Ranking ALL 32 NFL starting quarterbacks! Are CJ Stroud and Jordan Love top 10 QBs?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 พ.ค. 2024
- This episode is sponsored by AURA! Stop data brokers from exposing your personal information. Go to aura.com/OLineCommittee to get a 14-day free trial and see how much of your information is being sold.
Jeremiah Sirles, Alex Boone and Phil Mackey are here to rank the NFL’s quarterbacks, and much more!
1:00 -- Alex Boone laments being an adult, which launches the boys into farm-life stories
9:00 -- Mackey ranks the 32 projected starting QBs in the NFL! This leads to some fun debates!
39:00 -- New York Giants backup QB Tommy DeVito is a CONFIDENT dude!
45:00 -- A college football player is suing for his NIL money
57:00 -- Fanatics is suing Marvin Harrison, Jr.
60:00 -- Dumb Football Questions: Do players really need agents?; Who is the most revolutionary offensive line coach ever and why?; Do college football players care about getting degrees?
Please click the LIKE and SUBSCRIBE buttons to help us grow this channel!
OLine Committee OFFICIAL MERCH! -- the-oline-committee-shop.four...
Listen to OLine Committee on Spotify! -- open.spotify.com/show/4I4s73D...
#BlueWireVideo
---
Two former NFL offensive linemen (Alex Boone and Jeremiah Sirles) team up with a die-hard football fan and media dweeb (Phil Mackey) for entertaining, informative, opinionated, behind-the-scenes discussions about the game -- from a trenches perspective!
#NFL - กีฬา
Only show I can actually watch for 30+ minutes straight. You guys are great
The chemistry on this channel is unheard of.
This is the best sports talk pod I've found since Green Light. It's informative , funny, and pretty chill. Well, unless Prison Warden Alex is in charge😊 Thanks fellas!
😊 50:49 50:54
“Magic Johnson cured aids with money” 😂 comedy gold. You guys need to organize a listener party/gathering eventually!
Thank you for the show
Literally my favorite show on TH-cam. When you see the title you KNOW it’s going to be an awesome show! Almost at 20k followers! Let’s go!!
Using UDFA during contract negotiations for a veteran is like asking someone with 10 years of work experience what their GPA was
My great grandpa was the corn hand picking champion for the state of Minnesota in the 1920-30s. They called it the battle of the bang boards. I cannot imagine how hard that was.
I was tapping to open a different app when the banner notification popped down. I hit that instead; here I am. Let’s go boys.
Also: enable notifications.
Best podcast going ‼️🥃
Boone and his kid interaction was as real as it gets😂😂😂😂 You guys are awesome!!!😂 1:08:20
Im sitting in the combine, harvesting Corn in South Africa listening to you 3 stuges saying how you worked on your family ranches. 😀🤣
Aint no way that man said magic cured aids with money lmao
Southpark said that like 20 years ago. He stole that comment if he did!
@@23ryanfisher damn now i do remember seeing that episode 😂
This is hands down my favorite podcast I've ever followed. You guys always bring it. Thanks for the hours of awesome entertainment.
Duuuuude... I grew up in the city, but my grandparents had 75 acres of alfalfa like 50 miles out of town, and we threw hay bails every year at harvest.
Also during the summer, we did landscaping for my aunt and uncle, who were Marine DI's in the 70's.
When my brother and I were 13 and 12, we spent the entire summer in the house we remodeled. One weekend, dug up and re-sculpted a backyard pathway of 6, tons of landscaping brick. In late June. In a 105° heat wave.
When my brother joined the core in 2018, he was already prepared for how hard they work you.
Moving rocks hit home with me. Except in my backyard it was a few dozen railroad ties.
There's a difference between gym strength and work strength. No freaking doubt
You guys are always the best part of my work week; keep it up!
Jeramaiah I was driving to Lincoln at 6am for work from Omaha and holy shit man I got slammed with rain and hail on i80.
Keep up the locker room insights....you guys funny insightful..informative
Great episode boys!! I think Boone went through his Cursing Quota for the year in the first 10 minutes….. and I FUCKING LOVE IT!! 😂
I see your rocks and ante up 100# square bales to stack on a trailer, then re-stack in a hay mow....love the podcast guys. Growing up on the farm was the best!
I worked landscaping from 17-23 it was a good college job and kept me in shape for lacrosse. Once I graduated I decided I wanted to continue working landscaping- it fucking sucked, long ass hours/horseshit pay, body is constantly in the shitter bc ur move 300-700lbs rocks for boulder walls. I eventually left bc I wanted to do more union level projects which is its own headache but Whenever my gf wants to do landscape project I just start getting war flashbacks
I was prepared to get mad at the ranking for Sam Darnold but then realized that "May not be starting is a month" is a perfectly fair ranking, lol.
You guys get me through the day. Got a co-worker to subscribe today….he’s a big Nebraska fan
Respect for y’all for putting respect on Jared Goffs name my dudes!
Verbal contracts are binding as long as there is a "meeting of the minds". If I've learned anything from watching 30 years of Judge Judy, verbal contracts are binding unless there is a written contract that supersedes the verbal agreement.
Dumb football question: does coaching staff allow star players to voice opinions on draft picks/coaching hires?
Thanks for the content boys, easily my favorite podcast!
When you said Lamar is a 4k yard passer was that a prediction? It has to be since he's never thrown 4k yards.
he saw the 24-25 season script lol
You need lawyer Chase on this episode.
Best Podcast on UTUBE
You are talking about my grandfathers and my dad and uncles. They're all gone now but they were farmer strong. :)
Great Ep! Keep posting this Sh!t!
Back in the 60’s we loaded flat bed trailers with 50 lbs bags cement. About have the football and wrestling team worked there during the summer
"Lamar is a 4k passer married to a 1k rusher."
What boss? What year did Lamar hit 4k passing?
I don't feel a need to back the beeping truck up to Jackson but c'mon....we could.
I like how you got the quote wrong lol
@@wc6046 I didn't memorize it. I didn't see a transcript either. It's a point I disagree with. There was an hour long podcast and one point I disagreed with. That's a pretty solid success rate.
He had a not perfectly consistent rookie this season & Hollywood Brown as his #1 receiver in his other MVP season. Raise your hands if those were your top fantasy football choices. I don't know why some QBs get consideration for their team's coaching & play-calling & others don't, especially as Lamar's old OC has had some of the most in-depth videos done on what he does wrong & it's _everything._ If he wasn't there to undermine Lamar's chances of getting the huge contract then something is _seriously wrong_ with ownership & management of that team.
Yeah, I gotta watch you guys all the time! And, I never thought that watching Offensive Line guys talk about their craft could be so entertaining!
Any agent available for hire to negotiate my salary with my current employer at the end of the year? TIA lol
52:57 that sounds turning college sports into semipro sports or a quasi farm system
19.9k!!! It must be so close.
Dumb football question: Alex and Jeremiah if you guys had to choose 4 players past or present to play with you in the trenches who would they be?
Here’s my booster: Michael Hunt. Just call him Mike….🤣
Sirles, the ⚡️⚡️drafted McKinley and have Hayden & Hurst & Parham in the TE room. Plus Chark, Rice and Johnston was thrown into a role he doesn’t fit well last year. Herbert made Guyton & Tyron Johnson known names in the chargers community his rookie year. He’ll elevate the pass catchers with a run game that keeps the D honest for the first time in his career! Tell em Boone!!!
JJ has six interceptions in three practices. I think that's the box you have to look at as well. 🤣
Correcting Jeremiah Swift went from Eagles to Bears not the Lions.
Hi, guys.Thank you for the love it
JJ McCarthy #1, suck it J.
Got my jersey ordered
Skol
Why does Purdy get knocked for being helped by his system when Goff plays in almost the exact same offensive system?
As much as I agree that the NIL should be more formal, just because a person does not sign something specific does not mean there is not a contract. Generally, contracts only require an offer, acceptance, and consideration. Yes, it is preferred to have a written contract, but an oral offer, that is said with serious intent to honor, can be an enforceable contract. That is why I agree that there should be a more formal process.
Everyone loves landscaping until they do it for a living, playing in the back yard is not landscaping.
Jared Goff had the best Oline in the league last year, fantastic skill position players, and Johnson as his offensive coordinator how does that not have the same effect on him that the 49ers & Miami situations have on there QB's?
Goff has been great these last few years but I would love to see how he did for instance behind last year's 49ers Oline!!
Dumb Football Question: If there wasn't a salary cap, which team would have the best roster?
My bag is scarred
Wow Brock Purdy 12th seems like a terrible take. Especially with someone like Lawrence above him. What has Lawrence done in the NFL that has shown he can produce better than Purdy? When does actual NFL production matter more than a draft position? Not sure how to grade this are we saying who has the best athletic scores or who plays the position the best?
Lawrence and Herbert over any other top 10 QB and they don't compare in stats/wins/production. So why is draft postiion and combine stats still what people rank on?
C’mon Boonie. Just use a large neck bottle of Gatorade like the truck drivers.
Every advanced stat says Purdy is an at worst a Top 10 QB, and many place him firmly in the Top 5. Jimmy G, Trey Lance, CJ Betheard, Nick Mullins, and Sam Darnold couldn’t produce anywhere near Purdy’s level. Since that Miami game in 2022, nobody has more TDs or fewer INTs. Nobody averages more air yards per attempt or completion. No QB in NFL history has ever had a season where they were top 5 in yards and bottom half in completions. That’s called efficiency!
Swift is in Chicago now Searls. Somebody give Jeremiah a current Bears roster. So Caleb with DJ Moore, Udunze, Keenen Allen, D'Andre Swift and Cole Kmet is 24th?🤣🤣🤣
Bears suck tho
Rookies should always be deadliest until they play a snap
Coming soon. NIL money for the Pop Warner stud RB…
100 away from 20k!!!
Jimmy made the Watson trade! AB loves his draft picks while Jimmy loves the splash moves.
Keep the hair Joe
Jeremiah it's called a verbal contract
Can you really be a "cheat code" if you have 2 career playoff wins going into your 6th year?
All these chokers like Herbert, Lamar and Dak need to be regraded because they always fall short when needed most!
NIL and length of play in college. Dependent upon whim of politicians.
Most of these universities are state schools.
Many of the big schools are Ag Grant.
It will be decided. And may not be in the way you like.
Tyrod Taylor has the best gig. All that cash AND not getting crushed every Sunday…
Oh yes i miss the farm life
Dumb Football Question: Do any of you guys get out of football without retiring before you get seriously hurt. Watching Jerome Bettis walk hurts my knees…
DFQ: In a perfect storm scenario, Darnold and KOC are clicking and Darnold throws for 4000yds 40tds and 10int. Do the Vikings sign or entertain signing Darnold to a long term deal as the franchise QB?
23:05 Smith ***
Why does everyone rank T Law so high? What has he done
THE DISRISPECT ON PURDY IS MASSIVE, GUYS YOU KNOW ABOUT FOOTBALL WHAT I KNOW OF PARTICLE PHYSICS
Euphoria
I thought of this 2 yrs ago with Livvy Dunne. Lsu could make more money. She could make more money. But when she runs out of eligibility she's the 18th best gymnast in the country and has no shot at the national team.
Dumb oline question: How can a line be rated top 5 in pass protection but be bottom 5 in run protection or vice versa? You'd think if a line is elite in one regard their baseline for the other would be at least average but that rarely seems to be the case.
Dumb Football Question: Best UFDA you played with?
Can't with the Rodgers hate.
Purdy should be higher than 12.
Trevor Lawrence over Matthew Stafford is egregious.
Um.. verbal contracts are real contracts.
Should Bachmans sponsor Boonie?
2 seconds in the Hogs are battling hehehe Rhino you protest too mulch hahaha
Dumb ?- best complete Oline unit in NFL history?
7 acre farm?
UFL Update. Brahmas made the playoffs…🎉
Absolutely ridiculous rankings
Buddy in the red shirt is fucking clueless. Rodgers is easily a top 10 QB. What a joke of a list that casual made.
Lawrence above stroud is laughable and Herbert that high is silly
Dumb football question, inspired by the QB rankings and the talent dropoff... Is NFL QB the hardest job in the world? Simply because there are only 20 guys who can do it proficiently at any given time? Of course there are jobs with higher stakes, like brain surgeon or astronaut. But there are way more than 20 people who can do those jobs well. What other job can only 20 excel at?
Mackey's QB list is the biggest piece of 💩 on the Internet this week.
Boone, how did Ohio State get away with cheating all those years?
Dumb Football Question, or maybe not so dumb.
What is wrong with the Giants OL? 10 years of bad OL play. Players change, coaches change, front office changes, yet the OL is just perpetually bad. Young players don't develop, vet players come in and get worse. I cannot figure it out, you guys have any idea? Will this new OL coach make a difference? Will Neal figure it out?
12 for Purdy is fair… even though I think he’s light years better then Dak and Goff. My only real issue is CJ stroud is in the same system as Brock and no one mentions it. I think Stroud is great… but let’s pump the brakes until we see it happen again.
Is this about football or landscaping ??
Let me throw you guys for a loop. th-cam.com/video/5JO1PsupF_U/w-d-xo.html. Count how many times ball -placement from the QB forces the receiver to0 have to stop altogether or a few more inches might have meant they don't get tackled. Fields throws only 2 of the latter.
Caleb throws over 10 of both kinds.
Fields was _WAY more_ accurate a passer as well as better rusher than Caleb in college only media didn't call him generational. Likely because those pretty spirals that Caleb threw were caught, making him Look spectacular. But he's not in Fields' _league_ when it comes to accuracy.
If you watch highlights, despite the lack of on-field talent (let's play "how many times do his receivers deflect passes that hit them in the hands into becoming INTs or Incomplete Passes") Fields not only still does in the NFL everything Caleb has only so far done in college he actually improves in '21, threading those eye-level passes just out of reach of defenders like Dan Marino used to.
Everything changed in '22. It's just even former players have short memories like the fans do. Man, _everything_ Fields got blamed for was actually due to play-calling & lack of on-field talent.
Here's hoping he gets to start anywhere soon.
The only thing Dak hasn't done is win a Superbowl and he's ranked lower than guys who also haven't won a Superbowl. He's held to a different standard.
You’re Kyler take is so lazy and like 2 years out of date
Please... only do the QB bs once a year. Ugh
Guys 11 minutes of your small talk not of my interest please just jump up to the content you almost lost my attention and for sure you lose many others attention
I holding your receipts and when Jordan Love dominates the league and the Lions I am going to tell you #1. You don't know shit, #2, You don't know quarterbacks and #3. you don't know Matt Lafleur!
1 Mahomes 2 Burrow 3 Allen 4 Tua 5 Jackson 6 Lawrence 7 Stroud 8 Purdy 9 Hurts 10a Stafford 10b Prescott 11a Herbert 11b Love
Your top 10 is laughable just dumb to have guys like Herbert, Goff, Dak, Allen over CJ Stroud and Brock Purdy or Jalen Hurts, is just dumb
Love is not top 10. But, he's a he's good enough. I'd put him at 12-14, but that's plenty high to win it all if the rest of the team is good enough. So far, Stroud IS top 10, but I think he has to avoid the sophomore slump to keep that status.
Mahomes and Allen are still the water mark for the NFL.
Lost
Why didn't you talk about Charger's draft pick Ladd McConkey?????