My sister once told my mom she’d call CPS over some banal reason and she responded “call them. They’ll come and take you to a foster home, probably split you and your siblings up, and you can sleep in bunk beds with 5 other kids to a room.” That was the last time my sister used that tactic
Not exactly the same thing here, but I was ratted out to the police for a dumb kid thing (thanks Ray!). They came on a Sunday morning, my mom answered the door with her plate of pancakes, let them in and said they were here for me and just went back to eating. I was so isolated at that moment, so very much on my own that I never did anything like that again. Tough moms are the best moms, I’m glad you’re holding the line with your kids.
It's the old.... "I'll stop right here and let you kids walk the rest of the way, if you don't settle down !!!!" But seriously, they talk about helicopter parents, but they've evolved into bulldozer parents. Like the ones who start fist fights at little league games, over balls and strikes......smh
I remember my sister saying that and my mother slapped the life out of her...never mentioned it again. I wish my child would tell me some BS like that.
I became a single father after 17 years of marriage. My sons mother, due to the lousy healthcare system died from cancer. Two weeks after the funeral sitting at the kitchen. How am I going to raise a 7 and 11 year old sons that were hurt because their mother died. Then it dawned on me. Marine Corp barracks. I screamed down the hall at the boys and to got into the living room. Told them I loved them, I can't run this house alone, you're going to have have learn some new skills like washing cloths, dishes and cooking. 10 years later, the boys took me out on Mother's Day. I was given a Mother's Day Card. "Happy Mother's Day, Dad. Mom would be proud." The youngest turned down three full ride college scholarships enlisted in the military, oldest now runs a family business and side hustles. Tough Love never hurt any kid.
I don't trust anyone that claims to be perfect. And I know from personal experience...tough love doesn't do shit but cause resentment. If your kid joined the military rather than take a full ride scholarship... he's dumb and you are too for not advising him better. Should have taken the full ride THEN joined the military as an officer.
My wife is a middle school teacher and was suspended- because she took a cell phone away from a child- during a mid-term exam. Board ruled, that she was " derelict" in her duty to remove the connection between the 12 yr old and her mother. As it turned out- ... the mother was asking the child ( during her exam), what she wanted for dinner that night.
That is insane. Everyone knows that electronic devices need to be stowed during exams to reduce the chance of cheating. What idiots are running the school board?
OMG! 🙄 Kids need structure and parameters. The GOP termites have infiltrated the school boards, city councils...and have fostered the continued pussification of 'murica!
I was a teen when cell phones started proliferating, and we weren’t allowed to have them in class. And those were just plain Nokia phones that do nothing but make phone calls. Restricting smart phones in school is a no-brainer.
You're about my age then. I remember when others would laugh at me for not having one. So, then I would ask them what it's like to have their parents track them 24/7. Oh, the reactions were priceless.
please ban parents who think their kids should GET a smart phone before the age of 18....common you must really hate your kids if you hand them a mobile pornographic device , the stalkers out there must be having a field day..whatever. if you think your kid NEEDS a cell phone, then you are simply a horrible parent.
All devices, because kids will be sly and say they have a tablet not a smartphone... 😂 they will say the rules specifically says smartphones. Think like a kid too....
@@kantraxoikol6914 oh wahh porn wahh. I've been watching porn since the age of 12 right when smart phones got big, and it does no harm unless you're weak minded. Same with people who can't handle the mixed bag of the interest
I graduated from high school 20 years ago and the whole class had cell-phones. We had to leave them in our lockers. Seems like a no brainer and not something you need to pass a law about.
I only vote Democrat, and I enjoyed and appreciated Abigail Shrier’s book Irreversible Damage. I like to consider all viewpoints and then make my decision. I don’t appreciate being told what to think, or that I should follow the views of others because my decisions make them uncomfortable.
Volunteered in an elementary school for 4 months. It's *insane* to allow phones in classrooms period. Kids distract each other enough as it is, plus they have laptops in classes already! We made it through all of school w/o phones. If your parents need to reach you, they can call the office!
I had a teacher at a technical college who would deduct points from your grade if you kept looking at your cellphone during class. None of us wanted that to happen.
When I was a kid - we were given bicycles - skateboards - mini bikes - ball gloves a ball and a bat - a basketball - a fishing pole - a kickball and we went outside. I didn't even know what a bicycle helmet was until I was middle aged. I certainly never wore one - and I don't even think they were being manufactured when I was a kid. I walked to and from school - even in winter ( up north ) by myself etc . . We stayed out until dark and sometimes later than that. My Mom NEVER knew where I was. And this was all NORMAL.
The world, to me, seems so much colder All the children seem much older, than they did yesterday They learn so fast, they learn so hard, too soon they're gone from the backyard, before they've had time to play I miss yesterday The neighborhoods, the little stores, nobody ever locked their doors, they all knew where you were from Now I wonder behind lock and key, is the price we pay worth the security, we're sealed up tighter than a drum I miss yesterday
We would definitely still be doing this, but unfortunately both parties have allowed nearly unlimited corporate profit at any cost, resulting in so many things that took these choices away from modern Americans in the US.
I've seen men in their 60's wear a helmet while riding a bicycle even though they know that nobody wore a helmet in the 80's. They believe the government propaganda that we were all stupid daredevils in the 80's.
I was a high school teacher up until 2 years ago. I had a clear plastic shoe organizer hanging in my classroom. Students put their phones in this when they came in to the room and grabbed it when they left. This worked for the most part. They could still see their phone and knew they'd be reunited shortly. Eventually this idea caught on and many colleagues starting doing the same.
@@semperfidelification Good way to put it. People (not just Students) get anxious (sometimes extremely) if they don't have their phone. I'm guilty of this. 10 years ago, I didn't have a phone, now it's hard to be without it.
"Advocacy" journalism is hard to read ... when you're hopeful you'll actually encounter journalism. The Post hasn't practiced anything except preaching to the choir for years. P R eA c H I N G .... lalala!
I think Welch was really saying because the new chief is British, he has no familiarity with him. If he were American, Welch would likely know or be familiar with his style and leanings. This is too complicated to communicate in the 10 second sounds bites allowed on this show.
I was babysitting my nieces and nephews once so their parents could all have a night out... I told them to go outside and play after getting rambunctious in the house... they were about 10 yrs old... their response "play what" ? broke my heart as my kids were outside all the time...
My kids go to a K-12 charter school where phones (and smart watches) have always been banned (phones are allowed to be in their locker for use before and after school) and they've never complained about it because it is normal for them. This should be the norm everywhere.
Phones should be nothing but phones! You call and text that should be it. I’m Gen-X and we never had this crap and we were just fine. And I like to know who called these phones smart? They’re nothing but dumb-dum phones if you ask me.
Yes! Adults are just as bad now. I take trail walks and I’m amazed at how many people are walking and glued to their phones. No one is present anymore.
You are so right on the Prison mess today. My book, Bodies in Beds, Algora Publishing, hits hard on the private prison issue, as I worked in one for 12 years here in Colorado, now owned by Core Civic. Needless to say, they would never rehire me!!
They’d still be friends if “trump hate” weren’t so profitable for the trump haters. And msnbc is so outlandish. They just make things up and act like it’s real.
Why don't we require smartphones to become "dumb" phones during school hours. Kids can only call Mom/Dad during school hours. No other data services should be available.
I’m a huge skeptic of and very critical of today’s journalism but even in the movies as a kid, I knew it was for profit. Perry White was always yelling, “Lane!! Get in here!” He always wanted her to get the scoop and I figured it was to beat news rivals and to sell papers. I think it’s always been about profit.
3 หลายเดือนก่อน +7
Everything is for profit, literally EVERYTHING. Your Wife/Girl Friend is with you for profit
As a retired teacher, NO PHONES. The students use the phones to record teachers, especially when the students try to trigger a response to get the teacher in trouble.
I'm not sure what Matt Walsh is talking about. The issue was the new CEO did not want to his reporters to cover his participation in the British tabloid scandal. Then he reorganized the newsroom and the editor was demoted. This does a complete disservice to the actual story.
In the golden era of broadcast journalism, news & public service programming were required by FCC licensing. FCC could require the same for cable & social media firms.
@@JohnnyRingo-c5v Can be. UK judicial inquiries were brought against the Murdochs' Sun Newspaper Group and News of the World - the latter was shut down.
@@JohnnyRingo-c5v Not a crime, just clear evidence that to claim the WaPo is left wing when conservative Bezos buys it as a vanity project then replaces more than one person with Murdoch hires is a clear sign that it's changing.
I'm a School Psychologist in an urban area and at the multiple schools I work at, kids (all ages) have to hand in their cell phones before school starts.
Why is Bill Maher commenting on parenting again? Don't get me wrong I love you Bill Maher and I respect you and your whole career? The reason people don't listen to your advice on having children is the reason why we are still alive
When my sister spanked one of her for his rude and disrespectful behavior,he threatened to call child services,after she delt with him. She said " now go make your call, hope you like your new parents".
My son reported me to the schools resource officer, I made him read 1 hour after school..... He had and read the Goosebumps series 🤭😉 The resource officer called me and asked, do you know my mom?? 🤭🤣
The GOP has dug itself into such a deep hole over the last 7-8 years and they just keep digging. My former party is unsavable at this point, and it will take at least a generation to overcome. Quite possibly two generations.
Funny you say that because I feel the same way about the Democratic Party. They are no longer the party of the working class and haven’t been for some time now. They need their own version of Trump who will hopefully return them to the values they held one or two generations ago.
We who’ve experienced Complex PTSD - even from neglect - often need to see things through a victim lens for a while. Not forever. It made me sad that Abigail et al dismissed this kind of thing as nonsense and laughable. It’s real. Trust me.
@@hansteichmann Project 2025 is a collection of right-wing policy proposals from The Heritage Foundation to reshape the U.S. Federal Government in the event of a Republican victory in the 2024 U.S. presidential election. I hope in the coming months that mainstream news outlets will start talking about it, because many people are still unfamiliar with it.
This segment would be pretty much the same if the guest's were replaced by random members of the audience. Abigail got about 30 seconds, that was cool.
Bill was extremely unfair to Hunter Biden not discussing the fact the major source of his and most peoples severe addiction problems was childhood trauma. Hunter and his brother witnessed their mother and sister die in front of their faces in a horrific accident when they were young. If that wasn’t bad enough, Hunter dealt with his brother and beat friend dying of cancer. That would push anyone over the deep end. I bet Bill Maher owns a gun and is addicted to drugs, maybe he should get charged with gun charges too. Maher never went to law school and passed the bar like Hunter. He acts like Hunters a complete low life dependent on his dad who has some kind of control over an adult.
I thought that too. Seeing your mom and sister die is enough to throw any kid into deep trauma. That was really crass of Bill. Cruel. He clearly deeply dislikes Biden. I don’t like him either but this is a whole other level.
Hey Bill, I’ve watched Wheel of Fortune maybe 5x but you could learn a lot from just watching Sajek’s last goodbye speech. He is funny, self deprecating and humble. Also democrats have to stop bringing spoons to a knife fight
Incumbents almost always win a second term. trump is a one term president, because he was so awful as a leader. Remember,Joe Biden crushed trump by 10 million votes in 2020,He'll destroy trump by more votes this November.
A 35 year veteran teacher, now retired. Kids sit a circular dinning table in the morning and talk on their phones, NOT to each other. Try competing w your piece of chalk and knowledge when they have this tied to their hip. You do know porn is free, right?
From what I hear from one of my daughters who teaches in NYC... The biggest complaints about the proposed phone ban in schools are the parents. They WANT their child to be able to call them in case of a school shooting.
Then we absolutely have to get rid of the phones in schools. Clearly these parents are not motivated enough to actually do anything possible to stop school shootings before they start and this is what they're using to cope
Oh my gosh this is horrifying. As a person who grew up in Europe, this would have never crossed my mind. I'm so sorry you have to factor this in as a risk for your children.
Good point, I just think parents will have to wait to hear any news. These parents will not be able to help their children during school shootings anyway.
I know what my mom and dad would have said if I called child services on them They would have said fine Take the kid Let him try the system and see how he does there
Really? Phones aren't already banned in school over there? Crazy. My last few years in school were as the iPhone was becoming popular and you just didn't take it out in class or you KNEW you risked having it taken off you for the day. You kept it in your friggin pocket till breaks n shit.
@cindypoole6792 Good point! Biden also struggles with a stutter which I notice gets more pronounced when he seems tired. In addition, Biden has arthritis and walks with a stiff gait. Sometimes I worry that we're just one fractured hip away from disaster, especially since Kamala Harris is an unpopular VP. The first Presidential debate later this month will allow both candidates to stake their claims and prove to their supporters that they are the best man for the top job. I trust that President Biden can perform well if he sticks with listing his accomplishments and allowing former President Trump to whine about his victimhood...maybe Hannibal Lecter's name will even be invoked again - LOL!
If someone younger than Biden was running for president on the Democratic ticket, then Trump's old age would become obvious and be a key part of the Democratic messaging. The only reason that Trump can get away with his age is because his competitor is even older.
Once a kid refused to give me their phone, I started calling security. If the school has rules that support taking the phone, the teacher was correct in taking the phone - I hate that they say this creates PTSD in a child. It’s hard enough to teach without competing against a bot. 🤖
'Oh no, reform the republican party in his imagine' Yeah, the republican party needs major reform, and I hope it's this way. Why be 'loyal to your party' if your party isn't loyal to the people and especially it's base?
In my youth I said to my mother " I'm gonna call CPS on you". She handed me the phone and replied " you better call an ambulance because your going to need one of those."
Wow, I love your mom. My dad would say: if you ever want to leave the house again, you will not misbehave; you will not touch anything that you do not have permission to. You will not make noise; you will not do anything to embarrass your mother or myself. He never had to once hit us - it was the "threat". We behaved. I was never scared of my dad in the real sense. But I respected it and did what he and my mom said. God help the school that ever asked my mom to show up in the same vein, btw. LOL
I'm so old CPS of any sort didn't exist in NYC when my brothers and I were growing up. Mom was the disciplinarian in the house since dad traveled a lot on business. Mom had no qualms about smacking my brothers around (me being the oldest of us 4 boys, well, they managed to make me mr. goody two-shoes). Dad told us never to raise our arms to protect ourselves.
Though I agree that Trump alienating every Republican who isn't behind him isn't a great idea, honest-to-God Americans know that the Trump prosecution and conviction was banana Republic stuff. Having another Mitt Romney in the Senate creates as many problems at it solves.
To clarify, I think they can easily ban any USE of cell phones in schools or during class, but I'm not in favor of actually banning them. They should be allowed to have them in their pocket or backpack imo.
Nobody watches CNN! More people watch fox, according to ratings. I dont watch any of the lying media outlets but fox has beaten cnn in ratings. So not sure why you got confused about that. Cnn needs trump. Trump doesn’t need cnn. Trump can use twitter and get way more views than cnn could bring in. Tucker carlson proved that.
Ahhhhh at the end of the day it's a business! It's not a charity... But obviously it's not profitable because nobody wants to buy their "product". Trump bashing as a business model gets very old very quick, even for people who don't like him... But really Bezos only bought the paper to do that very thing.
![วันเกิดเธอ (TO YOU) - PHUWIN [ OFFICIAL MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_ROx1Bj3T0Y/mqdefault.jpg)
My sister once told my mom she’d call CPS over some banal reason and she responded “call them. They’ll come and take you to a foster home, probably split you and your siblings up, and you can sleep in bunk beds with 5 other kids to a room.” That was the last time my sister used that tactic
Haha! My son said that to me once. I handed him the phone and said good luck. He, also, never tried that one again!
Not exactly the same thing here, but I was ratted out to the police for a dumb kid thing (thanks Ray!). They came on a Sunday morning, my mom answered the door with her plate of pancakes, let them in and said they were here for me and just went back to eating. I was so isolated at that moment, so very much on my own that I never did anything like that again. Tough moms are the best moms, I’m glad you’re holding the line with your kids.
I believe that's referred to as "calling your bluff." _Very_ effective.
It's the old.... "I'll stop right here and let you kids walk the rest of the way, if you don't settle down !!!!" But seriously, they talk about helicopter parents, but they've evolved into bulldozer parents. Like the ones who start fist fights at little league games, over balls and strikes......smh
I remember my sister saying that and my mother slapped the life out of her...never mentioned it again. I wish my child would tell me some BS like that.
I became a single father after 17 years of marriage. My sons mother, due to the lousy healthcare system died from cancer. Two weeks after the funeral sitting at the kitchen. How am I going to raise a 7 and 11 year old sons that were hurt because their mother died. Then it dawned on me. Marine Corp barracks. I screamed down the hall at the boys and to got into the living room. Told them I loved them, I can't run this house alone, you're going to have have learn some new skills like washing cloths, dishes and cooking. 10 years later, the boys took me out on Mother's Day. I was given a Mother's Day Card. "Happy Mother's Day, Dad. Mom would be proud." The youngest turned down three full ride college scholarships enlisted in the military, oldest now runs a family business and side hustles. Tough Love never hurt any kid.
❤
He should've taken the scholarship
I don't trust anyone that claims to be perfect. And I know from personal experience...tough love doesn't do shit but cause resentment. If your kid joined the military rather than take a full ride scholarship... he's dumb and you are too for not advising him better.
Should have taken the full ride THEN joined the military as an officer.
@@jimig399 exactly
@@jimig399 not to mention the fact that the US as of late hasn't participated in any just conflicts. Why would anyone want to do that to civilians
This made me cry 😢❤what a good father
My wife is a middle school teacher and was suspended- because she took a cell phone away from a child- during a mid-term exam. Board ruled, that she was " derelict" in her duty to remove the connection between the 12 yr old and her mother. As it turned out- ... the mother was asking the child ( during her exam), what she wanted for dinner that night.
Cell phones....google during tests a no brainer,
LOL, you can’t make this $hit up 😅😂
Cell phones shouldn’t even be allowed in class. This is why there are so many moronic MAGAs.
That is insane. Everyone knows that electronic devices need to be stowed during exams to reduce the chance of cheating. What idiots are running the school board?
OMG! 🙄
Kids need structure and parameters. The GOP termites have infiltrated the school boards, city councils...and have fostered the continued pussification of 'murica!
I was a teen when cell phones started proliferating, and we weren’t allowed to have them in class. And those were just plain Nokia phones that do nothing but make phone calls.
Restricting smart phones in school is a no-brainer.
agree
You're about my age then. I remember when others would laugh at me for not having one. So, then I would ask them what it's like to have their parents track them 24/7. Oh, the reactions were priceless.
Bring beepers back😮😢
I wish the audience wouldn’t applaud all the time.
Its their job. They are paid employees.
Oh! So TRUE!!!!
That needs to stop or be turned-volume down!!
It interrupts the flow too often
It’s a liberal audience. They’re instructed to applaud
@@DennisAnthonis did you not know that most TV audiences are instructed to applaud?
@@dawiedarling- And "live" shows often have staff who cue them from the sidelines by clapping.
Abigail Shrier is correct about the 15 - 22 year old kids being brought up without skills to survive - and their parents are to blame!
I pay for the roof over my family's head by working on a computer 10 hours a day. Computer literacy is a survival skill.
@@robadkerson I don't think that's the jab you think it is when he is literally typing this on the internet.
Who took home economics, Shop/Woodworking/small engine classes out of schools?
@@chazzanschutz6096 they did?!
@@chazzanschutz6096 the department of education? The public school system?
Prisons and journalism should be not be run for profit
Please ban smart phones in all schools.
That would be helpful for so many reasons. This social media has polluted everyone...including many adults
please ban parents who think their kids should GET a smart phone before the age of 18....common you must really hate your kids if you hand them a mobile pornographic device , the stalkers out there must be having a field day..whatever. if you think your kid NEEDS a cell phone, then you are simply a horrible parent.
All devices, because kids will be sly and say they have a tablet not a smartphone... 😂 they will say the rules specifically says smartphones. Think like a kid too....
🙄🙄🙄😊
@@kantraxoikol6914 oh wahh porn wahh. I've been watching porn since the age of 12 right when smart phones got big, and it does no harm unless you're weak minded. Same with people who can't handle the mixed bag of the interest
This was a great Overtime. Not overly political, guests weren't talking over each other... just very civil, of which we could use more.
I graduated from high school 20 years ago and the whole class had cell-phones. We had to leave them in our lockers. Seems like a no brainer and not something you need to pass a law about.
Abigail Shrier is a hero of mine.
Trump is a hero of mine! Lol
@@iwanttoprocreatewithmileycyruswho is your other hero? Is he a dictator from Germany in the 1930s
I love Abigail! Hate Matt Walsh.
I only vote Democrat, and I enjoyed and appreciated Abigail Shrier’s book Irreversible Damage. I like to consider all viewpoints and then make my decision. I don’t appreciate being told what to think, or that I should follow the views of others because my decisions make them uncomfortable.
If I had called child services on my mom as a kid she would have told then to take me away.
Volunteered in an elementary school for 4 months.
It's *insane* to allow phones in classrooms period.
Kids distract each other enough as it is, plus they have laptops in classes already!
We made it through all of school w/o phones.
If your parents need to reach you, they can call the office!
Give them flip phones
I had a teacher at a technical college who would deduct points from your grade if you kept looking at your cellphone during class. None of us wanted that to happen.
@@shawnnewell4541 that's cray. College isn't supposed to be the same as school
@@shawnnewell4541 did she deduct points for having a laptop too,?
Wtf in elementary school?!?!?!
When I was a kid - we were given bicycles - skateboards - mini bikes - ball gloves a ball and a bat - a basketball - a fishing pole - a kickball and we went outside. I didn't even know what a bicycle helmet was until I was middle aged. I certainly never wore one - and I don't even think they were being manufactured when I was a kid. I walked to and from school - even in winter ( up north ) by myself etc . . We stayed out until dark and sometimes later than that. My Mom NEVER knew where I was. And this was all NORMAL.
My mom taught elementary school and would have kids in groups, one group was outside unsupervised with saws and hammers to build stuff. No injuries.
The world, to me, seems so much colder
All the children seem much older, than
they did yesterday
They learn so fast, they learn so hard, too soon they're gone from the backyard, before they've had time to play
I miss yesterday
The neighborhoods, the little stores, nobody ever locked their doors, they all knew where you were from
Now I wonder behind lock and key, is the price we pay worth the security, we're sealed up tighter than a drum
I miss yesterday
We would definitely still be doing this, but unfortunately both parties have allowed nearly unlimited corporate profit at any cost, resulting in so many things that took these choices away from modern Americans in the US.
I've seen men in their 60's wear a helmet while riding a bicycle even though they know that nobody wore a helmet in the 80's. They believe the government propaganda that we were all stupid daredevils in the 80's.
And you grew up to be a helicopter parent.
I was a high school teacher up until 2 years ago. I had a clear plastic shoe organizer hanging in my classroom. Students put their phones in this when they came in to the room and grabbed it when they left. This worked for the most part. They could still see their phone and knew they'd be reunited shortly. Eventually this idea caught on and many colleagues starting doing the same.
Interesting you tapped into the " security blanket" aspect of the phone.
@@semperfidelification Good way to put it. People (not just Students) get anxious (sometimes extremely) if they don't have their phone. I'm guilty of this. 10 years ago, I didn't have a phone, now it's hard to be without it.
Did you mean shoe organizer?
@@suzanneemerson2625 yep. thank you.
My Dad would say here’s five dollars go play in traffic… 😂
Abagail Shrier is fantastic.
Agree 💯 she should be a regular guest
“Just me being lazy.”
LOVE the honesty.
"Advocacy" journalism is hard to read ... when you're hopeful you'll actually encounter journalism. The Post hasn't practiced anything except preaching to the choir for years. P R eA c H I N G .... lalala!
I think Welch was really saying because the new chief is British, he has no familiarity with him. If he were American, Welch would likely know or be familiar with his style and leanings.
This is too complicated to communicate in the 10 second sounds bites allowed on this show.
Parents used to tell kids go out and play. now they just expect nothing from them.
That’s a MAGA win along with homeschooling.
And grandparents complained "When we were kids we didn't just play outside all day , we worked and learned real skills!"
I was babysitting my nieces and nephews once so their parents could all have a night out... I told them to go outside and play after getting rambunctious in the house... they were about 10 yrs old... their response "play what" ? broke my heart as my kids were outside all the time...
not any parents i know, but go ahead and generalize based on your very limited experiences
@@bikingal4283 That is sad. A whole generation of fearful kids.
Bill always cracks me up when he starts talking about parenting, like he even knows. Lol
My kids go to a K-12 charter school where phones (and smart watches) have always been banned (phones are allowed to be in their locker for use before and after school) and they've never complained about it because it is normal for them. This should be the norm everywhere.
Ma, I’m bored! “Go outside!”
Take smart phones away from adults too
Fr these tech companies are no different than big tobacco
Phones should be nothing but phones! You call and text that should be it. I’m Gen-X and we never had this crap and we were just fine. And I like to know who called these phones smart? They’re nothing but dumb-dum phones if you ask me.
No sense of irony, huh?
Yes! Adults are just as bad now. I take trail walks and I’m amazed at how many people are walking and glued to their phones. No one is present anymore.
@@elainehewitt6813 I don't think anything is wrong with that. at least they're walking
You are so right on the Prison mess today. My book, Bodies in Beds, Algora Publishing, hits hard on the private prison issue, as I worked in one for 12 years here in Colorado, now owned by Core Civic. Needless to say, they would never rehire me!!
Phones have been banned in schools in France for years, in most of Canada for a while... It's beneficial in every way.
Thats because the phones arent in french
Just kidding, i was on my phone during french class
@@Dancerlayla-z6g 👀
@@Dancerlayla-z6g I guess English is the only language used in the world... Right?
@@danavlahova6137 my post was a joke, i thought it would be funny
Really, show me when Trump went on the Bulwark or MSNBC ? This guy is full of it.
Hell, Trump used to call in to Morning Joe/MSNBC!
@@jeffbeck8993used to when he was friends with Republican Joe before he was president.
They’d still be friends if “trump hate” weren’t so profitable for the trump haters. And msnbc is so outlandish. They just make things up and act like it’s real.
@@jeffbeck8993When was that? 10 years ago?
@@elainehewitt6813 Oh how times flies when you're having fun.
Why don't we require smartphones to become "dumb" phones during school hours. Kids can only call Mom/Dad during school hours. No other data services should be available.
They have always been misnamed and should be called dumb phones. After all they literally make people dumber.
Journalism died when they made it "For Profit"
Like so many other things that have made profit their first priority unfortunately.
Journalism was always for profit.
True!
I’m a huge skeptic of and very critical of today’s journalism but even in the movies as a kid, I knew it was for profit. Perry White was always yelling, “Lane!! Get in here!” He always wanted her to get the scoop and I figured it was to beat news rivals and to sell papers.
I think it’s always been about profit.
Everything is for profit, literally EVERYTHING.
Your Wife/Girl Friend is with you for profit
I'm unconvinced that Matt Welch isn't James Maynard Keenan in a get up
It's Maynard James Keenan
As a retired teacher, NO PHONES. The students use the phones to record teachers, especially when the students try to trigger a response to get the teacher in trouble.
I really wish the WOO guy would be banned permanently. He ruins literally everything.
Can't stand it
I'm not convinced he's not a paid plant.
I concur.
Who is Woo guy?
I have no idea what you're even talking about - and who or what is this "WOO guy" - and what does that even mean ?
I'm not sure what Matt Walsh is talking about. The issue was the new CEO did not want to his reporters to cover his participation in the British tabloid scandal. Then he reorganized the newsroom and the editor was demoted. This does a complete disservice to the actual story.
Matt Walsh spouting BS on Real Time and it going unchecked! Shocking! 🤣
I rented a room from Matt's dad in the mid-'90s. I talked with Matt a few times and he was pretty cool.
He absolutely didn't buy it to make money. He definitely has a different motive for owning that newspaper.
Exactly and we don't know what deals he gets because he is a mass messenger manipulator for those with money to pay for the message.
@@semperfidelificationGet a grip.
In the golden era of broadcast journalism, news & public service programming were required by FCC licensing. FCC could require the same for cable & social media firms.
i do find it odd that we let kids have phones and text but passing notes was a punishably offence
:p
It's not that the new editor is British, it's that he's a Murdoch acolyte.
Oh what a crime 😂
@@JohnnyRingo-c5v Can be. UK judicial inquiries were brought against the Murdochs' Sun Newspaper Group and News of the World - the latter was shut down.
@@JohnnyRingo-c5v Not a crime, just clear evidence that to claim the WaPo is left wing when conservative Bezos buys it as a vanity project then replaces more than one person with Murdoch hires is a clear sign that it's changing.
Agree.
Growing up one of the "golden rules" was, "If the sun is out so am I, when it sets so has dinner"...
I'm a School Psychologist in an urban area and at the multiple schools I work at, kids (all ages) have to hand in their cell phones before school starts.
Why is Bill Maher commenting on parenting again? Don't get me wrong I love you Bill Maher and I respect you and your whole career? The reason people don't listen to your advice on having children is the reason why we are still alive
6:41 strange how Maher used to always say that journalism should be a loss leader, now he's saying it needs the incentive of profit to work 🤔
Just read a comment earlier... "To make a liberal cry, tell them a lie. To make a MAGA cultist cry, tell them the truth." Absolutely true.
Both groups are equally obnoxious and idiotic.
Funny, Biden being too old to be president is a truth that no liberal wants to hear. Because when they do, the loud screeching commences.
Well then Democrats should constantly be in tears listening to Biden. Biden is a pathological liar.
That's such an insanely grandiose image of a liberal .. they weep in the presence of falsehoods.... Lol.
@John-kj7tv
Are you one of the cultists?
The only problem with these OT segments (and I love them) is Bill doesn’t shut up. Let the guests speak and answer the questions.
thats hardly every time
@@robi6317 That's almost all the time. Show too.
I know from experience that every time I underestimated my opponent and thought he was stupid, I lost!
Trump and mastermind are opposite ends of the spectrum.
Here for Abigail Shrier
Hmmmn. I just renewed my NYT and WaPo subscuiptions.
I favor hard news over whatever social media spews out.
Love Abigail! Her book Irreversible Damage is a must read about the harms of gender ideology.
...on children. You left that part out.
Transphobe
@d.c.o.7544 exactly. Don't lump it all in together, even Abigail said it's not about adult choices.
Transphobe. “They’re coming for our kids!”
@@d.c.o.7544 It’s also harmful to everyone, especially women and children.
When my sister spanked one of her for his rude and disrespectful behavior,he threatened to call child services,after she delt with him. She said " now go make your call, hope you like your new parents".
My son reported me to the schools resource officer, I made him read 1 hour after school..... He had and read the Goosebumps series 🤭😉
The resource officer called me and asked, do you know my mom?? 🤭🤣
There are many reasons hitting children was outlawed in nearly every country, the US is a holdout because we have been allowed to ignore the research.
@@dawnoceanside7300 >>My son reported me to the schools resource officer, I made him read 1 hour after school.....
If your sister addresses her kid's rude/disrespectful behavior with violence, then she _should_ be reported to Child Services.
@@eponymousIme run along troll
Where is our Trump Dance?!
Gonna have to do it twice next week.
You will see it when he is sworn in as the next President.
Someone must have forced him to cut it. Bill doesn't overlook that type of thing.
@@robertheintz8017 maybe he can do it in his next mugshot?
I know, right? I was waiting for it too! I thought for sure he was going to work it into the end of New Rules somehow!
Kids having live cameras is a bit nerve racking
How is it any different than adults having them
Sounds like something a pedo would be nervous about
@@RenataKleinRK Not really, not anymore. They are manipulative master minds.
Yes, but no government institution should have the right to ban photos taken within its walls. They abuse this authority to cya.
Perverts agree
The GOP has dug itself into such a deep hole over the last 7-8 years and they just keep digging. My former party is unsavable at this point, and it will take at least a generation to overcome. Quite possibly two generations.
You’ll survive
I think the Republican party can get back on course over the next few election cycles, but the MAGA movement can’t be part of that resurgence.
@@ptguy02 true democracy right
MAGA has got to GO!!! It's a cancer.
Funny you say that because I feel the same way about the Democratic Party.
They are no longer the party of the working class and haven’t been for some time now.
They need their own version of Trump who will hopefully return them to the values they held one or two generations ago.
We who’ve experienced Complex PTSD - even from neglect - often need to see things through a victim lens for a while. Not forever. It made me sad that Abigail et al dismissed this kind of thing as nonsense and laughable. It’s real. Trust me.
Very real indeed.
BILL TALK ABOUT PROJECT 2025 !!
@tazerboy65 Absolutely! Everyone needs to know about Project 2025!
It’s about how democrats are going to be held accountable in 2025
What’s project 2025?
@@hansteichmann Project 2025 is a collection of right-wing policy proposals from The Heritage Foundation to reshape the U.S. Federal Government in the event of a Republican victory in the 2024 U.S. presidential election. I hope in the coming months that mainstream news outlets will start talking about it, because many people are still unfamiliar with it.
@@hansteichmann It's on the internet. Search engines are your friends.
Great program, educated and well spoken panel…..worthy topics. Good job Bill.
This segment would be pretty much the same if the guest's were replaced by random members of the audience. Abigail got about 30 seconds, that was cool.
Matt Welch thinks we're as impressed with him as he is with himself.
I went to sleep right after making that comment, realized after I was in bed it wasn't Matt Walsh but Matt Welch lol oops.
Bill was extremely unfair to Hunter Biden not discussing the fact the major source of his and most peoples severe addiction problems was childhood trauma. Hunter and his brother witnessed their mother and sister die in front of their faces in a horrific accident when they were young. If that wasn’t bad enough, Hunter dealt with his brother and beat friend dying of cancer. That would push anyone over the deep end. I bet Bill Maher owns a gun and is addicted to drugs, maybe he should get charged with gun charges too. Maher never went to law school and passed the bar like Hunter. He acts like Hunters a complete low life dependent on his dad who has some kind of control over an adult.
Great point
Be great if the Dems could start growing a pair and making that same point to any conservatives who dare lump Hunter in with Trump.
Clearly a progressive, playing the victim card to excuse anti-social behaviour. Hunter Biden is the victim of bad parenting.
@ChiChi-townGal 🤣😂🤣😂🤣
I thought that too. Seeing your mom and sister die is enough to throw any kid into deep trauma. That was really crass of Bill. Cruel. He clearly deeply dislikes Biden. I don’t like him either but this is a whole other level.
If Donald Trump ever had something good to be remembered by, I can't find it anymore. Ex republican
No new wars ✌🏼
@@afridgetoofar1818 what a bunch of crap
Abrahamic Accords!
@@earthforge3578 and what did it accomplish, peace in the Middle East
@@philster6383 Yup.
If you don't agree with a jury's decision, you have a right to appeal it.
Bill Maher are you a psychologist or a comedian lets define this 🤗
While I'm sure he doesn't do it, psychologists (among others) sometimes write things called books that anyone can read and learn from.
Hes a comedian,
Democracy dies in darkness
That was Ben Bradlee saying
I didn't know that saying came from him! Makes sense that it's the Washington Post's slogan now🩵
Moronic audience again. Laugh at any bs and clap for 15 seconds
Wrong, democracy dies right out in the open as everyone looks away.
Wp was misinformation hq sometimes
"So this is how liberty dies...with thunderous applause." - Senator Padmé Amidala
Hey Bill, I’ve watched Wheel of Fortune maybe 5x but you could learn a lot from just watching Sajek’s last goodbye speech. He is funny, self deprecating and humble.
Also democrats have to stop bringing spoons to a knife fight
Well said!
I loved his thing about being 'bland', that it's a talent you're born with or not, no one can develop it. So he's truly a comedian underneath it all!
Bill should take Pat's example
Something happened to him lately. I think he has Dementia, his filter is gone completely
Thanks will check it out soon as. I miss bob barker and alex trebek
No, democracy is trying to win over autocracy, Matt Welch.
Lol
Correct
Such a bad episode tbh. I’m sick of maher’s weird shit he’s been on lately.
Yes to OP. Trump is getting rid of the establishment.... which is exactly what we want
@@andrewmontgomery5439to replace it with what?? More criminals??? Did yall not learn from his disasterous term??
Our grammar school teachers would confiscate our baseball cards!
The LA times was never that much of a colossus
Matt and Abigail made this an interesting discussion.
I'm so sick of Maher joking about Biden's age.
Biden acts every bit of his age, and then some.
Yeah, these jokes are getting old
Same, I wish he would just stop that because there's enough people already doing that and it's not helpful.
I'm so sick of Maher punching down on trans kids.
Biden's age IS a joke.
Biden is old .. this is not a joke.
The left went woke, but the right went joke. How else do you explain a clown like Trump as the face of the Republican Party ?
was there a proper question in that ?
Because Barry was a failure for 8 years.
@@TheZ1A900 If you don't know, the jokes on you.
as bad as Trump may be, he's going to win because Biden is so unpopular and refuses to let someone else take Trump on
Incumbents almost always win a second term. trump is a one term president, because he was so awful as a leader. Remember,Joe Biden crushed trump by 10 million votes in 2020,He'll destroy trump by more votes this November.
A 35 year veteran teacher, now retired. Kids sit a circular dinning table in the morning and talk on their phones, NOT to each other. Try competing w your piece of chalk and knowledge when they have this tied to their hip. You do know porn is free, right?
How many people are whining about RFK being appointed by JFK still? Get over it. Like none of these people have seen nepotism before.
Not enough discussion from Abigail.
Sen. Fetterman is a fantastic role model and person! Thank you, sir!
From what I hear from one of my daughters who teaches in NYC... The biggest complaints about the proposed phone ban in schools are the parents. They WANT their child to be able to call them in case of a school shooting.
Then we absolutely have to get rid of the phones in schools. Clearly these parents are not motivated enough to actually do anything possible to stop school shootings before they start and this is what they're using to cope
Oh my gosh this is horrifying. As a person who grew up in Europe, this would have never crossed my mind. I'm so sorry you have to factor this in as a risk for your children.
Those parents are morons since the ban is for smartphones, not basic cell phones so they can still make calls.
Flip phones ftw
Good point, I just think parents will have to wait to hear any news. These parents will not be able to help their children during school shootings anyway.
Spot on honest and hysterical as always thanks for your insight and wisdom once again!
Kids learn…watch their parents….there is your trouble.parents in America are lost is it a wonder their children are
I know what my mom and dad would have said if I called child services on them
They would have said fine
Take the kid
Let him try the system and see how he does there
Trump did not come to CA to campaign but to collect some checks to pay his legal bills!
Perfect place to get it.
Maybe he should have sold some artwork while he was there.... (this is a Biden joke, which has to be explained to you, for obvious reasons).
Which you get when you defend yourself against the Stalin trial machine.
@@OldOhioGranny Stalin trial machine? In Stalin's Russia they had no trials.
The last question was really great because it took things away from what divides towards what unites
Really? Phones aren't already banned in school over there? Crazy. My last few years in school were as the iPhone was becoming popular and you just didn't take it out in class or you KNEW you risked having it taken off you for the day. You kept it in your friggin pocket till breaks n shit.
Trump will be 78 on the 14th... he's OLD TOO. Bill needs to stop slamming Biden for being old. Jeesh!
Biden isn't just old he's demented. There is a difference maybe you don't see these videos in the US.
Seriously, when is Bill going to complain that Trump is unfit for office????
@cindypoole6792 Good point! Biden also struggles with a stutter which I notice gets more pronounced when he seems tired. In addition, Biden has arthritis and walks with a stiff gait. Sometimes I worry that we're just one fractured hip away from disaster, especially since Kamala Harris is an unpopular VP. The first Presidential debate later this month will allow both candidates to stake their claims and prove to their supporters that they are the best man for the top job. I trust that President Biden can perform well if he sticks with listing his accomplishments and allowing former President Trump to whine about his victimhood...maybe Hannibal Lecter's name will even be invoked again - LOL!
If someone younger than Biden was running for president on the Democratic ticket, then Trump's old age would become obvious and be a key part of the Democratic messaging. The only reason that Trump can get away with his age is because his competitor is even older.
😂😂 to say Trump is too old with a corpse currently sleeping at the White House is laughable!!
I just wish he would stop smacking his lips. I know he does it for emphasis, but it makes him almost unwatchable
He used to touch his nose constantly during the monologue. Now he claps his hands together instead.
It's in case you didn't already think he was smug and self righteous.
He didn’t do it so obviously until last season when he got on his high horse about Covid sounds like grandpa sucking his dentures back in
It’s pretty annoying.
Give it a break! I’m sure have no annoying habits!
Overtime just keeps getting better and better and very informative too😃
Did Bill not know that Trump was won nearly 50% in 3 major counties in California in 2020?
Orange, San Bernardino, and San Diego.
Once a kid refused to give me their phone, I started calling security. If the school has rules that support taking the phone, the teacher was correct in taking the phone - I hate that they say this creates PTSD in a child. It’s hard enough to teach without competing against a bot. 🤖
I'm for kids only being allowed to have flip phones haha
Yes
I LOVE Abigail Shrier
In Japan i haven't really monitored my kids since they learned how to ride a bicycle.
japan is the safest country on earth for kids
Many countries are far safer than the US for both children and adults. I would prefer to move overseas for a family as well.
Good for you (in my Christian Bale voice) 😅
@@vtxgenie1100%
@@vtxgenie1
Demographics
'Oh no, reform the republican party in his imagine'
Yeah, the republican party needs major reform, and I hope it's this way. Why be 'loyal to your party' if your party isn't loyal to the people and especially it's base?
Larry Hogan is a decent man and politician. Rise above T, Larry! We do need to respect the rule of the law!
Hi from🇦🇺! Possibly Beso secretly employed David Pecker-🤭
In my youth I said to my mother " I'm gonna call CPS on you". She handed me the phone and replied " you better call an ambulance because your going to need one of those."
Wow, I love your mom. My dad would say: if you ever want to leave the house again, you will not misbehave; you will not touch anything that you do not have permission to. You will not make noise; you will not do anything to embarrass your mother or myself. He never had to once hit us - it was the "threat". We behaved. I was never scared of my dad in the real sense. But I respected it and did what he and my mom said. God help the school that ever asked my mom to show up in the same vein, btw. LOL
I'm so old CPS of any sort didn't exist in NYC when my brothers and I were growing up. Mom was the disciplinarian in the house since dad traveled a lot on business. Mom had no qualms about smacking my brothers around (me being the oldest of us 4 boys, well, they managed to make me mr. goody two-shoes). Dad told us never to raise our arms to protect ourselves.
That’s horrible.
loved the show - even - considered - fun - weird (thank you) - Matt was real - Abigail kept looking for HER moment... LOVED THE SENATOR..!!
The Senator has turned out to be an embarrassment to many Pennsylvanians who regret voting for him and won't vote for him ever again.
Though I agree that Trump alienating every Republican who isn't behind him isn't a great idea, honest-to-God Americans know that the Trump prosecution and conviction was banana Republic stuff.
Having another Mitt Romney in the Senate creates as many problems at it solves.
To clarify, I think they can easily ban any USE of cell phones in schools or during class, but I'm not in favor of actually banning them. They should be allowed to have them in their pocket or backpack imo.
3:33 Trump did CNN town hall , can you imagine Biden doing a Fox town hall
CNN brought in Trumps audience, Fox wouldn’t.
Did you see cadaver Biden at the war memorial in France? What an embarrassment to the country.
Nobody watches CNN! More people watch fox, according to ratings. I dont watch any of the lying media outlets but fox has beaten cnn in ratings. So not sure why you got confused about that. Cnn needs trump. Trump doesn’t need cnn. Trump can use twitter and get way more views than cnn could bring in. Tucker carlson proved that.
THIS!
Trump lost. Facts. 🇺🇸
Journalism should not be “for profit”
Do you think automotive repair should be, as well? Let me guess, you probably think the state should run newspapers.
Ahhhhh at the end of the day it's a business! It's not a charity... But obviously it's not profitable because nobody wants to buy their "product". Trump bashing as a business model gets very old very quick, even for people who don't like him... But really Bezos only bought the paper to do that very thing.
Doesn't matter where Trump is at when he has the same circus around him.
Kudos to Matt Welch for realizing, and especially for mentioning, that Bernie Sanders is a left-wing populist.
I love last week tonight with Bill Maher
Real time
Some men see things as they are and ask why, Benedict Donald sees things...and asks 'why me?'
Bigly.
Stupid.
💯 - he ALWAYS plays the victim. I'm so sick of his whining. Instead of so much winning, it's so much whining!!!
My replies were messed with. As if there is free speech on this platform.
@@secularmagahat4933Q?
Your Joey boy just s@@t his pants.