Producer Reacts to Twice "Yes or Yes"
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 พ.ย. 2018
- In this episode the Producer checks out the "Yes or Yes" MV from Twice!
Help support Form of Therapy by subscribing to us on Patreon! / formoftherapy
Subscribe to Form of Therapy for more future Reaction videos & let us know in the comments down below what else you'd like to see!
#TWICE #YES_OR_YES #트와이스
Follow us & stay up to date
Facebook: / formoftherapy
Twitter: / formoftherapy
Instagram: / formoftherapy
Follow the cast
@formoftherapy
YES I FORGOT ABOUT DANCE THE NIGHT AWAY. IM SORRY FORGIVE ME
@VOTE LOOΠΔ for ROTY Doesn't BDZ also start with the chorus? Or are we not including Japanese songs? haha
Are you gonna react to mono??
Not Iconic 😆😂😂😂
Form of Therapy never
Haha I always wondered if you and reacttothek knew each other
I think Twice are maturing without wildly changing their concept which i love. They're becoming less cute and catchy but more fun and earnest but still catchy. I love the change.
ay same
Yes that is exactly what I was saying...this is a more mature type of song...like it's somewhat still cute but more mature
Still cute tho
Young and Wild is a perfect example
Yes that is true
The words which you missed are "Jeongyeon has lines".
yassss lead vocalist risesssss. 😭💛
VOTE LOOΠΔ for ROTY Mina often has a nice amount of lines though?
@VOTE LOOΠΔ for ROTY she's been having lines since forever wdym
VOTE LOOΠΔ for ROTY vote for Loona as female rookie at the year!
@@kangseulgiisseulgibear1593 hey this is a Twice reaction dont promote here and Im not being butthurt but I just want you to promote somewhere else thank
I feel like Twice really has improved.
It's because they did.
Why is there a comment from 12 hrs ago? Wtf this vid is like just an hour ago! I’m confused 😐
lol what, this comment was made 13 hrs ago, wtf youtube 😂😂
@@timmytrumpet8783 they're probably a patron that gets early access to videos
Yes, especially with the choreography
It seems like Twice is getting to the point in their careers where they’re finally finding what people want and finding their best strengths to give their upmost best. They’re improving daily and it works very well from them
Yeah. They used to do easy dances and then they realised people enjoyed their harder choreos. They used to talk sing but now they deliver impactful vocals. Every song is better than the last.
They're new choreography is hard, but I like how when they sing the title of the cheoreo the dance is a little simplier. Like if we cant dance to the rest of it, we can at least do the hand movements. 👌🏾
Everyone telling twice to switch up the concept, but when they finally do with this song fans are disappointed because its "not catchy" and that really annoys me because this one of twice's best title tracks
This is mainly because fans liked twice originally for the cutesy concept. But many non fans (general people) would like to see something different compared to what ever most gg does these days. This song definitely has more depth than other twice songs tho.
I agree, I like the direction twice is going for if they continue with what they did with yes or yes. For me it's their best title track, and I like how different it is from their other songs.
uwu boi This is the best tittle track of Twice so far. I can actually see their growth in this comeback: Twice still keeps their cutesy concept to some extend but it is totally different. I got goosebumps and almost cried at my first time watching the MV because I was shocked by how good the song, the choreography, and the video are. This comeback is on another level in comparison to other ones.
This song is catchy af my friend cant stop saying "yes or yes"
it really is..same with dance the night away.that song made me actually like twice
I love how he forgets about DTNA but then brings up summer nights then forgets about DTNA again 💀
Let's dance the memory away!
I also really appreciate how dynamic the choreography is and how it's different from their other title tracks. Like it's not as cutesy and it showcases their dancing more.
Lionheart18 exactly! Like all their dances are easy enough for fans to easily do but I feel like they went away from that route this comeback.
Rock Solid It’s definitely their most exhausting choreography alongside Dance the Night Away and Heart Shaker’s.
What really comes off from this song, is the confidence they portray. The lyrics have a confident woman taking charge, the dance is really energetic and overall, it feels like they aren't so much hiding behind their image, but showing off their strengths. They feel genuine here, more so than in their earlier stuff. Nothing wrong with the cutesy stuff, and they aren't abandoning it, but I like how since WIL they seem to be growing as artists, and not being pigeon-holed, instead showing off their different attributes and styles. Definitely one of their best title tracks.
This. Absolutely. The lyric takes confidence to deliver, not being coy, sexy, or coquettish. The girls got the tone, facial expression, and body language (including choreo) right with individuality coming from each member.
Agreed. It isn't so cookie cutter. 'I am pretty girl why dont you love me!!'
I get what you mean about the lyrics, but idk I kinda felt it a bit ......rapey? Like “yes or yes” or
“I respect your decision but reject your rejection “. Mind you I LOVE this song, but I got some major FATE Kiyo-Hime yandere vibes from it XD
@@joseangeles8382 I think that interpretation is just silly, and totally removed from context. It's false virtue signaling. I guess it's just the thing nowadays, to get offended on someone's behalf, just in case, or to make oneself seem somehow superior.
When you look look at what is actually being said in the song, the meaning is pretty clear. It's about confidence and self-worth, the narrator is stating "I know you'll come around, because I'm awesome." In the narrator's view there is no need to force any of this, because they are confident in the outcome. That's why she feels at ease rejecting the potential rejection. She wants him to arrive at the same conclusion she has already come to.
Chauncer I guess so , yeah. I guess the immediate vibe was very “you have no choice” yknow? I thought that if a boy group came up with a song like this, it would be received totally different. For them it’s kinda like “oh they’re cute girls so it’s ok ^_^” Mind you, I wasn’t all “omgawd it’s a song about sexual assault “ I just got yandere vibes from the whole creepy stare into the camera and some of the lyrics. The song is about confidence, but every reaction video that I have seen , everybody was commenting (I’m pretty sure in a joking way) “oh we don’t have a choice”
Honestly it bought me back to their debut! The outfits (especially in that first dance scene w Tzuyu in the middle!) and then the breakdown really reminded me of ‘let me see how you gon’ treat me!’
It should! Because this is another one of their color pop concept that they used in LOA and they're the only one who can pull off such a concept.
What you heard in this song was GROWTH! :D
Twice both as artists and as a group are all flourishing as they gain more and more in experience.
You can hear this even more reflected in the entire Yes Or Yes mini-album and it's truly a joy to behold :]
I really wish Twice would utilize Dahyun and Chaeyoung's rapping abilities more in their title tracks but overall, I feel like this song is the best of the year for Twice the more I listen to it.
@ldc62 I disagree. No one in Twice is going to blow you away with their rap skills, that I will agree with, however Chaeyoung is a solid rapper when given the chance. You also have to remember this is a very cute group so none of the members are going to be on a level of higher end female rappers like Lisa, Jennie, Soyeon, CL, etc.
@ldc62 Chaeyoung says hi
They reserving it for the darker concept/girl crush concept🤗❤️
ldc62 Sixteen says hi
@ldc62 Watch SIXTEEN ;)
Chaeyoung is a phenomenal rapper, and Dahyun can also slay it.
It just hit me. The glass ball Nayeon held in a short frame in DTNA was referencing this comeback. Wow.
I just had like 89 heart attacks reading this
Fact Wisp here. Confirmed Glass Bead *cough* sorry i mean Glass Ball in DTNA MV at 4:06
Holy crap...didn't even think about it!! Spoiler Queen at her best....
Wow. Now i need to check on that again
@@user-sl1cz4pc4p dont die yet, we need more streamers ^^
As someone who likes Twice but doesn't stan them this was my favourite title track they've put out. It does seem more mature but not to the extent that they're pretending to be something they're not. I really enjoyed this, what a great comeback - congrats Twice and Onces!
Thank you so much! Btw you should listen to the whole YES OR YES album, it has really really great songs. My favourites are Say you love me and Young and Wild.
Have a nice day
Or if you're more into ballads i reccomended you TWICE's Be as One, After moon, Melting and One in a million!
@@kurotoshiro1490 Thanks, I think I will check out their album :)
Thank you uwu btw TWICE is coming back this April so please anticipate ^.^ have a nice day
@@kidcaptainwembri so what did you think?
TWICE has really grown as a group, I’m so proud of them and hope they continue to do amazing
Yes, the girls are truly amazing and you can see they are a GROUP, that they work together and care about each other. Besides they are very talented, i really like Nayeon's voice💕
it’s so interesting that PD loved heart shaker and love bomb so much bc the same guy also did yes or yes
really? They are all bops
the singing from the heart songs😭
GOD i understand your idea about "singing from the heart", I thought I'm the only one who thinks like that! They sang the chorus ernestly, it has "melancholic" vibe in it! It makes me kinda melancholic when hearing...
Me too. Yes or yes is definitely one of my favourite songs from Twice. I like how they are improving both in singing and dancing every comeback. And I also really liked the camerawork at the end of the MV and extended chorus.
Me too! The extended chorus surprised me and i loved it! Now i'm looking forward to TWICE new comeback this april hehe
Heart Shaker is my favourite TWICE song too, mostly because of its chorus. In terms of song structure, I think David Amber has a good feel for how to build up to hard-hitting choruses better than most. That's the main similarity I see between Yes or Yes and Heart Shaker. That and the fact that he apparently likes giving a surrealist feel to his cinematography through his camera movements and angles.
Structurally, this song is definitely weirder than most of the other TWICE songs - it kind of feels almost like a revolving door of interesting musical styles, in the same way that SNSD's I Got a Boy was. When I first heard YoY, my first impression was actually that it kind of felt more like a Red Velvet song (in the same vein as Power Up, Red Flavor or Russian Roulette). But I found myself liking it on repeat a lot - it definitely grows on you quickly. Actually I found it becomes even more of an earworm if you listen to WITHOUT the music video. Great changeups in rhythm and driving beats throughout.
YES OR YES really surprised us all! And the songs from the whole YES OR YES album are so so great you should listen to them! My favourites are Say you love me and Young and Wild. Have a nice day!
Twice is love ❤,
“A followup to what is love?” did you forget about dance the night away? Lol
Edit: People saying dtna was their worst song...it’s actually my fave dance song so eh kinda breaks my heart but it’s called opinion
I think he did :
I FUCKING DID
Rudy Rooster I forget about it too
Can’t blame him 🤷🏽♂️
out of all twice songs, DTNA didn't blow me away like all the other title tracks but I don't hold it against them because it's hard to make catchy and a big hit each time ;-;
BUT it is still a good song and it still did make it to my playlist
I think what I liked best about this song was it had hints of "retro" vibes without going all out like a lot of current Kpop songs. A lot of songs right now are going for a 90s pop/R&B vibe when they go retro.... This song sounds more like early 2000s girl pop, but subtly.
I think that the girls are improving and there is some type of change in their style to. It has passed a lot of time since Momo used her real voice, I think since Like ooh-ahh, their debut, so you can see the change here.
If PD says it's good, it is definitely a bop
Every time Twice released a song: "this is definitely the most different song by Twice" i like that
I think it’s cause Twice style is slowly changing. And I get you on the “earnesty” part, I felt the same. The melody, flow and tone relate on a more personal way nowadays rather than simply having a catchy melody.
Yes or Yes is a masterpiece its so different yet has the TWICE feel to it it makes you happy but so hyped at the same time its amazing i love it im so thankful that im a once and i got to listen to such an amazing song
My dad literally loves this song and my mom hates it but sings it lol yes or yes is a certified bop
You should really listen to the whole album, it's so great! The way they delivered the songs, the beat, the HIGH QUALITY, i'm so impressed. Especially "Say you love me", "Young and Wild" and "After moon". Actually again the whole album. The six new songs are so great. Thank you!
Likey also starts with the chorus
Rui Miguel I think in this song the chorus is even extended after the first time
i think the bsides of this album are one of their best
Me mES Same I don’t really like their B sides usually but these ones are fucking great
David Amber same guy from Heartshaker and Love Bomb.
I instantly LOVED heart shaker, I overplayed it 82929x times when it first came out and I don't even consider myself a Once. That song is my fav fav fav twice song ever
I watch Form of Therapy for video commentary, ReacttotheK for the melody and notes commentary, Dream Yume Entertainment for the technicality of the music and KPOP Junkee for theories. Also watch Cody & Wyatt to fangirl with :)
My go-to reaction channels and for the same reason 👍
ReacttotheK doesn't really like Twice tho
@@owlperson5075 I don't think OP meant just Twice, but generally speaking.
Also watch Mika reaction
@@owlperson5075 I don't watch them for TWICE, but their commentary. That's why I watch Cody & Wyatt :)
Okay, I've listened to a very small part of their discography
Dance the Night Away - I've heard the Chorus too many times outside of the MV to not get annoyed by it (I'm sorry, I like the song as a whole but it's one of those songs with a chorus that mostly repeats a word or phrase and I hate those and that's unfortunately the part people always play 😟)
What is Love? - yo the artistry and the references. I love it.
BDZ album - I wasn't expecting it to be so good omg
Yes or Yes - *DIES FROM THE CONCEPT, THE MUSIC, THE VOCALS, THE OUTFITS, THE AESTHETIC, THE MAGIC, THE MOST PERFECT VIDEO, THE BOP* *revives to add TWICE to list of artists to stan* *dies again because of how overwhelmingly good this was*
.
.
.
Suffice to say that I quite liked this one and I'm happy that it's the first comeback of theirs that I've been here for.
If you let me i reccomended you this TWICE's songs:
-Say you love me
-Young and Wild
-After moon
-Wishing
-Be as one
Hope you enjoy them, have a nice day
@@kurotoshiro1490 honey I already have the entire BDZ album 😂
I'll look into the first three though! Thank you! :)
@@zephyrsblade7188 okey! Great albums hahah thank you
Also feel like the earnestly of the singing, especially the chorus n it moved me in some ways, the last time I feel this is “time for the moonlight” from gfriend earlier this year
I had no expectations for their comeback but I found myself singing to Yes or Yes! with them while watching the MV. The fact that it is different makes it refreshing and fun. I'm glad they did this.
The magic thing is hot in kpop, I love the card and eye tricks they used here. Twice can obviously captivate us, so it's a perfect trope. Yeah, that moving parade float was just another expensive effect, adding up to another great video. :) Thanks!
For real! This is probably my third favorite comeback! (Right after What Is Love and Heart Shaker) I could FEEL the emotions that they poured into the song
This is the first time I have liked a twice title track right off the bat since ooh ahh tbh.
Yes or Yes really reminds me of the golden era of AKB48. It's fun, catchy, energetic, and they come across as very.. approachable?(I can't think of the right word) Needless to say, I really like the song.
Wait love bomb? And Yes or Yes Same producer!!???
yeah love bomb, heartshaker, and yes or yes are produced by david amber
and also heart shaker, and HyoYeon's mystery
Is Sadness manager left then David Amber enter?
@@YDYUGI No, they don't have the same job. She wasn't involved at all in the songs.
So about David Amber, he composed the song with Andy Love and do the arrangement
@@L4in1998 oh is that so. thank you for the Info,.
listening party for this album too? their b-sides for this album are one of the best imo
Totally agree
*IM WAITING FOR THIS REACTION*
-❤ FROM THE PHILIPPINES
same haha, I'm also from philippines :)
Same
PD!!!! TWICE just dropped their new EP FANCY and I feel like you’d love it and the title track!! The album itself features chae and dahyun rapping so much omg
I'm actually smiling while watching the actual MV. This song is full of positive vibes
DIVING DEEPER FOR "Yes or Yes" Album please! ALL OF THE B-SIDES ARE SOOOOOO GOOD, I'm not even exaggerating. 🙏
I've just started studying media and film studies this year, and I am planning on working on the visual aspect of music videos. I absolutely LOVE your channel because your videos are about something I love (KPOP) but you also talk about the camera shots lighting etc. so it's almost like i'm studying but having fun at the same time 😊👌🏻
I live for yes or yes personally
It's really a change of style but still TWICE
Their style and imagine is there wish what I love about them having their identity and not changing just for the sake of it
Will you be doing a listening party to the whole album? :) I feel like you’ll LOVE Sunset
yeah and young and wild will rek him :D
OMG I LOVE SUNSET
After Moon is so good too
After Moon +1
Andre Ren Yes he should!
Yes PD you're right that Jeongyeon and Momo part is so good, kinda addicted to it
Jihyo really looks amazing with that short hair 💘❤😍
Finally!! I've been waiting for this reaction.. thank you soooo much for the upload ☺
WHOA! I'VE NEVER SEEN PD SMILE AND SCREAMED LIKE THAT SINCE HEARTSHAKER!!! 😍
Also the production team for this MV is Naive Creativr Production which made a lot of JYPE artists' MV throughout these past years. They always make a great MVs. I agree that David Amber has made such great bops for girlgroups that now he is on the same level of Black Eyed Pilseung (producers for Twice's title tracks including Likey and also Apink's new song). TWICE also worked with different producers for this mini album which i think Twice is experimenting different genres. That shows how they have improved a lot for 3 years and always working hard to deliver their best.
Favorite k-music review/react channel .... Love hearing your thoughts on the songs and MVs.
Yes or Yes is such a good song
his reaction to the beginning of the song was my reaction! I was shook
I have been waiting for this since yesterday.
YESSS I WAS WAITING FOR THIS
Yes I felt it too They changing their style each time comeback and this is getting mature I'm really into what is love and heart shaker too
I LOVED this TWICE title track! Can't get enough!
In my opinion, Twice is already great when they debut. And yes they are definitely improving over the years and their style starts changing from Likey. (And Likey is my favourate yet) They got lots of criticism in the era of Cheer Up and TT, saying their dance is too simple, they could not sing, their lyrics are meh blablabla. But if you followed some of their cover stages, you'll find their ability in singing and dancing is at least on the same level with other major girl groups. And they are able to handle sexy and girl crush concepts very well, especially sexy concept. I can understand JYPE wants to play things safe, so the the style change is coming very slow, but I'm fine with that. Twice is meant to give someone energy and smile after one day's tiring work.
Another thing is, if you try to learn their dances each time, their choreography is getting very difficult since What is Love! Anyone who tries will know what I'm saying.
this song just gets better and better the more you listen to it ugh
I was waiting for thisssss 👌🙏
The only reaction that matters to me the most 👌👀💞
tbh to me this feels like heartshaker! feels very genuine & sincere
The whole ep is bomb!! Sunset is my personal fave :)
I honestly think this is their best title track/comeback. I wasn’t a big fan, more casual and passive of a lot of their previous stuff but I really feel a lot more maturity and growth in this one. I’m looking forward to see what else they can really do. The fact that their changing for the better or changing at all when they’re already really big is a huge risk but they’re pulling it off well.
nayeon always makes the chorus so heartfelt 💛 i like heartshaker and yes or yes the most~
I waited for this... Thanks!
I was waiting for your reaction!
This is what ive been waiting for PD-nim. Love lots
Listen I'm not a twice stan and i admit they have some cute songs but this oneeee I'm Obsessed with!!! The chorus , choreo, melody ughhh I literally can't stop listening.
Listen to more B-sides
-Twicecoaster lane 2 special album
-Signal mini album (I know signal wasn't the best title song *BUT* the bsides for this album are some of the best)
Twicetagram(twice first full album)
And thats about it the first 2 mini albums are good too but idk if you'd like it as much
I love this comeback! So proud of Twice :)
This is my favourite TWICE song so far. It's just so different.
Since you've reacting to twice you earned new subscriber....once here 😁
I've been waiting for this.
Likey!!!! It started with the chorus!
It’s so amazing and different but I love it so much
I really love this come back :-) YES!
love how you smile watching the video 😀
Its not just you. I really felt they are transitioning to new concepts and its not a bad thing because they did it gradually. YES OR YES is the most different music style and choreo they had. I love TWICE and I am very happy to stumble in your channel which is very unbiased. You says the Yays and Nays in their music which is rare to other channels who are just reacting for the sake of reacting not even paying attention to details. Two thumbs up 👍👍
this is the best twice title track for me the chorus is such a blessing :')
Yes or yes is just suited well for them. It's still cute and catchy, yet the lines suit them more. Also the visuals and choreo shows maturity.
I think the eyes are hypnotizing you...making you think you actually have a choice but both answers are yes and yes. I think it's really clever.
I know this probably won't be seen but it's worth a shot- there's a new girl group debuting tomorrow called DreamNote (their title track is "Dream Note" and their single album is called "Dreamlike) and Dream Note was actually produced by the same person that did Heartshaker, Yes or Yes, Love Bomb etc. (David Amber) so you might really like it if you can do a reaction video on it!
Make me curious, I will see later.. I love David amber work.. I'm from Brazil
i love the chorus so much
So when I went to watch this my dad asked to join me bc he doesn't understand my kpop love and he had his jaw dropped the whole time and he literally said "wow I understand wow" and yeah... this was fucking incredible.
Likey also was a title track that started off with the chorus, and is imo also one of their strongest tracks
Woah I can't believe you, Kevin and Umu are friends haha cuz this channel and ReacttotheK are my 2 main go-to channels for Kpop reaction videos. I'm so happy to find out that you and Kevin have the same sentiment as mine cuz there's just something about Heartshaker and the title tracks after that, that I love. Been talking about it with some fellow Twice fans and they couldn't understand it. I also love every Twice title track after Heartshaker (but HS is still my fave haha)
The more I listen to this song the more i fall in love with the actual structure of it. It's so unique and well done.
I think this yes or yes comeback is the transition from the brightbubble gum pop like usual twice's tittle tracks to the more twice's mature style, followed by The Best Thing I Ever Did and future comebacks
gOD i love this song so much its probably the first twice title track i've liked this much (yes im a very passive twice listener dont attack me ugh) i love how different it is and i also love that theyre experimenting more with harder choreo ahhhh
One of the most different tracks and MVs. I am kinda sad that there are less Momo dance cuts, Dahyun/Chaeyoung rap chaining. Yet, for some reason, I am still drawn to it.
Because it's all balanced
@@iankee88 I wouldn't call that balanced. Momo's lack of lines is made up in her stage/dance presence, as with Dahyun and Chaeyoung with rapping (though both of them seem to be moving more towards singing).
my two favourite and only reactor channels wowowowow reacttothek and formoftherapy 💗
i love this song so much. they didnt let me down
KEVIN N U ARE RIGHT, OFF THE JUMP MY FAVORITE SONG WAS HEART SHAKER & THIS GIVES ME SUCH GOOD VIBES AND IS ON PAR WITH HEART SHAKER TO ME IN TERMS OF MY FAVORITE, THAT AAAA~ INTRO IS SO GOOD
I thought nothing would ever beat likey as my top comeback but goddamn yes or yes is just absolute perfection istg i cried ㅠㅠ ♡
Omg I also do watch the classical musicians! It’s amazing. I think I started watching before I watched form of therapy stuff
I completely agree with you. heart shaker is also my fav twice song. the song makes me emotional. the same happens with zoo by red velvet? makes me emotional too. the strange thing is that they're all happy songs...
it was definitely not bad. one of my favorite parts about twice is that when i dont like the title track as much (cheer up, dnta and now this) the bsides always make up for it. this album's bsides are pretty amazing.