The beaurocrats and Murray Watt are dodging and weaving scrutiny because they are all incompetent,,,,if this was a big company they would be held to account and fired !!
thankyou for what? we, us people need to be e-mailing all the traitors that we call govt & calling them out & insist that they provide us the full details of their business.
Yes Senator, I’ve heard your question, and I’m choosing to protect the Government and my job rather than answer your question honestly. After all the consistent policy of this government is to gaslight the public as often as possible.
She doesnt work for u or any of us... maybe you haven't figured it out yet that you are living under tyranny, you do as your told and don't you dare ask questions. We are slaves to those who rule
This woman is an example of what is wrong with this country's governance. We the people pay Senator Paterson to ask you questions and we expect you to answer them. Why does the Chair always manage the meetings in favour of the public servants? I believe we need legislation to compel these people provide answers when asked.
why is this public servant being so evasive, why does Senator Paterson have to keep on asking the same thing?? how much is this woman paid by the Australian public.
@@Jess.am488 nearly half a million dollar salary and she is unable to answer questions directly more than a disgrace Jess.am488. I am lost for words. WTF is going on in our parliament
I'd love to be paid to gaslight, lie and waffle for hours on end, but I'm unemployed and every day I draw closer to homelessness, these people are sick, and I'm getting tired of the senators letting these criminals get away with this. All we do is talk, why are none of these people on trial in front of the PEOPLE of Australia as the jury?
Yeah, the Chair running interference for Miss Foster was disgusting. Remember someone was murdered because of Miss Fosters actions. She is responsible for that murder.
Bureaucratic double speak yet again! I am astounded at the garbage these public servants dish up in response to questions from the public or their representatives. The arrogance of this approach is gob smacking- it’s as if it is below them to actually answer a question - instead of tossing up inane pseudo polite gibberish. These people would not last a second in the real world where questions demand an answer and you can’t hide behind your ministers
Straight out contempt of the Senators questions, she should absolutely be held to account for her avoidance & dribble she is spruiking. She didn’t answer a single question! She is being paid a huge salary to do so The chair is an absolute disgrace, straight out looking after her mates. What a joke
@@damianpritchett5489Senator Nita Green is the chair. Was raised in a single mother home from a young age where everything is the fault of the dead beat wife bashing father and was programmed by the mother who never exaggerated her situation to be a man hater, you'll learn to identify them over the years after coming across a few, I've found they all have a similar condescending attitude , mannerisms and other tells that you can pick up.
@@buildmotosykletist1987The majority will do something about it at the next Federal election,you can bet on that !!These dud public servants are acting under orders from the hopeless Labor government !!
Senator watt speaks when not asked to and butts in to ride shotgun over the befuddled bureaucrats when they are being taken to task. Arrogance personified.
The Home Affairs Secretary is another dud….not up to the measure of accountability required by a tax payer funded political appointment. Obfuscation and gibberish her manner. The Chair equally deficient in progressing issues in the public interest. Appalling waste of time and resources….absolute BS. We deserve so much better than these lazy, smug dolts.
Dock their pays for not providing information to taxpayers on how they spend our money , she was asked back in February and now she's spent months doing nothing but rehearse on how not to answer and be accountable. Time these parasites senior positions were held to account and should not be based on how sensitive they feel.
The quiet squeaky girl voice from a grown woman is not fooling anyone. Deceitful behavior. What we have here is a professional victim when held accountable.
They act like they are in charge, if I did this to my boss I would be shown the door. And sensitive information is another word for sh1t we do not want the public to know about because we are lying and covering up.
Miss Foster is extremely clever with her words and as is typical a public servant as you could imagine. Who is this woman that she can slime her way around questions and actually not answering questions.
So, let me get this straight. The Labor party promised they would be more transparent than the Liberals and we would also have lower electricity prices? Well we know how the electricity thing went and now as far as transparency is concerned , well well well... how dare you expect us to deliver on the increased transparency, as we promised, it will be business as usual thank you very much! M.A.G.A, Make Albo Go Away.
What I see is incompetence, incompetence, incompetence. This is just unbelievable to have people running government departments with such incompetence! I am ashamed to hear what I am hearing.
Prepare, preparation, my team, prepared, my thinking, how would i, my mind, my mind, my mind. Thats what im hearing. Wonderful obfuscating language skills.
it is really simple. Yes or No. By obfuscating as she does, i personally read that as a NO answer, with regards to the Australian people being kept in the loop.
She departs from commitments to Ministers and Senators. This ineffective inefficient dunce-headed overpaid inept bureaucrat should be sacked. Im sure you could find a person at Job network that would carry out her role perfectly well for a fraction of the cost. Out you go!!
No wonder so much tax payers money is wasted and nothing ever gets done and when it does, its over budget and not needed. Too many people in politics milking the system, we need a good cleansing, the system needs to change where people working for the tax payer are held accountable.
Interesting, especially considering the leaked document from Albo's office to the department heads on how to avoid any serious inquiries from the Senate. A Labor minister continues to uphold it's ingrained culture of bullying/intimidation & their lack of transparency....
The responses given are pathetic at best and bordering on criminal negligence. The chair is not supporting or requiring that appropriate questions be answered. Sack these incompetents and thank god Senator Patterson has the public interest foremost for the Australian public.
James catches them out all the time . We are paying these idiots top money for literally nothing , bloody disgraceful
Listening to this bureaucrat reminds me of listening to Paula Vennells from the British Post office. Just dodging every question.
The beaurocrats and Murray Watt are dodging and weaving scrutiny because they are all incompetent,,,,if this was a big company they would be held to account and fired !!
of course the opposition hate labour and labor hate liberal so what else would you expect from that child paterson.
Embarrassing. Why are these jelly fish in positions of authority? Ditto for the Chair.
Hear hear
Yeah, the Chair running interference for Miss Foster was very un-parlimentary.
The chair consistently behaves this way, it's embarrassing.
It becomes clearer why Labor Marxists prefer weak public servants.
Kakistocracy is why
Thankyou senator Paterson for trying to do your job despite the obvious obstruction.
thankyou for what? we, us people need to be e-mailing all the traitors that we call govt & calling them out & insist that they provide us the full details of their business.
Never stop, Senator James Paterson 👏
Isnt this woman being paid by the taxpayers ? It is sensible to be accountable to the taxpayers
Yes Senator, I’ve heard your question, and I’m choosing to protect the Government and my job rather than answer your question honestly. After all the consistent policy of this government is to gaslight the public as often as possible.
Thank you James . We just continually see the DECEPTION.
please tell this person that she works for us , we don't work for her
Patterson works for the fossil fuel industry.
And your point is what?
@@keithdrower9120• a f..... greenie no doubt, one of the doom and gloom tree hugger brigade.
She doesnt work for u or any of us... maybe you haven't figured it out yet that you are living under tyranny, you do as your told and don't you dare ask questions. We are slaves to those who rule
This woman is an example of what is wrong with this country's governance. We the people pay Senator Paterson to ask you questions and we expect you to answer them. Why does the Chair always manage the meetings in favour of the public servants? I believe we need legislation to compel these people provide answers when asked.
24 million people in the country and we get this bunch of incompetent clowns, we are a joke.
Patterson is a joke....!
27 million now thanks to out of control immigration.
@@keithdrower9120🤡
@@keithdrower9120 : Labor is the joke as shown very clearly on the video.
So what have YOU done or will do to fix this or are you a joke ???
This is what a useless incompetent public servant looks like
We need more people like you senator Patterson thank you
Yes, I absolutely agree with you. He is brilliant and should be prime minister. Extremely intelligent and clever with his thinking.
@@di_r67also not intimidated by anyone. Just wants the facts.
That woman is obstructive and very obviously unwilling to comply with a reasonable request.Looks evasive and as if hiding something.
Well done Senator, keep it up.
why is this public servant being so evasive, why does Senator Paterson have to keep on asking the same thing?? how much is this woman paid by the Australian public.
Her total salary is over $484k of our taxpayer $$. It's a bloody disgrace.
@@Jess.am488 nearly half a million dollar salary and she is unable to answer questions directly more than a disgrace Jess.am488. I am lost for words. WTF is going on in our parliament
Keep at them Senator Patterson
I'd love to be paid to gaslight, lie and waffle for hours on end, but I'm unemployed and every day I draw closer to homelessness, these people are sick, and I'm getting tired of the senators letting these criminals get away with this.
All we do is talk, why are none of these people on trial in front of the PEOPLE of Australia as the jury?
So sorry to hear about your not having a job. Everything has gone to China….
You would "love it" well your part of the problem unemployed people are good at gaslighting centerlink
James is amazing, intelligent and catches them out every time
She should be sacked and removed from the public service
Agreed. She is paid over $484k of our taxpayer dollars and this is what we get for it!
Blah Blah Blah and the chair needs to keep quiet.
That would make a change, they love wasting time and interrupting genuine questions from representatives of the people actually DOING THEIR JOB.
Yeah, the Chair running interference for Miss Foster was disgusting. Remember someone was murdered because of Miss Fosters actions. She is responsible for that murder.
I'm not sure you understand the purpose of a committee chair...
Why can't she just table a Senator's request.
Jail her & personal fine her $1000/day until she table requested doc.
Don't fine her, cos we'll end up having to pay it. Ban her from attending meetings. She would probably be happy with that.
Stuff off....!
😂 on what legal basis and authority?
Bravo Senator Patterson, BRAVO!
Bureaucratic double speak yet again! I am astounded at the garbage these public servants dish up in response to questions from the public or their representatives.
The arrogance of this approach is gob smacking- it’s as if it is below them to actually answer a question - instead of tossing up inane pseudo polite gibberish.
These people would not last a second in the real world where questions demand an answer and you can’t hide behind your ministers
EXACTLY.
Straight out contempt of the Senators questions, she should absolutely be held to account for her avoidance & dribble she is spruiking. She didn’t answer a single question! She is being paid a huge salary to do so
The chair is an absolute disgrace, straight out looking after her mates. What a joke
What is this person HIDING..?HAS SHE 'BEEN INFLUENCED' TO NOT GIVE CLEAR AND PRICISE ANSWERS TO THE SENATOR BY THE MINISTER SHE IS WORKING FOR.??
these people are responsible for taking a pay, and not doing what they are employed to do.
NO TRANSPARENCY HERE - what a total waste of tax payers money. Just because they are present does not mean they are answering any valid questions😏
The chair is a disgrace!
What's the name of the chair? Need to put in a complaint.
The chairs voice is enough to send a person around the bend.
@@damianpritchett5489Senator Nita Green is the chair. Was raised in a single mother home from a young age where everything is the fault of the dead beat wife bashing father and was programmed by the mother who never exaggerated her situation to be a man hater, you'll learn to identify them over the years after coming across a few, I've found they all have a similar condescending attitude , mannerisms and other tells that you can pick up.
How much does this continuous waffle cost us per hour $$$$$$$$$$$$$ ? 🙄
Thank you for your service senator Paterson ! 🙏
Well done James keeping the bastards honest
She is carefully choosing her words. We just going around in circles. Same thing Never A Straight Answer.
If only !
OMG…..bureaucratic arrogance fully supported by Labor MP’s……
Thanks Senator, the minister is evasive............
A sweetie voice will not cover up incompetence.
Just sack her and all the other b/s politicians
Go senator Paterson good to see 👍👍👍
Public servant trying to flex her muscle, picked the wrong bloke
And Murray Watt comes in to save the day and blames Dutton
Sack the chair
Paterson should be the next P.M.
Thank you Senator!.
It’s not unparliamentary. He’s doing his job, asking questions on behalf of the people.
For goodness sake people are homeless and this baloney is going on NO wonder australians hate the govt
What are YOU doing about it ? Are you a memberof a party? Are you protesting? Are you writing letters? What are YOU doing ?
@@buildmotosykletist1987The majority will do something about it at the next Federal election,you can bet on that !!These dud public servants are acting under orders from the hopeless Labor government !!
....... no wonder Australia's productivity is negative !!
What a grub!!!
Yep a huge Government of hopelessly inept people is exactly that hopelessly inept.
God his Awesome , James keeping them honest and calling out the truth
Back to your knitting lady.
There only seems to be one person in that chamber trying to do work for the Australian people.
Chair, Please Help....I'm trying to Bullshit my way Out of This ?
What a waste of tax payers money - ducking and weaving as expected by Labour. It’s standard practice.
This is the pathetic standard of the bent public service in Australia, when a question is too hot for them, ahh rephrase your question npblah blah,,,,
What are we paying these beaurocrats for we wouldn't be employed if we can't be accountable
Senator watt speaks when not asked to and butts in to ride shotgun over the befuddled bureaucrats when they are being taken to task. Arrogance personified.
Senator i only prioritise what i want to do, over any requests to prepare in advance. Semantics at an advanced level. This is disgraceful
The Home Affairs Secretary is another dud….not up to the measure of accountability required by a tax payer funded political appointment. Obfuscation and gibberish her manner. The Chair equally deficient in progressing issues in the public interest. Appalling waste of time and resources….absolute BS. We deserve so much better than these lazy, smug dolts.
Where the he'll do they employ these people from. One flew over the cookoo nest. Just do your bloody job
Dock their pays for not providing information to taxpayers on how they spend our money , she was asked back in February and now she's spent months doing nothing but rehearse on how not to answer and be accountable.
Time these parasites senior positions were held to account and should not be based on how sensitive they feel.
Every bloody time, I will take that on notice, they won't answer questions, they have had months to get it together, what the hell is going on
Who cares what the chair thinks. The chair is supposed to be neutral, the isn't to take a side.
They're never neutral because they come from the government side !
Abject time wasting.
The quiet squeaky girl voice from a grown woman is not fooling anyone.
Deceitful behavior.
What we have here is a professional victim when held accountable.
She clearly doesn't know who she works for.
Waste of time. Waste of Money.
They act like they are in charge, if I did this to my boss I would be shown the door. And sensitive information is another word for sh1t we do not want the public to know about because we are lying and covering up.
Miss Foster is extremely clever with her words and as is typical a public servant as you could imagine. Who is this woman that she can slime her way around questions and actually not answering questions.
So, let me get this straight. The Labor party promised they would be more transparent than the Liberals and we would also have lower electricity prices? Well we know how the electricity thing went and now as far as transparency is concerned , well well well... how dare you expect us to deliver on the increased transparency, as we promised, it will be business as usual thank you very much! M.A.G.A, Make Albo Go Away.
Miss Foster is a waste of time and ratepayers money and the chairs a clown.
What I see is incompetence, incompetence, incompetence. This is just unbelievable to have people running government departments with such incompetence! I am ashamed to hear what I am hearing.
Act in a parliamentary way thats a disgrace he was being very rationale and reasonable that chair is out of line and biased.
Prepare, preparation, my team, prepared, my thinking, how would i, my mind, my mind, my mind. Thats what im hearing. Wonderful obfuscating language skills.
Great work Senator. The wrongdoers are worried now.
"If i speak gently & softly like a little girl i can escape all scrutiny & people will protect me".
Need to tape what these jokers say, so they can't deny what they've said.
jUST LIKE A KID THAT DID NOT DO THEIR SCHOOL HOMEWORK. nAUGHTY NAUGHTY
SEN. J PATERSON...SPOT ON, LET THE PEOPLE LEARN THE TRUTH.....
The Chair is all over the little things, but, doesn't care that our once pretty good country is going to the shit-house !
No wonder the country is broke
I’m so glad thousands of people are watching these useless bureaucrats and when people get angry enough they’ll lose their jobs.
Murray watts is just a grub too
it is really simple. Yes or No. By obfuscating as she does, i personally read that as a NO answer, with regards to the Australian people being kept in the loop.
All you need to know about the socialist Australian Labor lead public servants.
She departs from commitments to Ministers and Senators. This ineffective inefficient dunce-headed overpaid inept bureaucrat should be sacked. Im sure you could find a person at Job network that would carry out her role perfectly well for a fraction of the cost. Out you go!!
A classic public servant 😅
I’m sick of the chair running cover for these incompetent public servants
Unbelievable stuff from labor.
Oh! My god and we pay these people what a joke As Mr Dutton said he would look at all Bureaurats when he wins prime minister ship
The chair is another leftie public servant who has made it up the ladder! Fancy that ? 😂
She should retire
No she should be sacked
So, integrity and transparency does'n't exist in Govt.
No wonder so much tax payers money is wasted and nothing ever gets done and when it does, its over budget and not needed. Too many people in politics milking the system, we need a good cleansing, the system needs to change where people working for the tax payer are held accountable.
That 'Chair' is obnoxious and should be reported for unparliamentary admonishment of a Senator. Totally out of line.
She's obviously past her use-by date. Out she goes.
The incompetent Murray Watt riding rough shod i see.
School yard bully attitude comes to mind 🤔
Weasels the lot of them
Interesting, especially considering the leaked document from Albo's office to the department heads on how to avoid any serious inquiries from the Senate. A Labor minister continues to uphold it's ingrained culture of bullying/intimidation & their lack of transparency....
The chair is clearly bias
DEI working its magic throughout our public service
Who's the Chair related to? Besides Colonel Sanders.. she's got a chip (without chicken salt for once) on her shoulder for sure..
Her time to shine.
Stone walling
The responses given are pathetic at best and bordering on criminal negligence. The chair is not supporting or requiring that appropriate questions be answered. Sack these incompetents and thank god Senator Patterson has the public interest foremost for the Australian public.