I love how Pèpa is complaining about rain on their wedding day and her husband responds with "what a joyous day, but anyway..." he's so in love with his wife nothing can bring down his happiness, not even torrential rain.
My favorite Disney movie. Still feel so bad for Abuela, it's hard to imagine the pain she must have gone through. Still not an excuse to tread other people badly, of course.
This is one of my favorite movies of all time, from the voice actors and animation, to the lyrics and music, it’s all amazing! The songs were written by the one and only Lin Manuel Miranda, who also wrote Hamilton(my favorite thing ever) among other things, he’s just the best. This movie is a great rewatch too, you pick up on many new things.
No, Abuela did not get a gift. She is the keeper of the Candle [Miracle]. Think of it as like the orchestra conductor whose job is to stand out in front, and therefore they don't play an instrument themselves. And Mirabel did not get a gift, most likely, because she is meant to be next in line to inherit Abuela's position as the head matriarch and keeper of the family miracle.
It just dawned on me what the plot of Encanto 2 could be: there was one prediction Breuno made that had not come true, yet. Isabella has not met her man of her dreams; we were lead to believe it was Marco, but he was Delores', ergo being an open question.
Part 1 of 2 "...the whole thing, like her mood affects the weather, seems kind of bad..." Yeah... in fact that whole side of the family seems to have powers that are either useless or detrimental. But _beyond_ that... there _may be_ something far darker to it. th-cam.com/video/Xz2oowy5JxY/w-d-xo.html "...she's a really good sister..." Cousin, actually. Antonio is Mirabel's cousin, not brother. "...he can transform, that's kind of cool..." Most uses for it are either frivolous (entertainment, avoiding having to get a stool), or criminal (getting other people's stuff by pretending to be them), or not useful in such a small community (infiltration). "...nothing happened..." _Nothing_ happening would have been better than what _did_ happen. The door vanished. _DENIED!_ That's... so much worse. "...give me [Antonio's] ability..." This one is actually kind of useful. It comes up later, when the rats tell him everything. Imagine this in a city? Rats are _everywhere!_ The ability to find out most things would be _impressive._ If you could also talk to _insects_ (never shown, it looks like only tetrapods), you'd have a spy network that might make Dolores obsolete, and without the problems Dolores definitely has. "...I love animals..." It's an interesting quirk of language that most of us don't really mean this. We mean we love tetrapods. Beetles are animals, and ants, and worms, etc. All insects are animals. Yet many people who 'love animals' don't love those. Arachnids are animals, too (spiders, scorpions, things that _look like_ spiders but aren't, like the camel spider). A lot of the time, we don't even mean _tetrapods,_ but rather just the birds and mammals, excluding reptiles, snakes, amphibians, etc. "...and she's... not even in the picture..." Let's be clear, that's _Mirabel's_ fault. They didn't look around to check that everyone was there, they just called out for them all to gather, maybe asked if everyone was ready, and _Mirabel_ didn't _say_ anything. There's _ten_ other people in that photo, _all_ of whom gathered _by themselves_ and got into the picture. No one told her _not to be_ in the picture. They weren't _excluding_ her, _she_ excluded _herself._ You have to be responsible for yourself in a crowd. When people say 'let's gather', you can't get upset if you don't gather. When someone calls out asking if everyone's ready, you can't get upset if you don't speak up. _That said,_ it is _entirely understandable_ as to _why_ Mirabel made the choice she did. Being an introvert myself (which Mirabel isn't normally, but she was in that moment), I get not joining in _and_ people not noticing. And _also_ noting that just because _this instance_ wasn't one where she was being excluded or pushed away, this doesn't mean she _wasn't_ being excluded and pushed away in lots of other ways elsewhere, _including_ the moment before the picture was called for, with the line 'a gift just as special as you'. "...the strength of the house seems to depend on the strength of the family..." Yep. Very well caught. And it explains every other aspect of the story, and why it happens the way it does. "...maybe they were there, so what are we gonna do about it, let's see if they're gonna be there again..." One of the issues with magic like this is that... well... maybe they'll only appear while Mirabel is alone (obviously that doesn't happen here). When magic is allowed for, we can't count on anything. _That said..._ in a sense it's not nearly that bad, even in this story. _You_ live in a magical world already. There are invisible forces pinning you to the ground. If someone came along and said a _different_ invisible force moved something... you'd be appropriately skeptical _even though_ you live in a world of invisible forces. They haven't seen the magic _do_ that before, so they're skeptical that it happened now. One other thing to note is that it's clear this family _very much_ counts on its image. That is, the denial is less about not believing her and about the fact that this is a private, family matter that she tried to display in front of everyone. "There is nothing wrong" was said to the crowd. Then Mirabel's mom wasn't saying, specifically, that she didn't believe... but more that she's worried about Mirabel 'losing her way in this family', like Bruno did. It's a _social_ issue more than anything. People will believe, or _not_ believe, things under social pressure to conform to those around them. It's why, for instance, _most_ people who convert into a religion do so into the _dominant_ religion around them (obviously not 100% of the time). Muslims who become Christian almost always live in Christian communities (even if the _country_ is largely non-Christian, such people tend to be surrounded _by_ Christians). "...that just makes telling everyone there's no problem so much worse..." It's a thing that happens a _lot_ in upper tier families, or highly connected communities. When your ability to function _at all_ or to function at the _upper end_ is _dependent_ on the good will of those around you, you tend to become _extremely_ image conscious... because all of that can vanish in a heartbeat if your image becomes tarnished. Imagine if the village thought there _really was_ a problem with the magic. Do you think they might start _avoiding_ the Madrigals, due to not _trusting_ them anymore? Or how about how quickly a rumor like that could lead to _fear_ about the magic being 'out of control'? Just the _rumor_ of it could crush them, even if it weren't true. Honestly, I get where Alma was coming from. She's matriarch of _one_ of, but not the _only,_ top families in their village. That said, she's still wrong. Not because of what she said to the crowd, but because of what she _didn't_ say _after_ that. As soon as that happens, the next morning you grab the adults _and_ Mirabelle, minimum, and have a meeting, saying you believe her, but that you need to keep this _quiet_ (and for the reasons I listed above) while looking into it. Probably pull in Dolores, Louisa, and Isabella, too, and tell them to be on the look out for anything... to report it, but to do so _quietly_ until they can figure out what's going on. And _also_ that they may need to talk about when to involve the village, and what to do with their gifts if things are being problematic. In other words, not catastrophizing, not gaslighting, but _also_ not trying to sweep it under the rug _internally_ at least (even if, at first, you hide it from the neighbors until you figure it out or it's becoming an issue that affects others). "...that's my prediction..." You understand story telling _very_ well. :) Your prediction was 100% correct. At least at this point. You later add other stuff which is wrong, but... still, pretty good! "...his room is terrible..." Yeah... I remember seeing something on that, too. Honestly, it's hard to see how this house is being at all kind to most of them. "...didn't give her a gift to test how strong they really are..." That's one notion. Personally, my conclusion is that one of two things is true. 1) She's effectively disabled. It wasn't about giving or not giving, she was just born with an impairment. But _just because_ she's impaired in that way doesn't make her shameful or unable to do anything else. 2) If there _is_ an intent behind it... then it's to have Mirabel _replace_ Alma. Alma's getting old, she's gotta be _at least_ 70 in this movie. She won't be around much longer, so they need a new leader. Alma lacks magic, but she's got a will you could bend bars around. Name _anyone else_ in that family as strong-willed as Mirabel. The only thing Mirabel needs at this point is to learn a bit more from Alma and the others on how to navigate the social issues, so she doesn't burst in and scream the family's problems to the world. Personally, I hope for the second, and given modern Disney it seems more likely that this is the case. "...catalyzer..." Catalyst.
Part 2 of 2 "...he's just telling you it's gonna happen..." Actually, in the case of the wedding, he _did_ cause it. If he hadn't _said_ anything, she wouldn't have stressed out and had her emotions cause a hurricane (see the first Matrix movie with the Oracle, "What vase... how did you know I'd-" "mmmm, what's _really_ gonna cook your noodle later on is wondering if you'd even have broken it if I hadn't said anything"). But then he didn't _know_ that the _reason_ it happens would be because he said something. Bruno's gift shows what _will_ happen, and it takes Bruno's actions into account for that. As you see later, _every part_ of Bruno's vision about Mirabel _actually_ happened, _all_ of it. Bruno was wrong, his vision wasn't showing him that her future was undecided, it was showing that she would both break the house _and_ restore it. Also, the history of people accusing those who _predict_ the future of making that future _happen_ is quite extensive. The problem is we suffer from hyperactive agency detection. When things happen, we find things with minds to blame it on. If you know what's coming, it's because you made it happen... at least according to a lot of folk. And, honestly, that _is_ one way you'd know. Moreover, this _same feeling_ has been used in entertainment, tricking us into accepting magic. When a magician sets up a trick that is running on automatic, but pretends that waving their hands is what caused the thing to move... that's the same idea. _They_ aren't doing anything, someone else is or it was set up to do it on its own. And this issue continues _today._ A (not professional) magician, Matt Dillahunty (better known for other things), performed a magic trick for people to try to explain skepticism to them. Then he _showed them how the trick was performed._ The reaction he got? They didn't believe him that what he was showing them of how the trick worked was what he did the first time. The first time was real magic, the next time was something else. People are _alarmingly_ gullible. (Side note: Two of the other issues, the hair loss and weight gain, might _also_ be Bruno's fault, as stress can cause both of those things.) "...don't talk about it..." Well, in defense of the father... he seemed, to me, to be suggesting they hold off on saying anything _that night._ Not that they hide it indefinitely, but that since they had company coming over and it was the night of the proposal to Isabella that they put a lid on it until _after_ that event. If we're being kind. This is a thing we all do to some extent. Of course... that proposal was _part of_ the problem, which talking about all this could have solved... but in a way it was too late. If all this had happened a day or two _before_ this, they might have had a different outcome. "...I don't think she's much older than about 12 or 13..." Pretty close. She's 15. Which, at the time, was is basically an adult in 1950s Colombia (which is where and when this takes place). The age of consent _today_ is 14 in Colombia. "...and now everyone's seeing the cracks..." If you mean the literal cracks in the walls and such, they definitely saw them before that. Alma motions to them a moment before this confrontation when talking to Mirabel's parents. Great reaction. Have a nice day!
It's entirely sound proof, as confirmed by the creators. Still, terrible "gift". I have to assume she has to focus to hear things at full blast and anything else is just background noise otherwise her gift would have drove her mad many years ago.
I love how Pèpa is complaining about rain on their wedding day and her husband responds with "what a joyous day, but anyway..." he's so in love with his wife nothing can bring down his happiness, not even torrential rain.
love him
the couples in the family are so cute
That's because the rain was caused by his wife, and he loves everything about his wife.
@@retirolester he's such a good husband hey both are.
My favorite Disney movie. Still feel so bad for Abuela, it's hard to imagine the pain she must have gone through. Still not an excuse to tread other people badly, of course.
This is one of my favorite movies of all time, from the voice actors and animation, to the lyrics and music, it’s all amazing! The songs were written by the one and only Lin Manuel Miranda, who also wrote Hamilton(my favorite thing ever) among other things, he’s just the best. This movie is a great rewatch too, you pick up on many new things.
Antonio is a cousin but she acts like a sister, ;]
her power is showing family their true
3:58 I want Casita
*Chair moves 1 inch to the right*
*SCREAMS* "GHOST!"
I LOVED THIS. Sorry if you're not Deutsche, but I got that vibe and it made me feel nostalgic
Talking about metaphors, I'm a little surprised that you didn't comment on the butterfly motif recurring throughout the movie.
Yeah, I realised that it's a metaphor but I wasn't sure, what it stands for 😂 Read up on that though 😂😊
Lin Manual Marada wrote surface about his older sister and Louisa
Surface preasure
No, Abuela did not get a gift. She is the keeper of the Candle [Miracle]. Think of it as like the orchestra conductor whose job is to stand out in front, and therefore they don't play an instrument themselves.
And Mirabel did not get a gift, most likely, because she is meant to be next in line to inherit Abuela's position as the head matriarch and keeper of the family miracle.
It just dawned on me what the plot of Encanto 2 could be: there was one prediction Breuno made that had not come true, yet. Isabella has not met her man of her dreams; we were lead to believe it was Marco, but he was Delores', ergo being an open question.
They could answer how Tonito's power of talking to animals was helpful to the family.
Bruno's prophecy for Isabella said nothing about the man of her dreams. Listen to it again.
@@ammaleslie509 Ok I had misheard "life" as "man".
I'll play the shot game each time you say "like" wish me luck.
Good reaction tho
Yeah... seems to be my favorite word... 😂 you're gonna be wasted after 😂
Part 1 of 2
"...the whole thing, like her mood affects the weather, seems kind of bad..."
Yeah... in fact that whole side of the family seems to have powers that are either useless or detrimental. But _beyond_ that... there _may be_ something far darker to it.
th-cam.com/video/Xz2oowy5JxY/w-d-xo.html
"...she's a really good sister..."
Cousin, actually. Antonio is Mirabel's cousin, not brother.
"...he can transform, that's kind of cool..."
Most uses for it are either frivolous (entertainment, avoiding having to get a stool), or criminal (getting other people's stuff by pretending to be them), or not useful in such a small community (infiltration).
"...nothing happened..."
_Nothing_ happening would have been better than what _did_ happen. The door vanished. _DENIED!_ That's... so much worse.
"...give me [Antonio's] ability..."
This one is actually kind of useful. It comes up later, when the rats tell him everything. Imagine this in a city? Rats are _everywhere!_ The ability to find out most things would be _impressive._ If you could also talk to _insects_ (never shown, it looks like only tetrapods), you'd have a spy network that might make Dolores obsolete, and without the problems Dolores definitely has.
"...I love animals..."
It's an interesting quirk of language that most of us don't really mean this. We mean we love tetrapods. Beetles are animals, and ants, and worms, etc. All insects are animals. Yet many people who 'love animals' don't love those. Arachnids are animals, too (spiders, scorpions, things that _look like_ spiders but aren't, like the camel spider). A lot of the time, we don't even mean _tetrapods,_ but rather just the birds and mammals, excluding reptiles, snakes, amphibians, etc.
"...and she's... not even in the picture..."
Let's be clear, that's _Mirabel's_ fault. They didn't look around to check that everyone was there, they just called out for them all to gather, maybe asked if everyone was ready, and _Mirabel_ didn't _say_ anything. There's _ten_ other people in that photo, _all_ of whom gathered _by themselves_ and got into the picture. No one told her _not to be_ in the picture. They weren't _excluding_ her, _she_ excluded _herself._
You have to be responsible for yourself in a crowd. When people say 'let's gather', you can't get upset if you don't gather. When someone calls out asking if everyone's ready, you can't get upset if you don't speak up.
_That said,_ it is _entirely understandable_ as to _why_ Mirabel made the choice she did. Being an introvert myself (which Mirabel isn't normally, but she was in that moment), I get not joining in _and_ people not noticing. And _also_ noting that just because _this instance_ wasn't one where she was being excluded or pushed away, this doesn't mean she _wasn't_ being excluded and pushed away in lots of other ways elsewhere, _including_ the moment before the picture was called for, with the line 'a gift just as special as you'.
"...the strength of the house seems to depend on the strength of the family..."
Yep. Very well caught. And it explains every other aspect of the story, and why it happens the way it does.
"...maybe they were there, so what are we gonna do about it, let's see if they're gonna be there again..."
One of the issues with magic like this is that... well... maybe they'll only appear while Mirabel is alone (obviously that doesn't happen here). When magic is allowed for, we can't count on anything.
_That said..._ in a sense it's not nearly that bad, even in this story. _You_ live in a magical world already. There are invisible forces pinning you to the ground. If someone came along and said a _different_ invisible force moved something... you'd be appropriately skeptical _even though_ you live in a world of invisible forces. They haven't seen the magic _do_ that before, so they're skeptical that it happened now.
One other thing to note is that it's clear this family _very much_ counts on its image. That is, the denial is less about not believing her and about the fact that this is a private, family matter that she tried to display in front of everyone. "There is nothing wrong" was said to the crowd. Then Mirabel's mom wasn't saying, specifically, that she didn't believe... but more that she's worried about Mirabel 'losing her way in this family', like Bruno did. It's a _social_ issue more than anything. People will believe, or _not_ believe, things under social pressure to conform to those around them. It's why, for instance, _most_ people who convert into a religion do so into the _dominant_ religion around them (obviously not 100% of the time). Muslims who become Christian almost always live in Christian communities (even if the _country_ is largely non-Christian, such people tend to be surrounded _by_ Christians).
"...that just makes telling everyone there's no problem so much worse..."
It's a thing that happens a _lot_ in upper tier families, or highly connected communities. When your ability to function _at all_ or to function at the _upper end_ is _dependent_ on the good will of those around you, you tend to become _extremely_ image conscious... because all of that can vanish in a heartbeat if your image becomes tarnished. Imagine if the village thought there _really was_ a problem with the magic. Do you think they might start _avoiding_ the Madrigals, due to not _trusting_ them anymore? Or how about how quickly a rumor like that could lead to _fear_ about the magic being 'out of control'? Just the _rumor_ of it could crush them, even if it weren't true. Honestly, I get where Alma was coming from. She's matriarch of _one_ of, but not the _only,_ top families in their village.
That said, she's still wrong. Not because of what she said to the crowd, but because of what she _didn't_ say _after_ that. As soon as that happens, the next morning you grab the adults _and_ Mirabelle, minimum, and have a meeting, saying you believe her, but that you need to keep this _quiet_ (and for the reasons I listed above) while looking into it. Probably pull in Dolores, Louisa, and Isabella, too, and tell them to be on the look out for anything... to report it, but to do so _quietly_ until they can figure out what's going on. And _also_ that they may need to talk about when to involve the village, and what to do with their gifts if things are being problematic. In other words, not catastrophizing, not gaslighting, but _also_ not trying to sweep it under the rug _internally_ at least (even if, at first, you hide it from the neighbors until you figure it out or it's becoming an issue that affects others).
"...that's my prediction..."
You understand story telling _very_ well. :) Your prediction was 100% correct. At least at this point. You later add other stuff which is wrong, but... still, pretty good!
"...his room is terrible..."
Yeah... I remember seeing something on that, too. Honestly, it's hard to see how this house is being at all kind to most of them.
"...didn't give her a gift to test how strong they really are..."
That's one notion. Personally, my conclusion is that one of two things is true.
1) She's effectively disabled. It wasn't about giving or not giving, she was just born with an impairment. But _just because_ she's impaired in that way doesn't make her shameful or unable to do anything else.
2) If there _is_ an intent behind it... then it's to have Mirabel _replace_ Alma. Alma's getting old, she's gotta be _at least_ 70 in this movie. She won't be around much longer, so they need a new leader. Alma lacks magic, but she's got a will you could bend bars around. Name _anyone else_ in that family as strong-willed as Mirabel. The only thing Mirabel needs at this point is to learn a bit more from Alma and the others on how to navigate the social issues, so she doesn't burst in and scream the family's problems to the world.
Personally, I hope for the second, and given modern Disney it seems more likely that this is the case.
"...catalyzer..."
Catalyst.
Part 2 of 2
"...he's just telling you it's gonna happen..."
Actually, in the case of the wedding, he _did_ cause it. If he hadn't _said_ anything, she wouldn't have stressed out and had her emotions cause a hurricane (see the first Matrix movie with the Oracle, "What vase... how did you know I'd-" "mmmm, what's _really_ gonna cook your noodle later on is wondering if you'd even have broken it if I hadn't said anything"). But then he didn't _know_ that the _reason_ it happens would be because he said something. Bruno's gift shows what _will_ happen, and it takes Bruno's actions into account for that. As you see later, _every part_ of Bruno's vision about Mirabel _actually_ happened, _all_ of it. Bruno was wrong, his vision wasn't showing him that her future was undecided, it was showing that she would both break the house _and_ restore it.
Also, the history of people accusing those who _predict_ the future of making that future _happen_ is quite extensive. The problem is we suffer from hyperactive agency detection. When things happen, we find things with minds to blame it on. If you know what's coming, it's because you made it happen... at least according to a lot of folk. And, honestly, that _is_ one way you'd know. Moreover, this _same feeling_ has been used in entertainment, tricking us into accepting magic. When a magician sets up a trick that is running on automatic, but pretends that waving their hands is what caused the thing to move... that's the same idea. _They_ aren't doing anything, someone else is or it was set up to do it on its own. And this issue continues _today._
A (not professional) magician, Matt Dillahunty (better known for other things), performed a magic trick for people to try to explain skepticism to them. Then he _showed them how the trick was performed._ The reaction he got? They didn't believe him that what he was showing them of how the trick worked was what he did the first time. The first time was real magic, the next time was something else.
People are _alarmingly_ gullible.
(Side note: Two of the other issues, the hair loss and weight gain, might _also_ be Bruno's fault, as stress can cause both of those things.)
"...don't talk about it..."
Well, in defense of the father... he seemed, to me, to be suggesting they hold off on saying anything _that night._ Not that they hide it indefinitely, but that since they had company coming over and it was the night of the proposal to Isabella that they put a lid on it until _after_ that event. If we're being kind. This is a thing we all do to some extent. Of course... that proposal was _part of_ the problem, which talking about all this could have solved... but in a way it was too late. If all this had happened a day or two _before_ this, they might have had a different outcome.
"...I don't think she's much older than about 12 or 13..."
Pretty close. She's 15. Which, at the time, was is basically an adult in 1950s Colombia (which is where and when this takes place). The age of consent _today_ is 14 in Colombia.
"...and now everyone's seeing the cracks..."
If you mean the literal cracks in the walls and such, they definitely saw them before that. Alma motions to them a moment before this confrontation when talking to Mirabel's parents.
Great reaction.
Have a nice day!
@@robindude8187 Thanks for the very detailed comment 🙃 I enjoyed reading about your opinions to this movie 😊
i want a cool house like their's
Antonio and Mirabel are cousins
merbelle was 5 when when Brunio went into hiding
I want a house like this
Same 😍
@@queen_butterfly_1 so mich help and fun
how does Delous sleep
Encanto 2 Trailer
she's Antonio's cousin
love Brunio
Did you really skip the entire opening sequence?
how does Daloris ever sleep
Probably doesn't 😵😂
@@queen_butterfly_1 poor her
@@queen_butterfly_1 I assume her MAGIC ROOM is suited to helping her sleep and likely sound proofish
It's entirely sound proof, as confirmed by the creators. Still, terrible "gift". I have to assume she has to focus to hear things at full blast and anything else is just background noise otherwise her gift would have drove her mad many years ago.
👨💼👨💼👨💼👨💼👨💼👨💼