Everything Wrong With Mamma Mia In 15 Minutes Or Less
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ต.ค. 2024
- With Mamma Mia 2 approaching quickly, we reluctantly decided to go looking for sins in the original Mamma Mia. We instantly regretted this decision.
Thursday: Typing sins.
Remember, no movie is without sin! Which movie's sins should we expose next?!
•CinemaSins website: www.cinemasins... •
•Channels•
--TVSins: / @tvsins
--MVS: / @musicvideosins
•Members get MORE! ALL videos early, bonus videos and podcasts, merch discounts and MORE on Patreon!• / cinemasins
•Merch!• teespring.com/...
•Podcasts•
-SinCast A weekly chat with Jeremy, Chris and Barrett about their love and hatred for movies and entertainment. cinemasins.lib...
--Behind the Sins: CinemaSins writers Aaron, Jonathan and Deneé, give a behind the scenes look at what it takes to release the previous week's videos across the CinemaSins brand. redcircle.com/...
•Writers Social•
Jeremy: / cinemasins
Chris: / sincastcinemasins
Barrett: / musicvideosins
Aaron: / aarondicer
Jonathan: / samloomis13
Deneé / deneesays
•Discord: Request on Facebook or Reddit!
•Reddit: / cinemasins
•Jeremy's Book: cinemasins.com...
Fun Fact about this film a lot of the 'extra's who you see dancing are actually locals who live on the Island and asked if they could join in. The people on the docks dancing were all locals living on the island originally not intended to be in the film!
That's not a fact
Yes it is... you clearly don't know what a fact is.
Wow now I feel like I am a outsider to this world as that someone would do that from my perspective is just ridiculous and pointless but I stand corrected I guess.
Jack™ i wish i was on of them :(
That's so cool!
You missed a sin. What kind of a daughter and her bestfriends would get so excited reading her mother's diary about sleeping with 3 different guys.
Callisto Emari Lawson I get the daughter being excited for learning about who her dad might be but her friends were wayyyyyy too into their friend’s mom’s sex life
You missed a sin. What kind of a daughter and her bestfriends would get so excited reading het mother's diary about sleeping with 3 different guys.
Uhhh... me
I would.
Have you been to america ???
sin counter - 0. this is a top-to-bottom perfect movie
buuuuuuuut seriously, a lot of these sins were accurate (pierce brosnan's singing voice deserved like 10) but even more of them weren't valid. you can't sin a musical for having music, or at most, you can only sin it once. anyone who goes to see mamma mia knows what they're getting into.
runandgo Just so you know, a lot of the sins are him joking. It took me a while to understand too.
Sin counter- 0 this is is a top- to- bottom perfect movie buuuuuuuut serious a lot of these sins were accuate (plerce brosnan's
Sin counter- 0. This is a top- to- bottom perfect movie buuuuuuuuut seriously. A lot of these sins were accurate ( pierce brosnan's singing voice deserved like 10) but even more of them weren't valid. You can't sin a musical for haven't music, or at most, you can only sin it once anyone who goes to see mamma Mia knows what they're getting into.
Pierce Brosnan singing deserved about 7 billion
Why do people hate his voice so much, it's one of the best in the movie
13:45 Sophie and Sky ended up not getting married so they gave the wedding to Donna and Sam. He was literally making a toast to his own wife dude 😂😂
Shannon Marie yup
Now see this is actually another thing that should be a sin I think, because it makes no sense that Donna and Sam can be married. Correct me if I'm wrong and maybe the laws are different in Greece but before you get married you need an actual marriage license from the city hall or something; the ceremony is just a ceremony but if you have the license before that you're technically already married. So really Sophie and Sky would be married already, and Donna and Sam's marriage wouldn't be official until they got a license. You don't get married just by having a priest say "I pronounce you man and wife." 😂
~:~
I came to the comments to just to check if anybody had mentioned this!!! Yes! True!
Natalie Harshman many places you c an have a religious ceremony which is just that, a ceremony ( without legal value to the government), but with a lot of value to the people that are taking part. But that said, some places ( religious places) wouldn’t marry a couple just like that either, without checking them, having them be part in the religious community, or have a future legal contract etc. though I’ve seen a few without those.
@@harshmnr of course anyone can get married at anytime but it won't be recognized by the state without the license
You missed a sin. The biggest sin. Sophie and her dude never actually got married. They went through all the wedding planning, spent all that money and got to the freaking alter but decided at the last second to not actually get married. Then they just ran off. Ugh!
Black Swan That's pretty big. But the biggest sin is that this all could have been avoided with a DNA test.
Black Swan How is that a sin? Plus the wedding wasn't waisted, he mom got married
Avalasia Love RIGHT that's what i've been thinking of the ENTIRE FILM
Avalasia Love they offer to do a DNA test near the end.
She refuses, and the dads all take 1/3rd custody.
Shoot me
And that Donna actually got married instead.
“Man can this movie go two minutes without breaking into song” ................. it’s a musical
The song needs to connect to the plot, but instead they break the moment.
James Campbell A MUSICAL NONETHELESS
@@magicgirl2831 that should be a sin in itself lmao
Correction I think it’s less than 2 minutes
@@Tex_Killer it's a jukebox musical u imbecile
I know damn well this movie is no masterpiece but I absolutely love it lmao
Same. It’s not deep, but it’s fun as hell.
It's pretty garbage, but for some inexplicable bizarre reason, I also love it.
It’s a guilty pleasure movie and we all love it
A.M Lash agreee
Same
90% of these sins are just him being salty about the music
For good reason
Llsif Lover so?
Llsif Lover more so the terrible singing than the actual songs
Yeah, because 90% of the movie is singing
It's called nick picking that's apart of their job
are you seriously sinning this musical for having too much music?
Joelisnotfaulous - no, for shit singing
If you said that german to anyone they would not understand
First of all you have to use the informal you when calling someone a twat
Du not sie
Second of all you have used an english verb in the sentence
Du bist not sie are
Third of all i would nevwr call someone a twat in german - the german language was made for insults.
Du bist eine backfeifengesicht
(You are a person with a very punchable face)
At least they can sing
No.I'm sinning this musical for having songs that basically never match the movie's plot!
Joelisnotfaulous - : that's what I hear most people complain about and I'm like "seriously ? It's a musical, what did you expect ?!
I loved this film and have such good memories of watching with my Mum. Slipping through my fingers always brings a lump to my throat. This might be the silliest film ever and make no sense but with the right people it can make a great afternoon.
Gwen Owen Grease is the same way
exactly. My mom had a terrible day at work and in the evening we decided to go see this movie. We had an amazing time and my mom felt so much better after this. She still loves this movie to this day. Sometimes I don't care if the movie's bad or not - if it makes me (or anyone) feel better, then it's enough.
yeah I love this movie.
Hear, hear! 😊
Same, I told my mom that the night before I get married we have to watch it
I loved that he sinned the part where Tanya asks Donna if she's getting some HAHAH Girls escalating conversations to that point is so relatable i'd say 4 seconds took longer then I would have expected
yeaa!!! I was thinking the same thing… oh if hears my friends and I talking God knows how many sins he would give us…
Righhttt
I was thinking that exactly
I love this movie. And I am taking a lot of sins off (In my head obviously) this especially the first one. You can't sin a musical for being a musical. Also never sin Meryl Streep
...she can stay on pitch.
No...he sinned the musical because it's a musical filled with people that really can't sing well at all
Oh, god, I lost it at both Kermit doing James Taylor and drunk man doing a David Bowie impression to describe Colin Firth and Pierce Brosnan's singing.
I will say this for the movie, everyone looks like they're genuinely having a good time. Like, no one looked miserable or put upon.
Yeah, the whole point of the movie is that it's a romance musical but also secretly a female friends film. Like in what other movie have you seen women's friendships portrayed so accurately as Donna's?
Did you just sin a musical for being a musical?
BrookeInProgress All musicals are bad. What's your point? (Don't actually answer that. It was a rhetorical question)
Lion O Cyborg its her opinion and I mean it's literally a musical known for singing. Which is why he shouldn't have sinned it for being something it literally is supposed to do
Wren Kalin so there are musicals not known for singing?
Jason Maxwell what no im saying he shouldn't have sinned it for literally being what it's supposed to be. And idk I don't like musicals
Lion O Cyborg hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha.....hahahahahahhahahahahahahahhaha....hahahahhahahahhahahahahaha no
3:38 you clearly have no idea how girl best friends talk.
Exactly
Exactly
@Michael Valensi neither do i
Mama Mia....
.... Here we go again...
RasenRendan X *clapping*
RasenRendan X DANK JOKE BRUGH😂😂😂😂
oh my...
RasenRendan X *bA dUm TsSsSs*
RasenRendan X *so impressed*
Comparing Pierce Brosnans singing to a drunk David Bowie Impersonator was the best sin since a while.
FreshRigi Yeah
I thought comparing Colin Firth to Kermit the Frog doing a James Taylor impression was even more accurate.
RedHeadKevin And how!
a movie based on a musical
cinimaSins: ItS A MusICaL???
Right? It's so annoying they really hate all musicals just for being musicals.
I'm generally ok with musicals, but you must admit this one musicals a little too much.
It musicals too much? That's almost as dumb as this sin video
Alessio Aletta there's no such thing as "musicals too much" when we are talking about Broadway
some regard we understood what the joke was supposed to be, we are complaining that it didnt make sense. It is a film adaptation of a Broadway musical. That's how it is SUPPOSED to be, but the fact he ragged on the musical aspect at least 4 times shows he hasn't done a lick of research or doesn't care that this is how it is supposed to be and that is incredibly lazy.
Kinda seems like you got bored and fast forwarded over the part where Sophie decides not to get married, and Meryl and Pierce get married instead. At first I thought maybe you just didn't have a problem with it (despite it's being up there with the most egregious of sins) but at 13:40, you say Pierce is interrupting Sophie's reception, when she's already passed that baton, and he can talk as much as he wants at his own reception.
Glad you made this though. Kermit meets James Taylor. Brilliant.
It’s against the law to insult Meryl Streep
....Wow, is she trying for once Not to win an oscar in this performance? ..........(damn, it feels good to be a gangster)
TRUE DAT MY G
She defended a rapist lmao FUCK MERYL STREEP
SAY IT LOUDER SIS 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
So it should be, Meryl is considered one of/the best actors/actresses of all time. So those who say she is bad are kidding themselves!😏😏 Love Meryl ❤❤❤💕💕💕
The biggest sin of this movie is how the daughter wants a man she's never met to 'give her away' at her wedding. What a insult to her mother who had raised her on her own.
in case you havent seen the whole movie she ends up foregoing her possible dads and does have her mother to give her away :)
uponangelwings just like Meghan Markle 😉
Well you can think that but have you ever and I mean EVER grown up not knowing who ur dad is?? My Bff has, it is so hard so be grateful.
I has and I'm good, I preffer one thousands time my mom over so...
she ends up asking her mother to give her away and it's a really beautiful moment
“Ah, sudden chorus of townspeople!” 😂😂😂
A critical part of every musical!
It's a literal Greek chorus.
"Slipping through my fingers" is actually the best!!!!
Facts
Dude you missed a sin. Meryl Streep on the roof singing "there's a fire in my soul" while she grabs her crotch. WTF you never miss those. OMG.
You Wished LOL but it’s Meryl STREEP tho. The Academy would have him blacklisted from YT for making such a lewd remark
chio1obesgubler but then again he called out christine for doing it in 'does your mother know?' lmao.
HeyItsSarahX But does The Academy have HER back tho??
Lol I love what I just read
LOL! 😂😂😂😂
You should do Mean Girls. Amanda Seyfried doesn’t sing in that
(Edit: wow! I never expected that this comment would get over 100 likes, or any at all lol thanks guys)
Nkiruka J I’d Love To See A CinemaSins For Mean Girls!!! One of My Favourite Films of All Time!!!
I can't believe they haven't done mean girls yet
Oof
Yeah
Mean girls would be epic to make him suffer through. Haha
Nkiruka J haha he really should
"Wow they cant go two minutes without singing"
Its almost like its a musical
jack fraust huh who would’ve thunk
They couldve went past a 2 minute mark
*a bad musical
Don't even try to say that's famous so it must be good. Don't you dare.
And there are different types of musicals. I prefer ones that have a song every 15 minutes or so. Musicals where they sing all the fucking time just get annoying and it makes the songs stand out less.
Moolers what about hamilton those are just songs.
mamma mia isn't a movie, it's a LIFESTYLE, and it's a full on tradition in my family
Huh
Bella Ludovici lmao what are you doing? Do you have any arguments to support you? I see you replying to all these people including me saying, why? Huh? Get a life lmao 😭
Well HUH is usually something people say when they dont quite understand something but if you assume that's an argument I guess I'll never get my answer
Bella Ludovici I think I know what huh means lol I don’t need a definition 😁😁. What do you not understand? You can read, right? So I assumed the only reason you said “huh” was because you didn’t agree with her
@@username-kx7ds nobody says huh cuz they disagree, that doesnt even make sense. What I was trying to figure out is what part is the lifestyle: ABBA, musicals, this movie??I know as a family mine have certain things particular to just us so thats all I meant, no need to be so angry over a huh...
I hate musicals, but actually like this movie. Also, it was Sam and Donna's wedding. Sky and Sophie called theirs off at the altar.
I love good musicals, and I hated this movie. I guess it was made for you.
I know this film is not a masterpiece, and it has bad singing and a thin plot but i just love it? There's something about it that makes me feel so happy and puts a big smile in my face
David Cas: I think that's the whole point of this musical/movie. That's why the tag line is "the feel-good movie event of the summer !"
ABBA(?)
Because ABBA
David Cas I think the singing is pretty ok just not Meryl
THANK YOU DEAR FUCKING GOD
"movie with an a list cast is somehow written by the back up lighting crew from days of our lives". 🤣😂
HouseMDaddict
I DIED.....LOL,
HouseMDaddict
Let me save you some time: the entire video is just him complaining about Meryl Streep and the fact that it’s a Musical.
This is one of the worst reviews of his that he has done
@@alicem1961 Review?
Yeah it’s like that’s the whole purpose of this channel or something
@@EATSLEEPDRIVE2002 I'll never understand these comments under their videos. It's a goddamn comedy channel, why do people take it seriously? They are obviously nitpicking and exaggerating, they know that.
Can’t believe the sequel has an 87% on rotten tomatoes with 39 critic reviews so far. The first one has a 54% so it seems like they did something better this time, of course it’s still early and the score will definetely change, but it looks like it’s a little bit better
Apart from anything else - haven't all the top-tier Abba songs already been used up?
HUNGER GAMES rotten tomatoes is a worthless site for reviews. Regular idiots contribute the scores lol.
Like, Steam game reviews.
Those are always super accurate and informative
The sequel is much worse than this one... i've seen it.
I give it a 55% for future rotten tomato
I didn't like the first movie, but I'm looking forward to seeing the second one!
*WARNING: Watching too many CinemaSins videos will ruin your further cinema experiences.*
I started to watch the serie Star Wars: The Clone Wars and i'm hearing the voice of Jeremy everywhere!
Niv 'Mohnd Oh dear. Another lost soul whose cinematic experience I'd forever ruined by this channel.
Boy, i said *too many*
I love CinemaSins, i ain't a hater or a trol. Just warning...
Try to watch any Fast and Furious video without his voice. It is impossible. Every movie i am watching now has his commenting it.
Yeah but most of his comments or sins are just nitpicks or for humor
that will never be me, I was cinema sinning and mystery science theatering my entire movie viewing life. I even extend that to my television watching and youtubing as well.
I think the biggest sin here is that Cinema Sins called a soprano sax an alto sax.
Me too
I think you should cut this movie a lot of slack. I mean, it's a musical, and every musical has an equal portion of cheese and cringe. And this was originally written as a Broadway musical, so I think that makes it even harder to be masterfully transferred to cinema, unlike with musicals intended to be movies and musicals based off of books. Movies based off of plays have much less creative liberty than ones bases on books or original ones, and plays naturally have a thing about them that makes them weird to be turned into movies. Although this movie has a lot of cringe-worthy and cheesy moments, I still find it enjoyable because it is fun and certainly has a unique story, and it is also set on an awesome Mediterranean island. It's one of those fun, feel good, and delightfully cheesy movies that are hard to dislike.
Andrew Bresnan you're wrong, Sweeney Todd....
Uuuh Climax and Dancer in the Dark don’t. And yeah Sweeny Todd.
While I agree with you about the difficulties in translating play to film, I'd have to say that CinemaSins' policy on source material would apply here. It's still the responsibility of the writers and directors to make a coherent, decent story, regardless of the source material.
@@thriller985 Sweeney Todd was a musical movie I actually liked. Maybe I'll watch it on Halloween.
every musical definitely doesn't have a bit of cheese and cringe
This seems more like “things I don’t like” more than “things wrong with it”
Congrats on watching your first CinemaSins video
That's literally just all Cinema sins videos
That's what this channel has now become, sadly.
Thank You!!
TRUE HOME BOY
That awkward moment when an amazing TH-camr Sins your childhood movie.
Honestly it's not even sins it's just his opinion and comedy
Yeah just gotta remember it's only his opinion. And while a majority of the time I agree with him, I know there's movies I enjoy that others don't. He did sin Lion King, after all 😂
I don't want to be the person who says "how dare you ruin this movie" so I am not. But....
MAMMA MIA IS MY JAM!!
ThatHufflepuffGirl 21 depends. Mamma Mia is my peanut butter.
I felt like brain cells died watching this horrible film and I love musicals typically!
Mamma Mia is my entire sandwich!
@@__-zf3tz It's my peanut butter jelly time, peanut butter jelly time, yeaha, yeaha, yeaha! Peanut butter jelly, peanut butter jelly, peanut butter jelly with a baseball bat.
Brian the dog
@@lijohnyoutube101 It's more the singing voices than the songs that aren't so good, it's that and how they don't make sense with the story.
109 sins should be removed for the presence of Colin Firth
should go to -200 for the presence of Julie Walters
Colin Firth is a grace to humanity
but all of them come back for peirce brosnans shitty singing
Alina Orschlet That’s not tea idiot
......Nope
Colin Firth did actually sound like Kermit the Frog 😂😂
I would have forgiven his presence in the movie if he had spontaneously broken out into Rainbow Connection, banjo and all.
Why there are so many songs about rainbows and what's on the other side? (confess, you can't take it out of your head now too)
🎵Rainbows are visions but only illusions and rainbows have nothing to hide🎵
🎵So we’ve been told and some choose to believe it🎵
🎵Someday we’ll find it the rainbow connection the lovers the dreamers and me🎵
No matter how much I love a movie, I can't express how much fun I have watching your Sins videos making fun of them.
This is such an awesome channel and Jeremy is such an awesome narrator!
"Narration... Ding!"
jaspr1999 how did you find his name?
jaspr1999 the megamind one was a bit aggressive, he literally kept saying the movie sucked even though it was a great movie
poketdoom it wasn't
jaspr1999 read it in his voice
poketdoom, - My favorite was the original Pete's Dragon. Since I saw it when it first came out at the theater it shows me how much times have changed just in my lifetime... Aside from me laughing hysterically through his Sin Counting.
One thing about the particular musical is that it is called a jukebox musical. This means like ya know the story was created around the songs. So it makes sense that there are some plot holes (a lot) and that not all songs seem to fit 100% together. But cinemasins probably knows that
Pierce Brosnan=drunk David Bowie impersonator. Yesssss.
Pierce Brosnan "Where are those happy days they seem so hard to find?"
Me "Definitely start looking before we heard you sing?
12:55 that 8 Mile reference though 😂
PrinceTrexus lol yes! F*ckn hilarious! 😂
Was about to post this, it is too great! lmao
CinemaSins acapella, still better musical than Mamma Mia
It was perfect!! Lmao
I lost my sh*t when I heard that,I was literally crying. Best sins review in a while
ofc I got a Mamma Mia ad before this video
Avanda The Screaming Llama same
Avanda The Screaming Llama Efore
Avanda The Screaming Llama me too
Avanda The Screaming Llama SAAAAMMMEE!!!!!
Yea same -_-
With that 3rd last sin, did he entirely miss when Sophie cancelled her wedding and he mom got married instead?
Honestly Mamma Mia is one of those feel good movies you don't have to think about too hard. Who cares about plotholes :D
Mamma Mia is one of those movies you can't think about too hard...
It's fine if you do.
H4T890EQ
=E]RSMKJRPO
They aren’t even plotholes; just people being a bit dim.
I felt horrible after watching it. I use to be an open minded person, then I saw this piece of shit.
Sin 106 was off. Sophie never got married anyways lol
awkwardnchey yes, thank you
Yes, the most rage-inducing part of this whole dumpster fire of a movie!!! The wedding for Sophie was in the end pointless since she ended up standing up her fiancé for no reason, gained 3 well-off dads who want to make up not being there for her, and essentially wasted everyone’s time & money...all in the name of finding herself, or whatever!!!
Emerald Fox it might have been a theater musical first, or a bad “ABBA Greatest Hits” commercial given a story, however it’s musical-turned-romantic-comedy version was a muddled mess of a film plot-wise. If you enjoyed it, great. It sucked for me and getting to remember it through the CinemaSins filter was the best part of a very dumb movie
*13:35 I understand that you didn’t put it in the video but he MARRIES DONNA so this is now his ceremony so he can sing whatever he wants.
And Sophie didn't end up getting married! So she doesn't have a husband
So many 'Sins' and you forgot the most obvious one. The time loop hole:
Donna met these guys during the Flower power era according to "Our last summer". Let's say 1974 to make it more plausible.
So Sophie was born in 1975. The musical is set in 2004, the movie in 2008. Which would make Sophie somewhere between 29 and 33 played by 23 year old Seyfried. And they say that Sophie is 20 years old several times...
And where did she meet these obviously English best friends that has never been to Greece or this island when she has grown up and spent her whole life on this island.
nope that summer where donna met all the guys was in 1979 which is said in the second movie :)
humblehanna23 it’s also in the og musical in the diary I’m pretty sure
No, the musical and film are set in 1999. Allegedly.
The diary says Donna get pregnant with Sophie in 1979, so Sophie was born in either 1979 or 1980. And since Sophie is 20 years old, this movie has to take place in either 1999 or 2000.
Damn it the song so damn catchy and man the nostalgia is so real i remember watching this everyday as a kid
Jcfrosty Cheesebugga, I'm sorry. I really am.
Jcfrosty Cheesebugga name and profile picture checks out
The ABBA verisions are catchy, sure. But what they did in this movie? I feel like CS owes me damages for the hurt my ears suffered from the little excerpts they showed o.o
then listen to the actual band who created the songs instead of watching a movie do their awful renditions
Funny that i got the ads for mama mia here we go again
Ghost_tea same
Ghost_tea same here
Same:)
Me too
Not me
This is the weirdest movie, the premise, the cast, it's all so odd
TheRealBeatMaster
It DEFINITELY didn't age well. #SoCringy.
TheRealBeatMaster agreed don’t care about the new movie
'member when these Sins were actually based upon solid reasons?
Oh, I 'member!
this movie is bad but like,, good. like. it's good if you don't think about it at all (like not even for a second) like never once apply critical thinking. cuz it's got some bops, a cute girl, and 3 drunk old women and who doesn't love that. this sounds like im kidding but this is really how i feel about this movie.
theater memes AGREED.
Throw logic out into that beautiful Mediterranean Sea and enjoy yourself.
If you ignore all the bad parts, then its pretty enjoyable lol. Meryl Streeps acting AND some parts of her singing were especially bad, felt too forced at times which isn't exactly good for acting.
"Discount Grease/Greece". I died.....
maybe it's just me but I actually like this movie and watch it often.
Bentley's Backwoods Bushcraft. Me too
Good for you?
I don't get ppl that watch movies more than once
Same I have seen it wayyyy too many times
I honestly love this movie
But... wasn't that a soprano sax? It's straight and long, alto saxes curve up. Sin to you! xD
@Unsexy Devil I went to school for music education, I was just being silly two years ago. xD
@Unsexy Devil dude this account is older than 2 years xD
thanks! I didn't get to graduate, financial aid is a jerk, but I do plan to go back and finish eventually! xD
Darth Vader: Luke, I don't know if I'm your father
Mr. mini, 😂😂
NOOOOOOOOooooooooo!!
"I mean, there was Obi Wan, Jar Jar, and then that black guy with the eye patch. For all I know, any of them could be your dad, but based on how annoying you are now, and how bitchy you'll be when you're 60, I'm betting it was Jar Jar."
Let’s just sing a bunch of songs
Poppa was a rolling ....B-88?
*Am I the only person that actually likes this movie? lol* 😹
No. Youre not special
No, there's a reason it was a huge box office success and has been given a sequel!
I love this movie. I’m aware it’s not a masterpiece, but it is fun as shit to watch
One of my FAVORITE MOVIES EVER, left half way through this vid cause i got bored of bad insults on a great movie 😂😂😂😂😂
I lav it. I know it's not for everyone though.
I can't stop critiquing everything I watch now
theglitcher_ ofhacks Except, Cinemasins doesn’t critique, it nitpicks, because they are proud certified assholes. Critique is what reviewers do when they don’t make an annoying point out of a perfectly justifiable movie trope.
Ditto
"Colin Firths singing voice is like Kermit the Frog doing a James Taylor impression" I've been watching cinemasins for 3 years and I think this is my favorite sin ever.
You should stop doing videos for musicals if you're going to criticize it for being a musical, especially if it is the film adaptation of a Broadway musical. They sing every 5 seconds because it's almost a carbon copy of the Broadway show, and Broadway musicals are known for singing every 5 seconds. I'm not sure why you're so surprised this movie is a musical.
DismemberedHat You must be new here 🙄
Which is funny coz I'm new here too, but I picked up before I even watched it that it's A JOKE
Katie Aviss I'm not new here. In fact, I've been here so long, I remember when CinemaSins didnt nitpick like this and when they actually did research to produce some quality material. Sinning a musical for having music is like sinning an action movie for having action scenes or a romance for having kissing scenes. It's just lazy writing to sin the musical for having music, not just once, but at least 4 times. Sorry I dont ride CS's dick like the rest of this comment section and can actually form an opinion
DismemberedHat would be good at sinning CinemaSins DING!
Katie Aviss no I looked him up he's a real movie critic that makes TH-cam videos about the movies he criticises.
Yeah, I've watched a bunch of his videos and he nit-picks about every single thing in a movie and sometimes he will just put a sin just to put a sin it doesn't make sense XD
The way you pronounce ABBA deserves a Sin, DING!
If you say ABBA often enough even so many times in one instance it sounds like you're having a fit of some sort than anything else.
Buzz The Buzzard xD
the slowed down singing that's playing in the background when you're pointing out sins is actually hilarious 6:25
2:39 I mean, really? That's a reason for hating this movie, is that wrong for any reason?
And in 4:51 yes, ofc she can sing, and better than you guess
You forgot that the majority of the people in Greece are Orthodox, so that priest at the wedding is dressed in completely the wrong clothes. He wouldn't pass as Catholic, either, which is the other prominent Christian "branch" in southern and western Europe.
Spoken like a true Ravenclaw lol
Pretty much nonexistent, as catholics amount to less than 1% of the population. However, the people involved in the marriage are probably not Orthodox, so it would make sense not to invite a local priest.
I've been thinkint about that, too, but - didn't Donna raise her daughter in Greece? So if she wanted to practise her faith, she'd have to join a local community, and that would (most likely) be an orthodox one, and you can bet the groom is orthodox, too. So it makes very little sense to bring in an American priest. I mean, I know there are people who will join a church just for the wedding and then leave again, but I kinda doubt that's the case here, either.
I do, as a matter of fact.
Lilian Achura Based on Donna's character and backstory (this movie and in trailors for the sequel), I highly doubt she was religious. We also don't know where she was raised or anything so that also plays a factor. Sophie would almost definetely follow suit because that's how she's been brought up. Sky's background is also unknown. However, as Sophie says, he would rather get married quickly in jeans and "wash it down with a bottle of beer". Literally he's only getting married for Sophie. He's probably not religious or at least he doesn't care enough to care who marries them.
Long story short, it doesn't really matter to them who's the officiant as long as the marriage will be legally recognized.
Loved this movie. It was fun to watch. Can’t wait to see the upcoming one.
Arabella Gentile THANK YOU! all these comments are so rude
Yes daddy cinema, please give me more sins
HAHAHAHA!!
😄😏
Chadybb The sad dads is y hot
D'Bomb Gamer would be incredibly good at Cinema Sins.
When the "Dancing Queen" group dance music is slowed down it's chilling af.
As much as I love this channel and you guys constantly and consistently make me laugh, 13:37 , it actually became Sam (Pierce Brosnan) and Donna's (Meryl Streep) wedding, not Sophie and Sky's.
Ashaylan Govender which was a pretty stupid way to end an already crappy movie!! The CinemaSins filter was the best way to go back to this pile of garbage lol
I was about to comment this same thing
I’m just gonna point out that 13:37 is leet
that is how the broadway musical ended. they were true to the orriginal story. now im not saying it is good writing, but it was true to the source material
Lemme sin this and say at 12:06 you say the wedding band has an alto sax. But that is a soprano sax mate.
“Lucille Ball eat your heart out” had me laughing so loud and long
When he said that about Colin Firth’s singing I freaking lost it
#1 The musical is a bit better
#2 In the musical, the actual protagonist is the mother, not the bride. The soon-to-be bride is just what sets things in motion.
Diego Ruiz
Wow. TrivialFacts😉 Thank You. Cos i won't be watching the musical! 😘
I loved this movie as a kid, but now that I'm older, the plot would all be solved in a few minutes with a DNA test. Still, it's still silly, musical fun.
Yeah instead of finding out who the father is which is the movie's entire plot, lets just sing a bunch of from a long dead genre.
Maury would take care of that shit in minutes
Maury : "You are.... not the father, none of you are the father. He is."
**Antonio Benderas bust through the door and starts singing**
Would've loved if they took the South Park route. The twist is Meryl Streep is actually the father. Would've set up perfectly for the sequel. Who's her mother? Or in other words, Mama Mia?
Still waiting for Everything Wrong With Pulp Fiction.
steven alvarez I would love to see that
omg yes! It's a sin that hasn't been done yet.
Same, also waiting for EWW - Wolf of Wall Street.
Pulp Fiction is amazing.
I cant believe you think pulp fiction has anything wrong with it...
You can't sin a musical for having music.
The fun part is doing just that anyway.
They're sinning because the movie is 95% horrible covers of good songs that don't connect to the plot or characters at all and are basically just there to flex how much money the filmmakers had to not only get to use these songs, but also to get Meryl Streep in their """"film"""""
Yes onel can
Hahaha sin a musical for being a musical. I would do the same
To be fair, Beauty and the Beast is a musical, and there's like 5 songs in the whole movie. Just because something is a musical doesn't mean you get to have only music and ass for plot. Musicals are awful when they're live action, pretty much universally. I'm with you. It's a musical? sin.
Yea, that's exactly where I stopped watching this sins video... :/ If you don't like musicals, maybe not watching them is the better idea. :/ Others were at least ... funny?
It's mandatory.
I think he was sinning it for not being a musical in the same since as the show
My 8th grade social studies teacher let us watch this...
glad you survive
Marcona Jake my teacher let us watch Elf
12:56
Yeah
Good choice for them
They totally aren't fired right now
Let you or made you? Because if she let you, what in God’s name would make you agree to that?
My 8th grade drama teacher made us watch it, officially scared for life😖
THERE'S NOTHING WROOOOONNGG
Exactly
Aspiring Marauder. Pretty sure the "we instantly regretted this decision" meant they regretted watching the movie
YESSS
Yeah. They should start doing a "YTchannalsins" that way, they can criticize their own channel. I think the only reason they hadn't already made one is bc they have two and they'll have to review their own channels as well
@sok mai ashoe A lot of people hate it, not bc it's a musical. Most of the people in the world enjoy music, but apparently you don't.
I would also like to know how you know swear words when your english isn't that good.
this movie was perfection. absolutely nothing wrong with it but i’ll still watch the video
I cannot believe you didn't remove a sin for the iconic Dancing Queen. How dare you...
Human Disaster Ikr... this video is quite disappointing
It was kinda lame, to be honest. This whole movie is horribly lame in my opinion.
Drek Gray I normally love CinemaSins, especially when they do a movie I like, but this video this annoyed me. Felt like they were repeating the same sin over and over again
As I've said in the past about Mamma Mia! They used that song ALL kinds of wrong.
friday night ? it was broad daylight on like, a tuesday.
dancing Queen, 17?
um... nobody is 17 in this movie, no way in hell it was Meryl Streep. 71, maybe. not 17.
they butchered it, and honestly I think they used it too early in the movie to begin with.
That is something you END the movie on, ( which they also did, lol? )
they blew their load early, and it was not satisfying for anyone.
Sorry but That 70's Show Musical Special was better than this entire movie.
LMAO THE DANCING QUEEN SEQUENCE SPED DOWN SOUNDS SUPER GREAT
Before watching this I watched an ad for mama Mia
Sarah St.louis same
Same
Same
omg when he slows done at the dancing queen part, you can hear them in the background and it sounds like grown men chanting ABBA. it's goddamn hilarious.
Omg it is🤣🤣
This movie is a gem. Me and my sisters do nothing but sing ABBA mostly when we do karaoke (and some old songs cos we just prefer them in karaoke really haha) and just--I really enjoyed watching it :D
I know CinemaSins and yes how it's satire and all that but still, just wanna say that this movie still has a special place in my heart xD I honestly cannot wait for the sequel! Or I suppose, prequel?
Moon Mun it’s both, prequel sequel like The Godfather Part 2 except not as brilliant
Look, I *love* ABBA, and I say it proudly, and I know Bjorn and Benny are behind the play, but . . . geez. The first hurdle it has going for it is the same one that all jukebox musicals have going for them: No matter how well the performers can sing, all their singing does is to remind you that *they aren't the people you want to hear singing those songs.* And in the second place, *THEY CAST A BUNCH OF PEOPLE WHO CAN'T SING.* At least the sequel has Cher, who CAN sing . . . but Cher is not Anni-Frid, and THAT's who I want to hear doing "Fernando."
You want a movie that honors ABBA and doesn't fall into the jukebox musical trap, watch Muriel's Wedding.
+WakenerOne One thing I never understood was why you'd have a musical full of Abba songs, but have the plot have nothing to do with Abba.
Lady Marmalade, and then, there's *THAT.* I know the same thing was done with the Beatles catalog a few years back, but not being a big Beatles fan, I don't know the name of the movie. But It had nothing to do with the Beatles, either.
Moon Mun Donnas dead so
Pierce Brosnan did NOT steal the spotlight from Sophie in her wedding! She decided that they are not ready for marriage so Pierce Brosnan married Meryl Streep and therefore is kind of allowed to have a sappy song toast to her new wife.
THANK YOU!
MY biggest question is why didn't she just inform all the potential fathers and called in a paternity test? Plot solved...
I hate this scene so much, because I love the original version of "When All Is Sad And Done", the most misused song in this flick. Why? It is about a divorce!
Also When all is said and done isn't even in the stage show but they decided to give PIERCE BROSNAN an extra song
Brought to you by "mamma mia 2:here we go again" in theaters this Friday
Pretty sure most of the script is from the stage musical.
Also, now you have to do Here We Go Again.
P.S. You're wrong. It ended up being Sam and Donna's wedding, so he gets to hold a speech.
This comment was a long time ago but I was just in the musical and the script for the movie and the musical are SO different; the musical's script is a lot dirtier (we had to censor parts of it), a lot of the songs that are in the musical aren't in the movie (Under Attack, Knowing Me Knowing You, etc.). A lot of the songs that are there are moved around in the movie (Take A Chance On Me happens before the wedding scene, Winner Takes It All happens in the scene before that, etc.) And the music/vocals are slightly different; the ending belt of Winner Takes It All is a C5, not....whatever Meryl was singing.
@@elenafahmi9955 Not to mention that in the musicals script Sam proposing to Donna feels much more deserved than the movie. Sam had actual character development and Harry had a bit more too. Harry singing Our Last Summer with Donna in the musical feels way more in place because it was THEIR summer, having all 3 of the dads singing it and telling those experiences to Sophie felt extremely weird. Also it might be a nitpick but I can't get over the change in sound mixing (Idk what it qualifies as) when the movie jumps from dialogue to song
Thrash Division I think it’s just transitions; the movie didn’t really have any transitions from speaking to singing it’s just talktalktalkYOU CAN DANCE, and it comes out of nowhere. In the musical, the beginning instrumentals are backed up a little bit underneath the dialogue so that when they start singing, it’s not something that came out of nowhere.
Haha Pierce Brosnan sings like a drunk David Bowie. By the way you forgot to sin the waterloo ending
i can't believe i never realised that amanda seyfried is the only one in this who can sing
Alex Hallahan Meryl can
Madi H she's alright certainly one of the better ones but not great
Most of them aren't great, but not terrible either. I actually really like Pierce Brosnans singing voice
Alex, I def didn't remember how bad the singing was.
Actually Christine Baranski, who plays Aunt Tanya can sing really well. She’s in a few musicals, including Chicago.
Just to further your knowledge, that was a soprano sax
Remember when sins were actual technical or plot mistakes... Instead of this 'I don't like the music or singing'.
*Mamma mia someone ate my spaget.*
Good points, but I’ll love this movie nonetheless
Also, can you do Sound of Music? ^^
I have to say, I really really *want* to hate this movie, but I just can't. My sister loves it too much, and I love my sister too much, for me to really hate it. I just know it's not meant for people like me. That's fine.
Spira
I loved Sound Of Music, but I also want Jeremy to sin it!
....i don't like musicals much
Buona Sera, Mrs. Campbell the 1968 better Mamma Mia
8:28 This dancing on the boat is priceless perfection and probably the best in this movie
The sin that bothered me was at the end when he talks about the reception being for Sophie's wedding, if he didn't fell asleep he would know that Sky and Sophie never got married and Donna and Sam did.
He called a soprano sax an Alto. Google is a thing, man.
GOOGLE IS NO MAN IM AN FEMINIST