This interviewer is just pathetic. She is all over the place with no idea what she is talking about. She should have done more research before talking with Mr. Mahbubani. Very disappointing interview.
**Totally agreed your views. The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
The interviewer has no knowledge about China and Chinese per se. Yes, India is afraid to open its economy to the outside world that's why it is still falling behind China. She also talk about the border issue.
**Totally agreed your views. The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
Agreed! She is very hostile and angry, I think he sensed her animosity through out the interview too. The score from 1-10 which 10 is the highest , hers is 1.
With people like this lady in India with such biased attitude, it seems the PM has his work and hands tied up or risk losing support among his Indian nationalist supporters.
When you are already very strong in your own view on certain issues, dont be an interviewer. You try to impose and not explore. Thats very rude to your guest. On the other hand, Kishore is very diplomatic (being a diplomat for over 30 years).
The profit margins from these mergers or investments or acquisitions are favoring the Chinese companies a lot and on this scale of.massive Chinese money pouring into her economy.so the average Indian stands to benefit more from a local company than a foreign one.
Hats off to Prof Kishore for his understanding of geopolitics and the responses together with historical situations he gave for the queries asked in this interview. He was smiling throughout the interview and kept his head cool and shown how diplomats must conduct their business.
It is very likely that might happen in India. Since India and some African countries are the only countries who's people live with animals; Has worst health system in the world. After all it has been transferred from animals to humans.
actually only india media talk about this, chinese media never mention this. your country is in mess, anti-china have market in your country, that's not healthy.
These comments make me sad. Japan killed millions of Chinese and still have territorial disputes yet they continue to do business properly. Same between Japan and South Korea, and as he said Vietnam-China. We Indians are too emotional. The other asian countries are pragmatic. They can separate economics and politics. I guess we will continue to be poor for a long time with such irrationality.
Agree. For eg, shouldn't burn other country's president's picture or flag. (Maybe can accept if burn TV n old laptop and hand phone). One of the reasons why president Xi cut off the border conflict news from their general population ( those majority with no vpn) or disclose casualties was so that their people won't do emotional things that they regret and cannot take back or say emotional or disrespectful statements that hurt the other.
She is no kid...But one with a loaded mindset n ideology. You can never wakes up one who pretends to be sleeping....Or pretending to be drunk like India.
**Totally agreed your views. Yep. The Modi's government is pretending they're the "banana without skin" !** **The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias, childish or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
She must have been smart to the extent she knows she needs to read many books. She has shown what she has achieved so far, and demonstrated that she will need to read a lot more.
@@Robertsmith001 Because China has more important things to do like continuing developing its economy and technology. If China become much more strong than US, Taiwan will be back without a actual war. What India is doing now? Blaming China? That can not make India stronger.
These 2 giants i.e. 🇨🇳 and 🇮🇳 have century-old, deep-rooted link and influence to 🇰🇭---civilization e.g. diplomatic, economy, language, culture, and religion, etc. When these 2 giant-neighbors, both are respectful friends of 🇰🇭, it hurt in our (🇰🇭) heart❗
Since being released from servitude to Britain in 1947, India has chosen a path that means playing all the world's powers against each other as a matter of survival. For the World powers, committed to the game of brinksmanship, it means they can't trust anything India says or does. India is a nuclear power, to the chagrin of Washington D.C., which means India is not so easy to order around. For India, with its enormous population, this means not being taken for granted anymore. Few of the other countries on Earth have adopted and perfected such a stance.
That's why India should not be too cosy yet with the West. We should ask China to release their territorial claims in return of Indian neutrality during the upcoming cold War
Interviewer herself is not objective n try to load the discussion. Obviously she is not too pleased with what she hear. Many people like her n that's why India will never overcome it's emotions.
**Totally agreed your views. The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
**Totally agreed your views. The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
I don’t know this lady. But I want to make a few guesses: 1. This lady should have received a college education in the United Kingdom or the United States, which made her very pro-western. 2. Through the lady’s hair color and dress, I think she should aspire to be a white, not a dark-skinned Indian.
**Totally agreed your views. The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting** **However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. **Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
@@ph1688 Kishore had an interview with another Indian interviewer, she had the same attitude, if all Indian have the same mentality, this will be India's downfall.
Then you should learn more on 1962 War, Tibetan crisis of 1959, Dalai Lama's arrival to India. Do you know why we read history in school? So the same mistake is not repeated again.
You are free to think whatever you want but you already knew now what world thinks of CCP China. There must be a reason why entire world is upset with you. Eventually you will end up with what you deserve. This is the tipping point.
Never mind. We will liberate you from wuhan virus by 2023. On economy : readvthe latest. India is already recovering from wuhan virus. More than 60 ambassadors visited our vaccine mfg facility 4 days back. Lessons to learn
I respect Kishore's knowledge and wisdom and admire his maturity in handling this this unprofessional and annoying interviewer. What prevents India and China from fostering warm and very cordial relations...on both sides? In India the bureaucracy is the suspect which is scared of loosing the power and grip on politicians and the country. Politicians rely on them heavily at all levels for critical information because most of them are not smart enough to comprehend policy papers or even file briefings. PM Modi tried to change it but quickly gave up. In China, it may be the generals who dream of their country as another policeman enforcing its will and power across the world since PLA controls virtually everything in its soil. In India the "babus" fear loosing their relevance if India upgrades its crumbling third world infrastructure and emerge as an economic/military superpower with China's help. China's economic transformation in a short span of time is unprecedented in the recorded history of mankind. There is no reason to suspect that India cannot replicate China's economic miracle in may be even a shorter time span.
I think she does represents the majority of the views of the Indian people. It is unfortunate the arrogant of sugar candy from the West has blinded a lot of human beings. Of course propaganda for nationalism for votes, has stop the people from seeing truth and self evaluations. Mr Modi is trying to reform India for going into the next century, but the very slogan that help him elect also working against his will to reform India. Reform is painful but the pain is short term, wheres his election victory is back by the working class and farming mass.
Emotional soup and economics is mixed here ! She is asking perfectly what are the solutions for the problems we have ! We have mixed emotions and economics that’s why the questions are like that ! It’s called discussion according the context
**Totally agreed your views. Yep. The Bodi's government is pretending they're the "banana without skin" !** **The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
Don't blame the lady . India is blarring propoganda 24/7 against china. India did a big change in status of ladakh and Kashmir .the home minister said in their parliament . He will give his life and take aksai chin and Tibet from China . China just in it territory protecting it and in five years it will make moving and commuting in that area world class services for people to live do business vacation and enjoy
Except for the Chinese geopolitics and economics is two sides of the same coin. China is hell - bent on economic and military dominance irrespective of the harm it does in the process.
@@ravisharma167 go and check how many US military bases are there in the globe. If you don't have any idea, go and watch John Pilger's documentary "the coming war on China". Now talking about economic dominance, China as a country is moving forward in every sector of life. Do you want China to stop their economic activity for the sake of America? Every country in this world wants to move forward. Let me ask you a simple question: If your country is surpassing the western countries in economy, do you really want your country to stop prospering? What's harm in prospering and leading the country to a developed status. Don't act like a British Derivative.
This is the problem with India, so pedantic, even at the end the woman has to quib Chinese troops on Indian soil....focusing on the trees and not the woods as Prof Mahbubani has spend the last hour trying to put across.
@Prince p How is it that China is dangerous while it seldom involve itself in wars since independent? While US as a democracy country involved itself in over 200 wars since independent?
😓😓Everyone knows we are still a poor country. every day we talking about china. but nothing do anything. look Shanghai, Shenzhen, Guangzhou, Beijing, and hong kong cities. these are another world like usa. first, we need to develop our country economy. China is a powerful country after usa now. we cannot fight with china's economy, technology, and military power. this is the reality if we like or not.🙁 china gdp -$15.2 trillion(2020) indian gdp -$2.6 trillion(2020)😑 India and China had the same GDP and GDP per capita in 1950, today China's GDP is more than five, six times that of India. we are both the same population.🤷♀️ china gdp per capita -$10,261 (2019) india gdp per capita -$2104 (2019)😑 we cannot develop our country using media. media is media. Bangladesh gdp per capita is better than us.😡 But we always thinking fight with china. we are not the same level. this is the reality if we like or not. Am i wrong.🤷♀️
Sadly India is largely influenced by the China threat narrative which was created by the US with an insidious agenda only benefit the oligarchies. Time to wake up, my Indian bro!
@@charlieq4255Modi understands ...I believe. But like all Democratic system, it's tough to balance all interest parties. This is a big problem in modern democratic system where voices don't necessarily the best interest of a country as a whole, but different pockets of people.
I’m a Malaysian Chinese working in an MNC in Singapore. Throughout my growing life in Malaysia and working exposure in Singapore, I encountered many Chinese and Indians from Malaysia, Singapore and India. I believe if we can put aside nationalism and ethnicity, and share common goals, we can achieve many great things together. Geopolitics is complex, very complex for ordinary people like us. But Mr. Kishore said it right, focus on growing the economy first. The border issue will not go away anytime soon. To keep harping on this and miss out on other opportunities, it’s short-sighted and put India on greater disadvantage in future. I truly believe that prosperity for entire Asia is much better than just for a single country.
She perfected the look of "indignant incomprehension". Whenever Mabubahni say something substantial, she puts that expression on her face. She should really copyright it and sell it to Western progressives and baizuo.
Its so obvious that orof Kishore is trying to talk in the easiest way possible with the simplest world to allow that lady to understand what he is talking. Like a adult talking to a small kid. IQ difference is real
I don’t know this lady. But I want to make a few guesses: 1. This lady should have received a college education in the United Kingdom or the United States, which made her very pro-western. 2. Through the lady’s hair color and dress, I think she should aspire to be a white, not a dark-skinned Indian.
" democracy like ours" this lady is still in the colonialism mentality. as if democracy is and was India's savior. she is the reason why India cant reaches its potential. the elite Indians who hold on to colonial power and lead, influence the emotional lower class
@@KirbyZhang if you surf the comment boards in some india - china relationship topic videos, majority indians talk about chinese products like this way. adopt a western tune with a ridiculous self-confidence
@@Sammy58328 Chinese people dont give a shit about rankings made by western institutes. I remember USA was ranked no. 1 in prepareness of dealing with future pandemic in 2018, LMAO
Chinese are used to everything being smooth and comfortable for their leaders. Indians are used to asking questions and making things uncomfortable because that sometime leads to new places.😉
Mr Cosmos No....he is not wasting his time.......he is educating her....he is giving her much broader vision which she clearly lacks.....she had also not done the homework.....if she had done some research in advance of this interview on ASEAN & RCEP by reading Kishore's books, she would have fared slightly better, I think.
Actually her behavior made this points more urgent and rational, the perfect foil for the message he is getting across. I am sure it wasn't intentional though.
@Shiv Chandra Sahu I do not know about him.. But I am fully FOR free trade.. But the Goods applicable for free trade should not destroy the domestic market.. See all over the world.. Google & see how many industries was destroyed in the US & around the world due to China's cheap pricing.. Having a free trade agreement with China is like having a free trade agreement with the DEVIL himself.. We might think we are winning, But actually we will be digging our own grave.. See how the US & Australia got in to a relationship with China, Now they cannot De-couple it.. It will be forced & painful Amputation if they want to completely De-couple from China's dependence today. China is too cunning for any legitimate country to have a Win-Win relationship.. Period.
@Shiv Chandra Sahu I dont Fully understand what you are saying..Hope u r not part of Chinese propaganda machinery. But Yes, USA is not destroyed.. But heavily damaged, Let me give certain points # With no other country US has such trade defeciany of $350B.. So are most other countries.. Eg., Aus, Srilanka, Pakistan, Vietnam, Venezuela etc.. # The above happened because China is a Very Very Smart BUT Cunning country.. US is not stupid, But they were blinded by China's Gimmicks & deception for almost 30years. # China will crub your freedom of speech, They will even meddle with the country's Internal matters too.. See the recent letter to Aus by China.. Describing how Aus should treat China to have better trade relations.. This is downright Anarchy on a another sovereign country.. # Pakistan has become a colony of China, Its like a slave now. # China plays safe only with US, Because it still needs US for bettering its economy further. All other country's are use & throw for China, Including India.. Again Aus is a good example for the above.
@Shiv Chandra Sahu Yes, So is China & USA.. USA trusted China blindly now they are suffering for the same. You want India to end up exactly like it? India to lose freedom of speech? India to lose its sovereign integrity? We Indians have had very bad experience of invasions, We enabled the invaders to invade us.. Eg., How we let in British for Trade.. I hope you dont want more examples..
@@manofsan He remains as unbiased as possible throughout, and as he said, he does not let emotions take hold of him so he does not confine himself within the mindset of a single nationality, so calling him a traitor shows how hostile you are to change or even a different perspective. You miss the point, just because he criticises India does not mean he supports China, and vice versa. He does not say China is a successful nation, he only uses the development of China as an example in order to emphasise the problems in India. In fact, he only mentioned China because it was instigated by the lady who was interviewing him. This video isn't about China, it never was. Its entire message was to encourage Indians to give up a sense of self-worth and open up relations and see that anti-Chinese sentiment is only hurting the free market economy in India, and gave example of countries that benefited through cooperation with their enemies, like Vietnam, in which he specifically says that India should take advantage of China like how China took advantage of the large American market. You are falling for the same fatal error as the one Kishore suggests, you are so focused on defending the negatives that in the end you won't want to change existing issues.
@@manofsan I like his concept of geopolitics as a cold hard calculation, in which he put some fantastic examples in such as the relationship between Vietnam and China as a model in which India could potentially follow, such that he criticises existing perceptions of correlation between international relationships to relationships on a personal level.
@@manofsan There is your first mistake, assuming he supports China. No no no, he is criticising India. Every country receives criticism. If this was another video to show how India is growing with double digit growth rate, then it serves no purpose. That doesn't benefit anyone, that doesn't teach anyone anything. If you didn't want to hear criticism, didn't want to learn anything , then why did you go click on this video? There are plenty of videos talking about the good in India. This is merely a video talking about the aspects that need improvement, it's a shame these videos aren't more common. A countries success has a direct correlation with the amount of criticism it receives. The more powerful a country is, the more countries that hate it and criticise it
@@Sammy58328 Yea everything sucks but at least we have our freedom of press. Yea that freedom of press is really helping you country lol. You cant even think for your own, even the white man control the way you think.
As a supporter of Modi and BJP myself I share the same disappointment with respect to China relation. Both India and China have been exploited by the Anglo Saxon West for 200 years. China is finally on the verge of avenging their century of humiliation against West. And India is on the wrong side of the game. It's the same divide and rule strategy on Asia level. India should support China to its rise and create a multi polar world countering the West.
@@dnhdfnfkrjxjxfjjggj3002 How many more Indians were killed by the Brits during their occupation. How sad that the Stockholm syndrome is alive and well among Indians today. Asians need to overcome differences and compete with the west.
@@HKChineseCanadian no stockholm syndrome is present in Indians. In fact we hate britishers more than you do(for opium war ). We have good relations with Chinese people and will surely have in future too. Also we dont have problems with other asian countries(except few) whereas China has problems and disputes with majority of them. Now who is stopping and being problematic for cooperation bw asian countries. Huh🤨🤨🤨🤨🤨
@@dnhdfnfkrjxjxfjjggj3002 I agree that border dispute was a huge strategic blunder from China's side. They made enemy out of a close and neutral neighbour for small piece of not important mountain pass. And India should fight back on that front. Remind China that it's in China's interest to learn to compromise for its long strategic goals.
@@wilsonpecker6422 yup and if you see India strategy it has no problem with china rise and prefer cooperation over competition but for china it is vice versa
**Totally agreed your views. Yep. The Modi's government is pretending they're the "banana without skin" !** **The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
Yes. The mindset should be like CCP. If you speak against CCP, you will be jailed, tortured, harvest your organs and can be killed. Even the composer of your national anthem Tian Han is escaped from the great CCP mindset. So is Nobel laureate Liu Xiaobo.
**Totally agreed your views. The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting.****However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
@@rahulray9983 Kishore is praising China in which aspects? He is basically analysing facts, and give advice. Bear in mind, as Kishore pointed out, China and India were in the same position in the 80s, and now China GDP is 5 times of India. Any people on this earth has the right of enjoying decent life, as what average people in western countries live in
@@manofsan Worst kind of traitor? How is Kishore a traitor? Kishore is a Singaporean, so he's not picking sides at all. He just so happens to be speaking the truth that you don't want to hear.
to any foreigners of china - anybody that supports china is brave and brillant will be loved by china man , anybody that does not support china is stupid will be hated by china man. this is no longer what is right and what is wrong world , this is a who wants china love world , you want china love you know what to do .
The is the second video that I watched Kishore being interviewed by 2 different hot-headed, biased, loud-mouth Indian women. He responded with wealth of knowledge, calm and integrity 👍
**Totally agreed your views. Yep. The Modi's government is pretending they're the "banana without skin" !** **The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias, childish or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
Not all Indians. There are those who view China as a long partner in terms of trade and many other scales, like Mr. Kishore and then we have her, who is basically you know, "China is the greatest enemy India has and America is our greatest ally". There are many who understand propaganda. ✌️🇮🇳🤝🇨🇳
Chinese (not just China) have the best of both ancient civilizations' philosophical thinking. Confucianism, Taoism and Hinduism/Buddhism. Unfortunately India have lost connection with Asian neighbours with wrong assumptions about communist China. People in China still chant sutras in Sanskrit.
CCP effectively tried to destroy Buddhism and Confucianism during the Cultural Revolution. I don't see ancient Chinese philosophy driving much of Chinese thought these days. It's Communism combined with capitalism in order to maximize profit and power for the state.
**Totally agreed your views. Yep. The Modi's government is pretending they're the "banana without skin" !** **The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias, childish or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
**Totally agreed your views. Yep. The Modi's government is pretending they're the "banana without skin" !** **The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
We are quite cosy with our other Asian brothers except China and Pakistan who keep claiming Indian territories and have created a proxy Anti Indian alliance.
Don't ask for advice if you don't have intention to accept. Just asking Kishore for the sake of asking. They will still stick to their centuries old mindset.
@@limchyehock6722 Yes. The mindset should be like CCP. If you speak against CCP, you will be jailed, tortured, harvest your organs and can be killed. Even the composer of your national anthem Tian Han is escaped from the great CCP mindset. So is Nobel laureate Liu Xiaobo.
Kishore has given excellent advice to Indian - control your emotions. It’s irony is that the world greatest democracy is hijacked by high level of emotion, while China, the world greatest authoritarian society, suppress the emotion. In democracy, politicians and media thrive on fanning emotions. If Vietnam were a democracy, it might not be able to keep anti Chinese sentiment in check.
@阿孚 Debate has merits of pro and con, factual and substances. Hers is accusations and bias provoking rebuttal. Fortunately, she faced a highly respected and competent leader to be able to expose her planned agenda! He agenda - That is to tarnish the reputation of the Chinese Leaders.
China offered 3 times for the border settlement in the past, 1st Chou En-Lai, 2nd Deng Zhao Ping and finally Hu Jintao; India refused all of them and now asking for the statement. Chinese says, why didn't you accepted on that time?
By rebuilding trust means rebuilding political dialogue about strategic issues, even there won't be any result coming out of it. Arguing about facts will never solve the issue, because you will always have tow different facts from both sides against each other. The real question is whether India and china have the political will to talk and make progress dealing with the border issues.
Prof Kishore has a very high IQ and EQ level. I can relate to it. Its basically a result of mixing indian, chinese and western brains together. Bamm, you’re next level.
@@shakerbrigade8321 Listen to him carefully...He has many a times criticized China objectively not blindly nor emotionally. Sad that many people choose to do selective listening.
@@shakerbrigade8321 Why Singapore is more developed than China,because it got the main point early than China and China got the main point ,India didn't .
**Totally agreed your views. Yep. The Modi's government is pretending they're the "banana without skin" !** **The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
**Totally agreed your views. Yep. The Modi's government is pretending they're the "banana without skin" !** **The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
6:01 Mahbubani: "9 of the SEA countries have Indic culture." In point of fact, ancient relics of Indian empires have been unearthed in Malaysia which long long predate the arrival of the self-proclaimed "sons of the soil" Malay majority ethnic group to present-day Malaysia. So Mahbubani is spot on. That entire landmass stretching from Myanmar, Thailand, Vietnam to the north all the way down south to Singapore is not known in geography books as Indochina for no reason. It harks to the historical influence of the two civilisations in this part of the world.
Kishore had already told her that Modi officially said no Chinese soldier entered the Indian territory, why this lady keeps talking about the border issue? Fool
She's an editor of The Print. Don't take that as an example of India's media. The print is propagandist and they want paint it like China is this sort of "evil dragon" and India is "warrior nation". She's biased right here.
india is always a laggard, always not ready, always talk too much n do little india is only interested in joining EU n security council.....anyway good for RCEP or else india will become a stumbling block to the organisation......
@@HoneyBadgerz ,why shld i b sour ? india has much to lose, not RCEP countries or else they wont even think of signing such cooperation agreement....india chicken out coz she cannot compete
Intricate economic ties will just ease the conflict in whatever forms. However, refraining from talking or cooperating with each other will only intensify the conflicts. Indians think China is intruding their borders. Chinese think exactly the same as the place called South Tibet is now in actual Indian rule. As professor Kishore says, stop focus only on the superficial impasse that has zero solution. Rather, move on to cooperation. China and Indian should send more exchange students and scholars to learn and understand better about each other. They should develop tourism relationship with each other as well see how prosperous Indian culture including Buddhism is cherished in China.
You're very observant. Good for you.👍👍 China did not just open to foreign investment, China reformed its political system n transformed her mkt economy using Chinese characteristics. They don't follow blindly like India.
@@wunhonglee8952, you're correct. In late 1970's, Xiaoping visited Spore, Japan, n Korea. (later visited US). He saw for himself the economic prosperity of these Asian nations. Japan n S.Korea are close to US so instead he asked LKY of Spore what was his secret that made Spore very successful. How did a very small country like Spore become one of the top developed countries in the world? Foreign investment, said LKY. Spore has no minerals to sell, no oil, no major agricultural products, nothing. Just hardworking n educated workforce. Foreign investment promote economic development with favorable tax policies n free trade incentives. When TXP returned to China, he was very careful not to make drastic changes bcos there were strong resistance from the old Chinese Communist top leaders. He had to devise a slow n steady change and revamp the Chinese Communist thinking. That's how the "black cat" economic slogan was born. He must also test the economic theory so that big mistake like what Mao did will not happen again. That's why he chose Shenzhen as an economic corridor bcos it was near HK n near the coast for port development. If he failed, the pain will be confined to Shenzhen only, not the whole of China. It is like taking a small sample of the food to test it, make sure it is good to eat b4 you start eating everything. The rest is history - it doesn't matter if it is a black cat or white cat as long as it catches the mouse 😀😉. He also slowly reformed the political system, moving closer to Socialism with Chinese culture as a central theme. Slowly the Chinese population enjoy unprecedented freedom n a disciplined educated workforce like Spore. Spore provided the economic model but it was tweaked and remodeled by Xiaoping to fit China's model. LKY was a lawyer trained in UK. TXP was trained in France. Both were very pragmatic. I'm pretty sure TXP grapple with this question: Is the political system determine the economic structure of a country? Or the economic structure determines the political system of a country? In the US, it has shifted. It appears the economic structure determines the political system of US. Why? Mega corporations control politics using economic power. BTW, I'm not fr China. Just ovesea Chinese with UK n US advanced education.
@@wunhonglee8952, that's news. I did not know that. TXP was an economic genius and a practical man. LKY told him not to be afraid to accept mistakes made, learned from it n changed course to correct the actions. Failure is the nurse of wisdom. China became the 2nd largest economy in the world within 30 - 40 yrs. No country in the human history has ever developed at such a phenomenal speed. The US became independent in 1776, n after WWII in 1945, 169 yrs later became the largest economy in the world. By 2050, China will pass the US economy. TXP would never dream that China's economic miracle is so fast at geometric progression bcos he has no idea about geometric progression speed in technological advancement. Perhaps, you want to know how does geometric progression work. But, he lays the foundation. That's why TXP will go dwn in history as the father of modern China. Graphic presentation of economic development fr 1800 - 2040. th-cam.com/video/4-2nqd6-ZXg/w-d-xo.html
Respect Kishore M presentation. Presumptuous question rebuttal smoothly by him in some of the interviews. A very insightful person without mixing facts with allegations.He defined clearly on neutral stand.
India, India, you cannot expect others to give in to u . You have to solve your problems, not asking others for favour .No one could become great by doing simple , easy things without working hard.
India has its position n point of view, so does it's neighbors. China has strong views too on why it's holding strong on its position. Unless both come together n focus on areas of mutual benefits, putting aside differences for now, the world will not progress.
@James Lum lol. You tried mate. You had the advantage of surprise, but still couldn't succeed. Your govt was too scared to even reveal casualty numbers. With what exactly will you march to new delhi? That overglorified police force you call PLA? Please. You tried twice in 2020, were repelled both times. If you have any sense, you would wait for atleast 20 years before trying again.
@@YohannesKristiawan well china has had a habit of begging USSR. One time Russia does not intervene, and lo and behold China is crying all over town. Even taiwan is insulting china nowadays, just how hopeless are you guys 😂😂
She lives in her own world, on the other hand, Kishore grew up in Singapore, Canada and New York as an ambassador of Sg in the United Nations. The main reason why China appointed president Xi for life because they wanted him to finish his projects which have multi-years to accomplish.
No the main mistake of Indians is not to see China as competitor but to see China as evil. That’s the black and white mindset Indians inherited from the west. If China were seen as a competitor Indians know how to negotiate and compete. But when you see China as evil there can be no negotiation.
The interviewer painting India as the perfect guy. In any border disputes, both parties claim that their rights is being violated. She insists China is sitting on India land. Then she goes on and say that it’s ok for Singapore to be clean coz Singapore is small and has large expat population. OMG! With all these excuses, how one is going to progress and improve with this kind of mind set. There she goes again ..but they don’t want to treat others as equal. Obviously she doesn’t seem very intellectual, maybe it’s her prejudices that is stopping her from being rational. 🤦♀️ She keeps on dragging him into agreeing with her narratives.
Indias policies are being dictated by US . We have no policy . Dr Mabhubami is so sharply right. We should not be diffident and getting shrunk .PM Modi is constrained by his RSS big boss. India has failed to excercise sound geopolitics and understand realpolitik . PM Modi lost diplomatic space in Afghanistan by looking back at US for orders ! Indian Mitary Veterans .
First class interviewee but Third class interviewer. Obviously she is politically motivated, refused to accept any negative feedback about India. I am sad that India is full of this calibre of intellectuals. My hope for better India diminishing each day.
Indian army crossed the line and occupied Chinese lands in last Doklam standoff for a month but China only warned not fought back, populist Modi showed to Indians he's tough guy and that really helped Modi to get votes in election, finally Indian army withdrew peacefully, Xi visited India shaked hands with Modi and Modi also visited China, relationship seemed recovered well..but Modi tried to repeat again to cross into Chinese land and beat Chinese because Modi had Trump as friend also he wanted to shift focus on failed pandemic control, this time Chinese army fought back can't let Indians occupied one month again, then you see 3 Indians died in a fistfight and 17 Indian died in river or cold, Modi was surprised this time China fought back so he lost face to its Indian nationalists, so he said Chinese didn't crossed the line, but Indians can't accept it's Indian army crossed the line and got killed, that's how populism went out of control, then India keeps saying China is invader expansionist, so how did Indian die in Chinese territory?
@@Robertsmith001 China figures India accepts the British imperialism view on Asia and acts upon the imperialism towards China, Sikkim and other countries. pls don't say Sikkim liked the idea. that was a forced annexation. Sikkim was a corrupt country... India had to... India can defend like this. UK said the same thing. China believes that India is proud to have been colonized as part of British empire.
@LanceS I'm not familiar with Sikkim, but your depiction of Tibetans as having neither their culture, language, nor religion intact is factually incorrect. Tibet is modernizing, but both the Chinese central government and the Tibetan autonomous government have invested heavily and continue to invest in the protection and preservation of Tibetan culture, including the Tibetan language.
@LanceS where you get your sources with made up claims? that is the reason why India will never amount to anything, politicians are being elected due to populism and not towards the growth of the country and the populations are sheep that the indian news blindly hate another country similar to its size. there is a saying actions talk louder than words, start by removing the caste system in india for the lower caste to have an even playing field before saying you are the biggest democratic county in the world.
@LanceS I am glad you confirmed the annexation illegal and mentioned Tibet , Republic of China's soil recognized even in London then, which was a dream ticket for British colonizers/Brits to create buffer zone north of British India. Brits enjoyed certain privileges in Tibet, China, such as armed commercial posts, post services and even some unclear diplomatic ties with Tibetan nobles. so-called Davis line and MacMahon line, named after the colonizers, show off their desire. After 1947, Chinese believed that India wanted to inherit the privileges left by colonizers and treat the Asian neighbours like or as the previous imperialist. China, either PRC or ROC, denied any imperialist attempt to corrode Chinese sovereignty. However, Sikkim failed.
I read a few of the bad reviews of this interview. But generally the seemingly bad review is actually not that bad, in fact its enlightening particularly for many Indians, if they truly look at Kishore's answer in correct perspectives: 1. That Indian-China border is an old issue, but will never go away. 2. That Indian, knowing that this issue will never go away, should at the same time, learn to live with it but to move forward and to engage China in a positive way, and to grow Indian Economy as an ultimate aim. 3. Kishore used the term ' creative destruction' on Indian economy status quo just once, but its an important step for the long term good. He should elaborate this more so that the Indian populace can understand the term better. To me it could mean that opening up Indian economy will initially cause some shake-up in the normal Indian industries (or probably sees many many Chinese products will flood the market), but the subsequent new replacement indian industries will be able to compete with the world better. Effectively leads to a better and bigger future economy than the status quo. 4. 'Don't be emotionial'= means do not just look at the recent border event and stopped the important step to engage China which is very important for Indian economy in long term, whether you like it or not. 5. Kishore hinted strongly that all border issue, the quad engagement to go against China, and American's involvement in South China Sea are just geopolitical play, ie. American self interest as primary objective. NOT because American loves India. That was one of the issue why when the interviewer interrupted Kishore so many times with various questions, most are just the same answer.
Why and what does she meant by cheap Chinese products in India? Not most Indian in India afford to buy expensive branded product like her. Surely she's rich and never give a thought fot those that are poor that can't afford expensive goods. Indian products is rarely seen, in this part of the world, certainly would love to find them. Even here rich Indians goes to dollar store to buy Chinese products. Total respect for Kishore Mahbuhani. Bought his book, good read 👍👍
India is finally at the stage where it can become a power player soon with the largest population. However looking at history, it has been sitting on the fence and if that is the best strategy for India -then so be it...Hopefully India will be all on board with BRICS as well as RCEP (withdrew at the last moment because someone promised a bilateral deal which coincidentally fell through) If the leadership thinks West is the way to go - then proceed at full steam ahead... recently someone calculated that good old Britannia reaped $45 trillion of resources from India during the past 200 yrs !!! so the west is not a friend after all....anyway the leaders now have matured and India has to stand for her citizens and not be played by the many goldilocks coming and wooing... if India falls for this then another $45 trillion will be extracted... choose wisely
This interviewer is just pathetic. She is all over the place with no idea what she is talking about. She should have done more research before talking with Mr. Mahbubani. Very disappointing interview.
thank you much. i won't need to waste my time watch this interview. 👍😁
She has outdone Kishore by displaying more books on her shelves than Kishore but not her intelligence.
**Totally agreed your views. The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
The interviewer has no knowledge about China and Chinese per se. Yes, India is afraid to open its economy to the outside world that's why it is still falling behind China. She also talk about the border issue.
Typical Indian kind of view of the world. Always black and white and they always “white”. Mr Mahbubani has been very nice and patient with her
Kishore, my all time favourite speaker. The lady is just interrupting.
**Totally agreed your views. The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
.kishore is proposing a free trade with China. India can pursue a free trade with .Asean without China. No problem with that.
Agreed! She is very hostile and angry, I think he sensed her animosity through out the interview too. The score from 1-10 which 10 is the highest , hers is 1.
@@ph1688 Couldn’t say any better!👍👍👍
@@dt4951 Kishore apologizes for China. He is only looking for profits. Not concerned with Human Rights. Kishore is an evil man.
She has a bigger library but a small mind 😵🤧
No mind chat masala
Only inside boths...
What an analogy. hahah
🤔 maybe it's just wallpaper.. 😂
@@ivan.indrasaputra Epic 😂
the lady interviewer is just making excuses for the India without taking in the facts in her face. she doesn't see it, neither will India.
With people like this lady in India with such biased attitude, it seems the PM has his work and hands tied up or risk losing support among his Indian nationalist supporters.
@@laurencegoh4669 Truth
Indians staying overseas do well because their mentality is different from the Indians living in India. Period.
The host was not being impatient but was emotional as Kishore has said about Indians when it comes to geopolitics.
But that’s still impatient, I mean if u can’t control ur emotion in an interview or conversation like this, why host it?
This woman looks extreme, no wonder India still stay as stooge....
She is reasonable, China hates Indian people like Kishore because it has Western imperialist mindset
She does not speak as a diplomat but as a sincere journalist
she is a rational one among most of indian reporters. so you can image how paranoid of most of them are.
Indian government are more like PROTECTIONIST GANGSTER . LOL
@@Robertsmith001 Reasonable with that combative stance of interviewing ? Think again.
When you are already very strong in your own view on certain issues, dont be an interviewer. You try to impose and not explore. Thats very rude to your guest. On the other hand, Kishore is very diplomatic (being a diplomat for over 30 years).
I would say average India are smart, but those in high place now are just kind of not tackling the issue at the right angle.
Isn't those average vote for even smarter leader? They are democratic country, right... 😀
The profit margins from these mergers or investments or acquisitions are favoring the Chinese companies a lot and on this scale of.massive Chinese money pouring into her economy.so the average Indian stands to benefit more from a local company than a foreign one.
The professor did his best to convey some wisdom to the clueless hostess
Hats off to Prof Kishore for his understanding of geopolitics and the responses together with historical situations he gave for the queries asked in this interview. He was smiling throughout the interview and kept his head cool and shown how diplomats must conduct their business.
do not interrupt when Mr Mahbubani is still talking ! video timer 1:34.. wrong statement "RECP is led by China " -- RCEP is led by ASEAN not China
I wish INDIA will heed or do exactly what the Professor is saying ,because that's the only way forward for INDIA 🇮🇳 ❤❤❤❤
Who broke the trust first. Now the Chinese are saying covid19 originated in india.. build trust, i am tempted to say bs
It is very likely that might happen in India. Since India and some African countries are the only countries who's people live with animals; Has worst health system in the world. After all it has been transferred from animals to humans.
actually only india media talk about this, chinese media never mention this. your country is in mess, anti-china have market in your country, that's not healthy.
These comments make me sad. Japan killed millions of Chinese and still have territorial disputes yet they continue to do business properly. Same between Japan and South Korea, and as he said Vietnam-China. We Indians are too emotional. The other asian countries are pragmatic. They can separate economics and politics. I guess we will continue to be poor for a long time with such irrationality.
Agree. For eg, shouldn't burn other country's president's picture or flag. (Maybe can accept if burn TV n old laptop and hand phone). One of the reasons why president Xi cut off the border conflict news from their general population ( those majority with no vpn) or disclose casualties was so that their people won't do emotional things that they regret and cannot take back or say emotional or disrespectful statements that hurt the other.
Professor is talking to a kid.
She is no kid...But one with a loaded mindset n ideology. You can never wakes up one who pretends to be sleeping....Or pretending to be drunk like India.
He schooled her but I doubt she learnt.
**Totally agreed your views. Yep. The Modi's government is pretending they're the "banana without skin" !** **The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias, childish or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
Kishore appears to be a Chinese puppet. Just get him to criticize Mao he will clamp up.
This lady has to finish reading the books behind her first before she starts her next interview....! She is not qualified to be an interviewer....!!
She must have been smart to the extent she knows she needs to read many books. She has shown what she has achieved so far, and demonstrated that she will need to read a lot more.
Professor Kishore is an amazing diplomat. He approach diplomacy in a mature way, I am amazed that the US and EU still behave like children.
The lady is obsessed with the territory. Then why India did not start the war.
China is obsessed with Taiwan, why China did not start a war?
@@Robertsmith001 Because China has more important things to do like continuing developing its economy and technology. If China become much more strong than US, Taiwan will be back without a actual war. What India is doing now? Blaming China? That can not make India stronger.
These 2 giants i.e. 🇨🇳 and 🇮🇳 have century-old, deep-rooted link and influence to 🇰🇭---civilization e.g. diplomatic, economy, language, culture, and religion, etc. When these 2 giant-neighbors, both are respectful friends of 🇰🇭, it hurt in our (🇰🇭) heart❗
看了评论突然放心了，这个国家该穷，怪不得别人，蠢到无药可救
印度人的自尊心大于他们勇气，不会有大作为的民族。
我看到的更多英文留言的是一种理性
@@mbs4685 这个女人相当可以代表大部分印度人的想法，而这些民粹主义思想左右了他们的政府
Since being released from servitude to Britain in 1947, India has chosen a path that means playing all the world's powers against each other as a matter of survival. For the World powers, committed to the game of brinksmanship, it means they can't trust anything India says or does. India is a nuclear power, to the chagrin of Washington D.C., which means India is not so easy to order around. For India, with its enormous population, this means not being taken for granted anymore. Few of the other countries on Earth have adopted and perfected such a stance.
China ko laddakh, sikkim aur Arunachal pradesh chahiye.
De do trust establish ho jayega.
Agar nahi dena hai to ladna padega
That's why India should not be too cosy yet with the West.
We should ask China to release their territorial claims in return of Indian neutrality during the upcoming cold War
@@wilsonpecker6422 Yes. Absolutely right. This is what is needed to win against China🇨🇳. India can't face China alone at all.
The interviewer keep interrupting, not a good interviewer.
Kishore made so much sense, thumbs up for him, thumbs down for her.
Interviewer herself is not objective n try to load the discussion. Obviously she is not too pleased with what she hear. Many people like her n that's why India will never overcome it's emotions.
She did not listen to a word he said just waiting for her turn to talk. That’s the problem between India and China
she attempted to lead the interviewee the "direction" she wanted, she failed.
**Totally agreed your views. The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
**Totally agreed your views. The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
This lady is the perfect example for Indian Economy
I don’t know this lady. But I want to make a few guesses: 1. This lady should have received a college education in the United Kingdom or the United States, which made her very pro-western. 2. Through the lady’s hair color and dress, I think she should aspire to be a white, not a dark-skinned Indian.
This lady is acting like a crying baby.
She is unclear of geopolitics .
This lady is the reason why India, is way behind China, and will even lose out to Indonesia.
@@jonaswolfxin dark skinned indian? Ugh have you stooped down that low!
She keeps on saying China occupy India land.
The mentality side cannot be overcome.
**Totally agreed your views. The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting** **However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. **Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
@@ph1688 Kishore had an interview with another Indian interviewer, she had the same attitude, if all Indian have the same mentality, this will be India's downfall.
@@kin9225 ...then they're not to cure!
India is occupying Kashimr and Nagaland, etc. She should be ashamed
Then you should learn more on 1962 War, Tibetan crisis of 1959, Dalai Lama's arrival to India. Do you know why we read history in school? So the same mistake is not repeated again.
One important lesson I learn from Kishore Mahbubani is how to handle an interveiw by a narrow minded and short term/single issue interviewer.
Absolutely....She represents many Indian politicians n their narrow mindset. Possessing an ego bigger than its self confidence can accommodate.
You are free to think whatever you want but you already knew now what world thinks of CCP China. There must be a reason why entire world is upset with you. Eventually you will end up with what you deserve. This is the tipping point.
Never mind. We will liberate you from wuhan virus by 2023. On economy : readvthe latest. India is already recovering from wuhan virus. More than 60 ambassadors visited our vaccine mfg facility 4 days back. Lessons to learn
@James Lum lmao just mind ur own biz
@James Lum You are proof that Chinese has Western imperialist mindset
I respect Kishore's knowledge and wisdom and admire his maturity in handling this this unprofessional and annoying interviewer. What prevents India and China from fostering warm and very cordial relations...on both sides? In India the bureaucracy is the suspect which is scared of loosing the power and grip on politicians and the country. Politicians rely on them heavily at all levels for critical information because most of them are not smart enough to comprehend policy papers or even file briefings. PM Modi tried to change it but quickly gave up. In China, it may be the generals who dream of their country as another policeman enforcing its will and power across the world since PLA controls virtually everything in its soil. In India the "babus" fear loosing their relevance if India upgrades its crumbling third world infrastructure and emerge as an economic/military superpower with China's help. China's economic transformation in a short span of time is unprecedented in the recorded history of mankind. There is no reason to suspect that India cannot replicate China's economic miracle in may be even a shorter time span.
This lady is very biased and don't want to face reality.
The Lady is of Anglo Saxon heritage... do I have to say more?
Reality only exist in their ideology, not in real world.
I think she does represents the majority of the views of the Indian people. It is unfortunate the arrogant of sugar candy from the West has blinded a lot of human beings. Of course propaganda for nationalism for votes, has stop the people from seeing truth and self evaluations. Mr Modi is trying to reform India for going into the next century, but the very slogan that help him elect also working against his will to reform India.
Reform is painful but the pain is short term, wheres his election victory is back by the working class and farming mass.
@@hl3369 good insight!
Call that bad interviewer and our mass media is full of them, same as our environment is full of garbage ... Trash !
who is this lady??? she's mixing economics in her emotional soup... why is she the interviewer?
India's top intellectual think-tank, with misplaced ego displaying a wall full of books but empty in her head.
Emotional soup and economics is mixed here ! She is asking perfectly what are the solutions for the problems we have ! We have mixed emotions and economics that’s why the questions are like that ! It’s called discussion according the context
**Totally agreed your views. Yep. The Bodi's government is pretending they're the "banana without skin" !** **The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
@@Albion80s Agreed, There are couple Indians in my company two are like Pompeo and others act like this “miss know it all “. Very annoying!
Don't blame the lady . India is blarring propoganda 24/7 against china. India did a big change in status of ladakh and Kashmir .the home minister said in their parliament . He will give his life and take aksai chin and Tibet from China . China just in it territory protecting it and in five years it will make moving and commuting in that area world class services for people to live do business vacation and enjoy
Kishore tell them the truth, Economics is economics and Geopolitics is Geopolitics
Except for the Chinese geopolitics and economics is two sides of the same coin. China is hell - bent on economic and military dominance irrespective of the harm it does in the process.
@@ravisharma167 Mr kishore Mahubani say there are no black n white. Indian's uses their emotion not cunning, Chinese's uses their clear mind.
@Soldat a/s didn't understand your Comment
Ravi Sharma, spend some money if you have and visit China and see things by yourselves... Living like an ostrich all your life is foolish
@@ravisharma167 go and check how many US military bases are there in the globe. If you don't have any idea, go and watch John Pilger's documentary "the coming war on China".
Now talking about economic dominance, China as a country is moving forward in every sector of life. Do you want China to stop their economic activity for the sake of America? Every country in this world wants to move forward.
Let me ask you a simple question: If your country is surpassing the western countries in economy, do you really want your country to stop prospering?
What's harm in prospering and leading the country to a developed status. Don't act like a British Derivative.
This is the problem with India, so pedantic, even at the end the woman has to quib Chinese troops on Indian soil....focusing on the trees and not the woods as Prof Mahbubani has spend the last hour trying to put across.
Chinese troops on Indian soil is reality, so why deflect from the argument
@@ravisharma167 Do your troop on Pakistan soil?
@@flhong Stupid comment. Learn English first.
@Prince p How is it that China is dangerous while it seldom involve itself in wars since independent? While US as a democracy country involved itself in over 200 wars since independent?
@Prince p maddog won't get mad if people doesn't tease over and over again, to test its patient.
😓😓Everyone knows we are still a poor country. every day we talking about china. but nothing do anything. look Shanghai, Shenzhen, Guangzhou, Beijing, and hong kong cities. these are another world like usa. first, we need to develop our country economy. China is a powerful country after usa now. we cannot fight with china's economy, technology, and military power. this is the reality if we like or not.🙁
china gdp -$15.2 trillion(2020)
indian gdp -$2.6 trillion(2020)😑
India and China had the same GDP and GDP per capita in 1950, today China's GDP is more than five, six times that of India. we are both the same population.🤷♀️
china gdp per capita -$10,261 (2019)
india gdp per capita -$2104 (2019)😑
we cannot develop our country using media. media is media.
Bangladesh gdp per capita is better than us.😡 But we always thinking fight with china. we are not the same level. this is the reality if we like or not. Am i wrong.🤷♀️
As long as one refuses to accept facts and then work on them then the rest of the world can comfortably fold its arms and relax!
Sadly India is largely influenced by the China threat narrative which was created by the US with an insidious agenda only benefit the oligarchies. Time to wake up, my Indian bro!
You said Bangladesh GDP better thsn lndia. What the f**k❗
@@charlieq4255Modi understands ...I believe. But like all Democratic system, it's tough to balance all interest parties. This is a big problem in modern democratic system where voices don't necessarily the best interest of a country as a whole, but different pockets of people.
I’m a Malaysian Chinese working in an MNC in Singapore. Throughout my growing life in Malaysia and working exposure in Singapore, I encountered many Chinese and Indians from Malaysia, Singapore and India. I believe if we can put aside nationalism and ethnicity, and share common goals, we can achieve many great things together.
Geopolitics is complex, very complex for ordinary people like us. But Mr. Kishore said it right, focus on growing the economy first. The border issue will not go away anytime soon. To keep harping on this and miss out on other opportunities, it’s short-sighted and put India on greater disadvantage in future.
I truly believe that prosperity for entire Asia is much better than just for a single country.
India is in Asia not Western country. So behave like an Asian. Forget about USA if India wants to prosper.
They forgot who they are
@Ratan Patel lol you think. I usually dont act this way but the idiocy is too good to pass up.
@Ratan Patel India. That's the joke. You started it with your idiocy lol.
If india want to prosper do as Asian do 😂😂🤣😂 be great india this European don’t count you America always say American first so find new Room guys
USA defended India while China invaded it in the early 1960s.
After seeing a few interviews with Indian hosts' mentality 🤔 it will take at least another generation😌
Very hard to change centuries old mentality. Still full of mistrust.
Perfect product of colonialism... They still say India is superior because it has British government system.
She perfected the look of "indignant incomprehension". Whenever Mabubahni say something substantial, she puts that expression on her face. She should really copyright it and sell it to Western progressives and baizuo.
I think India will soon be 100 years behind China in terms of civilization standard.
China's media houses are best. Long live CCP!
PM Modi has stated categorically and on record that there are no Chinese soldiers on Indian territory....
www.aa.com.tr/en/asia-pacific/china-did-not-enter-indian-territory-pm-modi/1883565
how you expect indian to take note of that when this women ignore her PM and take it as a pinch of salts
India is free to buy more toys and kickbacks for the generals, built a supply line, station its troops at the border through the winter. 👍😁
@@willengel2458 Indian used the Mongolians to fight their battles but yet they don’t considered them as their own people .
How loathe!
@@dt4951 which Mongolians may I ask?
Holy, the interviewer is so narrow minded it was like Kishore was talking to a brick wall.
That was expected. Singapore is rank highest IQ in the world whereas India is very low in rank
Its so obvious that orof Kishore is trying to talk in the easiest way possible with the simplest world to allow that lady to understand what he is talking. Like a adult talking to a small kid. IQ difference is real
The interviewer can’t see the forest for the trees. Her sense of victimization is debilitating.
Don't talk about forests. The interviewer can't even see the tree for the leaves and branches.
yet the trees make up the forest. Without the trees there is no forest.
这个臭傻逼在说啥？
I don’t know this lady. But I want to make a few guesses: 1. This lady should have received a college education in the United Kingdom or the United States, which made her very pro-western. 2. Through the lady’s hair color and dress, I think she should aspire to be a white, not a dark-skinned Indian.
" democracy like ours" this lady is still in the colonialism mentality. as if democracy is and was India's savior. she is the reason why India cant reaches its potential. the elite Indians who hold on to colonial power and lead, influence the emotional lower class
and she talks about "cheap chinese goods" with hate as if she's a westerner and her countrymen make $60k per year.
@@KirbyZhang that's what I mean by elitism within Indian society.
@@KirbyZhang if you surf the comment boards in some india - china relationship topic videos, majority indians talk about chinese products like this way. adopt a western tune with a ridiculous self-confidence
You get what you pay for, dear friend...
@LanceS why does she hate them, the alternative is she would have nothing, lol.
Sorry to Kishore, I had to down vote this video - the interviewer is not in your league and she made the interview very awkward.
The interviewer has an agenda in mind and trys to derail Mr Kishore, but Mr Kishore is a smart man.
Agreed
Atleast there is an interview. And then we have a country in North East of India which ranked 2nd last in Press Freedom Index.
@@Sammy58328 Chinese people dont give a shit about rankings made by western institutes. I remember USA was ranked no. 1 in prepareness of dealing with future pandemic in 2018, LMAO
Chinese are used to everything being smooth and comfortable for their leaders. Indians are used to asking questions and making things uncomfortable because that sometime leads to new places.😉
Kishore wasting his time with this lady.
Mr Cosmos
No....he is not wasting his time.......he is educating her....he is giving her much broader vision which she clearly lacks.....she had also not done the homework.....if she had done some research in advance of this interview on
ASEAN & RCEP by reading Kishore's books, she would have fared slightly better, I think.
Actually her behavior made this points more urgent and rational, the perfect foil for the message he is getting across. I am sure it wasn't intentional though.
I ran out of all the words to curse this lady.
😂😂😂😂
Yes Why?
@Shiv Chandra Sahu I do not know about him.. But I am fully FOR free trade..
But the Goods applicable for free trade should not destroy the domestic market..
See all over the world..
Google & see how many industries was destroyed in the US & around the world due to China's cheap pricing..
Having a free trade agreement with China is like having a free trade agreement with the DEVIL himself..
We might think we are winning, But actually we will be digging our own grave..
See how the US & Australia got in to a relationship with China, Now they cannot De-couple it..
It will be forced & painful Amputation if they want to completely De-couple from China's dependence today.
China is too cunning for any legitimate country to have a Win-Win relationship.. Period.
@Shiv Chandra Sahu I dont Fully understand what you are saying..Hope u r not part of Chinese propaganda machinery.
But Yes, USA is not destroyed.. But heavily damaged, Let me give certain points
# With no other country US has such trade defeciany of $350B.. So are most other countries.. Eg., Aus, Srilanka, Pakistan, Vietnam, Venezuela etc..
# The above happened because China is a Very Very Smart BUT Cunning country.. US is not stupid, But they were blinded by China's Gimmicks & deception for almost 30years.
# China will crub your freedom of speech, They will even meddle with the country's Internal matters too.. See the recent letter to Aus by China.. Describing how Aus should treat China to have better trade relations.. This is downright Anarchy on a another sovereign country..
# Pakistan has become a colony of China, Its like a slave now.
# China plays safe only with US, Because it still needs US for bettering its economy further. All other country's are use & throw for China, Including India..
Again Aus is a good example for the above.
@Shiv Chandra Sahu Yes, So is China & USA.. USA trusted China blindly now they are suffering for the same.
You want India to end up exactly like it?
India to lose freedom of speech?
India to lose its sovereign integrity?
We Indians have had very bad experience of invasions, We enabled the invaders to invade us..
Eg., How we let in British for Trade.. I hope you dont want more examples..
Kishore is such a respectful and tolerating mind.
also when the question is stupid，he laughs it off but in a kind way。
@@manofsan Could you give an example of a point you don't agree with? I think it's important to see different perspectives
@@manofsan He remains as unbiased as possible throughout, and as he said, he does not let emotions take hold of him so he does not confine himself within the mindset of a single nationality, so calling him a traitor shows how hostile you are to change or even a different perspective. You miss the point, just because he criticises India does not mean he supports China, and vice versa. He does not say China is a successful nation, he only uses the development of China as an example in order to emphasise the problems in India. In fact, he only mentioned China because it was instigated by the lady who was interviewing him. This video isn't about China, it never was. Its entire message was to encourage Indians to give up a sense of self-worth and open up relations and see that anti-Chinese sentiment is only hurting the free market economy in India, and gave example of countries that benefited through cooperation with their enemies, like Vietnam, in which he specifically says that India should take advantage of China like how China took advantage of the large American market. You are falling for the same fatal error as the one Kishore suggests, you are so focused on defending the negatives that in the end you won't want to change existing issues.
@@manofsan I like his concept of geopolitics as a cold hard calculation, in which he put some fantastic examples in such as the relationship between Vietnam and China as a model in which India could potentially follow, such that he criticises existing perceptions of correlation between international relationships to relationships on a personal level.
@@manofsan There is your first mistake, assuming he supports China. No no no, he is criticising India. Every country receives criticism. If this was another video to show how India is growing with double digit growth rate, then it serves no purpose. That doesn't benefit anyone, that doesn't teach anyone anything. If you didn't want to hear criticism, didn't want to learn anything , then why did you go click on this video? There are plenty of videos talking about the good in India. This is merely a video talking about the aspects that need improvement, it's a shame these videos aren't more common. A countries success has a direct correlation with the amount of criticism it receives. The more powerful a country is, the more countries that hate it and criticise it
Friendship amongst nations is nothing. Only national interest.
That’s called business.
That's called politics 😊
The interviewer is quite hopeless, so obsessed with displaying her Indian bias and constantly interrupting her guest.
Even the intelectual Indians are this way, can you imagine the low-educated ones?
And then we have a country in North East of India which ranked 2nd last in Press Freedom Index.
@@Sammy58328 Yea everything sucks but at least we have our freedom of press. Yea that freedom of press is really helping you country lol. You cant even think for your own, even the white man control the way you think.
@@nsebast Nobel Laurate Liu Xiaobo too agreed to your point.
@LanceS Sorry my IQ cant go as low as you.
As a supporter of Modi and BJP myself I share the same disappointment with respect to China relation.
Both India and China have been exploited by the Anglo Saxon West for 200 years. China is finally on the verge of avenging their century of humiliation against West.
And India is on the wrong side of the game.
It's the same divide and rule strategy on Asia level.
India should support China to its rise and create a multi polar world countering the West.
Yeah and China should kill our 20 ssoldiers by backstabbing
@@dnhdfnfkrjxjxfjjggj3002 How many more Indians were killed by the Brits during their occupation. How sad that the Stockholm syndrome is alive and well among Indians today. Asians need to overcome differences and compete with the west.
@@HKChineseCanadian no stockholm syndrome is present in Indians. In fact we hate britishers more than you do(for opium war ). We have good relations with Chinese people and will surely have in future too. Also we dont have problems with other asian countries(except few) whereas China has problems and disputes with majority of them. Now who is stopping and being problematic for cooperation bw asian countries. Huh🤨🤨🤨🤨🤨
@@dnhdfnfkrjxjxfjjggj3002 I agree that border dispute was a huge strategic blunder from China's side.
They made enemy out of a close and neutral neighbour for small piece of not important mountain pass.
And India should fight back on that front. Remind China that it's in China's interest to learn to compromise for its long strategic goals.
@@wilsonpecker6422 yup and if you see India strategy it has no problem with china rise and prefer cooperation over competition but for china it is vice versa
Remember learn the skill from West but not the mindset.
**Totally agreed your views. Yep. The Modi's government is pretending they're the "banana without skin" !** **The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
Yes. The mindset should be like CCP. If you speak against CCP, you will be jailed, tortured, harvest your organs and can be killed. Even the composer of your national anthem Tian Han is escaped from the great CCP mindset. So is Nobel laureate Liu Xiaobo.
@@Sammy58328 you should go to china and tell them democracy will bring them to heaven and how bad live evil ccp give. ...LOL
@@yourbaba4996 you want him to go to the land of concentration camps and speak against the nazis?
@@anandsingh7366 he deserved. good chance to prove where is the land of concentration camps . have you been there?
its annoying how she kept on interrupting n cutting him off middle of speech.....
You can't blame Her, He does talk a hell of a lot.
Professor Kishore is a true diplomat. He has finally succeeded a bit in opening this lady's mind and hopefully she will be a bit more open minded.
Kishore is a CCP agent to be precise?
Your mind is full of shite
@@petagonkyi Yeah he goes all around the world praising CHINA
**Totally agreed your views. The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting.****However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
@@rahulray9983 Kishore is praising China in which aspects? He is basically analysing facts, and give advice. Bear in mind, as Kishore pointed out, China and India were in the same position in the 80s, and now China GDP is 5 times of India. Any people on this earth has the right of enjoying decent life, as what average people in western countries live in
Thank Kishore! I have learn a lot from your talk, yet again!
Listen to a wise man trained by LKY.
haha, that’s reasonable
My god, he is like teaching a student that refuses to understand or learn
😂😂😂😂
Even the educated Indian is like this, imagine the uneducated one.
@Britswiss Ameri then why act as the puppet of western countries
Western countries have done nothing but looted India
@@manofsan Haters gonna hate. No use discussing anything with people like you.
@@manofsan Worst kind of traitor? How is Kishore a traitor? Kishore is a Singaporean, so he's not picking sides at all. He just so happens to be speaking the truth that you don't want to hear.
Kishore used Modi's words to shut up the lady.
to any foreigners of china - anybody that supports china is brave and brillant will be loved by china man , anybody that does not support china is stupid will be hated by china man. this is no longer what is right and what is wrong world , this is a who wants china love world , you want china love you know what to do .
@John Kang. This woman is definitely no lady !
The is the second video that I watched Kishore being interviewed by 2 different hot-headed, biased, loud-mouth Indian women. He responded with wealth of knowledge, calm and integrity 👍
He always make fair comments
The interviewer..still not get it...even at last still border border border border........omg.....
**Totally agreed your views. Yep. The Modi's government is pretending they're the "banana without skin" !** **The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias, childish or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
I have so much respect for Prof. Kishore Mahbubani for remaining calm, clear and patient throughout this interruptive interview.
The woman listens to react instead of understanding and ask intelligently. Good to know that is Indian negativity about CHINA 🇨🇳
Not all Indians. There are those who view China as a long partner in terms of trade and many other scales, like Mr. Kishore and then we have her, who is basically you know, "China is the greatest enemy India has and America is our greatest ally". There are many who understand propaganda. ✌️🇮🇳🤝🇨🇳
Chinese (not just China) have the best of both ancient civilizations' philosophical thinking. Confucianism, Taoism and Hinduism/Buddhism. Unfortunately India have lost connection with Asian neighbours with wrong assumptions about communist China. People in China still chant sutras in Sanskrit.
so what ?
CCP effectively tried to destroy Buddhism and Confucianism during the Cultural Revolution. I don't see ancient Chinese philosophy driving much of Chinese thought these days. It's Communism combined with capitalism in order to maximize profit and power for the state.
This interviewer is freaking terrible. She cuts him off so much. She's asking paranoid questions about China and Xi. What the hell
**Totally agreed your views. Yep. The Modi's government is pretending they're the "banana without skin" !** **The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias, childish or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
Atleast there is an interview. And then we have a country in North East of India which ranked 2nd last in Press Freedom Index.
Sinophobic news. Very prevalent in the west and india
This woman is a one issue interviewer....keep harping on the one issue that is just one among hundreds....
Just curious how the ' host ' get into her position ? So overly unQUALIFIED ! So highly agitated and unprofessional.
Well....kishore did say they are quite emotional.....
Sadly until now India still love their colonial masters( THE WEST ) more than their Asian brothers !
**Totally agreed your views. Yep. The Modi's government is pretending they're the "banana without skin" !** **The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
We are quite cosy with our other Asian brothers except China and Pakistan who keep claiming Indian territories and have created a proxy Anti Indian alliance.
@Suntree Mat so did I lie about China-Pak allying?
"I want to make a simple point - it is very complex."
Someone please tell her shut. We are here to listen to Kishore.
Don't ask for advice if you don't have intention to accept. Just asking Kishore for the sake of asking. They will still stick to their centuries old mindset.
@@limchyehock6722 Yes. The mindset should be like CCP. If you speak against CCP, you will be jailed, tortured, harvest your organs and can be killed. Even the composer of your national anthem Tian Han is escaped from the great CCP mindset. So is Nobel laureate Liu Xiaobo.
@@Sammy58328 傻逼 BBB
I like Prof Kishore analysis...fair & to the point
Kishore has given excellent advice to Indian - control your emotions. It’s irony is that the world greatest democracy is hijacked by high level of emotion, while China, the world greatest authoritarian society, suppress the emotion. In democracy, politicians and media thrive on fanning emotions. If Vietnam were a democracy, it might not be able to keep anti Chinese sentiment in check.
Wait, is this a debate or an interview?
Not a debate. It is just an interview but this lady showing the world her stupidity. Period.
@阿孚 Debate has merits of pro and con, factual and substances. Hers is accusations and bias provoking rebuttal. Fortunately, she faced a highly respected and competent leader to be able to expose her planned agenda! He agenda - That is to tarnish the reputation of the Chinese Leaders.
I like to listen this guy.
Wtf do you guys mean rebuild trust..when they were the ones who always break it
Capturing aksai chin was Shah's claim in parliament I guess
China offered 3 times for the border settlement in the past, 1st Chou En-Lai, 2nd Deng Zhao Ping and finally Hu Jintao; India refused all of them and now asking for the statement. Chinese says, why didn't you accepted on that time?
@rakesh barman You should not accept. It is India who is asking China to go back. Indian government should stop complaining about it then.
By rebuilding trust means rebuilding political dialogue about strategic issues, even there won't be any result coming out of it. Arguing about facts will never solve the issue, because you will always have tow different facts from both sides against each other. The real question is whether India and china have the political will to talk and make progress dealing with the border issues.
@@Abidkhan-uw9vy you idiot that's the Indian claim according to the parliamentary resolution....
I like Kishore's focus that people with vastly different outlooks can come together and resolve their differences.
Prof Kishore has a very high IQ and EQ level. I can relate to it. Its basically a result of mixing indian, chinese and western brains together. Bamm, you’re next level.
I think people should focus on something more productive and efficient. There are things that are never going to happen.
You can't talk to Indians with reason. you just waste your time.
YES I KNOW,BUT I WANT TO PRACTISE MY ENGLISH AND LOGICS WITH THEM.😂
Yup . Rationality means succumbing to CCP.Well this sort of rationality is only limited to CCP and their bots .
This kishore is known to be on chinease pay roll.I have followed him multiple times and he always present things as if CCP is some kind of avataar .
@@shakerbrigade8321 Listen to him carefully...He has many a times criticized China objectively not blindly nor emotionally. Sad that many people choose to do selective listening.
@@shakerbrigade8321 Why Singapore is more developed than China,because it got the main point early than China and China got the main point ,India didn't .
Kishore is a voice of reason 😁😁😁😁
The Voice of Chingi’s reasoning…
he is the best... from mexico.
These 2 origin are from the same root however their way of thinking towards this issue is galaxy far apart.
**Totally agreed your views. Yep. The Modi's government is pretending they're the "banana without skin" !** **The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
I watch all of Kishore’s videos. The ones he goes up against antagonistic Indian journalists are the most interesting.
**Totally agreed your views. Yep. The Modi's government is pretending they're the "banana without skin" !** **The video meeting hosted by Indian ( country's ) women was interesting. However, the host of the show seems either lacks of up-today experiences, bias or is completely ignorant, ashamed of being part of the public. She is more likely to influence (or uses) prejudice, American style or overly arrogant herself, where she always loses her persistence over the guest. Whether she or her government board obeys the advice of guests or not, they are all helpful, valuable and practical for India without an insult. If I'm not wrong, this is one of the most generous, righteous conversations I have ever seen from Dr. Kishore Mahabubani. All Indians should appreciate him for such great remarks. Don't play Top-Notch When You're Not-Top!**
@@ph1688
You mean coconut, white inside and brown outside ? Or do you mean Mangosteen ?
This lady was listening selectively - sad.
There is a saying that there are no 'last words' when it comes to diplomacy.
6:01
Mahbubani: "9 of the SEA countries have Indic culture."
In point of fact, ancient relics of Indian empires have been unearthed in Malaysia which long long predate the arrival of the self-proclaimed "sons of the soil" Malay majority ethnic group to present-day Malaysia. So Mahbubani is spot on. That entire landmass stretching from Myanmar, Thailand, Vietnam to the north all the way down south to Singapore is not known in geography books as Indochina for no reason. It harks to the historical influence of the two civilisations in this part of the world.
Kishore is great, the woman is some how too usual and too indish
This women is crazy, it’s Indian soldiers crossed the border and your PM Modi had said Chinese solders didn’t cross to Indian territory
Yes, yes eat up the propaganda
Kishore had already told her that Modi officially said no Chinese soldier entered the Indian territory, why this lady keeps talking about the border issue? Fool
She's an editor of The Print. Don't take that as an example of India's media. The print is propagandist and they want paint it like China is this sort of "evil dragon" and India is "warrior nation".
She's biased right here.
@@naiyayika Problem is Indian media is all anti-China. China don't bash India.
india is always a laggard, always not ready, always talk too much n do little india is only interested in joining EU n security council.....anyway good for RCEP or else india will become a stumbling block to the organisation......
Grapes are sour for you.
Indians are happy with India didn't join RCEP
@@HoneyBadgerz ,why shld i b sour ? india has much to lose, not RCEP countries or else they wont even think of signing such cooperation agreement....india chicken out coz she cannot compete
Intricate economic ties will just ease the conflict in whatever forms. However, refraining from talking or cooperating with each other will only intensify the conflicts. Indians think China is intruding their borders. Chinese think exactly the same as the place called South Tibet is now in actual Indian rule. As professor Kishore says, stop focus only on the superficial impasse that has zero solution. Rather, move on to cooperation. China and Indian should send more exchange students and scholars to learn and understand better about each other. They should develop tourism relationship with each other as well see how prosperous Indian culture including Buddhism is cherished in China.
苏苏 Buddhism originated from Nepal
1978 Mr Deng Xiaoping asked, "how to grow China's economy", Mr Lee Kuan Yew replied, "open up China to the world"
You're very observant. Good for you.👍👍
China did not just open to foreign investment, China reformed its political system n transformed her mkt economy using Chinese characteristics. They don't follow blindly like India.
@@HeresMyView its Mr Deng Xiaoping employ the ideas of Mr Lee Kuan Yew.
@@wunhonglee8952, you're correct. In late 1970's, Xiaoping visited Spore, Japan, n Korea. (later visited US). He saw for himself the economic prosperity of these Asian nations. Japan n S.Korea are close to US so instead he asked LKY of Spore what was his secret that made Spore very successful. How did a very small country like Spore become one of the top developed countries in the world? Foreign investment, said LKY. Spore has no minerals to sell, no oil, no major agricultural products, nothing. Just hardworking n educated workforce. Foreign investment promote economic development with favorable tax policies n free trade incentives. When TXP returned to China, he was very careful not to make drastic changes bcos there were strong resistance from the old Chinese Communist top leaders. He had to devise a slow n steady change and revamp the Chinese Communist thinking. That's how the "black cat" economic slogan was born. He must also test the economic theory so that big mistake like what Mao did will not happen again. That's why he chose Shenzhen as an economic corridor bcos it was near HK n near the coast for port development. If he failed, the pain will be confined to Shenzhen only, not the whole of China. It is like taking a small sample of the food to test it, make sure it is good to eat b4 you start eating everything. The rest is history - it doesn't matter if it is a black cat or white cat as long as it catches the mouse 😀😉. He also slowly reformed the political system, moving closer to Socialism with Chinese culture as a central theme. Slowly the Chinese population enjoy unprecedented freedom n a disciplined educated workforce like Spore. Spore provided the economic model but it was tweaked and remodeled by Xiaoping to fit China's model. LKY was a lawyer trained in UK. TXP was trained in France. Both were very pragmatic. I'm pretty sure TXP grapple with this question: Is the political system determine the economic structure of a country? Or the economic structure determines the political system of a country? In the US, it has shifted. It appears the economic structure determines the political system of US. Why? Mega corporations control politics using economic power.
BTW, I'm not fr China. Just ovesea Chinese with UK n US advanced education.
@@HeresMyView from 1978 Mr Deng send over 34,000 youth bright CCP to learns an understudies from the Singapore's govt.
@@wunhonglee8952, that's news. I did not know that. TXP was an economic genius and a practical man. LKY told him not to be afraid to accept mistakes made, learned from it n changed course to correct the actions. Failure is the nurse of wisdom.
China became the 2nd largest economy in the world within 30 - 40 yrs. No country in the human history has ever developed at such a phenomenal speed. The US became independent in 1776, n after WWII in 1945, 169 yrs later became the largest economy in the world. By 2050, China will pass the US economy. TXP would never dream that China's economic miracle is so fast at geometric progression bcos he has no idea about geometric progression speed in technological advancement. Perhaps, you want to know how does geometric progression work. But, he lays the foundation. That's why TXP will go dwn in history as the father of modern China.
Graphic presentation of economic development fr 1800 - 2040.
th-cam.com/video/4-2nqd6-ZXg/w-d-xo.html
Respect Kishore M presentation. Presumptuous question rebuttal smoothly by him in some of the interviews. A very insightful person without mixing facts with allegations.He defined clearly on neutral stand.
India, India, you cannot expect others to give in to u . You have to solve your problems, not asking others for favour .No one could become great by doing simple , easy things without working hard.
India has its position n point of view, so does it's neighbors. China has strong views too on why it's holding strong on its position. Unless both come together n focus on areas of mutual benefits, putting aside differences for now, the world will not progress.
Neither we asks you to solve our problem.
You touch our border.
You will suffer.
No more no less.
@James Lum talk more, plan more, beg more, loose more... 😂
@James Lum lol. You tried mate. You had the advantage of surprise, but still couldn't succeed. Your govt was too scared to even reveal casualty numbers.
With what exactly will you march to new delhi? That overglorified police force you call PLA? Please.
You tried twice in 2020, were repelled both times. If you have any sense, you would wait for atleast 20 years before trying again.
@@YohannesKristiawan well china has had a habit of begging USSR. One time Russia does not intervene, and lo and behold China is crying all over town.
Even taiwan is insulting china nowadays, just how hopeless are you guys 😂😂
She lives in her own world, on the other hand, Kishore grew up in Singapore, Canada and New York as an ambassador of Sg in the United Nations. The main reason why China appointed president Xi for life because they wanted him to finish his projects which have multi-years to accomplish.
Mr.kishor is smart n wise man n he love India so much👍👍👍
The main mistake of Indians is it sees china as the competitor but in reality US is comletitor of China.
No the main mistake of Indians is not to see China as competitor but to see China as evil. That’s the black and white mindset Indians inherited from the west. If China were seen as a competitor Indians know how to negotiate and compete. But when you see China as evil there can be no negotiation.
2 mins into this , i've removed all doubts about the interviwer's intelligence level 🤭
I am watching this for a second time. Kishore is so wise, and the host appears to be very narrow minded.
The interviewer painting India as the perfect guy. In any border disputes, both parties claim that their rights is being violated. She insists China is sitting on India land. Then she goes on and say that it’s ok for Singapore to be clean coz Singapore is small and has large expat population. OMG! With all these excuses, how one is going to progress and improve with this kind of mind set. There she goes again ..but they don’t want to treat others as equal. Obviously she doesn’t seem very intellectual, maybe it’s her prejudices that is stopping her from being rational. 🤦♀️
She keeps on dragging him into agreeing with her narratives.
Indias policies are being dictated by US . We have no policy . Dr Mabhubami is so sharply right. We should not be diffident and getting shrunk .PM Modi is constrained by his RSS big boss. India has failed to excercise sound geopolitics and understand realpolitik . PM Modi lost diplomatic space in Afghanistan by looking back at US for orders ! Indian Mitary Veterans .
if the elites of India were all like this lady, no one could save the indians.
When hate prevail, logic takes the backseat
First class interviewee but Third class interviewer. Obviously she is politically motivated, refused to accept any negative feedback about India. I am sad that India is full of this calibre of intellectuals. My hope for better India diminishing each day.
Indian army crossed the line and occupied Chinese lands in last Doklam standoff for a month but China only warned not fought back, populist Modi showed to Indians he's tough guy and that really helped Modi to get votes in election, finally Indian army withdrew peacefully, Xi visited India shaked hands with Modi and Modi also visited China, relationship seemed recovered well..but Modi tried to repeat again to cross into Chinese land and beat Chinese because Modi had Trump as friend also he wanted to shift focus on failed pandemic control, this time Chinese army fought back can't let Indians occupied one month again, then you see 3 Indians died in a fistfight and 17 Indian died in river or cold, Modi was surprised this time China fought back so he lost face to its Indian nationalists, so he said Chinese didn't crossed the line, but Indians can't accept it's Indian army crossed the line and got killed, that's how populism went out of control, then India keeps saying China is invader expansionist, so how did Indian die in Chinese territory?
Self-respect and arrogance, are the main reasons for the unhappiness of India with China.
China is acting like the western imperialist towards India
@@Robertsmith001 China figures India accepts the British imperialism view on Asia and acts upon the imperialism towards China, Sikkim and other countries. pls don't say Sikkim liked the idea. that was a forced annexation. Sikkim was a corrupt country... India had to... India can defend like this. UK said the same thing. China believes that India is proud to have been colonized as part of British empire.
@LanceS I'm not familiar with Sikkim, but your depiction of Tibetans as having neither their culture, language, nor religion intact is factually incorrect. Tibet is modernizing, but both the Chinese central government and the Tibetan autonomous government have invested heavily and continue to invest in the protection and preservation of Tibetan culture, including the Tibetan language.
@LanceS where you get your sources with made up claims? that is the reason why India will never amount to anything, politicians are being elected due to populism and not towards the growth of the country and the populations are sheep that the indian news blindly hate another country similar to its size. there is a saying actions talk louder than words, start by removing the caste system in india for the lower caste to have an even playing field before saying you are the biggest democratic county in the world.
@LanceS I am glad you confirmed the annexation illegal and mentioned Tibet , Republic of China's soil recognized even in London then, which was a dream ticket for British colonizers/Brits to create buffer zone north of British India. Brits enjoyed certain privileges in Tibet, China, such as armed commercial posts, post services and even some unclear diplomatic ties with Tibetan nobles. so-called Davis line and MacMahon line, named after the colonizers, show off their desire. After 1947, Chinese believed that India wanted to inherit the privileges left by colonizers and treat the Asian neighbours like or as the previous imperialist. China, either PRC or ROC, denied any imperialist attempt to corrode Chinese sovereignty. However, Sikkim failed.
I read a few of the bad reviews of this interview. But generally the seemingly bad review is actually not that bad, in fact its enlightening particularly for many Indians, if they truly look at Kishore's answer in correct perspectives:
1. That Indian-China border is an old issue, but will never go away.
2. That Indian, knowing that this issue will never go away, should at the same time, learn to live with it but to move forward and to engage China in a positive way, and to grow Indian Economy as an ultimate aim.
3. Kishore used the term ' creative destruction' on Indian economy status quo just once, but its an important step for the long term good. He should elaborate this more so that the Indian populace can understand the term better. To me it could mean that opening up Indian economy will initially cause some shake-up in the normal Indian industries (or probably sees many many Chinese products will flood the market), but the subsequent new replacement indian industries will be able to compete with the world better. Effectively leads to a better and bigger future economy than the status quo.
4. 'Don't be emotionial'= means do not just look at the recent border event and stopped the important step to engage China which is very important for Indian economy in long term, whether you like it or not.
5. Kishore hinted strongly that all border issue, the quad engagement to go against China, and American's involvement in South China Sea are just geopolitical play, ie. American self interest as primary objective. NOT because American loves India. That was one of the issue why when the interviewer interrupted Kishore so many times with various questions, most are just the same answer.
Mainland China & Taiwan are, also, an old issue. Yet china has never accepted this. Practice what you preach!
Why and what does she meant by cheap Chinese products in India? Not most Indian in India afford to buy expensive branded product like her. Surely she's rich and never give a thought fot those that are poor that can't afford expensive goods.
Indian products is rarely seen, in this part of the world, certainly would love to find them.
Even here rich Indians goes to dollar store to buy Chinese products.
Total respect for Kishore Mahbuhani. Bought his book, good read 👍👍
I actually don't mind the interviewer being so emotional because it became a good foil for Kishore to emphasis the importance of his message.
India is finally at the stage where it can become a power player soon with the largest population. However looking at history, it has been sitting on the fence and if that is the best strategy for India -then so be it...Hopefully India will be all on board with BRICS as well as RCEP (withdrew at the last moment because someone promised a bilateral deal which coincidentally fell through) If the leadership thinks West is the way to go - then proceed at full steam ahead... recently someone calculated that good old Britannia reaped $45 trillion of resources from India during the past 200 yrs !!! so the west is not a friend after all....anyway the leaders now have matured and India has to stand for her citizens and not be played by the many goldilocks coming and wooing... if India falls for this then another $45 trillion will be extracted... choose wisely
Beautifully stated. Hopeful better sense will prevail in India and we’ll collaborate on shared prosperity with China.
This guy speaks the truth. It's too bad people like him aren't running India.