I haven't watched the film yet, but I did read the book. I think this is a common thing in Hollywood, and especially in this era, but the ingles was in his early 20's, not his mid 40's, and Maria was barely out of grade school. I obscenity in the milk of thy casting.
i heard that the casting was chosing by the autor of the book (Hemingway) He sent a copy of his book to Ingrid Bergman , and wrote a note telling she'is Maria
I was totally just wondering the other day when it was that I started saying "yo lo cage en la leche" as an exclamation, and you just reminded me how long it has been since I read this book.
Aside from the fact that Hemingway wrote the Robert Jordan character with Cooper in mind, it would have been very hard to find a leading man in his early 20s who had the star power and screen presence that Cooper had. This role required the actor to be stoic, idealistic, reluctantly romantic, and adventurous. It was basically custom-made for him, even though he was older.
My grandmother saw this film in the theater in 1944 at Stephens College in Columbia, Missouri, when she was 19 years old. She wrote: "Mary, Betty and I went down to Hall and saw Gary Cooper and Ingrid Bergman in “For Whom the Bell Tolls” in technicolor. Magnificent is the word -- we dripped all over the place. Not Mary tho. Not out til 6:30. What a picture!!! I can’t put into words what happened to me when I sat there and saw and thought and experienced. I saw clearly the future -- my whole life, past and present and future. My destiny, I guess. I have only to face it now -- it’s all cleared up, all the questions are answered -- except one maybe and that will come later. It isn’t imagination -- it’s . I saw it and felt it." Movies change lives.
Wow. That's amazing. Thank you for sharing your grandmother's memory of seeing this film. This was only Gary Cooper's second film in color and his best-known film in color (and Ingrid Berman's first film in color), so I can just imagine how exciting it must have been for fans back then to see this film in Technicolor. Plus, the whole story is so epic.
Read the novel a few years ago. Loved it so much I eventually got Gary Cooper & Ingrid Bergman tattooed on my arm. I finally get to watch the film today.
Seems like any movie star or leading man you ever liked in the movies, they all seem to pale when compared to Gary Cooper. He really stood out in so many ways. When I was a young girl, I watched his movies and used to dream that there was really a man out there like that somewhere.
I agree wholeheartedly. More recent leading men like Harrison Ford and Kevin Costner have been compared to Gary Cooper, but they pale in comparison. Cooper had the complete package as a leading man. He had a timeless male beauty, a sincere face, a quiet charisma, and an amazing personal style. It's no surprise that he was considered the ideal American male during his time. Even other leading men of that era--like Clark Gable, Cary Grant, and Gregory Peck--didn't come close.
Some years back was in Southern Chile in a cab. Talking a bit with the driver mentioned that I had driven cab in America. His face kind of lit up and the first thing he said after confirming I was American was 'Gary Cooper!'. Very cool. That was then, of course...
An den Film erinnere ich mich nur unscharf, aber ich habe das Buch gelesen. Es hat mich sehr beeindruckt! Unsere erste weibliche Katze hieß deshalb auf meinen Wunsch hin Pilar, und auch meine jetzige Katze heißt Pilar.
Maznifico documento cinematográfico en estos años del siglo XXI, los actores son de otra galaxia son inrrepetibles es como un lujo para los mejores cinéfilos del universo, sencillamente 🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
So they didn't film in Spain. I love Spain and they could have filmed medieval Spanish towns without modern interruption ack then. It that would have blown people away, the beauty.
Let's not. Spain in 1936 was anything but woke. Hemingway also not so much. It is what it is. We can be observant of our modern culture and values in many way without sanding down timepieces that are exactly that. Flawed. Original.
I haven't watched the film yet, but I did read the book. I think this is a common thing in Hollywood, and especially in this era, but the ingles was in his early 20's, not his mid 40's, and Maria was barely out of grade school. I obscenity in the milk of thy casting.
i heard that the casting was chosing by the autor of the book (Hemingway) He sent a copy of his book to Ingrid Bergman , and wrote a note telling she'is Maria
That is possibility the funniest thing I have seen in writing all year, and true to the book! I salute thy unprintable humor!
I was totally just wondering the other day when it was that I started saying "yo lo cage en la leche" as an exclamation, and you just reminded me how long it has been since I read this book.
Aside from the fact that Hemingway wrote the Robert Jordan character with Cooper in mind, it would have been very hard to find a leading man in his early 20s who had the star power and screen presence that Cooper had. This role required the actor to be stoic, idealistic, reluctantly romantic, and adventurous. It was basically custom-made for him, even though he was older.
“Obscenity in the milk” I love it!!
My grandmother saw this film in the theater in 1944 at Stephens College in Columbia, Missouri, when she was 19 years old. She wrote: "Mary, Betty and I went down to Hall and saw Gary Cooper and Ingrid Bergman in “For Whom the Bell Tolls” in technicolor. Magnificent is the word -- we dripped all over the place. Not Mary tho. Not out til 6:30. What a picture!!! I can’t put into words what happened to me when I sat there and saw and thought and experienced. I saw clearly the future -- my whole life, past and present and future. My destiny, I guess. I have only to face it now -- it’s all cleared up, all the questions are answered -- except one maybe and that will come later. It isn’t imagination -- it’s . I saw it and felt it." Movies change lives.
ωραια !
Wow. That's amazing. Thank you for sharing your grandmother's memory of seeing this film. This was only Gary Cooper's second film in color and his best-known film in color (and Ingrid Berman's first film in color), so I can just imagine how exciting it must have been for fans back then to see this film in Technicolor. Plus, the whole story is so epic.
I am in India and I have searched everywhere to watch this movie. I have not found a good print yet. Plz suggest me if you know
Fantastic! That story is a movie in itself!
Gary Cooper had Grannie and the gals dripping
RIP Ernest Hemingway (July 21, 1899 - July 2, 1961), aged 61
RIP Gary Cooper (May 7, 1901 - May 13, 1961), aged 60
RIP Ingrid Bergman (August 29, 1915 - August 29, 1982), aged 67
RIP Akim Tamiroff (October 29, 1899 - September 17, 1972), aged 72
RIP Katina Paxinou (December 17, 1900 - February 22, 1973), aged 72
RIP Joseph Calleia (August 4, 1897 - October 31, 1975), aged 78
You will always be remembered as legends.
Just read the book and that's exactly how I pictured Pablo.
A great story, and a memorable movie. Gary Cooper was hard to beat.
Read the novel a few years ago. Loved it so much I eventually got Gary Cooper & Ingrid Bergman tattooed on my arm. I finally get to watch the film today.
Wait. You had characters tattooed onto your arm from a movie you never saw?
Tattoo was stupid. Just should have watched the movie.
Hay gente que no sabe dejar vivir a otros. I would love to have a tattoo of Gary Cooper 😍 but tattoos have always scared me.
Time marches on!
+cj james Take a look to the sky just before you die...
Max Cady it's the last time he will
@@chopvansuey shattered goal fills his soul with a ruthless cry
joe Redmond stranger now are his eyes to this misery and the silence so loud!
Crack of dawn, all is gone except the will to be
1943 people: fighting
Also 1943 people: making a film
Thank you! I'm a WWII buff and that is one of the best remarks I've heard about the era in awhile.
As opposed to now where we totally don't make movies during war....
old but gold
I just finished reading the book. I have a criticism here and there, but I really liked it. Amazing.
The one and only Katina Paxinou!!!
She was great in this stole the whole show!
my best character in the book el sordo.
WHAT?!?
I felt like I was waiting for the trailer to start the whole time and then it ended..
Ingrid Bergman was a true women of style
Seems like any movie star or leading man you ever liked in the movies, they all seem to pale when compared to Gary Cooper. He really stood out in so many ways. When I was a young girl, I watched his movies and used to dream that there was really a man out there like that somewhere.
I agree wholeheartedly. More recent leading men like Harrison Ford and Kevin Costner have been compared to Gary Cooper, but they pale in comparison. Cooper had the complete package as a leading man. He had a timeless male beauty, a sincere face, a quiet charisma, and an amazing personal style. It's no surprise that he was considered the ideal American male during his time. Even other leading men of that era--like Clark Gable, Cary Grant, and Gregory Peck--didn't come close.
@@avocate2017 Beg to differ.
@@avocate2017 I totally agree with your comment. None can beat Coop.
Some years back was in Southern Chile in a cab. Talking a bit with the driver mentioned that I had driven cab in America. His face kind of lit up and the first thing he said after confirming I was American was 'Gary Cooper!'. Very cool.
That was then, of course...
The BBC did a T.V series of this in the 60s, but it has been lost to the world...pity!
An den Film erinnere ich mich nur unscharf, aber ich habe das Buch gelesen. Es hat mich sehr beeindruckt! Unsere erste weibliche Katze hieß deshalb auf meinen Wunsch hin Pilar, und auch meine jetzige Katze heißt Pilar.
Maznifico documento cinematográfico en estos años del siglo XXI, los actores son de otra galaxia son inrrepetibles es como un lujo para los mejores cinéfilos del universo, sencillamente 🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
obscenity in thy milk
I always thought of Pilar like one of the women in Gauguin’s paintings, i mean heavy/big .
Very Good Ernest Heminwey
La película acredita tener un subtitulado, no doblado, más completo que incluya los diálogos entre oficialesa alemanes.
Vale la pena hacerlo.
Read the book
Śmierć każdego człowieka umniejsza mnie, albowiem jestem zespolony z ludzkością. Przeto nigdy nie pytaj, komu bije dzwon: bije on tobie.
i believe pablo still living somewhere in the hills
Yeah it may be
oh yes i find one last year
Viejo querido
"For a hill men would kill, why? They do not know."
So they didn't film in Spain. I love Spain and they could have filmed medieval Spanish towns without modern interruption ack then. It that would have blown people away, the beauty.
AS PILAR - KATINA PAXINOU (GREEK ACTRESS) WON THE ONLY OSCAR FOR THIS FIRM AND A GOLDEN GLOBAL AWARD
Kiitos
John McCain...Rest In Peace!
Peliculas viejas y pierdo la cabeza
Kênh này có ai dịch sang tiếng việt thì tuyệt vời và gởi lời chúc thành công và hạnh phúc
got dvd chapter 1 blank screen and chapter 11 half missing. talk about being pissed off with a new dvd.
Are you sure that’s not the long blank intro and intermission?
Igual Kevin Kostner, Gary Cooper
This was only film great dilip kumar saw before making his film debut as he mentioned in an interview.
"I don't provoke"
what the hell? this aint metallica
Viva la República.
A tough book to try and read. No wonder no wonder it's not taught anymore. Pure hokum. Did the earth move?
reading the book at 5he minute very good just on ch 5
Russians, Armenian, Swede and Greek play Spanish, am I the only one who doesn't understand the cast choice?
+Настя Грекова Hemingway's choices. The writer has that right.
+Настя Грекова Yes, you're the ONLY one.
You forgot the mexican.
Since i saw "Touch Of Evil" with Charlton Heston playing a Mexican, nothing can surpise me.
I think that's why they're called actors......
not a single rabbit in the whole filim spoken by don roberto ... except those caught by the gypsy!
That is the song from Metallica
Metallica!
REALLITY HURTS RIGHT>>>???????
Oh el sordo..
I’m confused, where’s Brad Pitt or Hopkins
Ingrid Bergman was out of place in this film.
O It was a great movie but that is without a doubt one of the worst trailers I have ever seen.
Metallica
Dear Lord... the casting in those days... we need just a touch of "woke" here and we need a remake! (Just finished the book.)
Let's not. Spain in 1936 was anything but woke. Hemingway also not so much. It is what it is. We can be observant of our modern culture and values in many way without sanding down timepieces that are exactly that. Flawed. Original.
Can we not just make a movie from 1943 into a culture war thing