ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.ค. 2024
- Coils are at the heart of an innerspring mattress. In this video, GoodBed explains the differences between types of coils and springs, and how they affect the performance and suitability of a mattress...
For more detail on which are the best mattress coil types for different sleepers, see our full guide to spring mattresses here: www.goodbed.com/innerspring-m...
To find the best innerspring bed for your needs, start with our Mattress Match Quiz: www.goodbed.com/mattress-finder/
Skip to the information that interests you most by clicking on the times in the chapter headings below.
Time Chapter
0:00 Introduction
0:47 Pocketed Coils vs Connected Coils
1:15 Key Differences - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
Old video, but still very new. Well explained in great detail. Thank you
Our pleasure Patsy -- thanks so much for your kind words! Yes, the information in this video is still just as relevant today. I'm very glad it was helpful for you.
Wow this is actually a very good video. 10/10, deserves more views
Thanks for your kind words -- I'm very glad it was helpful for you!
Thank you so much for your time 🙏🏾
Our pleasure Sam! I hope you found our website and videos helpful.
Such a helpful video! I initially had an idea that pocket coils were the best. But I figured for the type of sleeper I am, connected would be a much better option.
Hi -- and thanks for the comment! Pocketed coils have definitely taken over the mid-range these days, but you can find quality connected coil mattresses too -- the Saatva mattress is a quality mattress that has a lot of fans, and it uses a connected coil support unit. You can find our review of it here: th-cam.com/video/MdaK7idKypI/w-d-xo.html
Hope that's helpful!
Fantastic video. Thanks so much.
Our pleasure Elishava -- thanks for letting us know it was helpful for you!
I really like the information content. Just bought a pocket spring mattress. It didn't work out for me, my back aches now. So I'm going to go back to bonnell spring mattress again(exchange) which I've been using for the last one decade. It worked really well for me but I had to change because the top layers got thinned out and the springs started popping out. And since in most of the videos that I watched and all the recommendations found on the internet, I decided to buy a pocket spring mattress.
Hi Pinkie. Thanks for the comment. For what it's worth, we do think that pocketed coils can be just as supportive as connected coils, but it you've found a mattress that works for you then that's cool. It is a little harder to find connected coil mattresses these days, but you might have a look at Saatva -- it has a connected coil support along with high-quality foams as the comfort layer.
Here's our video on it: th-cam.com/video/MdaK7idKypI/w-d-xo.html
Hope that's helpful!
Very informative video.
Thanks so much for letting us know it was helpful for you!
Perfect explanation!! Thanks to you I am going now to the store to buy my matress! ;)
So glad it was helpful for you Aru -- thanks for letting us know!
Thank you
You're welcome
Very nice...
good summary
Thanks! And thank you for taking the time to comment!
Good video
Glad to hear it was helpful for you -- thanks for letting us know!
thanks mate
You're very welcome.
Thanks! It's very hard to find traditional innerspring mattresses these days.
Hi. Yes, it is increasingly difficult. However, all brick and mortar mattress stores carry more traditional innerspring units. They are harder to find in the online brands, though.
Thanks for the video, much helpful. Can you please share your opinion about a person who is a side and stomach sleeper and has lower back problems (hernia)?
Thanks in advance.
Hi Vladimir. Mattresses with springs CAN be suitable for all sleepers -- but there is a lot of variety from mattress to mattress. In our view, it's less about the general type of mattress and more about the specific materials and construction that determine whether a mattress is a good fit for your needs.
Have you taken our GoodBed quiz yet? That is a great place to start when beginning your mattress search: www.goodbed.com/mattress-finder/quiz/
Thanks for the video. I'm in the market for a new bed. I have lower back issues and I cannot have any of that soft foam on top of my mattress. I need a firm mattress that will support my back and I'm also a back sleeper. With that in mind, which type of coil do you feel would support me the best? Also, do twin matresses tend to weat faster than full sized? Thanks!
Hi there -- Thanks for your question. First the easy question. Assuming they are the same model, have equivalent under-bed support, and are used the same way, a twin-size and full-size mattress should wear the exact same. The only small difference could be that to the extent your sleeping time (and the associated wear) is spread over a larger surface area, this could give a very slight edge to the full-size. But if you sleep in the same place on the mattress, this possible advantage would be eliminated anyway. Also, it goes without saying that if the full-size mattress is being used by 2 people (vs 1 on the twin-size), this would certainly affect the equation.
In terms of the best type of coil for you, if you are an average weight back sleeper who really can't have any foam on top of your mattress, I'd be inclined toward pocketed coils over connected coils. Back sleepers need more conformance than stomach sleepers but less than side sleepers. This means that they can generally succeed with either coil type. However, if they use a connected coil, they will rely on the comfort layers above the coil unit to provide the conformance they need -- without those, they will not get enough support for their lumbar curve, etc. Pocketed coils, on the other hand, offer enough conformance for a back sleeper on their own, even with little to no padding on top.
I hope that's helpful.
I just got a simmons mattress with LFK spring. how good is that type? can you help me to explain about the LFK spring from simmons
Hi. Simmons doesn't have any current models sold under the "simmons" name -- they are now all Beautyrest. Are you perhaps in another country or did you buy one at a clearance outlet?
Can you make a video review of aireloom mattresses? Specifically their pacific palisades, preferred collection, and hybrid models
Hi there -- Thanks for your suggestion. We do prioritize our editorial content based on input from our readers, so we will certainly take note of this request.
Seems like with many things in life there is no one size fits all solution. This was a good explanation, thank you. It seems as a side sleeper a pocket spring would be best for me. Now all that is left for me to research is how to keep a mattress from soaking up fluids and becoming funky so my expensive mattress can last for years. A hospital I stayed in for a couple of weeks had hypoallergenic covers which protected the mattress, but on a particularly sweaty night of sleeping you would wake up in a puddle and be very cold.
Hi. That's a great question. One solution is to get a waterproof mattress cover to go on top of the mattress. Then you can add a thin mattress pad -- that would absorb any sweat, but can be easily washed. Meanwhile the mattress cover underneath will protect your investment.
Some products claim to be both -- this one gets pretty good Amazon reviews (we have no affiliation with them -- just an option to check out): www.amazon.com/Reaks-Waterproof-Mattress-Protector-Cooling-18-Hypoallergenic-Vinyl/dp/B08CD9DLMQ/
I'm only 51. But motion isolation was a complete non factor my whole life. But what I did see was beds wearing and sagging in one spot and needing replacement. The beds that didn't were Serta single coil and the Stearns and Foster, which was 3 times the price ($1500 and $4500) in 1990s dollars.
Which coil system would be best for a back sleeper then?
Hi. Any coil system can (and should) provide good support. But the shape and type of coil can effect durability, resistance to body impressions, and motion isolation. But in terms of support, any of the coil systems can do that (assuming of course that they are well made and adequate for your weight). Hope that helps!
Hey Mike! Love your mattress info videos. So helpful, thanks for all your work. Have a question for you. I am sleeper that mostly switches all night from stomach to side and I seem to sleep best on stomach. Anyway I am looking for a new bed and would love your recommendation. One of the best beds I have slept on believe it or not was an old Serta Perfect Night Royal in an airbnb lots of nasty pee stains and the whole 9 yards BUT it was an amazing sleep!!! It is a discontinued model and I am looking for something you think would be comporable or best you would recommend. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated. I trust your opinion. Thanks again brother.
Hey there! It's sometimes hard to find the specs on older models, but it looks like that one might be an older model from Serta's hotel line? You might check out similar models with their 532 or 800 count continuous coil. Hope that helps!
@@goodbed Thanks Mike, great advice! What Beauty Rest Black would you recommend for Stomach and Side sleeping positions? I am 180lb 6' male. Any suggestions?
@@Chitching Hey Ty! We'd probably recommend something in the "Medium" range. Beautyrest doesn't like to give out too many details on their specs, but the "Medium" options often use a slightly thicker gauge of coil that is more supportive for slightly larger body types. Trying out the C-Class or L-Class Medium options would be a good starting place.
We talk a bit more about this in our written overview here: www.goodbed.com/reviews/beautyrest-black-mattress-preview/
I'm a back and side sleeper..I wanted a medium, pillowtop mattress..should I get pocketed or connected
Hi Tiffany. Either type can be a great mattress. Pocketed coils is more common these days in quality mattresses, but a few brands are still doing connected. If motion isolation is a priority, going with pocketed coils is generally better. And for people on the plus side in terms of weight, connected coils can help spread the load better throughout the spring system, which might mean better longevity in terms of wear and tear.
But if neither of those applies to your needs, then either type of coil can work. It's more a question of overall construction quality.
Hope that helps and thanks for the comment!
I need a connected coil mattress cant seem to find any do you know of any luxury connected coil mattress's? thanks
Hi Jersey -- Thanks for your question. The most widely available example of a well-made mattress that uses connected coils is the Saatva HD. You can find more info about that one here:
www.goodbed.com/mattress-model/saatva-hd/
In addition, the flagship line of Saatva mattresses also uses connected coils, though it has pocketed coils above them. You can check out our review of that mattress here:
www.goodbed.com/reviews/saatva-mattress-review/
If you are looking for something even more luxurious, there is a connected coil luxury mattress brand made on the West Coast called McRoskey. You can find more information on that one here:
www.goodbed.com/mattresses/mcroskey/
I hope that's helpful.
GoodBed but even a saavta mattress has foam
I want a coil spring bed like they used to make
With supported sides, cotton and no foam at all
What is the best connected coil mattress out there? I have the pocket coil and just hate it. I want an even mattress that is flippable. Do you know where I can get a good one. Please advise, thank you.
This is a very hard question to answer. The industry is largely moving away from connected coil mattresses, and these are practically unheard of in the online space. Your best option is probably to look around locally and see if you can find a smaller manufacturer that still produces a connected coil. A few common names for these coil units are Luraflex, Verticoil, and Bonnell units. These are still produced, they're just becoming more and more rare. If that doesn't turn up anything, give us a shout and we'll see if we can find something in your location. Good luck!
Which is better for side sleeper? Continuous coils or zoned pocket coils?😊😊
Hi Takisha -- Thanks for your question. As a broad generalization, pocket springs are a better option for a side sleeper than a connected coil unit. And in case you weren't aware, a "continuous coil" is a type of connected coil design.
The reason pocket springs tend to be better for side sleepers is because the independent movement of individually wrapped coils allows them to conform more closely to your body's curves, which tend to be most pronounced when you're lying on your side. Basically, in order to maintain proper alignment when on your side, you need your spine can remain in a straight line (when viewed from the side), which means you need the mattress to not only provide enough overall support but also to accommodate your body's curves.
In terms of the overall support aspect, this is typically where the zoning comes in, which in many (though not all) cases, entails reinforced coils in the center zone (under your hips), which gives extra support for the heaviest part of the body. This feature is as useful for back and stomach sleepers as it is for side sleepers.
I hope that's helpful.
What do you suggest for someone who is overweight and have spinal problem??
Hi Atin. We'd suggest you head over to our GoodBed Quiz! Answer some questions about ALL your needs, as well as your preferences on comfort, and we can give you a short list of mattress models that come closest to meeting your needs.
You can start the quiz here: www.goodbed.com/mattress-finder/quiz/
Hey Mike I want to find a pocketed coil twin mattress for a child. Only thing is i need it not to be so thick because its for a day bed trundle. Any tips on finding something like that?
Hi there -- Thanks for your question. By "not so thick," how much clearance do you have? Remember to allow some extra space for bedding (protector, sheets, blanket / comforter, etc.) to comfortably slide under the bed. Would a 10" mattress be too thick?
@@goodbed 10" of clearance is perfect. Sorry I assumed those things were universally sized.
Ok, thanks. It's definitely trickier to find slimmer pocketed-coil beds. Below 10", most innerspring options will be connected coil units, and fairly flimsy, low-end ones at that. Whereas most pocketed coil mattresses are more in the 12" range and up. That said, at 10 inches, your universe of options for pocketed coils does start to open up. In terms of the mattresses that we've reviewed in-depth, the only option that comes to mind that has pocketed coils and is 10" or less would be the Tomorrow Sleep Hybrid. You can see our review of this mattress here: www.goodbed.com/reviews/tomorrow-hybrid-mattress-review/
That said, if you've got a little more clearance than that, it opens up some more options, such as these:
* Avocado (11"): www.goodbed.com/reviews/avocado-green-mattress-review/
* Sapira (11"): www.goodbed.com/reviews/sapira-mattress-review/
* Aviya (12"): www.goodbed.com/reviews/aviya-mattress-review/
* Brooklyn Signature (12"): www.goodbed.com/reviews/brooklyn-signature-mattress-review/
* Beautyrest Black Calista Extra Firm (12"): www.goodbed.com/reviews/beautyrest-black-calista-extra-firm-mattress-review/
I hope that's helpful.
Hey mike!
I'm a 250 pound guy who is a stomach sleeper and can't seem to find a mattress that holds up. I prefer a firmer feel and not letting my hips sink. What would you suggest as a good mattress that stand up against time? I've had to get rid of the saatva (broke down very quickly) and the nest bedding latex (very quick and was recommended by your site) and another box mattress I forgot the name.
Basically need something that stands the test of time for a big body and a partner. Could you please please help me out? Currently checking out what the classic brands have with beautyrest and sterns and foster. Just don't want to make another mistake. This things are expense lol
Hey Nate. Have you checked our video for the King Koil World Extended Life mattress? It's made specifically to address those needs. We were impressed with it, but AFAIK it's unfortunately only available in Southern California at this point:
th-cam.com/video/CK07D7Ow5Wg/w-d-xo.html
Perhaps more pertinently, we have a new video coming today on the WinkBed Plus, which is another hybrid mattress that's specifically designed to support higher weights. That one is available online and ships nationwide. Stay tuned.
I hope that's helpful.
Hi Nate -- FYI, the WinkBed Plus video is now out. Here it is:
th-cam.com/video/oO7sd3sPKK0/w-d-xo.html
I hope it's helpful for you.
Try King Koil. Made for heavier people with great support.
Shiffman mattresses.
Hi. Does a connected coil matress need a box spring or can it be on a platform bed like a foam mattress?
Hi. A platform bed should work for just about any mattress, whether foam, hybrid, or innerspring. A platform bed is generally the most universally supportive base.
@@goodbed cool I read somewhere that innerspring mattresses need a boxspring but I guess that might not be the case with more modern mattresses
@@DevoraFierroGrande You're correct that requirements have changed over time as the design of the mattresses themselves has changed. 30 years ago, the vast majority of mattresses were specifically designed to be used in conjunction with a box spring. Since then, the industry has moved 180 degrees in the opposite direction to the point that only a rare few mattresses can/should be used with a box spring, and the vast majority just need a sturdy, stable, solid foundation (eg, a platform, closely spaced slats, etc.). I hope that's helpful.
Question: because purple uses the polymer material on top and that is used for ventilation and motions, do the coils used on the purple hybrid mattress do much ? I see reviews on the beds and all I can really gather is that they’re better for heavier people. The original purple uses memory foam beneath the polymer.
Hi there -- Thanks for your question. First, just to clarify, there is no memory foam in the original Purple. Underneath the Purple grid is a 4" layer of regular poly foam, below which is another firmer layer of regular poly foam.
But to answer your question more generally, there is no 2" layer of any mattress comfort material on any mattress that is going to be the entirety of what you feel. Not even a 4" layer can be the entirety of what you feel -- if it were, it would have to be an extremely hard, almost like a solid surface. To illustrate what I mean, both the Purple Hybrid (fka Purple.2) and the Original Purple use the same 2" layer of polymer grid on top. If you took that grid off of the mattress and put it on the floor, lying on it would not resemble the feel of either of those mattresses -- this is because that 2" grid alone doesn't support your body's entire weight, not even close.
Now, in the case of those two Purple models, what's under the grid feels very different. With the Original Purple, it's a relatively soft layer of poly foam. And with the Purple Hybrid, it's a layer of pretty firm pocketed coils. This is why the Purple Hybrid is indeed better for heavier people. It's also why the Original Purple has a softer overall feel than the Purple Hybrid. That said, if you really want to understand these models, you need to watch our review of the Purple Hybrid mattress. It's honestly the only review you need to watch, as I am certain you will find that it explains all of this better than any other review you may have seen. You can find it here:
www.goodbed.com/reviews/purple-4-mattress-review/
I hope that's helpful.
GoodBed
It was very helpful! Thank you so much for the breakdown. It was just what I was looking for. I can’t believe I didn’t find this video before.
Glad to help!
hi, what is Chiropractic Coil? ive been trying to find other meaning for it.
Hi there -- Thanks for your question. AFAIK that is not a term used to refer to a general style or class of coil. My guess is that it's either a branded term used to refer to the coils made or used by a specific company, or just a marketing description that some company created in order to make their coils sound better. In either case, those coils would fall broadly into one of the families of coils discussed in this video.
I hope that's helpful.
Hey Fadzli: "Chiropractic Coil" is a trade name used by King Koil Malaysia for a Bonnell spring unit.
Wait, if a pocket coil is zoned, doesn't that mitigate the dip? or is it still worst than the connected coil in terms of over compression?
Hi Jaze.
There are a lot of factors that go into the formation of body impressions, but in our view, it's rarely the springs that are the culprit -- typically, it's the eventual compression of a bed's comfort materials -- the foams that lie on top of the spring unit -- that are responsible for the formation of impressions.
Zoned support coils are intended to better support the lumbar area -- they're meant to help a mattress reach up into the small of your back while cradling your hips. Could they have a secondary effect negating body impressions? For sure -- but in our experience it's still going to be the top comfort materials that degrade before the coils lose integrity.
Hope that's helpful!
What do you say about coway prime series 2?
I'm 24, I've had what I think is a pocketed coil mattress since I was 3! I'm terrified to buy a new one, no bed has ever compared- it hasn't lost its firmness- it's perfect...but it's so old and a twin, a real conundrum.
Hi Lethia. Thanks for the comment. If you love the mattress you're on, what you are looking for in a replacement is something as close to a "traditional" mattress as you can find. We hear from our readers that Saatva has a lot of those same qualities -- the bounciness of the springs and a firm feel. Here's our review on that one: www.goodbed.com/reviews/saatva-mattress-review/
In addition, many store brands have that same traditional-mattress feel. Serta iComfort Hybrid, and most Beautyrest models come to mind here. Although I understand your trepidation, you can definitely find a larger 'grown up' mattress that has that same traditional feel that you like.
Have you taken our GoodBed Quiz yet? Answer some questions about your sleep positions and preferences, and we can point you in the direction of some mattress models that come closest to fitting your needs. Start the quiz here: www.goodbed.com/mattress-finder/quiz/
Hope that's helpful!
Is Hourglass spring a kind of Bonnell Spring?
Hi there -- Yes, or put more accurately, the Bonnell design is a type of hourglass coil. Offset coils would also fall into this camp. And both Bonnell and Offset would fall under the broader category of what we refer to in this video as Connected Coils.
Here is some more information about different types of coils: www.goodbed.com/guides/mattress-types/innerspring-mattresses/coil-types/
I hope that's helpful.
GoodBed oh it’s the other way around. What happens when there’s more Pocketspring Layers (1 in the main mattress and 1 in the Box springs) over the Bonnell Spings (1 in the Box Spring) would it be any less steady, supportive or durable or would it mean less moving
Are wrapped pocket coil noisless?
Hey Marcos! This is a great question, and... it depends. Often these are totally noiseless (and they definitely don't make the squeaking noises associated with worn out "traditional" tied coil systems), but occasionally the pocketed coils can bump into each other. This can create a noise like a light popping sound as these coil pockets compress and release. However, this typically diminishes as the mattress breaks-in and is often not present at all. Hope this helps!
Is there any information on your channel in regard to innerspring beds and possibly radiation being produced or amplified by them?
Ah I don't think so, sorry! FWIW, this rumor was debunked a number of years ago: www.snopes.com/fact-check/coil-mattresses-cause-cancer-amplifying-radio-waves/
Is it possible that pocket coils can cause neck pain with certain people?
I bought a modern sealy Posturepedic plus plush hybrid (high point 14"). and I liked it, but I woke up with really bad pain if I slept on it the wrong way. Ended up having my mom pick it up, and she loves it...
Went back to an older connected coil 2000s era Sealy Posturepedic "Ultra plush euro top" and the neck pain went away after a day.
There was nothing wrong with how the new mattress felt aside from my neck having significant pain 3-4 times in a 3-4 month period.
I don't really understand whats causing it aside from coil system or newer foam materials.
Hi there -- Thanks for your question. 99% of the time that a mattress set-up results in neck pain, it's due to your pillow and mattress not being a good combination for what you need as a sleeper. Your mattress and pillow work together to hold the top of your spine (including your neck) in proper alignment. All else being equal, if your mattress is more conforming, you need a lower profile pillow. If your mattress is less conforming, you need a higher loft pillow. This is why when you change your mattress, unless it has the exact same support characteristics as your previous mattress, you will generally need to change your pillow too. It's highly unlikely that your old connected coil model has the same support characteristics as your new pocketed spring model, so your pillow requirements would have changed when upgrading to the new mattress. The good news is that this can typically be solved with a new pillow, and does NOT mean you chose the wrong mattress. Since your new pocket spring mattress is likely more conforming than your old connected coil mattress, my guess is you need a lower profile pillow than you had before, but that's just a hunch.
I hope that's helpful.
@@goodbed well.. I did go through multiple pillows and even lowered as you mentioned..
This was suggested by the guy who hooked me up with the high point.
It was actually a newer pillow on a lower profile that caused the worse pain ive ever felt!
It might just be the foam structure of the bed... Same pillow selection on older bed works fine.
I actually stopped at my local MF store today to try to firm version of the high point.. felt eerily similar to the plush right next to it. (I understand these beds are more broken in).
Ended up on alternative designs like the 12" medium posturepedic and this felt better than both the 14" high point variations to me subjectivelly
I think the issue itself is more the "highpoint" bed design itself.. I was most happy on stuff that felt "on top" or grounded.
Any suggestions for me? I'm used to "plush" connected coil style mattress' with euro/pillow tops.
I didnt mind the sterns/beautyrest innersprings.
Was thinking of grabbing the costco kirkland lakeridge, even though its kind of a "firm" like the 15" euro top sterns. (Marketing says medium).
@@jaszjsz What position do you generally sleep in and roughly how much do you weigh?
@@goodbed i'd say 80% side, 20% back. The neck issue seemed to stem from me rotating to back and locking a bad position.
Currently 200 @ 5'11, but I've gain a bit of weight. Normally around 170.
@@jaszjsz Given all the information you've provided, including your preference for more of a sleeping "on" your mattress feel as well as your need for at least some conformance as someone who is primarily a side sleeper, I would take a look at a latex hybrid. Here's a list of the ones I'd start with, but you can add or remove filters as you like: www.goodbed.com/mattress-models/?support_s1_sp_side=side&support_s1_w_avg=avg&support-type=53&comfort-type=5&cushioning=1&cushioning=2
I hope that's helpful.
👍
I have had the same mattress for 12 years. It has the label Super orthopedic on it. I cant find it anywhere. Its double sided spring or coil. Its soooo comfortable & I cant find it anywhere. Theres no brand name on it😅. Thanks for the info tho 😆
Hi Honey. Good question. My guess is that this was a store brand or 'generic' type of innerspring bed found at a mattress store. Today's mattress stores will carry something comparable -- a connected coil or pocketed coil mattress with a small amount of foam comfort padding.
A good place to start is our GoodBed Quiz. Answer some questions about your support needs, sleep positions and preferences and we can put together a short list of mattress that should come closest to meeting your needs. Start the quiz here: www.goodbed.com/mattress-finder/quiz/
Hope that's helpful!
GoodBed Thank You so much!
Now if a person could find a connected coil mattress with out all those layers of memory foam, then you'd have a great bed. Oh wait those were made 15/20 years ago back when they made beds you couldn't roll up and squeeze into a box
If only they still made them
Ohh wait, I have one! It's 20 years old connected coil surrounded by wool and cotton. Best bed ever. Too bad no one makes them anymore
I'd rather sleep on the floor than in a bed made of foam
Hi there -- Thanks for your comment. Yes, you are certainly not alone in this sentiment. I have often wondered whether there will ultimately be a comeback of this type of bed. In the meantime, there is at least one mattress I know of that is made much like the old-school mattress you describe (minus the connected coils):
www.goodbed.com/mattress-model/my-green-mattress-pure-echo-medium-firm/
I hope that's helpful.
Did you find any? I want one.
Your first 2 minutes intro bored me..did not finish watching. Make your delivery interesting. Edit your scripts. Grow a hair!
Hi there -- Thanks for the constructive feedback! 😂 In our next educational video, we'll try to include a chase scene to add some interest -- and we'll get to work on growing Mike's hair out right away! 👍