Geelong has many young forwards and Melbourne has been trying to finalize theirs for years. Perhaps offering Ollie Henry as part of a bundle would be attractive to the Demons.
I would hold out in hopes of landing Harley Reid. But if I was to choose. I'd say send next seasons first rd pick, phenox foster and a tom stewart signed gurnsey to Melbourne, for Petracca.
Agree with you Paul. Petracca would be phenomenal but I feel like we’ve already done deals to get Bailey Smith, and I just don’t think we have enough bait left ( that I would be ok to part with) to get Petracca. You also have to think about lifestyle a bit too, he’s probably not a guy that’s wanting the farm/surf lifestyle that appeals to some other players?
And where do we magic up all these 1st round picks that it would take to get Petracca and Smith? Salary cap space is the easy part. We were lucky in getting Jez in that we managed to squeeze the Weagles for 2 x 1st round pics in the Kelly trade.
For me, if its only 1, id be going after Pettacca. Then Smith. Im going to be very contraversial...would you trade Jhye Clark? Dees lose Petracca and Oliver, they need mids. Or if they are losing Neale-Bullen, do you offer Mannagh? FYI...i dont think we will get him. But like the thought experiment 😊
if we traded out atkins, conway, and the 1st round pick for trac and a late pick, that might work in our favour. i eel that conway could def be traded as we are likely to develop de koning as our ruck.
Nah, a bit too old to invest 7 years and close to 10millions dollars for, plus whatever trades we will have to dish out. We don't even know if he will come back as the same player, after what he went through. He'll probably go to Tasmania in a few years. Next......
Love the content but zero chance. Our 1st round this year is for smith , and that's unders . When u make finals 18 out of 20 years, you don't have a lot of draft capital. I don't thinomgetting anyone in is a good idea . I would even reject smith, honestly. We have allot of developing talent that will need a couple of years. We should be building for 2027.
Won’t get him to much and have to lose to many good kids. Only way is if he “retires” for a year and says he will stay retired unless he gets to the cats.
Neale, Ollie Henry and a first rounder? Wouldn’t wanna lose those guys, but we would have to give up some players of quality to land him (Petracca). I wouldnt touch Oliver, and after his ACL, an early/mid first round pick and steakknives should be enough for Smith.
Superstar... but no. This years draft is stacked with no clear number. I think we'll get Smith, but I'd rather not cough up our first round pick for this year
We haven’t relied on first round draft picks to build a premiership side in the past, I back the cats D&R team to make up for the loss of a 1RD pick to allow an A Grader to head our way.
@@protoindoeuropeanyeah I trust the club, but when every pick in the first round is supposed to be something special, it’s good news for us. Imagine what we could do with a first round pick. I already like the trajectory of Clark and O’Sullivan. I think we need to take advantage of it before Tassie bleeds everyone dry
@@calebsmith9773 jhye clark has 2 years to really prove himself at the level, theres still a grace period for him, but he hasnt exactly set the world on fire
Honestly? Just give them Neale and our first round pick. We can look for a junk big lumbering forward. We can invest in our other young talls and by the time we win the premiership in 2025 or 2026 with Christian the young talls will come good and we're 1 premiership richer. Neale is good but hes not petracca good
@@thejbse There are a few others that could get the Dees interested... All I'm saying is Pick 1 + Neale + one other younger mid or player I would gladly take for Petracca. And I love Big Jaws, it'll be hard to see him go
@kezp8114 You love Neale so much that you want him out 😮. Next year 2 first round pick a allowed to be traded so this year smith and next Track but both this year will not happen
There's no way way we have enough to get Petracca, let's just be grateful that we can get hopefully land Bailey 🙏 Oliver and or/Macrae would be an incredible bonus too but I'll be happy to at least just get Smith 💙🤍
Geelong has many young forwards and Melbourne has been trying to finalize theirs for years. Perhaps offering Ollie Henry as part of a bundle would be attractive to the Demons.
Shannon Neale, I feel, is the guy to step up into the massive vacuum left by Hawkins.
I would hold out in hopes of landing Harley Reid.
But if I was to choose. I'd say send next seasons first rd pick, phenox foster and a tom stewart signed gurnsey to Melbourne, for Petracca.
The “signed gurnsey” alone should be enough really
Neale is 22yo and 203cm and is needed to replace Hawkins. No way you trade him.
I think we definitely need a powerhouse midfielder, whoever that is and whatever it takes.
Agree with you Paul. Petracca would be phenomenal but I feel like we’ve already done deals to get Bailey Smith, and I just don’t think we have enough bait left ( that I would be ok to part with) to get Petracca. You also have to think about lifestyle a bit too, he’s probably not a guy that’s wanting the farm/surf lifestyle that appeals to some other players?
Love you Sparlock ❤️
Just the player we need. Geelong need to throw the kitchen sink at getting him.
@@Mankyweb ain't no way the trac gonna be a kitty kats player.
@@paulkyriakopoulos3444 One can only hope.
Stanley, Tuohy, Parfitt, Duncan, Rohan, Hawkins, O'Connor off the list Go for Petracca, & Smith
And where do we magic up all these 1st round picks that it would take to get Petracca and Smith? Salary cap space is the easy part.
We were lucky in getting Jez in that we managed to squeeze the Weagles for 2 x 1st round pics in the Kelly trade.
@@paulkyriakopoulos3444 get excited for petracca, smith and reid :)
@@joeyrobertson9523 and big brown paper bags dude. How exciting lololololol 😁😎😁👊
Get clarry and baz down and I’ll be good thanks 🤙
Ahhh wouldn't it be great, not going to happen as he has many years left on his contract though.
imaging having harley reid and petracca in the mid
For me, if its only 1, id be going after Pettacca. Then Smith.
Im going to be very contraversial...would you trade Jhye Clark? Dees lose Petracca and Oliver, they need mids.
Or if they are losing Neale-Bullen, do you offer Mannagh?
FYI...i dont think we will get him. But like the thought experiment 😊
We will need to be very creative that’s for sure
if we traded out atkins, conway, and the 1st round pick for trac and a late pick, that might work in our favour. i eel that conway could def be traded as we are likely to develop de koning as our ruck.
do not trade atkins fuck sake
We need Smith, huge bonus if we can land Petracca as well
Nah, a bit too old to invest 7 years and close to 10millions dollars for, plus whatever trades we will have to dish out. We don't even know if he will come back as the same player, after what he went through. He'll probably go to Tasmania in a few years. Next......
Love the content but zero chance. Our 1st round this year is for smith , and that's unders . When u make finals 18 out of 20 years, you don't have a lot of draft capital. I don't thinomgetting anyone in is a good idea . I would even reject smith, honestly. We have allot of developing talent that will need a couple of years. We should be building for 2027.
Won’t get him to much and have to lose to many good kids. Only way is if he “retires” for a year and says he will stay retired unless he gets to the cats.
Neale, Ollie Henry and a first rounder? Wouldn’t wanna lose those guys, but we would have to give up some players of quality to land him (Petracca). I wouldnt touch Oliver, and after his ACL, an early/mid first round pick and steakknives should be enough for Smith.
Dees supporter here.
I’d take that deal. It’s reasonable and fair.
13 minutes to tell us Dees supporters that you have nothing to offer.
Really, those two first round choices would need to be single digit figures.
Can we have him for peanuts please
short answer NO! he will see out his contract at the Dees
mr P needs to come down to the cats and get away from satan
Haha
His coming to freo
Superstar... but no. This years draft is stacked with no clear number. I think we'll get Smith, but I'd rather not cough up our first round pick for this year
We haven’t relied on first round draft picks to build a premiership side in the past, I back the cats D&R team to make up for the loss of a 1RD pick to allow an A Grader to head our way.
@@protoindoeuropeanyeah I trust the club, but when every pick in the first round is supposed to be something special, it’s good news for us. Imagine what we could do with a first round pick. I already like the trajectory of Clark and O’Sullivan. I think we need to take advantage of it before Tassie bleeds everyone dry
@@calebsmith9773 jhye clark has 2 years to really prove himself at the level, theres still a grace period for him, but he hasnt exactly set the world on fire
No it’s Hawks or nobody Hands off Geelong
Both will be at the demons next year mate
Probably
no
Honestly? Just give them Neale and our first round pick. We can look for a junk big lumbering forward. We can invest in our other young talls and by the time we win the premiership in 2025 or 2026 with Christian the young talls will come good and we're 1 premiership richer. Neale is good but hes not petracca good
They can have Parfitt too
@@kezp8114 Bit hard to trade Parfitt when he's an unrestricted free agent at the end of this season though? Means he can just walk yeah?
@@thejbse There are a few others that could get the Dees interested... All I'm saying is Pick 1 + Neale + one other younger mid or player I would gladly take for Petracca.
And I love Big Jaws, it'll be hard to see him go
@kezp8114 You love Neale so much that you want him out 😮. Next year 2 first round pick a allowed to be traded so this year smith and next Track but both this year will not happen
@@BigGaloop15 sometimes you have to love something enough to let it go
There's no way way we have enough to get Petracca, let's just be grateful that we can get hopefully land Bailey 🙏
Oliver and or/Macrae would be an incredible bonus too but I'll be happy to at least just get Smith 💙🤍