I know if fish bait reads this, Nate will roll his eyes, but I want to say thank you to Bates for all of the hard work he does for this podcast. This podcast brings so much joy to so many people every Wednesday and Bates has to read through all of our comments. we appreciate you! None of this is lost on us 😊
I love how Graham is part of the disclaimer. It's like he has Nate's back in case the Mannings barge in and want to fight Nate. Everyone needs a friend like that.
Nate may not have had a good week because of the Manningcast, but my week was made SO great when my husband and I got to meet him on Sunday at a local coffee restaurant. He could not have been nicer--and I appreciate it so much! Only thing that would've been better would be for Laura, Brian, Dusty and Aaron to have been with him. And Harper! We're even bigger fans now. I didn't say it well that day--THANK YOU Nate, for the great entertainment you provide for our family and so many others. And I think I remember every funny story you've ever told. 1:07:50
Nate saying "I just can't let things go" when talking about the possible dinner with Eli is so relatable. This is what makes his comedy so good, its relatable to everyone.
We understood the delay was happening. We just rolled with it. We love you and your dad so much and we knew you would explain what happened. We’re the Nateland family of course you can vent to us.
Aaron saying “God forbid we have a little holiday spirit” about Christmas lights in November immediately after revealing he doesn’t even have a tree is gold.
Nic has such a beautiful smile and such a contagious laugh!!! ❤ Love listening to him - funny, intelligent, and articulate!!! ❤ I always miss when Dusty isn’t there, but Nic is fun!!!
I'll be honest with you, that "rant" Nate apologized for had softer tones and opinions than his discussion of an emu with a gun. Classy move to add a disclaimer, but, honestly, Nate's points were valid! Love the show, keep up the good work, fellas. Merry Christmas!
I’ve heard other ppl say that they don’t expect the Mannings to research them before going on their show, I think it’s so silly to give them passes just because who they are. Part of their job is to interview ppl so they need to be prepared for their job, that’d be like if they went out on the field without ever looking at the playbook. After hearing Nate’s experience I don’t think Mark or any other of those ppl were bad guests, I think the Mannings are just bad hosts
The Mannings clearly don’t have someone like Nate telling them what’s wrong with their show. I watch a lot and the delay is very annoying. They are constantly switching between interviews and the game so you don’t really get to enjoy either. It needs to just be the manning brothers and no guests. Just them 2 talking ball.
I think it would fall more to the producers and directors of the show than the Mannings. The Mannings are guys who understand football at the highest level and trying to provide insight to viewers at home. 2 games were happening live. It’s just not a great time to be interviewing a comic or doing magic tricks. I think it’s just more of a problem with the atmosphere and direction of the show than any specific people.
@@jordanmadden7388 That’s fair, I agree with the other guy who commented that said they should just keep the show between the Mannings and other players/their friends. I recognize what the Mannings bring to the table for their show but if you hear any of the great interviewers they say it is important to know your guests to bring the best out of them, have the best interview product or you run the risk of making your guest feel the way Nate did afterwards, although they should have a research team that would be for nothing if the Mannings didn’t take the time to familiarize themselves with Nate’s background
My husband started yelling for me to hurry to come see the Manning cast because you were on it and he knows how much our entire family loves you! You were great! I love how frustrated you were on the pod, it shows how important family is! Glad you left it in! Also neat that Mick 😉was on this pod. I had just been listening to old episodes that he was on. 😂
You nail 95 theses on someone's door ONE TIME and a whole group of people dislikes you. In all seriousness, I'm a Lutheran and got a big laugh when Bourbon said "Not Martin Luther King, just Martin Luther" and Aaron said "Oh the bad one." Keep up the hilarious comments fellas.
Regarding the Manning cast, I think I can say for all Natelanders when we're on your side. For anyone who saw it, we got to see in real life what it's like to have rough crowd who just doesn't get it, and struggling within a poor set up and atmosphere. You were obviously dealing with 2 very literal guys who's sole focus was juggling between the 2 games. It's also their error to pan away from a magician while he's still talking! I will give you the same advice you gave Aaron recently. As awful as I'm sure as it was to be in that moment, these kind of moments will help shape and grow you as a comedian if you let it. You'll look back on it some day and say "I learned this from that moment", and "Here's how I'm going to move forward." You adjusted, you persevered, you finished. We are proud of you. Who knows, maybe even one day you will write a joke about it. Hey bear!
You’re not wrong for being frustrated and venting to us folks Nate! I know it’s hard for you to say this bc you are legitimately humble-but they definitely should do some research on their guests if they don’t already have a relationship with them. It’s lazy and careless to not do at least a little research. It is on them, and that’s clear to us. You did what you could with what they gave you! Let it roll off… you’re killing it left and right. This will be a tiny thing to you after a little time goes by!
There is nothing Nate will ever do that I will not be blown away by. My husband and I have been giant fans for so long now that every little thing he does we are so proud of and can’t wait to tell our friends and family and share in enjoying his work together.
Nate is such a nice guy! I think Nate was super analytical and understands his craft. Meaning environments that are conducive to letting his talents shine.I think SNL is so good at understanding their host and making their talent shine. I also really love the Manningcast so much, and Nate is right about the type of guests that would suit that format. I learned a lot from listening to Nate in this podcast about his business and how things work behind the scenes.
Seeing good ol Mic on the podcast really warms my heart. If he and Teale ever move to Nashville please please please add him as the 5th Nateland member.
Nate’s rant about a career in comedy had a lot of parallels to my own adventure as an independent country music artist - and I’m thankful for it this morning
No, and I’m so upset on his behalf. Nate is so meticulous with his work. So that set up and lack of prep must have been frustrating. But, more, Nate respects everyone. To have his father shown disrespect - his father, of all people- seems a deep wound.
I can really appreciate and agree with Nate about our memory capacity. It's very true. Can anyone remember exactly what they had for lunch yesterday or the day before? So go on with the good humor, the great jokes and funny stories even if they're the same ones. That's what any big time musicians or bands do when they tour as well. Tunes and words being all you artists have is just fantastic. Actually a friend really loved your comedy, Nate, and by catching your name from him, I started to become happy to hear you, and see your Dad and his talent as well.
Hey Nate!❤and all the gang! I think your honesty and humility are the key to success. Too many people don’t have either one. Stay genuine to yourself 😊.
Skip ahead to 1:23 if you want to get to the topic and skip the complaining… I’ve loved Nateland since the beginning but it’s getting a little taxing when life is so heavy already. It used to be more of a lighthearted escape, especially the first year. Now they lean on Dusty a lot for that (love him!) and it really shows when he’s gone.
I think its sweet how every Christmas question about putting gifts out, opening gifts, etc Nate reverts back to Santa. I feel like this is a protective move for any potential young listeners to preserve the magic and I love it
One more thing...Nate - YOUR podcast is very, very steamlined! It's perfect! Even the rare 'uncomfortable moments' come around and you all come back together. Everyone on your podcast is incredibly sincere. I've been watching Dusty Slay's podcast with Hannah and despite being short, they are also very streamlined. (Dusty, please make them longer and have Hannah do her comedy!!!). Anyway, you would think the Mannings would have a podcast that is more together... Go Nateland!!
I didn’t see Manningcast. But I have always noticed and admired when people ask about Mr Stephen Bargatze as magician, Nate always says he’s funny, he “murders” etc because for some reason people like to put down magicians even though a good one has a lot of skill. Nate always talks up his father, which is endearing. I can see how that got under his skin. I actually didn’t think it was a bad rant (like college for instance). Nate also mentioned there were things he should have done. With such a successful SNL appearance we can see the difference in production making a difference. It sounds to me it was doomed pretty much straight away. Glad Peyton apologized. He should have.
I just love you guys! A wonderful part of my week... And, Nate, I'd be happy to have a talk with this Manning boys - using my 'Mom voice' - just say the word! They'd definitely know who you are when I'm done! 😂😉
Nate's rant was great. Two things - One, everything Nate ranted about was justified, but also those things are what make the Manning cast so good. It"s chaotic, unscripted, and always awkward because of the delay or Payton being distracted by the game. Nate, as a viewer, your interview was as good as any other on the show. Two - Nate said, "Peg in a . . ." and Aaron chimed in, "cog in a wheel." the phrases are "trying to fit a square peg in a round hole" and "cog in a machine." You all are truly doing the lord's work 😅
Never watched a Manningcast, but did watch a little after this. The thing that gets me, which Nate alluded to, is their pre-scripted comments that they don’t even try to hide that they’re reading word for word. Very unnatural. It would be much better just being conversational. I’m always looking for a lesson when things don’t go my way- Nate seems to do this as well. I think this was a great lesson for this point in Nate’s career. Many comedians talk about they want to get the reputation of always saying “yes”, so that they’re at the top of everyone’s list. With Nate having this sudden boost with SNL, I’m sure he felt like he needed to seize the opportunity. This was a great way to realize that you need to examine if it’s a good fit, even if it’s something you really want to do. I really think there was no harm done publicly (although it may have felt that way initially), so give yourself some grace! Your fans love you and your honesty 💕 Hope you all have a Merry Christmas!
The manning cast wasn’t that bad. You kind of expect people to be awkward. That’s the hardest part to watch when they have other celebrities on. I feel like there isn’t much of a chance for success. You did good with what they gave you.
Hey folks and Merry Christmas! I had an experience similar to Nate today. I’m standing in line at Best Buy waiting to check out when I feel the presence of another human being extremely close to me. Before I can turn my head I hear “you moved up in line already”. I turn my head to see a middle aged man speaking to me from about an inch away. As I turn my head we lock eyes and he says, “you’re not my daughter”. I too am a middle aged man with short hair and a beard. I notice his daughter is clearly in her teens with long blonde hair and no beard as he walks to her behind me in line. Questions are, who should be more offended and is her name Olivia too?
I like how theres this controversy about Nate/his dad on the Manningcast and no one is addressing the fact that 95% of what Eli says is indecipherable.
Just want to say that one of the highlights of my Christmas this year was getting a pair of tickets to your Orlando show in February! If any of you fellas every want to spend an extra day or two in Florida and want to go fishing, please hit me up! Would love to spend a day talking comedy and fish...as the past editor of Marlin magazine (25 years) and host of Florida Insider Fishing Report I've got quite a few stories! Including some about grwoing up in Wartrace, Tennessee! Thanks for all that you guys do! Merry Christmas.
I watched the MNF not knowing you were a guest and was so excited to see you! It didn’t seem like it went well, and I was livid when it was over haha I was so mad at the manning brothers in your defense. I don’t know yall, and yall don’t know me, but listening to this podcast for so long I feel like I do! Keep your head up man! You and your dad are awesome! Go Jackets!
Your true fans can quote from Full Time Magic!! 😂😂 I was upset, too, when they cut your dad's magic off!! You did great considering the circumstances!! Keep up the great work!! See you again real soon!!
I’ve almost completely switched to Great American Family…… LOVE these Hallmark movies during Christmas! Family friendly and easy to watch. Always a happy ending. ❤
Totally appreciate your honesty and critique of your experience on the Manningcast. Great lesson for other comics and shows your professional attitude to do your best. Now let it go.....you have MULTIMILLIONs of views of Washington's Dream skit on SNL!!! Judy
I KNEW I liked Nate's wife, Laura!! Nate said her birthday was December 20 and mine was just the day before that, December 19! (A few years different... ;) ) Not sure whether Laura is familiar with horoscopes, but ours is Sagittarius which is a fire sign. That explains how she manages to keep the Bargatze household in line! And not to mention being GORGEOUS!!! A very happy belated birthday, Laura! We bought tickets to see Nate in Everett, WA on January 27 and we're only twelve rows from the stage!!! Merry Christmas to you all!!
My in-laws have a Christmas tradition where they secretly assign each person in the family a code name on their presents. The names are usually selected based on a movie or tv show they all loved throughout the year. So my wife’s presents would have “To: Pam,” her brother would have “To: Dwight,” and so on. The tradition is for the kids to guess which gifts are for them based on the characters on the presents. This year, the code names are going to be stand up comics! “Nate” and “Dusty” will for sure be under the tree - Aaron and Bell-Jingles are a maybe
Love Mic N. and Nick B. on this podcast !!! Even Nate trying/struggling from podcast to podcast to pronounce the viewers last names is just laugh for me every pod i listen to..... Merry Christmas brothers, love ya All
Nate definitely didn't need the disclaimer at the beginning. His "venting" was totally understandable and kind. He didn't call the Mannings or ESPN into question, just the format and it's very obvious weak points. Nate's such a class act that I guess he felt guilty and felt an apology was necessary. He'll always be my favorite comic!
Growing up in Arkansas people would commonly refer to pecan pie as Karo nut pie. Never making a pecan pie myself, I had no idea what Karo syrup was or that it was a main ingredient in a pecan pie. When I was in college, when visiting a friend and his family back home, his mom asked us to go in the yard and fill a bucket with pecans for the tree in their yard to make a pie. I came in later with a bucket full of pecans and said “Gotta bunch of Karo nuts for you.” For 20 years I called pecans “Karo nuts” and never once did anyone correct me, until that day! Even now, at 33 years old, I still make that mistake and have to give my “pecan pie, Karo nut pie” explanation.
Thanks to Nateland and Nic, I could recognize the dumbest "Christmas song" playing at the chiropractor. I am curious as to why Nic enjoys "Santa Tell Me" so much. I am finding myself having more and more Nateland connections to my every day life, and I don't know if that's a healthy thing or not. 😂
Everyone completely glossed over the fact that Aaron casually said he's never seen Home Alone. I'm a huge The Shawshank Redemption fan. But Aaron never seeing Home Alone might be more egregious.
I am a bachelor living in an apartment. My holiday hack is I bought an inflatable tree, usually found as a lawn ornament. It makes me laugh everytime I inflate it and it packs away nicely!
Brian wondering why everyone didn’t rush to watch Game Day and the Manning show. Those are sports shows. Not everyone likes those. I’m lost when y’all start talking about who played for some college 10 years ago.
Growing up we didn't "play the Santa Claus game" as my mom put it. I imagined Santa on a chess board and was very confused why my friends played it. However, since we didn't have to wait for Santa, we were able to open Christmas presents after the Christmas Eve service. Although we didn't have Santa, "St. Nicholas" did bring us a stocking full of goodies on December 6th. I'll go proofread this now.
I was a fan from “yelled at by a clown” but If I say that no one believes. The reason is I sleep every night to some kind of comedy stand up so I start to learn about a lot of comics before the blow up.
Nate, if it makes you feel any better, I was on a podcast with 12 guests one time, and I was the only remote guest. Not only was there a delay, but the ONLY person with headphones other than me was the host. Every single bit of my banter fell on deaf ears. Nothing makes a guy look like a giant piece of crap more than teasing another guest and having everybody seemingly ignore it and move on over and over again. No recovering from that.
When I watched Manningcast I immediately thought of any person who has tried to engage in a conversation during a Superbowl when they were only there for the party. Big kudos for Nate to hang in there and roll with the punches.
Here's my thought, you were their guest. "Guest". When someone's a guest, whether in your home or on a podcast - you treat them as such. If you treat them with disregard, then it's on you. It definitely shows what kind of person they are. You guys always treat the guests on your podcast with respect and consideration. Your frustration over this situation is justified.
It's a real shame the Manningcast didn't know who they had with you being there. That's on them, not you. You're a whole lot more talented than they'll ever be. When they're old and nursing all their football injuries, you'll still be packing stadiums.
I can't describe to people what's in turtle candy bars because the top two things are pecans and caramel. I pronounce them like Nic and nobody likes it.
Presents from Santa being unwrapped seems like a more common tradition in the South. We were talking about this just last night at work. Christmas lights are socially legal any time after Halloween. Before Thanksgiving is early but legal.
I’ve always compared Thanksgiving as the holiday middle child. We go from Halloween straight into Christmas and poor Thanksgiving always gets overlooked…… I should also mention that I myself am a middle child.
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 76 | คู่เอก "ผึ้งหลวง vs สมิงดำ"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9SBshmGQOIM/mqdefault.jpg)
I know if fish bait reads this, Nate will roll his eyes, but I want to say thank you to Bates for all of the hard work he does for this podcast. This podcast brings so much joy to so many people every Wednesday and Bates has to read through all of our comments. we appreciate you! None of this is lost on us 😊
Alright, calm down
Thank you!
Breakfast for sure guides this show! :)
@@brianbatescomedyBrian you’re wonderful!!!!! 🫶
I love how Graham is part of the disclaimer. It's like he has Nate's back in case the Mannings barge in and want to fight Nate. Everyone needs a friend like that.
The best comment!
Nate may not have had a good week because of the Manningcast, but my week was made SO great when my husband and I got to meet him on Sunday at a local coffee restaurant. He could not have been nicer--and I appreciate it so much! Only thing that would've been better would be for Laura, Brian, Dusty and Aaron to have been with him. And Harper! We're even bigger fans now. I didn't say it well that day--THANK YOU Nate, for the great entertainment you provide for our family and so many others. And I think I remember every funny story you've ever told. 1:07:50
Nate saying "I just can't let things go" when talking about the possible dinner with Eli is so relatable. This is what makes his comedy so good, its relatable to everyone.
And remember the Mannings are athletes, not entertainers
We understood the delay was happening. We just rolled with it. We love you and your dad so much and we knew you would explain what happened. We’re the Nateland family of course you can vent to us.
Well said. I couldn't agree more.
What was the issue with the manning cast?
Loved seeing Aaron rustle around in his hoodie pocket and the next shot is of him eating the Milky Way.
Mood
found the time
2:03:42 - 2:04:27 , this whole sequence
Aaron saying “God forbid we have a little holiday spirit” about Christmas lights in November immediately after revealing he doesn’t even have a tree is gold.
Nic has such a beautiful smile and such a contagious laugh!!! ❤ Love listening to him - funny, intelligent, and articulate!!! ❤ I always miss when Dusty isn’t there, but Nic is fun!!!
I'll be honest with you, that "rant" Nate apologized for had softer tones and opinions than his discussion of an emu with a gun. Classy move to add a disclaimer, but, honestly, Nate's points were valid! Love the show, keep up the good work, fellas. Merry Christmas!
No part of the Manning Cast was Nate's fault. We love you Nate (and your dad).
I’ve heard other ppl say that they don’t expect the Mannings to research them before going on their show, I think it’s so silly to give them passes just because who they are. Part of their job is to interview ppl so they need to be prepared for their job, that’d be like if they went out on the field without ever looking at the playbook. After hearing Nate’s experience I don’t think Mark or any other of those ppl were bad guests, I think the Mannings are just bad hosts
The Mannings clearly don’t have someone like Nate telling them what’s wrong with their show. I watch a lot and the delay is very annoying. They are constantly switching between interviews and the game so you don’t really get to enjoy either. It needs to just be the manning brothers and no guests. Just them 2 talking ball.
I think it would fall more to the producers and directors of the show than the Mannings. The Mannings are guys who understand football at the highest level and trying to provide insight to viewers at home. 2 games were happening live. It’s just not a great time to be interviewing a comic or doing magic tricks. I think it’s just more of a problem with the atmosphere and direction of the show than any specific people.
@@jordanmadden7388 That’s fair, I agree with the other guy who commented that said they should just keep the show between the Mannings and other players/their friends. I recognize what the Mannings bring to the table for their show but if you hear any of the great interviewers they say it is important to know your guests to bring the best out of them, have the best interview product or you run the risk of making your guest feel the way Nate did afterwards, although they should have a research team that would be for nothing if the Mannings didn’t take the time to familiarize themselves with Nate’s background
My husband started yelling for me to hurry to come see the Manning cast because you were on it and he knows how much our entire family loves you! You were great! I love how frustrated you were on the pod, it shows how important family is! Glad you left it in!
Also neat that Mick 😉was on this pod. I had just been listening to old episodes that he was on. 😂
I hate when dusty is not there😢
same
I love Dusty. The four of them have such great chemistry.
Yeah why can't we have the BAND and Nic. ❤
@@jond661so you’re saying BANND?
same.
You nail 95 theses on someone's door ONE TIME and a whole group of people dislikes you. In all seriousness, I'm a Lutheran and got a big laugh when Bourbon said "Not Martin Luther King, just Martin Luther" and Aaron said "Oh the bad one." Keep up the hilarious comments fellas.
I love Nate apologizing for going off and telling his fans not to take things too seriously…classic
Regarding the Manning cast, I think I can say for all Natelanders when we're on your side. For anyone who saw it, we got to see in real life what it's like to have rough crowd who just doesn't get it, and struggling within a poor set up and atmosphere. You were obviously dealing with 2 very literal guys who's sole focus was juggling between the 2 games. It's also their error to pan away from a magician while he's still talking!
I will give you the same advice you gave Aaron recently. As awful as I'm sure as it was to be in that moment, these kind of moments will help shape and grow you as a comedian if you let it. You'll look back on it some day and say "I learned this from that moment", and "Here's how I'm going to move forward." You adjusted, you persevered, you finished. We are proud of you. Who knows, maybe even one day you will write a joke about it.
Hey bear!
I want a Bates CD and Weber poster for Christmas!
Me too!!!!
Link?
You’re not wrong for being frustrated and venting to us folks Nate! I know it’s hard for you to say this bc you are legitimately humble-but they definitely should do some research on their guests if they don’t already have a relationship with them. It’s lazy and careless to not do at least a little research. It is on them, and that’s clear to us. You did what you could with what they gave you! Let it roll off… you’re killing it left and right. This will be a tiny thing to you after a little time goes by!
The joke Nate did that was taken like a serious question, was the cold turtle joke all over again
Should’ve hit the Manning’s with the Dusty “we’re having a good time 👋 “
If Nate raged can you even imagine how Dusty would have lost it? Dusty will leave your house if you even say “get ‘em”
Nate shaming Nic for saying pecan different is hilarious when he pronounces Reese’s pieces - REESEES PEESEES
Well, most people do, so. Just makes sense as he is the greatest average American.
Thank you guys for creating the funniest and most wholesome podcast in the game, Merry Christmas and Happy Festivus Dusty
There is nothing Nate will ever do that I will not be blown away by. My husband and I have been giant fans for so long now that every little thing he does we are so proud of and can’t wait to tell our friends and family and share in enjoying his work together.
Nate is such a nice guy! I think Nate was super analytical and understands his craft. Meaning environments that are conducive to letting his talents shine.I think SNL is so good at understanding their host and making their talent shine. I also really love the Manningcast so much, and Nate is right about the type of guests that would suit that format. I learned a lot from listening to Nate in this podcast about his business and how things work behind the scenes.
Stoked to hear Balto is coming to tulsa in January! I immediately paused it and went and bought tickets.
Aaron not seeing Home Alone has to be revisited! That is more of a travesty than Nate not seeing Shawshank Redemption.
Seeing good ol Mic on the podcast really warms my heart. If he and Teale ever move to Nashville please please please add him as the 5th Nateland member.
29:11 - BlackMagic Bates over here tryin to end Will Levis career with some voodoo.😅
*Boodoo Bates
@@SnarfMonkey lol, there it is.
Bodacious sounding like a super supportive girlfriend when Nate is venting about the Manning cast is what I strive to reach in my relationship.
Mick is always one of my favorite guests. Tough to choose between him and Greg Warren, both so incredible ❤
Catching up on old episodes while keeping up with the new is surprisingly easy with this pod. Thanks for making a timeless listen!
Nate’s rant about a career in comedy had a lot of parallels to my own adventure as an independent country music artist - and I’m thankful for it this morning
I’ve never seen Nate so bothered by something.
Compared to traveling with Brian I thought Nate was tame 🤣
Makes you wonder if he’s a closeted road rager…I bet it’s just hilarious.😂…not that there’s anything wrong with that.
Have you watched every episode? He gets hot and bothered by nearly every mundane subject.
No, and I’m so upset on his behalf. Nate is so meticulous with his work. So that set up and lack of prep must have been frustrating. But, more, Nate respects everyone. To have his father shown disrespect - his father, of all people- seems a deep wound.
Let’s listen to Nate talk for 120 minutes straight
OK, I get that it might have been a little awkward, but Nate getting Peyton to talk about butt cheeks for a minute straight is comedy gold.
Loving that Nate is so real about things. He doesn't let anyone rule him. We adore that in all of you!
I can really appreciate and agree with Nate about our memory capacity. It's very true. Can anyone remember exactly what they had for lunch yesterday or the day before? So go on with the good humor, the great jokes and funny stories even if they're the same ones. That's what any big time musicians or bands do when they tour as well. Tunes and words being all you artists have is just fantastic. Actually a friend really loved your comedy, Nate, and by catching your name from him, I started to become happy to hear you, and see your Dad and his talent as well.
Hey Nate!❤and all the gang! I think your honesty and humility are the key to success. Too many people don’t have either one. Stay genuine to yourself 😊.
All of us know we can pick on our family members but don’t you dare…and that goes for our Nateland family too! ❤️
This one was more of a NateRant podcast, and i loved every second of it. Keep up the good work, guys.
Happy Birthday Laura ❤🎉 we love you!
Skip ahead to 1:23 if you want to get to the topic and skip the complaining… I’ve loved Nateland since the beginning but it’s getting a little taxing when life is so heavy already. It used to be more of a lighthearted escape, especially the first year. Now they lean on Dusty a lot for that (love him!) and it really shows when he’s gone.
I think its sweet how every Christmas question about putting gifts out, opening gifts, etc Nate reverts back to Santa. I feel like this is a protective move for any potential young listeners to preserve the magic and I love it
OMG i picked up on this as well, Nick was asking Nate about his dad playing santa at christmast, And Nate just kind of blew it off!
I'm glad Peyton Manning apologized. It was all pretty confusing. We love you and your dad!
Where can I find the apology? Thank you!
At the beginning of Nate's show.
@@user-sb7pw2ji2f
Keep your head up Nate. I'm sure your career will take off one of these days!
One more thing...Nate - YOUR podcast is very, very steamlined! It's perfect! Even the rare 'uncomfortable moments' come around and you all come back together. Everyone on your podcast is incredibly sincere. I've been watching Dusty Slay's podcast with Hannah and despite being short, they are also very streamlined. (Dusty, please make them longer and have Hannah do her comedy!!!). Anyway, you would think the Mannings would have a podcast that is more together... Go Nateland!!
I didn’t see Manningcast. But I have always noticed and admired when people ask about Mr Stephen Bargatze as magician, Nate always says he’s funny, he “murders” etc because for some reason people like to put down magicians even though a good one has a lot of skill. Nate always talks up his father, which is endearing. I can see how that got under his skin. I actually didn’t think it was a bad rant (like college for instance). Nate also mentioned there were things he should have done. With such a successful SNL appearance we can see the difference in production making a difference. It sounds to me it was doomed pretty much straight away. Glad Peyton apologized. He should have.
When you cant have Dan Soder on the next best thing is Nick Novicki. They must be fraternal twins.
The next best thing? Are you out of your mind?
I just love you guys! A wonderful part of my week...
And, Nate, I'd be happy to have a talk with this Manning boys - using my 'Mom voice' - just say the word! They'd definitely know who you are when I'm done! 😂😉
Nate's rant was great. Two things - One, everything Nate ranted about was justified, but also those things are what make the Manning cast so good. It"s chaotic, unscripted, and always awkward because of the delay or Payton being distracted by the game. Nate, as a viewer, your interview was as good as any other on the show.
Two - Nate said, "Peg in a . . ." and Aaron chimed in, "cog in a wheel."
the phrases are "trying to fit a square peg in a round hole" and "cog in a machine."
You all are truly doing the lord's work 😅
Hey Aaron -Michgander here. MSU is an agricultural school so it makes sense they would study Christmas trees.
Christmas Spirit.... Bah Humbug.
Nate being the only person in the room attempting to protect the idea of Santa and literally no one else picking up on it is PAINFUL
I was cracking up!!! “Cause I mean your sister was telling me that your dad would like…. Lights and everything…”
Never watched a Manningcast, but did watch a little after this. The thing that gets me, which Nate alluded to, is their pre-scripted comments that they don’t even try to hide that they’re reading word for word. Very unnatural. It would be much better just being conversational.
I’m always looking for a lesson when things don’t go my way- Nate seems to do this as well. I think this was a great lesson for this point in Nate’s career. Many comedians talk about they want to get the reputation of always saying “yes”, so that they’re at the top of everyone’s list. With Nate having this sudden boost with SNL, I’m sure he felt like he needed to seize the opportunity. This was a great way to realize that you need to examine if it’s a good fit, even if it’s something you really want to do. I really think there was no harm done publicly (although it may have felt that way initially), so give yourself some grace! Your fans love you and your honesty 💕 Hope you all have a Merry Christmas!
The manning cast wasn’t that bad. You kind of expect people to be awkward. That’s the hardest part to watch when they have other celebrities on. I feel like there isn’t much of a chance for success. You did good with what they gave you.
I think this one should be retitled “Nate Rants” 😂
Hey folks and Merry Christmas!
I had an experience similar to Nate today. I’m standing in line at Best Buy waiting to check out when I feel the presence of another human being extremely close to me. Before I can turn my head I hear “you moved up in line already”. I turn my head to see a middle aged man speaking to me from about an inch away. As I turn my head we lock eyes and he says, “you’re not my daughter”. I too am a middle aged man with short hair and a beard. I notice his daughter is clearly in her teens with long blonde hair and no beard as he walks to her behind me in line. Questions are, who should be more offended and is her name Olivia too?
Merry Christmas everyone and to all a Happy New Year!
The beginning seemed so serious like someone got cancelled, pretty much nothing happened lol
I like how theres this controversy about Nate/his dad on the Manningcast and no one is addressing the fact that 95% of what Eli says is indecipherable.
I'll Be Home for Christmas was written from the standpoint of a soldier during WW2.
Bing Crosby sang White Christmas in the movie. World War Two was raging everywhere and he was singing for the troops 🎄🎅🤶😂
Best line: “They got food at the club! They got chicken fingers . . . Everything you need to watch a show. “
Just want to say that one of the highlights of my Christmas this year was getting a pair of tickets to your Orlando show in February! If any of you fellas every want to spend an extra day or two in Florida and want to go fishing, please hit me up! Would love to spend a day talking comedy and fish...as the past editor of Marlin magazine (25 years) and host of Florida Insider Fishing Report I've got quite a few stories! Including some about grwoing up in Wartrace, Tennessee! Thanks for all that you guys do! Merry Christmas.
I watched the MNF not knowing you were a guest and was so excited to see you! It didn’t seem like it went well, and I was livid when it was over haha I was so mad at the manning brothers in your defense. I don’t know yall, and yall don’t know me, but listening to this podcast for so long I feel like I do! Keep your head up man! You and your dad are awesome! Go Jackets!
Your true fans can quote from Full Time Magic!! 😂😂 I was upset, too, when they cut your dad's magic off!! You did great considering the circumstances!! Keep up the great work!! See you again real soon!!
I’ve almost completely switched to Great American Family…… LOVE these Hallmark movies during Christmas! Family friendly and easy to watch. Always a happy ending. ❤
I’m so sorry that Nate and his dad had such a poor experience. I know it’s only going to get better from here
You were genius Nate. They blew it! Your Dad rocks.
Totally appreciate your honesty and critique of your experience on the Manningcast. Great lesson for other comics and shows your professional attitude to do your best. Now let it go.....you have MULTIMILLIONs of views of Washington's Dream skit on SNL!!! Judy
I KNEW I liked Nate's wife, Laura!! Nate said her birthday was December 20 and mine was just the day before that, December 19! (A few years different... ;) ) Not sure whether Laura is familiar with horoscopes, but ours is Sagittarius which is a fire sign. That explains how she manages to keep the Bargatze household in line! And not to mention being GORGEOUS!!! A very happy belated birthday, Laura! We bought tickets to see Nate in Everett, WA on January 27 and we're only twelve rows from the stage!!! Merry Christmas to you all!!
My in-laws have a Christmas tradition where they secretly assign each person in the family a code name on their presents. The names are usually selected based on a movie or tv show they all loved throughout the year. So my wife’s presents would have “To: Pam,” her brother would have “To: Dwight,” and so on. The tradition is for the kids to guess which gifts are for them based on the characters on the presents. This year, the code names are going to be stand up comics! “Nate” and “Dusty” will for sure be under the tree - Aaron and Bell-Jingles are a maybe
Love Mic N. and Nick B. on this podcast !!! Even Nate trying/struggling from podcast to podcast to pronounce the viewers last names is just laugh for me every pod i listen to..... Merry Christmas brothers, love ya All
If you ever wondered what a producer does, listen to the first 20 minutes of this episode. ManningCast should hire Laura!
I miss when all the guys can’t be there but this is the best podcast ever, hilarious.
Nate definitely didn't need the disclaimer at the beginning. His "venting" was totally understandable and kind. He didn't call the Mannings or ESPN into question, just the format and it's very obvious weak points. Nate's such a class act that I guess he felt guilty and felt an apology was necessary. He'll always be my favorite comic!
Growing up in Arkansas people would commonly refer to pecan pie as Karo nut pie. Never making a pecan pie myself, I had no idea what Karo syrup was or that it was a main ingredient in a pecan pie.
When I was in college, when visiting a friend and his family back home, his mom asked us to go in the yard and fill a bucket with pecans for the tree in their yard to make a pie. I came in later with a bucket full of pecans and said “Gotta bunch of Karo nuts for you.”
For 20 years I called pecans “Karo nuts” and never once did anyone correct me, until that day! Even now, at 33 years old, I still make that mistake and have to give my “pecan pie, Karo nut pie” explanation.
You were annoyed and rightly so. They unintentionally screwed up your appearance. It’s on them, despite what you say
Thanks to Nateland and Nic, I could recognize the dumbest "Christmas song" playing at the chiropractor. I am curious as to why Nic enjoys "Santa Tell Me" so much. I am finding myself having more and more Nateland connections to my every day life, and I don't know if that's a healthy thing or not. 😂
Everyone completely glossed over the fact that Aaron casually said he's never seen Home Alone. I'm a huge The Shawshank Redemption fan. But Aaron never seeing Home Alone might be more egregious.
I am a bachelor living in an apartment. My holiday hack is I bought an inflatable tree, usually found as a lawn ornament. It makes me laugh everytime I inflate it and it packs away nicely!
Brian wondering why everyone didn’t rush to watch Game Day and the Manning show. Those are sports shows. Not everyone likes those. I’m lost when y’all start talking about who played for some college 10 years ago.
Badminton Burrito Bates doesn't get enough credit for keeping the show on the rails!!
Growing up we didn't "play the Santa Claus game" as my mom put it. I imagined Santa on a chess board and was very confused why my friends played it. However, since we didn't have to wait for Santa, we were able to open Christmas presents after the Christmas Eve service.
Although we didn't have Santa, "St. Nicholas" did bring us a stocking full of goodies on December 6th.
I'll go proofread this now.
I was a fan from “yelled at by a clown” but If I say that no one believes. The reason is I sleep every night to some kind of comedy stand up so I start to learn about a lot of comics before the blow up.
Nate, if it makes you feel any better, I was on a podcast with 12 guests one time, and I was the only remote guest. Not only was there a delay, but the ONLY person with headphones other than me was the host. Every single bit of my banter fell on deaf ears. Nothing makes a guy look like a giant piece of crap more than teasing another guest and having everybody seemingly ignore it and move on over and over again. No recovering from that.
"Last Christmas" - WHAM! is the greatest x-mas song ever!
When I watched Manningcast I immediately thought of any person who has tried to engage in a conversation during a Superbowl when they were only there for the party.
Big kudos for Nate to hang in there and roll with the punches.
Aaron going HARD on poor Brenda Lee...."This song sucks!" Easy killer, she's a legend! LOL!
I'd been looking forward to a Nic appearance and I got my Xmas present!!
Inside the park homerun off a walk, is the best joke... I will laugh at it every single time.
Here's my thought, you were their guest. "Guest". When someone's a guest, whether in your home or on a podcast - you treat them as such. If you treat them with disregard, then it's on you. It definitely shows what kind of person they are. You guys always treat the guests on your podcast with respect and consideration. Your frustration over this situation is justified.
It's a real shame the Manningcast didn't know who they had with you being there. That's on them, not you. You're a whole lot more talented than they'll ever be. When they're old and nursing all their football injuries, you'll still be packing stadiums.
I can't describe to people what's in turtle candy bars because the top two things are pecans and caramel. I pronounce them like Nic and nobody likes it.
Presents from Santa being unwrapped seems like a more common tradition in the South. We were talking about this just last night at work.
Christmas lights are socially legal any time after Halloween. Before Thanksgiving is early but legal.
Judd is obviously shorthand for "Juddathan"
I'll make it as weird as they want to make it!!! 😂😂 👏
At this point, I overthink "pecan" like Aaron does. I end up saying some hybrid-PEE-cawn or puh-CAN-like a lunatic.
Man I really thought Nate had a good honest perspective here. And on the bright side: just imagine the Mannings let Dusty on. Good night of livin
I’ve always compared Thanksgiving as the holiday middle child. We go from Halloween straight into Christmas and poor Thanksgiving always gets overlooked…… I should also mention that I myself am a middle child.
Anyone else listening to this and thinking Aaron is the biggest Scrooge ever! Thank you Brian for keeping everyone in the holiday spirit 🎄