Carly Gregg Attorney: Teen Accused of Killing Mother Threatened in Jail
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 ต.ค. 2024
- A teenage girl accused of murdering her mother and trying to kill her stepfather will remain in an adult detention facility despite safety concerns raised by her attorney. Carly Gregg, 15, is charged with murder and attempted murder for allegedly shooting Ashley and Heath Smylie on March 19 at the family’s home.
#CourtTV Catch up on MS v. #CarlyGregg here:
www.courttv.co...
Watch 24/7 Court TV LIVE Stream Today www.courttv.com/
Join the Investigation Newsletter www.courttv.co...
Court TV Podcast www.courttv.co...
Join the Court TV Community to get access to perks:
/ @courttv
FOLLOW THE CASE:
Facebook / courttv
Twitter/X / courttv
Instagram / courttvnetwork
TikTok / courttvlive
TH-cam / courttv
WATCH +140 FREE TRIALS IN THE COURT TV ARCHIVE
www.courttv.co...
HOW TO FIND COURT TV
www.courttv.co...
![MS v Carly Gregg: Pretrial Hearing [RAW]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/SiyVyWferDo/mqdefault.jpg)
#CourtTV Catch up on MS v. #CarlyGregg here:
www.courttv.com/tag/carly-gregg/?
What do YOU think CourtTV?
The smirk that came across her face when they said she is intelligent was soooo creepy.
There's a facial expression I've observed with sociopaths. If you look at their mug shots, their chin is raised up in defiance and a show of dominance, with a direct stare. Carly did that right after her smirky smile, she raised her chin up to show her contempt for everyone she thinks is less intelligent than her, and then glared at the camera.
The way I don't care about this murderers feelings can't be fully expressed. You don't get to play victim now. She can sit in solitary if she is genuinely worried about her safety.
No but!! That gun should of been locked up!! Securely by thd gun owner only the gun owner has access to that gun that's were Americans up mess up keeping gun at home
@@susanlloyd1133 I agree. But that doesn't take away her decision to use the gun to kill her mother and attempt to kill her stepfather.
@@susanlloyd1133P.s. Remember the amount of trust that was invested in her. She even knew her mom's password and could jolly well access her phone to send pretentious messages in her name.
She's not Insane.
Thanks, doc
Announcing an incomplete education.
She is insane? Yes But does that mean she should escape real punishment? No
She's EVIL!
Smiling when the judge said she is intelligent. She is capable of standing trial. She thinks this is a joke.
Absolutely....that was so creepy...
I caught that, too. And she looked right at the camera after that and changed her face once she realized what she just did. Until that point, as a mother, I felt for her. When she did that, I saw the manipulation. She let her facade slip for a minute. That showed her thought process. Chilling.
💯
She is not a child, children don't murder.
@@levithewonderdog335 I was shocked
This Marie woman is insane!!! She knew exactly what she was doing.... Using her dead mother's phone to text her stepfather when will he be coming home. Proves her knowledge of intent to kill.
She's crazy not stupid deennak
Yep and shows how cunning she is. There's been hundreds of people her age, charged as an adult for the same type of crime. She's definitely not incompetent.
More sane than most killers to be able to premeditate a murder on a grown man and almost carry it out!😅
Not insane, just evil
She had told police months before the step father molested her
Im getting tired of hearing about Mental illness being an excuse to take someone's life. There is NO EXCUSE FOR MURDER, PERIOD!
@@grantpicklesimer2995 tell what I think the parents are responsible for this that gun should of been lock up securely 100%,she is a child it' jus gose to show America I quick enough to have guns for home protection but not quick enough to lock them up
"" securely""" with anybody having access to the locked up gun jus like you would do with money in a safe that's what Americans need to educate there self's on or parents should not have guns
Yup, people defending her are sick
No excuse but your not mentally ill you have no idea what it's like not too mention she's a young teen not knowing what's going on do you hear voices and see things that are not there no so keep your privileged mouth shut
@@susanlloyd1133if she wanted to off her mom,she would have with whatever she could find..anything can be a w3@p0n be for real
I'm sick of guns being allowed to anyone that hasn't a police record. Carly KNEW her mom had a gun and KNEW WHERE IT was!! She's NOT mentally ill. She's guilty on all counts of murder against her.
My Mom and I might have disagreements but I would never under any circumstances EVER think about taking my own Mother's life. There are just no excuse for it.
The fact she was smart and aware enough to use her mother’s phone to text her step father asking when he would be home is proof enough she was and is not insane. She is just evil.
No it isn’t. Sending a text message isn’t proof of sanity. At all.
Yep calculated… And then she called her friend to come look at mommy’s dead body. Nice! She’s not insane just a Cray Cray.
@@trickortrump3292 Your lack of awareness is astonishing
She's not a adult how she be charged as a adult that's not right they know it.dam
Leslie crazy are not dumb she crazy not stupid
Little psychopath 😡
Exactly and probably a spoiled brat.
Yet not securely locked up shame on American mog locking up gun safety
@@lisettegarvin5030 no she is crazy
14 !! She is unwell
This is just horrific what is wrong with kids today
Hope for the best prepare for the worst because it's going to get worse before it gets better 💯 😌 😢❤!
@@louisetringham5830 “kid these days” have been doing this since the dawn of time. This isn’t a new issue
Also, what’s wrong with the USA? How do kids get guns so easily there? They need to start asking why their gun crimes are so much higher than other westernized countries.
I know; I agree with you. We have a generation of lost souls. The family unit has been under attack for a variety of reasons. These children have no perception of right and wrong.
🙄🙄🤦 @@Westcoastaurora
She asked her father when he would be home. . . . Sounds like premeditation to me!
Threatened in prison. Who f cking cares? Who would think you don’t get threatened in prison?
She’s a child
She is an evil child
@@Noneofyourbusiness57817She is EVIL!!
@@Noneofyourbusiness57817😂
@@Noneofyourbusiness57817 and?.. what the f does that have to do with the price of tea in china?
She was big enough to murder and then an attempted murder to the stepfather. I can’t fathom how you can murder the mother who gave you life. Prayers for Justice. She needs to be locked up forever.
The one mother who prob but it’s always the good mums that have these selfish brats
Death sentence
She had said before the step father molested her and cops came. But said not proven.
then you must not be particularly self aware or familiar with case studies. Lets look at myths first... In the Greek creation epic, first recorded in Hesiod's Theogony, Cronus was jealous of his father Uranus' power as ruler of the universe. Cronus thus killed or castrated his father. Cronus, in turn, was overthrown by his own son, Zeus. Oedipus was fated to kill his father, a king, and marry his mother.
We see lots of cases throughout history of royalty committing these acts for wealth and power.
Kids often will usurp their parents. Often in small ways...sometimes in tragic ways. Now we do not live much of a directly mythic or royalty world, but the emotions are still present buried deep in the psyche. Beware all overbearing parents.
@@Transform108 Hogwash! Evil is just plan Evil!
If she was competent to commit murder and attempted murder then she is competent to stand trial for her crimes!
This is a CHILD. Peoples brains are mature at an age of 25. They are impulsive, cannot oversee the consequences. And then being tried as an adult?! Commit murder is one of the worst criminal offences BUT there is always an explanation for it. And that is something else than an excuse. Take care of children who commit these crimes instead of locking them away for life! That is also what society, civilization and rule of law should be about.
@@wvh4039 That 25 thing is not true some brains never stop developing
@@Anonymous-jw3mk true. Average is about 25...
She's not crazy just evil. Just because she did the deed doesn't raise her actions to the legal standard of incompetent.
Thanks, doc
NEEDS TO STAY IN JAIL OR A SEPARATE WING FOR PEOPLE LIKE HER. TO MANY MENTAL HEALTH IS POORLY FUNDED ANYWAY, BUT SHE'S NOT NECESSARILY INSANE NOPE. SHE KNOWS RIGHT FROM WRONG. LIFE.
She was hiding the gun out of sight of the cameras in the home and peeking around the corners.......absolutely she should stand trial. She couldn't wrap her head around the fact that shooting somebody in the head was wrong? Get out of here with that rubbish.
What? Someone threatened someone in a jail? Alert the media.
Oh wait, they literally did.
Yes, some ppl like knowing what's going on, with everything to do with this trial.
She was competent enough to murder someone she’s competent enough to be charged as an adult
Competent enough to do onlyfans.
Imagine You are giving birth to the monster who later kills you.
She is little psycho.
All psychopaths were children once
And all children are psychopaths. Well, mine are, at least. I'm just kidding, I love them.
Watch your back 😂😂😂just sayin 😅 ! @@mighty0974
Most still are children even when they appear to be adults
All children don’t turn into psychopaths, however. She’s either had a traumatic childhood or has a legitimate mental illness that was left undiagnosed. She shouldn’t be on Abilify either way.
This poor child. No one kills their own mother for nothing. I don’t know what her mother did to her. It’s never an excuse to kill somebody but she’s clearly a victim and the cycle continues so sad. I can tell it just looking at her. She has severe severe post traumatic stress disorder. ❤
All of a sudden everyone that commits a crime is insane Smdh. She knew exactly what she was doing and should get the maximum sentence for the crime.
how did this 14yo have access to a gun?
That part!
Its America 😮
@64endlesslove If it was the UK, she would have stabbed her mother to death.. so. 🙄
That's your retarded question? Great job
Parents didn't lock it up.
It's jail not summer camp.
Put her in solidarity confinement.
🎯
Where everyone comes together? Lol
All murderes are insane. Still need to be held accountable.
@@mighty0974 good point
@@mighty0974 They most certainly aren't 🙄
That's definitely not true.
Not true some are just mean and evil.
Some people are pure evil, not mental.
A tactic to garner her sympathy
How can anyone kill theire own mom I will never understand people like this !
This happened a few streets behind my house. Absolutely bizarre!!!
@@toithomas4560 can you shed light like what was her motive ?
@@araehquinlan5134 I wish I could. I can tell you what neighbors have said but it’s not 1st hand from me, yet. Supposedly very very very strict parents, especially her mom. Lots of people are thinking that something bad and ugly was going on behind their closed doors 🚪. Maybe they are just trying to make sense of it but idk anything for certain. But with that said we live in a county that doesn’t play around at all. All she would have had to do is tell a teacher a friend or someone and they would have been on them immediately like flies on poo. Fortunately it’s looking like we’re going to have some real transparency in this case. And they’re moving it along very quickly compared to the other states and trials. I’m leaning towards they didn’t do anything to her bc we’re seeing her face at her age. Idt she is mentally unstable either. She’ll be tried as a sane adult bc the judges would have never let her face out otherwise. Having your phone taken away is not grounds for a double execution. If Ykwis. She called her lil friend over after she called her stepdad to come home and showed off her mom. The dad was pulling up and she got him in the shoulder as she tried to finish him, he struggled with her and got her weapon out of her hands and she ran around the neighborhood for 30 minutes until they found her. I wonder what set of grandparents are standing behind her. No one has spoken of her bio dad yet that I’m aware of. Maybe his parents but not sure. I’ll be digging over the next few weeks to come for sure. Hopefully some of this helps with your question.
@@araehquinlan5134 I added a comment this morning but I don’t see it. We don’t know much more either. They usually move quickly around here though so shouldn’t be long before more comes to light 🤞
@@araehquinlan5134she’s right. Media and law enforcement has been very tight lipped about details.
I'm sick and tired of hearing the abuse and mental excuse.
Well it's clearly a factor in all cases. Someone who isn't affected by some sort of trauma/mental health issue doesn't usually commit these types of crime.. so ut will always be mentioned. It's a matter of how much it affects their ability to understand the situation and consequences
@@moonlightdancer5495 coming from someone who has mental health issues , I don’t make any excuses if you haven’t went any mental health issues at some point you don’t see any way out of , it makes you feel very desperate enough to get out of bad situations,she needs help even if she don’t having any mental health problems she still a kid, we don’t know what made her killed her mother and trying step father
@@denise8791One could argue that anyone who murders is mentally unwell. So why does the sick psychopath get a chance at “getting help” and doing this again while the victim had their whole life ripped away from them for no reason? Where I’m from there’s a guy who cut off someone’s head on a greyhound bus in front of everyone on it. Everyone present is traumatized for life, some responders had to quit working after that. Oh but guess what? He wasn’t taking his meds that day so it’s ok. He “got help”, was released with a new name and isn’t required to report to anyone about taking his meds after destroying so many lives. That’s fair to you because he was mentally unwell? I’m going to say it - you shouldn’t be allowed to take another breath on this earth after killing someone like that. I don’t care how mentally unwell you are.
🙄 stop watching them
She killed her mom for taking her burner phones and vapes and stuff. She is crazy. Watch the videos of her running around the house before she shoots her mom. Creeeeeepy af.
At 14 you know right from wrong!!!
But their brain isn’t developed enough to understand actions/consequences
Tell that to Chris Hansen.
@@lolz-f6c Bull crap! They are very aware that if they do wrong they will get punishment. She wasn't 5. She was well old enough to know that murder is way wrong. There is no way that she didn't know killing her mother wasn't going to have consequences.
@@jennifertheobald9823 I’m sorry, but you’re ignorant
She was threatened in prison?
GOOD
🤞🏼
In prison? I thought she was in jail. Big difference.
Let her sit in juvie till she’s 17 what’s the problem, she was tough enough to take a life 🙄
I think that’s a boy
In adult jail she is completely isolated and does not have access to school
@@North_West1 they have school in adult prisons. She will be just fine and never hurt anyone again
@@WiCKEDABYSSthey do not
She was completely sane. She waited for her stepfather to come home. That is planning.
And invited friends over.
After she killed her Mom, she used her Mom's phone to send text messages to her stepfather, luring him to come home.
@@leighdavis9522 yep. Pure evil.
What in the world is this girl's backstory? My gosh!!
Right? Guarantee there SA by the stepfather
@@MamawJohnsonBkj BS. She was under the care of a doctor and prescribed at least abilfy the defense has already disclosed. That's an antipsychotic prescribed to treat psychosis, including symptoms like hallucinations, and delusions. That isn't a run of the mill medication. That means that girl was hearing and seeing sh** that's not real! That Girl is mentally ill. Not a victim.
@@MamawJohnsonBkjhow do you know that??!! Maybe she's just a Phyco brat 🙄
@@jessicaanderson3379could be 🤷🏼♀️
@MamawJohnsonBkj my first thought?
It’s called evil and psychopathy….which doesn’t fall under the “insanity” plea.
That could be another reason for why she killed her mom
NPD imo
She's 14, F00l
She sounds like a little sociopath. What a mess!
Zero sympathy for her predicament! She’s wanted to be a grownup, now she gets to be a grownup. Teenagers don’t seem to fully appreciate what all comes along with being a grownup, they seem to think they can pick and choose in what situations they want to be treated as an adult vs. when they want to be treated like a child and it simply doesn’t work that way. They should treat her exactly how they would treat any other incarcerated person!
20:31 that little smile creeps me TF out followed almost immediately by the glare at the camera. around 20:46 she does it again. she’s evil. plain and simple.
Tanaalee she sick needs help
This appears to be a premeditated crime. After she killed her Mom, she allegedly used her Mom's phone to send text messages to her stepfather. She lured him to come home, then she shot him as he entered the house.
I was fourteen when my mom passed away. To this day the cause of death remains undetermined, but it has always made me feel something was shady. My mom was stolen from me. She took her own mother from herself. I try to pray for her but I really feel that this girl needs a lot of mental help. She does not even realize what she has done to herself yet. And of course what she did to her own mother is unimaginable for me. I am sorry for her mom. I pray for her step father I hope she gets help in there but she definitely should not be allowed to go about free. She can harm someone
@Gwen19764 God bless you ❤
I lost my Mom to natural causes when I was 22 yrs old to natural causes. It's been Decades..I still Miss Her!!🌷
I think her case is hopeless. We all know how much we love our Mom's.
She has no place in this world.
I would give my life to bring my mother back god only know how much I love and miss her six years ago died in front of me
I grew up in the same area as her, and people under 18 have an allotted amount of free mental health services. Additionally, I don't think therapists can deny the state coverage, because my therapist didn't accept Medicaid. ADDITIONALLY, every 14-16 year old girl has a "fragile" mental state so the defense is definitely reaching.
The question is why did she want to kill her mother and her stepdad? What was the motive?
In the video she returns to the kitchen after shooting her mom and has the presence of mind to conceal the weapon from the camera. Calmly sits down and starts texting. Chilling!
Look at how calm she's staying in court with hardly any signs of emotion and keeping one look on her face most of the time.
The timeline of the events that happened sounded more like an evil plan instead of a psychopath who didn't know better.
Definitely looking into what lead up to this horrendous crime, by this child,
vitally important. Learning the back story.
There has got to be some kind of back story. I'm sure we'll be learning more as time goes on.
Why aren't 90% of Politicians given a " competency hearing"??? I know what the result would be.
Hmm, I wonder what made this child want to murder her parents 🤔
Are you looking for a child abuse defense. 🙄
It would be nice to understand more about her home life. I mean what if she were horribly abused her whole life or something like that. I’m not saying she was, she may just be psycho, it would just be nice to have more information is all. I guess that is what the trial is going to do.
Maybe they took wifi away for more than 10 minutes
@@sabineliebehenz4492
😂
Hmmm maybe they took her phone away. These little monsters killing there parents constantly these days all because they wanted to.
Hell yea she is completely competent evil and competent
No way she was threatened in jail!!! That's another Lawyers ploy to get her easier time!! God bless her Mom.
This is a very sad case. Many of us haven’t got our mothers but this girl was lucky enough to have hers. Also she had a step dad too many experts say she is mentally disturbed and fir this reason she committed these crimes . If this is so , she should of received more help and why was this not given to her immediately. I secretly think by watching the live broadcast of her compentancy hearing , that she regrets murdering her mum and trying to murder her step dad but her deadly actions can not be undone . This is a very sad state of affairs . There are no winners here . Just pure misery and stress . This little girl’s life will be forever tainted with by her actions .
She's sorry now? Too little too late. She fits right in with the jailed murderers that are "sorry".
My mom passed away in her sleep and I am still 😢 over her passing. She is going to regret killing her once she grows up and realize your mom is your best friend.
She's a killer stop treating her like she's a baby or the victim. Her mother and step-father are the victims. She bragged about planning it and she did what she planned. PERIOD! She knew what she was doing. Court TV, stop giving her and other potentials excuses to murder.
She knew perfectly well what she was doing
friggin defense attorneys.. how do you live with yourselves on cases like this. its like a team that got together to come up with an excuse why you didn't do your homework. too many murderers get away with it because some attorney came up with the best "my dog ate it" bs excuses. that's disgusting.
She killed her mom for taking her burner phones and vapes and stuff. She is crazy. Watch the videos of her running around the house before she shoots her mom. Creeeeeepy af. Killed her mother for caring about her and tried to kill her step father. Lots of people in prison wish they had parents that cared as much as her mother did. I cannot imagine her moms thought when Carly shot her in the bathroom
Her mother deserves justice! If this child thought she was old enough to commit murder, then she's old enough to accept the consequences that come with her actions!! The American Justice System, spends to much time protecting the rights of the criminals. When they should be protecting the rights of the victims, who can no longer speak for themselves
Why wasn't i allowed to have sex when i felt i was old enough as a child then?
@@Anonymous-jw3mk So this child murdered her mother and u think she should have no consequences because she's a child?
@@rosearellanes5648 When you say accept the consequences, what do you mean, adult consequences or child consequences?
carly gregg is a psychopath. she needs to be held accountable for her cowardly actions.. justice for her mother ashley smylie!! and stepfather ! kids these days have no care in the world these days.
She's not insane. She played with her dog after the killing because she didn't give af.
Not her smiling when it was stated that “she’s a very smart juvenile”. When the camera panned in that’s when she snapped out of it to get back into her “innocent lost girl” role.
As if the threats would stop.. when she’s in with the big girls she’s screwed to face her inevitable reality, as she should!
Those Dogs are traumatized! They saw and heard it ALL! The White Dog is so scared and The Brown Dog is TRYING To Protect the White Dog by standing in between them AND THE WHITE DOG IS TRYING TO RETREAT LEAVE 🥺😔🥺😢
and?? Things happen in jail.. welcome to the real world!
Thank you, judge. NO BAIL!
Parents don't want or care enough to listen to their kids!! And some kids R just evil!!
20:28 This is *Wild* to me. She takes the judge's comment that she's "clearly intelligent" as a compliment, and gets a big sht eating grin on her face. Then *immediately* shoots her eyes over to the camera, and gives him a death glare when she realizes he was focusing in on her..
_Chilling_
She’s EXTREMELY dangerous to society.
Good to know SHE WENT DOWN WHEN SENTENCED
Why did this child have access to a pew pew?
What was her reasoning for doing this? 14 year olds don't just haul off and kill their parents..
Exactly what I was thinking that she will be evaluated and put in a mental institution rather than be sent to prison
Baby monster.
In the immortal words of MCR: Teenagers scare the living sh*t out of me.
Still remember that criminal's are arrested and have a trial to decide they guilt or innocent until then
Hello,
She deserves a long time in prison for what she did to her mother and stepdad.and to be tried as an adult.i hope she will think about all of what she has done.and I hope she will learn her lesson.
She planned it. She knew exactly what she was doing.
I think these kids rhink jail is sweet😂
she’s sick!
No. She’s a murderer
I disagree with this former attorney. Her faculties were on full function when she carried out this murder and the other attempted murder. If anything, it takes EFFORT to pull a trigger and to add to that she called a friend over?! It gives deliberate and AWARE! The jury and judge got it right with the verdict and sentence!
She sure knows how to play the system already!! Lmao!! Career criminal already.
That nurse doesn’t know what she’s talking about
Reason? There must be a reason?
Yes this is not normal maybe she was abused who knows
I listen too a lot of cases and all the defense lawyers can come up with is the mental card!!
Isn’t anyone else interested in finding out what drove her to commit such an awful act? Something was deeply wrong.
No. It does not clean the blood on her hands. That’s what protective services are for. Too late to tell her sad story. She had both police and CPS but chose the route she took.
She wasnt out for fame. It was something to do. She isnt curable.
She was smiling and waving ?? This is really sad. What would cause this young girl to do this to her mom? 😢
Why does there have to be someone or something to blame
Psychopaths are born that way
@@robingagan6288 bc it’s way more likely something was done to this child. Psychopathy is incredibly rare and even more rare for them to be born that way rather than having developed those symptoms after having experienced trauma in some way. I know this bc I’m a former forensic psychologist.
@@ElleDuderino that's interesting. I didn't realize psychopathy was something that could be developed later in life. I also thought they were born with these characteristics ingrained in their genetic makeup. Or are you saying you don't think it's psychopathy, it's potentially something else?
The idea that trauma can rewire the brain is fascinating to me in itself.
@@ElleDuderinosomething that we don’t know happened to the girl definitely
@@blockhartinabox psychopaths are born that way
Stop being so forgiving. People know exactly what what they are doing. - Author Unknown
I'm sick of these lawyers
Poor kid poor mother sad all around
What a weird world were these days.
When you go to jail you will have that happen. So to avoid issues kids don't kill
Bs. .she knew what she was doing...
they are trying to rush this
The daughter is heartless. Without a soul
Not worth the skin that encompasses her rot.
She still has a child’s pudgy cheeks. So very sad for all involved.
She is crazy like a fox. She slick. She knows what she is doing
She knows how to manipulate . She is crazy but not stupid
She's has no remorse she's deserve life in prison if they let her out she's well finished the job will her stepfather
22:31 seriously? how can she get something that simple wrong?
_Competency_ - which he asked about, is the ability of the defendant to understand the proceedings and assist in their own defence. It’s a matter which determines whether or not they are able to stand trial at the moment.
What she is describing is a mental illness defence (the wording of which varies from one jurisdiction to another: not guilty by reason of insanity, not guilty by reason of mental disease or defect, etc.)
She’s a defence attorney and former prosecutor and can’t differentiate between the two ???
If the parents kill a child they many times get off. If it is a baby or toddler completely. Why when teens obiviously snap for a reason it is life
Idk, this sounds insane to me. She’s out of her mind. Not a shred of remorse.