The Creation, Election and Selection of Imran Khan - Pakistan Lost - Ep 08 - Charter of Democracy
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 พ.ค. 2023
- Pakistan Lost is a series of audio essays on history exploring the choices that were made that impacted millions of people for decades to come.
Episode 8 of the series looks at the creation, election and selection of Imran Khan, how the military used Imran Khan against the Charter of Democracy.
Watch all the episodes of Pakistan Lost:
• Pakistan Lost - Episod...
The Pakistan Experience is an independently produced podcast looking to tell stories about Pakistan through conversations.
Please consider supporting us on Patreon:
/ thepakistanexperience
To support the channel:
Jazzcash/Easypaisa - 0325 -2982912
Patreon.com/thepakistanexperience
And Please stay in touch:
/ thepakistanexp1
/ thepakistanexperience
/ thepakistanexpeperience
The podcast is hosted by comedian and writer, Shehzad Ghias Shaikh. Shehzad is a Fulbright scholar with a Masters in Theatre from Brooklyn College. He is also one of the foremost Stand-up comedians in Pakistan and frequently writes for numerous publications.
shehzadghiasshaikh
Facebook.com/Shehzadghias/
shehzad89 - บันเทิง
I think we are fairly criticized for focusing more on PTI but I hope this video helps people understand why I do that, you may disagree with it but this is how I see our recent history, and I will always have a bias for democracy over dictatorship, I discuss that some more in the next podcast with Badar sahab.
Do let me know what you think, I personally think this is one of the best episodes of Pakistan Lost we've done.
@Rationality Seeker Urdu mai bana nay ka poora irada hay
@Rationality Seeker logo ko bohat hee amnesia hoga agar unko yaad nahee kaisay Imran Khan kaseeday parhtay thay Establshment kay
I like they introduction of motion graphics, I think at this point its a universal trend for most types of educational content on youtube
Liberal if you are should liberate your mind without bias and prejudice. There is hardly anything that I would disagree other than the implicit notion on weighing too much on charter of democracy. It was more of a desperation at that time for Sharif and Bhutto (as time proved in their following tenures) as it is now for Khan (time proving it again). They all have their own styles and character. Simply vote the one you like, don’t make heroes or villains out of them. May not be your intention, but this is exactly what polarisation means; something you held PTI implicitly responsible for.
You unfairly criticize the largest political party of Pakistan. Your views tend to ignore the targeted attack on women which is happening right now. You seem to be completely oblivious of the kidnapping and torture happening to the common man. You support the corrupt and try to act as if supporting such people is the right thing to do. Why don't you pray that your own sisters and mother go thru this turmoil if you believe all what is happening is okay. You shld be ashamed of the negative propaganda that you spread and make fun of those people who are being tortured and raped.. may your sisters and mother have the same fate, you have sold your soul to the corrupt.
This needs to be translated in Urdu and spammed in family WhatsApp groups. 😅
Agree 100%
Trueeeee
True
LOL, i want to send it to my so many friends who support IK to the core, but the problem is they will not watch it because it's in English :D
Khandaan toot jayen gai
Imran Khan will be remembered as the first person in Pakistan's history to educate the *common* people about the role of the military in civil government and its extent. The main culprits were the Army (and CIA) all along. Even my 80+ year-old grandma realizes this now.
It can be contended that social media has significantly influenced this situation. Acting as a double-edged sword. Having both favourable and bad consequences.
You are lying....
He is just only condemning Bajwa because he threw him out, he still just want army to support him, several times he asked for that by saying NEUTRAL TO JANWAR HOTA HAI.....
Yess
Lols first person for youthias because they would never listen to other.
@@drtariqwahab pitwarii?
@@luckypaki4563 Imran can't criticize the whole army, he's politician and knows very well that still over 60% of Pakistanis are impressed by army uniforms.
Been waiting for this. Excellent! 🙌🏽
Thank you!
This is my request Shehzad Ghias that you consider making videos in Urdu so that everyone in Pakistan can understand them.
Your content is highly appreciated and it would be great if more people could benefit from it. By creating videos in Urdu, you would be able to reach a wider audience and make a greater impact.
Thank you for considering this request. I look forward to seeing more of your work in the future.
Done sir
Can you please make a video focusing on what PPP, PML-N and PTI did in their last tenures for economy, job growth and industries? Like how their tenures made a direct impact on the civilians or their economic performance
oh no he wont do that, he will be exposed on his bullshit, anybody who has basic computer literacy can check all economic information via credible sources like world bank, WHO and compare data etc, its unfortunate how people like these can openly spread misinformation and get away scot free
Brave and unbelievable content. Accepting the mistakes of one's own country is really immensely difficult, but it shows how much you love your country. As a lover of ny own country India, I do recognise a fellow country lover (although our countries are different)
❤
@@ThePakistanExperience We would like to know how Nawaz Shraief was picked and why he kept taking orders from bahadur fauj making a mockery of democracy for 40 years. At least Imran Khan has turned against them and has turned people against lumber 1 We also like to know that even after knowing that Z A bhutto was hanged by Lumber 1 fauj, why did Benazir take oath as the puppet PM of Pakistan and now her son is trying the same. Why they didn't take a hard stand against the army? It seems like money, protocols and photo sessions are more important
@Sabrina Khan A lil correction: Imran khan is not standing against establishment but a few individuals who don't like him. Tho the new "ptm" in North Punjab have made all of them angry at him so it's time for their new born puppet party
@@Outofthisworld794 He can't abuse and thrash all army. There are people who love army. Hes a politician but people understood what he wants to say. Today, his supporters are criticizing the hanging of Z A Bhutto too.
How th is it difficult?
This quick recent history lesson should be taught in schools and colleges.
Hat's off, man. You deserve a medal 🏅 for this effort.
🙌
lol
Don't be too emotional
Amazing ! Your analysis is so impressive that I have shared it to almost everyone I know. Wonderful job Mash'Allah
🙌
Keep doing the great work. Loved this format of the video 😊
🙌
Converted from Hindu, come all your original religion, peace will come
Good job buddy!!!
And now I'm looking forward to your next videos in which you will tell us about the creation of other political parties and how they came in power xD.
Previous episodes of Pakistan Lost mai discuss huay hain woh
Eye-opening as always!!🙌
This is the kind of content we need.
Keep It Up son. I'm proud of you.
Fantastic narration. Very well presented too.
🙌
Love your presentation- keep it up.
🙌
Another excellent production. Keep up the good work.
🙌
"Imran Khan is an anti-politics politician." How very true!!!
I am not a Pakistani but have been following Pakistani politics since 2019. Therefore, I could follow most of it.
Others are asking you to make an Urdu version, that is very good suggestion.
I would say, you should also make another slower and streamlined English version, which an international audience who might not be familiar with the Pakistani politics of the past many decades can understand and appreciate. It would really make a highly informative and compelling 1-hr documentary!!!!
🙌
@@ThePakistanExperienceBhai, Tu anti Imran aur anti PTI hai. You claim to be fair but you arent. You too know this. Close your eyes and think once.
@@sudipoli1how is he anti imran? Unless the truth is anti imran.
RTS going down was a plan to keep IK from simple majority as PTI unexpectedly was winning from Karachi, and rts was shut down to adjust the seats in Punjab in PMLN'S favor because suddenly PMLN had gained 14 seats in Punjab as RTS went live. So, a plot to keep IK from simple majority and then keep getting bullied by coalition partners.
This jiyala won't accept this
Lol dream world mai reh lo jiggar
@@ThePakistanExperience isn't this the thing that has been happening from 2018 to 2022? IK was blackmailed by coalition partners.
Hmmmmm. One fundamental question. Who was not created by Establishment since your emphasis is on creation of IK or PTI????? Please stop spreading your personal views instead of having an academic discussion. I haven't seen a single program where you actually grilled PMLN for their performance with PDM or PPP.
Hmmm. One fundamental question. Why would you watch episode 08 of a series without watching the first 7 and then question kay ye kyon nahee bula ya woh kyon nahee bola bhai pehli kistain toh dekho
Very well nuanced podcast. Balanced and provides the right inferences verifiable factually. Stay safe my friend. You seem to be a reasonable voice from Pakistan.
🙌
You’ve done amazing job
Keep it up
Loved listening and watching
Very well scripted. 🙏
❤
Amazing ! Your analysis is super impressive. Wonderful job MashALLAH
🙌
Loved the way how he connected all the dots leading to the current situation.
🙌
What an amazing brief of whats been going on in the country since ages. Cudos to SGS for taking such a brave and courageous step, you are a true hero!
Love
❤
Brilliant. Just accurate and brilliant!
🙌
Kudos Brother 👏 EXCELLENT WORK 👌
🙌
Probably your best shorter video. Hats off to you for this. Please consider making an urdu version so it could be even more widely circulated.
🙌🙌
I can't but admire the analysis of this gentleman.
You never Disappoint me
Briefly summerize and explained
Thanx Man for existing💞
❤
Great video🎉
Very good work done
Well explained
Keep doing nice work like that....be truthful
❤
Awesome 🙌🏼
🙌
Absolutely true brother . Doing a great job 👍
Succinct! Loved the ian bothem ending🤣 off sick these days and lying in bed have gone through hours n hours of your podcasts. Dont agree with everything but enjoy the humour a-lot👍🏼
Thank you
@@PWiC-WUM I am not sure what you find absurd. I have written how casual conversation happens where I live. Please let me know if you want me to elaborate on any thing.
Kind regards
Can you make a video how the establishment actually ‘controls’ the policies and state if by law the power is supposed to lie with the politicians.
Kali Vigo se darr lagta hay sahab
@@ThePakistanExperience lol
If you watch enough TPE episodes, it will become very clear.
@@ThePakistanExperience do it on another anonymous channel. Leave a subtle clue in on of your videos to that channel.
understandable, but hopefully in the future you have the means and courage to do that!
Thanks Shahzad. Wish there could be a way to communicate this analysis to the grassroot level who can't understand English and to the people of opposite opinion. Beautifully concluded ❤
❤
Excellent analysis... A quality content.....
🙌
Shehzad, what a wonderful presentation! This video helps bring clarity and gives the viewer a bigger picture , away from confusing media noise and cacophony. I agree with other commenters that this needs to be dubbed in Urdu, in order to open the eyes of most Pakistanis to the truth.
🙌
Very well analyzed ❤👍
❤
I wish this video of yours go viral across social media.
🙌
Finally, waited for it too long. In a world where clarity is so hard to attain, thanks shehzad for helping me out in this
Thank you!
Inshallah.... Never lost a Election.... Never won a war... porkistani jajbe wali kaum
It is good to see the video was not a mix of English and Urdu. Well done! You can add Urdu and English Subtitles to increase the reach of this video.
Bro, i don't have words to laud the effort you have made to show us some truth in a post-truth era. Stay safe ❣️
❤
Good analysis
Shahzad, I recommend you to please use urdu. Most people don't understand or are not interested in english commentary. I usually send your videos to my family group. Most of them are pro PTI, but they do not understand english. You can add english subtitles if you like.
Ill make it in Urdu
This is pure and simple PDM propaganda. Lot of historical mish-mash but basically criticizing IK about everything. There is no better example than this that someone was paid handsomely to write and read this commentary. I am not impressed- a whole lot of verbal rubbish!
This video was no less than a sad documentary narrated by an artist. Keep it up!
🙌
Greatly put. Hata off this needs appreciation 👏
🙌
Good job and always try to keep making videos of the likes with least effect of personal likes and dislikes. You shall shine InshaAllah. We need context in analysis more than ever today.
🙌
It needs lots of courage to tell all that you have said. We pray for your safety.
🙌
Great analysis on how project imran was launched 👍
🙌
Excellent ❤
❤
Another one. ❤🔥❤🔥
❤
Well well well, Did you intentionally sneaked “The Office” reference at 7:59?
100%
Appreciate you calling out the ongoing grooming of ex-cricketers. This pattern needs to be recognized and corrected to avoid the repetition.
Wouldn't matter. You'll probably see Shahid Afridi as the PM of Pakistan 10 years later.
Shahid Afridi bhi handsome toh hay
@@ThePakistanExperience That checks all the requirements! ✅
I sincerely hope you will be safe in Pakistan with the reality of this video given what I have seen to scores of Pakistani Jouranlists. I am indian and I'm following your channel for over a year .I must say your content and presentation are Top class.Keep up the good work and be safe
❤
very fine analysis Shehzad.
🙌
Could you please share the link of gear you use in your studio....mike, chairs, headphones and computer you use for editing...i want to start channel of my own...
I am your old subscriber...now i have become Scientist in Indian Council of Medical Research
Shure mv7s mics connected to a rodecaster. I outsource the edit.
Sennheiser kay studio headphones hain
So exact analysis
🙌
The editing for this video is top notch. I assume you have purchased a license for a tool and spent more time in visualizing content - great work honestly. From a content perspective, and this is subjective, I think your factual presentation that the IK party strengthened establishment is spot on but I would really like to know why you have not tilted content a bit more on how PDM is further strengthening the estab - retired personnel hiring at certain government boards, the disregard for court requests etc. If the idea is supremacy of democracy then this inaction or cowardice is a bit worse from a national/political perspective than the childlike tantrum that comes from Zaman Park.
Thats the whole point, once a hybrid regime comes in you can't push them back..pdm has just replaced pti as their latest puppet
could you you make a breife video on What or Who is establishment in pakistan and dose it change with time or just pass same target within.
Zabardast
🙌
Another superb episode by Shehzad. Kudos sir
🙌
Software update hogeya apka
Wow ian botham getting out in 1992 world cup to the current state of Pakistan.. butterfly effect is so surreal when it plays out..
Exactly
Interesting
Babloo Kabhi current economic situation per bhi baat Kar liya Karo.... infatuated with Imran khan like a bitter ex...
Please make this is urdu so masses can understand. May Allah give you ajar for spreading awareness.
"How the turntables". I nearly spat out my tea from my 'world's best boss' mug 😂😂
😅😅😅
You are doing amazing work. It is high time if you can help connect Syed Muzammil with Akash Banerjee on your show. It will be an awesome show and people (especially we the liberals) from both sides will get to learn a lot about each other.
Thank you!
You are not a liberal , you are a bengali ! Self declared sjw. Sit down
Liberals 😂.... Liberals are in bed with Islamist in India bcoz of their common hate for Hindus... And they are fighting in Pakistan with each other..
Akash Banerjee is a liberal 🤔🤔🤔
@Gaurav Singh 😂 He is extreme right wing mad guy ( distorted retired military man)
Thank you for sharing your insightful analysis. I appreciate your valuable contribution.
❤
Please Link your sources in the description. Please Link the source to Zia bombing 2 villages in Sindh.
Nadeem Farooq Paracha. I said it in the video that he's the source.
That Ian Botham bit is a surprising cherry on the cake 🙂
😅
No matter who comes to lead Pakistan. No govt has a vision nor a roadmap. It's better to hire a firangi PM than a Pakistani.
Nopes. It matters. It matters a lot.
the best part was "how the turntables! " made me laugh out loud on an otherwise serious video
😅
This is the way that Media should act As you are doing Your reviews and videos are essential to build the thinking of young generation. Keep your voice up. We are with you. Keep Growing
🙌🙌🙌
@@ThePakistanExperience Thank You Sir
Despite your constant PTI and IK bashing even sometime to an absurd level, which is your right, I enjoy your content and discussions.
I think you missed few first time in Pakistan this time with PTI
1. People of Pakistan particularly Punjab region for the first time involved in a direct war with Pakistan Army
2. PTI effectively made common people go against their mighty Army.
3. Imran Khan is the only leader who went against 5th Largest Army in the world a number 1 spy agency ISI and still alive.
4. For the firs time there is a divide in Pakistan Army as major lower level officers are supporting PTI/Imran Khan and standing against Pakistan Generals
5. A large number overseas Pakistanis are also against Army Generals and most of them were also from ex-army Major Adil Raja is an example
Yes he led people against army but instead what he did?
He is just only condemning Bajwa because he threw him out, he still just want army to support him, several times he asked for that by saying NEUTRAL TO JANWAR HOTA HAI.....
If Pakistan army stays out of politics then maybe they wouldn't face such scrutiny? their job is to provide security and protect boarders not delve in politics, maybe he needs to do a video on how the army owns over 100 big companies in Pakistan, owns 50+ DHA and owns 12% of Pakistan's land and all live VIP lifestyles.
@@sohailrazaque9785 Sohail Bhai try explaining following question logically and see if it makes sense.
1. If Pakistan becomes friends with India who will loose relevance and 100 big companies, 12% of land and everything else you mentioned.
2. What did Pakistan achieve by fostering hatred towards almost entire world
3. who gained and who lost from Pakistan Kashmiri Policy
As you know every problem of Pakistan stems from it's occupation of army and you don't need army if you becomes friends with India but I know it's hard pill to swallow . As long as Pakistan foster Kashmiri terrorist and every other terrorist world no one not even Imran Khan will be able to save Pakistan
paid propaganda by PAK FAUJ..... we still love IK
W work bro W
What is happening in Pakistan is just The history repeating itself again & again & again & again & we Pakistanis, WE NEVER LEARN!
Quality content ❤❤
Keep it up best wishes to you and your team🎉🎉
❤
Shahzad, as much as i appreciate this video. I will suggest you to make your videos in Urdu as well. Language barrier is something that is huge problem for most people here.. You are trying to bring awareness, using Urdu as language will reach far more people as they will be able to understand everything that you are explaining.
Quality video! Gained so much Information!!
🙌
There should be a written article of it, in both English and Urdu
The problem with all this summary is that now PDM and establishment are in honeymoon, and this will be over because establishment has their own interests. And those who created a charter of democracy burried it alive. PDM's sins are graver than IK.
This was the initial plan, imran khan was brought as a spoiler to cut down the actual democratic forces, which backfired, and PDM had no choice but to gain a little space.
Given a little space, these traditional democrats will do wonders for Pak.
The spoiler will be cut to its original size
@@RJ.Mangal bro that is just defending them and labeling PTI in bad light
Then say what PTI did also was to save from them if we make such bizard logics in defence then nothing will be better
If pdm was for democracy they wouldn't have done it-a document of charter of democracy doesn't let that it be applied.. on the record PPP didn't give the power to mayors so what sort of democracy that what suits them ..they were also doing movement of vote ko izzat do because they wanted a deal of selection from establishment and similar is IK also raising now wants that deal of establishment
Currently PDM govt is backing establishment to do all violence against PTI so claimed democrats are same too
It is nothing new we don't have politicians who take ideological and have a stance as simple as that
This Shahzad somehow defends and keep and try to himself too and develop too a soft corner for them which is wrong . Syed Muzammil is better he doesn't do that criticize everyone he criticize PPP well on force conversion case criticize pdm and criticize IK too
Main problem is lack of nationalism in pakistan..army pdm pti all want their interests secure ..mulk jaye bhad mai
@@gpgautam1842 absolutely well said
@@shahzadsherali2555 Indians mai 100 burai hongi bhai but for us Nation is red line ..If modi whose popularity hovers around 70% in ratings also try to do anything against nation interest to agle din 7 % aa jayegi..imran got away even talking about balkanisation of Pakistan..I was appalled by this
Man, the last line ❤
❤
TPE is contributing greatly towards development of young minds into free thinkers on both sides of IB by producing such a high quality, honest content with No Holds Barred.
KudoS TPE. Keep up the Great Job.
🙌🙌❤❤
This is the very issue that has affected the India-Pakistan relationship for years . The Pakistan so called elected government and army are not on the same page . Vajpayee made a great effort towards Pakistan and what followed was the biggest terrorist attack in India .As an Indian I can just pray for Pakistan.
Beautifully summarized and great analysis. I am really feeling for PTI supporters who blindly followed him. Imran wanted to become Khomeini, Bhutto, Qazzafi, Erdogan and even ameer ul momineen at the same time. In the end he became no one because he was no one. He remained confused during all his political tenure and his followers are now more confused than him.
🙌
Shehzad, I hope and pray that you go a long way, Inshallah. It’s people like you who give me hope that there are still a few sane voices left in this country.
Kindly translate this in Urdu for all the WhatsApp Uncles and Aunties.
But sorry to disappoint you, those who need to listen to this won’t even bother watching the whole video. Because they have no concern with what’s right or what’s wrong. All they want is their favorite celebrity, who has lived a fairy tale life and looks good on TV to be the head of the state. They don’t have the capacity to think beyond.
🙌
Please also explain what was happened after removing Imran April-2022 till date….
Wow.... Listen to the last 10 second❤😂 Classic 🎉
❤😅
Shaikh Rashid (Birla mandir ki gheeeeentiyo wala) dikhai nahi de raha hai ?
Bro how are you so educated on the hypocrisy of every politician. Can you suggest a few books that can help me in understanding the true history of PAK, Imran , and every other politician . At the moment i only know what they have taught in school.
instagram.com/p/CsyWL2HMXBj/ this is a good start
Can't wait for the same thing to happen again in like 10 years.
See y'all soon....
Speaking shit about him! What about his popularity now? What project IMRAN KHAN and what Pakistan!
Wasnt aware that Zia actually bombed two villages. Shows that there's still much I'm ignorant on. Thanks for doing this and i agree with the other posters that this needs to be in Urdu for the majority awaam to digest as well.
Also, if you don't mind the suggestion, it would be great if you could share sources or clips (be it in the vid or via links separately) to validtate what you're saying as well. What you say may be "common knowledge" but the same is claimed by our tv/whatsapp pundits who then go on to make absurd claims which has led us down to this unfortunate path.
Not to mention, the presence of credible sources will make it hard for my more dedicated Insaafian friends to deny (cause obviously I’ll be sharing such stuff with them!) the facts lest they wish to adopt a more emotional approach over a logical one (in which case May God give them some hidayat).
Thanks again and stay safe!
#MayAllahprotectyoufromthenazrofVigos 🧿
Just comment as a separate comment on anything you need the source for and I'll reply with it
My favorite part, the last 3 seconds 😅😅
😅
Feudal sindhi talking about democracy why Don't you talk about zulfiqar bhutto what he did to his opposition
The ending though is salt on the wounds :p
😅