Rule, Britannia! ‘Makes People Feel Uncomfortable’ Should We Ditch the Song? | Good Morning Britain
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ม.ค. 2024
- Musician Sheku Kanneh-Mason, the former BBC Young Musician of the Year and cellist at Meghan and Harry's wedding has revealed he didn't stay until the end of the event as he didn't want to be there when the crowd sang 'Rule, Britannia!' He went on to say that it should not be performed, and there are so many other great pieces of music which could replace it. Kanneh-Mason said it leaves a lot of people feeling uncomfortable, even if they feel good singing it.
So, is it time to ditch this anthem at public events?
Broadcast on 22/01/24
Stream Good Morning Britain live, every weekday from 6am on the ITVX 📲 daytimelink.itv.com/WatchGMBYT
Subscribe now for more! bit.ly/1NbomQa
Like, follow and subscribe to Good Morning Britain!
The Good Morning Britain TH-cam channel delivers you the news that you’re waking up to in the morning. From exclusive interviews with some of the biggest names in politics and showbiz to heartwarming human interest stories and unmissable watch again moments.
Join Susanna Reid, Ben Shephard, Kate Garraway, Charlotte Hawkins and Sean Fletcher every weekday on ITV from 6am until 9 every weekday!
ITVX: daytimelink.itv.com/WatchGMBYT
Website: bit.ly/1GsZuha
TH-cam: bit.ly/1Ecy0g1
Facebook: on. 1HEDRMb
Twitter: bit.ly/1xdLqU3
www.itv.com
#GMB #rulebritannia #bbcproms #proms - บันเทิง
![[FULL EP.14] เซียนหรั่ง สอน มาร์ชจุ จับปูนา ฮากระจาย | เฮ็ดอย่างเซียนหรั่ง | One Playground](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/M8mPjd_T2lo/mqdefault.jpg)
If they don't like the UK, leave.
Well said dear 👏👏👏👏👏
I agree , unfortunately they won't leave but change to what they want as the woke want .
too right
Who said anything about not liking the UK? Rule Britannia is an antiquated song and if anything it's hilarious it's sung at all. Most Britain rules at now is shooting itself in the foot.
"If you don't like the starter, get out of the restaurant"
"If those young men who were at Normandy in 1944 could of seen Britain today, they wouldn't of gone 40 yards up those beaches" - Andrew Joyce
As French. Still can’t thank you enough to save and liberate us from the Nazis back in WW2.
And also freeing our Motherland France
Allies Forever 🇲🇫🟦⚜️❤️🇬🇧🟥👑
Totally agree!
Sadly, you might be right😢
Good Morning Britain really hate this country. Typical msm
He would HAVE used have not OF
People like this would see racism in a newly born kitten, they are obsessed.
Why should this be ditched ? No , keep it . 🇬🇧
As an Aussie I’d hate to see the Brits stop singing “Rule Britannia”
it's inevitable tragically !
This man is pure poison
SING IT LOUD AND PROUD! 🇬🇧
💪💪💪
Long live England,if you hate it so much why come here ,so just leave
No way , everyone who does not like it should leave our country, including this young man.
Bit of a racist statement which proves him right 👍🏾
@@danisanzu679 did not mention race in comment you brought race into it
He is a British person therefore he is more then welcome to stay if he wishes.
@@danisanzu679you can go as well 😂😂😂
Personally i thought it was about seeing off the french and the Spanish and telling them we rule the waves,but you always get these people jumping on the racist wagon
No , don’t bend the knee to this nonsense
Keep politics and wokeness out of society , music , schools and sport !
Sure did bend the knee to America though. Remember Harry Dunn?
It seems these days everything British from our culture to our patriotism is offensive to someone. Where does this end? Are we supposed to stop existing to make some people happy? It seems to me that people are finding rascism in literally everything we do past and present. Rule Britannia should not be gotten rid of. The past is the past let it stay in the past. History shows the evolution of how we learn from our mistakes.
There is a lot we can all celebrate about Britain. But slavery and colonialism are not part of it.
Are you trying to say that all that Britain did well Was subjugating others? Learning from mistakes does not include celebrating them.
If those against song Rule Brittania, might want to stop speaking English.....
@@user-gx6il7it8tIt is NOT “celebrating “ slavery. Just listen to the words before, believing and commenting on the words of bigoted activists who have a particular agenda and who have probably not listened to the words either.
Don't like our history find another country to live in
It makes me proud it is our history. If you don't like it leave, no one is making you stay. The world is your Oyster.
If you learn your history you need to research it more of course you will find there’s nothing to be proud of
Why is this uncomfortable? My grandparents moved to this country for a better life and I'm so glad they did. I'm proud to be British and as a POC it is NOT racist to be proud of our country. We're a very diverse country and its wonderful but stop trying to change to culture and make the country something different. It's issues like this that cause racial division and we don't need anymore of that.
You are right, it is not racist to be proud of your country, but it is racist to be proud of atrocities committed by your country. Can you not think of other positive things to celebrate about Britain other than slavery? 😢 That's really sad if you think all Britain was good at was slavery and colonialism.
@user-gx6il7it8t but the song itself isn't about that. And whilst I agree every country has done some wrongs in the past and some present, but if we keep living in the past, how do we move forward together? And we must remember whilst slavery (which is one the worst things to happen) by the British, American etc to the Africans, the Africans to the Portuguese, is disgraceful, lets learn from our mistakes and not repeat them. I say that and my ancestors were colonised by the British.
@@user-gx6il7it8tThe words are not “celebrating “ slavery! Listen to (or read, if you can) the lyrics. I don’t expect you will, you’ll just hang on to the opinions of the ill informed, activist, bigots who probably have never listened to the words either!
Britain has only been diverse for the last 30 years!
The Brits did not choose diversity nor mass immigration and multiculturalism, it has been enforced on us and our country without our consent!
It is not Racist it is patriotic! Too bad that folk feel differently and want Britian to get rid of it!
Rule Britannia relates to our Maritime superiority & Maritime History. Of course it should be sung. Loud & clear, and at every opportunity. It's our Heritage & Identity...💪
No it's not time to Ditch.. Let's sing it loud, I'm sick of people trying to find racism in all things they don't like.. Sorry you are in the UK we are patriotic, just fed up of other nations telling us we shouldnt be..
Let them leave if they are uncomfortable. Who cares?
Drill makes me uncomfortable other people flags in my country the marches every saturday and most restrants being halal makes me incredibly uncomfortable!!!
Here we go again from the woke group.
Those who are uncomfortable with this song are living in the wrong country.
As French, 🇲🇫🟦⚜️. You shouldn’t ditch Rule Britannia. It’s part of your History, the Glory and sucessful time. You actually rule the Waves. Couldn’t have asked for a better Rival than you Brits.
The lyrics is not pointing out black slavery. It says. [Britons never never never be slaves]
What’s wrong with that.
"This was the Charter, the Charter of the Land. And Guardian Angels sang this strain"
🇬🇧🟥👑💂🦁🌊🌎🌏
Why would you praise a rival? Do you think of the UK as a rival to France? I know you hated each other in the past, but do you still hate one another?
@@octavianpopescu4776 No, no. That’s not what I meant. We Franco British are still Rival in a peaceful. Acknowledge each other strenghs and values. We dont hate each other.
We joined forces for the time in the Crimean War 1853-1856 against Russia.
Queen Victoria visiting France
We fought each other for a Thousand years and now we’re good friends
"My Greatest enemy is my Greatest ally"
If I remember rightly this was written after the Navy had fought off and stopped the Barbary Pirates that had been raiding parts of the UK and taking people for slaves.
@@missc4079Yep. I believe it was written around 1740
yes, a bad history
Why do these programmes hold debates like this ? So pointless honestly if you want to sing it then do if you don’t go elsewhere so simple. Leave our patriotic music alone!
Rule Britannia!! 🇬🇧
Silly isn't it.
I would love to see the guy on the left come up against historian Rafe Heydel-Mankoo on this topic. Rafe has already debunked ignorant activist clowns like him about the song.
And Nana on GB news
femi the so called EU expert , that ships sailed now so he is a waycist grifter instead
@@snakeplissken5480 sadly not. We're on our way back in !
👍
If I’m not mistaken didn’t the ancient Romans call Britain Britannia, as an Australian I would say keep the song
But didn't the ancient Romans also enslave the Britons? Why venerate a name given by former enemies?
@@arstropica Because the British people don't whinge and whine about what happened in the 17th century. It was the way of the world then. Our ancestors didn't teach their children to hold on to hate, and that has been passed down through generations. Live in the here and now. No good will come from living in the past.
The word probably comes from the Celtic languages of Britain - it is first used in a Greek source that predates the Roman Empire by centuries.
@@TlevidsI believe Pretanī is the original Brittonic version of the word that predates both Greek and Latin forms. So why use the imperial Latin form? Then again, why would a former colony choose to become an empire itself?
@@irene56 Isn't transforming into an empire after 500 years of conquest by another empire: if you can't beat them, join them?
If it makes people uncomfortable they need to learn to deal with it. Worrying about what makes other people uncomfortable is not our responsibility. Saying that something makes them feel uncomfortable is just a new tactic to force people to give in to their demands. It is not highlighting slavery, that's not what it's even about.
Rule, Britannia! Britannia, rule the waves, Britons never, never, never will be slaves.
No, we made other people be slaves instead
@@peakyblunder So did practically every other country. And we were one of the first to end it.
Oh dear here we go again , it’s a British song in a British country if you don’t like it go live elsewhere where you like their songs , easy really.
[Britons never never never will be slaves] . We could change it with another way of saying it
@@peakyblundername me a country that doesn’t have blood on it hands. I say, keep the song.
He sounds full of anger.
Just leave Uk and move to the EU
He's always angry about something.
@@sedekiman824yep
@@sedekiman824needs to stay relevant because he doesn’t work or have a job. Unfortunately him staying relevant makes him money
@@JustBurnOil If the media did not give him a platform perhaps he would get a job. I'm sure he is reimbursed well for his appearances. Bet he is really very patriotic,
loves Rule Brittania, but his fake woke beliefs; make him more money, in today's world of the BBC, et al!
The door is open if you want to ditch rule Britannia!
Simples as the meerkats in Australia would say: if you feel uncomfortable, make sure you’re on the end of a row and leave before that section of the last night starts. We were always singing “Land of Hope and Glory” in primary and I loved it and still do. I am not and never have been an anglophile, but never once did I feel uncomfortable singing about another country’s praises of its colonialism
we used to sing hymns in assembly ,loved that too ,not allowed any more
Another person of a different colour, caste and creed, trying to undermine the British way of life. Britain fought against slavery and a lot of our sailors died to stop Black-birding. Those people who feel uncomfortable should clear off. With my blessing. B. Off.
He was told that it was written about the viking invasion but just ignores that and still says that it was celebrating slavery. He also ignores that Britain did more to stop the slavery than anyone. How about doing something to stop modern slavery.
If rule Britannia makes you feel uncomfortable then perhaps you are in the wrong country.
If it doesn't, maybe you're in the wrong era.
@@sueyourself5413 Make sense please?
I think they're trying to imply you belong in the 18th Century if this song makes you giddy with nationalism
@@peakyblunder They can imply all they want.
Exactly
No! Keep this song, it is a great song and in no way racist! Those who don’t like the song does not have to listen!
but we are slaves now , all working an paying for thousands to stay in conditions often better than our own
Seems that way...we have bee tolerate too long. Time to get our identity back. Those who don't like it can leave.
Britain's losing its identity
I am happy guns are not legal in uk.
God we really have gone totally woke as a nation and I've had enough we want our country back now !
yes you will have to give back everything that was stolen from many many countries too. than you will have your country back .
We want our country back from who or where ? It's the Tories, Royalty , billionaires and big business that have it . When was it ever ours?
ABOLUTELY.
Meant ABSOLUTELY.
All the flags apart from the Union Jack, English, Welsh, Scottish, and Irish flags make me feel exceptionally uncomfortable, but are they likely to be banned within the UK?
Can eveyone PLEASE STOP confusing the Union Flag with the Union Jack which is, and can only ever be, flown by a UK registered ship.
@@chrispower5963a union flag is the same flag but when referred to as Union Jack on a ship before 17th century. After the 17th century The Admiralty itself used both names interchangeably.
@@QueenBabylonniaDoes that even matter, I can tell you now that the majority of people today are not thinking of admiralty and ships when looking at those flags
Dont speak for me .......if you dont like the country .....LEAVE
Its worth remembering that this was written in the 1700s, a time when Britain was often under threat attack by others. After the failed armada in the 1500s, the Dutch got as far as Upnor Castle in Kent in the 1600s. (Samuel Pepys buried his gold in his garden in case they got as far as London.) The Navy was always under threat at sea and don't forget the white slavers who snatchedn people from our shores on more than one occasion and then the Napoleonic wars when Spain allied with the French. I think if people knew these facts they might understand the wording of Rule Brittania, written at a time when we needed a strong Navy.
i am happy singing it and proud as well, its someone else jumping on the bandwagon from 300 years ago playing that race card again, wanting compensation.
MAKE IT OUR NATIONAL ANTHEM ❤ ITS A BARNSTORMER OF A SONG
Is this serious don't like it leave then
That’s what the cellist did.
@@jujutrini8412 Oh you mean the hypocritical cellist who wants to cancel Rule Britannia but was happy to accept a MBE (Member of the Most Excellent Order of the British Empire). Guys seems a bit short on principles.
@@rogersinclair2772 One doesn’t have to like certain songs in order to be British. Being British is more than that. 😂
When are they going to get over it . Why do we live our lives now , dancing around slavery .
High opinion of himself if he thinks we care enough to cancel Rule Brittania...maybe time he learnt to play maracas or something else....but he's getting the attention he craves.😊
2:00 Completely ignores explanation of its origins.
NEVER NEVER GIVE THIS UP!
Part of our heritage and culture. I would suggest you go and live elsewhere!
The Palistinian flag makes me feel uncomfortable and yet it is flown all over England.
Thank you
Indeed and it's the most fake flag ever 🇺🇸👊🇬🇧
No, it only makes a small group of activists uncomfortable and that’s the truth of the matter but if they shout loud enough the rest of society normally gives in…Once again people are pushing their ideas with no real understanding of history. The song is patriotic - end of subject! Much of the bad behaviour from minority groups makes very many people more than a little uncomfortable too but still we try to understand what has created such attitudes and do not penalise such folk. Tolerance must go both ways if society is ever to fully integrate.
Wouldn’t be The Last Night of The Proms without Rule Britannia he should learn his history from
It is not wise for the indigenous British to take advice from non-whites as they are not citizens of this country.
We need to address the problem and a starting point would be to abandone the communist definition of citizenship, which is place of birth and use an older definition - that citizenship is defined by bloodlines.
I'm getting annoyed with this Femi guy. Always moaning about Britain and Brexit, hypes The EU. It was Britain that stopped slavery. Britons today are not responsible for the actions of people of the past. If he feels uncomfortable living in The UK, he should go and live with Guy Verhofstadt. Tired of hearing his constant moaning and slagging off this country.
What is the matter with these kind of people ? They go to other countries instead being grateful for their freedom they want to change things hang on to all that is British
My dna is totally British apart from a little French and Danish. This is my history , leave it alone.
If someone comes to your house and insults you then it is time for that person to leave.
Poor old Femi - still trying to punt his slavery grift 😂
Noticeable how out of touch GMB are with their audience as 79% disagree with them.
Give an inch and they take a mile
Time to understand that if it hadn't been for the fact that Britannia ruled the waves, slavery would not have been abolished. Millions of white Britons were enslaved by Arab Muslim North African slavers during the same period this guest cites. Sheku needs to reeducate himself, he should join in with enthusiasm if he understood the truth.
Worth while watching Utube - First Time Hearing How Britain Ended Slavery by Starr Larh.
Rule Britannia is a beautiful composition. We don’t need to muck it up with politics.
Please don’t bring this Femi guy back he’s been irrelevant since brexit pls keep it that way 😤
He is being paid by someone because he does not work but yet has a house and a office grrrrr
If it weren't for thr Europeans going to the farthest corners of the world, the people living there would be still living in The Stone Age. Sadly, there were many mistakes, but the good outweighs the bad. Think about that.
God help us when the army asks these wokes to fight for us. No patriotism 😞
Theres atrain leaving in 5mins. Our country our rules
Why r u giving these losers airtime
NEVER DITCH RULE BRITANNIA…. IT IS OUR HERITAGE. IF THEY FEEL UNCOMFORTABLE LEAVE ENGLAND AND GO TO ANOTHER COUNTRY. This is our Country, our heritage, go to where your heritage exists, West Indies or Africa and sing your heritage songs there, don’t change my heritage to suit you!🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧
It is important to refrain from linking black individuals exclusively to slavery and treating them as the sole race to have experienced enslavement. By examining history, we can acknowledge that people from all races have endured slavery at different points in history.
Stop this nonsense.
Why should we ditch anything? Femy should just do one, who cares what he thinks
Race baiters make me feel uncomfortable
“It was written at a time when slavery” so was every other historical song
Do not accommodate,do not tolerate,keep your traditions,keep your standards.They all want to change the standards,then Great Britain will become just like those countries,from which people are running.
What is wrong with the brits!
Stand up and be proud of your heritage and history!
Stop cowing to the minority who came to Britian for a better life!
Love Rule Britannia, patriotic and powerful song, Love from Canada
Did not mind taking the money for playing at the proms,as for the black panellist,he needs an history of slavery lesson
I am sick and tired of this nonsense. Yes Britian was involved in slavery,like every other powerful country back then (Spain,France,Portugal,Germany,Belgium,Netherland,USA)but Britain was also the first to abolish it. Why don't they talk about that?
No if you don't like it that's just tuff.
This is civil war. I am very old and disabled but very patriotic. I cannot march but I can show my PATRIOTISM by posting a UNION JACK in my window for all to see. The flag just fills the window (5 X 3 ft) is readily available at a very reasonable price from flag shops.
NB. I will vote REFORM ! ! !
You make me feel uncomfortable!!!!
I find all patriotism utterly cringe amongst many other things bur you can't get rid of everything that some of us find uncomfortable . There would be nothing left . Get a grip
Instead of being a cringey patriot you can become a nationalist; as long as there are different languages, there will be different countries with borders more or less firmly drawn 😊
Didn't think meercats hail from australia.
Oh dear... History seems to be as unstudied as science... despite both being very interesting and useful.
You could also argue that the lyrics were anti slavery
The British fought around the world to end slavery and fought west Africans to stop slavery
What about the Barbary Coast Pirates raiding southern England taking men, women & children from the village streets & homes? Lots of USA Cotton slaves were importing black African slaves themselves after their six years indenture. Given a plot of land & farmed cotton themselves. Anthony Johnson for instance shipped in hundreds, the profits went on more land & his own slaves were often not released after their six years, He was a very rich black guy.. What about the music they sang? Should "Swing Low Sweet Chariot" be banned? Was it a racist song against Land Owners??
The male news presenter explained the meaning behind the words of the song and the guest still thinks it should be banned because it was written when slavery existed? Ive heard it all now. They are nkt doing themselves any favours are they really.
Remind me why a song celebrating a win over the Vikings by King Alfred some 1000 and a bit years ago preventing them from CAPTURING AND SELLING BRITONS AS SLAVES is offensive in the 21st C.
Maybe some people need to learn the origins of the song and exactly what it refers to (and when it was written for that matter). It celebrates KING ALFRED THE GREAT and his victory over the vikings, I rather hate to think what some rather ignorant people actually think it refers to, I suspect they are being a) insulting and b) showing their ignorance - and that includes this musician who obviously hasn't bothered to even look and see where or when the song originated let alone WHAT IT IS REFERRING TO.
08.59 I feel very proud singing it.
Susana Reid’s argument that if someone feels uncomfortable about something then that is a good enough reason to stop the thing. So if someone feels uncomfortable about her show then that’s a good reason to stop it 😂😂😂😂
RULE BRITTANIA ..SING IT LOUD AND PROUD...👍👍🇬🇧
Nothing wrong with "Rule Britannia", it's a song that's all. Personally, I think the national anthem should be changed from "God Save the King" to "Land of Hope and Glory", I just think it's a better song. But how anyone could be offended by a song is baffling.
So, if a minority of people don't like Rule Britannia, that is reason enough to deprive those who do enjoy the song and who know it's not about slavery. The ignorance of some people seems to be wilfully unbound. Sing it loud and proud.
if you are not happy with the history of this fantastic country leave
Don't speak for all Gen Z people! Some people appreciates patriotic stuff.
if anyone finds rule Britannia is "uncomfortable" then they don't understand the song where it was born from.
They wouldn't have fought 80 years ago if they could see this for goodness sake
Our country our song if you are offended go live somewhere else with our blessing
IT SHOULD BE OUR NATIONAL ANTHEM
Why would you want to ditch an anti-slavery song?
The irony. Just a few days ago I saw a Royal Navy Mine Sweeper slowly 'reverse' into another Royal Navy Mine Sweeper. Nelson would be proud.
No no no we love Our Nation Men have died young and old my family lost loved ones .Don't like our Nation and songs leave .We lift our Nation up not Down thank you 🙏
if they dont like it leave