic, and then when you add the dynamics of his amazing band mates, it is quite a lot! Quite a lot of awesome!
The album version is excellent, but be sure to check out the Live in Montreal version from 1981 - absolutely fantastic, and showcases Freddie's mastery of the stage and Roger Taylor's excellent backing vocals.
And Live in Milton Keynes 💛
She did actually in this video, around 56:38
Try watching the whole video lmao
Absolutely!
Next time watch the video before commenting. ;)
8:11 a tiny thing that is actually very important... Freddie is insecure, the band is reassuring... He sings Someday, the band sings One-day... just a nice example of how deep these lyrics go...
I just learned something new about my favorite song! Thank you!
@@lcbcreative You are welcome!
Thank you for that insight - I'm sure most people won't have noticed and it is a great indication of the subtleties of the music.
@joyceharkin3641 it is rather subtle, but once you've heard it, it is there forever!
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA!! That's good! Insecure! Whatever..............LOL!!
The experience of facing something genuine has no substitute. To feel the inner true of another self through his art is as hard to explain as it is easy to experience.
The so-called Billboard music critics were just a bunch of pompous "no it all's". They always panned Queen, but the band's lasting popularity is the world's validation of Queen's genius.
So cool to see a classical musician utterly engrossed in the music of Queen. I had a smile on my face for the whole reaction, just awesome. I would love to see Brian, Roger and John watching your reaction Amy as I'm sure they too would have similar smiles. Well done and belated congratulations on your 100k subs milestone too :-)
I'm so excited that she also saw the show in Montreal, so icing on the cake!
Freddie Mercury and Queen are sort of like Cinderella. Under appreciated in the 70's - and found their full glory as the rest of civilization caught up to their 20 years ahead of them time. Now - 30 years after Queen became popular - the whole world recognizes Freddie as the greatest Rock Singer of all time - and perhaps the greatest showman ever. Freddie is simply an - ALL TIME - personality in the long-long history of the world.
I hope you've included the Highlander soundtrack in your Queen selections. Apparently the forthcoming re-make will include the original Queen soundtrack.
Didn't know there was a re-make in the works, but I'm not at all surprised since 99% of movies in the last 20 years are re-makes and never very good re-makes. But at least the movie soundtrack will be EXCELLENT!
@@davidrichards6509 Yeah, Chad Stahelski, the director of the John Wick series is currently in charge. Besides being a long term stuntman, Chad is also a martial artist with extensive experience in Filipino Martial Arts. Many people don't realize that fencing and knife fighting in Filipino culture is as developed as in say Japan, so the movie should be VERY good.
Hey! This time, my address is for Vlad. Thank you, man. I love you. Discovering, like Amy does, Somebody To Love by Queen without that live version would be blasphemy.
As I said earlier here in comments, I believe that absolutely every song by Queen was created with the stage in mind, even if twisted and worked for the studio recordings.
I wish you all the best. Cheers!
Thank you for this wonderful reaction, and a big thank-you to Vlad for arranging the surprise live version reaction! I had a sneaking suspicion that might happen! :) These Queen reactions have really made the weekends more enjoyable!
Great reaction, im glad you mentioned the bass, John Deacon is such a melodic player he's up there with the best
Thanks Amy and Vlad!
Roger om Drums and vocals live is unreal when they played this live - drives the song so well and takes over the lead chorus at the end with voice reversals with Freddie - outstanding !
Starting with the Official recording (this one) is great!! Then go to the live one in Montreal in 1981 as a follow up will please you. Every time Freddie does a concert, he sings the songs differently and the two concerts, one in Montreal and the other at Milton Keynes in 1982 are just amazing. I love watching your reactions.
Vlad & Amy GOOD COMPANY is a must listen most unusual New Orleans dixie jazz style Brian sings &his guitars as horns & trombones.
ive been making this prayer since 76. still waiting
This is an incredible song! One of the very best ones that Queen ever recorded.
Have you noticed the quality of the work Brian and Freddie contribute to each others compositions? This shows huge mutual respect!!
I agree. The way Brian’s guitar emulates Freddie’s voice at times is underestimated brilliance. Freddie’s vocals are unmatched but Brian manages to continue his melodies with clever guitar solos.
I love how accomplished musicians describe a piece of music like a chef describing every flavour of a delicious meal no one else can taste or an architect describing a building no one else can envisage without drawing a picture!
Freddie really was always looking for that one special somebody to love. Living in a boarding school thousands of miles from his parents affecting him for the rest of his life. Yes, this is his real feelings
That live-performance from Canada must be one of the greatest ever! Freddie is the greatest ever, and Queen!!! I love your channel!!!
It would be great if you could set up an interview with Brian May - he's very humble, intellectual and my guess is he'd love your analysis, knowledge and enthusiasm.
But he does get quite confused
Yes, it would be great if you can dive further in all Sir Brian May’s achievements, musically and so much more.
Queen's music + Freddie Mercury's voice = PASSION ❤
There was only one Freddie Mercury. He lived his nickname through his music with all of his passion and emotion. He must have been a very contagious person to work with. His energy fed the other bandmembers and the four of them together even rose above his sizzling energy. The sum of their parts multiplied the outcome. Mathematical this is impossible. So may we call it magic? But true magic, not the trickery by a magician, but magic that goes beyond the powers of man. It seems as if they were inspired by Freddie, and then their combined inspiration again fed them all as well. An explosion of artistry as a result. The same effect occurred when Freddie met and worked with montserrat Caballé. The utter inspiration we can witness, is so far out there.
I am glad how you presented Freddie at the start of the song hitting this one note, that triggered an outpoor of emotion, so well presented within the production, arrangement of this song. It all came together here. This is why this particulair Queen song is so magical to me. Again, magic as in 'not from this world'.
Yes, he sure was and is an inspiration. I’d like to add though that there was already magic between Brian and Roger, you can tell by listening to Smile. What a band, what talents!
Queen were always able to make their song so personal to the listener.
Playing an instrument well on your own is something. Playing well together with another musician is something else. Bands like Queen have musicianship on another level, and yes, that definitely shines through in the live clip.
I could listen to her talk all day. ❤ I bet she's a fantastic music teacher.
Vlad, show Amy the footage from Live Aide. There's a clip where he has the entire audience of 72,000 people following his vocal cues and it's just amazing! But she should react to the whole performance, they completely stole the show!
I can't begin to tell you how much I appreciate your appreciation of this song! Not only does it offer a sort of validation for my deep love of Queen (not that I feel the need for that validation), but your analysis has given me an entirely new layer of appreciation for the song.
One of my absolute favorite reactions from you. When you put your hand on your chin and just smiled. Lost in the joy and wonder of Freddy and Queen. He definitely found somebody to love in all of us loving him and his legacy. Your reaction was priceless. Thank you for all you do!
He did take us to church in this one. Lol
56:10 if I could like this video twice, this is where ❤. A gift within a gift ! Thank you both 🙏🏾🙌🏾🎉
Hi 👋 Mrs. Amy.
Yes, that’s what it did to me the first time I listened to it…it’s absolute genius and perfection in its apparently simplicity, compared to more lively classical music. When I first listen to “tunnel of love” (very luckily🍀 by my powerful Walkman headphones) from Dire Straits, I had kind of a such a pleasant thrill. It happened many years ago and I didn’t have a clue for it at that time.
Few days ago I watched a reaction video of that song and the TH-camr said at the end of the track: “that’s the closest thing to sex you can have by your ears” and I immediately remembered that sensation. I mean, these perfect and timeless songs translate themselves naturally and almost automatically into kind of physical pleasure for people sensitive to music (in your case also profound connoisseurs of it) as we are. Here is why I asked out loud for “the prophet song” reaction. Because of its clever and powerful crescendo storyboard, it’s theatrical and visionary acoustic (but also visual, as you also said) scenes.
Anyway, how is it possible that 4 young men has been such an artistic volcano 🌋 for more than 30 years? I personally struggle to think it’s really possible without a deep, deep, deep talent and inspiration.
I ❤ Queen so much, so excuse me for the long comment.
i like when she makes that face when something makes you happy.
Thank you Vlad for having her watch the live version also! It's one thing to make greatness on a studio track that you can do all this cool layering and retakes. It's another thing to bring it live and get the whole crowd invested. Just like going to church on Sunday!
Your explanation od Freddie’s passion and “all in” way of performing was so on point. Some are uncomfortable with it. Me…. My heart explodes with every listen ( especially live performances ).
Thank you for going on this journey.
Even more than Bohemian Rhapsody, this song showcases Queen's incredible absolutely to craft spectacular chords.
I do hope Freddy watched this wherever he is. He would definitely enjoy your response to his music!
I think this song is one of, if not the most beautiful rock songs ever written.
Since Amy is concentrating upon listening with her expert ear and knowledge, then at least listening to the Montreal version is well worth the experience. Freddie's performance in front of an audience always seemed to add "thousands of volts of electricity" . So Amy, I do enjoy your reactions and insights; I am not the only one who would love to see you react to the Montreal Somebody to Love, either listening, or even better watching this wonderful performance. The studio version that you are about to release your comments on is great of course.
im so glad she listend 2 the studio version 1st tho
Live in Montreal this song sounds unique
And the next one who should insert their foot into their mouth and eat their words, because they are eager to jump onto videos and commenting without watching them first.
If you had done that, you would not have written this comment...
This song is a prayer for those who feel loneliness.
Some people never find that someone in their entire lives.
Those that do, cherish them.
Freddie Mercury couldn’t find his love until he was 38. It was a matter of time and experience for him to maintain a successful relationship lasting 6 years until his final breath. 💞
I've learned after 58 years that being alone doesn't have to mean loneliness.
You can find and feel loneliness in a relationship.
I've found to be comfortable within myself is more important than to be uncomfortable along with another person.
Yet, I'm still waiting for that special person who thinks I'm special too.
Being able to truly love yourself is a special relationship in it's own.
Faults, warts and all.
I still wake up and I still hope and keep on trying.
Nothing beats a failure, but a try.
@@rodneygriffin7666 Thanks for the advice as I’m only 21 and also on the rainbow. Earlier this year, I read Jim Hutton’s semi-autobiographical work that described his relationship with Mercury, and since he was diagnosed as tabloids exposed his previous relationships, he became increasingly private and did not socially interact outside of his friend zone and band. He must have felt ostracised by those who betrayed him, to the point where he didn’t know whom to trust. I think Hutton’s presence helped him emotionally as he knowingly got closer to his death bed. I still hope I find the right people to be around, and this song always encourages me to get up and go searching. :-)
With regard to the 'Gimmick' aspect of the contemporary review in 1976....
For some context Amy, The American press in newspaper and magazine media HATED Queen at the time for the most part. Us fans at the time (I was 13 when this came out) couldn't understand what it was these reviewers were listening to?!! I always found their diversity of styles to be a strength that few other bands could approach. Many of the reviews were very toxic and spiteful. Screw 'em all!
I could listen to you all day Amy 👍👍
I guess that everyone that’s watches you wish’s we were vlad the absolute joy and pleasure the excitement of getting to share something for the first time with your friends is one of the best feelings ever. Vlad is def my hero for doing this for you
Something I particularly noticed is that after the crescendo and Freddy's voice fading out, the players all come back in one at a time like a curtain call, and they are all rigidly bound to the beat, while Freddy's voice isn't bound to the rhythm at all for the entire rest of the work. It's as if he has set himself free after all.
I was eagerly waiting for this reaction, the studio version, and thank you for the amazing surprise at the end, watching to the brilliant live performance. 😍 Freddie was a passionate guy, he was full of emotions, feelings, and he was able to set them into music, sadness, happiness, anger or the desire to love, to be loved.
Don’t know how many Queen fans think of this as their favorite Queen song but I have since I first fell in love with it… and Queen and especially Freddie. Like others I keep a Top Five Queen Songs in my mind ( heart ) This song is ALWAYS number one no matter how the other 4 might change. Not sure you know this was also Freddie’s favorite song of all the songs he wrote. He had good taste 😂
For me too. Always nr 1.
I tried to do a top 10 Queen line up. I ended up with 86 songs. So much brilliance I couldn’t narrow the list. 😂❤
His voice is full of yearning...🥺
This song can make me tear up it's so great. Its like a beautiful stream of consciousness. So glad you've heard it now. Drummer Roger Taylor is the high voice in the mix. Guitarist Brian May is an astrophysicist and built his famous guitar with his dad with wood from an old fireplace. Such unique tone.
Another track that does require listening to the studio version and watching the live version, definitely Montreal .. 👌
She was able to almost guess what the official video for this song looks like, Freddie on the piano playing the opening note before starting to sing, I love this video with images from the studio
The best Queen song of all time!
The live performance from Montreal is one of my favorite live performances ever!
Growing up as a huge rock fan, been a witness through the evolution of punk, hardcore and metal, savoured every genre and subgenre of rock music from the late 80's to the 2010's, and im proud to say my love for it all started with a single Queen record that my dad used to have.. and that vould be the first record i would play from cover to cover..
Love it. I hope you will do My Melancholy Blues too.