I quote this almost all the time to my friend group. (known locally as The Wolf) xD "Friends will come, and friends will go, but The Wolf goes on forever"
@Sdmedia or Splatter e Dodge, Dennis, BoCo, Freddie, Billy, George, Hank and the others Characters returning in CGI(specially in The Brenner Era S17-S21).
If he had returned to CGI alongside Sir Handel and Peter Sam in that bad episode, I don't think it would have been a great comeback... SPECIALLY in The Nitrogen/Miller era, remember how bad the 15 is?(looking the Bad returning of Wiff e Trevor in the S14 and S15 for example). In my opinion it would have been 100 times better if they had dropped the idea of having Duke come back and have him work at Ufsteld Castel during the S17 and King of The Railway, then yeah... have him go back to the Brenner era S17-S21.
I really enjoy these videos about the models. A few suggestions for the future would be Derek, Daisy, or the Troublesome Trucks. Keep up the good work!
I grew up with rusty to the rescue dvd definitely one of my favorites was always watching the 2 part duke the lost engine. I loved those two episodes out of the whole disc with its comfy atmosphere, music, sets, and all in wonder. thank you for the great episode and keep up the great work.
Fun Fact I've seen the Real life Palmerston engine dressed as Duke back in 2007 at york. Duke is another favourite character of mine I love his episodes in Season 4, Stories in the Books and his toys. Even though he's forgotten by the show I'm happy that the SIF team did ERS Stories about him which I really love to listen to.
It’s incredibly depressing that Duke never appeared again after season 4. It was also reported that Duke was supposed to return a total of 5 instances at different times but it just never happened.
@@darthknuxward3220 It has been a little while since I posted this comment so unfortunately I don’t remember the other 4 instances, but the most well known is him being in concept art for “Kevin the Steamie”, but as we all know it wouldn’t make it into the final cut.
I have done memories of driving down to Bayou Meto Arkansas when I was younger watching Thomas and Magic Railroad and the Rusty to the rescue DVD were my two favorite things to watch on my way down there, hence Duke was one of my favorite characters. :)
I was going to say that it would be interesting to see a video about the Flying Scotsman model, but then I remembered In the model series, only his tenders were made.
Out of all the narrow gauge engines duke is one of my most favorite engines alongside, Duncan, Peter Sam, & skarloey! I agree with basically all of what you said about him in this video and these facts of his model helped me understand why he wasn’t in future seasons ever since he appeared in the forth season of Thomas and friends the tv series! But they railway series book series is another story. But anyways good video by the way. 😊👏
1:49 The driver; how are you feeling you know after being left in a shed and all Duke; oh I’m fine, but did I really have to be taken to the skarloey railway with that thing The driver chuckled; you haven’t changed one bit, I wonder how Stuart and Falcon will react
I’m actually kind of glad duke didn’t appear in the hit model seasons because if he did he would’ve likely been flanderized like the rest of the narrow gauge engines
Yeah since they're old engines. They'd would have banters over their different way of wisdom like their senses of humor though Duke would be mostly no nonsense.
I kinda like how Duke doesn't look surprised when Falcon derails. It fits his character in a way, he knew the overconfident kid was going to slip up somewhere and was immediately ready to hold him back.
One of the rarest but most famous narrow gauge engine that is one of my favorite characters from season 4 also do you think you can do a history about Stepney’s model please?
I would have loved if they brought him back in CGI I imagine him and Luke would go along well, since he's rather nice compared to Stuart and Falcon when they were young
During my time when i was 8 i used to have a dvd about the full thomas and friends classic railways and boy i love watching the narrow gauge engines all day its very sad duke and smudger never appeared in cgi i wish also i lost the dvd a long time ago.
If I'm the director of the reboot, I would return to cgi. I would also introduce old characters like Duke, hank, molly, culdee engines,boco and smudged
TrainBoy, could it be possible to make a history of the Lynton and Barnstaple Railway's closed good van model? (This model appears in "a close shave for duck")
Man I hate all those people who call Thomas a messed up show saying it’s not suitable for kids because of stories like Granpuff and The Sad Story of Henry.
If he appeared in blue mountain mystery, he would call out Peter Sam, and Sir Handle for abandoning Thomas when they stupidly thought that Thomas broke their promise about Luke.
ThomasTankMerch really doing a better job with the models than Drayton Manor
Doesn't take much
I take better care of my socks than Drayton does of the models.
Thomastankmerch: I will take care of you forever and ever.
Drayton manor: no one likes you.
All of the models and the set that they run on Should all be handed to him
@@lisaandethanc4284 Or at least back to BRITT ALLCROFT.
“Engines come and engines go; Granpuff 'goes on' forever!"
- Falcon and Stuart
“You impertinent scallywags, whatever are you epi ges getting at”?
“Never mind Granpuff, we’re only young once”
I quote this almost all the time to my friend group. (known locally as The Wolf) xD
"Friends will come, and friends will go, but The Wolf goes on forever"
@@roaenokesyzlak7828 Well, you'd better mind, unless you wanna end up like Smudger....
@@namesarenotimp0rtant Smudger was cocky and rude. (Or whatever Duke said)
Duke the best narrow gauge character not in cgi
*best in ttte
To me Duke is the best engine in general.
also included the ones in the books like smudgers og character and like the culdee fell
@NWR Express Engine Mighty Mac and Fearless Freddie are also there, both of whom are interesting characters. But Duke is the best of course.
😢
“Cheer up grandpuff were only young once”
~ Sir Handel
Sir Handel is old asf
@@Unknown-nv7vh Ik
“WOLO” -Sir Handel, 1940-something
Sir handle\Falcon was built in 1904
"well you better mind unless you want to end up like smudger"
Duke isn’t the only one who could’ve came back.
*If it wasn’t for Paxton, we might have seen Derek again.*
I mean they have the same colours too
@Sdmedia or Splatter e Dodge, Dennis, BoCo, Freddie, Billy, George, Hank and the others Characters returning in CGI(specially in The Brenner Era S17-S21).
Seeing Duke appear in the CGI series, even for a short time, would have been great. If only the idea of him appearing in Kevin the Steamie was kept.
If he had returned to CGI alongside Sir Handel and Peter Sam in that bad episode, I don't think it would have been a great comeback... SPECIALLY in The Nitrogen/Miller era, remember how bad the 15 is?(looking the Bad returning of Wiff e Trevor in the S14 and S15 for example).
In my opinion it would have been 100 times better if they had dropped the idea of having Duke come back and have him work at Ufsteld Castel during the S17 and King of The Railway, then yeah... have him go back to the Brenner era S17-S21.
These are the kinds of videos that can never disappoint. Thank you again, sir, for giving us the content we all appreciate.
Duke is one of my favorite characters because of George's narration of him, and he's my 2nd lego model ttte I built (1st being Rusty).
I really enjoy these videos about the models. A few suggestions for the future would be Derek, Daisy, or the Troublesome Trucks. Keep up the good work!
I grew up with rusty to the rescue dvd definitely one of my favorites was always watching the 2 part duke the lost engine. I loved those two episodes out of the whole disc with its comfy atmosphere, music, sets, and all in wonder. thank you for the great episode and keep up the great work.
Fun Fact I've seen the Real life Palmerston engine dressed as Duke back in 2007 at york.
Duke is another favourite character of mine I love his episodes in Season 4, Stories in the Books and his toys. Even though he's forgotten by the show I'm happy that the SIF team did ERS Stories about him which I really love to listen to.
It’s incredibly depressing that Duke never appeared again after season 4. It was also reported that Duke was supposed to return a total of 5 instances at different times but it just never happened.
Do you remember all five instances?
@@darthknuxward3220 It has been a little while since I posted this comment so unfortunately I don’t remember the other 4 instances, but the most well known is him being in concept art for “Kevin the Steamie”, but as we all know it wouldn’t make it into the final cut.
@@ClipperMcflipper prob due to HiT’s orders
Smudger: Listen Dukey who worries about a few spills?
Duke: We do here I said but Smudger just laughed.
Duke: Until manager told him he would make him useful at last, Smudger stopped laughing then.
@@1v1_Empire Stuart and Falcon: W-why w-what did he do?
Duke: He turned him into a generator, he's still there behind our shed he'll never move again.
Hehehehehe
I have done memories of driving down to Bayou Meto Arkansas when I was younger watching Thomas and Magic Railroad and the Rusty to the rescue DVD were my two favorite things to watch on my way down there, hence Duke was one of my favorite characters. :)
*fun memories
This video truly would suit His Grace!
I'm glad that I was able to release my retelling of Duke's stories just before this video! This is amazing!
Who agrees that if duke could spear in AEG, he could play as a grandpa
Engines come and engines go, Grand-puff goes on forever!
I was going to say that it would be interesting to see a video about the Flying Scotsman model, but then I remembered In the model series, only his tenders were made.
Person: *randomly falls through Duke's shed*
Duke: "excuse me, are you a vandal? Driver told me vandals smash and break things"
Bless you no laughed the rescuers we dropped in because we couldn’t find your door
Out of all the narrow gauge engines duke is one of my most favorite engines alongside, Duncan, Peter Sam, & skarloey! I agree with basically all of what you said about him in this video and these facts of his model helped me understand why he wasn’t in future seasons ever since he appeared in the forth season of Thomas and friends the tv series! But they railway series book series is another story. But anyways good video by the way. 😊👏
I miss Duke. I wish he returned to CGI. Great video!
1:49
The driver; how are you feeling you know after being left in a shed and all
Duke; oh I’m fine, but did I really have to be taken to the skarloey railway with that thing
The driver chuckled; you haven’t changed one bit, I wonder how Stuart and Falcon will react
Wow, looks like Duke was found twice!
I’m actually kind of glad duke didn’t appear in the hit model seasons because if he did he would’ve likely been flanderized like the rest of the narrow gauge engines
You took about 20 episodes to cover Duke and that would never suit his grace
Man, I wish Duke was still around and had an episode with Skarloey, that would be interesting
Yeah since they're old engines. They'd would have banters over their different way of wisdom like their senses of humor though Duke would be mostly no nonsense.
Old Grandpuff is being a puff.
Love these videos, My second favorite narrow gauge besides Duncan and rusty
Love this old engine, great job!
Duke is my top 3 favorite characters
I like duke, he's one of those rare characters that I want a toy of it to my thomas collection as a kid.
I kinda like how Duke doesn't look surprised when Falcon derails. It fits his character in a way, he knew the overconfident kid was going to slip up somewhere and was immediately ready to hold him back.
This video would definitely suit his grace!
To be honest I tought u will do the main 6 narrow gauge engines before duke
One of the rarest but most famous narrow gauge engine that is one of my favorite characters from season 4 also do you think you can do a history about Stepney’s model please?
He’s o gauge!! That’s awesome
Duke = Thomas
Rusty = Edward
Peter Sam = Henry
Sir Handel = Gordon
Duncan = James
Rheneas = Percy
Bertram = Toby
Skarloey = Emily
I would have loved if they brought him back in CGI
I imagine him and Luke would go along well, since he's rather nice compared to Stuart and Falcon when they were young
And more willing to learn and well behaved too.
I love George Carlin was a voice of Duke.
7:00 HOLY SHIT TRAINBOY YOU GAVE ME A HEART ATTACK GODDAMIT
Engines that should be in CGI (my opinion
1.-duke
2.-bertram
3.-smudger
4.-BoCo
5.-jock
6.-frank
7.-fergus
8.-arthur
9.-murdoch
10.-molly
I like how Duke had a complete close up model
4:44 I love how they made it look like Duke is teasing Sir Handel 😂
This pleases His Grace.
duke needs much more attention because hes the hero of the railway
Dat ending tho
Nice
During my time when i was 8 i used to have a dvd about the full thomas and friends classic railways and boy i love watching the narrow gauge engines all day its very sad duke and smudger never appeared in cgi i wish also i lost the dvd a long time ago.
the focken calm music at the beginning and then falcon almost falling of a cliff focken hilarious
I missed it again darn great I always liked duke.
Good old Duke. I miss him.
Hi Trainboy I just wanted to say that Awdry made two models of Duke I just wanted to say that by the way nice video
I remember Duke!
If I'm the director of the reboot, I would return to cgi. I would also introduce old characters like Duke, hank, molly, culdee engines,boco and smudged
Hell yes
You wouldn't be allowed to make those decisions tho.
@@theoneandonlyluk7970 I know. I know. I'm just imagining
Are you starting now with the narrow gauge engines
Could we get skarloey or rusty next?
Duke is my favorite out of all of the narrow gauge engines.
TrainBoy, could it be possible to make a history of the Lynton and Barnstaple Railway's closed good van model? (This model appears in "a close shave for duck")
Up
well done, it was a fun streem
Duke, my favorite narrow gauge engine!
Epic video
Yo great video! (Small correction: awdry made 2 models of duke)
Can you do the history of Fearless Freddy please?
Man I hate all those people who call Thomas a messed up show saying it’s not suitable for kids because of stories like Granpuff and The Sad Story of Henry.
The only narrow gauge engines with tender I guess.
Duke is my favourite narrow gauge engine.
Me too
Me three
Doesn’t Thomastankmerch have a TH-cam channel?
I feel like I should remember the bit with the replacement tender
Thomas as a jinty sounds pog
I’m glad his grace is in a safe place
And not Dayton manor
4:44 Well i think we have found the real life story to Carson's A Tender Reunion
WHY ARE YOU MAKING THOMAS A JINTY REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE and thanks for FINALLY SUITING HIS GRACE
Duke is my faviorte narrow gauge engine too.
This was an awesome video
You should do The History of the Skarloey Railway engines
This video would suit his grace
Duke is my favourite narrow gauge engines
Honestly I'd like to see A model video of Fearless Freddie. I know he isnt a classic character but I really do wanna see the history if there is any
Great video next can have more diesels
I JUST MISSED IT!!! Anyways great video.
Wow Train boy you COOL
How long until the word “Bertram” is mentioned?
Edit: 4:19 folks
Good video.
If Duke did return in the Thomas And Friends CGI Series he would be voiced by Stacy Keach who did the voice of Skipper Riley in Disney's Planes 2013
I will break into ThomasTankMerch's house
That Ending Doe
If he appeared in blue mountain mystery, he would call out Peter Sam, and Sir Handle for abandoning Thomas when they stupidly thought that Thomas broke their promise about Luke.
He should’ve appeared in the cgi series
I always found it weird how Duke’s model never had front buffers. That always boggled me when I watched this show with my son years ago.
You should do the rest of the narrow gauge by number order inclusive freddie
Please do Rheneas or Skarloey next!
Ok I have to know this:
What do yall prefer to call him?
Like for granpuff
Dislike for Duke
To the people who dislike this video. That will never suit his grace!
hey trainboy do you plan to make a duke n scale model
@TrainBoy Any idea if TTM plans to repaint Duke to the correct shade?
Where the heck have I been? I just noticed he has a tender. Also at the end, “Regular Show”. Also @TrainBoy have you seen the CoolProps Thomas models?
I wish they brought back Boco
You Should Do Rosie Next
Ricky should be looking after Granpuff with his life
Models do be ding very good
dukey dukey - Smudger
What’s a Thomas jinty?