Ranking EVERY Bethesda RPG WORST TO BEST (Top 8 Games Including Starfield)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 ก.ย. 2024
- Howdy everyone, and today we are ranking the 8 RPGs by Bethesda Game Studios. Including the newly released Starfield. Any support is greatly appreciated!
#starfield #skyrim #fallout
Skyrim is my favorite game of all time, hands down an easy pick.
why
Skyrim=GOAT!!!! Agree!
Absolutely blessed with content lately, thanks for filling up some slow days lately
The first Bethesda game I ever played was Oblivion on the PS3, was one of the first games I ever got on the console, it blew my mind away the amount of depth that was in the game. I didn't play anything else for months. Still one of my favourites ever.
best game of all time imo, better on pc
It's hard for me to rank this list myself
I absolutely adore most of their games
For me to really rank their games I would have to make two lists, one to try and objectively look at which ones are actually their best
And then another where I forgo that objectivity and just rank them based on which ones are my favorites
The two don't match up only because which of their games are my favorites have shifted as time has gone on because some of the ones I absolutely loved prior don't hold up well as much, namely oblivion
So if I had the rank them in order of favorites these days it would go like this
1. Skyrim
2. Fallout 3
3. Starfield
4. Oblivion
5. Fallout 4
6. Morrowind
Never played 76 and I never will
Now if I had to really try and think about which of these games are actually their best as far as what they offer looking at them for how they were at time of release... Well that list changes
1. Oblivion
2. Skyrim
3. Fallout 3
4. Morrowind
5. Starfield
6. Fallout 4
7. Hamtaro
You have starfield at 3 your weird
Lmao casual gamer
@@mr.fantastic7756 trying to present yourself as some kind of hardcore gamer isn't the flex you think it is dude.
@@adamdavis1737 it is, kinda
The Railroad and The Institute are just shoved in there last moment? What are you talking about? The whole story and game world was built around these two factions. Infact the whole idea for the plot started with a quest in Fallout 3 called "The Replicated Man."
For real, the Institute were the group we essentially see first before even leaving the vault lol.
I’ve only really played starfield and Skyrim and I do enjoy both games, both are really good in my opinion.
The so called dated aspects of Morrowind are actually my favorite parts of the game, I love that theres no quest marker guiding your every footstep, it prompts actual exploration rather than just staring at the ui. Also Oblivions dungeons are NOT randomly generated like in Daggerfell, the only random elements are the loot and enemy gear, and thats based on level. The Oblivion gates are also handcrafted but the ones that you encounter in the wilderness, that aren't part the main quest, are chosen from like 10 preset options when you enter them. Which preset you get is random but the levels themselves aren't.
My favourites are: Dragon Age: Origins, The Witcher 3, Baldur's Gate, Wasteland 3, Mass Effect 2, Skyrim, Fallout New Vegas.
A true rpg lover
Your killing it with ranking videos! Keep it up!
i wouldnt change much, but F4 over F3 and Morrowind? its not a crime but, i would have putten it bellow TES3 and F3.
I think that's how people who grew up with Bethesda would rank them - F3 and Morrowind being higher on the list. For someone coming in fresh, the gameplay of F3 and Morrowind can really feel wonky.
Also, I think some people were OK with F4's RPG mechanic, as....thin as it was.
Every Bethesda game is someone’s favourite so it’s a very divisive series
He be rankin without blankin
Another great ranking video. Incredibly analytical and comprehensive opinions, it really shows how much work and effort is going in these videos. I was really glad to see Fallout 4 pretty high on this list and a bold move ranking it above fallout 3, the game is just so under-rated really. Also skyrim 1st place i also think is a fair placement. In any case just want to give some more support to this channel, i know its not a lot but i hope it helps even a little bit in any way. Please let me know if you are okay with suggestions in general, thanks.
wow that is incredibly generous of you. I really do appreciate the support like it seriously does help. Its thanks to people like you that make me continue making these videos. If you would like to see me look at something specifically just let me know. While I cannot say it will be looked in like the next week or two I can still shoot it to the top of my priority list for you. And again thank you for the generous support.
@@TotallyTubularJonathan I am happy to help out, I just can't help but notice the effort that goes into these videos and I know finishing all these games is no walk in the park, I myself spend almost 70 hours on finishing dying light 2 recently so I know it can be exhausting sometimes. In any case I will not drop a reccomendation now but I will drop one in my next donation. Don't get me wrong I am not trying to rush you or anything like that, I just want to participate in a way that feels meaningful
you my friend are legendary and are absolutely participating in a way that feels meaningful. And yes finishing all these games/videos its a grind but I welcome it. And Dying Light 2 is a great one to spend 70 hours in! I liked it more than the first one!
@@TotallyTubularJonathan Thank you for the kind words. Yeah dying light 2 is an improvement, especially parkour. In any case I look forward on watching more of your videos.
I have no idea how you put out this much content, but it’s very impressive and you deserve more subs.
Morrowind is the most RPG of all Bethesda games. There’s a quest you get from a woman on a random road who is wearing The Boots of Blinding Speed. She can’t see due the boot and needs an escort to a nearby town. The reward is the boots that give you super speed but also blinding the wearer without magic resistance. You can either escort her or… kill her and take the boots. You can do that with every quest reward instead of doing the quest and that makes Morrowind the most immersive and the best rpg. There are no characters that can’t be murdered unlike the rest of the Bethesda titles. Hate a faction? Kill them. Hate a quest giver? Kill them. This means you can only role play and absolute psychopath in Morrowind. now that’s role playing.
I’m not saying it’s the best game. Just the best RPG Bethesda has to offer
Can't you do that in skyrim too?
@@DanteMayCry-qv5kf nope, skyrim sucks
@@WeirdTroll666 Nah you suck
Probably the most controversial video, yet.
Touché Spaceguy.
Oblivion was so goated
Heya fella,just stumbled across this video have to say I love your honest opinions,my history with Bethesda games started with Morrowind.
My favourite has to be Fallout 3, still play it once a year...I'm thinking that Starfield gets a lot of bad press but for me it's sort of meeting the AC series in the middle,they are ramping up the 'rpg'aspects while Starfield is dumbing it dowm.im fine with with both and after about 150 hours into Starfield I'm loving it,maybe that's because I have to after all I did buy a Series X just to play it.
Anyway keep up the good work I have subscribed and can't wait to see your next video,thank you.
Great list!
My list- i love all of these games
6. Morrowind: Like you i didnt play it as a kid
5. Fallout 4
4. Starfield
3. Skyrim
2. Oblivion
1. Fallout 3
morrowind isn't that outdated i'd say, great rpg, and i even played it recently. Skyrim is really really overrated tbh.
Morrowind is the best Bethesda game, but I disagree with your Skyrim take. Skyrim holds up a lot better than Oblivion which is a weird in between. Also, you suck.
How I would rank them:
6) Starfield - I did enjoy it overall but the lack of on foot exploration worth engaging in ruins a lot of the appeal of a bethesda game
5) Morrowind -I didnt play it til i was like 25 and it had been out for 15 years or so, it was pretty dated
4) FO4 - I really like this game but some of the changes - move to perks, the voiced protagonist, etc - just werent for me
3) FO3 - great game, i just dont enjoy my time as much as the two above this one
2) Skyrim - all time classic, think its 2nd for me mostly just because Oblivion was the first BGS game i played
1) Oblivion - My first bgs game, also personally think this was where bethesda's quest design and creativity peaked. As great as skyrim is i feel thats where their quest design went downhill a bit, it was still good, but felt there was a downward turn there. There were so many great quests in oblivion - Who Dunnit, the haunted house you buy, a brush with death, that quest where you sleep on the boat and wake up at sea. There seemed to be a lot less quests where you talked to somebody and the quest was basiclaly just "go uh kill these guys in this building and come back" which is what it felt most of fallout 4's quests were. Dark brotherhood and thieves guild were both incredible, and while the graphics are dated now i love the art style, almost looks like a watercolor painting or something. Will probably always be my favorite bgs game
Good job man very nicely made video
Out of the ones I have played I would rank Morrowwind and Fallout 3 as my two favorites.
If New Vegas was on this list, it’s right up there with Skyrim if not better. But ya know, obsidian…
Before I watch the video, knowing what the contenders are, I'm gonna say what's my personal list and I'll later see to check how much I got right
8 - Elder Scrolls Blades
7 - Starfield
6 - Fallout 4
5 - Fallout 76
4 - Skyrim
3 - Fallout 3
2 - Morrowind
1 - Oblivion
Fallout 4 is best in terms of visuals, gameplay, world and has the most addictive loop.
Hey I’m just wondering if you included new vegas on the list, where would you place it?
I liked Oblivion and Morrowind far more than I liked Skyrim - especially Vanilla, unmodded Skyrim. While for FO3, The only memories I had of it, was that it was pretty buggy and crashed a lot the time I played it back in 2008. It was okay when it worked, but most of the time it crashed every 20 min on my PC.
same. skyrim is overrated
I gotta say, if Skyrim wasn’t horribly written (talking dragons, *wooooooot* ) I would like it a lot more. As is, I’d say it’s a 6 and Oblivion is both smarter and more wondrous. But I’m happy you liked it!
Oblivion has aged like pooh, its worse than Skyrim and significantly worse than Morrowind.
@@FrogWalrus no
It's funny that you call Starfield's engine an "old ass engine" because it's actually a new engine and Starfield is the first game made on it. It's the Creation Engine 2, which is supposed to be a more advanced version of the engine that Bethesda has been using for years, at least since Morrowind.
i started with morrowind when i was in high school and i spent a crazy amount of time just running around killing stuff and looting before i ever touched the main quest. amazing game.
The only mod you really need for Morrowind is accurate attack
Lmao casual gamer. Unsubscribed and blocked.
I’m sure he’s devastated…
fallout 3 and 4 over Morowind is a crime
He did say at the beginning that he didn’t play Oblivion and Morrowind back in the day and played them recently. Both of them, Morrowind especially though, have aged like milk. I can see how someone might have that opinion if they never played Morrowind growing up.
Fun watch and i am sure it took a lot of time so thanks for that. Personally, and i didn't grow up with these games really either, i can't stand Skyrim, Fallout 4 or Starfield. There's a difference between streamlining and removing all the fun out of characters. I don't even care about Elder Scrolls 6 or Fallout 5 based on Bethesda's trajectory. They have no problem rereleasing Skyrim 100 different times instead of actually making good games. They're the video game equivalent of M Night Shamylan and Zack Snyder. "Remember how cool and successful we were with this one movie we made a long time ago? Let's just keep doing that except worse and with less effort thrown in."
Leveling and character builds in Skyrim are beyond boring. I mean, i don't really get into heavy RPG mechanics a lot but Morrowind and Oblivion actually made me appreciate how much it attaches me to the world. I'd go either Fallout 3 or Oblivion for the best, even though they are both flawed. Morrowind #3. Everything else from Bethesda is just meh or worse. I hope Todd gets fired and they actually put someone with a genuine passion for their properties in charge. I mean, they let Obsidian make Fallout New Vegas and that game is 100% better than anything Bethesda has ever put out.
Fallout 3 > 4 imo, but great list! Oblivion will always have a special place in my heart, one of my first 360 games.
fallout new Vegas is the best RPG maybe ever.
N'wah
YOOOO he actually did it!! great video as always
Love these ranking videos!
“Starfield is Among Us”
Fallout 4 is number 1 for me
Awful
if you had to rank them, where would you put daggerfall/arena? :> Both are great, though have their issues :> Especially worth playing daggerfall unity.
2:48 the Switch is a mobile device
Always enjoy your videos!
Morrowind is behind F4 and F3? U're crazy. Me too is the person that thinks Oblivion is better than Morrowind, I give you that, but there's no way in Universe that shameful F3 and F4 is ahead of Morrowind
Morrowind is an incredible game, it's so much better than 4 it's not even close. 3 I absolutely love though and I think it's on par with Morrowind for me.
I mean it's just his opinion as well dawg
Almost like he said this was his opinion.
@@DemonKingNemo yes
The crazy part is that the only fallout better than morrowind is new Vegas
To be fair, blades was a great game for mobile. With nintendo switch and steam deck... it just doesnt have anything. :D
Is the music st the beginning the tranzit cod zombie map
If Fallout New Vegas was included on this list, where would you place it?
i will just say high up there
Hamtaro is in that old anime series 🐹🙂
Oblivion is by far the best Elder Scrolls game. The faction quests alone carry this to the top.
yessir
No
@@WeirdTroll666 You suck
@@FrogWalrus yes
Hamtaro, man. Great video.
Timestamps are available for a reason
New vegas?
That’s what I’m saying
Not a Bethesda game, it was developed by Obsidian
He literally mentions why it wasn’t included at the start…
Todd Howard is quite similar to Mr Biden
Really need time stamps
for me best to worst I would put them
blades though never played but everything I've ehard....bad.
starfield, this might be controverstial, but too many issues, I could write 5 paragraphs about them and will if someone wants to know them, but yeah this was bad, tedious, boring most of the time, some repetative exploration and many things.
Fallout 76, for all it's issues it has something that starfield doesn't....heart, and fun exploration, it's lacking a lot of other issues, but it was actually fun to go out and do dungeons and areas, unlike with starfield.
Oblivion. Probably the weakest of the elderscrolls series, it's exploration was almsot as bad as starfield, though it at least had some unique areas and such, but best loot I EVER found were all in two dungeons, every other place no matter how cool or remote, just ended up disapointing.
Arena. Where it all started, fun game, fun leveling system, I love that the amont of mana you have remains the same other then of course increasing INT, but instead the spells get cheaper based upon your level. So a 1000 mana spell at level 10 will cost 100 and so on. Started the adventures and was fun for it's time, recently finally beat after 30 years and enjoyed.
Daggerfall, this is a great game, though lacks a real outerworld, only real issue I have with it, a bit dated, but was fun to explore and do stuff, had werewolves, and wereboars, daedra and many more things. I rcommend checking out I think it's called daggerfall unity wich is a newer updated version with improved graphics and mod support.
fallout 4, not the best game in the series, but still had fun exploration, even if they had dumbed down a lot of stuff that made the previous games fun and memorable.
Fallout 3: Really good game, fun if I wasn't SOOO far behind on other games and backlog I wouldn't mind playing through again.
Skyrim, the grandaddy of them all, in some ways worse then Morrowind, but fixed so much and had a great time with exploration, definetly one of my favorites.
Morrowind, The fist elderscrolls for many people, still modded to this day I played this to death, I think at one point I had more hard drive filled with mods for the game, then the base game itself hehe. Werewolves before blood moon, and many more things. Maybe nostalgia so would have to play it again but definetly put it slightly above skyrim.
I loved Hamtaro
Fallout 76 is ahead of Starfield by a mile. You're taking the vanilla game 76 was and comparing it to all the other games which is intellectually dishonest. 76 while still divisive amongst fans is probably making Bethesda the most money and is now quite successful.
I literally even said I came back to the game in 2023. A majority of my play time is from 2023. You can even tell the gameplay is from 2023. The game is still ass lol just not abysmal
Did you even listen? You brain dead moron
IMO:
Skyrim: 10/10
Fallout 4: 9.5/10
Fallout 3: 9/10
Oblivion: 9/10
Starfield: 8/10
Morrowind wasn't even playable for me because I couldn't get past the generic fetch quests and the horrible combat.
💯
Morrowind worse than Fallout 4? The last good game made by Bethesda is worse than Fallout 4? Sorry man, but please accept my dislike.
Morrowind might be better than Fallout 4, if you avoid Morrowind's combat system. Morrowind might be better than combating malaria, if you avoid Morrowind's combat system.
@@looker999997 As your skills and stats level up, you will land your hits almost all the time and there are mods to make hits and spells always land.
Saying Morrowind is their last good game is insane
how much did Todd pay you for that Starfield review?
I really wish he did
Apparently the people who like Starfield are less credible than the people who played it for 100+ hours and still say it sucks.
This list is wrong.
Yeah, subjective rankings can’t really be wrong buddy.
Nice video, however putting Morrowind above Starfield looks sily. Morrowind even in his times was deeply flawed game and it aged very bad. It is unplayable right now even with mods. I played it a while because in his time it was it was technical achievement but most of its systems were just broken. It was beta version of the Oblivion tbh.
The writing, world building, ambience and role playing elements puts Morrowind far above any Bethesda Fallout game and firmly above Oblivion and Skyrim as the best game they ever made (as well as one of the best RPGs of all time).
@@younghegelian1 🤣
@@younghegelian1 very true
@@jmangames5562 you are 🌈
For me:
1) Skyrim
2) Fallout 4
3) Fallout New Vegas (with mods, I never even bothered trying to play it without mods)
4) Fallout 3
5) Oblivion
6) Starfield
None of them are bad, though
"Fallout New Vegas (with mods, I never even bothered trying to play it without mods)'" why?
No fallout new Vegas?
He mentions it at the start if you actually watch the video.
My personal take
1 oblivion
2 morrowind
3 fallout new vegas
4 fallout 3
Dont care for the rest i played them all yet i don't like them
And no im not a "nostalgia blinded fanboy" im literally 21 i never played those games on my childhood i used to play rts games back then
I just think sometimes you just have to say "NO" everyone can have their own opinion and tastes and should be respectful even if they dont agree with others
fallout new vegas > morrowind > skyrim > daggerfall > fallout 3 > oblivion > fallout 4
Play Starfield on the X: it runs much better.
Отлично
Отлишно
Stop swearing in video because my mum is watching and I’m in trouble now :(
I think Starfield is still even behind 76. At least with a multiplayer game you can always make fun with friends. Starfield is barren and there's no real excuse, there's more species diversity in Cyrodil alone than across a thousand planets in Starfield and having more in a game about space exploration when you offer a thousand planets and only 50 of those planets support life is pretty important. The combat felt clunky regardless of using Mouse and Key or Controller. they try to excuse a bunch of crap with "realism" but 80% of the weapons don't make mechanical sense, like less than base level understanding of firearms lack of mechanical sense. The moral ambiguity that Bethesda games play with is pretty much void, an experimental aerosolized contagion is the obvious right answer according to every NPC follower in the game, because it released after Coof, and they had their opinions manually changed to chastise you for thinking, in general an experimental drug is less preferable than introducing a natural predator to hunt an invasive species, and honestly the issue is that it's so obvious that originally they were both supposed to be comparable option. Oh and many storylines are very lazy "rip-offs" of other better sci-fi. It's not the worst game ever, just the worst Bethesda game ever.
Fallout 4 above 3 is blashephemous. It's barely even a Fallout game and is nowhere near as fun in my opinion. Plus Liam Neeson is your Dad.
Fallout 4 is my favourite
@@otakarlojkasek488 Sinner
Starfield is the worst because it has pronouns ( is just a joke. Didn't played the game yet )
@@tmoney142 Oh no, on the contrary, I found Starfield the less true Bethesda. The other games are also about exploring and finding interesting stuff on the way, let that be Bethesda's strongest abilitie, unfortunately it's Starfield 's biggest flaw.
Imo, Bethesda doesn’t make good games, just buggy messes that are clunky. The only game that is somewhat competent is Fallout New Vegas strictly bc of the side quests.
I don’t agree staefeild has good combat especially the space combat it’s pretty bad imo
staefeild does have good combat, but Starfield does not.
@@FrogWalrus lmao fair enough and honestly I tried to give it benefit of the doubt but I haven’t touched it since beating it and no longer looking forward to any elder scrolls or fallout content Bethesda incompetent and can’t change format to suit a fun gaming experience
*staefeild*
TOP IDIOTIC RANKING CASUAL CONSOLE "DAD" GAMER EVER MADE.