@@inali_illustrates9142 I find it bizarre and weird behavior to want to be this person your not. For example there is a band called Dark Star Orchestra, a Grateful Dead cover band. The lead singer is so obsessed that he literally looks just like bob weir,acts like him, talks like him, it friggin weird. But do what makes you happy
@@wisdomleader85 lol because this guy encompassas so much Einstein, that he's pretty much boasting about himself, because he's now Einstein. I'm glad I got it. 😌
@@frogandspanner No it’s not surprising, I was just letting everyone know even though he died at the dawn of relativity he still made a huge contribution to it
Wow, this video went from a very insightful, funny short story about one of the worlds most renowned geniuses, to a very heartfelt beautiful message to everybody about life.
I'm surprised he walks around like this. That hairstyle is to a theoretical physicist what a striped Breton shirt and beret is to a French painter: Almost grotesquely caricatural.
What a poweful last line. In one sentence he both says "be the change you want to see" and "your life is valuable even if you don't realize it." Absolute legend.
hahahahaha! That's the best goblin of the day!!! My favorite Einstein citation is "Don't believe every meme on the internet" but "Hawk tua" is a close second!
My life is valueless, not valuable. I could disappear tomorrow and nobody would know until the bank comes to check the property for abandonment. I know nobody. Nobody knows me. I have no friends, family, nor even acquaintances. I do not even have workers on my shift. I can promise you. Not all of us have a valuable life. It is not even very valuable to me.
@@indridcold8433 Value isn't intrinsic. If you don't value yourself no one will. Take some time to appreciate how many good things you do in just one day. Even if nobody notices you, notice yourself.
The two were very good friends, contrary to the premise which is inaccurate. It was Minkowski that made Einstein aware of the existence of Ricci calculus ( essential for the formulation of GR)
That’s honestly a good way to think of dying. When it’s my time it would be nice to have the mindset of “oh all the things I won’t get to experience” knowing that there is some good things for the people I’m leaving behind to experience
Two so human giants in XX Century science.Their love for discovery and proof of the truth of theories and science has not been invalidated by their reciprocal, slightly uncomfortable relationship. So much to be learned thanks to this small anecdote in history of science...
YEP , WE TURN IT AROUND ,UPSIDE UP , UPSIDE DOWN FORWARDS , BACKWARDS AND IT ALL COMES BACK THE SAME , YEP . A CATCH 22 . THE THEORY OF RELATIVITY .. YET TO UNDERSTAND THE CATCH 22 THERE MUST BE A CHALK BOARD OF NUMBERS AND LETTERS AND SIGNS TO ACTUALLY SEE IT AT WORK . .. OH YES CALCULUS .. ...U.S.MARINE... THANK GOD MY MAKER AND CREATOR FOR MY HEALTH IN JESUS NAME MY SAVIOR THE SON OF GOD MY MAKER AND CREATOR , AMEN
Um. That was a pretty ferocious comment, as far as comments go! Wow. I come across such lofty comments only rarely. Please share with me, your highest education level? I'm a logophile and you've totally intrigued me. Be well.
@@Chr15T I heard he was an abuser. And used her wife ideas. Abusers are usually nice with everybody except the victims. I think that it's very possible. I'm not affirming that. I love science and his work. That's why I try to be objective.
It’s important to talk about both his achievements and his flaws. History is filled with good and bad people. I hate how the advancement of our race comes at a cost sometimes. Like oh look this guy created special relativity but he was a poor family man.
@@Sebastianator01 But to personify someone as only good or only bad - is a trait of personality disorder, a breeding ground for sociopathy. Honesty about ourselves is the only way to pursue a healthy society. I don’t mean we have to slander, or expose, or “cancel“ people. The reason it’s important for us to know about Einstein’s first family is that society has idealized him and idolized his intellect. He was multi faceted, just like all of us. Truth is, everyone has a sordid story or two - even the smartest, the most beautiful, or rich, or athletic among us. We don’t need to judge Einstein. We need to judge humanity.
i don't think she had anymore endurance than others - she just had to make it - or go under - in her later years - her oldest son might have helped - (the second son was institutionalized for schizophrenia)
How dare you assume their gender. Do you know how hard their lives must be with people like you blatantly assuming that they are a he? Take a look in the mirror and reflect on your actions. Equality is more important than anything else in the world, your behavior is disgusting.
Einstein, nice? not nice to his parents, to his wife, to his children, to his teachers, to his uni friends. He grew up and learned to control himself with the world war, but he was not a nice person. Yet a genius that loved physics so much.
@@ShaktiFlowww false, he was a genius actually, yes he used a lot of others' works but that's normal and legit, take any scientific paper, you'll see minimum 10 other articles that are used. Plus he actually worked himself on the maths behind the general theory of relativity. In his papers he correctly credited the works of others, except his wife, that helped him a lot and ended up not mentioning her, the beginning of the downfall.
@@oranaro9000would you say the correct way to teach students information about controversial figures is to explain what they contributed to first, then explain the controversial side of that figure?
Prof Avi is still amazing in story telling. I fondly remember the amazing stories he narrated in our class of "The philosophy of Science" at the Weizman Institute of Science. Kudos!
@@babua03 I was so baffled to see him here for a second as I also attended his lectures there! He’s such an incredible teacher and storyteller indeed. Can keep you listening for hours without even moving away from his chair!
I thought his surename sounded Polish, and after a bit of research I found out that he was born in modern-day Lithuania (Which still had close cultural ties to Poland at the time), before his family had to escape Russian opression to Germany due to being jewish. Pretty interresting.
Next time your hear someone say "but what has medicine and science done for us", show him this video. A great mind died due to appendicitis. A normal surgery today, was life treating back then!
I have never heard anyone say "but what has medicine and science done for us" other than you and nature centred anarchists who think we should be dying from treatable conditions like appendicitis.
How dare you assume their gender. Do you know how hard their lives must be with people like you blatantly assuming that they are a he? Take a look in the mirror and reflect on your actions. Equality is more important than anything else in the world, your behavior is disgusting.
Aww I really loved those final words. There is always a new dawn. It’s true, no matter when we die, there will be SO much we miss in terms of great developments. The world keeps moving forward
That is such a heartwarming story of our broken nature, humanity filled with brokenness, mistakes, pride, arrogance and regret. Truly heartwarming and filled with the hope that together we may be able to be trusted one day with more secrets and their power that they contain. Thankyou
@@Robe-x3z yes!! We all have good snd bad traits in us!!! The same person is intelligent in some ways and stupid in other ways!!! Wise and foolish both in the same person!!! Brave and a coward too!!! In different ways!! And at different times!!! Cruel in some ways! Kind in other ways!!!! And so forth!
@@richardfadle5921 Quite true Richard, I consider it the hieght of arrogance to think that any of us consider could consider ourselves more "anything" in essence than another human considering hoiw little we truely know about our universe. Obviously there are vast differances and changes we can effect within our selves that we can make and work on. I like the old quote, "don't compare yourself with others but rather with who we were yesterday"
Beyond the side of this that reminds us about the complications of hatred, there is another side to this which reminds us that even many of the greats in mathmatics and physics for better or worse had their own struggles with their teacher in such fields
Projecting an image of nice serves political reasons. Such innocent lies hide hidden collaborations. I don't believe in the inanity between Minkowsky and Einstein.
No, he wasn't. But back in those days, people had some sense of responsibility, so he did give her his Nobel prize money. Not remarkable then, but I can't picture it today.
Teacher katherine❤❤ Thank you very much. You are very capable of teach us about RPaccents with passionable small talks and funny faces. Respect for you. You deserve it❤❤❤ always be happy!!
@@AngerTroll In the later years of their marriage, Einstein almost treated his first wife like a servant. He openly cheated on her with his cousin and eventually left her for his affair. Aftwerwards, he still continued cheating on his cousin. Not very two-sided lol
@@MissyGail4eva I didn’t want to be the first to say it, but if there’s any truth to his biography I think you’re right. I think he and Mileva made a great couple, plus she was smart and helped Albert. I don’t know about his cousin Elsa who he ended up with, but to each his own I guess.
@@Jack93885 So what makes a person a bad person to you? Because to me, mistreating vulnerable people while being nice to everyone else is not what a good person is.
@@DwynTwo people are complex. When I say "great person" I mean it in the sense that you get great people in Sid Meier's Civilization. A great person is someone who pushes society forward, who leads a righteous path. Gandhi or Marcus Aurelius are good examples of this kind of person who, while pushing forward the existence of humanity as a whole, fail to similarly improve the lives of those they personally interact with.
He did accept Minowski space though and used it himself in General relativity, which uses an assumption that when expressed mathematically says that space can always be locally (but not globally) be described like Minkowski space.
Who actually cares, Einstein was autistic. He also had an IQ where he could think of things that have nothing to do with the concept of a self at all. If he sees the insignificance of himself, why on earth would he see something of significance in another person? He was socially stunted because of a disability, but was also gifted an ability because of that same deficit. You may not look at the world the same way he does, and either way, the universe does not care about your senses. To be clear the universe doesn't care about what you think or your feelings. That's like saying JFK was a bad person because he was a pervert. You're just sensitive.
I'm always a little confused by the thumbnail sketches but then you fill it out so coherently, you have great vision for your art! These guys seem like they are having a chill day!
I'm with Einstein. I hated my Geometry teacher, too. She could turn the simplest of teachings into a confusing mess. I basically learned Geometry from the guy who sat beside me in class as he explained it on a level I could understand. Good times. 😂
I enjoyed my middle school geometry class. Kind of my first introduction to mathematical proof. (Well, I had seen/done the “obtain the quadratic formula by completing the square” the previous year in pre-algebra, but that lacked the “here is a formalized* concept of a proof” aspect to it.)
Good on ya mate. We really ought to encourage the youth. My freshman algebra teacher, Limbaco, pointed his .38 Cal. revolver at me … it was for me telling my dad, an attorney for Encyclopedia Britannica , that he ought to buy a set from Limbaco so I don’t have to study so hard. Thereafter I refused to go back to class. Incidentally a Following year I got slapped hard across the face by Macayan, a Jesuit priest algebra teacher. Great golfer too. It was coz he wanted to “catch the attention of the class”. Thereafter I got A despite refusing to attend class. Priest eventually died, I had absolutely nothing to do with it.😂
@@joaquinmisajr.1215 lol my 3rd grade teacher used to slap his ruler on our desk for sleeping in class and once broke the chalkboard to get our attention. And that was as recent as the 1990s but he was old school 😂
@PaulHosey indeed, in grammar school I finished a test first. My principal, who was teaching that day, announced to the entire class that, "the first done is the worst done." Why? Because it rhymes? I, too, received an A.
I think matter is a structure of energy and structure can be destroy, so I think matter can be destroyed. The only cannot be destroyed should be energy
its never a pity to die but rather waste the gift of life without pushing yourself as far as you can with the few moments we have! live a full and rewarding life and your death will not be in vain!
Just the reverse. I know, it sounds a bit crazy, but it's a difference between "to die" and "sacrifice your body, so others can live". And there is more.
Thoughts it was more like if something cool is happening when you are about to die, that’s good because it means we as a species are still learning and improving. If you’re on your deathbed and you think you won’t be missing anything new, then you know we as a species has stagnated which is horrible.
@@twilit the scientific experiment I base my comment on is the double slit experiment in quantum mechanics 👍 it illustrates and has done consistently for over 100 years that light , which everything is made of travels as a wave when it is not being observed , once a conscious observer is introduced then it behave as a particle , this means that the conscious observer collapses the wave function of potential into a particle of actuality or 3d experience! . Is this science enough for you ?
Not everything is made of light (Dark Matter?) and the double slit experiment doesn't say anything about the nature of consciousness. Just as Schrodinger's cat thought experiment doesn't say anything about life.
there is no evidence that she contributed to ANYTHING in his theory. Only that she worked with him. Also, he wasn't very nice to his son either who was schizophrenic
Given a task, Computers run by translating high-level algorithmic logic for solving the task --> program logic --> set of instructions and so on .. The algorithm is the "intelligence" and is consequently hard to get right for tasks of appreciable complexity. Machine learning methods attempt to discover the algorithm for a given task, from demonstrations under the assumption that there are consistent and "mostly" complete solution algorithms (always helps to provide additional information about the task - e.g., valid moves, goal configurations etc.) -- The oddity here is that discovering morality, doesnt seem to satisfy the above assumption.
Oh, so that’s where the Minkowski diagrams come from!😮They were part of a special relativity module I did in Applied Maths, including Ricci Tensors. I really enjoyed that module.Great info.
Because you are smart enough to be humbled by how little you really know. Most of life is mystery. Accepting this makes you appreciate it for what it is instead of trying to define and control it like a philosopher. It makes you appreciate it like a human who can explore, now with less ego in the way.
The speaker is Avshalom Elitzer, an Iranian Jew, who grew up in Israel. Elitzer is a physicist, philosopher, and published author. Dr Elitzer would not have personally known Einstein, however, since he was born 2 years after Einstein’s passing.
It's clear Hermann Minkowski had Polish roots, as 'Minkowski' with the ending of 'ski' is a typical ethnic, Polish name, and he was born on the territory of the former Polish-Lithuanian Empire that was simply divided and occupied by Russia, Austria, and Germany at the time of his birth. But the writing and spelling of the name leave no doubts - it's an ethnic Polish surname.
@@numbersix8919 My question was more addressed to Naticzka, which didn't become clear (my bad!). Your remark is more relevant to the topic of math / science. I'm not trying to diminish the contributions of Polish people to the field, it just feels irrelevant as a comment to this particular video. Maybe it's also because I've never understood this concept of national pride. If one of my compatriots achieved something great, how is this something that I can be proud of?
The best part is, there was a big delay between special and general relativity. This is rumored to be because Einstein couldn’t get the hang of using tensor calculus. And a big part of tensor calculus is using the Minkowski matrix. I apologize if this is an oversimplification or if my facts are wrong, but I distinctly remember learning about the Minkowski matrix when taking Quantum Mechanics in my undergrad.
This isn't a mistake. Science discovers new phenomena and invents theories and mathematical models to describe those phenomena and predict their behavior.
I agree with the response. Physics is about setting up mathematical models to describe reality, it's not reality itself. Copernicus' model describes reality well within some precision, but Kepler's model describes it better. Newton's theory describes it even better and we continue to use it in our everyday life. Einstein's theory is more precise, but that doesn't mean that it can explain everything.
@@trex2621 Einstein didn't discover the principle of relativity, Galileo did. Centuries later Lorenz invented the mathematics to describe relativity in his work on Maxwell's equations, Poincaré expanded on Lorenz' work and Einstein completed it and formalized it into a single theory that unified his predecessors' work (and did away with the luminiferous aether for good).
Ya sure guys, the invention of ideas through math/logic? Your giving yourself too much credit, there in lies pride, "we invented logic" It's like finding a path that's already winding through the forest, if you ever veer to the right or left your lost. Discovered is the correct term
Minkowski made this great contribution to the theory! The famous geometric interpretation of the Special Relativity Theory. Similarly, other geniuses contribute a lot to the General Relativity Theory, which is much more complex than the former one.
Almost. Einstein says that earth's mass is sucking space towards its center and the apple is floating in a region of space that's being sucked towards the center of the earth. The earth's surface is in the same region of space as the apple is, so the earth's surface must be moving through that region of space away from its center with the same speed as the regionis being sucked towards the center because the surface would fall towards the center just like the apple otherwise. Because you're standing on the earth's surface, you're moving too. That's why the apple is weightless while you feel the earth's surface pressing against your feet: the apple is just floating in space while you're being accelerated through space.
He was also emotionally abusive to his wife, not saying he wasn't a brilliant mind but it should definitely be acknowledged that he was nowhere near perfect.
I am sorry that's just an opinion of a platonist. In general, you discover a phenomenon and you invent a theory. I guess that's how it works. But I personally prefer to say he discovered relativity because I am a platonist who believes that everything that is reachable by the human brain already exists in a platonistic world.
I feel as though the teacher was giving Einstein a compliment on the way out. Almost as if to say his efforts were “tough love” to push Einstein to greatness. 🙏🙏🕊️✨
What a strange story and thing to say. Everything about this conversation was strange. First of all, Einstein didn’t invent the relativity, he explained it. He proved his teacher wrong and his teacher was proud of his student enough to state such words before dying. He literally said “pity to die now that my students work came to fruition”. And Einstein must have had a grin on his face when he read it, knowing what his teacher called him. Everyone at that seminar needs to go out and interact more. Live a bit.
Yeah the narrative is inaccurate. However in what way did Einstein proved his teacher wrong? He actually was lazy towards things he was not interested in :-). Anyway I would say, personally, neither invented nor discovered. I would use “Einstein formulated special relativity” ( of course giving Lorentz and Poincaré proper credit). The notion of “space-time” was formulated by St Augustine!!!!
Einstein didn't prove his teacher wrong - Minkowski's Spacetime viewpoint would soon be accepted & exploited by Einstein in the development of his General Theory of Relativity - Minkowski won that one
People keep calling out that Einstein treated his first wife badly. Wow, its almost like Einstein was a person that had flaws and not a perfect being of existence, and its possible to praise his scientific work while not liking his choices in his personal life.
When I hear about atomic clocks. No one mentions how if you go faster it takes longer for light to keep up with you at any speed. So time dilation seems to be false
I love the way Einstein thought and I thank him for mass times the speed of light squared. That E= MC squared . sure made it easy to figure out how the solar system worked...... Death is a dream that needs to be earned and I mean to the Urn. 🎶
to everyone saying "hiS wiFe iS tHe reAl geniUs": Yes, his wife was a smart person and yes she contributed to his work but it was just a contribution. Many people wants to believe the idea of "old white man bad, woman doesnt get credited" kinda bs. Also imagine 40s and 50s, one generation before that women was not considered adult humans in most of the world. How can you NOT expect sexism against women?
Relativity is bunk science, just like gravity. You can slow down time with isochronic tones because it makes your thought processing more efficient. The more efficient the processing, the slower time becomes. Having absolutely nothing to do with relative motion.
I like the way he says "may you all make the future brighter for all" As well as "You a matter to someone" Clever m8 Good luck to Anyone reading And May you all find peace in your domain
Respeto cada persona y a su dedicación , hablando de geometría . Albert estaba basado a un Reyno , hoy veo que les dan un valor a una matemática que te desleal y falta de respeto , a su fundadores
So lucky people were to live with Albert Einstein, he made fridge everywhere on world, any vehicle motor similar to petrol electric generators is made on Albert Einstein knowledge, very smart he was.
I don't think many actually learned the most important things Einstein and Sagan tried to teach the world. Had over two decades experience with people idolizing their work and nearly lost my passion for science twice. I guess it is merely a tempering process, science for the sake of science alone. Still, wish more people felt that.
guy studied einstein for so long he became him
🤣😂
@@asap5629 imitation is the sincerest form of flattery
@@inali_illustrates9142 Me training my children to be just like me and breed more clones
@@inali_illustrates9142 I find it bizarre and weird behavior to want to be this person your not. For example there is a band called Dark Star Orchestra, a Grateful Dead cover band. The lead singer is so obsessed that he literally looks just like bob weir,acts like him, talks like him, it friggin weird. But do what makes you happy
@@TheMenaceHimself2006 Me and you, breeding time
Why is Einstein talking in third person?
Definitely a big ego😢
😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂
Albi was a Rockstar. Even the hair is iconic 😄
The royal we of the chosen ones
“Einstein Was a Nice Guy” - Einstein 2024
Man I'm telling you, self-boasting isn't good
@@Ike878 boasting is when no iphone
I see that some folks didn't get the joke.
not just people didn't got the joke, but yt deleted my previous reply as well
@@RohitChOfficial Einstein was nice but self boasting isn't...
@@wisdomleader85 lol because this guy encompassas so much Einstein, that he's pretty much boasting about himself, because he's now Einstein. I'm glad I got it. 😌
a mathematician managed to make things incomprehensible" one of my favorite quotes form Einstein
what is funny because Minkowski diagrams makes relativity a lot easier to visualize. specially when you apply lorentz transformation.
Bro the quote is literally spoken and written on screen in the video you just watched and you still got it wrong an Einstein you are definitely not
@@TwoStacks217 douche
@@TwoStacks217 it was a simple typo bud chill
My algebra 2 teacher Mrs Ashby 😒 I could not understand anything she would put on the board omg
The great thing though is that when you learn special relativity and look at spacetime diagrams it’s called Minkowski geometry
Is it surprising to you that the geometry developed by Minkowski is called Minkowski geometry?
@@frogandspanner No it’s not surprising, I was just letting everyone know even though he died at the dawn of relativity he still made a huge contribution to it
@@Utopian1234 When teaching SR I find Minkowski's approach helps many students, and blends well into GR.
@@frogandspanner…he didn’t use the word surprising or any word remotely like surprising.
Wasn't Einstein a bit neglectful of his first wife and son? When he married his cousin didn't he also have affairs? Maybe he was nice about it?
Wow, this video went from a very insightful, funny short story about one of the worlds most renowned geniuses, to a very heartfelt beautiful message to everybody about life.
He really went all out on the Einstein costume
@@chatgptoracle 😂
He went so far that he's even a theoretical physics'genius
Its called being Jewish
ja deshalb ist res ja bloss alles angabe, war er dabei? ich glaube nicht aber er tut so um sich mit fremden loorbeeren zu schmücken.
I'm surprised he walks around like this. That hairstyle is to a theoretical physicist what a striped Breton shirt and beret is to a French painter: Almost grotesquely caricatural.
Case you are wondering, the speaker's name is Avshalom Elitzur
Thank you! 👍
Thank you
The name fits the accent. 😅💙🤍
Gratitude 😊
The spelling is wrong. The speaker’s name is Albert Einstein. There, fixed it for you. 😉
What a poweful last line. In one sentence he both says "be the change you want to see" and "your life is valuable even if you don't realize it."
Absolute legend.
Amen!.
hahahahaha! That's the best goblin of the day!!! My favorite Einstein citation is "Don't believe every meme on the internet" but "Hawk tua" is a close second!
My life is valueless, not valuable. I could disappear tomorrow and nobody would know until the bank comes to check the property for abandonment. I know nobody. Nobody knows me. I have no friends, family, nor even acquaintances. I do not even have workers on my shift. I can promise you. Not all of us have a valuable life. It is not even very valuable to me.
@@indridcold8433 Value isn't intrinsic. If you don't value yourself no one will. Take some time to appreciate how many good things you do in just one day. Even if nobody notices you, notice yourself.
Said the man who cheated on his wife twice
The two were very good friends, contrary to the premise which is inaccurate. It was Minkowski that made Einstein aware of the existence of Ricci calculus ( essential for the formulation of GR)
@@mbc4240 Could you provide a source on how that is based on minkowski's work? The link between special relativity and minkowski space is clear to me
I thought it was Marcel Grossmann.
@@mbc4240 I also thought that the 2 were friends.
All real friends were at some point a nemesis
@@haugtussa8989 that's not even true.
He really "absorbed" Einstein; the looks, the hair, the voice, the talk.
I knew this happened to people and their dogs but this one??!
And the knowledge i assume 😂
@@imdhepchannel7153 Einstein was German. This guy is Israeli, similar accent, but different
@@billiegoat4240Einstein was a German Jew, and he was even asked to be Israel’s 2nd president in the 50’s.
That’s honestly a good way to think of dying. When it’s my time it would be nice to have the mindset of “oh all the things I won’t get to experience” knowing that there is some good things for the people I’m leaving behind to experience
@@Goremejy don't worry you are the experience there is no death.
The concluding words are wonderful to hear, especially for someone who once struggled with life and even considered ending it prematurly.✌️💚
BUT WHY ,?
U.S.MARINE .
@@VINCENT-sr4oz why what?
💓
Always struggling with this. I'm so glad that you wrote that moment of your life in past tense
@@VentiWhoreshipper one day you will be able to talk about it in past tense too!✌️💚
Two so human giants in XX Century science.Their love for discovery and proof of the truth of theories and science has not been invalidated by their reciprocal, slightly uncomfortable relationship. So much to be learned thanks to this small anecdote in history of science...
YEP , WE TURN IT AROUND ,UPSIDE UP , UPSIDE DOWN FORWARDS , BACKWARDS AND IT ALL COMES BACK THE SAME ,
YEP . A CATCH 22 .
THE THEORY OF RELATIVITY ..
YET TO UNDERSTAND THE CATCH 22 THERE MUST BE A CHALK BOARD OF
NUMBERS AND LETTERS AND SIGNS TO ACTUALLY SEE IT AT WORK .
.. OH YES CALCULUS ..
...U.S.MARINE...
THANK GOD MY MAKER AND CREATOR FOR MY HEALTH IN JESUS NAME MY SAVIOR THE SON OF GOD MY MAKER AND CREATOR , AMEN
Um.
That was a pretty ferocious comment, as far as comments go! Wow. I come across such lofty comments only rarely.
Please share with me, your highest education level?
I'm a logophile and you've totally intrigued me.
Be well.
@@Echo_1174 🤣🤣🤣
@@QueenAlfred 🙄
@@Echo_1174 I know, right? Like...whaaat??🤨😑
having read several biographies of einstein, i am convinced he was not a nice guy.
@@Chr15T I heard he was an abuser. And used her wife ideas. Abusers are usually nice with everybody except the victims.
I think that it's very possible.
I'm not affirming that.
I love science and his work. That's why I try to be objective.
@@aliciahurtado5496 no, that is conjecture. sure he not nice with wife but that all conjecture
…and his first wife…and his children. Nobody wants to talk about those.
It's literally 90% of the comments lmao
It’s important to talk about both his achievements and his flaws. History is filled with good and bad people. I hate how the advancement of our race comes at a cost sometimes. Like oh look this guy created special relativity but he was a poor family man.
@@Sebastianator01 But to personify someone as only good or only bad - is a trait of personality disorder, a breeding ground for sociopathy. Honesty about ourselves is the only way to pursue a healthy society. I don’t mean we have to slander, or expose, or “cancel“ people. The reason it’s important for us to know about Einstein’s first family is that society has idealized him and idolized his intellect. He was multi faceted, just like all of us. Truth is, everyone has a sordid story or two - even the smartest, the most beautiful, or rich, or athletic among us. We don’t need to judge Einstein. We need to judge humanity.
@@meleshenko3767 the first part of your comment was reasonable. The last part however made you sound like the very sociopath you described.
@bleacher333 No it doesn't, at all.
Einstein also treated his wife badly. That lady had some kind of iron endurance.
i don't think she had anymore endurance than others - she just had to make it - or go under - in her later years - her oldest son might have helped - (the second son was institutionalized for schizophrenia)
@@MakerBoyOldBoy She could have left him any time she wanted.
@@spaceghost8995 Ideally, she could have. Unfortunately, it's not that simple, and the cultural context often makes it more difficult.
@@spaceghost8995 it’s not that simple, especially back then
@@ZxZNebula It has been said that in past eras the few choices for single women included becoming teachers or prostitutes.
I like how this guy kinda looks like Einstein himself, and he also sort of has a german accent
It's an Israeli accent
How dare you assume their gender. Do you know how hard their lives must be with people like you blatantly assuming that they are a he?
Take a look in the mirror and reflect on your actions. Equality is more important than anything else in the world, your behavior is disgusting.
He has a Hebrew accent
Einstein, nice? not nice to his parents, to his wife, to his children, to his teachers, to his uni friends. He grew up and learned to control himself with the world war, but he was not a nice person. Yet a genius that loved physics so much.
SOUNDS LIKE HE HAD SOME NEURODIVERGENT HANDICAPS
I’ve heard he wasn’t even the genius ppl say he was, that he was incorrectly credited with the work of others
@@ShaktiFlowww false, he was a genius actually, yes he used a lot of others' works but that's normal and legit, take any scientific paper, you'll see minimum 10 other articles that are used. Plus he actually worked himself on the maths behind the general theory of relativity. In his papers he correctly credited the works of others, except his wife, that helped him a lot and ended up not mentioning her, the beginning of the downfall.
@@ShaktiFlowww science is all about inheritance
@@oranaro9000would you say the correct way to teach students information about controversial figures is to explain what they contributed to first, then explain the controversial side of that figure?
Prof Avi is still amazing in story telling. I fondly remember the amazing stories he narrated in our class of "The philosophy of Science" at the Weizman Institute of Science. Kudos!
@@babua03 I was so baffled to see him here for a second as I also attended his lectures there! He’s such an incredible teacher and storyteller indeed. Can keep you listening for hours without even moving away from his chair!
I thought his surename sounded Polish, and after a bit of research I found out that he was born in modern-day Lithuania (Which still had close cultural ties to Poland at the time), before his family had to escape Russian opression to Germany due to being jewish. Pretty interresting.
Who?
Next time your hear someone say "but what has medicine and science done for us", show him this video. A great mind died due to appendicitis.
A normal surgery today, was life treating back then!
But nobody says that...
Yeah and pretty sure appendicitis is still dangerous
I have never heard anyone say "but what has medicine and science done for us" other than you and nature centred anarchists who think we should be dying from treatable conditions like appendicitis.
@noahway13 Unfortunately science denial is on the rise and respect for modern advancements seems to be dropping.
I think they had appendix removal back then too? What are you trying to say?
I feel like this guy can participate in an Einstein lookalike contest and get the third place.
@@johancakep So specific I love it 😂
Charlie Chaplain Reference?
Probably
How dare you assume their gender. Do you know how hard their lives must be with people like you blatantly assuming that they are a he?
Take a look in the mirror and reflect on your actions. Equality is more important than anything else in the world, your behavior is disgusting.
@@TimTheTierLister or that Einstein and his butler would be 1st and 2nd
Aww I really loved those final words. There is always a new dawn. It’s true, no matter when we die, there will be SO much we miss in terms of great developments. The world keeps moving forward
That is such a heartwarming story of our broken nature, humanity filled with brokenness, mistakes, pride, arrogance and regret.
Truly heartwarming and filled with the hope that together we may be able to be trusted one day with more secrets and their power that they contain.
Thankyou
@@Robe-x3z using ChatGPT to construct your comments? 😛
@@Robe-x3z ❤
@@Robe-x3z yes!! We all have good snd bad traits in us!!! The same person is intelligent in some ways and stupid in other ways!!! Wise and foolish both in the same person!!! Brave and a coward too!!! In different ways!! And at different times!!! Cruel in some ways! Kind in other ways!!!! And so forth!
@@richardfadle5921 Quite true Richard, I consider it the hieght of arrogance to think that any of us consider could consider ourselves more "anything" in essence than another human considering hoiw little we truely know about our universe. Obviously there are vast differances and changes we can effect within our selves that we can make and work on. I like the old quote, "don't compare yourself with others but rather with who we were yesterday"
@@Robe-x3z it's a redemption arch for the teacher
Beyond the side of this that reminds us about the complications of hatred, there is another side to this which reminds us that even many of the greats in mathmatics and physics for better or worse had their own struggles with their teacher in such fields
That was NOT the conclusion I expected from this- BEAUTIFUL.
Einstein was really, really, nice to his first cousin.
@@indridcold8433 wow what a good guy...
@@indridcold8433 oh no…
😂😂
NOOOOOOO
Oh who cares?
Unfortunately, he was not nice to his first wife at all...
Projecting an image of nice serves political reasons. Such innocent lies hide hidden collaborations. I don't believe in the inanity between Minkowsky and Einstein.
No, he wasn't. But back in those days, people had some sense of responsibility, so he did give her his Nobel prize money.
Not remarkable then, but I can't picture it today.
@@l.w.paradis2108you are so funny. I love what you said about not picturing it today.
peace and love,
yishmirai
😇🙏🏿💫
it takes two hands to clap
@@l.w.paradis2108another Non Nice is that the laws of nature/physics does Not care about humans welfare.
The Limitations of Materialism.
Teacher katherine❤❤ Thank you very much. You are very capable of teach us about RPaccents with passionable small talks and funny faces. Respect for you. You deserve it❤❤❤ always be happy!!
Einstein wasn't that nice to his wife, either.
I have a neighbor a few houses down who doesn't seem to be either... I'd personally rather have him be Einstein
Always two sides to that story especially with women
I mean it was also his cousin so…
@@AngerTroll In the later years of their marriage, Einstein almost treated his first wife like a servant. He openly cheated on her with his cousin and eventually left her for his affair. Aftwerwards, he still continued cheating on his cousin. Not very two-sided lol
@@MissyGail4eva I didn’t want to be the first to say it, but if there’s any truth to his biography I think you’re right. I think he and Mileva made a great couple, plus she was smart and helped Albert. I don’t know about his cousin Elsa who he ended up with, but to each his own I guess.
Einstein also abandoned his autistic daughter. Great father and person.
@@vallee7966 really??
Obviously you are being sarcastic but one can be a great person while being a terrible parent or spouse. Many great leaders were such people.
Not a great husband either, if I remember.
@@Jack93885 So what makes a person a bad person to you? Because to me, mistreating vulnerable people while being nice to everyone else is not what a good person is.
@@DwynTwo people are complex. When I say "great person" I mean it in the sense that you get great people in Sid Meier's Civilization.
A great person is someone who pushes society forward, who leads a righteous path. Gandhi or Marcus Aurelius are good examples of this kind of person who, while pushing forward the existence of humanity as a whole, fail to similarly improve the lives of those they personally interact with.
He did accept Minowski space though and used it himself in General relativity, which uses an assumption that when expressed mathematically says that space can always be locally (but not globally) be described like Minkowski space.
the qualities of Eisntein :
3rd intelligence
2nd lazyness
1st imagination
@@dwarinsarcilliann3246 Imagination Amen 💙
0 restraint from stealing patents
3rd Copying
2nd Synthesizing
1st Jewry
Fact 💯
0th getting women
He also hated his first wife, the one who sacrificed her own career to follow and care for him. 🤬🤮
Who actually cares, Einstein was autistic. He also had an IQ where he could think of things that have nothing to do with the concept of a self at all. If he sees the insignificance of himself, why on earth would he see something of significance in another person?
He was socially stunted because of a disability, but was also gifted an ability because of that same deficit. You may not look at the world the same way he does, and either way, the universe does not care about your senses. To be clear the universe doesn't care about what you think or your feelings.
That's like saying JFK was a bad person because he was a pervert. You're just sensitive.
he didn't treat Meliva well - tho it might not be from hate - as much as it was from self-centeredness
@@nilsanieves3457 and then he chose his cousin over her 💀
@@waspsandwich6548jews
@sinnombre5466 nah that was uncalled for 💀
He was the perfect teacher. Pretending not to believe in him, helped him to work hard to achieve his goals
I'm always a little confused by the thumbnail sketches but then you fill it out so coherently, you have great vision for your art! These guys seem like they are having a chill day!
I'm with Einstein. I hated my Geometry teacher, too. She could turn the simplest of teachings into a confusing mess. I basically learned Geometry from the guy who sat beside me in class as he explained it on a level I could understand. Good times. 😂
@@Strudle_Baker tbh geometry was just easy and boring. I took high school level geometry when I was 13.
I enjoyed my middle school geometry class. Kind of my first introduction to mathematical proof.
(Well, I had seen/done the “obtain the quadratic formula by completing the square” the previous year in pre-algebra, but that lacked the “here is a formalized* concept of a proof” aspect to it.)
They aren't talking about the geometry you do in school 💀
@@docd00bier bad curriculum ig, the highschool geometry taught in USA is taught in middle school in asia
@@docd00bier That's exactly what the guy who helped me said "boring and easy" Lol! Guess it's just hardwired in guys to do geometry 😏
Totally wasn't expecting the wholesome ending
My physics teacher accused me of being lazy and not trying when I finished a test too quickly. The next day I received an A+
congrats
Good on ya mate. We really ought to encourage the youth.
My freshman algebra teacher, Limbaco, pointed his .38 Cal. revolver at me … it was for me telling my dad, an attorney for Encyclopedia Britannica , that he ought to buy a set from Limbaco so I don’t have to study so hard.
Thereafter I refused to go back to class.
Incidentally a
Following year I got slapped hard across the face by Macayan, a Jesuit priest algebra teacher. Great golfer too.
It was coz he wanted to “catch the attention of the class”. Thereafter I got A despite refusing to attend class.
Priest eventually died, I had absolutely nothing to do with it.😂
@@joaquinmisajr.1215 lol my 3rd grade teacher used to slap his ruler on our desk for sleeping in class and once broke the chalkboard to get our attention. And that was as recent as the 1990s but he was old school 😂
Grades don't define anybody
@PaulHosey indeed, in grammar school I finished a test first. My principal, who was teaching that day, announced to the entire class that, "the first done is the worst done." Why? Because it rhymes? I, too, received an A.
Such a poetic ending, even if a little too German 🇩🇪
Thank you for sharing this with us. ❤
Matter or energy cannot be destroyed
@@matthewjohnson1092 only transformed
I think matter is a structure of energy and structure can be destroy, so I think matter can be destroyed. The only cannot be destroyed should be energy
That we know of
@@sfh7132 it can be
@@sfh7132 Conservation of mass:
Moral of the story: Don't embarrass your students.
its never a pity to die but rather waste the gift of life without pushing yourself as far as you can with the few moments we have! live a full and rewarding life and your death will not be in vain!
Just the reverse. I know, it sounds a bit crazy, but it's a difference between "to die" and "sacrifice your body, so others can live". And there is more.
That ending though
@@shawnhimes3004 lol, omg yes.
I wasn’t sure how to say it, so I’m going with what you said..!
This is a fantastic clip.
Thank you for uploading
What a great quote at the end there. Perhaps another way of putting it: it's always good to leave the party a little early!
Not really, it's more like hopefully it's a pity for you to leave the party, as it means it was meaningful for you and others
@@josephbaron3049 what no
Thoughts it was more like if something cool is happening when you are about to die, that’s good because it means we as a species are still learning and improving. If you’re on your deathbed and you think you won’t be missing anything new, then you know we as a species has stagnated which is horrible.
Time and space are functions of ones conceptual scheme, consciousness is the fundamental reality
Consciousness operates at a sub-quantum state.
@@Magicalfluidprocess this is discussion of science not new age
@@twilit the scientific experiment I base my comment on is the double slit experiment in quantum mechanics 👍 it illustrates and has done consistently for over 100 years that light , which everything is made of travels as a wave when it is not being observed , once a conscious observer is introduced then it behave as a particle , this means that the conscious observer collapses the wave function of potential into a particle of actuality or 3d experience! . Is this science enough for you ?
Fundamentalists are not appreciated around here :)
Not everything is made of light (Dark Matter?) and the double slit experiment doesn't say anything about the nature of consciousness. Just as Schrodinger's cat thought experiment doesn't say anything about life.
Thank you for the kind words! I will try harder to live.
He wasnt nice to his wife. She worked with him on that theory
Source?
@@NicholasVictor-j1p True. He even states this in personal letters to her.
there is no evidence that she contributed to ANYTHING in his theory. Only that she worked with him. Also, he wasn't very nice to his son either who was schizophrenic
Well to be fair, how many husbands were I'm those times
@@ambatuBUHSURK ThT’s the point.
Given a task, Computers run by translating high-level algorithmic logic for solving the task --> program logic --> set of instructions and so on ..
The algorithm is the "intelligence" and is consequently hard to get right for tasks of appreciable complexity. Machine learning methods attempt to discover the algorithm for a given task, from demonstrations under the assumption that there are consistent and "mostly" complete solution algorithms (always helps to provide additional information about the task - e.g., valid moves, goal configurations etc.) -- The oddity here is that discovering morality, doesnt seem to satisfy the above assumption.
Oh, so that’s where the Minkowski diagrams come from!😮They were part of a special relativity module I did in Applied Maths, including Ricci Tensors.
I really enjoyed that module.Great info.
How does getting so smart makes people heart so bright?
@@drdzdd because they have finally understood what they have and how to appreciate it
Because you are smart enough to be humbled by how little you really know. Most of life is mystery. Accepting this makes you appreciate it for what it is instead of trying to define and control it like a philosopher. It makes you appreciate it like a human who can explore, now with less ego in the way.
Very well said
Wonderful and true
@@Jack-in-the-country
@@EatingMcDonald_burger Thanks :)
Clearly it didn't make everyone's heart so bright...
Death is only a pity when you believe it is permanent.
The speaker is Avshalom Elitzer, an Iranian Jew, who grew up in Israel. Elitzer is a physicist, philosopher, and published author.
Dr Elitzer would not have personally known Einstein, however, since he was born 2 years after Einstein’s passing.
It's clear Hermann Minkowski had Polish roots, as 'Minkowski' with the ending of 'ski' is a typical ethnic, Polish name, and he was born on the territory of the former Polish-Lithuanian Empire that was simply divided and occupied by Russia, Austria, and Germany at the time of his birth. But the writing and spelling of the name leave no doubts - it's an ethnic Polish surname.
Naprawdę!
Poland became the center for mathematical physics in that era.
How is this at all relevant?
@jensraab2902 It is if you're Polish! Seriously, Stanislaw Ulam's _Adventures of a Mathematician_ is a great historical document.
@@numbersix8919 My question was more addressed to Naticzka, which didn't become clear (my bad!).
Your remark is more relevant to the topic of math / science.
I'm not trying to diminish the contributions of Polish people to the field, it just feels irrelevant as a comment to this particular video.
Maybe it's also because I've never understood this concept of national pride. If one of my compatriots achieved something great, how is this something that I can be proud of?
Death in itself is pretty tragic. Don’t need to make it more tragic by adding relativity.
Where's the fun in that
However, religions proclaim there is an afterlife.
@@steveflorida5849 however they are wrong and nobody cares
Eternal life cannot be granted to sinners.
@@name5702 according to Jesus we are all sinners
Yeah he should work on that closing remark, that came out pretty macabre
Very weird
Such a profound quote.
Back in the day arguments were on wholesome topics showing a grear deal of intelligence nowadays hmmm it is something else out there
Yes zi like that kind of humor fr
The best part is, there was a big delay between special and general relativity. This is rumored to be because Einstein couldn’t get the hang of using tensor calculus. And a big part of tensor calculus is using the Minkowski matrix. I apologize if this is an oversimplification or if my facts are wrong, but I distinctly remember learning about the Minkowski matrix when taking Quantum Mechanics in my undergrad.
minkowski metric had been used in special relativity already, what he didn't get a hold of easily was Riemannian geometry
@@randomuser3960 ahh gotcha, guess I misremembered. Thanks for the correction!
he really thought if he shaved we wouldn't notice
He was really nice too his Elsa they were related before marriage also shares clothes.
Real men Respect all, and give unconditional Love.
Teacher learns from students. He should have said discovered not invented. We need to be careful with words.
This isn't a mistake. Science discovers new phenomena and invents theories and mathematical models to describe those phenomena and predict their behavior.
I agree with the response.
Physics is about setting up mathematical models to describe reality, it's not reality itself.
Copernicus' model describes reality well within some precision, but Kepler's model describes it better. Newton's theory describes it even better and we continue to use it in our everyday life. Einstein's theory is more precise, but that doesn't mean that it can explain everything.
@@JerehmiaBoaz I would say that he INVENTED theory of special relativity to describe his DISCOVERY of special relativity.
@@trex2621 Einstein didn't discover the principle of relativity, Galileo did. Centuries later Lorenz invented the mathematics to describe relativity in his work on Maxwell's equations, Poincaré expanded on Lorenz' work and Einstein completed it and formalized it into a single theory that unified his predecessors' work (and did away with the luminiferous aether for good).
Ya sure guys, the invention of ideas through math/logic?
Your giving yourself too much credit, there in lies pride, "we invented logic"
It's like finding a path that's already winding through the forest, if you ever veer to the right or left your lost. Discovered is the correct term
He wasnt nice to his wife either!
@@christinewilde110 Yeah we got now shut it.
@@aadilharoon1807?
@@aadilharoon1807??
Minkowski made this great contribution to the theory! The famous geometric interpretation of the Special Relativity Theory. Similarly, other geniuses contribute a lot to the General Relativity Theory, which is much more complex than the former one.
And Einsteins hairdo lives on.
Newton said the apple falls on your head. Einsten says you rise up to the apple as its also falling to your head. 😮
@@beethovenlovedmozart headbutting an apple? 🤔
Almost. Einstein says that earth's mass is sucking space towards its center and the apple is floating in a region of space that's being sucked towards the center of the earth. The earth's surface is in the same region of space as the apple is, so the earth's surface must be moving through that region of space away from its center with the same speed as the regionis being sucked towards the center because the surface would fall towards the center just like the apple otherwise. Because you're standing on the earth's surface, you're moving too. That's why the apple is weightless while you feel the earth's surface pressing against your feet: the apple is just floating in space while you're being accelerated through space.
This stuff is just too heady for me!!
❤ what a beautiful and inspiring story 🎉
He was also emotionally abusive to his wife, not saying he wasn't a brilliant mind but it should definitely be acknowledged that he was nowhere near perfect.
its our fault for putting people on a pedestal. it doesn't need to be acknowledged, people need to stop with their halo effect
@@ChamplooMusashi Exactly. Still remember the phrase “Never meet your heroes”.
That turned beautifully dark
“Shut up and make me a sandwich” - Einstein
Cringe
@@hypno5690 yep. He was quite cringy to his cousin/wife
Frozen star theory
@@BaalBuster Like you are with your brothers. 😂
Einstein didn't invent relativity he explained it, If there were no Einstein relativity would still exist.
@@YeahNahMaybe947 well he invented the Theory of General Relativity
I am sorry that's just an opinion of a platonist. In general, you discover a phenomenon and you invent a theory. I guess that's how it works. But I personally prefer to say he discovered relativity because I am a platonist who believes that everything that is reachable by the human brain already exists in a platonistic world.
@@sen7826 no, he discovered it.
@@ZlatnoPeroTV the theory was created to explain
I feel as though the teacher was giving Einstein a compliment on the way out.
Almost as if to say his efforts were “tough love” to push Einstein to greatness. 🙏🙏🕊️✨
What a strange story and thing to say. Everything about this conversation was strange. First of all, Einstein didn’t invent the relativity, he explained it. He proved his teacher wrong and his teacher was proud of his student enough to state such words before dying. He literally said “pity to die now that my students work came to fruition”. And Einstein must have had a grin on his face when he read it, knowing what his teacher called him. Everyone at that seminar needs to go out and interact more. Live a bit.
Yeah the narrative is inaccurate. However in what way did Einstein proved his teacher wrong? He actually was lazy towards things he was not interested in :-). Anyway I would say, personally, neither invented nor discovered. I would use “Einstein formulated special relativity” ( of course giving Lorentz and Poincaré proper credit). The notion of “space-time” was formulated by St Augustine!!!!
Einstein didn't prove his teacher wrong - Minkowski's Spacetime viewpoint would soon be accepted & exploited by Einstein in the development of his General Theory of Relativity - Minkowski won that one
People keep calling out that Einstein treated his first wife badly.
Wow, its almost like Einstein was a person that had flaws and not a perfect being of existence, and its possible to praise his scientific work while not liking his choices in his personal life.
@@BattyBest The point is he was not a nice human being, period.
@@nilsanieves3457 if hating your wife is "not nice" then the world in 1940 was "not nice"
@@vercot7000How can you compare a domestic issue to mass murder?You dill.
I read his contract he had with his wife. He was not nice to her but he was honest said he'd sleep with anyone he wanted to basically.
Einstein never invented relativity from zero...He depended on earlier works of Poincare....
Read Poincare's Science and Hypothesis
He stole his intellectual property rather
@@nathanielgates2863 Nice argument. try proving it
@@vercot7000 it's very well documented just do your own research
@@nathanielgates2863 If it's "very well documented" then you should have 0 trouble listing off your sources right now. We both know you made it up
Answer: His former teacher of Geometry, Herman Minkowski.
When I hear about atomic clocks. No one mentions how if you go faster it takes longer for light to keep up with you at any speed. So time dilation seems to be false
It's a theory it's not a fact of nature or the universe
Being a chosen tribe intellectual property thief at the patent office is real nice 😂
I love the way Einstein thought and I thank him for mass times the speed of light squared. That E= MC squared . sure made it easy to figure out how the solar system worked...... Death is a dream that needs to be earned and I mean to the Urn. 🎶
to everyone saying "hiS wiFe iS tHe reAl geniUs":
Yes, his wife was a smart person and yes she contributed to his work but it was just a contribution. Many people wants to believe the idea of "old white man bad, woman doesnt get credited" kinda bs. Also imagine 40s and 50s, one generation before that women was not considered adult humans in most of the world. How can you NOT expect sexism against women?
You don't know the whole story. He was abusive to his wife and he screwed around on her
We get it. Every other comment mentions it. So what. Maybe she was not so nice to be around, like many women.
@@johningle1 Like most men, as well. Sorry for being redundant
@@kimwaldron2606 you can't generalize yourself to most men
@@randomuser3960 I don't engage in conversation with people on here who make personal attacks
@kimwaldron2606 then why are you replying? 1000 iq move
Relativity is bunk science, just like gravity.
You can slow down time with isochronic tones because it makes your thought processing more efficient. The more efficient the processing, the slower time becomes. Having absolutely nothing to do with relative motion.
Pretty sure he also wasn't nice to his wife
I like the way he says "may you all make the future brighter for all"
As well as
"You a matter to someone"
Clever m8
Good luck to Anyone reading
And
May you all find peace in your domain
What an intellect and subliminally well put all the way to the end. . .
Respeto cada persona y a su dedicación , hablando de geometría .
Albert estaba basado a un Reyno , hoy veo que les dan un valor a una matemática que te desleal y falta de respeto , a su fundadores
It's a pity when anyone dies. With very few exceptions, a person's loving thought, happy memories, grandest experiences, all die with him.
So lucky people were to live with Albert Einstein, he made fridge everywhere on world, any vehicle motor similar to petrol electric generators is made on Albert Einstein knowledge, very smart he was.
Such a nice talk.
Intelligent people give to the world, powerful people take from the world, that's the beauty of the world.
Sounds ugly
What a beautiful rivalry
"I wish for you, that it will always be a pity for you to die."
That hits surprisingly hard, even out of context.
I don't think many actually learned the most important things Einstein and Sagan tried to teach the world.
Had over two decades experience with people idolizing their work and nearly lost my passion for science twice.
I guess it is merely a tempering process, science for the sake of science alone.
Still, wish more people felt that.