The quote 'Don't try to ruin someone's life with a lie when yours can be destroyed with the truth' ...comes to mind. I wish JKR every success. These hateful people trying to marginalise the majority need to be stopped.
People are not smart enough these days to understand the bleeding obvious. You have to laugh in the direction society is going at the moment. It can not possibly stay this stupid forever. 😂
@@thetransagender2866it’s reality though. India is a dude and no amount of surgeries or hormones will change that. Man and woman aren’t socially constructed stereotypes. Wishing that to be the case won’t make it so.
JK Rowling is a Heroine for this awful period in history in that regard. Im not big into the Harry Potter books or films, but my respect for her is massive due to her just being a real human being with normal viewpoints, yet society now deems normalcy as the enemy, sadly. JK Rowling needs continuing to get support from news channels like yourselves at GB News.
Himdia Willoughby is so male in his presentation, I can't work out why he thinks anyone would believe he was anything else. JK is far less rude than many others and his targeting of her appears obsessive.
I don't understand why those who are openly trans expect others to treat them as if they aren't. If India lived as a man for 50yrs, then his lived experience is that of a male. It doesn't how feminine he may have felt, or that he believed he was in the 'wrong' body. What shapes a person is their interactions with others over time. We do tend to treat boys and girls / men and women, differently. Sometimes our 'treatments' are subtle; sometimes they are not, but there is little doubt that the experience of being a male - regardless of what is going on inside a male mind - is different to that of being a female. I accept India's right to live as he wishes, to wear what he wants and to be fully accepted as a transwoman. But I can't just forget that India was a man for 50yrs and accept that via feelings, medication and surgery, he has the same lived experience as I have because it simply isn't true.
All I've seen of him was a shouting down whilst towering over a woman who stood up for women, a tv presenter I believe. From that time I thought he's a bully.
see the thing is I obey, women want me to call myself a man then I start calling myself a man I have no issues but then men ask Me to refer myself as female and explain why I should then I listen. and say yeah I guess im a woman too?? then women get mad again but because im logical I agree and call myself a man again ((a gay man) and I happy like that a guy guy that dresses as a woman and I dont feel bad cause there just words, I can call myself a man and use my male name, even dress as a man again, but the truth is always there, Im skinny, im delicate, my testosterone levels have always been low, so I look gay af even if I try to dress like a man, then one day I get tired because men outfits cause theyre heavy and I cant do anything or move properly, I do better wearing dresses and heels, cause im feminine, I move faster, I do better, you know what I mean? so I go back to wearing female clothes, not even thinking im a woman or something. but because they feel right for my persona, and im ok being called a he, but women ask if I wanna be called a she and feel coplimented cause I wasnt really expecting it, and I say well yeah thank you!!! I dont mind being referred as a he!!! then they convince me and im calling myself a she, happy for a few days then someone starts the bullying and I perfectly go back to being called a he if thats what they want, then again someone tells me im a she, so at the end I dont know who to please anymore, if I could choose I would refer myself as human an IT
@@lefat4697 I think the point is theres nowadays a new trend that allows straight men to transition and there making us look bad and everyone now believes we are like them, I think thats the new wave and root of hate because tbh I do hate them too so I totally relate to the current hate towards trans if thyre all thinking of all these guys in the media who are trans but have girlfriends in secret, all these new trans athletes, models, Dylan, Caitlyn, all have girlfriends, when they talk, I just dont like the way they speak , very fake and something about them just doesn't sound right, so if people dont like them either its understandable, theyre also the type of men who will call themselves women so badly, like why? if you know who you are, how does the label man or woman affects you? you know what I mean? its not something we would do, other trans I know aren't like this , thats just insane
Apprantely this India person said something about you wouldn'kidnap women like that . Why isn't the police treating this person the way they treated Lawrence Fox .
Unacceptable! I won't stand for this... Comparing the *man* to a pig!?! Please... Pigs are actually useful for something and frankly make great pets. Not to mention great meals! And at least a pig knows that it is a pig. 🐖 Imagine if pigs started "identifying" as chickens?
What you said reminds me of Monty Python Life Of Brian. Stan: It's every man's right to have babies if he wants them. Reg: But you can't have babies. Stan: Don't you oppress me. Reg: Where's the fetus going to gestate? You going to keep it in a box?
I think its worse, where does the doner come from? I'm opting out of organ donation if this ever becomes viable, the idea of creating a baby from a dead mothers womb is evil and cruel to the child.
In THEORY. Who’s theory? It has never happened. Womb transplants have happened- about 100 - 50 resulted in pregnancy. But ALL were to women. Don’t forget a woman has to donate her womb first for it to take place. 🫣🙀🌻
I remember a time not that long ago when the media were falling over themselves to celebrate JK’s success. From humble beginnings to accomplished author . All the strong, independent woman stuff was bandied about like confetti…… And now, she is cast aside because she refuses to play make belief . Bloody ridiculous.
Rowling wrote the best selling books.. she didn't make the movies.. She has been 100% correct in all the trans stuff.. the left can't handle the truth.
Or introduce 'House Arrest' where people have to 'STAY HOME' or face arrest for 'not complying'. Thank goodness the government hasn't had the chance to rehearse that strategy eh? Oh, hang on...
He’s very selfish to waste police time. He should be kind and let police investigate crimes that result in physical harm. Stop demanding people play into his fantasy, it’s vey disturbing.
No, there is no case in which a human male has become pregnant, sustained a pregnancy and given birth and it would be completely reliant in the first instance they would have to have a donated uterus, donated eggs/ovaries, lots of complex hormones given, anti rejection drugs, and a caesarean to give birth as neo vaginas and penises cannot pass a baby through them, nor can male hips, and the male coccyx is fixed, not flexible and cannot move during the birthing process. It is beyond nonsense to make it seem as if male humans can fulfill the female human reproductive role and its this irresponsible remark that contributes to people thinking something is true that simply is not. My observations are not intended to be hurtful or cruel, it is just factual.
@@izoedyourbabydaddy7628 Indeed, there are human females who have parts of their body that are not fully working in accordance with their intended design that affects part of the process of their reproduction, (or preventing it!) amongst all the many, many different things that you need in terms of the 'equipment' for the human female reproductive role. None of those women, those females, have all of it missing completely. I am a human female whose body was not working in part in accordance with its general design, and that does not mean I am a male. My point was that for very many reasons it is completely misleading for the panel guest to suggest that there is a possibility that males can or will shortly be able to have medical interventions and drugs that will result in them conceiving, gestating and giving birth like females. The parenting role is something that is not conditional on an individual being pregnant and giving birth and I did not refer to parenting in my comment. A very significant part of being a female and a woman is managing the reproductive system and its physiological affects throughout her lifetime...whether that is menstruation and its physical impacts, menopause and its symptoms, trying to avoid pregnancy and the associated drugs and devices and practices, or trying to get pregnant, and the physical aspects and risks of pregnancy and childbirth, which includes everything from feeling queasy to risk of serious injury or death and then afterwards, the ongoing demands of breast feeding and 24/7 care of a person that can only survive hours without attention. As well as this you must also consider the financial impacts during the period your baby needs to use your body for survival, internally and once they have left it, as well as the intense care demands for some years thereafter.
@@shelleyphilcox4743 males can't give birth but there are men who have given birth. I think even discussing if males can give birth is pointless and redundant.
Please JK - take on the man Willoughby to call out the truth - as obviously Willoughby needs the truth to be reinforced to him as he's clearly deluded. I would love her to takdnon the police too! They're part of this stupid madness!
Monty Python Life Of Brian. Stan: It's every man's right to have babies if he wants them. Reg: But you can't have babies. Stan: Don't you oppress me. Reg: Where's the fetus going to gestate? You going to keep it in a box?
India had spent many years telling us he is a man on various media platforms so why is it imperative that we say he is a woman? I am sick of this gas lighting . No one can change their biological sex with, or without, the appropriate paperwork
Oh this will be good. It will be so funny watching JK Rowling using India Wolly as a human mop. India literally has no idea how money talks. And JK Rowling is drowning in it. Bring it on i say, it's about time something was done.
Do I hear an edge of PC nervousness in JHB's tone... worrying about what she is saying.... No such problem for our modern womens heroine, J K Rowling. She tells it like it is. The truth may hurt some but for the majority of us women, it's a breath of fresh air.
Why in the heck is the police in the UK even involved with these weird pronoun issues?? This isn’t a police matter. Do they have nothing else to do? I would be embarrassed to be made to investigate this. I’m a recently retired police officer in the US and if someone called us upset about a pronoun we would roll our eyes. This is not a police matter lol.
Well, there’s a theory it’s to do with mother issues. The aim of genuine male to female transgender people is to try and integrate into society, you rarely knowingly come across them. On a personal level, I’ve basically failed, I just cannot integrate, but that does not mean I can prance around like a mad panto dame and expect society to accept it!
what really irks me is the de-valuation of the very specific term "hate crime" it used to be heavy stuff like a fatwa on a cartoonist, anti-semitic slurs etc and now it is a weird guys hurt feelings... I hope that silly complaint does not lead anywhere
The echoes of Orwell and 1984 are up so close and personal now that we can miss the big ones…where they metaphorically get you to say and ultimately believe that 2+2 is not 4. The “misgendering” charge is the equivalent of accusing you of believing that 2+2=4. The India Willoughby thing is emblematic. The truth…the pre totalitarian truth …is that you “misgender” India Willoughby by calling him a woman..by referring to him as “her”. That IS actual misgendering. Another example of this is using the term “gender affirmation surgery” because what it actually “affirms” is that your “ gender” is what it says on your birth certificate. The fact that you NEED surgery to disguise your actual identity tells the truth of your actual gender.
I respect peoples identity choices however I’m conflicted when it comes to the question posed here: what if the whole population somehow was reduced to only a one (or very few) male and one trans women. Humanity would end they couldn’t have the next generation unless I’m mistaken
@@Hakushodemon I do but you are saying that humanity will cease to exist because transwoman can't bare children. But that's ridiculous because if humanity was reduced down to one man and one woman who can't bare children you would get the same results.
It should be impossible to alter an original birth certificate in any way. If his birth certificate stated male and now states female, how has this been allowed to happen?
JK Rowling is voicing her opinion, ppl weaponising her opinion is on them. When I first heard the row, it was mis-reported and shame on me I took it on face value until I exerted the energy to read her statement and comments in full. The following are a couple of excerpts “The idea that women like me, who’ve been empathetic to trans people for decades, feeling kinship because they’re vulnerable in the same way as women-i.e., to male violence-‘hate’ trans people because they think sex is real and has lived consequences-is a nonsense.” She continued, “I respect every trans person’s right to live any way that feels authentic and comfortable to them. I’d march with you if you were discriminated against on the basis of being trans. At the same time, my life has been shaped by being female. I do not believe it’s hateful to say so.” That is her stance and on that good on you JK Rowling.
I'm a biological woman and I wouldn't expect someone to go to jail for calling me a man. At most I might feel a little annoyed, but it's not a h*te crime. The word 'Man' is not a slur like the N word.
We leave in such ' bad ' times that people will work really hard to become a ' victim ' The trans activists take this to the extreme, demanding endless validation and celebration to prop up their awful psychological status 😮
Please never even mention the word woman when talking about men like this . What has happened to our freedom of speech ? The police are not good arbiters any more are they in fact they are a complete liability
Surely an offence has been committed, by this trans person re their passport - who is listed as "female." That is a declared lie. That is illegal, and should lead to withdrawal of passport.
He doesn’t care how other people identify....there lies the problem. People like this bloke help perpetuate the problems until it gets completely out of hand.
I've never read as single word or watched even a trailer of the Harry Potter books, just because they've never appealed to me ... but now I feel the desire to buy a copy of all her books
How it's transphobic to state actual reality? Identifying as isn't the same as being, if anything, by stating trans women are not women reaffirms they are in fact trans, which should be seen as a good thing!
that bloke india has reported JKR to the police for deliberately calling her a man....saying a crime has been committed....and what crime is that...telling the truth...what nonsense
Calling a man 'a man' is not hateful. Nor is it a police matter. From this not only is India cosplaying as a woman, he is cosplaying as an adult. No self respecting woman would act as he has been acting.
Curious. What if a doctor diagnosed a transperson like the one in question here with prostate enlargement, will he sue the doctor for malicious misdiagnosis and medical transphobia? After all he says she is a woman.
Correct. They can identify themselves anyway they choose. I JUST DON'T BELIEVE IN WHAT THEY CHOOSE. 🤥 So I will identify them as what I know them to be. 👍
The quote 'Don't try to ruin someone's life with a lie when yours can be destroyed with the truth' ...comes to mind. I wish JKR every success. These hateful people trying to marginalise the majority need to be stopped.
I like that quote 😊
India WillougHe is not a woman. Fact.
Well, close. The real name of WillyHe is Jonathan.
He blocked me on twitter, just coz i asked if he gets his prostate checked. haha
@@carolyncass8859OMG ahahahahaha 🤣🤣🤣
@@carolyncass8859 you minx 😊
“WilloughHe”…outstanding!
A bloke in a dress is still a bloke for gods sake!!
Just ask the Archbishop ;)
Kev you are 100 % correct and usually they look pretty horrible.
People are not smart enough these days to understand the bleeding obvious. You have to laugh in the direction society is going at the moment. It can not possibly stay this stupid forever. 😂
Has that India guy got nothing better to do than being a professional victim?
Desperate for attention & cash in maybe with woke lefty sponsors like the Guy on Bud Light & Tampax commercials.....
Some balls on him
It's creepy as
@@paulsmyth3580: NOT according to HIS gender-interpretation!
They look more masculine the older they get. This must be mortifying for them.🤣
J.K Rowling is 100% correct...😂😂😂😂😂
Its a geezer in a frock....
Who you?
@@thetransagender2866if I take dog hormones do i become a dog?
@@thetransagender2866it’s reality though. India is a dude and no amount of surgeries or hormones will change that. Man and woman aren’t socially constructed stereotypes. Wishing that to be the case won’t make it so.
@@nicholaswright3801 Using phony science to justify your transphobia
J K Rowling is 100% right. Oh yeah, and the last time I checked, men don't get pregnant.
JK Rowling is a Heroine for this awful period in history in that regard. Im not big into the Harry Potter books or films, but my respect for her is massive due to her just being a real human being with normal viewpoints, yet society now deems normalcy as the enemy, sadly. JK Rowling needs continuing to get support from news channels like yourselves at GB News.
Welcome to Orwell's 1984.
@XXLSSBBW hahaha, this gave me a laugh, but it's one of despair in all truths, as I see the similarities between the book and today's world.
Normalcy? Is that American for Normality?
@@Reprobus3 how tf have you never heard the word normalcy before? Also, no mate, this is an English speaking word.
@@KingDomsKingdom85 I've heard it, but the correct word in English is Normality.
Himdia Willoughby is so male in his presentation, I can't work out why he thinks anyone would believe he was anything else. JK is far less rude than many others and his targeting of her appears obsessive.
Himdia 🤣😂🤣😂🤣👍
Nice 😂
As a show of tolerance I'm going to start calling Jonathan WillyHe "Himdia"
I don't understand why those who are openly trans expect others to treat them as if they aren't.
If India lived as a man for 50yrs, then his lived experience is that of a male. It doesn't how feminine he may have felt, or that he believed he was in the 'wrong' body. What shapes a person is their interactions with others over time. We do tend to treat boys and girls / men and women, differently. Sometimes our 'treatments' are subtle; sometimes they are not, but there is little doubt that the experience of being a male - regardless of what is going on inside a male mind - is different to that of being a female.
I accept India's right to live as he wishes, to wear what he wants and to be fully accepted as a transwoman. But I can't just forget that India was a man for 50yrs and accept that via feelings, medication and surgery, he has the same lived experience as I have because it simply isn't true.
All I've seen of him was a shouting down whilst towering over a woman who stood up for women, a tv presenter I believe. From that time I thought he's a bully.
Thank you for using the correct pronouns for this man Julia.
see the thing is I obey, women want me to call myself a man then I start calling myself a man I have no issues but then men ask Me to refer myself as female and explain why I should then I listen. and say yeah I guess im a woman too?? then women get mad again but because im logical I agree and call myself a man again ((a gay man) and I happy like that a guy guy that dresses as a woman and I dont feel bad cause there just words, I can call myself a man and use my male name, even dress as a man again, but the truth is always there, Im skinny, im delicate, my testosterone levels have always been low, so I look gay af even if I try to dress like a man, then one day I get tired because men outfits cause theyre heavy and I cant do anything or move properly, I do better wearing dresses and heels, cause im feminine, I move faster, I do better, you know what I mean? so I go back to wearing female clothes, not even thinking im a woman or something. but because they feel right for my persona, and im ok being called a he, but women ask if I wanna be called a she and feel coplimented cause I wasnt really expecting it, and I say well yeah thank you!!! I dont mind being referred as a he!!! then they convince me and im calling myself a she, happy for a few days then someone starts the bullying and I perfectly go back to being called a he if thats what they want, then again someone tells me im a she, so at the end I dont know who to please anymore, if I could choose I would refer myself as human an IT
@@ReginaTrans_ so the point you are making is which?
@@lefat4697 I think the point is theres nowadays a new trend that allows straight men to transition and there making us look bad and everyone now believes we are like them, I think thats the new wave and root of hate because tbh I do hate them too so I totally relate to the current hate towards trans if thyre all thinking of all these guys in the media who are trans but have girlfriends in secret, all these new trans athletes, models, Dylan, Caitlyn, all have girlfriends, when they talk, I just dont like the way they speak , very fake and something about them just doesn't sound right, so if people dont like them either its understandable, theyre also the type of men who will call themselves women so badly, like why? if you know who you are, how does the label man or woman affects you? you know what I mean? its not something we would do, other trans I know aren't like this , thats just insane
I'm a jet plane! Build me a runway! I'm a professional victim!
@@lefat4697 You are just looking for a fight with your comment, aren't you? sigh..
Willoughby is a man end of story. These vantrestytes are annoying.😆
In Court
Do you tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth.
Yes…. He’s a man.
Very good
luv it
The police should have better things to do like stopping the shoplifting epidemic.
This country full of weirdos 😂
It’s like a real freek show circus I’m beyond bored of it all tbh with you.
You know what they say… the lunatics are running the asylum
Most are in the house of commons
…yes and the biggest weirdos are the people in power that allow all this shite to carry on and see it as normal.
Talk Fash TV viewers
Apprantely this India person said something about you wouldn'kidnap women like that . Why isn't the police treating this person the way they treated Lawrence Fox .
Arguably "hate speech". As you said, they came after Lawrence Fox for much the same.
Because it's a one sided WEF agenda. Keep up.
You can put lipstick on a pig but it's still a pig! 🤷♂️
Comparing him to a pig? That’s offensive to pigs. Some of my best friends …
😂😂😂
How true, Pigs are intelligent, sociable and as far as I know Boy pigs don't wear skirts and pretend that they're Lady Pigs.
Unacceptable! I won't stand for this... Comparing the *man* to a pig!?! Please... Pigs are actually useful for something and frankly make great pets. Not to mention great meals! And at least a pig knows that it is a pig. 🐖 Imagine if pigs started "identifying" as chickens?
Doctor: “I’m afraid that you have prostate cancer. “ Willoughby: “How dare you! I’m reporting you to the police” ……
So so true, when India's body is dug up by archeologists, they'll identify the body as being male. No getting away from it.
Such insanity from these men.
Must be the PMT
Saying that in theory a male could have a womb transplant so as to become pregnant is about as comparable as a head transplant.
I believe it has sort of happened before. Not that I'd consider that a real pregnancy.
What you said reminds me of Monty Python Life Of Brian.
Stan: It's every man's right to have babies if he wants them.
Reg: But you can't have babies.
Stan: Don't you oppress me.
Reg: Where's the fetus going to gestate? You going to keep it in a box?
@@XXLSSBBWThey have more chance of gestating in a glass box than a womb placed in side a man.
I think its worse, where does the doner come from? I'm opting out of organ donation if this ever becomes viable, the idea of creating a baby from a dead mothers womb is evil and cruel to the child.
In THEORY. Who’s theory?
It has never happened. Womb transplants have happened- about 100 - 50 resulted in pregnancy. But ALL were to women. Don’t forget a woman has to donate her womb first for it to take place. 🫣🙀🌻
I didn't like the Harry Potter films, but do admire JKR for speaking out. good for her.
I remember a time not that long ago when the media were falling over themselves to celebrate JK’s success.
From humble beginnings to accomplished author .
All the strong, independent woman stuff was bandied about like confetti……
And now, she is cast aside because she refuses to play make belief .
Bloody ridiculous.
Rowling wrote the best selling books.. she didn't make the movies..
She has been 100% correct in all the trans stuff.. the left can't handle the truth.
I don't either the 3 main kids were terrible actors especially DR and whatever the girls name is, but the books are good
@@monk3yboy69 Absolutely. And look now: the new definition of 'extremism' puts women like J.K. on 'the list'.
I identify as, means I'm pretending to be.
I identify as blk and I'm blk. Try again
@LuceliaBerger the original post says I identify means I'm pretending.....so if i identify as something that I am does that not prove the op wrong?
@LuceliaBerger I didn't choose to ignore it I pointed out the flaw.
@LuceliaBerger biracial people do that. What is your point?
If we are going to jail people for hurting someone else's feelings we had better build a couple of million prison places.
Or introduce 'House Arrest' where people have to 'STAY HOME' or face arrest for 'not complying'. Thank goodness the government hasn't had the chance to rehearse that strategy eh?
Oh, hang on...
He’s very selfish to waste police time. He should be kind and let police investigate crimes that result in physical harm. Stop demanding people play into his fantasy, it’s vey disturbing.
💥💯💥
It's a bloke in a frock.😅
They are getting more and more arrogant
A bloke in a frock is still a bloke is absolutely priceless and a fact
Once a man always a man 😊
That thing isn't a man.
intersex too
Hope India also reported himself to the police for "mis-gendering" Debbie Hayton 🤔🙄
And himself.
Spot on Julia!
We shouldnt be forced to partake is anyones delusions
Whats a woman....ask your moma...😂
@@mariachester950 excuse me? it's spelt "birthing person" not woman, get with the times.
The Dark Times
No, there is no case in which a human male has become pregnant, sustained a pregnancy and given birth and it would be completely reliant in the first instance they would have to have a donated uterus, donated eggs/ovaries, lots of complex hormones given, anti rejection drugs, and a caesarean to give birth as neo vaginas and penises cannot pass a baby through them, nor can male hips, and the male coccyx is fixed, not flexible and cannot move during the birthing process. It is beyond nonsense to make it seem as if male humans can fulfill the female human reproductive role and its this irresponsible remark that contributes to people thinking something is true that simply is not. My observations are not intended to be hurtful or cruel, it is just factual.
There are ciswoman who can't give birth. Having babies doesn't make a woman. Having babies makes a mother. It's the confusion for me 😂
@@izoedyourbabydaddy7628 Indeed, there are human females who have parts of their body that are not fully working in accordance with their intended design that affects part of the process of their reproduction, (or preventing it!) amongst all the many, many different things that you need in terms of the 'equipment' for the human female reproductive role. None of those women, those females, have all of it missing completely. I am a human female whose body was not working in part in accordance with its general design, and that does not mean I am a male.
My point was that for very many reasons it is completely misleading for the panel guest to suggest that there is a possibility that males can or will shortly be able to have medical interventions and drugs that will result in them conceiving, gestating and giving birth like females.
The parenting role is something that is not conditional on an individual being pregnant and giving birth and I did not refer to parenting in my comment.
A very significant part of being a female and a woman is managing the reproductive system and its physiological affects throughout her lifetime...whether that is menstruation and its physical impacts, menopause and its symptoms, trying to avoid pregnancy and the associated drugs and devices and practices, or trying to get pregnant, and the physical aspects and risks of pregnancy and childbirth, which includes everything from feeling queasy to risk of serious injury or death and then afterwards, the ongoing demands of breast feeding and 24/7 care of a person that can only survive hours without attention. As well as this you must also consider the financial impacts during the period your baby needs to use your body for survival, internally and once they have left it, as well as the intense care demands for some years thereafter.
@@shelleyphilcox4743 males can't give birth but there are men who have given birth. I think even discussing if males can give birth is pointless and redundant.
@@izoedyourbabydaddy7628Did you read what you posted? Or where you confused when you wrote that nonsense?
@@izoedyourbabydaddy7628 No biological males have given birth, ever. If you mean trans men, then yes, they can give birth because they are WOMEN
Please JK - take on the man Willoughby to call out the truth - as obviously Willoughby needs the truth to be reinforced to him as he's clearly deluded. I would love her to takdnon the police too! They're part of this stupid madness!
They can’t accept themselves for who they really are, but expect us to accept them for who they are not!
When telling the truth is illegal, we are doomed.
I can't believe that people who are supposed to be intelligent are falling for and trying to defend this crap.
*_It's no accident that the new definition of 'extremism' puts women like J.K. on 'the list'_*
I’d rather be labelled a transphobe than a liar !! Meat and two veg !!
The shape, alone, gives the game away.
A man's pelvic structure doesn't allow for a baby to grow in that space. How can stating a biological fact be hateful.
XY feature could be highly offensive 😊
Monty Python Life Of Brian.
Stan: It's every man's right to have babies if he wants them.
Reg: But you can't have babies.
Stan: Don't you oppress me.
Reg: Where's the fetus going to gestate? You going to keep it in a box?
If mis gendering becomes an offence maybe it would be safer to call anyone you're not sure about 'a**hole'.
India had spent many years telling us he is a man on various media platforms so why is it imperative that we say he is a woman? I am sick of this gas lighting . No one can change their biological sex with, or without, the appropriate paperwork
Oh this will be good. It will be so funny watching JK Rowling using India Wolly as a human mop. India literally has no idea how money talks. And JK Rowling is drowning in it. Bring it on i say, it's about time something was done.
If I were JK I’d counter sue!
Thankyou Julia. Keep up the good work. You, along with JKR, KJK and Helen Joyce are heroines of the age. Diversity terrorism is exactly what it is.
All bought and paid for by Westbro Baptist church
I love the fact the Julia is reporting india as him.
they might lock her up
Roy Walker "Say what you see".
Vanstrestyte.😆🤣🤔🕺🏽
😂 a sad bloke
A mixed up damaged man
a geezer in a frock
If trans "women" were women we wouldn't be having this discussion. Trans literally means make-believe in this context.
Do I hear an edge of PC nervousness in JHB's tone... worrying about what she is saying....
No such problem for our modern womens heroine, J K Rowling. She tells it like it is. The truth may hurt some but for the majority of us women, it's a breath of fresh air.
No way !
Why in the heck is the police in the UK even involved with these weird pronoun issues?? This isn’t a police matter. Do they have nothing else to do? I would be embarrassed to be made to investigate this. I’m a recently retired police officer in the US and if someone called us upset about a pronoun we would roll our eyes. This is not a police matter lol.
Why is it when men dress as women they dress like a 1950’s mum.
Because it’s a sexual fetish and a lot of it is tied to their mother. It’s in the psychological research
Well, there’s a theory it’s to do with mother issues. The aim of genuine male to female transgender people is to try and integrate into society, you rarely knowingly come across them. On a personal level, I’ve basically failed, I just cannot integrate, but that does not mean I can prance around like a mad panto dame and expect society to accept it!
It's a reflection of the parody image of women these men have.
I would respect these guys a lot more if they simply acknowledged they were perverts instead of pretending to take themselves seriously as women
Truth is a defense to libel and slander, but whose truth? Ridiculous. Why are we letting the patients run the asylum? Or, tail wag the dog?
Because when people like you were running the asylum the patients were treated unfairly.
Bravo, JK ...make 'em have it gal!!!!!
The bullying that JKR is getting is very symbolic to how mad the world has gone. Dear God...
what really irks me is the de-valuation of the very specific term "hate crime"
it used to be heavy stuff like a fatwa on a cartoonist,
anti-semitic slurs etc
and now it is a weird guys hurt feelings...
I hope that silly complaint does not lead anywhere
A guy who says, "I'm a woman" does not become a woman.
Nor does he if a couple of drugs are added.
Nor does he if he also has some elective surgery.
A man in a dress is a man in a dress. This is not complicated, that’s a man in a dress.
The echoes of Orwell and 1984 are up so close and personal now that we can miss the big ones…where they metaphorically get you to say and ultimately believe that 2+2 is not 4. The “misgendering” charge is the equivalent of accusing you of believing that 2+2=4. The India Willoughby thing is emblematic. The truth…the pre totalitarian truth …is that you “misgender” India Willoughby by calling him a woman..by referring to him as “her”. That IS actual misgendering. Another example of this is using the term “gender affirmation surgery” because what it actually “affirms” is that your “ gender” is what it says on your birth certificate. The fact that you NEED surgery to disguise your actual identity tells the truth of your actual gender.
I respect peoples identity choices however I’m conflicted when it comes to the question posed here: what if the whole population somehow was reduced to only a one (or very few) male and one trans women. Humanity would end they couldn’t have the next generation unless I’m mistaken
7 billion people on this planet and you are worried about some end of the world scenario 😂😂😂😂
@@izoedyourbabydaddy7628 its called using critical thinking. are you able to understand what a hypothetical question is? apparently not
@@Hakushodemon I do but you are saying that humanity will cease to exist because transwoman can't bare children. But that's ridiculous because if humanity was reduced down to one man and one woman who can't bare children you would get the same results.
@@izoedyourbabydaddy7628if an archeology team dig him up in 300 years they will say hear is a man in a dress
Have you seen the video from the interviewer afterwards he even calls Him a Him and is now denying it it’s so funny 😂😂😂
That bloke is crazy
It should be impossible to alter an original birth certificate in any way. If his birth certificate stated male and now states female, how has this been allowed to happen?
So easy to make a dubious living these days. Ian Willoughby is proof.😂
and it's only going to get worse & it's almost unbearable now !!!
JK Rowling is voicing her opinion, ppl weaponising her opinion is on them. When I first heard the row, it was mis-reported and shame on me I took it on face value until I exerted the energy to read her statement and comments in full. The following are a couple of excerpts
“The idea that women like me, who’ve been empathetic to trans people for decades, feeling kinship because they’re vulnerable in the same way as women-i.e., to male violence-‘hate’ trans people because they think sex is real and has lived consequences-is a nonsense.”
She continued, “I respect every trans person’s right to live any way that feels authentic and comfortable to them. I’d march with you if you were discriminated against on the basis of being trans. At the same time, my life has been shaped by being female. I do not believe it’s hateful to say so.” That is her stance and on that good on you JK Rowling.
Out of the three of them; one of them has balls.
I'm a biological woman and I wouldn't expect someone to go to jail for calling me a man. At most I might feel a little annoyed, but it's not a h*te crime. The word 'Man' is not a slur like the N word.
give it a year
We leave in such ' bad ' times that people will work really hard to become a ' victim ' The trans activists take this to the extreme, demanding endless validation and celebration to prop up their awful psychological status 😮
👉👉👉Science is NOT about feelings.
Science is not transphobic
Please never even mention the word woman when talking about men like this . What has happened to our freedom of speech ? The police are not good arbiters any more are they in fact they are a complete liability
Freedom of speech is not freedom of consequence
willoughby is British and he call him self India, he is men claim as women, it's offensive for indian women.
J.K. Rowling going to jail for this would be a perfect embodiment of Sirius Black at Azkaban for trying to kill the Potter's murderer.
Why don't all of us real women tell the bloody truth. Well done you for telling the truth.
It’s a BLOKE!!
Surely an offence has been committed, by this trans person re their passport - who is listed as "female." That is a declared lie. That is illegal, and should lead to withdrawal of passport.
Shakespeare was right about lawyers.
By which you mean Mr Bumble.
Although he WAS referring to the law, not to any of its representatives.
Always remember the rubric - if it's born with a dick, then it ain't no chick. That means you India Willoughby boy.
He doesn’t care how other people identify....there lies the problem.
People like this bloke help perpetuate the problems until it gets completely out of hand.
I've never read as single word or watched even a trailer of the Harry Potter books, just because they've never appealed to me ... but now I feel the desire to buy a copy of all her books
How it's transphobic to state actual reality? Identifying as isn't the same as being, if anything, by stating trans women are not women reaffirms they are in fact trans, which should be seen as a good thing!
Western world is slowly becoming Orwell's 1984
Himdia needs to be reported to the police for misogyny, he’s been offending women for years with no consequence.
The truth is an absolute defense
The truth as far as he is concerned is whatever he wants it to be. How full of s..t is this thing.
that bloke india has reported JKR to the police for deliberately calling her a man....saying a crime has been committed....and what crime is that...telling the truth...what nonsense
Good for J K Rowling!
Calling a man 'a man' is not hateful. Nor is it a police matter.
From this not only is India cosplaying as a woman, he is cosplaying as an adult.
No self respecting woman would act as he has been acting.
Curious.
What if a doctor diagnosed a transperson like the one in question here with prostate enlargement, will he sue the doctor for malicious misdiagnosis and medical transphobia? After all he says she is a woman.
Surely, J K has a case for stalking at the very least? Go J K. When's your next book out, I'm preordering!
Birth Certificate is registered when one is born!!!!
Why doesn’t India just man up
😂😂😂😂
It is Moral Blackmail. It is the Secular equivalent of 'Convert of Die'
I stand with JK Rowling ❤.
Same.
Somebody said to me, that it's a wonder that science has not found a cure for them yet.
Totally crazy. And scary!!
Aw someone doesn’t buy their delusion! Wahhhh ATTACK! lol 😂 JK had a backbone unlike some people
Rowling needs to sue India for defamation, period!
I mean girls who are into bodybuilding get called a “man” all the time, how many of them have reported any of that to the police? 😅
I have a biology degree. Studied biology 1988. Do I need to update my degree? what has changed and when?
Its a bloke
Correct. They can identify themselves anyway they choose. I JUST DON'T BELIEVE IN WHAT THEY CHOOSE. 🤥 So I will identify them as what I know them to be. 👍
The dude is just mad that his altered piping will cause him issues in life, cos that's in his future.
Men Are Not Women. Women Are Not Men
Just think. Most people didn't know what a pronoun was before all this nonsense.
I’m still not sure know
Love that phrase - “diversity terrorism”. 😮. Love that phrase 😊